Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

As a nation that executes prisoners, the United States is in poor company.

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length5,295 words
  • Reading time24 min
Write My Assignment FREE

As a nation that executes prisoners, the United States is in poor
company. Most countries that have the death penalty are terrible
violators of human rights. In 2017, only twenty-three countries performed executions, and the top executors were China, Iran, Saudi
Arabia, and Iraq. The United States carried out only twenty-five
executions in 2018. Most of the more than 2,700 death-row inmates
in America will never be put to death; they will die of natural causes.
Stephen B. Bright (1948–) believes that the United States
should and will get out of the execution business. Mr. Bright
teaches at Yale Law School, Georgetown, and Georgia State University College of Law.
The United States will inevitably join other industrialized nations in
abandoning the death penalty, just as it has abandoned whipping, the
stocks, branding, cutting off appendages, maiming, and other primitive
forms of punishment. It remains to be seen how long it will be until the
use of the death penalty becomes so infrequent as to be pointless, and it is
eventually abandoned. In the meantime, capital punishment is arbitrarily
Chapter 38
Why the United States Will
Join the Rest of the World in
Abandoning Capital Punishment
Stephen B. Bright
From Stephen B. Bright, “Why the United States Will Join the Rest of the World in Abandoning Capital Punishment” in Debating the Death Penalty: Should America Have Capital
Punishment? The Experts on Both Sides Make Their Case (Oxford: Oxford University Press,
2005), 152–182. Copyright © 2005 Oxford University Press. Used with permission.
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 411 17-06-2019 19:00:42
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
412 Chapter 38
and unfairly imposed, undermines the standing and moral authority of
the United States in the community of nations, and diminishes the credibility and legitimacy of the courts within the United States.
Although death may intuitively seem to be an appropriate punishment
for a person who kills another person and polls show strong support for
the death penalty, most Americans know little about realities of capital
punishment, past and present. The death penalty is a direct descendant
of the darkest aspects of American history—slavery, lynching, racial
oppression, and perfunctory capital trials known as “legal lynchings”—
and racial discrimination remains a prominent feature of capital punishment. The death penalty is not imposed to avenge every killing and—as
some contend—to bring “closure” to the family of every victim, but is
inflicted in less than 1 percent of all murder cases. Of more than 20,000
murders in the United States annually, an average of fewer than 300
people are sentenced to death, and only 55 are executed each year. Only
19 states actually carried out executions between 1976, when the U.S.
Supreme Court authorized the resumption of capital punishment after
declaring it unconstitutional in 1972, and the end of 2002. Eighty-six
percent of those executions were in the South. Just two states—Texas
and Virginia—carried out 45 percent of them.
Any assessment of the death penalty must not be based on abstract
theories about how it should work in practice or the experiences of
states like Oregon, which seldom impose the death penalty and carry it
out even less. To understand the realities of the death penalty, one must
look to the states that sentence people to death by the hundreds and
have carried out scores of executions. In those states, innocent people
have been sentenced to die based on such things as mistaken eyewitness identifications, false confessions, the testimony of partisan experts
who render opinions that are not supported by science, failure of police
and prosecutors to turn over evidence of innocence, and testimony of
prisoners who get their own charges dismissed by testifying that the
accused admitted the crime to them. Even the guilty are sentenced to
death as opposed to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole
not because they committed the worst crimes but because of where they
happen to be prosecuted, the incompetence of their court-appointed
lawyers, their race, or the race of their victim. . . .
Further experimentation with lethal punishment after centuries of
failure has no place in a conservative society that is wary of too much
government power and skeptical of the government’s ability to do
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 412 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
Abandoning Capital Punishment 413
things well. Further experimentation might be justified if it served some
purpose. But capital punishment is not needed to protect society or to
punish offenders, as shown by over 100 countries around the world that
do not have the death penalty and states such as Michigan and Wisconsin, neither of which have had the death penalty since the mid-1800s.
