Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics.
1
Introduction
“Over a 10-year period we have totally transformed our outlook, our resources and our prospects.
From being an inward-looking manufacturing company, we have become a customer-focused,
integrated service provider. From a large commodity supplier, we have become known for our valueadded and innovative designs. Most importantly, our performance as a company has been little short
of spectacular, and I see no reason why we cannot continue on this upward path [table 5.1]. I know
that the Group board is very impressed with our achievements and uses this subsidiary as its best
example of successful innovation.”
Table 5.1 ATS Selected financial information.
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Fixed Assets 3366 3312 2394 2520 3672 5028 5880
Plant & equipment 612 780 1020 1080 1920 3504 3720
Moulds
Total 3978 4092 3414 3600 5592 8532 9600
Current Assets 2898 4464 5052 4902 7926 5778 8238
Debtors Inventory 1572 3516 6174 7554 9354 13458 15402
Total 4470 7980 11226 12456 17280 19236 23640
Total Assets 8448 12072 14640 16056 22872 27768 33240
Financed by;
Share capital retained 300 300 300 300 300 300 300
Profits 1680 3180 4920 5280 6720 10560 15960
Loans from Group 2700 2520 3180 3420 4980 4740 2940
Total 4680 6000 8400 9000 12000 15600 19200
Current liabilities 3756 3192 3768 6804 10644 10464 10590
Creditors bank 12 2880 2472 252 228 1704 3450
Total 3768 6072 6240 7056 10872 12168 14040
Total Liabilities 8448 12072 14640 16056 22872 27768 33240
Sales and profits
Net Sales 15132 17232 25272 26796 30648 32364 48126
Net profits before tax 876 1110 1644 2172 3372 4248 6300
Sales by market
Industrial Focus 3020 17232 18450 17480 15560 13244 13066
Home-ware Brouge & 12112 0 6822 9316 15088 19120 32420
Design House Brouge 0 0 0 0 0 0 2640
Office
Total 15132 17232 25272 26796 30648 32364 48126
All figures in In PKR Million
Abdullah Khan, the CEO of ATS Synthetic & Plastics (ATS), knew his confidence was shared by his
colleagues. After all, ATS was believed to be one of Pakistan’s most profitable plastic household
products (home-ware) businesses. Originally founded in the 1960s as Focus Plastics, the company’s
growth had come initially from the manufacture of complex injection-moulded plastic components
for large industrial customers. Following the acquisition of the company by a large consumer
products group, it had rapidly extended its range to include popular household items such as washing
up bowls, pedal bins, baby baths, buckets and dustpans. These were sold under the Focus brand
name, initially through wholesale distributors and then increasingly to large national stores. By the
Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics.
2
early 2000s the home-ware business had grown to account for over 80% of turnover, which had itself
more than doubled in 10 years. Additional large injection-moulding machines had been purchased to
cope with the rapidly growing volumes of products. These machines provided many economies of
scale that enabled the company to compete aggressively in a market where barriers to entry were
low. However, competition was increasing, mainly from small, specialised manufacturers with low
overheads. The range of products supplied by these companies was often quite limited (just buckets
and bowls, for example), largely because of the high costs of moulds, which would be up to PKR 50
million each.
The products
By 2008 the company produced around 200 home-ware stock –keeping units (SKUs) and had
developed a reputation as a reliable source of supply of consistently high-quality products. It was then
decided to withdraw from the complex and cyclical industrial mouldings market in order to
concentrate on developing the more profitable household products business. Abdullah Khan
explained:
“We recognised that the industrial markets were becoming more difficult and much less profitable. In
the large white goods and automotive markets, order sizes (and therefore batch sizes) were getting
smaller, and we were also losing some larger contracts as production moved abroad. Basically, many
of our industrial customers were just too hard to do business with. They were always changing their
schedules, and at the same time they would not guarantee long term continuity of business. In the
end, we decided that the industrial business did not fit well and was particularly difficult to plan and
control alongside household products. Even in the Sales Office, it was felt that the commercial
relationships with household product wholesalers and National Stores were clearer and under
control, whereas business with the industrial customers was unpredictable and unstable. Schedule
changes in quantity and delivery date were an everyday occurrence that disrupted the office and
caused most internal communication problems. So, by 2011 all our industrial business had been
terminated. But our decision to concentrate on one, relatively new market was recognised as
carrying risks, and we were determined to differentiate ourselves from competitors. There were some
very competent, smaller manufacturers that could compete in some of the volume business by
undercutting our prices, not least because our overheads were higher than theirs! We were using the
latest, precision equipment, bought the best quality moulds, and generally positioned ourselves as
“technical professionals with a customer focused service”. We knew that we had to exploit these
differences, and that we would have to look for new markets that would really value our capabilities.”
