For this question, resume the role of a public information officer. During the public discussion at a college board meeting, a parent of a recent high school graduate complained to the board that her son, who graduated in the top 10 percent of his high school class, was unable to get a full schedule of general education courses. The parent asked why students enrolled in developmental education courses due to lack of success in high school could enroll before her son. A board member has asked you to explain open access and enrollment priorities in a 300–400 word memo to the board, defending open access and open enrollment. Using the unit readings attached below explain enrollment priorities to the board of trustees.
Students
Diverse Backgrounds and Purposes
Two words sum up the students: number and variety. To college
leaders, the spectacular growth in student population, sometimes as much as 15 percent a year, has been the most impressive
feature of community colleges. The numbers are notable: enrollment increased from just over five hundred thousand in 1960 to
more than 2 million by 1970, 4 million by 1980, nearly 6 million
at the turn of the century, and over 7.5 million by 2010. During
the 1960s, much of the increase was due to the expanded proportion of eighteen- to twenty-four-year-olds in the population— the
result of the World War II baby boom. More people were in the college age cohort, and more of them were going to college. A similar
phenomenon was apparent in the 2000s.
The top half of Table 2.1 shows the number of undergraduates
in all types of colleges relative to the number of eighteen- to
twenty-four-year-olds in the American population for each decade
from 1900 to 1970. The table accurately depicts the proportion of
the age group attending college for those years, but because many
undergraduates—nearly half the community college population
currently—are older than twenty-five, the table must be adjusted
to reflect what has been, since 1980, a more accurate depiction
of the rate of college going. Thus, the bottom half of the table
depicts the number of eighteen- to twenty-four-year-olds enrolled
in college as a percentage of the college-age population; the figure
equaled 41 percent in 2010. From the early 1960s through the mid1980s, between 45 and 55 percent of high school graduates were
45
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 46
46 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
Table 2.1. Undergraduate Enrollment in U.S. Colleges and
Universities Compared with Eighteen- to Twenty-Four-Year-Old
Population, 1900–2010
Year College-Age Undergraduate Percentage
Population Enrollment
(in thousands) (in thousands)
1900 10,357 232 2.2
1910 12,300 346 2.8
1920 12,830 582 4.5
1930 15,280 1,054 6.9
1940 16,458 1,389 8.4
1950 16,120 2,421 15.0
1960 15,677 2,876 18.3
1970 24,712 6,274 25.4
Year College-Age
Population
(in thousands)
Undergraduate
Enrollment of
18–24-YearOlds (in
thousands)
Percentage
1980 30,022 7,716 25.7
1990 26,961 8,628 32.0
2000 27,144 9,636 35.5
2010 29,312 12,077 41.2
Source: NCES, Digests, 1970, 2011; U.S. Bureau of the Census, Current Population Survey, 2010
entering some postsecondary school within a year of leaving high
school. In 2000, that figure was 63 percent, and by 2010 it neared
70 percent.
This chapter reports data on the numbers and types of students
attending community colleges and offers discussions of student
ability and academic preparedness, gender, race or ethnicity, and
life circumstances. Other methods of classifying students and their
intentions are examined, as are historic and contemporary methods
for assessing and tracking them. The chapter provides information
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 47
Students 47
on enrollment patterns and reasons for the high incidence of
dropout, but information on student achievement in areas such
as transfer, degree or certificate attainment, and job getting are
presented in Chapter Fourteen, on outcomes. Unless otherwise
noted, data in this chapter derive from National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) reports published in 2011 and 2012.
Reasons for the Increase in Numbers
The increase in community college enrollments may be attributed
to several conditions in addition to general population expansion:
older students’ participation; financial aid; part-time attendance;
the reclassification of institutions; the redefinition of students
and courses; and high attendance by women, minorities, and less
academically prepared students. Community colleges also recruited
students aggressively; to an institution that tries to offer something
for everyone in the community, everyone is potentially a student.
Demography has a profound effect on college enrollments.
The number of eighteen-year-olds in the American population
peaked in 1979, declined steadily throughout the 1980s, and was
23 percent lower in 1992, when it began increasing again. Overall
enrollments in public two-year colleges doubled during the 1970s
and then slowed to a 15 percent increase in each of the subsequent
two decades before accelerating to a 21 percent increase in the
first decade of the twenty-first century. This growth in a period of
decline in the eighteen-year-old population reflects the influence
of other factors on community college enrollments. However, it
pales in comparison with the surge of students entering in the 1970s.
To make up for the shortfall in potential younger students in
the 1980s, the colleges expanded programs that would be attractive
to older students. Numbers of working adults seeking skills that
would enable them to change or upgrade their jobs or activities to
satisfy their personal interests enrolled because they could attend
part time, and many more registered after losing their jobs in
the recession. Older students swelled the roster. According to
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 48
48 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
the American Association of Community and Junior Colleges
(AACJC, 1980), the mean age of students enrolled for credit in
1980 was twenty-seven, the median age was twenty-three, and the
modal age was nineteen. A national survey conducted by the Center
for the Study of Community Colleges found that by 1986 the mean
had gone up to twenty-nine, the median had increased to twentyfive, and the mode had remained at nineteen. But the percentage
of students younger than age twenty-five has increased steadily in
recent years, from 43 percent in 1995–96 to 53 percent in 2007–08.
In the latter academic year, 30 percent were under age twenty. Dual
enrollment, advanced placement, and similar collaborations with
high schools have led to a 7 percent population of students who are
younger than age eighteen; in 2010–11, 10 percent of the full-time
equivalent enrollment in Washington community colleges was
generated by dual-enrollment high school students (Washington
State Board for Community and Technical Colleges, 2011). Today,
the national mean age is twenty-nine years, the median around
twenty-two, and the mode just under age nineteen.
Note the discrepancy among these three measures. The mean is
the most sensitive to extremes; hence, even a small number of senior
citizens affects that measure dramatically. The median suggests that
the students just out of high school and those in their early twenties
who either delayed beginning college or entered community colleges after dropping out of other institutions accounted for half the
student population. This 50 percent of the student body that was
composed of students aged seventeen to twenty-two was matched
on the other side of the median by students ranging in age all the
way out to their sixties and seventies. The mode reflects the greatest number; nineteen-year-olds continued as the dominant single
age group. Thus, a graph depicting the age of community college
students would show a bulge at the low end of the scale, a peak at
age nineteen, and a long tail reaching out toward the high end.
The availability of financial aid brought additional students
as state and federal payments, loans, and work-study grants rose
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 49
Students 49
markedly. From the 1940s through the early 1970s, nearly all
types of aid were categorical, designed to assist particular groups
of students. The largest group of beneficiaries was war veterans; in
California in 1973, veterans made up more than 13 percent of the
total enrollment. Compared with contemporary figures, this was
an astounding number; in 2007–08, veterans and military service
members together made up only 4 percent of all undergraduates
(Radford and Wun, 2009). Students from economically disadvantaged and minority groups were also large beneficiaries of financial
aid; more than thirty thousand such students in Illinois received
state and local funds in 1974. Since the mid-1970s, more of the
funds have been unrestricted. Overall, 65 percent of full-time
students and 45 percent of the part-timers received some form of
financial aid during the 2007–08 academic year. Total aid averaged
$5, 650 per full-time aid-receiving student.
Part-time enrollment increased as the age of the students went
up. In the early 1970s, half of the students were full-timers; by the
mid-1980s, only one-third were (see Table 2.2). Today full-timers
constitute just over 40 percent of the student body, and these
Table 2.2. Part-Time Enrollment as a Percentage of Total
Enrollment in Public Two-Year Institutions of Higher Education,
1970–2010
Year Total Fall Enrollment Part-Time Enrollment Percentage
(in thousands) (in thousands)
1970 2,195 1,066 49
1975 3,836 2,174 57
1980 4,329 2,733 63
1985 4,270 2,773 65
1990 4,997 3,280 66
1995 5,278 3,437 65
2000 5,697 3,697 65
2005 6,184 3,797 61
2010 7,218 4,266 59
Source: NCES, Digest, 2011.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 50
50 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
figures do not include noncredit students enrolled in community
or continuing education, dual enrollment courses, and short-cycle
occupational studies. The pattern was consistent throughout the
country; in nearly all states with community college enrollments
greater than fifty thousand, part-time students far outnumbered
full-timers, sometimes by as much as three to one.
The rise in the number of part-time students can be attributed
to many factors: the opening of noncampus colleges that enroll few
full-timers; an increase in the number of students combining work
and study; and an increase in the number of reverse transfers, people
who may already have baccalaureate and higher degrees; to name
but a few. As examples of the latter group, over 48 percent of the
92,594 graduates receiving bachelor’s degrees from the University
of California and the California State University systems in 2001
took one or more classes at California community colleges in the
ensuing three years. Nearly all were credit courses. The colleges
made deliberate efforts to attract part-timers by making it easy
for them to attend. Senior citizens’ institutes; weekend colleges;
courses offered at off-campus centers, in workplaces, and in rented
and donated housing around the district; and countless other
stratagems have been employed. In 2011, 59 percent of student
credit hours earned at Arizona’s community colleges were in courses
provided at alternative times and places or via alternative delivery
methods (Arizona Community Colleges, 2012). Notable, however,
is that even though the recent increase in younger students has
decreased the ratio of part-timers, it is still close to 60 percent:
64 percent in Illinois, 63 percent in Florida and Washington, 65
percent in Texas and North Carolina, and 87 percent in California.
And nearly four of five of all students were employed, with 40
percent working full-time (Horn, Nevill, and Griffith, 2006).
The community colleges also play a role in educating students
from foreign countries. Fourteen percent of the more than 700,000
international students in U.S. higher education are in community
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 51
Students 51
colleges; Santa Monica College (California) and Houston Community College (Texas) each enrolls more international students
than any other public, two-year college in the nation, the latter
admitting more than all but five universities. Most international
students need to study English before attempting particular college
programs. In the community colleges, even though they pay $6, 500
tuition on average, they find English as a Second Language courses
offered at lower cost than in senior institutions and are less likely to
have to qualify for admission. More than three-fourths of international students are between the ages of twenty and thirty-four; most
are enrolled full time, often a qualification set by the conditions of
their visas; and they stay enrolled for an average of more than six
semesters (Hagedorn and Lee, 2005). The majority are from Asia,
with China topping the list.
In addition to enrolling international students, community
colleges also enroll most of the postsecondary students residing
in the country illegally, primarily because the colleges cost far
less than other institutional types. Although twelve states allow
undocumented students who meet certain requirements (such as
attending high school in the state for a specified number of years
and graduating or receiving a GED) to pay in-state tuition at
public colleges and universities, in most states these students are
ineligible for federal and state financial aid. And because there
are only a scarce number of private scholarships available to this
population, relatively few attend college. The Urban Institute
(Passell, 2003) estimates that only 5 to 10 percent of the roughly
65,000 undocumented students who graduate from high school
each year do so. Nonetheless, community colleges—especially
those in states with large immigrant populations—already serve a
fair number of undocumented students; California’s 112 colleges
alone enrolled 18,000 in 2005–06 (Gonzales, 2007). If the federal
DREAM (Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors)
Act, which was first proposed in 2001 and has been reintroduced
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 52
52 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
several times since, is ever enacted, community colleges can expect
further enrollment growth from this sector.
The growth in total enrollments did not result solely from the
colleges’ attracting students who might not otherwise have participated in education beyond high school. Two other factors played a
part: the different ways of classifying institutions; and a redefinition
of the term student. Changes in the classification of colleges are
common. Private colleges become public; two-year colleges become
four-year (and vice versa); and adult education centers enter the
category, especially as they begin awarding degrees. The universe
of community colleges is especially fluid. From time to time, entire
sets of institutions, such as trade and vocational schools and adult
education centers, have been added to the list. As examples, in
the mid-1960s four vocational-technical schools became the first
colleges in the University of Hawaii community college system,
and in the mid-1970s the community colleges in Iowa became
area schools responsible for adult education in their districts. Indiana’s Ivy Tech became a set of comprehensive colleges in 1999.
