Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

472 Appendix 1 Case studies

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length11,457 words
  • Reading time50 min
Write My Assignment FREE

472 Appendix 1 Case studies
Patagonia: Hiking a value trail of
marketing responsibility
David Fleischman, PhD
University of the Sunshine Coast, Australia
Background
Founded and headquartered in Ventura, California, USA, Patagonia is a privately
held company that is renowned for designing high-quality outdoor clothing and
equipment for sports such as skiing, snowboarding, mountaineering, rock climbing,
surfing, hiking and fishing. There are 32 Patagonia stores in the United States and
36 internationally. Three are located in Australia – at Burleigh Heads, Queensland;
Byron Bay, New South Wales; and Torquay, Victoria. In addition to its physical retail
stores, Patagonia offers an online store with its full range of products, which can be
ordered from anywhere in the world. With annual revenue nearing US$750 million,
it would seem that Patagonia is a typical commercial outdoor-clothing company
and you might be asking yourself, ‘What makes Patagonia different from other
outdoor-adventure apparel and equipment companies?’ In fact, Patagonia prides
itself on being anything but a traditional company. Accordingly, this case study
discusses how Patagonia uses its non-traditional marketing approach to craft
authentic value-creation opportunities. It also examines how Patagonia builds
relationships with consumers, and communicates and integrates its corporate
social-responsibility initiatives with its products, to create long-term value for all
of its stakeholders.
Marketing approach and value
creation
The marketing success of any company’s products centres on creating value with
consumers. While many companies overlook the notion that consumption and,
indeed, value creation comprise a process, Patagonia excels at creating value
with consumers across the entire consumption experience. From the materials,
manufacturing processes, transport and logistics, promotional communication,
purchase and disposal of its products, Patagonia provides opportunities for
consumers to be involved in the value-creation process.
Patagonia’s application of value creation in the consumption process stems
from a genuine understanding of its target consumers, and crafting a value
proposition that appeals to their needs and wants. Patagonia understands that
much of its consumer base has a desire to know how its products are sourced
and produced, along with maintaining a premium quality standard. For example,
before a consumer purchases a Patagonia product, he or she can explore what
materials the product is made from, how it is made, how it is transported
and ultimately made available for him or her to purchase. Patagonia provides
consumers with opportunities to gain product knowledge and interact via its
website and communication campaigns. Providing this information offers a
pathway to create value via educating and sharing knowledge with consumers in
the pre-consumption phase.
Once a consumer purchases a product, Patagonia’s main goal is to deliver
a premium quality product for the consumer to experience. Maintaining a level
of premium quality allows Patagonia to achieve a high standard of value while
consumers use (value-in-use) its products. The craftsmanship of its products is
guaranteed. Patagonia believes in the quality of its products so much that it offers
consumers the option (and actually prefers they take up that option) to fix products
that have simply worn out, rather than having them buy new products. Through
its ‘Repair is Radical Act’ and ‘Worn Wear’ initiatives, Patagonia builds more value
with consumers by providing them with instructions on how to maintain, care
for and repair their products. To many consumers, this is a sign of a high-quality
Courtesy of Patagonia
Courtesy of Patagonia
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
Appendix 1 Case studies 473
product and represents value for money in the consumption process. It also marks
a transition to the disposal point in the consumption process that makes Patagonia
different from many other organisations.
Often, when consumers finish using a product it is simply disposed of. Many
organisations overlook this opportunity to reconnect or to continue creating value
with consumers. For Patagonia, the disposal point in the consumption process
is perhaps where it creates the most value with consumers. At the disposal
consumption point, consumers are encouraged not to buy new products they do
not really need – a testament to Patagonia’s focus on designing durable premium
products. In addition, opportunities for other consumers to purchase and reuse
old, but still useable, products and to facilitate the repair or recycling of worn-out
Patagonia gear are provided. Providing opportunities to create value with customers
at the disposal point of the consumption process helps build deep and continuous
relationships with consumers. Thus, consumers remain constantly connected to the
company, which belies Patagonia’s consumer-centric and sustainable marketing
approach. But where does Patagonia’s consumer-oriented, sustainable, nontraditional marketing approach stem from?
Mission and strategy
Akin to most successful organisations, Patagonia’s approach stems from its
founder, Yvon Chouinard. As current Patagonia CEO Rose Marcarlo states, ‘Yvon
Chouinard’s very basic philosophy has always been to make the very best product,
make it as durable as possible.’ On the surface, Chouinard’s philosophy seems to be
product-oriented, which may not seem different from many similar organisations.
However, the market orientation and practice of Patagonia’s philosophy with
various stakeholders is what makes Chouinard’s approach unique. As he states, ‘…
my lifelong mission is to prove business can indeed have a simpatico relationship
with the natural world.’ Ultimately, it is this philosophy that underpins Patagonia’s
market-oriented mission statement: Build the best product, cause no unnecessary
harm, use business to inspire and implement solutions to the environmental crisis.
Patagonia’s mission statement sheds light on the purpose, values and experience
that the company is trying to create for its stakeholders.
However, when it comes to setting strategic objectives that support the
company’s mission, Patagonia takes what many would consider to be a
counterintuitive approach. Patagonia’s recent strategy is actually focused on
restraining growth. Many would consider this the antithesis of running a successful
company in a capitalistic global market. Ironically, instilling objectives that many
would consider to be anti-growth has generated double-digit growth. As founder
Chouinard has been quoted, ‘I know it sounds crazy, but every time I have made a
decision that is best for the planet, I have made money. Our customers know that –
and they want to be part of that environmental commitment.’
Patagonia also continues to diversify other areas of its business portfolio under
the same philosophical mission. For example, Patagonia Provisions is a division
that looks to source sustainably produced food products designed to be taken on
outdoor excursions. Its aim is to educate consumers about where food comes from
and what is involved with sustainable food production. In addition, Patagonia has
also recently invested in Yerdle, a company that helps people reduce new product
consumption. Finally, Patagonia is listed as a ‘B-corp’ or benefit corporation.
This entails being part of a consortium of businesses that share information and
resources with each other, aiming to create mutual value for all stakeholders in
responsible ways beyond simply maximising profits. A review of Patagonia’s B-corp
annual report indicates numerous strategic objectives – beyond profit – that
exemplify the augmented value the company provides consumers of its products.
(See <www.patagonia.com/pdf/en_US/bcorp_annual_report_2014.pdf>.) Most
areas of Patagonia’s business portfolio are accessible at its physical retail outlets
and online store to communicate with consumers about the previous and ongoing
strategic initiatives. This allows consumers to interact with all facets of Patagonia’s
business in person or digitally 24/7.
Targeting
The result of Patagonia’s mission, and non-traditional strategic objectives, is a clear
position of differentiation from its competition in consumers’ minds. Part of how
Patagonia has been able to establish its market position is through understanding
its marketing environment and target audience. Much of Patagonia’s growth over
the last seven years occurred during the fall-out of the Global Financial Crisis.
Rather than cut back on its marketing visibility or reduce the quality of products
to offer cheaper products or to achieve better price margins, Patagonia relied on
communicating its philosophy and focusing on the enduring quality and value of its
products. In turn, this fulfilled consumer needs linked to larger sociocultural trends,
such as frugality, value for money, reusing, repairing and recycling, during this time
period. Patagonia understood that many target consumers had a desire to spend
their discretionary income more wisely on fewer, but high-quality, products that
would last. Consumers appreciated a company that also committed to offering
pathways to purchase quality, used products or help them repair products they
already owned. From Patagonia’s understanding of the marketing environment and
consumer trends during a difficult economic period, it was able to build authentic
relationships with its consumers and better position itself against competitors.