Market Positioning
Sania Mirza, ATS’s Marketing Director, joined the company in the early 2000s, having previously
worked in a senior marketing role for a large retail chain of paint and wallpaper retailers.
“Experience in the decorative products industry had taught me that importance of fashion, even in
mundane products such as paint. Premium priced colours and textures would become popular for
one or two years, supported by appropriate promotion and features in lifestyle magazines. Two years
later they would look old fashioned and people who care about their surroundings would redecorate
individual rooms or even the whole house. The manufacturers and retailers which created and
supported these fashion trends were dramatically more profitable than those who simply provided
standard ranges. Instinctively, I felt that this must also apply to plastic home wares. At ATS, we
decided to develop a whole coordinated range of such items, and to open up a new distribution
network for them to directly serve individual up market stores, kitchen equipment shops and
speciality retailers throughout Pakistan & Expand to Middle Eastern & Northern African Market
(MENA).
Our first new range of kitchen items was launched in 2002, under the “Brouge” brand name. Within
one year, we had over 1,000 retail outlets signed up, and provided each with point of sale display
facilities and high-quality brochures. Illustrated feature articles in well-targeted magazines and
newspapers generated an enormous interest from the public, which was reinforced by the use of our
products on several TV cookery programmes. Within one year we had developed an entirely new
market! It was at this time that we changed the name of the company to reinforce our change of
Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics.
3
direction. “Brouge” now provides over 70% of our revenue and the bulk of our profits. The prices and
margins that we can achieve with Brouge are many times higher than for the Focus range, so we have
proved that the market appreciates the value inherent in our designs. We quickly learned that the
retailers liked the idea of a coordinated range of items. Customers could buy a few items to start a
collection, and progressively add to this. Our research indicated that some customers kept our
product on display in their kitchens as objects of beauty, or even as tokens of symbols of their
lifestyle, rather than hiding them away in cupboards. We exploited this idea in our advertising and
guarantee to supply retailers any item in any colour for at least four years. To keep ahead, we
continue to launch new ranges and colours at regular intervals. We now have the most
comprehensive range of designer items in the market; there are now six separate style ranges, and
many of these are offered in up to 12 contemporary colours. The Brouge ranges are highly profitable,
both for us and for the many thousands of retailers throughout Europe that stock our products.
In contrast to the success of Brouge, we now clearly understand that many of the Focus products
have effectively become commodities, as numerous competitors have gradually eroded market
prices. Supply Services continues to provide a basic support to Focus customers in terms of routine
order processing and production planning, whilst our Sales activity is largely confined to annual
bidding for large contracts. I certainly intend that we should continue to replace this declining, lowmargin Focus business with the exciting new Brouge ranges and other growth opportunities that we
have identified.
In addition to continuing development of Brouge, over the last two years we have been designing,
manufacturing and distributing products for some of the most prestigious design houses. This sort of
business is likely to grow, especially in MENA where the design houses now appreciate our ability to
offer a full service. We can develop products in conjunction with their own design staff and offer
them a level of manufacturing expertise they can’t get elsewhere. Most significantly, we can offer
MENA-wide distribution service that is tailored to their needs. From the customer’s point of view, the
distribution arrangements appear to belong to the design house itself. In reality, they are based
exclusively on our own call-centre, warehouse and distribution resources.”
Manufacturing operations
All manufacturing was carried out in a large, leased, modern facility, which was located approximately
20km from the Head Office in outskirts of Lahore. The factory had areas for receiving and holding raw
materials, and the moulding area included 24 large injection moulding machines. The most recent
had automated robotic devices to remove finished products from the machines and to place them on
conveyors leading to the packing area. Adjacent to the moulding area was a large tool store with a
capacity to store about 200 moulds on racks, and a small mould repair section with skilled craftsmen.
Products, and individual components of products, were moved to the packing area, where they were
assembled and/or labelled (where required), inspected, packed in bags or cartons and palletised.
Finished goods were then taken to an adjacent large, Narrow-aisle ware-house with high-level racking
and special forklift machines. In one corner was an order-assembly and dispatch bay, with a platform
access to load delivery vehicles. Hakeem Khanzada, the Operations Manager, described the
development of these facilities over the preceding decade:
“The move away from industrial products allowed us to dispose of most of the older, more inefficient,
and smaller injection-moulding machines. Having only larger machines now allows us to use large
multi-cavity moulds. This increases productivity by allowing us to produce several products, or
components, each machine cycle. It also allows us to use high quality and complex moulds which,
although cumbersome and more difficult to change over, give a very high-quality product. For
example, it would have taken the same labour and machine time to make 3 items per minute on the
old machines as 18 per minute on the large modern machines with a 6-cavity mould. That’s a 600%
increase in productivity! We are also proud that we achieve such high dimensional accuracy, excellent
surface finish, and extreme consistency of colour required for the Brouge products. We can achieve
all this because of our expertise derived from years in the technically-demanding industrial markets.