Sometimes institutional reclassification is made by an agency that
gathers statistics; in the 1990s, the National Center for Education
Statistics and the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of
Teaching began including accredited proprietary schools to their
community college databases, but data on those institutions are
listed separately. And in 2005, they both, along with the American
Association of Community Colleges, removed the community colleges that had begun offering bachelor’s degrees. All these changes
modify the number of students tabulated each year.
Reclassification of students within colleges has had an even
greater effect on enrollment figures. As an example, when the
category defined adult was removed from the California system,
students of all ages could be counted as equivalents for funding
purposes. In most states, the trend has been toward including
college-sponsored events (whether or not such activities demand
evidence of learning attained) as courses and hence the people
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 53
Students 53
attending them as students. The boundaries among the categories
degree credit, non–degree credit, noncredit, and community service are
permeable; student tallies shift about as courses are reclassified.
Furthermore, the community colleges have taken under their aegis
numerous instructional programs formerly offered by public and
private agencies, including police and fire academies, hospitals,
banks, and religious centers. These practices swell the enrollment
figures and blur the definition of student, making it possible for
community college leaders to point with pride to larger enrollments
and to gain augmented funding when enrollments are used as the
basis for accounting. They also heighten imprecision in counting
students and make it difficult to compare enrollments from one
year to another.
Nonetheless, the proportion of Americans attending college
increased steadily through the twentieth century, and the availability of community colleges contributed notably to this growth. In
2010, 40 percent of all students beginning postsecondary education
enrolled first in a two-year college. Of the students who delayed
entry until they were age thirty or older, 61 percent began in a community college (NCES, 2012). As the following sections detail, the
colleges have been essential especially to the educational progress of
people with lower levels of academic preparedness, lower incomes,
and other characteristics that had limited their opportunity for
postsecondary enrollment.
Students’ Lives
Unlike full-time students at residential, four-year universities,
whose lives may revolve around classes, peers, and social events,
community college students often struggle to fit required
courses, tutoring, and other educational activities into schedules
constrained by part- or full-time jobs, family commitments,
child-rearing responsibilities, long commutes, or other obligations.
These responsibilities complicate educational progress for even
the most committed students and are often cited as the primary
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 54
54 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
reasons that community college students are less likely than their
four-year counterparts to persist to a degree or certificate.
The U.S. Department of Education’s survey of students beginning postsecondary education in 2003–04 (NCES, 2012) illustrates
these challenges. One-quarter of community college students had
one or more dependents; almost half of these were single parents.
A full 12 percent claimed some sort of disability. Of students categorized as dependent, 28 percent came from the lowest income
quartile, and 21 percent of all students reported incomes at or
below the poverty level. When students first enrolled, 45 percent
were working part time; another 33 percent held full-time jobs. A
total of 12 percent spoke a primary language other than English.
And 45 percent were the first in their families to attend college.
The colleges have initiated numerous programs to assist students
in overcoming these challenges. But the social and economic
realities that affect students’ ability to enter and succeed in college
are not likely to disappear, and as long as the door remains open
to all who desire higher learning, community colleges will be
challenged to provide education and services in ways that better fit
into their students’ lives.
Student Ability and Academic Preparedness
Classification of students by academic ability reveals a higher
proportion of lower-ability or less well-prepared students among
community college entrants than among those matriculating at
four-year institutions. As Cross (1971) pointed out, three major
philosophies about who should go to college have dominated the
history of higher education in this country: the aristocratic, suggesting that white males from the upper socioeconomic classes would
attend; the meritocratic, holding that college admission should be
based on ability; and the egalitarian, which “means that everyone
should have equality of access to educational opportunities, regardless of socioeconomic background, race, sex, or ability” (p. 6).
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 55
Students 55
By the time the community colleges were developed, most young
people from the higher socioeconomic groups and most of the highaptitude aspirants were already going to college. Cross concluded,
“The majority of students entering open-door community colleges
come from the lower half of the high school classes, academically
and socioeconomically” (p. 7).
Various data sets reveal the lower academic skill level of the
entrants. The College Board’s Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT)
means for community colleges have been considerably lower
than the norm for all college students and—like the norm for
all students—has declined in recent years. In 2012 the average
national SAT composite score was 1226 (411 Critical Reading,
416 Mathematics, 399 Writing) for students who indicated an associate degree as their objective, whereas it was 1433 (477 Critical
Reading, 490 Mathematics, 466 Writing) for students with bachelor’s degree aspirations (College Board, 2012). Since the SAT
scores are highly correlated with annual family income (Michaels,
2006), these norms reflect not only the college’s lower entrance
requirements but also the socioeconomic status of their students.
Indeed, the socioeconomic status of dependent students attending
two-year colleges tends to be lower than that of dependent students
at four-year institutions: in 2003–04, 26 percent of community college students but only 20 percent of four-year college students came
from the lowest income level, defined as 125 percent of the poverty
limit (Horn, Nevill, and Griffith, 2006).
Like most other institutions of higher education, the community
colleges have also sought out high-ability students and have made
special benefits available to them. For example, in 1979, MiamiDade Community College began giving full tuition waivers to all
students graduating in the top 10 percent of their local high school
class, and in 1991 it extended that offer to the top 20 percent.
Students in that group were eligible to apply for the Academic
Achievement Award, which provided $3, 200 to cover in-state
tuition and fees for two years. Those individuals graduating in the
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 56
56 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
top 5 percent received $5, 000 for two years, which essentially
covered not only tuition and fees but also textbook costs. The
Achievement Award program has since evolved into an Honors
College (Miami Dade College, 2012), but not before the idea
spread to other states. New Jersey’s NJ STARS (Student Tuition
Assistance Rewards Scholarship) program, created in 2004, offers
scholarships to students in the top 15 percent of their high school
class. These scholarships cover the full price of tuition for up to
five semesters at New Jersey’s nineteen community colleges as
long as the students maintain full-time enrollment in an associate
degree program and a grade-point average (GPA) of at least 3.0.
In 2006 the program was expanded, making NJ STARS recipients
who earn an associate degree with a GPA of 3.25 or higher and
meet the requirements for transfer eligible for the NJ STARS II
program, which provides tuition discounts of up to $7, 000 at all
of the state’s public four-year colleges or universities. In 2008–09,
4,300 NJ STARS students were enrolled in the state’s community
colleges and over 1,400 in four-year institutions, together receiving
about $18 million in merit scholarships (Nespoli, 2010).
The growth of merit scholarships and honors programs evidences the colleges’ welcoming the better-prepared students.White
(1975) surveyed 225 colleges in the North-Central region and
found that about 10 percent had formalized honors programs.
Twenty years later, Peterson’s Guide to Two-Year Colleges, 1995
(1994) listed honors programs in over 25 percent of the institutions, and in 2011 they existed in more than one-third (Peterson’s
College Search, 2011). Outcalt and Kisker (2003) found that over 9
percent of the faculty reported having taught at least one honors
course in the previous two years. Often, universities get involved;
UCLA has assisted colleges throughout Southern California in
building honors programs and linking them with transfer opportunities (Kane, 2001). The students in honors programs often
receive priority registration, special academic advisors, and tuition
discounts in addition to intensive courses. Montgomery College
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 57
Students 57
(Maryland) has honors programs on each of its three campuses. Its
Montgomery Scholars enrolls students directly from high school
and pays their tuition and fees for two years, including the cost
of a summer studying in England. More than 80 percent graduate,
and most transfer. A Sophomore Business Honors Program is open
to second-year students. Two additional programs are designed
for part-time, working adults at the college’s branch campuses
(Ashburn, 2006).
The creation of honors colleges and scholarship programs for
high-ability students certainly creates a lower-cost avenue to a
bachelor’s degree for students who might not want or be able
to afford four years at a university, but some question whether
the inclusion of these students—and efforts spent catering to
them—crowds out more traditional community college populations, whose grades or test scores may preclude them from attending
any other institutional type (Rhoades, 2012). Claims of diminished
access and abandonment of the colleges’ egalitarian mission intensify as demand for enrollment surpasses what the states are willing
to pay, but, as long as public universities face the same enrollment pressures, students who in better economic times may have
attended a four-year institution directly will be welcomed into community college honors colleges and transfer curricula, no matter
what the critics say.
Gender
Probably because it is easier to sort students by gender than by
any other variable, differences between male and female college
students have long been documented. Historically, among less
well-prepared students, fewer women than men attended college.
When funds were limited, more male than female high-ability
students from low-income families entered college. Furthermore,
the women who went to college were more likely to be dependent
on their families for support. Not until 1978 did the number of
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 58
58 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
women attending college in the United States exceed the number
of men. In 2010, women were ahead, 57 to 43 percent (the ratio is
the same in community colleges). Overall, in each year since 1978,
more women than men have earned associate degrees; in 2009–10,
62 percent of the degrees went to women.
Some slight change has occurred in the types of programs
that community college students enter, although the traditionally
gender-differentiated fields persist. The associate degrees awarded
reveal these differences. In 2009–10, women earned 86 percent
of the degrees in education; 85 percent in the health professions,
and 65 percent in business. Men dominated in mechanic and
repair technologies with 95 percent of the degrees; engineering
technology, 87 percent; computer and information science, 76
percent; and physical sciences, 62 percent. Women had a slight
edge in liberal arts degrees, and men in homeland security, law
enforcement, and firefighting.
Although many community colleges have been focusing on
increasing enrollment and completion among male students
(Perrakis, 2008), the National Science Foundation (NSF) and
several other federal and philanthropic agencies have spent a
significant amount of money to increase female participation in
science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) fields. The
NSF alone anticipated investing $100 million in community
colleges in fiscal year 2012 (Patton, 2011), and a small but growing
body of research is addressing the reasons that females may avoid
STEM fields as well as the ways community colleges might redesign
these programs to attract more women and minorities (Starobin
and Laanan, 2008; Tsapogas, 2004).
Racial and Ethnic Diversity
The community colleges’ diligence in recruiting students from
segments of the population that had not previously attended
college yielded sizable increases in the college attendance of racial
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 59
Students 59
and ethnic minorities. In 1997, community colleges, with 38
percent of the total enrollment in American higher education,
were enrolling 46 percent of minority students, up from 20 percent
in 1976. This imbalance has stabilized in recent years as fouryear colleges and universities have worked to improve access for
underserved groups. Nonetheless, minority students make up a
significant percent of the community college population: in 2010,
they constituted 42 percent of all community college enrollments
nationwide. Naturally, the pattern differed from state to state
depending on the minority population. Hawaii, with 78 percent, as
well as California and New Mexico, with over 60 percent, had the
highest percentages of minorities among their community college
students. Minorities were also enrolled in significant numbers in
other locales that had well-developed community college systems or
high minority populations: Texas, Mississippi, Georgia, Louisiana,
New Jersey, Maryland, Nevada, Florida, Arizona, and the District
of Columbia were above the national average.
When the enrollment figures are disaggregated by ethnic groups,
they are even more revealing of the community colleges’ contributions to access: 15.6 percent of all community college students
are African American (African Americans make up 12.6 percent
of the total U.S. population); 18 percent are Hispanic (16.3 percent of the U.S. population); 6 percent are Asian American or
Pacific Islander (5 percent of the U.S. population); and 1.1 percent
are American Indian or Alaska Native (0.9 percent of the U.S.
population). As these data show, proportions of minority students
enrolled in community colleges exceed their share of the national
population; this holds true for most states as well. Indeed, the
African American proportion of community college enrollment in
2011 exceeded the African American proportion of the eighteento forty-four-year-old population in all fifty states. Comparable
figures for Hispanic enrollments were found in all but Mississippi
and South Dakota, where the percentages were equivalent.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 60
60 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
More so than in the universities, the community college student population tends to reflect the ethnic composition of the
institution’s locale. Community colleges in cities with high proportions of minorities—Chicago, El Paso, Los Angeles, Miami,
New York, Phoenix—enroll sizable numbers of minority students.
In 2010, 94 percent of the students at Laredo Community College (Texas) were Hispanic; 79 percent of the students at Lawson
State Community College (Alabama) were African American.
