Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

companies have benefit plans

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length35,574 words
  • Reading time155 min
Write My Assignment FREE

WHERE HAVE ALL THE PENSIONS GONE?
Many companies have benefit plans that promise income and other benefits to retired employees in exchange
for services during their working years. However, a shift is on from traditional defined benefit plans, in which
employers bear the risk of meeting the benefit promises, to plans in which employees bear more of the risk. In
some cases, employers are dropping retirement plans altogether. Here are some of the reasons for the shift.
• Competition. Newer and foreign competitors do not have the same retiree costs that older U.S. companies
do. Southwest Airlines does not offer a traditional pension plan, but United has a pension deficit exceeding $100,000 per employee.
• Cost. Retirees are living longer, and the costs of retirement are higher. Combined with annual retiree
healthcare costs, retirement benefits are costing the S&P 500 companies over $25 billion a year and are
rising at double-digit rates.
• Insurance. Pensions are backed by premiums paid to the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation
(PBGC). When a company fails, the PBGC takes over the plan. But due to a number of significant company
failures, the PBGC is running a deficit, and healthy companies are subsidizing the weak.
• Accounting. To bring U.S. standards in line with international rules, accounting rule-makers are considering rules that will require companies to “mark their pensions to market” (value them at market rates). Such
a move would increase the reported volatility of the retirement plan and of company financial statements.
When Great Britain made this shift, 25 percent of British companies closed their plans to new entrants.
As a result of such factors, it is understandable that experts can think of no major company that has instituted a
traditional pension plan in the past decade. What does this mean for you as you evaluate job offers and benefit
packages? To start, you should begin building your own retirement nest egg, rather than relying on your employer
to provide postretirement income and healthcare benefits. Recently, a sample of Americans was asked the following question: When you retire, do you think you will have enough money to live comfortably, or not? The
graph on the next page shows a change in responses from nonretired adults from 2002 to 2014.
Prior to 2008, a majority of nonretired Americans consistently thought they would be able to live comfortably in retirement. But this dropped to 46 percent early during the U.S. recession in 2008 and stayed below
50 percent until 2014. In 2012, fewer than four in 10 nonretirees thought they would have enough money to live
comfortably in retirement.
General economic conditions affect how Americans look at retirement. Americans are generally more positive about retirement when the economy is growing. However, the continuing political discussion about the
fragility of the country’s Social Security and Medicare programs may reduce nonretired Americans’ comfort with

20 1
2
3

Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefits
Understand the fundamentals of pension
plan accounting.
Use a worksheet for employer’s pension
plan entries.
Describe the accounting and amortization
of prior service costs.
4 Explain the accounting and amortization
for unexpected gains and losses.
5 Describe the requirements for reporting
pension plans in financial statements.
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After studying this chapter, you should be able to:
1117
projections of their monetary resources in their retirement. In addition, many are beginning to realize that
retirement at the age of 65 may no longer be possible given the possible extension of social benefits to later ages.
This means that retirement accounts, including individual retirement accounts and defined contribution
pensions such as 401(k) plans, will need to become a bigger piece of the pie to fill the gap left by smaller government and employer-sponsored benefits. So get started now with a personal savings strategy to ensure an adequate nest egg at your retirement.
Sources: Story adapted from Nanette Byrnes with David Welch, “The Benefits Trap,”BusinessWeek (July 19, 2004), pp. 54–72;
and T. Riffkin, “More Americans Think They Will Retire Comfortably,” http://www.gallup.com/poll/168959/americans-thinkretire-comfortably.aspx.
REVIEW AND PRACTICE
Go to the REVIEW AND PRACTICE section at the end of the chapter for a targeted summary review
and practice problem with solution. Multiple-choice questions with annotated solutions as well as
additional exercises and practice problem with solutions are also available online.
PREVIEW OF CHAPTER 20 As our opening story indicates, the cost of retirement
benefits is steep. For example, British Airways’ pension and healthcare costs for retirees in a
recent year totaled $195 million, or approximately $6 per passenger carried. Many other companies are also facing substantial pension and other postretirement expenses and obligations.
In this chapter, we discuss the accounting issues related to these benefit plans. The content and
organization of the chapter are as follows.
ACCOUNTING FOR PENSIONS AND POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS

FUNDAMENTALS
OF PENSION PLAN
ACCOUNTING
• Defined
contribution plan
• Defined benefit
plan
• Role of actuaries
• Measures of the
liability
• Components of
pension expense
USING A PENSION
WORKSHEET
• 2017 entries and
worksheet
• Funded status
GAINS AND LOSSES
• Unexpected
gains and losses
(assets)
• Unexpected
gains and losses
(liabilities)
• Corridor
amortization
• 2019 entries and
worksheet
REPORTING
PENSION PLANS
IN FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
• Within the financial
statements
• Within the notes
to the financial
statements
• Pension note
disclosure
• 2020 entries and
worksheet—a
comprehensive
example
• Special issues
PRIOR SERVICE
COST (PSC)
• Amortization
• 2018 entries and
worksheet

This chapter also includes
numerous conceptual and
international discussions
that are integral to the topics
presented here.
2002
30
45
60%
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
% Yes % No
2012 2013 2014
Live Comfortably During Retirement or Not?
1118 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
FUNDAMENTALS OF PENSION PLAN ACCOUNTING

A pension plan LEARNING OBJECTIVE 1
Understand the
fundamentals of pension
plan accounting.

is an arrangement whereby an employer provides benefits (payments)
to retired employees for services they provided in their working years. Pension accounting may be divided and separately treated as accounting for the employer and accounting for the pension fund. The company or employer is the organization sponsoring the
pension plan. It incurs the cost and makes contributions to the pension fund. The fund
or plan is the entity that receives the contributions from the employer, administers the
pension assets, and makes the benefit payments to the retired employees (pension recipients). Illustration 20-1 shows the three entities involved in a pension plan and indicates
the flow of cash among them.
1When used as a verb, fund means to pay to a funding agency (as to fund future pension benefits or to fund
pension cost). Used as a noun, it refers to assets accumulated in the hands of a funding agency (trustee) for
the purpose of meeting pension benefits when they become due.
2The FASB issued separate guidance covering the accounting and reporting for employee benefit plans. [1]

