Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

Chapter 3 Genetic Control

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length2,507 words
  • Reading time11 min
Write My Assignment FREE

Prenatal Genetic Testing
Prenatal genetic screening tests — such as first trimester
screening or the quad screen — involve a blood sample from
the mother and, for first trimester screening, an ultrasound to
measure the amount of fluid in the tissue at the back of the
baby’s neck. These tests don’t pose any risks for your health or
your baby’s health. However, they can only tell you if the risk
of Down syndrome or certain other conditions is higher than
normal. They can’t tell you with certainty if your baby does or
doesn’t have a chromosomal disorder. That requires invasive
testing, such as amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling —
both of which carry a slight risk of pregnancy loss. A new
blood test for Down syndrome is now available in some areas,
but a positive result still requires confirmation by
amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling.

Challenge of genetic control
It’s long been known that who we are depends in part on our
environment and in part on our parents. This old and familiar idea
was given greater clarity and precision with the discovery of DNA as
the chemical basis of heredity.
This increased understanding also took a practical turn: within
limits, we are better able to test for the genetic factors underlying
diseases and even non-disease traits.
Newfound knowledge and ability can result in new ethical questions.
The increased understanding of genetics, and in particular, of the
ability to test for particular genes, has resulted in a set of ethical
questions, some of which are discussed in this chapter.
Genetic Control
When considering the moral value of human life,
amongst the most conservative moral positions one
might encounter is the belief that human life becomes
morally significant at conception, and the level of
significance is such that it bestows an inalienable and
absolute right to life. Another conservative position
adopted in this context invokes the concept of
‘potentiality’ in support of the early moral significance of
human life. That is the idea that once a human life has
been created it has the potential to develop to full
personhood, and therefore there is a moral imperative
upon us not to interrupt or jeopardise that potential
development even in its earliest stages.
Genetic Control
If one rejects the conservative positions that emphasise
the moral significance of the mere presence of human life
and/or the potentiality for personhood, one then has to
ask what would or could make the moral difference in
affording full moral status and consequent protections,
and again there are a variety of views. Traditionally some
cultures and religions have placed importance upon the
experience of quickening, the point at which a woman
first experiences the feeling of the fetus within her
womb. Moving on from this relatively early stage (16 to
20 weeks), others have argued that the point at which
human life becomes viable without the biological support
of a woman’s body is the point at which the fetus should
be considered to have an independent right to life.
Section 1: Dilemmas of Genetic Choice
Genetic screening, counseling prenatal diagnosis, and
embryo selection offer the prospect of avoiding the
misery caused by crippling or fatal genetic diseases.
If a genetic disorder can be detected before birth, it is
possible to prevent the birth of children with those
diseases. This would be of benefit to all including the
children who might have been born.
Yet, as positive as this outcome might appear, the
possibility of genetic choice raises a number of troubling
ethical issues, among them are:
Dilemmas of genetic choice
Diagnostic procedures themselves present a possible risk
to the mother or fetus. When are those risks justified?
In most cases in which prenatal diagnosis indicates that
the fetus suffers from a genetic disorder or
developmental defect, the only means of avoiding the
birth of an impaired child is abortion.
But is abortion morally justified? If it is not, then is prenatal
genetic screening justified? (Chapter 5 examines
the morality of abortion in detail.)
Dilemmas of genetic choice
A similar moral question arises in connection with embryo selection
which is possible through In Vitro Fertilization.
With this procedure, several of a woman’s eggs are fertilized outside
her body and allowed to develop into early-stage embryos. During
this time it is possible to screen the embryos for defects and to select
only those which are free of them for implantation in the uterus.
What are our moral obligations, if any, to the defective embryos not
chosen?
Prospective parents who learn through genetic testing that giving
birth will possibly or likely result in an impaired child might decide
nonetheless to go forward with the birth. Do they have right to do
so?
Dilemmas of genetic choice
Children born with genetic diseases and defects require
the expenditure of large amounts of public funds. Given
these costs, is society justified in requiring that people
submit to genetic screening, counseling, or prenatal
diagnosis?
Do physicians have an obligation to inform their patients
who are prospective parents about the kinds of genetic
tests that are available?
What if a doctor is opposed to abortion and is afraid that
his patient would seek one if the results of screening
revealed a genetic defect?
Reading: The Morality of Screening for Disability
Jeff McMahan
McMahan reviews four common objections to
prenatal or pre-implantation screening for
disabilities:
screening is discriminatory