The evidence of neighborhood attendance is revealed when the
community college has several campuses in the same city. At East
Los Angeles College in 2010, 65 percent of the students were Hispanic; at Los Angeles Southwest College, 63 percent were African
American; at Los Angeles Pierce College, 36 percent were Hispanic, 32 percent white, and 13 percent Asian. Just a few miles
inland, at Glendale Community College, half of the study body
was white. More than thirty community colleges enrolling around
twenty thousand students have been established especially to serve
American Indians; Dine College (Arizona), Oglala Lakota College ´
(South Dakota), and Navajo Technical College (New Mexico)
are notable examples. The federal Tribally Controlled Community
College Assistance Act of 1978 and the grants awarded by Congress
beginning in 1980 gave a great impetus to the development of these
colleges, now functioning in twelve states.
Because the issue of minority students’ progress in college has
been so charged politically, the question of whether the community colleges have enhanced or retarded progress for minority
students has been debated at length (see, for example, Astin, 1982;
Bailey, Jenkins, and Leinbach, 2005; Long and Kurlaender, 2009;
Richardson and Bender, 1987). Those who say that the community
colleges have assisted minority students point to ease of access, low
tuition, and minimal entrance requirements. They note the numerous programs that provide special services to minority students and
applaud efforts made to recruit them. Their most telling argument
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 61
Students 61
is that a sizable percentage of those students would not be in college
at all were it not for the community colleges.
Several analysts have charged that minority students who begin
their postsecondary education at a community college will do
less well than those of equal ability who enroll at the senior
institution and that this differential is greater for them than it
is for the majority of students. These detractors have taken the
position that, because students who begin at a community college
are less likely to obtain degrees, minorities are actually harmed by
two-year institutions. Table 2.3 presents evidence typically used to
support this assertion, showing that the percent of associate degrees
earned by white students is greater than that group’s share of total
community college enrollment, while the percent of degrees earned
by various minority groups is equal to or less than each group’s
share of enrollment.
Despite the achievement gaps illustrated in Table 2.3, it is
difficult to disaggregate the effects of community colleges from
the characteristics of the students who enter them. In general,
students who enter community colleges instead of universities
are less academically prepared, have lower aspirations, and are
from a lower socioeconomic class. The various studies that have
attempted to control for those variables frequently also attempt to
Table 2.3. Percent of Community College Enrollment and Associate
Degrees Earned, by Race/Ethnicity, 2010–11
Race/Ethnicity Percent of Percent of Associate
Enrollment Degrees Earned
African American 15 14
American Indian or
Alaska Native
1 1
Asian or Pacific Islander 6 5
Hispanic 19 14
White 55 65
Two or more races 2 1
Source: NCES, Digest, 2012.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 62
62 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
control for the fact that minority students are more likely to attend
school part time. However, as Adelman (2005) noted, “The studies
often highlight variables over which the community college has
but modest control—gender, race and ethnicity, first-generation
college status, SES, second language background, marital and
parental status” (p. 118). He concluded that the colleges can do
little to change them but must work with the students they have.
The question of whether community colleges are beneficial to
minority students is thus unresolved. If sizable percentages of minority students would not attend any college if no community college
were available, and if the act of attending college to take even a
few classes is beneficial, then community colleges have certainly
helped. But if the presence of a convenient community college
discourages minority students from attending senior institutions
and reduces the probability of their completing the baccalaureate,
then for those students who wanted degrees the college has been
detrimental. However, the latter contention is tempered by the
numbers of minority students who enter community colleges and
subsequently transfer to selective senior institutions where they
would not have been admissible as freshmen.
The question is not whether minority students tend to be
concentrated in two-year colleges; they do. The question is not
whether they tend to go through to the level of the associate
degree and then transfer to the university; as a group, they do so at
lower rates than white or Asian students, although in colleges that
have a transfer rate substantially higher than the national norm
the transfer rate for African American and Hispanic students is
higher than the national norm for all students (Szeleyni, 2002).
The question is whether community colleges are working to serve
all students, no matter their background, intentions, level of academic preparedness, family or community responsibilities, ability
to pay, commitment to full-time attendance, or intervening life
circumstances. And the answer is: mostly they are, as evidenced
by the sheer amount of philanthropic money sought to improve
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 63
Students 63
student progress and outcomes in the colleges as well as the substantial attention paid by practitioners and scholars alike to closing
achievement gaps and implementing best practices. The colleges
are not designed exclusively for the purpose of passing students
through to the baccalaureate. The issue of student achievement
must be seen in its total context; it is not encapsulated by statistics
about minority student progress.
Whom do the community colleges best serve? Egalitarians would
say that the institutions should maintain parity in the percentage
of each minority group attaining each of the following goals:
entering college, enrolling in transfer-credit courses, persisting in
any courses, gaining the associate degree, gaining admittance to a
high-level technological program, graduating from such a program,
and transferring to the university. In practice, however, this level
of equivalence is impossible to attain, short of imposing strict
quotas at every step. For the minorities as for any other identifiable
student group, the question should be put more broadly: “The
community college or what alternative?” For most students in twoyear institutions, the choice is not between the community college and
a senior residential institution; it is between the community college
and nothing.
Classifying Students and Their Intentions
The classification of students into special groups is often more politically inspired than educationally pertinent. Women, minorities,
and the disabled were able to have their concerns translated into
special programs only after they became politically astute. From
the college perspective, the temptation to place courses or students
in separate categories was always present. The mature woman with
a bachelor’s degree, taking an art class for credit because it was
taught by someone she admired and was scheduled at a time of
day that was convenient for her, was not deserving of the special
treatment accorded to “returning women,” “the aged,” or “students
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 64
64 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
intending to transfer.” She was there for her personal interest. Yet
because of politically and institutionally inspired definitions, she
would be counted each time the institution reported its numbers
of women, aged, and transfer students.
At other times, students are excluded from one classification
or another, when in reality they fit better in that category than
the one for which they are counted. Schuetz (1999) provided a
relevant example: the definition of an adult student (currently those
over age twenty-four) might be more accurate if it included anyone
who is at least eighteen years old and working at least twenty-five
hours per week, raising a child or children while enrolled, or both.
In other words, there may be value to classification schemes where
the students’ life conditions become more important than arbitrary
markers such as chronological age, although the complexity of
building such a scheme on a national scale may be prohibitive.
Classifying students takes other forms as well. Assessments of
community college students have been made from perspectives that
span the social sciences: psychological, sociological, economic, and
political. To the psychologist, community college students are
pragmatic, little concerned with learning for its own sake. They
are not self-directed or self-motivated; they need to be instructed.
To the sociologist, the students are struggling to escape from their
lower-class backgrounds; some do, but many are inhibited by a
bias against leaving family and friends that a move in class would
engender. To the economist, students from low-income families
pay more in the form of forgone earnings as a percentage of total
family income than their counterparts from higher-income groups,
a differential that more than offsets the savings gained by attending a low-tuition institution. To the political scientist, students
attending community colleges are given short shrift because the
institutions are funded at a lower per capita level than the universities, and hence the students do not have equivalent libraries,
laboratories, or faculty–student ratios available to them.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 65
Students 65
But determining the reasons that students attend college is not
an exact exercise. They come for a variety of purposes, and the same
person may have a half-dozen reasons for attending. As an example,
when the National Postsecondary Student Aid Study offered students the opportunity to cite their reasons, 52 percent chose
“transfer,” 43 percent “complete associate degree,” 17 percent
“complete certificate,” 42 percent “job skills,” and 46 percent “personal interest” (Horn, Nevill, and Griffith, 2006). Much depends
on the way the questions are asked and the interpretations that
the respondents make. There can be little doubt that although
most students attend community colleges to better themselves
financially, a sizable percentage are there for reasons of personal
interest having nothing to do with direct fiscal benefit. In 1986 the
Center for the Study of Community Colleges (CSCC), sponsored
by the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching,
asked students their primary reason for attending and found 36 percent seeking transfer, 34 percent job entry skills, 16 percent job
upgrading, and 15 percent personal interest. Hoachlander, Sikora,
and Horn (2003) found comparable figures almost two decades
later: 59 percent of the students were seeking transfer, degree, or
certificate; 23 percent entered to improve or attain job skills; and
16 percent were enrolled for personal interest.
The conventional belief is that community college students—
in contrast to students in four-year colleges—are less interested in
academic studies and in learning for its own sake; instead, they are
interested primarily in the practical, which to them means earning
more money. Although some research evidence supports that belief,
the perception that higher education is to be used particularly for
occupational training seems pervasive among students in all types
of institutions.
Whether these characterizations are correct, they mean little to
institutional planners. Certainly, community college students are
realistic in the sense that they use the institutions for their own
purposes. But what students do not, in schools where attendance is
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 66
66 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
not mandated? Certainly, more are from lower social classes than
those attending the universities, but their class base is higher than
that represented by the sizable percentage of Americans who do not
attend college at all. Certainly, many are from the lower-income
groups, but their attendance usually leads to higher earnings.
Certainly, they welcome an instantly responsive institution, but
the effects of nonpunitive grading and of forgiveness for past
educational sins on their proclivities for learning have not yet
been traced.
Unaware of all these analyses, the students continue attending
the community colleges for their own purposes. Those just out
of high school may matriculate merely because they have been
conditioned to go to school every time September appears on the
calendar. Students of any age wanting a better job may attend
because career programs are connected to employers. Those who
have jobs but want additional skills may hope to find a short-term
program that will teach them to use new equipment introduced
in their industry. Many begin at the introductory level and learn
complete sets of job skills enabling them to qualify for trades
that they might have known nothing about before entering the
programs. Some students seek out special interest courses, ranging
from The Great Books to Beginner Yoga, taking a course or two
whenever one that strikes their fancy appears in the class schedule.
Some use the community colleges as stepping-stones to other
schools, finding them convenient and economical entry points to
higher education and the professions.
The community college certainly serves a broader sector of the
local population than does any other higher education institution.
In 2010, the community colleges in twenty-three states enrolled
6 percent or more of the population aged eighteen to forty-four,
up from nine states twenty years prior. Eight states, all in the
West or Midwest, enrolled at least 8 percent; five of these enrolled
more than 10 percent (NCES, Digest, 2011; U.S. Bureau of the
Census, 2010). Much depends on demography— the percentage of
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 67
Students 67
population that is over age seventeen—but more relates to the
overall college-going rate in the state, the availability of other
postsecondary forms, and the accessibility of community colleges.
Assessment and Tracking
Curriculum tracking within the colleges has risen and fallen
with the times. Throughout their early years, the community
colleges typically administered achievement tests to matriculants
and attempted to place students in courses presumed to be consonant with their abilities. Students were shunted from transfer to
developmental or occupational programs, a practice that gave rise
to the cooling-out thesis postulated by Clark in 1960. Most institutions also maintained academic probation, F grades, one-term
dismissal of students not making satisfactory progress, transcripts
required for admission, entrance tests, midterm grades, penalties for dropping classes after the eighth week, mandatory exit
interviews, required class attendance, and mandatory orientation
courses. However, during the early 1970s, these practices fell into
disfavor as many students demanded the right to enter courses of
their own choosing. Furthermore, measuring students’ abilities has
never been an exact science; a student deficient in one area of
knowledge may be well qualified in another, and stories of abuses in
program tracking are common. Educators rationalized their inability to assess their students accurately by saying that anyone had
the right to try anything, even if it meant failure. The 1970s saw
an erosion of course prerequisites as surely as dress codes had been
abandoned in an earlier day.
By the end of the decade, the pendulum had swung back,
propelled more by the students than by changes in institutional
philosophy. The occupational programs were being reserved for
the favored few, while the transfer curricula were entered by those
unqualified for the technologies or uncertain of their direction.
This use of the collegiate courses by the less able, those waiting for
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 68
68 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
billets in the more desirable programs to open, and those trying to
make up deficiencies in prior preparation may have contributed
to high dropout rates. Subtly but decisively, the transfer programs
were being transformed into catchalls for unable and uncommitted
students.