Employer
(company)
Contributions
$
Pension Fund
Fund Assets
Benefts
$

Investments Earnings
$ $
Pension
Recipients
(employees)
ILLUSTRATION 20-1
Flow of Cash among
Pension Plan Participants
A pension plan is funded when the employer makes payments to a funding agency.1
That agency accumulates the assets of the pension fund and makes payments to the
recipients as the benefits come due.
Some pension plans are contributory. In these, the employees bear part of the cost
of the stated benefits or voluntarily make payments to increase their benefits. Other
plans are noncontributory. In these plans, the employer bears the entire cost. Companies generally design their pension plans so as to take advantage of federal income tax
benefits. Plans that offer tax benefits are called qualified pension plans. They permit
deductibility of the employer’s contributions to the pension fund and tax-free status
of earnings from pension fund assets.
The pension fund should be a separate legal and accounting entity. The pension
fund, as a separate entity, maintains a set of books and prepares financial statements.
Maintaining records and preparing financial statements for the fund, an activity known
as “accounting for employee benefit plans,” is not the subject of this chapter.2 Instead,
this chapter explains the pension accounting and reporting problems of the employer
as the sponsor of a pension plan.
The need to properly administer and account for pension funds becomes apparent
when you understand the size of these funds. Listed in Illustration 20-2 are the pension
fund assets and pension expenses of six major companies.
Size of 2014 Pension Pension Expense
Company Pension Expense as % of Pretax
($ in millions) Fund (Income) Income

General Motors
Hewlett-Packard
Deere & Company
$79,152
10,866
11,447
$151
(225)
164
3.56%
–3.43
3.42
Merck 3,247 12 0.07
The Coca-Cola Company 6,343 34 0.36
Molson Coors Brewing 2,883 21 2.71