It can be argued that capital punishment was necessary when America
was a frontier society and had no prisons. But today the United States
has not only maximum security prisons, but “super maximum” prisons where serial killers, mass murderers, and sadistic murderers can
be severely punished and completely isolated from guards and other
inmates.
Nor is crime deterred by the executions in fewer than half the states
of an arbitrarily selected 1 percent of those who commit murders, many
of whom are mentally ill or have limited intellectual functioning. The
South, which has carried out 85 percent of the nation’s executions since
1976, has the highest murder rate of any region of the country. The
Northeast, which has the fewest executions by far—only 3 executions
between 1976 and the end of 2002—has the lowest murder rate.
The United States does not need to keep this relic of the past to show
its abhorrence of murder. As previously noted, 99 percent of the murders in the United States are not punished by death. Even at war crimes
trials in The Hague, genocide and other crimes against humanity are not
punished with the death penalty. The societies that do not have capital
punishment surely abhor murder as much as any other, but they do not
find it necessary to engage in killing in order to punish, protect, or show
their abhorrence with killing.
Finally, capital punishment has no place in a decent society that places
some practices, such as torture, off limits—not because some individuals have not done things so bad that they arguably deserved to be tortured, but because a civilized society simply does not engage in such
acts. It can be argued that rapists deserve to be raped, that mutilators
deserve to be mutilated. Most societies, however, refrain from responding in this way because the punishment is not only degrading to those on
whom it is imposed, but it is also degrading to the society that engages
in the same behavior as the criminals. When death sentences are carried
out, small groups of people gather in execution chambers and watch as
a human being is tied down and put down. Some make no effort to suppress their glee when the sentence is carried out and celebrations occur
inside and outside the prison. These celebrations of death reflect the dark
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 413 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
414 Chapter 38
side of the human spirit—an arrogant, vengeful, unforgiving, uncaring
side that either does not admit the possibility of innocence or redemption
or is willing to kill people despite those possibilities.
A HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATION THAT
UNDERMINES THE STANDING AND MORAL
AUTHORITY OF THE UNITED STATES
If people were asked 50 years ago which one of the following three countries—Russia, South Africa, or the United States—would be most likely
to have the death penalty at the turn of the century, few people would have
answered the United States. And yet, the United States was one of four
countries that accounted for 90 percent of all the executions in the world
in 2001 (the others were China, Iran, and Saudi Arabia), while Russia and
South Africa are among the nations that no longer practice capital punishment. Since 1985, over 40 countries have abandoned capital punishment
whereas only four countries that did not have it have adopted it. One of
those, Nepal, has since abolished it. Turkey abolished the death penalty in
2001 in its efforts to join the European Union, leaving the United States
the only NATO country that still has the death penalty. . . .
The retention of capital punishment in the United States draws harsh
criticism from throughout the world. . . . Capital punishment also affects
the United States’s relations with other countries in other ways. Canada
and Mexico have repeatedly protested when their nationals are executed
by the United States, as have other countries. Canada, Mexico, and most
European countries will not extradite suspects to the United States if they
are subject to capital punishment and will not assist in the prosecution of
people facing the death penalty. Just as the United States could not assert
moral leadership in the world as long as it allowed segregation, it will
not be a leader on human rights as long as it allows capital punishment.
ARBITRARY AND UNFAIR INFLICTION
Regardless of the practices of the rest of the world or the morality of
capital punishment, the process leading to a death sentence is so unfair
and influenced by so many improper factors and the infliction of death
sentences is so inconsistent that this punishment should be abandoned.
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 414 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
Abandoning Capital Punishment 415
The exoneration of many people who spent years of their lives in
prisons for crimes they did not commit—many of them on death row—
has dramatically brought to light defects in the criminal justice system
that have surprised and appalled people who do not observe the system
every day and assumed that it was working properly. The average person has little or no contact with the criminal courts, which deal primarily with crimes committed against and by poor people and members of
racial minorities. It is a system that is overworked and underfunded,
and particularly underfunded when it comes to protecting the rights of
those accused.