During the 1980s, the community colleges groped for a middle
ground between linear, forced-choice, sequential curricula and the
lateral, laissez-faire approach of letting students drop in and take
any course they wanted. Recognizing that neither of the extremes
was tolerable and that neither best served the students, the staff
in most institutions attempted to maintain some semblance of
counseling, orientation, and testing to determine why students
had appeared and how they could best be helped. But students
were using the college for purposes other than those anticipated
by program planners. Except for those enrolled in the selective
admissions, high technology, and allied health fields, few students
attended courses in the sequence envisaged by program planners.
Moves toward encouraging students to matriculate in and to
complete programs gained momentum during the 1980s. One of
the first requirements was to test the students at entry, place them
in programs commensurate with their aspirations and abilities, and
demand that they make steady progress toward completing the program. For example, Miami-Dade Community College established a
policy of assessing students, mandating certain courses, and placing
on probation or suspending students who were not making satisfactory progress—in short, reinstating the policies under which most
institutions had operated fifteen years earlier (Middleton, 1981).
During the first two years that the policy was in effect, several
thousand students were dropped from the rolls, but enrollments
eventually stabilized and student attendance patterns increasingly
reflected the changed policy.
The practice of requiring testing and program placement spread,
often prodded by legislators who were appalled at the dropout rates.
Florida, Georgia, New Jersey, Tennessee, and Texas mandated that
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 69
Students 69
all entering students or students seeking degrees or transfer take
tests in the basic skills. And numerous community colleges in
states where testing had not been mandated were beginning to
require testing on their own. The Southern Regional Education
Board (Abraham, 1987) found that in the 1980s twice as many
two-year colleges as four-year colleges in its region had policies
governing testing and placement. A national survey from the same
time period found that, although the majority of the two-year
colleges accepted all persons over age eighteen who had earned a
high school diploma, almost 90 percent of them used tests to place
first-time students (Woods, 1985).
The move was not without its detractors. Some felt that statemandated testing would lead to a reduction in institutional ability
to serve various types of clients. In 1988, a group of Latino
rights organizations sued a California college on the grounds of
discrimination in access. This led to a state mandate that entrance
tests be validated in relation to student achievement. Others
deplored the tests’ effects on curriculum; students take the courses
that teach them to pass the tests, and mandated exit tests invariably
are built on generalized content. In recent years the controversy has
centered on the validity of tests designed to determine incoming
students’ placement into developmental or college-level courses.
While the vast majority (92 percent) of two-year colleges offer such
exams (NCES, 2003), some recommend only that students enroll
in the suggested level; other institutions mandate developmental
enrollment based on a specified cutoff score. The risk of the former
strategy, of course, is that too many students enroll in and fail
college-level courses for which they are not prepared. The risk of the
latter, some argue, is worse: that students who might have succeeded
in college-level courses are instead shunted into remediation, an
educational purgatory from which only a small percentage will
emerge. This question is only the latest reincarnation of the
decades-long debate about tracking in community colleges (see
Chapter Eight on developmental education), a persistent issue due
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 70
70 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
to the important questions it raises about academic quality, social
justice, student needs, and the individual and social benefits of
college attendance.
Enrollment Patterns and Dropout
To transfer to a senior institution, enter the job market, get
a better job, or merely learn for one’s own purposes: these are
students’ chief reasons for attending community colleges. And
these same reasons go a long way to explain enrollment patterns
characterized by a substantial number of dropouts (students who
withdraw from a college), stop-outs (students who withdraw but
then subsequently enroll some time later), and swirling students
(those who attend multiple institutions, sometimes concurrently,
en route to a degree or certificate). The community colleges pride
themselves on open access, which translates into ease of entry. In
general, this means that students may register with little advance
commitment and enroll in classes without completing a plan of
study. Part-time attendance is not discouraged, and withdrawing
from classes without penalty and reenrolling is considerably more
typical student behavior than that found at the universities. The
colleges have made numerous efforts in recent years to tighten
requirements by demanding advance registration, preenrollment
counseling, filing of matriculation plans, and mandatory testing
and advisement. But the attendance patterns that were encouraged
during an era of laissez-faire, open-access policies still dominate.
Not surprisingly, these attendance patterns lead to retention
rates that are significantly lower than those at four-year institutions.
Among first-time, degree-seeking community college students in
fall 2009, only 60 percent returned for fall 2010 (the corresponding
rate at public four-year institutions was 80 percent). Add in
students who may have enrolled for reasons other than a degree,
and retention rates slip to slightly over 50 percent; among part-time
students it is lower still: 41 percent (NCHEMS, 2010). Retention
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 71
Students 71
rates tell only part of the story; several additional questions are
justified. Which students persist? Who drops out, stops out, or swirls
and when? Who completes the programs, transfers, or satisfies their
reasons for entry? More studies of student attendance patterns have
been conducted than of any other area within the institutions.
Students are tracked, transcripts are analyzed, the dropouts are
surveyed, and grade-point averages earned by transferring students
are reviewed, all in an attempt to learn how and why students stay
or leave. The presenting reason is to determine how the college
can better serve its matriculants; the result is a wealth of research
tracking students into and out of the institutions.
Swirling Students
In 1990, Alfredo de los Santos and Irene Wright coined the term
student swirl to describe patterns of enrollment in Phoenix’s Maricopa Community College District in which students took courses
offered by multiple institutions, sometimes concurrently, at times
and places that were most convenient or had space available.
The swirling phenomenon is apparent in most states, particularly in metropolitan areas. In 2011, close to seventy thousand
California community college students attended two institutions
concurrently; nearly five thousand attended three; and at least
four hundred took classes at four or five colleges (Rivera, 2012).
Many swirling students also enroll in community college courses
after transferring to a university, a phenomenon since titled reverse
transfer.
A recent report from the National Student Clearinghouse
(2012b) illustrates the extent of the swirling phenomenon: among
students who first enrolled in a community college in 2006, onethird transferred at least once in the ensuing five years. A full
61 percent of these transferred to a four-year institution; 38 percent
transferred laterally, that is, to another community college. Furthermore, between 41 and 52 percent of students who began at
a four-year college and transferred to another institution earned
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 72
72 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
at least some credits from a community college, often during the
summer months. The report concluded that “the linear view of
college access and success that focuses on the initial institution
attended often fails to address the realities on the ground” (p. 48)
and called for new analytical approaches in which “students are
the unit of analysis and institutions are viewed as stepping stones
along a diverse set of educational paths” to learn more about the
factors associated with success for mobile students (p. 48).
Dropouts
Most of the hundreds of dropout studies conducted over many
decades have relied on surveys of nonreturning students. The
reasons that students drop out are quite varied, but in general most
of them are related to situations beyond the college’s control. A
change in work schedule is often cited, along with such personal
reasons as health problems, difficulty in obtaining child care, family
conflicts, financial burdens, change in residence, or attendance at
another institution. Many of the early leavers have already attained
the objective for which they attended; they wanted to take only
a course or two. Hence, their leaving had nothing to do with
college policies or procedures; they got what they wanted and
then withdrew. And in studies that asked students whether they
intended to return, a majority of the respondents indicated that
they would be back one day. The availability of the institution
seemed quite popular and may even have contributed to the lack
of persistence: Why not leave when other demands interfere? You
can always return.
Although most of the reasons for leaving school are beyond
the college’s ability to amend, some of the reasons suggest that
institutional intervention might be helpful. One discovery is that
decisions to drop out are usually made early on. As an example,
Kangas (1991) interviewed students who withdrew and found that
71 percent of them thought about leaving in the first four weeks;
85 percent did not talk to their instructor about withdrawing. And
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 73
Students 73
although he found that only around one student in six offered
reasons related to the classroom, the instructor, or the college,
the students who withdrew indicated that they had never really
gotten involved with the college; most of them studied alone, and
most were working forty or more hours per week outside school.
Nationally, of the students entering community colleges in fall
2003 and leaving by the end of their first year, 27 percent indicated
they had never participated in a study group, 24 percent had never
socialized with faculty or advisers, and 27 percent had never spoken
with faculty outside class (NCES, 2012).
Retention can be enhanced if actions are taken to integrate
the students with the college. This must be started early, even
before the instructional term begins. Programs of early start and
summer involvements have been tried and have been demonstrably
successful. Adelman examined several large-scale data sets and
concluded that summer-term credits “held a consistently positive
relationship to degree completion” (2006b, n.p.). The National
Science Foundation funds summer bridge programs to increase the
number of secondary school, community college, and four-year
college students entering science, mathematics, and engineering
curriculums. But these reach only a few students; those who
in the main are already committed. The rest of the beginning
students need to be alerted to the availability of advising and,
more important, to the campus services that can help them in
making the transition from their life in the community to life as
a student. Child-care facilities, now found in most colleges, are
essential. And early alert systems, which identify students who
are at risk for academic failure so that a faculty or staff member
can offer assistance, are becoming prevalent; 56 percent of twoyear college campuses have some sort of early alert system in
place within first-year courses (Barefoot, 2005). Interestingly, few
colleges have created sizable numbers of on-campus jobs for aides,
paraprofessionals, peer tutors, teaching assistants, clerical workers,
or custodial assistants, all jobs that might bring the students into
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 74
74 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
closer association with the institution and thereby encourage them
to work fewer hours away from the college.
The admissions procedures alone, which allowed students to
enter classes almost at will, certainly contributed to the dropout
rate. Studies of the reasons that students drop out of college rarely
consider the strength of their initial commitment, but it seems
likely that a student who petitions for admission, takes a battery of
entrance tests, and signs up for classes six months in advance
of the term is more genuinely committed to attending than one
who appears on the first day of classes with little preliminary planning. Data on students’ ethnicity, prior academic achievement,
and degree aspirations pale in comparison with the essential component: the degree of their personal commitment. NCES (2009)
defined strongly directed students as those who reported an intention to complete a program of study, attended at least half time
during their first year, and enrolled in a formal degree or certificate
program. The strongly directed were less likely to drop out than
their moderately directed or not directed peers, a finding corroborated
by several state-level studies (North Carolina Community College
System, 2007a, 2007b). This group also tended to be younger.
Determining the intrainstitutional procedures that affect
dropout tells only part of the story. The colleges’ efforts to recruit
and enroll sizable numbers of students must also be considered. As
open-door, noncompulsory institutions, community colleges have
historically made tremendous efforts to bring in sizable numbers of
students. Over the years they established off-campus recruitment
centers and sent vans staffed with counselors into shopping centers
and parks. They advertised in newspapers and on billboards
and conducted telephone solicitations. Some of the advertising
campaigns were planned as carefully as sophisticated marketing
plans used by private businesses. By 1988, a sizable percentage
of the nation’s community colleges had organized marketing
divisions (Bogart and Galbraith, 1988). These efforts certainly
contributed to maintaining enrollments, but for many years they
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 75
Students 75
also tended to attract students with only a casual commitment
to college-level studies. The wholesale, intense marketing efforts
have ceased recently. In fact, many overcrowded colleges are
turning students away as reduced state and local allocations force
a reduction in enrollment slots.
Studies of student dropout may be only marginally relevant to
an institution that regards accessibility as its greatest virtue. The
community colleges have organized themselves around the theme
of ease in entrance, exit, and reentry. Having made a considerable
effort to recruit students and offer them something useful, most
faculty members and administrators do want to keep them enrolled,
at least until degree or program objectives have been fulfilled. But
it is difficult for an institution built on the theme of easy access to
limit easy exit.
Still, any institution needs to demonstrate its usefulness to
society if it is to continue to be supported. When a school that
people are not obligated to attend continues to enroll greater
segments of the population, its administrators can argue that it
must be offering something of value to those who are investing
their own time and money. They can also argue that enrolling
ever greater percentages of the population is a social good because
the more people who are exposed to schooling, the more likely
it is that intellectual leaders will emerge from among them. If
intellectual ability in the population is distributed on a probability
basis, intelligent people will come forth if more are given access
to schooling. By that line of reasoning, any restricted educational
system runs counter to social policy, whether the restriction is by
wealth, sex, race, or scholastic test.
Questions of program completion fade in that light. The better
question to ask is: Of what value is the community college even to
those people who do not graduate or transfer to a baccalaureatedegree-granting institution? By their nature, by deliberate intent,
the community colleges sought to become open-access institutions.