ILLUSTRATION 20-2
Pension Funds and
Pension Expense
See the FASB
Codifcation
References
(pages 1179–1180).
Fundamentals of Pension Plan Accounting 1119
As Illustration 20-2 indicates, pension expense is a substantial percentage of total
pretax income for many companies.3 The two most common types of pension plans are
defined contribution plans and defined benefit plans, and we look at each of them in
the following sections.
Defi ned Contribution Plan
In a defined contribution plan, the employer agrees to contribute to a pension trust a
certain sum each period, based on a formula. This formula may consider such factors as
age, length of employee service, employer’s profits, and compensation level. The plan
defines only the employer’s contribution. It makes no promise regarding the ultimate
benefits paid out to the employees. A common form of this plan is a 401(k) plan.
The size of the pension benefits that the employee finally collects under the plan
depends on several factors: the amounts originally contributed to the pension trust, the
income accumulated in the trust, and the treatment of forfeitures of funds caused by
early terminations of other employees. A company usually turns over to an independent third-party trustee the amounts originally contributed. The trustee, acting on
behalf of the beneficiaries (the participating employees), assumes ownership of the pension assets and is accountable for their investment and distribution. The trust is separate
and distinct from the employer.
The accounting for a defined contribution plan is straightforward. The employee
gets the benefit of gain (or the risk of loss) from the assets contributed to the pension
plan. The employer simply contributes each year based on the formula established in
the plan. As a result, the employer’s annual cost (pension expense) is simply the amount
that it is obligated to contribute to the pension trust. The employer reports a liability on
its balance sheet only if it does not make the contribution in full. The employer reports
an asset only if it contributes more than the required amount.
In addition to pension expense, the employer must disclose the following for a
defined contribution plan: a plan description, including employee groups covered; the
basis for determining contributions; and the nature and effect of significant matters
affecting comparability from period to period. [2]
Defined Benefi t Plan
A defined benefit plan outlines the benefits that employees will receive when they
retire. These benefits typically are a function of an employee’s years of service and of the
compensation level in the years approaching retirement.
To meet the defined benefit commitments that will arise at retirement, a company
must determine what the contribution should be today (a time value of money computation). Companies may use many different contribution approaches. However, the
funding method should provide enough money at retirement to meet the benefits
defined by the plan.
The employees are the beneficiaries of a defined contribution trust, but the
employer is the beneficiary of a defined benefit trust. Under a defined benefit plan, the
trust’s primary purpose is to safeguard and invest assets so that there will be enough to
pay the employer’s obligation to the employees. In form, the trust is a separate entity.
In substance, the trust assets and liabilities belong to the employer. That is, as long as
the plan continues, the employer is responsible for the payment of the defined benefits (without regard to what happens in the trust). The employer must make up any
3At the end of 2014, pension assets for the 16 major pension markets were estimated at $36.1 trillion,
representing a 6.1 percent rise compared to the 2013 year-end value. Pension assets relative to gross domestic
product (GDP) reached 84.4 percent in 2014, which represents a 2.3 percent increase from the 2013 ratio of
82.1 percent. The largest pension markets are the United States, United Kingdom, and Japan with 61.2 percent,
9.2 percent, and 7.9 percent of total pension assets in the study, respectively. In U.S. dollar terms, the pension
assets’ growth rate of these three largest markets in 2014 was 9.0 percent, 5.7 percent, and –1.2 percent,
respectively. See “Global Pension Asset Study—2015,” www.towerswatson.com.
1120 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
shortfall in the accumulated assets held by the trust. On the other hand, the employer
can recapture any excess accumulated in the trust, either through reduced future funding or through a reversion of funds.
Because a defined benefit plan specifies benefits in terms of uncertain future variables, a company must establish an appropriate funding pattern to ensure the availability of funds at retirement in order to provide the benefits promised. This funding level
depends on a number of factors such as turnover, mortality, length of employee service,
compensation levels, and interest earnings.
Employers are at risk with defined benefit plans because they must contribute
enough to meet the cost of benefits that the plan defines. The expense recognized each
period is not necessarily equal to the cash contribution. Similarly, the liability is controversial because its measurement and recognition relate to unknown future variables.
Thus, the accounting issues related to this type of plan are complex. Our discussion in
the following sections deals primarily with defined benefit plans.4
INTERNATIONAL
PERSPECTIVE
Outside the United
States, private pension
plans are less common
because many other
nations rely on government-sponsored
pension plans. Consequently, accounting for
defi ned benefi t pension
plans is typically a less
important issue elsewhere in the world.
4A recent federal law requires employees to explicitly opt out of an employer-sponsored defined contribution
plan. This should help employees build their own nest eggs (as suggested in the opening story) and will
contribute to further growth in defined contribution plans. However, note the following three warnings:
(1) low-income workers will still not be able to stash enough away, (2) it leaves each participant alone to
manage risk, and (3) companies establish a minimum contribution, which too many participants choose
to use, instead of a larger contribution.
WHAT DO THE NUMBERS MEAN? WHICH PLAN IS RIGHT FOR YOU?
Source: Form 5500 filings with U.S. Department of Labor, November 2014, “Private Pension Plan Bulletin.”
Defi ned contribution plans have become much more popular
with employers than defi ned benefi t plans, as indicated in the
chart below. One reason is that they are cheaper. Defi ned
The total amount of pension assets held by pension plans is
$22,117 billion, which is 127 percent of gross domestic product. In 2014, 58 percent of these assets were in defi ned
contribution plans often cost no more than 3 percent of payroll,
whereas defi ned benefi t plans can cost 5 to 6 percent of
payroll.
contribution plans and 42 percent in defi ned benefi t plans.
Pension plan assets have grown 6.6 percent per year over the
period 2004–2014.
Active Participants (in millions)
Calendar Year
0
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Defned Beneft Plan Defned Contribution Plan Total
Number of Active Participants in Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plans (in thousands) by Type of Plan
Fundamentals of Pension Plan Accounting 1121
The Role of Actuaries in Pension Accounting
The problems associated with pension plans involve complicated mathematical considerations. Therefore, companies engage actuaries to ensure that a pension plan is appropriate for the employee group covered.5 Actuaries are individuals trained through a long
and rigorous certification program to assign probabilities to future events and their
financial effects. The insurance industry employs actuaries to assess risks and to advise
on the setting of premiums and other aspects of insurance policies. Employers rely heavily on actuaries for assistance in developing, implementing, and funding pension funds.
Actuaries make predictions (called actuarial assumptions) of mortality rates, employee
turnover, interest and earnings rates, early retirement frequency, future salaries, and
any other factors necessary to operate a pension plan. They also compute the various
pension measures that affect the financial statements, such as the pension obligation, the
annual cost of servicing the plan, and the cost of amendments to the plan. In summary,
accounting for defined benefit pension plans relies heavily upon information and measurements provided by actuaries.
Measures of the Liability
In accounting for a company’s pension plan, two questions arise. (1) What is the pension
obligation that a company should report in the financial statements? (2) What is the pension expense for the period? Attempting to answer the first question has produced
much controversy.
Alternative Approaches
Most agree that an employer’s pension obligation is the deferred compensation obligation it has to its employees for their service under the terms of the pension plan. Measuring that obligation is not so simple, though, because there are alternative ways of measuring it.6
One measure of the pension obligation is to base it only on the benefits vested to the
employees. Vested benefits are those that the employee is entitled to receive even if he
or she renders no additional services to the company. Most pension plans require a certain minimum number of years of service to the employer before an employee achieves
vested benefits status. Companies compute the vested benefit obligation using only
vested benefits, at current salary levels.
Another way to measure the obligation uses both vested and nonvested years of service. On this basis, the company computes the deferred compensation amount on all years
of employees’ service—both vested and nonvested—using current salary levels. This
measurement of the pension obligation is called the accumulated benefit obligation.