However, some sceptics question Patagonia’s approach. Some believe
Patagonia’s high prices and promotional materials are targeted to affluent
consumers who have the luxury of time to pursue adventures in exotic locations,
rather than less-affluent budget-conscious consumers looking for value for
money in durable products. Several of Patagonia’s stores are located in high
socioeconomic areas, indicating some potential insight to the latter strategy.
Others note that Patagonia’s pathways for fixing and purchasing used Patagonia
equipment are simply marketing strategies that steer consumers towards trading
up and purchasing additional products they might be interested in. Despite some
scepticism on the authenticity of altruism embedded in Patagonia’s initiatives, the
company continues to maintain double-digit growth.
Corporate social responsibility (CSR)
Along with well-positioned value propositions and consumer value-creation
opportunities, Patagonia’s corporate social-responsibility initiatives are often
considered exemplary. Patagonia is widely noted as developing CSR initiatives
that go above and beyond most other commercial companies. It has established
the Sustainable Apparel Coalition of organisations, which includes companies
such as Target and Walmart. Patagonia founder Yvon Chouinard co-authored an
award-winning book, The Responsible Company, which acts as a blueprint for
organisations that want to improve their CSR. In addition, Patagonia has also
provided consultation services to companies, such as Nike, that want advice on
enhancing their CSR. Other CSR initiatives Patagonia has developed include: the
Footprint Chronicles, which helps educate and connect consumers to the social
and environmental impacts of the products they buy; the Worn Wear initiative,
which encourages consumers to fix their worn products by providing them
with guides for caring and repairing products; the 1% for the Planet initiative,
which awards funds via its Environmental Grants Department to not-for-profit
organisations that promote environmental sustainability and conservation; and
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
474 Appendix 1 Case studies
the Cleanest Line Common Thread initiative, which supports recycling and/or
reselling and reusing products consumers no longer have a need for. All of these
initiatives contribute to Patagonia’s classification as a B-corp. Indeed, Patagonia’s
CSR initiatives help further build the sense of value that consumers receive in
consuming Patagonia products, by satisfying both immediate and future needs
of its stakeholders.
Beyond developing ethical and impactful CSR initiatives, Patagonia is unique in
the way it embeds CSR into the organisation. Patagonia integrates and promotes
its CSR initiatives in tandem with its products to further enhance consumer value.
Many organisations develop CSR initiatives of merit, but few integrate and promote
them in a way that demonstrate value via a connection to the consumer experience
of using the products. Building narratives is Patagonia’s strategy for demonstrating
to consumers the connection between its CSR initiatives and product value.
For example, Patagonia’s annual catalogue is not simply a glossy magazine
with pictures of its products and information about prices. Its catalogue is put
together more like a coffee-table book that is filled with stories of people wearing
Patagonia products, often partaking in adventures that connect with the company’s
CSR initiatives. Patagonia also produces ‘mini-documentaries’ that demonstrate its
manufacturing process by telling stories about its producers and suppliers in its
supply chain through the Footprint Chronicles initiative. Patagonia also encourages
consumers to interact on its website and share stories about their personal
experiences with Patagonia products. Some stories are then showcased in a short
documentary about how consumers have worn and repaired Patagonia products
over the years, underpinning its Worn Wear CSR initiative. Using promotional
elements that not only communicate and create visibility for its products, but also
incorporate its CSR initiatives, helps make Patagonia’s CSR initiatives more tangible
for consumers to connect with and become inspired by.
Patagonia continues to be a leader in CSR and to build relationships that
grow its consumer base through authentic value-creation opportunities across the
marketing process. It accomplishes this with counterintuitive marketing strategies
that are anchored to its mission of creating the best-quality product with as little
impact as possible on the world’s environment. Although some may question
Patagonia’s altruism within its marketing strategies and consider it risky to develop
business strategies that are anti-growth, Patagonia has experienced consistent
growth over the last decade. Patagonia’s dedication to being a responsible
B-corp that designs products and develops CSR initiatives that are integrated and
promoted with a high level of integrity, demonstrates its ability to fulfil short-term
consumer needs and focus on long-term value, which benefits all stakeholders it
influences.
Discussion questions
❶ What marketing approach does Patagonia utilise? Justify your answer.
❷ What type of value might consumers associate with Patagonia products?
What are some examples of how Patagonia creates various types of value
with consumers via building relationships?
❸ Thinking about the target marketing process, how does Patagonia segment its
target audience? Describe a profile of a typical Patagonia consumer.
❹ Think about the macro- and microenvironmental factors that influence
organisations. What types of trends has Patagonia observed in the macro- and/
or microlevel environments? How have these trends influenced Patagonia’s
marketing strategy?
❺ What other companies or industries may benefit or not benefit from utilising
Patagonia’s anti-consumption and anti-growth approach? Would Patagonia’s
marketing strategy and approach to business be suitable for all organisations?
Justify your answer.
❻ What types of CSR marketing initiatives does Patagonia employ? How might
Patagonia continue to improve their CSR initiatives?
Sources
‘B-corp annual report – Patagonia’, 2014, available at <www.patagonia.com/pdf/en_US/
bcorp_annual_report_2014.pdf>, accessed 27 February 2016.
Baer, D, ‘How Patagonia’s new CEO is increasing profits while trying to save the world’, Fast
Company, 28 February 2014, available at <www.fastcompany.com/3026713/lessonslearned/how-patagonias-new-ceo-is-increasing-profits-while-trying-to-save-the-world>,
accessed 29 February 2016.
Bradley, R, ‘The woman driving Patagonia to be (even more) radical’, Fortune, 14 September
2015, available at <http://fortune.com/2015/09/14/rose-marcario-patagonia/>, accessed
3 March 2016.
Chouinard, Y & Stanely, V, The Responsible Company, 2012, Ventura, CA: Patagonia.
‘Footprint-Patagonia’, 2016, available at <www.patagonia.com/us/footprint>, accessed
4 March 2016.
‘Inside Patagonia – Patagonia’, 2016, available at <www.patagonia.com.au/insidepatagonia>, accessed 3 March 2015.
Mackinnon, J B, ‘Patagonia’s anti-growth strategy’, The New Yorker, 21 May 2015, available
at <www.newyorker.com/business/currency/patagonias-anti-growth-strategy>, accessed
2 March 2016.
PYMNTS, ‘Retail growth by not growing’, PYMNTS, 2 December 2015, accessed
1 March 2016.
Ryan, K, ‘The bottom line: Patagonia, North Face, and the myth of green consumerism’,
Groundswell Stories, 31 July 2014, available at <http://groundswell.org/the-bottom-linepatagonia-north-face-and-the-myth-of-green-consumerism/>, accessed 28 February 2016.
Sacks, D, ‘Patagonia CEO Rose Marcario fights the fights worth fighting’, Fast Company,
6 January 2015, available at <www.fastcompany.com/3039739/creative-conversations/
patagonia-ceo-rose-marcario-fights-the-fights-worth-fighting>, accessed 29 February 2016.
Stock, K, ‘Patagonia’s “buy less” plea spurs more buying’, Bloomberg Business, 28 August
2013, available at <www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2013-08-28/patagonias-buy-lessplea-spurs-more-buying>, accessed 1 March 2016.
‘Worn wear stories – Patagonia’, 2016, available at <www.patagonia.com/us/wornwear-stories?dmmid=54069308&utm_source=em&utm_medium=email&utm_
campaign=112715_ww&ett=1564556750&src=112715_ET_mi5>, accessed
28 February 2016.
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
Appendix 1 Case studies 475
Supermarket wars: The battle
continues!