Law enforcement officers, usually overworked and often under tremendous public pressure to solve terrible crimes, make mistakes, fail
to pursue all lines of investigation, and, on occasion, overreach or take
shortcuts in pursuing arrests. Prosecutors exercise vast and unchecked
discretion in deciding which cases are to be prosecuted as capital cases.
The race of the victim and the defendant, political considerations, and
other extraneous factors influence whether prosecutors seek the death
penalty and whether juries or judges impose it.
A person facing the death penalty usually cannot afford to hire an
attorney and is at the mercy of the system to provide a court-appointed
lawyer. While many receive adequate representation (and often are not
sentenced to death as a result), many others are assigned lawyers who
lack the knowledge, skill, resources—and sometimes even the inclination—to handle a serious criminal case. People who would not be sentenced to death if properly represented are sentenced to death because
of incompetent court-appointed lawyers. In many communities, racial
minorities are still excluded from participation as jurors, judges, prosecutors, and lawyers in the system. In too many cases, defendants are
convicted on flimsy evidence, such as eyewitness identifications, which
are notoriously unreliable but are seen as very credible by juries; the
testimony of convicts who, in exchange for lenient treatment in their
own cases, testify that the accused admitted to them that he or she
committed the crime; and confessions obtained from people of limited
intellect through lengthy and overbearing interrogations.
. . . These are not minor, isolated incidents; they are long-standing,
pervasive, systemic deficiencies in the criminal justice system that are
not being corrected and, in some places, are even becoming worse. . . .
Law enforcement agencies have been unwilling to videotape interrogations and use identification procedures that are more reliable than those
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 415 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
416 Chapter 38
presently employed. People who support capital punishment as a concept are unwilling to spend millions of tax dollars to provide competent
legal representation for those accused of crimes. And courts have yet
to find ways to overcome centuries of racial discrimination that often
influence, consciously or subconsciously, the decisions of prosecutors,
judges, and juries.
A WARNING THAT SOMETHING
IS TERRIBLY WRONG: INNOCENT
PEOPLE CONDEMNED TO DEATH
Over 100 people condemned to death in the last 30 years have been
exonerated and released after new evidence established their innocence
or cast such doubt on their guilt that they could not be convicted. The
100th of those people, Ray Krone, was convicted and sentenced to
death in Arizona based on the testimony of an expert witness that his
teeth matched bite marks on the victim. During the ten years that Krone
spent on death row, scientists developed the ability to compare biological evidence recovered at crime scenes with the DNA of suspects. DNA
testing established that Krone was innocent. On Krone’s release, the
prosecutor said, “[Krone] deserves an apology from us, that’s for sure.
A mistake was made here. . . . What do you say to him? An injustice
was done and we will try to do better. And we’re sorry.” Although
unfortunate to be wrongfully convicted, Krone was very fortunate that
there was DNA evidence in his case. In most cases, there is no biological evidence for DNA testing.
Other defendants had their death sentences commuted to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole because of questions about
their innocence. For example, in 1994, the governor of Virginia commuted the death sentence of a mentally retarded man, Earl Washington,
to life imprisonment without parole because of questions regarding his
guilt. Washington, an easily persuaded, somewhat childlike specialeducation dropout, had been convicted of murder and rape based on a
confession he gave to police, even though it was full of inconsistencies.
For example, at one point in the confession Washington said that the
victim was white and at another that the victim was black. Six years
later, DNA evidence—not available at the time of Washington’s trial
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 416 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
Abandoning Capital Punishment 417
or the commutation—established that Washington was innocent and he
was released.
Although DNA testing has been available only in cases where there
was biological evidence and the evidence has been preserved, it has
established the innocence of many people who were not sentenced to
death. A Michigan judge in 1984 lamented the fact that the state did not
have the death penalty, saying that life imprisonment was inadequate
for Eddie Joe Lloyd for the rape and murder of a 16-year-old girl. Police
had obtained a confession from Lloyd while he was in a mental hospital. Seventeen years later, DNA evidence established that Lloyd did not
commit the crime. On his release, Lloyd commented, “If Michigan had
the death penalty, I would have been through, the angels would have
sung a long time ago.”