has harmful consequences for disabled people
expresses a hurtful view of disabled people
reduces human diversity.
Reading: The Morality of Screening for Disability
Jeff McMahan
If these objections show that screening is wrong,
McMahan argues, they also imply that it is permissible to
cause oneself to have a disabled child.
Those who accept the objections to screening and claim
that being disabled is no worse than being nondisabled
seem committed to accepting that it is permissible to
deliberately cause a disability prenatally, even for a
trivial reason.
If we find this view unacceptable, McMahan claims, then
we must find the objections to prenatal screening for
disability wrong.
Reading: Genetic Dilemmas and the Child’s
Right to an Open Future
Dena S. Davis
Davis asks whether genetic counselors must
assist couples who wish to have a child who will
be deaf or an achondroplasia dwarf.
Taking deafness as an example, she argues that
although counselors are professionally
committed to an ethic of patient autonomy they
may reject such a request, on the ground that it
would limit the future autonomy of any child
that might be born.
Reading: Genetic Dilemmas and the Child’s
Right to an Open Future
Dena S. Davis
Davis compares the situation with one in which Jehovah’s
Witnesses refuse to consent to a lifesaving blood transfusion
for their child and one in which Amish parents remove their
children from school after the eighth grade.
 While courts have allowed the second, Davis sees both as
unjustifiably denying children an “open future.”
Whether or not deafness is considered a disability in a
culture, being born deaf significantly restricts the choices
open to a child. Thus, if it is chosen before birth by the
child’s parents, it must be considered a harm. For this
reason, genetic counselors should not help parents produce
deaf children.
Section 2 Genetic Selection: A New Eugenics?
The goal of genetic screening is typically understood
to be to detect genetic defects before birth.
But, as our understanding of genetics increases, it
may soon be possible to identify genes responsible
for positive traits, such as intelligence or good
memory.
Assuming that this possibility becomes a reality,
what should our moral stance be towards selecting
for such traits (producing “designer babies”)?
Reading: Procreative Beneficence: Why We
Should Select the Best Children
Julian Savulescu
Julian Savulescu argues that if tests for non-disease
genes become available, we have a moral obligation
to use them in making decisions about reproduction.
Because disease-causing genes reduce the well-being
of a person, what he calls the “principle of
Procreative Benevolence” directs us to select against
them. It isn’t the disease itself we are selecting
against, Savulescu claims, but its impact on a life.
But non-disease genes can also have an impact.
Intelligence, for example, can also affect well-being.
Reading: Procreative Beneficence: Why We
Should Select the Best Children
Julian Savulescu
Thus, genetic information about qualities relevant
to it should be used to select the embryo or fetus,
with the aim of producing a life of the greatest wellbeing.
Procreative Beneficence, Savulescu holds,
must be balanced against Procreative Autonomy.
Even so, doctors should try to persuade potential
parents to seek out and use genetic information
that will let them select for the greatest possible
well-being in the life to be created.
Section 3: Genetics and Abortion
The goal of genetic testing is to provide information
to doctors, patients and prospective parents so that
they can make informed decisions.
One kind of decision concerns possible medical
treatments. For example, if a woman knows that she
carries a gene (such as BRCA-1) which increases her
chances of familial breast cancer, she might elect to
have a radical mastectomy.
Section 3: Genetics and Abortion
Another kind of decision concerns whether to carry
a pregnancy to term or have an abortion.
The morality of abortion is a familiar question
explored in depth in Chapter 5.
In this section, the authors examine a narrower
issue: abortion aside, are there any moral limits to
the use of pre-natal testing?
Reading: Fetal Privacy and Confidentiality
Jeffrey R. Botkin
Botkin argues for placing legal and ethical limits on
prenatal testing.
A woman’s right to get information about her fetus, he
claims, is not derived from the right to privacy, which
justifies her decision to have an abortion. Rather, it is
derived from the doctrine of informed consent.
When she seeks prenatal care, she is entitled to receive
information not only about herself, but about the health
of her fetus.
Reading: Fetal Privacy and Confidentiality
Jeffrey R. Botkin
As with other sorts of communication between a doctor
and a patient, the information the doctor should disclose
is subject to rational limits.
These limits include protecting the fetus’s right to
privacy, a right that must be balanced against the
potential harm the birth of the fetus poses for the
parents.
Prenatal testing is justified, Botkin concludes, when the
harm the fetus poses is similar in magnitude to the birth
of an unwanted child.
Reading: Implications of Prenatal Diagnosis
for the Human Right to Life
Leon R. Kass
Leon Kass expresses concern that the practice of
“genetic abortion” will strongly affect our
attitudes toward all who are “defective” or
abnormal.
Those who escape the net of selective abortion
might receive less care and might even come to
think of themselves as second-class specimens.
Reading: Implications of Prenatal Diagnosis
for the Human Right to Life
Leon R. Kass
Kass presents six criteria that he suggests ought to be
satisfied to justify the abortion of a fetus for genetic reasons.