Jan Charbonneau
University of Tasmania, Australia
Every day, a fierce battle rages in Australia. At stake, the $88 billion Aussies spend
annually on groceries (IBIS World, 2016). Yes … Australian consumers spend
$88 billion per year on milk, bread, toilet paper, chicken, frozen pizzas, pet food
and chocolate bars.
Aussies are spoiled for choice when it comes to where they spend their
$88 billion, from corner stores to large suburban supermarkets and endless options
in between. Yet, for many years, two main players have dominated Australia’s
supermarket sector – Woolworths and Coles. While figures vary, the estimates are
that this duopoly control 60–80 per cent of the market. By comparison, in the United
Kingdom, the two major chains (Tesco and Sainsbury) control 48 per cent, and in
the United States, the top two control about 20 per cent (Wal-Mart and Kroger).
If you think these two supermarket giants have been around forever, it’s because
they nearly have. Woolworths – often affectionately called Woolies – opened its
first outlet in Sydney in 1924 as a ‘handy place where good things are cheap’.
Today, Woolies employs over 111 000 Aussies at its almost 1000 supermarkets.
Coles started as Australia’s first variety store in Melbourne in 1914, expanding into
today’s network of almost 2300 stores and employing over 100 000 Australians
who serve its weekly 20 million customers.
Australia’s giants battle it out
Since 2008, Woolies and Coles have been locked in a heated battle for each and
every Aussie supermarket dollar. Previous higher prices and lower quality had lost
Coles significant market share, something they were determined to fix. As these
two giants battle it out in each aspect of the marketing mix, it is often difficult to
determine who is winning as each move by one is countered by the other.
The average supermarket contains between 20 000 and 40 000 SKUs (stock
keeping units, or individual products). Both supermarkets cater for every price
range, stocking their shelves from floor to ceiling with the big brands Aussies
cannot live without; speciality offerings, such as ‘gluten-free’; lower-priced ‘basics’;
and shelf after shelf of home brands.
Both are loyal Aussie companies, accessing 96 per cent of their fresh fruit and
vegetables, 100 per cent of their fresh milk and 100 per cent of their fresh meat
from Australian sources (so just who are ‘the fresh food people’?). Both believe in
ethical sourcing, offering sow-stall-free pork and Fairtrade chocolate. Both offer
the convenience of online shopping by delivery or ‘click and collect’ and have the
obligatory smartphone app for ordering.
Both use traditional (television and flyers) and online (websites and social
media) media for promotion, and make extensive use of their celebrity chefs (Jamie
Oliver for Woolies; Curtis Stone and Heston Blumenthal for Coles) for product
development, branding and promotion. And both sponsor popular televisioncooking competitions (so, if I want to ‘cook like a Masterchef’, where should I
shop?), ensuring maximum exposure for their brands and stores.
But the main battleground for these two giants is price. Supermarkets are highvolume, low-margin businesses. Cost of goods sold typically account for 75 per cent,
with overhead, including staff and stores, adding another 18 per cent. That leaves about
7 cents out of every $1 of that annual $88 billion sales – and then, of course, there
are taxes and interest to pay! So, keeping customers is vital – but today’s customer
is extremely price sensitive. According to the 2008 Grocery Inquiry, the majority
of consumers are likely to change supermarkets for as little as a 5 per cent price
difference (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, 2008). Woolworths’
own research suggests that 68 per cent of consumers actively look for price discounts,
with 47 per cent buying on price alone (Woolworths, 2014).
The two giants satisfy their consumers’ price sensitivity through sales promotion
pricing, offering regular weekly and daily specials, bulk buys and special promotions,
such as ‘Buy one, get one free’ and ‘Buy this, get that’. In the last couple of years,
however, Coles and Woolies have gone one step further, with ‘everyday low prices’
– no need to wait for a sale, prices on these items are permanently reduced!
Since 2011, Coles has permanently reduced the price of 2000 products (Coles,
2015) and, in 2015, Woolworths invested $200 million in lower prices (Woolworths,
2015). To get an idea as to just how competitive these two players are, when Coles
reduced the everyday price of its roast chickens to $8.00, Woolworths responded
by lowering theirs to $7.90!
The winners in this price battle are clearly the consumers. Coles, for example,
claims its ‘big red hand’ can save Aussie households an average of $640 per year
(Coles, 2015). But many of these in-store specials or ‘everyday low prices’ are
‘brought to you by’ distributors, suppliers and producers. While supermarkets often
reduce their margins for special sales, the majority of the price reductions are the
result of lower wholesale prices.
So, why would a distributor, supplier or producer reduce its wholesale price,
not just for weekly specials as they have historically done, but permanently? Like
martin berry/Alamy
sammybez/Alamy
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
476 Appendix 1 Case studies
their supermarket customers, they are under pressure to generate sales, but with
the added threat of having shelf allocations changed, ‘shelving costs’ increased or,
worse, their products de-listed and replaced with home brands or parallel imports
(brands purchased at lower prices overseas and imported) if they do not support
price reductions. Next time you are in the supermarket, check out the number of
home brands and you will quickly realise this is a bona fide threat.
Despite this ongoing competition-based price battle, with each supermarket
trying to best the other with its combination of sales promotion and ‘everyday low’
pricing, both Coles and Woolworths carefully manage pricing of their entire mix
of products to ensure that overall profit does not suffer – thereby playing a very
delicate balancing game.
BUT – and it is a very large ‘but’ – change is afoot in supermarket land.
Consumer demand and shopping behaviours have been changing, and new
competitors are grabbing market share.
Australia’s changing shoppers
In 2013, Woolworths commissioned a report analysing the changes to Australian
supermarket shopping behaviours over the past 25 years (Woolworths, 2013).
The report, Trolley Trends, revealed Australia has become a more cosmopolitan society,
with Aussies developing a taste for such foods as lamb kofkas and chicken korma.
Even the traditional Aussie ‘roast and three veg’ dinner has changed and is now more
likely to be roast chicken, not beef, with pasta or rice, not potatoes. Today’s shopper
looks for a wider range of fresh and healthy foods and spends more time preparing
restaurant-style foods at home. ‘Superfoods’ such as kale, and ‘exotic’ ingredients such
as lemongrass, are now regularly stocked items. And, believe it or not, the secondbest-selling grocery category is fresh fruit, surpassing staples such as milk (Han, 2015).
Aussies have also changed their shopping behaviour, increasingly using
supermarkets like a pantry. Gone is the big weekly shop, with Aussies now
shopping an average of 2.5 times per week and buying, each time, an average
9.5 products worth $36. Have you noticed more shopping baskets at store entries,
trolleys getting smaller and even the stores themselves shrinking in size (e.g.
Woolworths Metro)?
So, what about the supermarket of the future? Woolworths’ 2014 Future of
Fresh report suggests that for 2034’s main customers, now labelled Generation
Alpha, supermarket shopping will be more of a social experience. These hyperconnected consumers will view the local shopping centre as their ‘new village
green’, a place to connect with friends and neighbours. Their physical shopping
experience will focus on fresh and local produce and foodstuffs, with common
household items most likely home-delivered (no more lugging 10-kilo bags of dog
food) and perhaps ordered automatically (via their ‘smart’ refrigerator/pantry).
2034’s shoppers will demand a ‘back-to-basics approach – food that is organic,
local, fresh and delivered daily’, focusing on the impact on their personal health.
Buying fresh is already important to four out of five Australians but 2034’s
customer will be increasingly interested in the ‘social health’ aspect of their
purchases – the impact on ‘communities, growers, local farmers, and the
environment’ – investigating the provenance of their purchases (e.g. its source,
how it was made). Approximately half of all households are forecast to be singles
and couples without children so the focus on convenience is expected to continue –
watch as Australia’s supermarkets roll out more items designed to ‘save time’, such
as pre-cut vegetables and healthy takeaway and fresh meals.