A third measure bases the deferred compensation amount on both vested and nonvested service using future salaries. This measurement of the pension obligation is
called the projected benefit obligation. Because future salaries are expected to be higher
than current salaries, this approach results in the largest measurement of the pension
obligation.
The choice between these measures is critical. The choice affects the amount of a
company’s pension liability and the annual pension expense reported. Illustration 20-3
(on page 1122) presents the differences in these three measurements.
5An actuary’s primary purpose is to ensure that the company has established an appropriate funding
pattern to meet its pension obligations. This computation involves developing a set of assumptions and
continued monitoring of these assumptions to ensure their realism. That the general public has little
understanding of what an actuary does is illustrated by the following excerpt from the Wall Street Journal:
“A polling organization once asked the general public what an actuary was, and received among its more
coherent responses the opinion that it was a place where you put dead actors.”
6One measure of the pension obligation is to determine the amount that the Pension Benefit Guaranty
Corporation would require the employer to pay if it defaulted. (This amount is limited to 30 percent of the
employer’s net worth.) The accounting profession rejected this approach for financial reporting because it is
too hypothetical and ignores the going concern concept.
1122 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Which of these alternative measures of the pension liability does the profession
favor? The profession adopted the projected benefit obligation—the present value of
vested and nonvested benefits accrued to date, based on employees’ future salary
levels.7 Those in favor of the projected benefit obligation contend that a promise by an
employer to pay benefits based on a percentage of the employees’ future salaries is far
greater than a promise to pay a percentage of their current salary, and such a difference
should be reflected in the pension liability and pension expense.
Moreover, companies discount to present value the estimated future benefits to be
paid. Minor changes in the interest rate used to discount pension benefits can dramatically affect the measurement of the employer’s obligation. For example, a 1 percent decrease in the discount rate can increase pension liabilities 15 percent. Accounting rules require that at each measurement date, a company must determine the
appropriate discount rate used to measure the pension liability, based on current
interest rates.
Recognition of the Net Funded Status of the Pension Plan
Companies must recognize on their balance sheet the full overfunded or underfunded
status of their defined benefit pension plan.8 [3] The overfunded or underfunded status is measured as the difference between the fair value of the plan assets and the projected benefit obligation.
To illustrate, assume that Coker Company has a projected benefit obligation of
$300,000, and the fair value of its plan assets is $210,000. In this case, Coker Company’s
pension plan is underfunded, and therefore it reports a pension liability of $90,000
($300,000 – $210,000) on its balance sheet. If instead the fair value of Coker’s plan assets
were $430,000, it would report a pension asset of $130,000 ($430,000 – $300,000).
Benefts for
vested employees
only at
current salaries.
Benefts for
nonvested
employees at
current salaries.
Projected
beneft
obligation
Benefts for vested
and nonvested
employees at
future salaries.
Accumulated
beneft
obligation
(FASB’s choice)
Vested
beneft
obligation
Present value of
expected cash flows
computed by actuaries
ILLUSTRATION 20-3
Different Measures of the
Pension Obligation
7When we use the term “present value of benefits” throughout this chapter, we really mean the actuarial
present value of benefits. Actuarial present value is the amount payable adjusted to reflect the time value
of money and the probability of payment (by means of decrements for events such as death, disability,
withdrawals, or retirement) between the present date and the expected date of payment. For simplicity,
though, we use the term “present value” instead of “actuarial present value” in our discussion.
8Recognize that GAAP applies to pensions as well as other postretirement benefit plans (OPEBs). Appendix
20A addresses the accounting for OPEBs.
Fundamentals of Pension Plan Accounting 1123
In 2010, by slowing the growth of pension liabilities and increasing contributions to
pension funds, the S&P 500 companies reported aggregate overfunding (assets exceeded
liabilities) of $42.9 billion. However, by 2014, these same pension plans were underfunded by $394.9 billion.9
9J. Ciesielski, “S&P 500 Defined Benefit Plans: State of the Pension Plan Promise, 2014,” The Analyst’s
Accounting Observer (May 28, 2015).
10At one time, companies applied the cash basis of accounting to pension plans by recognizing the
amount paid in a particular accounting period as the pension expense for the period. The problem was
that the amount paid or funded in a fiscal period depended on financial management and was too often
discretionary. For example, funding could depend on the availability of cash, the level of earnings, or
other factors unrelated to the requirements of the plan. Application of the cash basis made it possible to
manipulate the amount of pension expense appearing in the income statement simply by varying the cash
paid to the pension fund.
WHAT DO THE NUMBERS MEAN? ROLLER COASTER
The chart below shows what has happened to the fi nancial health
of pension plans over the last few years. It is a real roller coaster.
At the turn of the century, when the stock market was
strong, pension plans were overfunded. However, the bubble
burst, and by 2002 companies in the S&P 1500 saw their pension plans funded at less than reported liabilities. Then, plans
bounced back, and by 2007 pension plans were overfunded
again. However, due to recent downturns in the wake of the
fi nancial crisis, plans are now underfunded again and the future
is highly uncertain.
A number of factors cause a fund to change from being
overfunded to underfunded. First, low interest rates decimate
returns on pension plan assets. Second, using low interest
rates to discount the projected benefi t payments leads to a
higher pension liability. Similarly, as was observed recently,
actuaries may revise estimates related to mortality rates or
expected salary levels, which could lead to an increase in the
projected benefi t obligation and more underfunded plans.
Finally, more individuals are retiring and living longer, which
leads to a depletion of the pension plan assets.
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Funded Status of Defined Benefit Pension Plans for the S&P 1500
105%
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
65
Source: http://www.mercer.com/newsroom/SP-1500-pension-funded-status-declines-in-2014-as-low-interest-rates-and
new-mortality-tables-overpower-positive-asset-returns.html
Source: V. Monga, “Longer Lives Cut Premium to Offload Pensions,” Wall Street Journal (February 3, 2015).
Components of Pension Expense
There is broad agreement that companies should account for pension cost on the accrual
basis.10 The profession recognizes that accounting for pension plans requires measurement of the cost and its identification with the appropriate time periods. The determination of pension expense, however, is extremely complicated because it is a function of
the following components.
1. Service cost. Service cost is the expense caused by the increase in pension benefts
payable (the projected beneft obligation) to employees because of their services
1124 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
rendered during the current year. Actuaries compute service cost as the present
value of the new benef ts earned by employees during the year.
2. Interest on the liability. Because a pension is a deferred compensation arrangement, there is a time value of money factor. As a result, companies record the pension liability on a discounted basis. Interest expense accrues each year on the projected benef t obligation just as it does on any discounted debt. The actuary helps
to select the interest rate, referred to as the settlement rate.
3. Actual return on plan assets. The return earned by the accumulated pension
fund assets in a particular year is relevant in measuring the net cost to the
employer of sponsoring an employee pension plan. Therefore, a company should
adjust annual pension expense for interest and dividends that accumulate
within the fund, as well as increases and decreases in the fair value of the fund
assets.
4. Amortization of prior service cost. Pension plan amendments (including initiation
of a pension plan) often include provisions to increase benef ts (or in rare situations,
to decrease benefts) for employee service provided in prior years. A company
grants plan amendments with the expectation that it will realize economic benefts
in future periods. Thus, it allocates the cost (prior service cost) of providing these
retroactive benef ts to pension expense in the future, specif cally to the remaining
service-years of the affected employees.
5. Gain or loss. Volatility in pension expense can result from sudden and large changes
in the fair value of plan assets (resulting in differences between the actual return and
the expected return on plan assets) and by changes in the projected beneft obligation
(which changes when actuaries modify assumptions or when actual experience differs from expected experience). We will discuss this complex computation later in the
chapter.
Illustration 20-4 shows the components of pension expense and their effect on total
pension expense (increase or decrease).
Pension
Expense