The end product quality is second to none, and extensive benchmarking studies carried out by some
of our customers have confirmed our superiority in quality conformance. By standardising on single
Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics.
4
large machines, any mould can fit any machine. This is an idea situation from a planning perspective,
as we are often asked to make a run of Brouge products at short notice on the next machine to
become available. This standardization has also enabled us to carry a complete range of spare parts
for the machines, and the maintenance staff has become very skilled in caring for this specific size and
type of machine.”
Supply Services
The Supply Services Department of the company was regarded as being at the heart of the company’s
customer service drive. Its purpose was to integrate the efforts of design, manufacturing and sales.
Essentially it had two functions: firstly, to plan and schedule production in order to maintain
appropriate inventory availability, and secondly to plan the distribution of products from the
warehouse to customers. Anaya Khan, the Supply Services Planning Manager, was responsible for the
scheduling of all manufacturing and distribution of products from the warehouse to customers. Anaya
Khan, the Supply Services Planning Manager, was responsible for the scheduling of all manufacturing
and distribution and for maintaining inventory levels for all the warehoused items. Supported by
three other staff, she also prepared performance reports, monitoring the utilisation of equipment,
output rates for each product and scrap rates. Although the organisation chart showed Anaya Khan
reporting directly to Marketing, Sania Mirza did not often feel the need to intervene in the day-to-day
workings of the department, preferring to concentrate on the more innovation orientated activities of
the Marketing Department. This relative autonomy allowed Anaya to optimise the planning
throughout the internal Supply Chain.
“We try to establish a preferred sequence of production of each machine and mould. To minimise setup times, we plan for each mould to start on a light colour, and progress through a sequence to the
darkest. In this way we can change colours in around 15 minutes, with relatively small amounts of
waste. Because our multi-cavity moulds are large and technically complex, mould changes take
around three to four hours, so careful scheduling is important to maintain utilisation. The factory is
usually not scheduled for weekend production, and maintenance is usually performed on Saturday
mornings. Over recent years the general reduction in batch size has unfortunately brought down
average utilization, but with the wider product range, now at about 2500 SKUs, this was somewhat
inevitable. However, our pick rate, which measures the availability of finished goods inventory, has
been maintained at around 92%. This means that, on average, there is one in twelve chances of us not
being able to supply any one SKU from stock. I know that Sania would like us to reach 100%, but there
is always some constraint that prevents us achieving higher availability. At the moment that
constraint is warehouse space.
Everything would be fine if we were able to stick to schedules, but short-term unplanned changes
seem to be occurring more frequently than ever before. For example, last Monday we have an urgent
request from Sales to produce a run of 500 rainforest-green pasta strainers because of unexpected
demand levels. This involved complete re-scheduling. Ideally, we would like some stability, but the
market is dynamic and continual schedule changes affect utilisation, efficiency and scrap rates.
Certainly better marketing forecasts would help… but even our own promotions are sometimes
organised at such short notice that we often get caught with stockouts. Although Focus products
have relatively stable volumes, the Brouge products are much more seasonal, which makes capacity
planning and scheduling very difficult at peak times around Holiday Season.
At the same time, I have to schedule production time for new product mould trials; we normally
allow three shifts (24 hours) for the testing of each new mould received, and this has to be done on
production machines. From my perspective, it is often a difficult choice whether to schedule products
that are needed urgently or mould trials for new product launches with are equally urgent.”
Supply Services had become a large and strategically important part of the company. It maintained its
own fleet of medium and small distribution vehicles for the Pakistan market, but mainly used
international parcel carriers for the MENA market. In the Pakistan market a standard delivery
timetable was used, delivering once or twice a week depending on the area. In addition, an express
delivery service was offered for those customers prepared to pay a small delivery premium. However,
a recent study had shown that almost 40% of express deliveries were initiated by the company rather
Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics.
5
than by customers. Often this would be to fulfil follow up deliveries of orders containing production
out of stock at the time of ordering. The express delivery service was not normally required for Focus
products. Anaya Khan explained some of the issues faced by her department;
“Most of our time is spent planning the production and delivery schedules for Brouge products, which
involves a vast range of moulded parts, bought-in components, packaging, and finished goods. In
contrast, the Focus planning is relatively straightforward, since the product range is simpler, and the
vast majority of deliveries are to a small number of important customers. The size of each Focus order
is usually very large, usually with regular call-offs and deliveries to customers’ own distribution
depots. Although the organisation of Focus products is straightforward, the consequences of failure
are large. If we cannot fulfil an order, and therefore miss a delivery slot, we are inevitably upsetting a
very large, powerful customer. My job is to ensure that we satisfy all our customers!”