And, interestingly, price and value for money are expected to still remain
paramount – good news for shoppers, but perhaps not such good news for
supermarkets, distributors, suppliers and producers.
New players entering and old players
changing
While Coles and Woolies are Australia’s undisputed supermarket giants, they are
facing some major competition. Perhaps the biggest threat to these giants is a
player that opened its first Australian store in 2001 and offers fewer SKUs (around
1000) in smaller premises – ALDI. Although a new entrant in the Australian market,
ALDI has a comparable history to Coles and Woolies, opening its first store in
Germany in 1913. ALDI now has more than 7000 stores across three continents,
including over 400 in Australia, with more on the way.
ALDI stores are smaller – about 830 square metres – compared to Coles’ and
Woolies’ average 4000 square metres (IBIS World, 2016). But ALDI manages to
cram these smaller premises full of bargains on Aussies’ most-demanded and
popular products, many under its own private label. ALDI bills itself as a ‘discount
supermarket offering great quality at incredibly low prices’. Projections are that
ALDI will hit $15 billion in annual sales by 2020, taking a serious bite out of the
giants’ market share (AFN, 2016a).
ALDI has already surpassed IGA (Independent Grocers of Australia) to become
Australia’s third-largest supermarket with market share of over 12 per cent, and
is a key driver of reduced prices in the sector overall (Chung, 2016). And, for the
foreseeable future, each new ALDI store takes market share from existing players,
rather than cannibalising any existing ALDI stores.
While it is no longer number three, don’t rule out IGA just yet. IGA, the
backbone of many smaller communities, not only has expansion plans – it is now a
player in the price game. Price reductions across the IGA network are supported by
the efforts of Metcash, the wholesale, distribution and marketing company that has
harnessed the purchasing power of 2400 independent grocers and convenience
stores. IGA is now able to price-match hundreds of routinely purchased products
against the lower of Woolworths’ or Coles’ everyday shelf prices, ensuring ‘it
pays to shop independent’. Should the big players be worried? IGA shoppers are
Australia’s most loyal, with 30 per cent of those who mainly shop at IGA only
shopping at IGA – this compares to 25 per cent for Woolies, 24 per cent for Coles
and 7 per cent for ALDI (AFN, 2015).
And, in a somewhat ironic twist, upmarket retailer David Jones, owned by
South African Woolworths Holdings (not affiliated with Woolworths Australia)
intends to move into the premium end of the grocery market, appealing to
Australia’s increasingly discerning ‘foodies’ (AFN, 2016b). In 2008, Woolies tried
to do the same with its own ‘posh grocer’ – Thomas Dux – but could not make it
work, eventually closing down the brand. Perhaps another ‘Woolies’ can make it
work – time will tell.
Competition is likely to heat up even further as German discount chain Lidl,
the fourth-largest retailer in the world, has signalled its intention to move ‘down
under’, registering trademarks and assessing property.
Innovation for competitive advantage
So, how will Australia’s grocers achieve and sustain competitive advantage?
Management guru Peter Drucker stated many years ago that the only sustainable
competitive advantage is innovation.
Consider the transformation in business models as power has shifted from
suppliers to customers. Who would have thought that the world’s major source of
short-term accommodation would not own one room (think AirBnB) or the world’s
biggest taxi service would not own a car (think Uber). So, to remain relevant,
Australia’s supermarkets, from the largest to the smallest, need to innovate in
response to changing shopper behaviours and changing competitors.
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
Appendix 1 Case studies 477
How do they do that? In its 2015 annual report, Woolworths nicely articulated
the answer for supermarkets: ‘… innovating to meet market challenges and finding
new ways to delight our customers … firmly embedding the customer at the core
of all decision making’. So, for consumers, watch this space: Supermarket wars –
the battle continues!
Discussion questions
❶ How do Australia’s supermarkets provide value for their customers?
❷ Access Woolworths’ reports, Trolley Trends and Future of Fresh. Select one
supermarket and prepare a report indicating how it could take advantage of
the insights in these two reports.
❸ Identify four family or friends – two of whom do their main shopping (at least
75 per cent) at one of Australia’s main three supermarkets only (Coles, Woolies,
ALDI), and the other two who routinely shop in at least two supermarkets.
Interview each to determine:
• why they are – or are not – ‘store loyal’
• how they believe each of Australia’s main three supermarkets have
responded to changes in the way that Australians shop
• which supermarket they believe has the lowest prices, and why
• how important they believe price is to supermarket selection
• which supermarket they believe is winning ‘supermarket wars’, and why
• any recommendations they would make to their preferred supermarkets
(e.g. new products, opening hours, layout and so on).
Based on the responses, prepare a report for one of the supermarkets as
to opportunities for competitive advantage.
❹ Visit <woolworths.com.au>, <coles.com.au> and <aldi.com.au>. Compare
and contrast the marketing mixes for these three supermarkets and discuss
how (and, indeed, if) each could create a unique position and sustainable
competitive advantage in the supermarket sector.
❺ The focus on price and value for money is expected to continue into the
foreseeable future, with prices expected to continue going ‘down, down, down’.
Discuss the short-term and long-term impacts of supermarket price wars.
Sources
<www.aldi.com.au>
<www.coles.com.au>
<www.costco.com.au>
<www.wesfarmers.com.au>
<www.woolworths.com.au>
<www.woolworthslimited.com.au>
AFN, 2015, ‘Aldi vs IGA: When does loyalty count?’, <www.ausfoodnews.com.au>,
9 September.
AFN, 2016a, ‘Aldi Australia’s $15 billion sales prediction, Morgan Stanley’, <www.
ausfoodnews.com.au>, 20 April.
AFN, 2016b, ‘Will the David Jones entry into premium groceries be a success?’, <www.
ausfoodnews.com.au>, 15 February.
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, 2008, Report of the ACCC Inquiry into
the Competitiveness of Retail Prices for Standard Groceries, <www.accc.gov.au>, July.
Chung, Frank, 2016, ‘Moody’s rings Aldi alarm bell for Coles, Woolies’, <www.news.com.
au>, 22 April.
Coles, 2015, 2015 Annual Report, <www.coles.com.au>.
Han, Esther, 2015, ‘Australia’s growing love for fresh fruit transforms typical grocery basket’,
<www.smh.com.au>, 13 September.
Hogan, Andrea, 2016, ‘The top 20 supermarket brands Australians say they cannot do
without’, <www.ausfood.com.au>, 23 March.
IBIS World, 2016, Supermarkets and Grocery Stores in Australia: Market Research Report,
<www.ibisworld.com.au>, February.
Stuart Alexander, ‘Market overview’, <www.stuartalexander.com.au>.
Woolworths, 2013, Woolworths Trolley Trends, <www.woolworths.com.au>.
Woolworths, 2014, Future of Fresh, <www.woolworths.com.au>.
Woolworths, 2015, Annual Report 2015, <www.woolworths.com.au>.
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
478 Appendix 1 Case studies
Realestate.com.au: From garage
start-up to market leader
Geoff Fripp
The University of Sydney, Australia
Introduction
Realestate.com.au is an Australian digital advertising business specialising in
residential property listings, and is owned and operated by REA Group (ASX: REA). They
are the market leader, with 95 per cent of all properties for sale being placed on their
website. They have achieved strong levels of consumer engagement, with their website
averaging almost 900 million page views per month in 2015. (REA Group, 2016)
This is an impressive market position for a firm that was only set up in 1995
and did not start trading as realestate.com.au until 1998. The business was initially
established by Marty Howell and Karl Sabljak, who first ran the operation out of
their garage with the help of two family members (Kohler, 2005).