Sometimes evidence of innocence has surfaced only at the last minute. Anthony Porter, sentenced to death in Illinois, went through all the
appeals and review that are available for one so sentenced. Every court
upheld his conviction and sentence. As Illinois prepared to put him to
death, a question arose as to whether Porter, who was brain damaged
and mentally retarded, understood what was happening to him. A person who lacks the mental ability to understand that he is being put to
death in punishment for a crime cannot be executed unless he is treated
and becomes capable of understanding why he is being executed. Just
two days before Porter was to be executed, a court stayed his execution
in order to examine his mental condition. After the stay was granted,
a journalism class at Northwestern University and a private investigator examined the case and proved that Anthony Porter was innocent.
They obtained a confession from the person who committed the crime.
Anthony Porter was released, becoming the third person released from
Illinois’s death row after being proven innocent by a journalism class
at Northwestern.
Some people have been executed despite questions of their innocence. Gary Graham was sentenced to death in Texas based on the identification of a witness who said she saw a murder from 40 feet away.
Studies have demonstrated that such identifications are often unreliable.
But Graham had the misfortune to be assigned a notoriously incompetent lawyer, Ron Mock, who had so many clients sentenced to death
that some refer to the “Mock Wing” of death row. Mock failed to seriously contest the state’s case, conduct an independent investigation, and
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 417 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
418 Chapter 38
present witnesses at the scene who would have testified that Graham
was not the person who committed the crime and that the perpetrator
was much shorter than Graham. Although it was apparent that Graham
did not receive a fair trial and adequate legal representation, he was
executed by Texas in 2000. Whether Graham was innocent or guilty
will never be resolved because in his case, like most others, there was
no DNA evidence that would conclusively establish guilt or innocence.
Some proponents of capital punishment argue that the exoneration
of Porter and others shows that the system works and that no innocent
people have been executed. However, someone spending years on
death row for a crime he did not commit is not an example of the system working. When journalism students prove that police, prosecutors,
judges, defense lawyers, and the entire legal system failed to discover
the perpetrator of a crime and instead condemned the wrong person to
die, the system is not working. Porter and others were spared, as Chief
Justice Moses Harrison of the Illinois Supreme Court observed, “only
because of luck and the dedication of the attorneys, reporters, family
members and volunteers who labored to win their release. They survived despite the criminal justice system, not because of it. . . .”
. . . Courts will always be fallible and reversible, while death will
always be final and irreversible.
THE TWO MOST IMPORTANT
DECISIONS—MADE BY PROSECUTORS
The two most important decisions in every death penalty case are made
not by juries or judges, but by prosecutors. No state or federal law ever
requires prosecutors to seek the death penalty or take a capital case to
trial. A prosecutor has complete discretion in deciding whether to seek
the death penalty and, even if death is sought, whether to offer a sentence less than death in exchange for the defendant’s guilty plea. The
overwhelming majority of all criminal cases, including capital cases,
are resolved not by trials but by plea bargains. Whether death is sought
or imposed is based on the discretion and proclivities of the thousands
of people who occupy the offices of prosecutor in judicial districts
throughout the nation. . . . Some prosecutors seek the death penalty at
every opportunity, and others never seek it; some seldom seek it; some
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 418 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
Abandoning Capital Punishment 419
frequently seek it. There is no requirement that individual prosecutors—who, in most states, are elected by districts—be consistent in their
practices in seeking the death penalty.
As a result of this discretion, there are great geographical disparities in where death is imposed within states. Prosecutors in Houston
and Philadelphia have sought the death penalty in virtually every case
in which it can be imposed. As a result of aggressive prosecutors and
inept court-appointed lawyers, Houston and Philadelphia have each
condemned over 100 people to death—more than most states. Harris
County, which includes Houston, has had more executions in the last
30 years than any state except Texas and Virginia. . . .