New product development
Hakeem Khanzada explained the new product development process:
“We receive detailed drawings of the new products from the Design Office, which is managed by
Marketing. The Brouge and “design house” products are often high precision, complicated objects,
each of which represents its own technical challenges. However, we pride ourselves on our ability to
overcome the technical and quality problems and, when we have decided on the basic mould
requirements; orders are placed with our preferred mould makers, located in South Korea. Not only
do these suppliers offer the highest standards of mould quality, but they are also significantly cheaper
than comparable European mould makers. It usually takes around 4 to 5 months to get a new mould,
which then has to be tested on our production machines. At the scheduled time, we fix the mould
into a machine and undertake trials until we get a perfect quality output. These then become the
operating parameters and are recorded for future use. This whole process can take up to 24 hours, so
we sometimes miss a night’s sleep if there is an important trial in progress!
The operators are as keen as we are to get the cycle times as fast as possible, since their bonus
payments are based on good output. We make it easy for them by getting the settings right from the
outset, but I’m afraid they don’t all appreciate that. Sometimes, several operators spend most of a
shift involved with normal production setups and argue that they could have made more bonus wages
on production. There is always a bit of tension here, but I still believe that we must continue to link
wages and output if we are to retain our excellent record of productivity!”
Latest developments
The “Brouge Office” brand had been introduced in late 2010 and was perceived as a very successful
entry into a new market, employing many of the marketing ideas developed with the Brouge
household range. Brouge Office items comprised filing trays, storage boxes and a range of desk items
– all innovatively styles and in seasonal colours. Users were encouraged to change the colour in use
every season to provide variety in drab, open-plan offices. Brouge Office branded products were sold
through specialist office equipment contractors and retailers. Abdullah Khan, the CEO summed up his
view of the current situation;
“Our alliances with several Italian and German design houses have been a particularly significant
recent development for ATS. In effect, we are positioning ourselves as a complete service partner to
the designers. We have a well-developed design capability ourselves, together with manufacturing,
order processing, and order taking and distribution services. These abilities allow us to develop
genuinely equal partnerships that integrate us into the whole industry’s activities.”
Sania Mirza also saw an increasing role for collaborative arrangements;
“It may be that we are seeing a fundamental change in how we do business within our industry. We
have always seen ourselves primarily a company which satisfies end consumer desires by providing
good service to retailers. The new partnership arrangements put us more into the “business to
business” sector. I don’t have any problem with this in principle, but I’m a little anxious as to how
much it gets us into areas of business beyond our core expertise.”
Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics.
6
The actual and prospective partnership deals fell into two broad categories, which are explained
below.
Design house collaborations – Some years ago, ATS had forged several partnerships with South
Korean design houses, the most successful of which was with a famous company of modest designers.
Generally it was the company’s existing design expertise which was attractive to design-house
partners. Not only did ATS employ professionally respected designers but they had also acquired a
reputation for being able to translate the most difficult technical designs into manufactureable and
saleable products. Design house partnerships usually involved relatively long lead times but produced
unique products with very high margins, nearly always carrying the design house’s brand. Sania Mirza
was enthusiastic about these developments.
“This type of joint venture relationship plays to our strengths. Our design expertise gains us entry to
the partnership; we are soon valued equally for our marketing, distribution and manufacturing
competences. We gain access to the latest design philosophies, ideas and market research, along with
the rights to use their leading designer brand names. In return, they get a good royalty payment and
access to our unique capabilities. It is certainly a win-win arrangement which is unique to the
industry.
Major retailer services – This type of collaboration involved ATS taking responsibility for the whole
category of plastic home wares for a large supermarket groups. It involved having access to the
retailer’s sophisticated sales data systems and, based on this data, deciding what each store should
have on its shelves. The product ranges supplied were not particularly adventurous in their design or
colours but were clearly in the “Brouge” style and often carried the Brouge brand. Where
appropriate, competitors’ products and the Focus range could be included where they filled gaps in
ATS’s ranges. Sania Mirza explained more about these category management services.
“Broadly speaking, the supermarkets do not seem to be as sophisticated in their non-food buying as
they are in food products. In effect, they have handed over part of the responsibility to us and trust us
to supply ranges or products which are appropriate for their customers overall but, to some degree,
selected to be appropriate for their individual stores. Their objective is invariably to use us to extract
the best profitability from the category, particularly in terms of profit per square metre of shelf space.
So far, this is working reasonably well, although the real costs of understanding their sales data are
probably higher than we realise.
The post Case Study; ATS Synthetic & Plastics. appeared first on My Assignment Online.