Fast forward 20 years and, today, realestate.com.au is the prime asset of the
REA Group, a publicly listed Australian company with an annual turnover in excess
of $600 million and a net profit of $214.5 million in 2015–16 (REA Group, 2016).
The Group have expanded operations into commercial property listings, media
advertising, strategic partnerships and international operations.
So how did a ‘garage start-up’ prove to be so successful and change the way
Australians buy and sell property? And how do they still manage to remain the
market leader when their main competitor (Domain, <www.domain.com.au>) is
a subsidiary of a major media operator in Australia? Let’s review their history and
their current marketing strategy to find out the answers to these questions.
The internet world in 1995
It is likely that most students reviewing this case study would have grown up with
the internet but, back in 1995, the internet was a relatively new concept. At that
time, it is estimated that only around 16 million people worldwide were internet
users, which was less than 1 per cent of the world’s population (Internet World
Statistics, 2015). And, keeping in mind that Google was not established until 1998
and YouTube only started in 2005 (Hosch, 2015), the launch of the realestate.com.
au business in 1995 demonstrated a lot of foresight regarding the potential impact
of the internet.
While there are some advantages of being first to market, it also carries the
burden of being responsible for educating the market – in this case, about the
benefits of this new technology. Fortunately for realestate.com.au, Fairfax Media
(with their Domain website) did not follow them into online property advertising
for another four years (Delvin, 2005), giving them some breathing space to get
established and create their market.
The business model: Consumers
versus customers
Before we review how realestate.com.au became established, it is necessary to
clarify the difference between what they call their ‘customers’ and what they call
their ‘consumers’, as this will help us understand their business model and strategy.
The firm views the visitors to their website as their consumers. These are people
looking to buy, sell or rent property, as well as those just interested in viewing
properties for sale. As these consumers access realestate.com.au’s services for
free, they are not classified as customers. Instead, the firm’s customers are the real
estate agents who take out paid subscriptions, as well as the media agencies who
take out advertising space on their website.
It is important to note that while it is the customers that are the main sources of
revenue, it is consumers that actually provide the value to the firm. This is because
the greater the number of consumers visiting the website, the greater amount that
the firm is able to charge for its listings and advertising space.
The challenges of new product
adoption
As you are probably aware, there are many industries that have been ‘disrupted’
due to the internet and its capabilities. And there are numerous success stories of
new players becoming the market leader during the internet era, such as iTunes,
Amazon and even Seek.com.au in Australia.
But imagine the challenge that realestate.com.au was facing in the late 1990s
as a service firm trying to sell intangible benefits. They had to convince real estate
agencies to change from their traditional promotional practices of newspaper
advertising to start spending money on online advertising. It is always difficult to
break an established system that is working well for every party involved. Buyers
were accustomed to scanning newspaper ads or viewing a real estate business’s
shopfront window, and agents were content in getting the property vendor to
‘invest’ in a newspaper advertising budget that showcased, not only the property,
but the real estate agency as well.
Therefore, realestate.com.au had to clearly communicate the relative
advantages of online advertising over traditional advertising. There were several
key benefits that realestate.com.au communicated to agents, including:
• Online advertising will promote the property to potential buyers who are
outside the geographic reach of the newspaper, such as interstate and
international investors.
• The agents could provide more information for potential buyers, such as
photographs and floor plans.
• This extra information would deliver better-qualified prospects, who were
already knowledgeable about the property, resulting in a more efficient sales
process.
• Being an online advertiser would create a point-of-difference for the agency
and lead to more clients in the long term.
With its ongoing selling efforts (driven by extra staff numbers), realestate.com.au
managed to slowly gain traction and, by 2001, the team had achieved 15 per cent
agent penetration, which represented around 1200 agencies (Baker, 2008).
But this rate of growth proved expensive and, by the late 1990s, the expenditure of
the firm far exceeded revenues. As a consequence, they needed to bring in equity
partners (such as Macquarie Bank in 1998), resulting in the founding owners’
share of the company being substantially diluted over a series of capital-raising
transactions.
realestate.com.au
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
Appendix 1 Case studies 479
The slow-moving dominant player
Until the mid-1990s, the classified advertising section of the newspaper (property
and jobs listings, in particular) were considered to be ‘rivers of gold’ by the major
newspapers. This is because classified advertising generated high and almost
‘guaranteed’ profits, year after year.
However, with the advent of the internet, the newspapers, like many other
established industry leaders at the time, did not recognise the threat of this new
technology. Typically, industry leaders perceived the online channel as a minor threat
due to its low level of consumer usage and much lower profit margins – at the time.
It was not until 1999 that Fairfax Media decided to set up its own online
property-search website. And, in order to protect its newspaper advertising revenue,
they decided to build a new brand and launched with domain.com.au (rather than
leveraging their existing newspaper brand/s). Their initial strategy was built around
heavy (and free) promotion in their own newspapers. They believed that, with their
strong readership base, they would be able to catch-up and eventually dominate the
online advertising market as well as they did the traditional newspaper advertising
market. But they had given their competitor a four-year head start in signing up
agents, and realestate.com.au had around 1000 agency relationships by that time.
Today’s continued success: It’s all
about consumer engagement
While the above discussion provides an overview of how realestate.com.au achieved
its early success, we need to explore how they have managed to maintain their market
dominance, particularly given the competitive threats they were (and still are) facing.
A key success factor for realestate.com.au is their higher level of consumer
engagement. This is a competitive advantage that they choose to publicise
regularly. For example, here are some key metrics that have appeared in their media
releases and investor presentations (REA Group, 2016):
• Ninety-five per cent of all properties in Australia are listed with realestate.com.
au, as opposed to 72 per cent for Domain.
• Realestate.com.au averaged 889 million monthly page views in 2016, which
is 5 times more than Domain.
• Realestate.com.au calculate that they control 85 per cent ‘share-of-time’ that
consumers spend on realestate.com.au and Domain.
• The realestate.com.au user’s average dwell-time on site is 6.1 times longer
than for Domain.
There are two main areas that drive realestate.com.au’s consumer engagement,
namely product design and website features, and entertainment and information.
Product design and website features
In terms of product design, it is clear that realestate.com.au are a fast adopter of
technology and generally lead the property-advertising market with innovation.
Being at risk of becoming a generic offering, the firm needs to ensure they offer
clear service differentiation. In addition to regular improvements to their website
in terms of simplicity and ease of use, some of the extra functionality they have
recently introduced includes:
• a ‘discover’ facility that helps consumers identify suburbs within their financial
budget
• a price-lookup service that estimates the value of virtually every property in
Australia
• a ‘find an agent’ guide to help choose the best real estate agency
• a renovation calculator to help consumers estimate the total cost of potential
renovations.
Realestate.com.au have also introduced third-party provided services, such as
access to a home-loan broker and a utility transfer service (where consumers can
organise relocation of services with all their utility suppliers with one request). These
services have the dual benefit of improving the overall service to the consumer,
while also enhancing the firm’s revenue position. As you can see, realestate.com.au
are developing their website to become a ‘one-stop shop’ for all consumer needs.
Information and inspiration
Realestate.com.au’s research indicated that many consumers were viewing
properties for general interest outside of their buying/selling property cycle.
In other words, the website was starting to become a form of ‘entertainment’ for
their audience. Management decided to reinforce this perception by developing
engaging content, both online and in television advertising. The firm also decided
to tap into the general interest in property, as demonstrated by the success of
television shows such as The Block and Selling Houses Australia. And, in 2015,
they launched their own web series called ‘Australia Lives Here’. This series
profiles Australian celebrities, sports stars, actors and television chefs, allowing
viewers to ‘tour’ inside their homes and to find out what makes a celebrity’s
property their ‘home’.