Interest on
liability
(increases pension
expense)

Actual return on
plan assets
(generally decreases
pension expense)
Service cost
for the year
(increases pension
expense)
Gain or loss
(decreases or
increases
pension expense)
Amortization of
prior service cost
(generally increases
pension expense)
ILLUSTRATION 20-4
Components of Annual
Pension Expense
UNDERLYING
CONCEPTS
The expense recognition principle and the
defi nition of a liability
justify accounting for
pension cost on the
accrual basis. This
requires recording an
expense when employees earn the future benefi ts, and recognizing
an existing obligation
to pay pensions later
based on current services received.
Service Cost
The service cost is the actuarial present value of benefits attributed by the pension
benefit formula to employee service during the period. That is, the actuary predicts
Fundamentals of Pension Plan Accounting 1125
the additional benefits that an employer must pay under the plan’s benefit formula as a
result of the employees’ current year’s service, and then discounts the cost of those
future benefits back to their present value.
The Board concluded that companies must consider future compensation levels in
measuring the present obligation and periodic pension expense if the plan benefit
formula incorporates them. In other words, the present obligation resulting from a
promise to pay a benefit of 1 percent of an employee’s final pay differs from the promise
to pay 1 percent of current pay. To overlook this fact is to ignore an important aspect of
pension expense. Thus, the FASB adopts the benefits/years-of-service actuarial
method, which determines pension expense based on future salary levels.
Some object to this determination, arguing that a company should have more freedom to select an expense recognition pattern. Others believe that incorporating future
salary increases into current pension expense is accounting for events that have not yet
happened. They argue that if a company terminates the plan today, it pays only liabilities for accumulated benefits. Nevertheless, the FASB indicates that the projected benefit obligation provides a more realistic measure of the employer’s obligation under
the plan on a going concern basis and, therefore, companies should use it as the basis
for determining service cost.
Interest on the Liability
The second component of pension expense is interest on the liability, or interest
expense. Because a company defers paying the liability until maturity, the company
records it on a discounted basis. The liability then accrues interest over the life of the
employee. The interest component is the interest for the period on the projected benefit obligation outstanding during the period. The FASB did not address the question
of how often to compound the interest cost. To simplify our illustrations and problem
materials, we use a simple interest computation, applying it to the beginning-of-theyear balance of the projected benefit liability.
How do companies determine the interest rate to apply to the pension liability? The
Board states that the assumed discount rate should reflect the rates at which companies can effectively settle pension benefits. In determining these settlement rates,
companies should look to rates of return on high-quality fixed-income investments currently available, whose cash flows match the timing and amount of the expected benefit
payments. The objective of selecting the assumed discount rates is to measure a single
amount that, if invested in a portfolio of high-quality debt instruments, would provide
the necessary future cash flows to pay the pension benefits when due.
Actual Return on Plan Assets
Pension plan assets are usually investments in stocks, bonds, other securities, and real
estate that a company holds to earn a reasonable return, generally at minimum risk.
Employer contributions and actual returns on pension plan assets increase pension plan
assets. Benefits paid to retired employees decrease them. As indicated, the actual return
earned on these assets increases the fund balance and correspondingly reduces the
employer’s net cost of providing employees’ pension benefits. That is, the higher the
actual return on the pension plan assets, the less the employer has to contribute eventually and, therefore, the less pension expense that it needs to report.
The actual return on the plan assets is the increase in pension funds from interest,
dividends, and realized and unrealized changes in the fair value of the plan assets.
Companies compute the actual return by adjusting the change in the plan assets for the
effects of contributions during the year and benefits paid out during the year. The equation in Illustration 20-5, or a variation thereof, can be used to compute the actual return.

Actual
Return =
(
– (Contributions – Benefits Paid)
(
–
Plan Plan
Assets
Assets
Ending Beginning
Balance Balance

ILLUSTRATION 20-5 Equation for Computing Actual Return
1126 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Stated another way, the actual return on plan assets is the difference between the
fair value of the plan assets at the beginning of the period and at the end of the period,
adjusted for contributions and benefit payments. Illustration 20-6 uses the equation
above to compute the actual return, using some assumed amounts.

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet.xls
1 General Journal Entries Memo Record
2
3 Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash Plan
Assets
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
4
5
6
7
8
9

ILLUSTRATION 20-7
Basic Format of Pension
Worksheet
If the actual return on the plan assets is positive (a gain) during the period, a company subtracts it when computing pension expense. If the actual return is negative (a
loss) during the period, the company adds it when computing pension expense.11
USING A PENSION WORKSHEET
We will now illustrate the basic computation of pension expense using the first three
components: (1) service cost, (2) interest on the liability, and (3) actual return on plan
assets. We discuss the other pension expense components (amortization of prior service
cost, and gains and losses) in later sections.
Companies often use a worksheet to record pension-related information. As its
name suggests, the worksheet is a working tool. A worksheet is not a permanent
accounting record. It is neither a journal nor part of the general ledger. The worksheet is
merely a device to make it easier to prepare entries and the financial statements.12 Illustration 20-7 shows the format of the pension worksheet.

LEARNING OBJECTIVE 2
Use a worksheet for
employer’s pension
plan entries.
Fair value of plan assets at end of period
Deduct: Fair value of plan assets at beginning of period
$5,000,000
4,200,000

Increase in fair value of plan assets 800,000
Deduct: Contributions to plan during period $500,000
Less benefits paid during period 300,000 200,000
Actual return on plan assets $ 600,000
ILLUSTRATION 20-6
Computation of Actual
Return on Plan Assets
11At this point, we use the actual rate of return. Later, for purposes of computing pension expense, we use
the expected rate of return.
12The use of a pension entry worksheet is recommended and illustrated by Paul B. W. Miller, “The New Pension
Accounting (Part 2),” Journal of Accountancy (February 1987), pp. 86–94.
The “General Journal Entries” columns of the worksheet (near the center) determine the entries to record in the formal general ledger accounts. The “Memo Record”
columns (on the right side) maintain balances in the projected benefit obligation and the
plan assets. The difference between the projected benefit obligation and the fair value of
the plan assets is the pension asset/liability, which is reported in the balance sheet. If
the projected benefit obligation is greater than the plan assets, a pension liability occurs.
If the projected benefit obligation is less than the plan assets, a pension asset occurs.
Using a Pension Worksheet 1127