Who can estimate the extent of the social need they were fulfilling?
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 76
76 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
In summation, if the purpose of the collegiate enterprise is to
pass most students through to the baccalaureate degree, then the
community college is a failure by design. But as the president of
La Guardia Community College emphasized, “It does matter if a
community college moves an adult from reading at the 5th grade
to the 9th grade level, or learns how to compute percentages, or
develops the capacity for the intellectual problem solving necessary
to get and keep a job” (Mellow, 2008, p. 3).
Issues
Institutional planners will continue to face questions about the
numbers and types of students enrolled. For example, which groups
have first claim on the institution? If enrollment limitations mean
that some students must be turned away, who shall they be? Those
of lesser ability? Those with indistinct goals? Those who already
have baccalaureate degrees? Historically, colleges have influenced
the types of students they attract by expanding or contracting offcampus or off-hours classes and enforcing student probation and
suspension procedures more or less stringently, to name but two
obvious means.
More direct methods may have to be developed in the future.
While colleges will likely stop short of creating lists placing the
categories of potential students in order from highest to lowest priority, some have flirted with slightly subtler strategies for essentially
doing the same. In 2012 Santa Monica College (California) proposed opening additional sections of high-demand courses during
the summer months, asking students to pay roughly four times the
normal tuition in hopes that the courses would raise revenues and
help ease overcrowding during the school year. The plan was eventually tabled after intense student protests, but community colleges
in at least six states—Alaska, Arizona, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas,
and South Dakota—are already charging differential tuition based
on the cost of course delivery (Friedel and Thomas, 2013). Colleges
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 77
Students 77
across the country may well follow suit as resource constraints and
enrollment pressures build, the possibility of which raises an important question: Who should decide on these policies (and hence the
student types), the colleges or the states?
Historically, the community college student has been defined
as one who is enrolled in a course. But it may be time to modify the
definition of student to include only those who are enrolled past
the first census week or even longer than that. Counting everyone
who registers, even those who take no classes or who drop out after
the first couple of sessions, distorts the data on student success.
Other open questions include the following. How will start-andstop enrollment patterns and a growing willingness by students
to piece together a mobile education affect the ways colleges
offer courses and support services? How might it change our
understanding of student progress and outcomes? How will the
recent moves toward assessing students at entry and demanding
that they make continual progress toward completing a program
affect enrollments of various groups? How will they affect retention
and program completion?
And the broadest questions of all: Which people benefit most
from, and which are harmed by, an institution that allows all to
attend at their pleasure? For which students should society pay
full fare? The personal and social implications of these questions
give way rapidly to the political and fiscal as soon as they are put
to the test.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c02.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 7:03pm Page 78
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-18 10:16:30.
8
Developmental Education
Enhancing Literacy and Basic Skills
Nothing has been easier to decry than the ineffectiveness of
the schools. One observer of American education noted:
Paradoxical as it may seem, the diffusion of education
and intelligence is at present acting against the free
development of the highest education and intelligence.
Many have hoped and still hope that by giving a partial
teaching to great numbers of persons, a stimulus would
be applied to the best minds among them, and a thirst for
knowledge awakened that would lead to high results; but
thus far these results have not equaled the expectation.
There has been a vast expenditure . . . for educational
purposes . . . but the system of competitive cramming in our schools has not borne fruits on which we
have much cause to congratulate ourselves. (Parkman,
1869, p. 560)
The sentiments in this passage, written in 1869 by the American
historian Francis Parkman, have been echoed countless times since.
One hundred years after Parkman’s comment, the American poet
and critic John Ciardi complained that “the American school
system has dedicated itself to universal subliteracy” (1971, p. 48).
The novelist Walker Percy offered this devastating critique: “Ours
is the only civilization in history which has enshrined mediocrity
as its national ideal” (1980, p. 177).
235
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 236
236 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
A steady outpouring of books continued the critique. Hirsch
began his best seller with the words, “The standard of literacy
required by modern society has been rising throughout the developed world, but American literacy rates have not risen to meet
this standard” (1987, p. 1). Harman’s examination of illiteracy
described how “more and more working members of mainstream
America are found to be either totally illiterate or unable to read
at the level presumably required by their job or their position in
society” (1987, p. 1).
The conventional belief was that literacy had declined. But how
much? And by what measurement? Certainly the colleges were and
are deeply involved with developmental studies, but at what cost to
their image? And to what effect? In this chapter, several dilemmas
surrounding the tracking of students into less-than-college-level
courses are explored, especially the difficulty in assigning standards
and definitions and assessing program outcomes. Some examples
of the ameliorative practices in which the colleges are engaged are
also noted.
Decline in Literacy
Unmitigated denunciations are one thing; accurate data are quite
another. Information on the literacy of the American population
over the decades is difficult to compile, even though for well over
one hundred years the Bureau of the Census has collected data
on the number of people completing so many years of schooling.
Intergenerational comparisons are imprecise because different percentages of the population have gone to school at different periods
in the nation’s history and because the United States has never had
a uniform system of educational evaluation. Still, an understanding
of the importance of literacy, concern about its decline, and the
need to do something about it have become widespread.
Eight National Education Goals were set into law on March
31, 1994, when President Clinton signed the Goals 2000: Educate
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 237
Developmental Education 237
America Act. One of the eight goals was that every adult would
be literate, possessing the knowledge and skills to compete in
the workplace and exercising the responsibilities of citizenship.
Although the act itself has been superseded, its emphasis on standards, norms, and instrumentation so that measures of literacy
in all age groups could be reported according to common referents has survived, incorporated into the contemporary emphasis
on accountability. Subsequent federal legislation has emphasized
testing students periodically, with the intention of encouraging
schools where students score below the norm to improve.
Concerns about literacy came as no surprise to educators who
have reviewed the scores made on nationally normed tests taken
by people planning on entering college. The available evidence
suggests that the academic achievement of students in schools
and colleges registered a gradual improvement between 1900 and
the mid-1950s, an accelerated improvement between the mid1950s and the mid-1960s, and a precipitous, widespread decline
between then and the late 1970s, before stabilizing in the early
1980s. The SATs taken by college-bound high school seniors show
mathematical ability at 494 in 1952 and 502 in 1963; it dropped
as low as 492 in 1980 but by 2012 had reached 514. Verbal ability
went from 476 in 1952 to 543 in 1966 and then dropped in 1980
to 502, where it remained stable for many years before dipping to
496 in 2012 (College Board, 2012; see Table 8.1).
The scores made by students who participated in the ACT Program between 1995 and 2010 reveal a similar pattern (Table 8.2). In
those years, reading and science scores were stable, English showed
a slight increase, and math demonstrated a greater increase. The
overall composite rose to 21.1 in 2008 and remained there through
2012. Declines in academic achievement during the 1970s and
subsequent stabilization were confirmed by the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) studies of seventeen-year-old
students. After bottoming out in the early 1980s, students’ performance in math rose so that their average score in 2008 was slightly
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 238
238 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
Table 8.1. SAT Scores for College-Bound Seniors, 1975–2012
Year Critical Reading Mathematics Writing
1975 512 498 –
1980 502 492 –
1985 509 500 –
1990 500 501 –
1995 504 506 –
2000 505 514 –
2005 508 520 497∗
2010 500 515 491
2012 496 514 488
∗Score from 2006, the first year of the writing portion.
Source: College Board, 2012.
Table 8.2. ACT Test Scores for High School Seniors, 1995–2010
1995 2000 2005 2010
Composite 20.8 21.0 20.9 21.0
English 20.2 20.5 20.4 20.5
Math 20.2 20.7 20.7 21.0
Reading 21.3 21.4 21.3 21.3
Science 21.0 21.0 20.9 20.9
Source: NCES, Digest, 2011.
higher than in 1973. Over the same period, their scores in reading
showed a gain in the 1980s but dropped back to the 1975 level
thereafter.
No one can say with assurance which social or educational condition was primarily responsible for the decline in student abilities
that apparently began in the mid-1960s and accelerated throughout
the 1970s before leveling off. Suffice it to say that numerous events
came together: the coming of age of the first generation reared on
television; a breakdown in respect for authority and the professions;
a pervasive attitude that the written word is not as important as
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 239
Developmental Education 239
it once was; the imposition of various other-than-academic expectations on the public schools; the increasing numbers of students
whose native language is other than English; and a decline in
academic requirements and expectations at all levels of schooling.
The time that the current generation has spent texting or on social
media websites hasn’t helped either.
The effect of schooling and the availability of other educational
opportunities are suggested by the relationships between family
income and SAT scores. According to the College Board (2012),
scores made by the more than 1.6 million college bound seniors
who took the SAT showed a straight-line, positive correlation
with family income. Those with income greater than $100,000
averaged 540 in reading, 555 in math, and 533 in writing, while
those with income less than $20,000 scored 434 in reading, 460
in math, and 429 in writing. Since students from low-income
families are considerably more likely to attend community colleges
than universities, these figures do much to explain patterns in the
colleges’ student body.
School Requirements
Of all the listed conditions, academic requirements are the only
ones that are within the power of the schools to change directly.
Several premises underlie schooling—for example, that students
tend to learn what is taught, that the more time they spend on a task
the more they learn, and that they will take the courses required
for completion of their programs. Hence, when expectations, time
in school, and number of academic requirements are reduced,
student achievement, however measured, seems certain to drop as
well. In its 1978 report, The Concern for Writing, the Educational
Testing Service noted, “The nub of the matter is that writing is a
complex skill mastered only through lengthy, arduous effort. It is
a participatory endeavor, not a spectator sport. And most high
school students do not get enough practice to become competent
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 240
240 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
writers” (p. 4). In the 1960s and 1970s, the schools put less emphasis
on composition, and even in composition courses creative expression
was treated at a higher level than were grammar and the other
tools of the writer’s trade.
Copperman (1978) recounted the depressing statistics regarding
deterioration of the secondary school curriculum. Specifically,
the percentage of ninth- through twelfth-grade students enrolled
in academic courses dropped between 1960 and 1972, from 95
to 71 percent in English courses and proportionately in social
studies, science, and mathematics. In other words, the average
high school graduate had taken four years of English in 1960 and
only three years in 1972. And the curriculum in English shifted
from sequential courses to electives chosen from courses in creative
writing, journalism, public speaking, classical literature, science
fiction, advanced folklore, composition, mass media, poetry, and a
host of other options. Not only were students taking less science,
math, English, and history, but in the academic classes they did
take the amount of work assigned and the standard to which it was
held deteriorated as well.
During the 1980s, school reform shifted toward educational
excellence and outcomes assessment. In 1983, the National Commission on Excellence in Education published A Nation at Risk
(Gardner and others), in which it highlighted the importance of
education for the civic well-being of our nation. The report suggested that states adopt a curriculum, known as the New Basics, to
include four years of English; three years of mathematics, science,
and social studies; one-half year of computer science; and two years
of foreign language for students who wish to go to college. Ravitch
noted that “by late 1983, a national survey found that forty-six
states had either raised their graduation requirements recently or
were debating proposals to do so” (1985, p. 67).
A notable shift in high school course enrollments occurred.
Between 1982 and 2009, the average number of Carnegie credits taken by high school students increased from 21.6 to 27.2
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 241
Developmental Education 241
Table 8.3. Average Number of Carnegie Units Earned by Public
High School Graduates in Various Subject Areas: 1982, 1994, 2000,
2009
1982 1994 2000 2009
Total Carnegie Units 21.58 24.17 26.15 27.15
English 3.93 4.29 4.26 4.37
Social Studies 3.16 3.55 3.89 4.19
Total Math 2.63 3.33 3.62 3.91
Total Science 2.20 3.04 3.20 3.47
Foreign Language 0.99 1.71 2.01 2.21
Source: NCES, Digest, 2011.