They have also launched a lifestyle content section on their website, to give
consumers personal insights and inspiration about creating and styling a home.
These extra facilities represent a move towards branded entertainment, where
the website is engaging and entertaining its audience, rather than simply being a
functional information tool. These services encourage consumers to regularly visit
the website and perhaps start thinking about their next property. And even if such
initiatives do not trigger the need for a property purchase, they bring more traffic to
the website, which helps drive advertising revenues.
Using advertising to broaden
positioning
In 2014, Arnold Schwarzenegger became the spokesperson for realestate.com.
au. Schwarzenegger, as a high-profile Hollywood actor, was virtually guaranteed
to achieve cut-through and most likely to go viral. This advertainment series
consisted of seven television commercials that were humorous in nature, based on
the premise that Schwarzenegger had confused Australia with his home country
of Austria.
To launch the television commercial, the firm booked space on all free-to-air
channels, plus subscription channels, plus main digital-advertising channels – all
at the same time – in order to maximise the commercial’s reach. The firm targeted
the 6.20 pm time slot as this was the peak usage time for technology by Australian
consumers. Accordingly, the television ad was able to reach 2.7 million people in
the first night alone (realestate.com.au, 2014).
The key goal of the television commercial was not brand awareness, but was
designed to broaden the firm’s positioning from being simply a property-search
website to being a full one-stop shop for all property needs.
Growing revenues: From price
penetration to value-added pricing
When the firm first started in the late 1990s, the concept of online advertising
was new and consumers generally turned to newspaper listings for their property
search. This traditional consumer behaviour, as well as the relatively low level of
internet penetration at the time, meant that the start-up business had to price its
services quite low initially.
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
480 Appendix 1 Case studies
Market-penetration pricing is designed to reduce financial risk and remove
price as an obstacle to the sale in order to maximise sales. Like many internet-based
businesses at the time, the firm’s focus was on maximising the customer base, with
the plan of dominating the market and eventually generating strong revenue due
to their large-scale size. (Note: You may be aware that Facebook did not engage in
advertising in its first years in order to achieve strong usage levels before doing so.)
Despite a few shaky years where the firm’s investment in growth exceeded
their revenue and most of their capital injections, the overall revenue plan has
worked. With almost 900 million page views per month, realestate.com.au has the
ability to reach virtually all serious property buyers in the country. And along with
their 65 per cent audience exclusivity (REA Group, 2016), their dominant position
gives the firm the ability to charge higher subscription fees per month to the real
estate agencies, as well as higher rates for their advertisers.
Another advantage of their traffic volume is the degree of competition between
real estate agencies. By offering the option for a property to be listed higher in the
consumer’s online search results, realestate.com.au has been able to continue to
grow revenue. Many agents are now choosing this extra option (known as depth
products) and, in many cases, passing the extra cost on to the property vendor. This
has the overall effect of increasing the revenue per listing, while having thousands
of real estate agents effectively acting as a salesforce selling advertising to the
end-consumer.
Migration to mobile and their future
Realestate.com.au is tapping into the trend of consumers using multiple devices.
Australians now spend more time on their devices than they do watching television,
and consumers tend to carry a device with them most of the time. The firm has
recognised that consumers access their website via multiple devices and have
provided consumers with the ability to access their realestate.com.au account from
any device and automatically sync their preferences and favourite property selections.
In 2015, the number of visits to the firm’s website via smartphones accounted
for over 20 per cent of their total traffic (REA Group, 2016). As a result, the firm is
focused upon consumer retention across all devices and technologies. For example,
at the start of 2016, the firm announced that their app had been downloaded more
than 5 million times (realestate.com.au, 2016). And, in 2015, they were first to
market with an app for the Apple Watch, which sends property alerts to consumers
for relevant and nearby properties (a form of location-based marketing).
It is likely that the digital property-advertising market in Australia is approaching
maturity and, with 95 per cent agent penetration, there are only limited growth
prospects for the firm domestically without the addition of new services. This is why
the REA Group overall is now pursuing international expansion.
Discussion questions
❶ There are several extra services and website features discussed in the case.
Outline the firm’s product offering, using the three levels of products model.
In which of the three levels do you think realestate.com.au have achieved their
greatest degree of service differentiation?
❷ The case suggests that the firm’s revenues are reaching maturity in the
Australian market. What new product ideas do you have for the firm? (Please
consider both the firm’s consumers and their customers.)
❸ What are the competitive advantages of Fairfax Media (with their Domain
website)? What marketing activities would you recommend for them to
implement in order to challenge realestate.com.au for the market leadership
over time?
❹ The product was adapted over time because of the relative advantages and
extra benefits doing so offered to the market. Other than these superior
product benefits, what were the other factors that contributed to the success
of this new product?
❺ Do you agree with REA Group’s pricing approach? Why, or why not? As part
of your answer, outline the risks inherent in the firm’s approach to pricing
strategy.
References
Baker, S, 2008. Property Portal Watch [Online], <www.propertyportalwatch.com/2008/08/
about-realestatecomau/>, accessed 14 February 2016.
Delvin, D, 2005. Sydney Morning Herald [Online], <www.smh.com.au/news/10-years-online/
how-we-built-our-home-on-the-web/2005/04/07/1112815644831.html>, accessed
13 February 2016.
Hosch, W L, 2015. Encyclopedia Britannica [Online], <www.britannica.com/topic/GoogleInc>, accessed 12 February 2016.
Internet World Statistics, 2015. Internet World Stats [Online], <www.internetworldstats.
com/>, accessed 14 February 2016.
Kohler, A, 2005. Sydney Morning Herald [Online], <www.smh.com.au/news/business/slippingthrough-the-classified-net/2005/10/04/1128191717753.html>, accessed
13 February 2016.
REA Group, 2016. REA Group Investor Presentation FY 2016 [Online], <www.rea-group.com/
irm/PDF/1908_0/REAGroupInvestorAnalystPresentation>, accessed 14 February 2016.
realestate.com.au, 2014. Media release: Arnold Schwarzenegger fronts new realestate.
com.au brand campaign [Online], <www.rea-group.com/IRM/PDF/1269/
ArnoldSchwarzeneggerfrontsnewrealestatecomaucampaign>, accessed 12 February 2016.
realestate.com.au, 2016. Media release: More than 5 million downloads [Online],
<www.rea-group.com/IRM/PDF/1798/Morethan5milliondownloads
forAustraliasmostusedpropertyapp>, accessed 11 February 2016.
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
Appendix 1 Case studies 481
Tasmanian Walking Company:
Balancing luxury and adventure
in a sustainable experience
Gemma Lewis, PhD
University of Tasmania, Australia
For over 25 years, the Tasmanian Walking Company (TWC) has been marketing
multi-day guided walks; enabling people of all backgrounds and fitness levels
to experience some of the world’s most iconic mountain and coastal scenery.
The founder, Ken Latona, was a pioneer in establishing accommodation-based walks
in Australia. Using his architectural expertise, he won the right to design and develop
the Cradle Mountain huts on Tasmania’s world-famous Overland Track. To this day,
these remain the only private accommodation offering along the track. The Cradle
Mountain Huts Walk has been enhanced and improved since its beginning some
30 years ago. The most challenging and, at six days, the longest of TWC’s
experiences, the walk takes guests into the heart of Tasmania’s World Heritagelisted Cradle Mountain–Lake St Clair National Park.
TWC’s domestic customer profile comprises of mostly mature (45–65
years of age) consumers living in urban areas and who are seeking a luxury,
adventure- and nature-based experience. They tend to be retired professionals
(e.g. doctors, lawyers) – in other words individuals with a high disposable income
and willingness to pay for a guided nature walk, rather than undertaking the
experience independently.