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—2017.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 Pension
Asset/
Liability
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Plan
Assets
Items Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017 100,000 Cr. 100,000 Dr. —
7 9,000 Dr. (a) Service cost 9,000 Cr.
8 10,000 Dr. (b) Interest cost 10,000 Cr.
9 10,000 Cr. (c) Actual return 10,000 Dr.
10 (d) Contributions 8,000 Dr. 8,000 Cr.
11 (e) Benefts 7,000 Dr. 7,000 Cr.
12
13
14 9,000 Dr. Journal entry for 2017 8,000 Cr. 1,000 Cr.*
15 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 112,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr. 1,000 Cr.**
16
17 *$9,000 – $8,000 = $1,000
18 **$112,000 – $111,000 = $1,000

ILLUSTRATION 20-8
Pension
Worksheet—2017
Entry (a) in Illustration 20-8 records the service cost component, which increases
pension expense by $9,000 and increases the liability (projected benefit obligation) by
$9,000. Entry (b) accrues the interest expense component, which increases both the liability and the pension expense by $10,000 (the beginning projected benefit obligation
multiplied by the settlement rate of 10 percent). Entry (c) records the actual return on the
On the first line of the worksheet, a company records the beginning balances (if
any). It then records subsequent transactions and events related to the pension plan
using debits and credits, using both sets of columns as if they were one. For each transaction or event, the debits must equal the credits. The ending balance in the Pension
Asset/Liability column should equal the net balance in the memo record.
2017 Entries and Worksheet
To illustrate the use of a worksheet and how it helps in accounting for a pension plan,
assume that on January 1, 2017, Zarle Company provides the following information
related to its pension plan for the year 2017.
• Plan assets, January 1, 2017, are $100,000.
• Projected benefit obligation, January 1, 2017, is $100,000.
• Annual service cost is $9,000.
• Settlement rate is 10 percent.
• Actual return on plan assets is $10,000.
• Funding contributions are $8,000.
• Benefits paid to retirees during the year are $7,000.
Using this data, the worksheet in Illustration 20-8 presents the beginning balances
and all of the pension entries recorded by Zarle in 2017. Zarle records the beginning balances for the projected benefit obligation and the pension plan assets on the first line of
the worksheet in the memo record. Because the projected benefit obligation and the plan
assets are the same at January 1, 2017, the Pension Asset/Liability account has a zero
balance at January 1, 2017.
1128 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
plan assets, which increases the plan assets and decreases the pension expense. Entry
(d) records Zarle’s contribution (funding) of assets to the pension fund, thereby decreasing cash by $8,000 and increasing plan assets by $8,000. Entry (e) records the benefit
payments made to retirees, which results in equal $7,000 decreases to the plan assets
and the projected benefit obligation.
Zarle makes the “formal journal entry” on December 31, which records the pension
expense in 2017, as follows.
2017

Pension Expense 9,000
Cash 8,000
Pension Asset/Liability 1,000

Funded Status
The credit to Pension Asset/Liability for $1,000 represents the difference between the
2017 pension expense of $9,000 and the amount funded of $8,000. Pension Asset/Liability (credit) is a liability because Zarle underfunds the plan by $1,000. The Pension Asset/
Liability account balance of $1,000 also equals the net of the balances in the memo
accounts. Illustration 20-9 shows that the projected benefit obligation exceeds the plan
assets by $1,000, which reconciles to the pension liability reported in the balance sheet.

Projected benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
$(112,000)
111,000

Pension asset/liability (Credit) $ (1,000)
ILLUSTRATION 20-9
Pension Reconciliation
Schedule—December 31,
2017
If the net of the memo record balances is a credit, the reconciling amount in the pension asset/liability column will be a credit equal in amount. If the net of the memo
record balances is a debit, the pension asset/liability amount will be a debit equal in
amount. The worksheet is designed to produce this reconciling feature, which is useful
later in the preparation of the financial statements and required note disclosure related
to pensions.
In this illustration (for 2017), the debit to Pension Expense exceeds the credit to
Cash, resulting in a credit to Pension Asset/Liability—the recognition of a liability. If the
credit to Cash exceeded the debit to Pension Expense, Zarle would debit Pension Asset/
Liability—the recognition of an asset.
PRIOR SERVICE COST (PSC)
When either initiating (adopting) or amending a defined benefit plan, a company often
provides benefits to employees for years of service before the date of initiation or amendment. As a result of this prior service cost, the projected benefit obligation is increased
to recognize this additional liability. In many cases, the increase in the projected benefit
obligation is substantial.
Amortization
Should a company report an expense for these prior service costs (PSC) at the time it
initiates or amends a plan? The FASB says no. The Board’s rationale is that the employer
would not provide credit for past years of service unless it expects to receive benefits in
the future. As a result, a company should not recognize the retroactive benefits as pension expense in the year of amendment. Instead, the employer initially records the
prior service cost as an adjustment to other comprehensive income. The employer
then recognizes the prior service cost as a component of pension expense over the

LEARNING OBJECTIVE 3
Describe the accounting
and amortization of prior
service costs.

Prior Service Cost (PSC) 1129
Expected
Group Number of Employees Retirement on Dec. 31
A 40 2018
B 20 2019
C 40 2020
D 50 2021
E 20 2022
170
remaining service lives of the employees who are expected to benefit from the change
in the plan.
The cost of the retroactive benefits (including any benefits provided to existing
retirees) is the increase in the projected benefit obligation at the date of the amendment. An actuary computes the amount of the prior service cost. Amortization of the prior
service cost is also an accounting function performed with the assistance of an actuary.
The Board prefers a years-of-service method that is similar to a units-of-production
computation. First, the company computes the total number of service-years to be
worked by all of the participating employees. Second, it divides the prior service cost by
the total number of service-years, to obtain a cost per service-year (the unit cost). Third,
the company multiplies the number of service-years consumed each year by the cost per
service-year, to obtain the annual amortization charge.
To illustrate the amortization of the prior service cost under the years-of-service
method, assume that Zarle Company’s defined benefit pension plan covers 170 employees. In its negotiations with the employees, Zarle Company amends its pension plan on
January 1, 2018, and grants $80,000 of prior service costs to its employees. The employees are grouped according to expected years of retirement, as follows.
Service-Years
Year A B C D E Total
2018 40 20 40 50 20 170
2019 20 40 50 20 130
2020 40 50 20 110
2021 50 20 70
2022 20 20
40 40 120 200 100 500
ILLUSTRATION 20-10
Computation of ServiceYears