(see Table 8.3). All academic areas showed an increase, with
mathematics, sciences, and foreign languages showing the most
notable gains. In 2009, 70 percent of students took chemistry compared with 32 percent in 1982; 88 percent took geometry in 2009
versus 47 percent in 1982; 30 percent took biology, chemistry, and
physics compared with 11 percent in 1982. Overall, the high school
curriculum was rebuilt to the levels of the 1950s. The effect of the
strengthened requirements was a reduced number of high school
occupational classes (bookkeeping, typing, shop) and an increase
in the totality of courses taken by graduates.
In sum, students coming to the colleges in the 1990s and 2000s
had taken more academic courses, and their academic abilities had
begun to climb. Indeed, high school seniors’ grade-point averages
rose from an average of 2.68 in 1992 to 2.98 in 2005 (Landsberg,
2007). Student testing had increased as well, with more than onethird of the states requiring a minimum competency test for high
school graduation. But as the SAT, ACT, and NAEP results show,
overall gains in literacy have come slowly, if at all.
A recent report from Educational Testing Service reveals that,
despite all types of school reforms in the past generation, little
has changed. High school completion rates (exclusive of GEDs),
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 242
242 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
77 percent in 1969, fell to 70 percent in 1995 and crept back up
to 75 percent in 2009, which has resulted in the United States
dropping behind all but five of twenty-six countries listed by
the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development.
Noteworthy here is that during that same period total spending
per pupil in public K–12 schools more than doubled in constant
2009–10 dollars, the student–teacher ratio (class size) dropped by
half, and the percentage of teachers with at least a master’s degree
doubled. One in four ACT-tested high school graduates of 2011
who took the core curriculum—four years of English and three
each of math, science, and social studies—met the ACT College
Readiness Benchmarks in all four subjects; 28 percent failed to
reach any of the benchmarks (ACT, 2011). Just over half the
graduates met the standard for reading, a decline from the peak of
55 percent reached in 1999; only 45 percent met the benchmark
for math in 2011. The problem is even more acute in some states:
ACT found that “more eighth and tenth graders are on track to
being ready for college-level reading than are actually ready when
they graduate” and suggests that “state standards in high school
reading are insufficient—or nonexistent” (p. 3). More than half of
the 49 states with reading standards fully define them “only through
the eighth grade” (p. 3). And a recent report from the National
Center on Education and the Economy (2013) emphasized the
continued disconnect between demands in college-level English
and mathematics courses and high school requirements, both in
terms of subject matter content and faculty expectations of students.
College Admissions
Because each college set its own standards and because the
founding of colleges preceded the development of a widespread
secondary school system, the early colleges displayed a wide variety of admission requirements. By the late nineteenth century,
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 243
Developmental Education 243
most were operating their own remedial education programs. In
1895, 40 percent of entering students were drawn from preparatory programs operated by the colleges and universities themselves
(Rudolph, 1977, p. 158).
Numerous attempts to stabilize college admissions have been
made. In 1892, the National Education Association organized the
Committee on Secondary School Studies, known as the Committee
of Ten, which was to recommend and approve the secondary school
curriculum for college matriculation. In 1900, the College Entrance
Examination Board began offering a common examination for
college admission. Nonetheless, the wide variety in types and
quality of colleges in America made it impossible to devise uniform
admission standards. There has never been a standard of admission
to all colleges in the United States. The Educational Testing
Service and the ACT Program offer uniform examinations across
the country, but each college is free to admit students regardless of
where they place on those examinations.
Of all postsecondary educational structures in America, the
public community colleges bore the brunt of the poor preparation
of students in the twentieth century. When sizable cohorts of
well-prepared students were clamoring for higher education, as in
the 1950s and early 1960s, the community colleges received a large
share of them. But when the college-age group declined and the
universities became more competitive for students, the proportion
of academically well-prepared students going to community colleges shrank. Thus, the colleges were dealt a multiple blow: relaxed
admission requirements and the availability of financial aid at the
more prestigious universities; a severe decline in the scholastic
abilities of high school graduates; and a greater percentage of applicants who had taken fewer academic courses. And although the
recent upturn in the eighteen-year-old population has lowered
the median student age in community colleges, it has done little to
elevate the students’ abilities.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 244
244 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
The community colleges responded by accommodating the
different types of students without turning anyone away. They
have always tended to let everyone in but have then attempted to
guide students to programs that fit their aspirations and in which
they have some chance to succeed. Students who qualified for
transfer programs were never a serious problem; they were given
courses similar to those they would find in the lower division of
the four-year colleges and universities. Technical and occupational
aspirants were not a problem either; vocational programs were
organized for them. Internal selectivity was the norm; failing certain
prerequisites, applicants were barred from the health professions
and technology programs. The students who wanted a course or two
for their own personal interest found them both in the departments
of continuing education and the transfer programs.
The rest, the poorly prepared high school pass-throughs, has
been the concern. How should the colleges deal with students who
aspire to a college degree but who are reading at the fifth-grade
level? Shunting underprepared students to the trades programs was
a favored ploy, giving rise to Clark’s cooling-out thesis (1960).
Another ploy was to offer a smattering of developmental courses
where students would be prepared, more or less successfully, to
enter the transfer courses—or entertained until they drifted away.
But the decline in achievement exhibited by secondary school
graduates and dropouts in the 1970s hit the colleges with full
force. The problem of the underprepared student became central
to instructional planning.
The Magnitude of Remediation
Remedial and developmental and, less often, compensatory and basic
skills have been used more or less interchangeably for courses
designed to teach literacy (the essentials of reading, writing, and
arithmetic) plus broader skills for living (time management, how
to study, coping with family crises). Students have been advised to
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 245
Developmental Education 245
enroll in those courses on the basis of entrance tests or prior school
achievement. The courses are not often accepted for credit toward
an academic degree, but their funding comes through the regular
academic instructional budget, sometimes augmented by special
state or federal program appropriations to assist disadvantaged
students.
Although the decline in student ability stabilized in the 1980s,
developmental education grew until it leveled off in the 1990s.
The rise in remedial course enrollment occurred because student
ability had sunk so low that college staff members, legislators, and
the staff of the universities to which the students transfer had
had enough. The dropout and failure rates were unconscionably
high. When the population was expanding and an ever-increasing
number of new students showed up each year, the problem was
not as acute, and few colleges did anything about coordinating
developmental education. In the late 1970s, however, the attitude
shifted as the college staff realized that it was more feasible, not
to say socially and educationally defensible, to keep the students
enrolled than to let them drop out as a result of academic failure.
All public two-year colleges offer developmental courses. The
Center for the Study of Community Colleges (CSCC) tallied
the sections offered in a national sample of colleges in 1998
and found that 29 percent of the scheduled class sections in
English and 32 percent in math were designated as developmental
(Schuyler, 1999b). These data were corroborated in state studies:
14 percent of the credit-course enrollment in Illinois, 17 percent in
North Carolina, and 23 percent each in Florida and Washington
community colleges were in remedial courses (Illinois Community
College Board, 2005; North Carolina Community College System,
2007a, 2007b; Florida Department of Education, 2007; Washington
State Board for Community and Technical Colleges, 2006).
Data on entering students who need remedial help suggest the
magnitude of the problem. The Education Commission of the States
estimates that 40 percent of all college students and 58 percent
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 246
246 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
of those in community colleges require some remediation (Fulton,
2012). A 2010 study of 250,000 incoming students at fifty-seven
community colleges across the country found that 59 percent were
referred to developmental math and 33 percent to developmental
English or reading (Bailey, Jeong, and Cho, 2010). The percentage
of underprepared entrants varies widely. A recent study of one
hundred thousand students in six community colleges that are
part of a large, urban system found that roughly 90 percent of
the students were assigned to remediation in one or more subjects
(Scott-Clayton and Rodriguez, 2012). Of all the recent high school
completers, 46 percent (and 92 percent of the GED graduates)
entering Kentucky’s public institutions in 2004 were underprepared
for college (Kentucky Developmental Education Task Force, 2007).
In California, 72 percent of entering students required to take
the placement exam in fall 2010 were directed to basic skills
courses in English, and 85 percent were referred to developmental
math. Strikingly, of those students testing into remedial math,
the largest percentage assessed at three levels below college-level;
only 14 percent of these ever completed a college-level math
course (California Community Colleges, 2012). Over 70 percent
of students entering Virginia’s community colleges in 2007–08
were referred to developmental math (nearly half to three levels
below college-level math) and 34 percent to developmental English
(Virginia Community Colleges, 2010). Nationwide, 44 percent of
first-time community college students enroll in between one and
three developmental courses; 14 percent take more than three.
Developmental Teaching
How do college faculty members who face students daily feel about
massive developmental education efforts and the poorly prepared
students in their classes? Students’ abilities exert the single most
powerful influence on the level, quality, type, and standard of curriculum and instruction offered in every program in every school.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 247
Developmental Education 247
Other influences—instructors’ tendencies, externally administered
examinations and licensure requirements, the entry levels imposed
by succeeding courses in the same and other institutions—are
of lesser importance. Nothing that is too distant from the students’ comprehension can be taught successfully. All questions
of academic standards, college-level and remedial courses, textbook readability and coverage, and course pacing and sequence
come to that.
Students are part of the instructors’ working conditions. Except
for faculty members recruited especially to staff developmental
programs, most feel that their environment would be improved
if their students were more able. In the CSCC’s 1977 National
Science Foundation–sponsored survey of science instructors at
two-year colleges throughout the country (Brawer and Friedlander,
1979), respondents were asked, “What would it take to make yours
a better course?” Over half noted “students better prepared to
handle course requirements,” a choice that far outranked all others
in a list of sixteen (p. 32). More than twenty years later, Outcalt
(2002b) found almost the exact response among the academic
faculty he surveyed.
If students cannot be more able, at least they might be more alike
so that instruction can be better focused. Teaching groups of students whose reading or computational abilities range from the third
to the thirteenth grade is demoralizing; everything is more difficult,
from writing examinations to showing group progress—hence, the
unremitting pressure for ability grouping, remedial courses, and
learning laboratories that serve to remove the poorer students from
the classrooms.
As integrated developmental programs grew in the 1980s,
separate divisions combining faculty members, counselors, and
support staff were formed to accommodate them. As noted in
Chapter Three, this separation of the developmental education
staff from the academic discipline–centered faculty has led to
an increased level of professional consciousness among members
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 248
248 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
of the former group. They publish their own journals, which
carry articles on peer tutoring, the pros and cons of mandatory
testing, ways of organizing reading and writing laboratories, and
the various treatments they apply to students who come within
their purview. In some colleges the academic instructors still treat
them as pariahs, but they have their own colleagues and support
groups. A continuing problem, however, is that an overwhelming
number of developmental instructors are part-timers.
Assessment and Placement
More than half the states have regulations governing remedial
instruction. Some have mandated that it not be offered in the
public universities; Florida, Missouri, New York, South Carolina,
and Arizona are notable examples. Others have placed limits
on the number of developmental courses a university may offer
and directed the universities to arrange remedial instruction for
their students with the community colleges, thus inflating their
numbers of developmental students. Illinois law stipulates that
“the primary emphasis on postsecondary remedial programs [is] at
Public Community Colleges” (Ignash, 1997, p. 7), an example of
persuasiveness seen also in several other states.
As responsibility for remediating the underprepared has been
shunted to the community colleges, assessment and placement
of incoming students have become integral. Beginning in the
late 1970s, the nation’s community colleges moved toward a
system of placement testing, restricted admissions to many courses
and programs, integrated developmental programs complete with
counseling and tutorial services, and assessment of the efficacy
of these procedures. In the 1980s, state-mandated placement
testing was installed, first in Florida and Georgia; subsequently in
Texas, California, and New Jersey; and by 2000 in twenty more
states. These requirements affected all the publicly supported
institutions, and at the start of the twenty-first century 92 percent
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 249
Developmental Education 249
of community colleges were administering high-stakes exams to
determine whether students should be referred or directed
to developmental or college-level courses.
Some of the states that have mandated assessment and placement have specified tests and cutoff scores. The Massachusetts
Board of Higher Education requires that all colleges in the state
use the College Board’s ACCUPLACER Computerized Placement
Test, and its cutoffs for reading and math fall within a narrow range.