In addition to targeting high-income consumers in the Australian states of
Victoria, New South Wales and Queensland, TWC target overseas tourists, and have
successfully raised their profile (via international trade shows) in the United States,
the United Kingdom and Japan. Interestingly, although Chinese tourists rank
Australian beaches, the Australian wildlife and Australian food and wine as their
top three attractions (Tourism Australia, 2015), they are not currently a target
market for TWC – possibly because they are less interested in consuming these
experiences while undertaking a multi-day adventure walk.
After many years offering just the one walking experience, TWC added to their
product portfolio in 1999 when they launched the four-day Bay of Fires Lodge Walk.
This walk allows the company to tap into a new market segment – consumers
looking for a beach-walk experience rather than bushwalking (Tasmanian Walking
Co., 2016). More recently, TWC have built an ecologically sustainable day spa at
the award-winning Bay of Fires Lodge, where guests can enjoy treatments using
the organic skincare range supplied by LI’TYA (Li’tya, 2016). Before introducing this
new activity, TWC had to adapt certain treatments to ensure they maintained their
focus on sustainable resource usage. Their outdoor bathing pavilion, for example,
was only possible through the installation of additional rainwater tanks. If, during
summer, rainwater is scarce, TWC cease offering this spa treatment.
In 2014, the new owners of TWC achieved their vision of adding a third product
to the eco-tourism operation: the Wineglass Bay Sail Walk. This land-and-water
tourism experience guides customers in small groups around Maria Island, Freycinet
Peninsula and Schouten Island. During the day, guests walk among the coastal
wilderness and, of a night, enjoy three-course dinners aboard the company’s luxury
yacht, Lady Eugenie.
In October 2017, the company will launch a fourth eco-tourism product
targeted to the true adventure seeker, the Three Capes Lodge Walk, in Tasmania’s
rugged south. This experience will offer customers a second long-distance and
challenging bushwalk experience, similar to that offered by the Cradle Mountain
Overland Track.
Managing customer expectations and
creating value
Ensuring their guests have realistic expectations and are prepared for walking in
the alpine or coastal wilderness can be challenging for TWC. On the TWC website,
potential customers can click on a page titled, ‘Which walk is right for me?’, where
they match up their interests and fitness levels with the three different walks currently
on offer. A detailed itinerary for each walk is also available online, so that consumers
can learn about what to expect on each day of their multi-day walk experience.
At their company headquarters, TWC’s small marketing and sales team are
responsible for managing the company’s customer database and implementing
their pre- and post-walk communications strategies. Part of this process is gaining
insight into customer needs and identifying opportunities for new target markets
or new products. The sales team are also responsible for interacting with customers,
and managing the online reservations and booking system.
Once consumers decide on their walking experience, TWC use pre-walk
communications and direct marketing to generate the sale and ensure their
customers have all the necessary preparatory information. After their initial
enquiry, customers are personally emailed an itinerary, a ‘gear list’ and a link to
frequently asked questions (FAQs). TWC have also produced short videos (which
are emailed to customers or made available online) in which their guides explain
the importance of certain equipment, such as proper hiking boots, thermal clothing
and gaiters. In most cases, guests will have four to five real-time conversations
with TWC prior to arriving for their walk. This approach enables TWC to fully
understand the customers’ needs and, in turn, customers can ask questions and
volunteer feedback. TWC’s small marketing team pride themselves on their ability
to provide this one-to-one interaction and personal service. They understand that
multi-day walks are out of the comfort zone for many of their customers; hence,
they place significant emphasis on ensuring guests arrive in Tasmania feeling happy
and excited, rather than nervous and anxious.
When customers arrive at the company’s headquarters to commence their
walking experience, they are personally greeted by the guides and, over coffee, go
through a hands-on induction process and final briefing. All guests are required to
bring appropriate walking gear, which is checked by guides prior to departing for
the walking experience. During these formalities, TWC guides are also getting to
know the guests and establishing a positive dynamic among the group, which is
never more than 10 people.
Tasmanian Walking Company
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
482 Appendix 1 Case studies
TWC guides are subject to intense training to ensure they deliver high levels of
service and hospitality. They are the company’s most important asset. Their actions,
knowledge of flora, fauna, history and geology, and their engaging personalities, all
add significant value to their relationships with customers and between the guests
themselves. TWC staff are profiled on the TWC website and social media so that
customers can begin to establish a personal relationship with the guides/company
as they do their research.
Personal selling and marketing
communications
Not surprisingly, guided multi-day walks that combine sustainable adventure travel
and contemporary luxuries are not a product every tourist can afford – for example,
a TWC walk currently retails for approximately $3000 per person. TWC purposely
avoid targeting mass markets with their product, as maintaining small groups and
a feeling of exclusivity adds value to the consumer experience. Each walk is priced
as a package, inclusive of transport to and from the destination, accommodation,
all meals and a personal guide. Customers are expected to provide all of their own
walking equipment, and can pay extra for spa treatments during the Bay of Fires
Lodge Walk.
Through attending travel and tourism trade shows, such as the Australian
Tourism Exchange (ATE), TWC are slowly building up their profile in international and
overseas markets. ATE connects Australian tourism businesses with wholesalers and
retailers from around the world, via a mix of scheduled one-on-one appointments
and broader networking events (ATE, 2016). TWC participate in this event on an
annual basis. In preparation for their attendance at the ATE, TWC’s personal selling
and sales-promotion activities commence approximately two months prior, as they
identify – online – the wholesalers and retailers they would like to meet with at
the actual event. ATE organisers then match up TWC’s preferences with those
wholesalers and retailers that have opted to speak to them. Upon receiving the
schedule, TWC’s Director of Sales and Marketing prepares herself for a busy four
days of 15-minute meetings with approximately 100 inbound tour operators and
wholesalers, such as Flight Centre Global, where she explains the TWC product and
what new features are available for the coming tourist season.
In terms of marketing to the domestic market, TWC work closely with public
relations specialists to attract the ‘right’ type of journalists and media personalities
to participate in their guided walks. After immersing themselves in the experience,
journalists produce stories about the TWC offering, which are published in both
print magazines and online travel blogs. Importantly, TWC can then share these
stories, visual imagery and testimonials via their own website and social media.
In addition to utilising testimonials by others, TWC encourage their customers
to share their own experiences (post-walk) via social media – and, in particular,
photos they have taken. This type of promotion is a key part of TWC’s advertising
strategy, and helps to engage new and future customers in an online community.
When TWC upload their own imagery and posts, they avoid using hard sales tactics
and can subtly share content that is engaging and educational. TWC also ensure
that any of their company blog and social media posts are relevant according to
the season, so that followers get an accurate idea of what to expect if they were
to experience a certain walk at that time of the year. For example, in winter, TWC
will upload and share images of walkers going through snow and complement this
with comments such as ‘Rug up and get walking’ or ‘With the first autumn snows
falling in the mountains, it’s time to start making your winter plans.’ TWC also share
high-quality educational videos on their Facebook page so potential customers can
learn about native Tasmanian wildlife.
Keeping the company’s online community and social media presence up-todate is time-consuming for a small business and presents additional challenges
in terms of user-controlled content. The high-quality and personal experience on
offer does mean that the majority of customer-created content in which TWC is
tagged, is positive. However, like all businesses, TWC must manage the risk of
negative word of mouth spreading via this medium. They do so via their post-walk
communications with customers; in addition, guides are instructed to report any
issues with the company in their follow-up reports.