Total Cost per Annual
Year Service-Years Service-Year Amortization

×
=
2018 170 $160 $27,200
2019 130 160 20,800
2020 110 160 17,600
2021 70 160 11,200
2022 20 160 3,200
500 $80,000
ILLUSTRATION 20-11
Computation of Annual
Prior Service Cost
Amortization
Computed on the basis of a prior service cost of $80,000 and a total of 500 serviceyears for all years, the cost per service-year is $160 ($80,000 ÷ 500). The annual amount
of amortization based on a $160 cost per service-year is computed as follows.
Illustration 20-10 shows computation of the service-years per year and the total
service-years.
An alternative method of computing amortization of prior service cost is permitted.
Employers may use straight-line amortization over the average remaining service life of
the employees. In this case, with 500 service-years and 170 employees, the average would
1130 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
be 2.94 years (500 ÷ 170). The annual expense would be $27,211 ($80,000 ÷ 2.94). Using this
method, Zarle Company would record expense in 2018, 2019, and 2020 as follows.

Year Expense
2018 $27,211
2019 27,211
2020 25,578*
$80,000
*.94 × $27,211

2018 Entries and Worksheet
Continuing the Zarle Company illustration into 2018, we note that the company amends
the pension plan on January 1, 2018, to grant employees prior service benefits with a
present value of $80,000. Zarle uses the annual amortization amounts, as computed in
the previous section using the years-of-service approach ($27,200 for 2018). The following additional facts apply to the pension plan for the year 2018.
• Annual service cost is $9,500.
• Settlement rate is 10 percent.
• Actual return on plan assets is $11,100.
• Annual funding contributions are $20,000.
• Benefits paid to retirees during the year are $8,000.
• Amortization of prior service cost (PSC) using the years-of-service method is $27,200.
• Accumulated other comprehensive income (hereafter referred to as accumulated
OCI) on December 31, 2017, is zero.
Illustration 20-12 presents a worksheet of all the pension entries and information
recorded by Zarle in 2018. We now add an additional column to the worksheet to record

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—2018.xls
1 General Journal Entries Memo Record
2
3 Other
Comprehensive
Income
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 7 Prior Service
Cost
8 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 112,000 Cr. 1,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr.
9 (f) Prior service cost 80,000 Cr. 0 80,000 Dr.
10
11 Balance, Jan. 1, 2018 192,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr.
12 9,500 Dr. (g) Service cost 9,500 Cr.
13 19,200 Dr. (h) Interest cost 19,200 Cr.
14 11,100 Cr. (i) Actual return 11,100 Dr.
15 27,200 Dr. (j) Amortization of PSC 27,200 Cr.
16 (k) Contributions 20,000 Dr. 20,000 Cr.
17 (l) Benefts 8,000 Dr. 8,000 Cr.
18
19 44,800 Dr. Journal entry for 2018 77,600 Cr. 20,000 Cr. 52,800 Dr.
20
21
Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2017 0
22 Balance, Dec. 31, 2018 212,700 Cr. 78,600 Cr. 134,100 Dr. 52,800 Dr.
23

ILLUSTRATION 20-12
Pension Worksheet—2018
Gains and Losses 1131
the prior service cost adjustment to other comprehensive income. In addition, as shown
in rows 19, 21, and 22, the other comprehensive income amount related to prior service
cost is added to accumulated other comprehensive income (“Accumulated OCI”) to
arrive at a debit balance of $52,800 at December 31, 2018.
The first line of the worksheet shows the beginning balances of the Pension Asset/
Liability account and the memo accounts. Entry (f) records Zarle’s granting of prior service
cost, by adding $80,000 to the projected benefit obligation and decreasing other comprehensive income—prior service cost by the same amount. Entries (g), (h), (i), (k), and (l) are similar to the corresponding entries in 2017. To compute the interest cost on the projected benefit obligation for entry (h), we use the beginning projected benefit balance of $192,000,
which has been adjusted for the prior service cost amendment on January 1, 2018. Entry
(j) records the 2018 amortization of prior service cost by debiting Pension Expense for
$27,200 and crediting Other Comprehensive Income (PSC) for the same amount.
Zarle makes the following journal entry on December 31 to formally record the 2018
pension expense (the sum of the annual pension expense column), and related pension
information.
2018

Pension Expense 44,800
Other Comprehensive Income (PSC)
Cash
52,800 20,000
Pension Asset/Liability 77,600

Because the debits to Pension Expense and to Other Comprehensive Income (PSC)
exceed the funding, Zarle credits the Pension Asset/Liability account for the $77,600
difference. That account is a liability. In 2018, as in 2017, the balance of the Pension
Asset/Liability account ($78,600) is equal to the net of the balances in the memo accounts,
as shown in Illustration 20-13.

Projected benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
$(212,700)
134,100

Pension asset/liability (Credit) $ (78,600)
ILLUSTRATION 20-13
Pension Reconciliation
Schedule—December 31,
2018
The reconciliation is the formula that makes the worksheet work. It relates the components of pension accounting, recorded and unrecorded, to one another.
GAINS AND LOSSES
Of great concern to companies that have pension plans are the uncontrollable and unexpected swings in pension expense that can result from (1) sudden and large changes in
the fair value of plan assets, and (2) changes in actuarial assumptions that affect the
amount of the projected benefit obligation. If these gains or losses impact fully the financial statements in the period of realization or incurrence, substantial fluctuations in pension expense result.
Therefore, the FASB decided to reduce the volatility associated with pension expense
by using smoothing techniques that dampen and in some cases fully eliminate the
fluctuations.
Smoothing Unexpected Gains and Losses on Plan Assets
One component of pension expense, actual return on plan assets, reduces pension
expense (assuming the actual return is positive). A large change in the actual return can
substantially affect pension expense for a year. Assume a company has a 40 percent
return in the stock market for the year. Should this substantial, and perhaps one-time,
event affect current pension expense?
Actuaries ignore current fluctuations when they develop a funding pattern to pay
expected benefits in the future. They develop an expected rate of return and multiply it by