The Texas Success Initiative has established a college-readiness
standard on the Texas Higher Education Assessment, required of
all exiting high school students who plan on entering college.
California allows its 112 community colleges to choose their own
measures, and in 2007 over one hundred different instruments
were in use (Brown and Niemi, 2007). In a survey of entering
community college students conducted by WestEd in 2010, most
did not understand that their performance on placement tests would
determine the classes they could take or that their score
would affect when they could begin earning college credit or how
long it would take to complete their course of study (Venezia,
Bracco, and Nodine, 2010). Students’ apparent ignorance of the
consequences of placement tests significantly ups their stakes.
Are placement tests valid? State policies rarely ask. A few
call for regular review of cut scores but not of the instruments
themselves. The most common approach often fails to distinguish
between students who would benefit from remediation and those
who could succeed in college-level courses with additional support.
Too many students are directed toward developmental studies
based on tests of limited validity; one recent study found that three
of every ten students is misassigned to developmental English;
error rates for math placement are lower but not trivial (Belfield
and Crosta, 2012). Commercially available tests have become
popular: COMPASS, ASSET, and ACCUPLACER. Tests gain
reliability if they are matched with course requirements, and short
refresher courses offered prior to testing are also helpful; however,
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 250
250 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
these test prep courses are available at less than half of the
community colleges. When high school grade-point averages are
used in combination with placement tests, predictions of college
success are considerably more accurate. When Long Beach City
College began using high school grades to determine whether
incoming students belonged in developmental classes, 53 percent
of one thousand in the group were placed into college English,
compared with less than 6 percent from the same high schools in
the prior year. And 62 percent passed the course, the same as the
college’s typical pass rate (Fain, 2013b).
Integrated Programs
Proceeding in tandem with assessment and placement procedures
have been a number of integrated programs combining instruction
in the three Rs with counseling, tutoring, study skills seminars, and
a variety of special interventions, such as early alert systems
and monitoring of students’ attendance and progress. The courses
may include remedial reading and writing, and adjunct classes
centering on certain content areas also may be provided. The
students may be tutored individually by professionals or peers.
The programs frequently include reproducible instructional
sequences presented through learning laboratories. Nearly half
use computers as an interactive instructional tool for on-campus
reading, writing, and mathematics, and one-fourth offer developmental courses through distance instruction. In some of the more
sophisticated developmental programs, remedial classes are offered
through the English and mathematics departments, adjunct courses
or study programs are offered through the learning resource center,
study skills activities are presented by members of the counseling
staff, and tutorials are coordinated by any of these divisions.
Numerous descriptions of such programs may be found. Some are
organized as bridge programs designed to assist recent high school
graduates in making the transition to college. These programs
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 251
Developmental Education 251
include counseling and efforts to direct the students toward career
goals as well as an emphasis on basic academic skills. The Freshman
Initiative Program at Bronx Community College (New York) is
designed for entering freshmen requiring two or more remedial
courses. Students take two or three developmental courses and at
least one credit-bearing class in their first term, all while receiving in-class tutoring and professional counseling. Santa Monica
College (California) offers a Summer Bridge and Learning Communities Program through its First Year Institute.
Many other permutations can be cited. Some programs allow
students to enter the academic courses but insist that they take
advantage of tutorial assistance available to help them with their
coursework. This is an old approach, matching learning laboratories
with the specific course areas. Some of these labs are dedicated to
math, others to reading or writing. Also prevalent are open-entry,
open-exit courses, where students can drop in at any time and work
with an instructor on specific problems. However, where these are
volitional, they may be playing into the students’ tendency not to
place extra effort on their college work.
Overall, numerous patterns are in play: self-standing developmental courses; learning assistance keyed to students in regular
college classes; supplemental instruction for students in high-risk
courses; precollege bridge programs; learning communities; and
combinations of all of these. The point is that the colleges have
now abandoned the practice of allowing students to drop in and
drop out at will and have moved distinctly into a mode of mandatory
assessment and placement in sequences designed to keep students
in school and to help them improve their basic skills so that they
can complete an academic or occupational program satisfactorily.
Program Effects
Although only a minority of developmental programs in community colleges are evaluated in a regular and systematic fashion, many
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 252
252 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
reports indicate varying effects. The measures usually employed
are student retention, grade-point average, remedial course completion, successful transitions to the college-level programs, and
graduation rates. Levin and Calcagno cited studies showing that
“about seventy percent of students pass the reading and writing
remedial courses they enroll in, but only thirty percent pass all
their remedial math courses” (2007, p. 4). The more remedial
courses students must take, they less likely they will be to progress
on to college-level classes or to earn a credential. And even
when all remedial sequences have been completed, many students
fail to enroll in or complete college-level classes. According to
Bailey, Jeong, and Cho (2010), one-third of students who complete a remedial course or sequence never enroll in college-level
courses, even though three-quarters of those that do successfully
complete them. In Arizona, for example, 28 percent of developmental math learners beginning college in fall 2005 successfully
completed a college-level course in math within six years; the comparable statistic for developmental English students was 47 percent
(Arizona Community Colleges, 2012).
Are developmental programs effective? Pascarella and Terenzini’s meta-analysis found remedial programs “at least modestly
effective in helping students overcome deficiencies in their precollegiate academic preparation and associated disadvantages”
(2005, p. 398). Hundreds of studies reported in the published
literature and in the ERIC files suggest that student placement
procedures are valid and that students learn to read and write in
the remedial classes. Even though some single-college studies have
found enrollment in developmental courses to have no effect on
subsequent achievement, the inconsistency seems to relate both to
the way programs are organized and to the variations among types
of students.
The integrated programs, designed to affect retention as well
as learning by combining remedial instruction with counseling,
tutorials, and assistance specifically tailored to the other courses
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 253
Developmental Education 253
that the students are taking, have more salutary effects than the
freestanding or separate developmental classes, which have lower
retention and lower long-term success rates. Since 2006 when
Valencia College (Florida) began requiring a Student Success
course for all students who had been directed to developmental
classes, persistence rates have risen significantly, to 81 percent for
the class entering in 2010 (Florida Department of Education, 2006).
Levin and Calcagno (2007) agreed that isolated courses are considerably less effective than those that link basic skills courses with
credit-bearing courses, use supplemental instruction, or establish
learning communities. They pointed to successes attained through
learning assistance centers that include career counseling, tutoring,
and other enhancements. They also contended that instruction in
critical thinking, complex problem solving, and abstract reasoning
can be salutary for remedial students.
The positive effects of integrated developmental education
programs are not surprising; when staff members are involved in
a comprehensive program, they pay close attention to students,
integrate teaching with counseling, provide a greater variety of
learning materials than ordinary students receive, and motivate
their enrollees to devote more time to their studies. In short, when
special treatment is applied; when students are given supplemental
counseling, tutoring, and learning aids; and when they are singled
out for additional work, they tend to remain in school. Special
treatment of any sort yields special results.
The various students classified as needing remediation also
influence developmental outcomes. Gallegos described one type,
the nonnative English speaker, with several risk factors: “There
is overwhelming evidence that developmental students and traditional students are, on the average, fundamentally different in
many ways that will not be affected by successful remediation”
(2006, p. 35). Developmental students often have elevated high
school grade-point averages, suggesting grade inflation. They are
more likely to be bilingual, are often the first generation in their
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 254
254 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
family to attend college, are from low socioeconomic status backgrounds, have dependents, and attend part time. Evaluating “the
effectiveness of developmental programs by comparing the academic success of students exiting these programs to that of students
placed initially in the corresponding college-level course” (p. 57) is
often undertaken, but in many cases students will continue to speak
Spanish to anyone they spoke Spanish with before, disabilities and
financial disadvantages will persist, their numbers of children will
remain the same, and the educational level of their parents
will not change.
Indeed, according to the Council for the Advancement of
Adult Literacy (Chisholm, 2008), only 8 percent of English as a
Second Language (ESL) students make the transition to collegelevel courses (although presumably they do gain in employment
probability). The council attributes this to the fact that many ESL
programs center on life skills, and thus even those students who
complete ESL sequences still do not have the English language skills
necessary to succeed in postsecondary education. The life skills
classes rarely teach the special vocabulary, grammar, and listening
required for college study and indispensable for writing papers,
taking notes, and understanding teachers. Three to six hours
per week are not enough; high-intensity classes of twelve to
twenty hours per week, such as those employed at Mira Costa
College (California), are necessary. The Community College of
San Francisco has a well-developed program, including vocational
ESL that teaches enough for students to hold entry-level jobs in
health, construction, and maintenance.
Student age is another factor influencing developmental outcomes. In a study of 30,000 first-time traditional students and
5,700 older students, the Community College Research Center
at Teachers College found that older students were more likely
to need some remediation because they had forgotten some of
their basic math and English skills (Calcagno, Crosta, Bailey, and
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 255
Developmental Education 255
Jenkins, 2006). Prince and Jenkins used data from the Washington State Community and Technical College System to track the
progress of low-skill students twenty-five or older with no more
than high school diplomas. Only 13 percent of the ESL students in
this group went on to earn some college credits, but around 30 percent of the Adult Basic Education students entered college-level
courses, with 5 percent earning forty-five units or a certificate or
degree within five years. As for the programs’ value to students’
earnings, “Attending college for at least one year and earning a
credential provides a substantial boost in earnings . . . Short-term
training such as that often provided to welfare recipients may help
individuals get into the labor market, but it usually does not
help them advance beyond low-paying jobs” (2005, p. 23).
Legitimacy
Like any other public agency, an educational institution must
maintain its legitimacy. The community colleges have strived to
maintain their claim to a position in the postsecondary sector
through numerous stratagems. Beginning in the 1950s and 1960s
they sought people with doctoral degrees to serve as staff members
and rewarded current staff members when they obtained the higher
degree, even though possession of a doctorate bore little or no
relation to a faculty member’s professional activities. The doctorate
was a way of saying, “We are as good as the senior institutions.”
Similarly, they segregated their developmental programs in an
attempt to regain the legitimacy lost when the colleges accepted
adult basic studies and job training programs that could in no
measure be considered college level.
Actually, a school’s legitimacy rests on its academic standards and the definition of its guiding principles. Academic
standards certify that a student holding a certificate or degree has
met the requirement for employment or for further study at another
college; they are the basis for the reputation of institutions and the
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 256
256 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
people who work in them. Community college instructional programs, testing and counseling services, course content, and course
requirements must all relate to a shared vision of desired competencies and outcomes. Their certificates or degrees must evidence
some set of proficiencies achieved at some minimum level.
What are the standards in developmental education? Here the
special programs exhibit several problems in common with
the traditional. One of the main problems is the difficulty in setting
fixed exit criteria (grading standards) for courses and programs
where a wide range of students share the classroom. Either the exit
criteria must be fluid, with a different standard for each student,
or the time and type of instruction must be greatly varied, or the
instructors must maintain exceedingly modest expectations. All
three options are at play in practically all programs.
Standardized expectations of accomplishment, or exit criteria,
suggest social norms as contrasted with standards for individuals.
Social norms imply that people who would function adequately
in particular social settings (the workplace, school) must act to
a certain standard. The alternative, relating accomplishment
to the desires or entering abilities of individuals, suggests that
any accomplishment is satisfactory. This conflict between social
and individual standards is an issue of the absolute versus the
relative, and it strikes at the heart of developmental education.
Different groups take different positions on the issue. Community college instructors—particularly those not teaching developmental classes— tend to argue in favor of absolute standards. The
Academic Senate for California Community Colleges (ASCCC)
has studied the problem extensively, surveying its members and
sponsoring state conferences on the issue. The ASCCC deplored
some of the pressures to lower standards: students entering the college with inadequate basic skills but with the expectation of passing
the courses, as they have done throughout their prior school careers;
ill-prepared students insisting on enrolling in transfer courses rather
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 257
Developmental Education 257
than remedial courses; the virtual elimination of D and F grades
and concomitant wider use of passing grades; and a reduction
in the number of required subjects. In 1977, the ASCCC Academic Standards Committee recommended that standards should
be maintained through the use of diagnostic and placement testing, directive counseling, academic prerequisites for courses, and
proficiency testing before awarding academic degrees. These recommendations were in no small measure responsible for California’s
adopting matriculation standards in the 1980s.