Current and future customer needs
Understanding customer needs, both now and in the future, is a vital element
of TWC’s marketing success and their new product development strategy. Even
when customers demand new features, such as day spa treatments, within the
guided-walk experience, TWC are able to deliver. Collaboration at an industry
level assists TWC to generate ideas from external sources, and stay on top of
market trends. The company are founding members of Great Walks Australia
and Great Walks of Tasmania. Both networks comprise only guided walks that
epitomise quality and best practice in the industry. Great Walks of Australia, for
example, has just nine walks in their collection, two of which are TWC products
(Great Walks of Australia, 2016). Similarly, Great Walks of Tasmania currently has
only six members. As a member of these networks, TWC obtain new ideas for
additional services they can add to their product, and benefit from referral activity
between businesses.
Although other members of these networks offer similar walking experiences,
TWC do not view them strictly as competitors. Instead, by encouraging customers
to experience other walks around Australia, TWC and their fellow network
members are adding to demand for the sector as a whole. Once customers have
had their first guided-walking experience, they tend to want to experience a second
or third walk in a new location. For example, if a customer has visited Tasmania and
completed a Maria Island walk (a product offered by another walking company),
their interest and desire to complete a different guided walk on their next trip
is enhanced by the high-quality experience they have already had. TWC invest
heavily in managing relationships with their customers so they will return and
experience another product in the TWC portfolio, or experience the same walk
again in a few years’ time. They do so by keeping in touch with their customer base
via e-newsletters and social media, and offer return customers a discounted price
on their next TWC walk.
Managing the product life cycle (PLC) is another important aspect of TWC’s
marketing strategy. The Cradle Mountain Huts Walk is the most mature of their
Tasmanian Walking Company
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.
Appendix 1 Case studies 483
products; however, TWC prevent sales from going into decline by continually
improving – among other things – the sustainable accommodation, food and wine
on offer. The worldwide reputation of Cradle Mountain also helps TWC maintain
demand for this product. In addition, TWC maintain their exclusive rights to being
the only private-accommodation provider along the Overland Track (all other
walkers have tents and public huts as their only accommodation option). This gives
the company a significant advantage in terms of access; even when the weather is
poor, TWC can still offer their customers a comfortable winter-walking experience.
Other products in the TWC range are at different stages of the PLC. The Bay
of Fires Lodge Walk and Wineglass Bay Sail Walk, for example, are arguably in
the growth phase, while the upcoming Three Capes Walk is still in the product
development phase. Having a range of walks at different stages in the PLC helps
ensure that TWC maintain their profits well into the future. Furthermore, renting
the Bay of Fires Lodge out to other businesses during the off-season for walking,
such as to photographers to run photography workshops, provides another revenue
stream for the business.
Social and environmental
sustainability
Despite changing ownership over the years, TWC’s core values have remained
the same. The flat-structured company is built on the notion of environmental
sustainability and social responsibility. Their tag-line ‘It’s in our nature’ has a
dual meaning. First, the walks are based in Tasmania, which is the company’s
‘natural’ and physical environment. Second, and more importantly, every staff
member employed by TWC is deeply passionate about environmentally sustainable
adventure travel, and upholds these values in the luxury experience and knowledge
they provide. Nature and environmental responsibility are very much integral to the
organisation and underpin TWC’s marketing strategy.
Sustainability is also a key element of the TWC brand. Right from the beginning,
the company have used environmentally sustainable practices and materials to
build their guest accommodation, which is a perfect example of providing modest
luxury experiences in the natural environment. All buildings are solar powered;
rainwater is collected in tanks and then recycled; heating uses renewable gas;
and food and living supplies are brought in and all litter taken away. These actions
have assisted the company to gain Advanced Ecotourism certification, and win
numerous awards at a national and state level. The company also follow bestpractice track guidelines on all of their walks, which ensure customers and guides
follow designated trails, remove all waste and recycle wherever possible. Given
their location in a World Heritage-listed national park, the Cradle Mountain huts
are subject to the highest levels of environmental scrutiny. However, TWC embrace
these standards and, through their sustainable marketing, ensure they leave the
natural environment in a better condition than when they arrived.
Through their sustainable marketing initiatives, TWC are focused not only on
enhancing the natural environment for future customers to enjoy, but also on
giving back to the community. The company, for example, buy almost all of their
produce and supplies locally. They make a point of using local cafés to source
packed lunches for their customers as they travel to the starting point of their
walk. This helps to support the local economies and business community in remote
Tasmanian towns such as Derby and Sheffield, and provides regular and significant
food orders that keep locals employed. In addition, TWC staff regularly volunteer to
work with environmental organisations, such as Conservation Volunteers Australia
(also known as the ‘Green Army’), to remove weeds from wildlife sanctuaries or
to clean up rubbish from natural areas, such as Forester Beach (along the Bay
of Fires Lodge Walk). Furthermore, when the company require new materials
such as staff uniforms, they conduct extensive research to ensure they purchase
from businesses who share the same values as TWC. Dealing with like-minded
companies is another important component of TWC’s sustainable marketing
strategy, and helps to validate the message that they uphold their environmental
and social responsibilities.
Where to next?
Like any other small, eco-tourism business, TWC are subject to the same challenges
of seasonality, external market trends and competition. Yet, their clear focus on
providing high-quality adventure experiences within the natural environment has
provided them with a source of competitive advantage, which the owners are
planning to grow in years to come. Maintaining their points of difference requires
a triple-bottom-line approach to protecting and enhancing nature and making a
profit. Similarly, TWC must attract passionate and authentic staff to deliver their
high-quality experience and uphold their company values. Having recently won
Gold in the ecotourism category at the Qantas Australian Tourism Awards, TWC’s
future looks very bright.
Discussion questions
Note: Students are encouraged to visit the TWC website (<www.taswalkingco.
com.au/>) for further and up-to-date information.
❶ Identify what you think makes the TWC market offering unique. What is the
likely combination of tangible goods and pure services involved in each of
TWC’s guided walking products?
❷ What challenges do TWC face in terms of ensuring their product offering
and business model remain sustainable? How might a company of this size
manage an increase in demand while also ensuring the natural environment
is protected?
❸ How do TWC use direct marketing to build one-to-one relationships with their
customers? What are the benefits of TWC’s using direct marketing with their
customers?
❹ Why are networks and industry relationships important to TWC? What other
strategies could an eco-tourism business of this size use to source ideas and
incorporate into its new product development strategy?
References
Australian Tourism Exchange (ATE), 2016, ‘About ATE16’, <www.tradeevents.australia.com/
teo3/eventModule/home.do?eventModuleId=29085>, accessed 29 July 2016.
Great Walks of Australia, 2016, ‘The walks’, <http://greatwalksofaustralia.com.au/walks/>,
accessed 5 August 2016.
Li’tya, 2016, ‘About Li’tya’, <http://litya.com/about-litya.html>, accessed 29 July 2016.
Tasmanian Walking Co., 2016, ‘Your walking tour guides’, <www.bayoffires.com.au/walk/
guides/>, accessed 29 July 2016.
Tourism Australia, 2015, ‘China: Market profile’, <www.tourism.australia.com/documents/
Markets/Market_Profile_2015_China.pdf>, accessed 24 October 2016.
Acknowledgements
The author wishes to thank Tasmanian Walking Co., and in particular, Ros Young
(Director of Sales and Marketing), for generously providing information and
imagery for the purposes of this case study. For more information on Tasmanian
Walking Co., visit their website: <www.taswalkingco.com.au>.
Armstrong, Gary, et al. <i>Principles of Marketing</i>, P.Ed Australia, 2017. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uow/detail.action?docID=5220646. Copyright © Pearson Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty Ltd) 2018—9781488611841—Armstrong/Principles of Marketing 7e
Created from uow on 2019-08-13 22:44:45.
Copyright © 2017. P.Ed Australia. All rights reserved.

The post 472 Appendix 1 Case studies appeared first on My Assignment Online.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order