He focuses on the question raised by the last criterion:
according to what standards should we judge a fetus with
genetic abnormalities unfit to live?
As candidates for such standards, Kass examines the
concepts of social good, family good, and the “healthy and
sound” fetus.
He finds difficulty with all, and in the end he professes
himself unable to provide a satisfactory justification for
genetic abortion.
Section 4: Embryonic Stem Cells: End of the
Battle?
Embryonic stem cells are undifferentiated cells produced
after a fertilized egg has divided several times.
The blastocyst, a hollow ball of cells, contains a little
lump called the inner-cell mass consisting of fifteen to
twenty embryonic stem cells.
As development proceeds, embryonic stem cells
differentiate and become specialized. They turn into socalled
adult stem cells. These cells go on to produce the
approximately 120 different cell types.
Section 4: Embryonic Stem Cells: End of the
Battle?
Before embryonic stem cells begin to differentiate,
they have the potential to become any of the
specialized cells. It is because of this potentiality that
researchers have thought they might be used to treat
many chronic, debilitating, and life-threatening
diseases.
However, because retrieving embryonic stem cells
often results in the destruction of the embryo itself,
some of the moral objections raised against abortion
are also raised against embryonic stem cell research.
Section 4: Embryonic Stem Cells: End of the
Battle?
But new research raises the possibility of being able to
take a somatic cell, such as a skin cell, and “reprogram” it
back to its earlier, undifferentiated adult stem cell status.
As an adult stem cell, the cell could potentially be made
to differentiate into any other cell type, as embryonic
stem cells are able to do.
The immediate appeal of being able to acquire human
embryonic stem cells by converting somatic cells is the
possibility that researchers will no longer need to create
or destroy human embryos.
Section 4: Embryonic Stem Cells: End of the
Battle?
Thus, the arguments over the moral legitimacy of
stem-cell research and treatments based on stem
cells should significantly abate, if not wholly
disappear.
But, as the readings in this section make clear, this
promise is not as obvious as it might at first appear.
Reading: Stem Cells from Skin Cells: The
Ethical Questions
Insoo Hyun
Hyun argues that the genetic modifications of
human skin cells to be like embryonic stem cells,
though exciting, will not remove the ethical problems
of stem cell research.
First, induced pluripotent stem cell (iPS cell)
research will have to be carried out in conjunction
with embryonic stem cell research in order to
determine their value and safety for clinical
applications.
Reading: Stem Cells from Skin Cells: The
Ethical Questions
Insoo Hyun
Second, the use of iPS cells will raise complicated issues
of informed consent because they will be solicited from
gravely ill patients whose hopes might easily be
exploited, as might, those of future patients who may
seek treatments with iPS cells.
Finally, iPS cell research may come up against the same
questions about personhood as embryonic stem cells if it
turns out that somatic cells can be programmed to
generate supporting extra-embryonic (placental) tissues
needed for the embryo to develop into a fetus or if iPS
cells can be programmed to generate human sex cells.
Reading: Ontological and Ethical
Implications of Direct Nuclear
Reprogramming
Gerard Magill and William B. Neaves
Magill and Neaves argue that the 2007 scientific
breakthrough of producing induced pluripotent stem
cells (iPS cells) from human skin cells has ethical
implications for how we regard natural human
embryos, as well as embryos produced by cloning
(i.e., somatic cell nuclear transfer.)
The iPS cells share with embryos the potential to
develop, given the right conditions, into a late-term
fetus. Further research may show that iPS cells, like
embryos, can also make their own placentas.
Reading: Ontological and Ethical Implications of
Direct Nuclear Reprogramming
Gerard Magill and William B. Neaves
This would make them indistinguishable in relevant
ways from embryos (however produced).
Thus, those who consider an embryo the moral
equivalent of a person and seek to protect them must
either extend the same protection to iPS cells or change
the criteria for personhood to ones that rely on features
from a later state of embryonic development.
Otherwise, defenders of the embryo-as-person view must
reject using iPS cells for therapeutic purposes, in the
same way that they reject the destruction of embryos and
cloning.
Reading: Declaration on the Production and the
Scientific and Therapeutic Use of Human Embryonic
Stem Cells
Pontifical Academy for Life
The declaration by the Pontifical Academy sets out
the official Roman Catholic position on the moral
aspects of acquiring and using human embryonic
stem cells.
The Academy declares it is not morally legitimate to
produce or use human embryos as a source of stem
cells, nor is it acceptable to use stem cells from cell
lines already established.
Reading: Declaration on the Production and the
Scientific and Therapeutic Use of Human Embryonic
Stem Cells
Pontifical Academy for Life
The Academy endorses the idea of directing research
toward using adult stem cells to achieve the benefits
that it is hoped embryonic stem cells might achieve.
In 2008, the congregation for the Doctrine of the
Faith issued “Instruction Dignitas Personae on
Certain Bioethical Questions,” in which it reaffirmed
these positions and justification.

The post Chapter 3 Genetic Control appeared first on My Assignment Online.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order