How to Brief a Case Opinion Using the “IRAC” Method
When briefing a case, your goal is to reduce the information from the case into a
format that will provide you with a helpful reference in class and for review. Most
importantly, by “briefing” a case, you will grasp the problem the court faced (the
issue); the relevant law the court used to solve it (the rule); how the court applied the
rule to the facts (the application or “analysis”); and the outcome (the conclusion). You
will then be ready to not only discuss the case, but to compare and contrast it to other
cases involving a similar issue.
Before attempting to “brief” a case, read the case at least once.
Follow the “IRAC” method in briefing cases. The following explains the sections of the
Template you are provided.
Facts
Write a brief summary of the facts as the court found them to be. Eliminate facts that
are not relevant to the court’s analysis. For example, a business’s street address is
probably not relevant to the court’s decision of the issue of whether the business
that sold a defective product is liable for the resulting injuries to the plaintiff.
However, suppose a customer who was assaulted as she left its store is suing the
business. The customer claims that her injuries were the reasonably foreseeable result
of the business’s failure to provide security patrols. If the business is located in an
upscale neighborhood, then perhaps it could argue that its failure to provide security
patrols is reasonable. If the business is located in a crime-ridden area, then perhaps
the customer is right. Instead of including the street address in the case brief, you may
want to simply describe the type of neighborhood in which it is located. (Note: the
time of day would be another relevant factor in this case, among others).
Procedural History
List the court of the current opinion and date of opinion AND the lower courts, their
rulings and dates. This is a listing, not a long narrative.
Issue
This is stated as a succinct statement or question. What is the question presented to the
court? Usually, only one issue will be discussed, but sometimes there will be more.
What are the parties fighting about, and what are they asking the court to decide? For
example, in the case of the assaulted customer, the issue for a trial court to decide
might be: whether the business had a duty to the customer to provide security patrols?
Rule(s):
Determine what the relevant rules of law are that the court uses to make its decision.
These rules will be identified and discussed by the court. For example, in the case of
the assaulted customer, the relevant rule of law is that a property owner’s duty to
prevent harm to invitees is determined by balancing the foreseeability of the harm
against the burden of preventive measures. There may be more than one relevant rule
of law to a case: for example, in a negligence case in which the defendant argues that
the plaintiff assumed the risk of harm, the relevant rules of law could be the elements
of negligence, and the definition of “assumption of risk” as a defense. Don’t just simply
list the cause of action, such as “negligence” as a rule of law: What rule must the court
apply to the facts to determine the outcome? This is a simple statement or list, not a long
narrative.
Application/Analysis:
This is the most important portion of the brief. The court will have examined the facts
in light of the rule, and probably considered all “sides” and arguments presented to it.
How did the court apply the rule(s) to the facts and analyze the case to reach its decision?
What did the court consider to be a relevant fact given the rule of law? How did the
court interpret the rule: for example, did the court consider monetary costs of providing
security patrols in weighing the burden of preventive measures? Did the court imply that
if a business is in a dangerous area, then it should be willing to bear a higher cost for
security? Resist the temptation to merely repeat what the court said in analyzing the
facts: what does it mean to you? Summarize the court’s rationale in your own words.
If you encounter a word that you do not know, use a dictionary to find its meaning.
Conclusion:
What was the final outcome of the case? In one or two sentences, state the court’s
ultimate finding of the case. This is NOT “plaintiff won.” It is the key principle that
comes out of the case. For example, in the case of the assault, the conclusion might be:
“The court ruled that the business did not owe the assaulted customer a duty to provide
security patrols.”
Dissenting Opinion.
Is there a dissenting opinion(s) in an appeals case? For the Supreme Court especially, the
dissenting view can be an important indicator of the key issues of the case and even a
predictor of future cases that the court might hear. Briefly summarize the dissent’s
position, if there is one, in your own words, and consider the implication of the dissent’s
view.
Note: “Case briefing” helps understand a court opinion and is a skill that is
honed with practice. This exercise gives you an opportunity to practice and
enhance your understanding of reading and using court cases in your coursework and in
business.
The post Case Opinion Using the “IRAC” Method appeared first on My Assignment Online.