Support for efforts to bring all students to at least college-level
literacy comes from many other areas, not least the American
Association of Community Colleges. As its 1988 Commission
on the Future of Community Colleges pointed out, “Literacy is
essential both for the individual and society . . . community colleges
must make a commitment, without apology, to help students
overcome academic deficiencies” (AACJC, 1988, pp. 16–17).
The association carried its point a step further when it sponsored
a national study seeking to determine the long-term success
of students who had participated in developmental programs.
The study found that most students who had gone through the
remedial programs did well in their college-level studies, entered
occupational programs or direct employment, and in general joined
the mainstream of American life, much like a general cohort of
the students entering community colleges (McCabe, 2000).
Advocates of the concept of lifelong learning often provide
an opposing view. To them, any seeker of knowledge should find
the institution a resource to be used for an infinite variety of purposes. Cross, for example, argued that substantial changes in school
forms are needed, so that anyone may learn anything at any time:
“My concern is that in our exuberance for recruiting adults and
certifying that their learning projects meet our standards, we will
corrupt independent, self-directed learners into learners dependent
on someone else to determine where, when, and how people should
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 258
258 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
learn. Visions of a learning society with people of all ages enthusiastically pursuing learning that interests them could so easily
turn into a joyless learning society with people grimly fulfilling
requirements and seeking legitimacy for every conceivable variety
of learning” (1978, pp. 19–20). These opposed positions suggest differing views about current and potential students. Some see them
as lethargic illiterates, others as humanistic knowledge seekers.
Both viewpoints defend the legitimacy of the institution, conveniently assigning blame for dismal developmental outcomes to the
lack of effort or the lack of interest, respectively, of underprepared
students.
The Dilemma of Tracking
Segregating the less well-prepared students has much appeal.
Classes can be made more homogeneous; the bright students
are not forced to wait for the less able to catch up; and, most
important, the instructors whose classes have been relieved of
the poorer students can retain the attitude that they are teaching
in a true college. However, the practice of shunting students to
developmental classes is based on tenuous assumptions, especially
the assumption that student performance standards are immutable,
when nearly all school programs are based on shifting norms. The
concept of functional literacy provides an example.
Definitions of Functional Literacy
One definition of functional literacy is the level of reading,
writing, and calculating ability that people need to succeed in
the public realm in which they choose to operate. Under this
definition, the level of literacy required to function as a citizen,
taxpayer, or homemaker, or in any other non-specific milieu,
serves as a criterion. A second definition is the level of reading,
writing, and ability to send and receive messages that it takes to
obtain and maintain a job. Obviously, different levels of literacy
are required for performance in various jobs. A third definition of
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 259
Developmental Education 259
functional literacy is the level required to perform successfully in a
college program. Here again, alternative programs require different
levels of competency. Harman cited a 1956 omnibus definition: “A
person is functionally literate when he has acquired the knowledge
and skills in reading and writing which enable him to engage
effectively in all those activities in which literacy is normally
assumed in his cultural group” (1987, p. 4). All of these definitions,
then, can be subsumed under the statement, “Functional literacy
is the ability to communicate in the symbolic language of reading,
writing, and speaking that is adequate for people to maintain
themselves in the context of particular situations,” or, as the
NAEP defined it, “using printed and written information to
function in society, to achieve one’s goals, and to develop one’s
knowledge and potential” (Kirsch and Jungeblut, 1986, p. 3).
So defined, functional literacy is related to the milieu in
which people find themselves. It is relative; there are no absolute
minimum standards of competence. A functionally literate person
in some school settings may be functionally illiterate in certain
jobs. And a person who is quite able to communicate within the
confines of certain jobs may be functionally illiterate for purposes
of a college program.
The dilemma here is that institutional legitimacy and faculty
predilections rest on standards, defined outcomes, and certifiable
results, but the definitions guiding staff efforts and the precepts of
continuing education or lifelong learning are relative. Each person
brings idiosyncratic backgrounds and aspirations to the institution;
each finds a separate set of experiences. How can the two be
reconciled in an open-admissions institution? The question is not
limited to developmental education, but the influx of students with
low academic ability brought it to the fore.
Imprecise Criteria
Selective admission to any program is as discriminatory as it is
justifiable. Regardless of the yardstick applied, the people who are
shut out of the programs in which they wanted to enroll have been
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 260
260 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
discriminated against. Yet with accrediting agencies, state licensing
boards, and senior institutions looking on, program directors feel
justified in admitting only a select few, particularly if the field of
endeavor for which the program prepares people can take only
so many graduates or if college facilities allow for only so many
matriculants.
Should the colleges restrict admissions to certain programs?
If some applicants cannot gain admission because their level of
literacy is lower than a cutting score, the issue is resolved for them.
But if applicants are admitted to the program, then its operators are
responsible for teaching the skills required for them to succeed in
it. The pattern of allowing all to enter and using the program itself
to screen out the unworthy should be discounted, first because one
cannot simultaneously teach and judge and second because it is too
expensive, in terms of both public funds and concern for people, to
allow sizable numbers to enroll with the expectation that many of
them will not complete the course of study.
The pressures for selective admission to various programs have
grown in recent years. In the 1950s, most colleges screened students
into remedial programs if their prior high school grades or their
scores on entrance tests suggested that they might not be able
to succeed in the transfer programs. In the 1960s, the pressure to
allow anyone to enter a transfer program grew, the reason being
that remedial programs were seen as catchalls for the less worthy,
as holding tanks for students who would not succeed in higher
education. In the 1970s, the pendulum swung back, with many
institutions building developmental programs, screening students
into them, moving away from the attitude of letting students try
everything and fail if they must. That trend accelerated in the
1980s as state mandates spread.
However, it is quite possible to teach functional literacy in the
transfer program, especially for students whose assessment scores
approach the cutoff for placement in college-level courses. Some
notable efforts at mainstreaming— that is, allowing lower-ability
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 261
Developmental Education 261
students to take the regular college classes even while they are being
assisted supplementally—have been made. Remediation does not
have to come in the form of segregated developmental courses.
It is likely that most students can succeed in the collegiate
and occupational programs if they are required to supplement their
courses with tutorials, learning labs, special counseling, peer-group
assistance, and a variety of other aids. The open-door philosophy of
the community college implies that these students should not be
denied. Students who are shut out of collegiate programs typically
miss exposure to the humanistic and scientific thought on which
these areas are based. Community colleges have succeeded in
opening access to all; if that access is limited to developmental
courses that offer primarily the same type of basic education that
failed the students in the lower schools, then students have been
cruelly denied access to higher learning.
Those who would impose standards for programs at any level
face difficulties stemming from lack of consensus on institutional
purpose, antagonism to the idea of group norms, and, in secondary
schools and community colleges, the inability to impose entrance
requirements. Selective screening into the transfer programs could
not be maintained in an earlier era because students demanded and
got the right to fail, and that contributed to the unconscionable
attrition figures of the 1970s. Selective admission into the collegiate
programs has been tried again because it is easier to screen students
out en bloc than to establish criteria for functional literacy course
by course. Yet unless those criteria are defined, selective admissions
will again be unsuccessful.
Reconciling the Dilemma
In any institution that takes a chance on marginal students the failure rate will be high relative to 100 percent success. But the
success rate will also be high relative to the 0 percent outcome
of not admitting them at all. The only issue is the cost. Three
options are available to colleges that would reconcile the conflict
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 262
262 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
between maintaining standards and allowing all students to enter
the programs of their choice. First, they can define the specific
competencies required to enter and succeed in each course. College
level, program proficiency, and academic standards are not sufficiently
precise. There is too much variation among courses in the same
program—indeed, among sections of the same course—for these
criteria to hold. Screening tests can be used at the point of entry
to each class. And precise exit criteria—also known as specific,
measurable objectives—can be set.
The second option is to allow all students to enroll in any course
but to limit the number of courses that poorly prepared students
can take in any term and to require that they take advantage of
the available support services. Thus, students might take only one
course at a time and participate in tutorial and learning-laboratory
sessions on the basis of two or three hours for each credit hour
attempted.
A third is to build freestanding developmental programs and
insist that all students designated as reading, writing, or computing
at a level precluding their passing college-level courses enroll
in them. These programs would emphasize study skills, directing
attention to the problems that kept the students from achieving in
their earlier schooling.
All three options are now employed to some extent. The colleges that rely on precisely specified measures of student progress
have built their programs on absolute standards. But these are in
a distinct minority. The many that monitor student progress and
insist that students participate in auxiliary instructional exercises
or developmental courses taught within the academic departments
have moved well toward building the kind of college-wide instructional effort that teaching poorly prepared students demands. But
the separate programs that concentrate exclusively on remedial
studies have become the most widespread, involving especially
trained instructors and judging success by the number of students
who pass through to the academic and occupational programs.
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 263
Developmental Education 263
They are effective only when they employ comprehensive efforts
complete with support services and connections with the colleges’
other programs. The freestanding remedial course is much less
likely to succeed.
At least two options are not acceptable: allowing sizable percentages of students to fail; and reducing academic standards so that
those who do get through have not been sufficiently well prepared
to succeed in the workplace or in further education. High failure
rates have led to numerous charges that the community colleges are
a dead end for many of their matriculants, especially minority students. By reducing standards, the colleges were merely pushing the
problem off to the students’ employers or the academic institutions
in which they subsequently enrolled. Since the 1980s, the numerous state mandates designed to improve student progress reflect a
decided unwillingness to allow either of those options to continue.
Issues
Whether the community colleges pick up the seventeen-year-olds
who have left high school early and whether they serve as a
bridge between schooling and work for their older students,
developmental education fits within their mission of connecting
people with opportunities. They will be involved in remedial
studies in one form or another, but several questions remain: Is
developmental education effective? How does it affect the college
staff? How can it be maintained without jeopardizing the college’s
standards and its legitimacy in higher education? How many
times should the public pay the schools to try to teach the same
competencies to the same people?
College staff need more information about the effects of the
developmental education in which they are so heavily engaged.
Do segregated remedial programs lead to higher standards in other
courses? Do the faculty members outside the programs add content
to the courses from which the underprepared students have been
Cohen, Arthur M., et al. The American Community College, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2013. ProQuest Ebook Central,
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/capella/detail.action?docID=1366278.
Created from capella on 2020-04-19 23:38:40. Copyright © 2013. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Cohen c08.tex V2 – 07/19/2013 9:40pm Page 264
264 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
removed? Do they pass students through the courses more rapidly
when they are relieved from having to wait for the students of
lesser ability? If so, all these results should be tabulated as benefits
of the separate programs. So far, studies of these effects have been
almost nonexistent.
Several attempts to engage instructors in defining the outcomes
of their courses in specific, measurable terms have failed. What
forms of staff development would be successful? What incentives
could be used?
Would allowing instructors to test the students who sought
entry to their classes and bar those who did not pass the test
suffice to encourage them to take responsibility for passing a
specified percentage? To date, they typically refuse, individually
and collectively, to be held accountable for results.
Required support services increase instructional costs. Can the
colleges find sufficient funds for the necessary tutors, counselors,
learning laboratory technicians, and paraprofessional instructional
aides?
Is it worthwhile to reexamine how applicable traditional
college-level standards are to various academic and career tracks?
For example, most developmental students in community colleges
are steered toward algebra-based remediation, as algebra or a
higher mathematics is often required for an associate degree. But
some colleges—most notably those in Texas—have questioned
whether developmental students not planning to enter mathor science-based fields would be better served by taking classes
in statistics or quantitative reasoning, which might prove more
relevant to their future careers and present less of a barrier in the
transition to credit-bearing courses.
The overriding issue is whether community colleges can maintain their credibility as institutions of higher education even while
they enroll increasingly less well-prepared students. If they can, they
will fulfill the promises of their earliest proponents. Regardless, the
United States is not going to abandon its functional illiterates, and
the community colleges are going to be involved in educating them.
The post A memo defending open access and open enrollment appeared first on Versed Writers.