Whether death is sought may depend on the side of the county line
where the crime was committed. A murder was committed in a parking
lot that contained the boundary between Lexington County, South Carolina, which at the time had sentenced 12 people to death, and Richland
County, which had sent only one person to death row. The crime was
determined to have occurred a few feet on the Lexington County side of
the line. The defendant was tried in Lexington County and sentenced to
death. Had the crime occurred a few feet in the other direction, the death
penalty almost certainly would not have been imposed. . . .
Thus, whether the death sentence is imposed may depend more on
the personal predilections and politics of local prosecutors than the heinousness of the crime or the incorrigibility of the defendant.
The Role of Racial Bias
The complete discretion given to prosecutors in deciding whether
to seek the death penalty and whether to drop the death penalty in
exchange for guilty pleas also contributes to racial disparities in the
infliction of the death penalty. In the 38 states that have the death penalty, 97.5 percent of the chief prosecutors are white. In 18 of the states,
all of the chief prosecutors are white. Even the most conscientious
prosecutors who have had little experience with people of other races
may be influenced in their decisions by racial stereotypes and attitudes
they have developed over their lives.
But the rest of the criminal justice system is almost as unrepresentative of Americans’ racial diversity as prosecutors’ offices. In the South,
where the death penalty is most often imposed and carried out, over
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 419 17-06-2019 19:00:43
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
420 Chapter 38
half the victims of crime are people of color, well over 60 percent of
the prison population is made up of people of color, and half of those
sentenced to death are members of racial minorities. Yet people of color
are seldom involved as judges, jurors, prosecutors, and lawyers in the
courts. . . .
Although African Americans constitute only 12 percent of the
national population, they are victims of half the murders that are committed in the United States. Yet 80 percent of those on death row were
convicted of crimes against white people. The discrepancy is even
greater in the Death Belt states of the South. In Georgia and Alabama,
for example, African Americans are the victims of 65 percent of the
homicides, yet 80 percent of those on death row are there for crimes
against white persons. . . .
Study after study has confirmed what lawyers practicing in the criminal courts observe every day: People of color are treated more harshly
than white people. A person of color is more likely than a white person
to be stopped by the police, to be abused by the police during that stop,
to be arrested, to be denied bail when taken to court, to be charged with
a serious crime as opposed to a less serious one that could be charged,
to be convicted, and to receive a harsher sentence. But a person of color
is much less likely to be a participant in the criminal justice system as
a judge, juror, prosecutor, or lawyer.
It would be quite remarkable if race affected every aspect of the
criminal justice system except with regard to the death penalty—the
area in which decision makers have the broadest discretion and base
their decisions on evidence with tremendous emotional impact. The sad
reality is that race continues to influence who is sentenced to death as it
has throughout American history.
The Death Sentence for Being Assigned
the Worst Lawyer
Capital cases—complex cases with the highest stakes of any in the
legal system—should be handled by the most capable lawyers, with
the resources to conduct thorough investigations and consult with various experts on everything from the prosecution’s scientific evidence to
psychologists and psychiatrists to investigate the defendant’s mental
health. The right to counsel is the most fundamental constitutional right
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 420 17-06-2019 19:00:44
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
Abandoning Capital Punishment 421
of a person charged with a crime. A person accused of a crime depends
on a lawyer to investigate the prosecution’s case; to present any facts
that may be helpful to the accused and necessary for a fair and reliable
determination of guilt or innocence and, if guilty, a proper sentence;
and to protect every other right of the accused. However, U.S. Supreme
Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg observed in 2001 that she had “yet
to see a death case among the dozens coming to the Supreme Court . . .
in which the defendant was well represented at trial. People who are
well represented at trial do not get the death penalty.”
Those receiving the death penalty are not well represented because
many states do not provide the structure, resources, independence, and
accountability that is required to insure competent representation in an
area of such specialization. . . .
In states with no public defender offices, lawyers in private practice
are assigned to defend capital cases and paid well below market rates.
Lawyers, like many people, are attracted to work that pays well. Few
lawyers are willing to take the most difficult and emotionally demanding cases with the highest stakes for wages that are among the lowest
in the legal profession. A paralegal who works on a federal bankruptcy
case is compensated at a higher hourly rate than a lawyer who defends a
capital case in Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi, Virginia, and many other
states that send many people to death row. . . .
In several states where journalists have investigated—Illinois, Kentucky, Tennessee, and Texas—they have found that a fourth to a third of
those sentenced to death were represented at their trials by lawyers who
were later disbarred, suspended, or convicted of crimes. . . .
Many courts continue to operate on the fiction that anyone licensed
to practice law—even someone whose practice is mostly real estate or
divorce law—is competent to handle capital cases. This is like saying
that every doctor is competent to do brain surgery. . . .
Justice Hugo Black wrote for the U.S. Supreme Court in 1956 that
“[t]here can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a [person] gets
depends on the amount of money he [or she] has.” But today, no one
seriously doubts that the kind of trial, and the kind of justice, a person
receives depends very much on the amount of money he or she has.
The quality of legal representation tolerated by some courts shocks the
conscience of a person of average sensibilities. But poor representation
resulting from lack of funding and structure has been accepted as the
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 421 17-06-2019 19:00:44
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
422 Chapter 38
best that can be done with the limited resources available. The commitment of many states to providing lawyers for those who cannot afford
them was aptly described by a Chief Justice of the Georgia Supreme
Court: “[W]e set our sights on the embarrassing target of mediocrity.
I guess that means about halfway. And that raises a question. Are we
willing to put up with halfway justice? To my way of thinking, one-half
justice must mean one-half injustice, and one-half injustice is no justice
at all.”
The proponents of capital punishment are always quick to say that
people facing the death penalty should receive better legal representation. But they do not explain how this is going to be accomplished—
whether by a sudden burst of altruism on the part of members of the
legal profession, who are going to suddenly start taking capital cases for
a fraction of what they can make doing other work; a massive infusion
of funding from state legislatures that are searching for revenue for education, transportation, and other areas that have a constituency; or some
other miracle. The right to competent representation is celebrated in the
abstract, but most states—and most supporters of capital punishment—
are unwilling to pay for it. As a result the death penalty will continue
to be imposed not upon those who commit the worst crimes, but upon
those who have the misfortune to be assigned the worst lawyers. . . .
CONCLUSION
. . . We should have the humility to admit that the legal system is not
infallible and that mistakes are made. We should have the honesty to
admit that our society is unwilling to pay the price of providing every
poor person with competent legal representation, even in capital cases.
We should have the courage to acknowledge the role that race plays in
the criminal justice system and make a commitment to do something
about it instead of pretending that racial prejudice no longer exists. And
we should have the compassion and decency to recognize the dignity of
every person, even those who have offended us most grievously. The
Constitutional Court of South Africa addressed many of these issues in
deciding whether the death penalty violated that country’s constitution.
Despite a staggering crime rate and a long history of racial violence
and oppression, the Court unanimously concluded that in a society in
Rachels & Rachels_9781538127926.indb 422 17-06-2019 19:00:44
Rachels, J., & Rachels, S. (Eds.). (2019). The right thing to do : Readings in moral philosophy. Retrieved from
http://ebookcentral.proquest.com
Created from newschoolarch-ebooks on 2020-04-23 14:04:16. Copyright © 2019. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. All rights reserved.
Abandoning Capital Punishment 423
transition from hatred to understanding, from vengeance to reconciliation, there was no place for the death penalty. The American people
will ultimately reach the same conclusion, deciding that, like slavery
and segregation, the death penalty is a relic of another era, and that this
society of such vast wealth is capable of more constructive approaches
to crime. And the United States will join the rest of the civilized world
in abandoning capital punishment.

The post As a nation that executes prisoners, the United States is in poor company. appeared first on Versed Writers.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order