LEARNING OBJECTIVE 4
Explain the accounting
and amortization for
unexpected gains and

losses.
1132 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
an asset value weighted over a reasonable period of time to arrive at an expected return on
plan assets. They then use this return to determine a company’s funding pattern.
The FASB adopted the actuary’s approach to dampen wide swings that might occur
in the actual return. That is, a company includes the expected return on the plan assets
as a component of pension expense, not the actual return in a given year. To achieve this
goal, the company multiplies the expected rate of return by the market-related value of
the plan assets. The market-related asset value of the plan assets is either the fair value
of plan assets or a calculated value that recognizes changes in fair value in a systematic
and rational manner. [4]13
The difference between the expected return and the actual return is referred to as
the unexpected gain or loss; the FASB uses the term asset gains and losses. Asset gains
occur when actual return exceeds expected return; asset losses occur when actual return
is less than expected return.
What happens to unexpected gains or losses in the accounting for pensions? Companies record asset gains and asset losses in an account, Other Comprehensive Income (G/L),
combining them with gains and losses accumulated in prior years. This treatment is similar to prior service cost. The Board believes this treatment is consistent with the practice of
including in other comprehensive income certain changes in value that have not been
recognized in net income (for example, unrealized gains and losses on available-for-sale
securities). [5] In addition, the accounting is simple, transparent, and symmetrical.
To illustrate the computation of an unexpected gain or loss and its related accounting,
assume that in 2019, Zarle Company has an actual return on plan assets of $12,000 when
the expected return is $13,410 (the expected rate of return of 10% on plan assets times the
beginning-of-the-year plan assets). The unexpected asset loss of $1,410 ($12,000 – $13,410)
is debited to Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) and credited to Pension Expense. We
show treatment of this loss in the worksheet in Illustration 20-18 (page 1137).
WHAT DO THE NUMBERS MEAN? PENSION COSTS UPS AND DOWNS
For some companies, pension plans generate real profi ts. The
plans not only pay for themselves but also increase earnings. This
happens when the expected return on pension assets exceed
the company’s annual costs. At MeadWestvaco, pension
income amounted to approximately 27 percent of operating
profi t. It tallied 11 percent of operating profi t at CenturyTel and
9.5 percent at Sun Trust Banks. The issue is important because
in these cases management is not driving the operating income—
pension income is. And as a result, income can change quickly.
Unfortunately, when the stock market stops booming,
pension expense substantially increases for many companies. The reason: Expected return on a smaller asset base
no longer offsets pension service costs and interest on the
projected benefi t obligation. As a result, many companies
fi nd it diffi cult to meet their earnings targets, at a time when
meeting such targets is crucial to maintaining the stock
price.
13Companies may use different ways of determining the calculated market-related value for different classes
of assets. For example, an employer might use fair value for bonds and a five-year moving-average for
equities. But companies should consistently apply the manner of determining market-related value from
year to year for each asset class. Throughout our Zarle illustrations, we assume that market-related values
based on a calculated value and the fair value of plan assets are equal. For homework purposes, use the fair
value of plan assets as the measure for the market-related value.
Smoothing Unexpected Gains and
Losses on the Pension Liability
In estimating the projected benefit obligation (the liability), actuaries make assumptions
about such items as mortality rate, retirement rate, turnover rate, disability rate, and
salary amounts. Any change in these actuarial assumptions affects the amount of the
projected benefit obligation. Seldom does actual experience coincide exactly with actuarial predictions. These unexpected gains or losses from changes in the projected benefit
obligation are called liability gains and losses.
Gains and Losses 1133
Companies report liability gains (resulting from unexpected decreases in the liability balance) and liability losses (resulting from unexpected increases) in Other Comprehensive Income (G/L). Companies combine the liability gains and losses in the same
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) account used for asset gains and losses. They accumulate the asset and liability gains and losses from year to year that are not amortized
in Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income. This amount is reported on the balance
sheet in the stockholders’ equity section.
Corridor Amortization
The asset gains and losses and the liability gains and losses can offset each other. As a
result, the Accumulated OCI account related to gains and losses may not grow very
large. But, it is possible that no offsetting will occur and that the balance in the Accumulated OCI account related to gains and losses will continue to grow.
To limit the growth of the Accumulated OCI account, the FASB invented the corridor approach for amortizing the account’s accumulated balance when it gets too large.
How large is too large? The FASB set a limit of 10 percent of the larger of the beginning
balances of the projected benefit obligation or the market-related value of the plan
assets. Above that size, the Accumulated OCI account related to gains and losses is
considered too large and must be amortized.
To illustrate the corridor approach, data for Callaway Co.’s projected benefit obligation and plan assets over a period of six years are shown in Illustration 20-14.
ILLUSTRATION 20-14
Computation of the
Corridor

Projected Market-Related
Asset Corridor*
Value +/– 10%
2016 $1,000,000 $ 900,000 $100,000
2017 1,200,000 1,100,000 120,000
2018 1,300,000 1,700,000 170,000
2019 1,500,000 2,250,000 225,000
2020 1,700,000 1,750,000 175,000
2021 1,800,000 1,700,000 180,000
*The corridor becomes 10% of the larger (in red type) of the projected benefit
obligation or the market-related plan asset value.

Beginning-of-the- Benefit Year Balances Obligation 250
200
150
100
50
0
(in thousands)
2016
50
100
150
200
250
2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

10 0 1 0
2 25
17 5 180
10 0 12 0
1 0
180
The
Corridor

170
225
175
ILLUSTRATION 20-15
Graphic Illustration
of the Corridor
How the corridor works becomes apparent when we portray the data graphically,
as in Illustration 20-15.
1134 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
If the balance in the Accumulated OCI account related to gains and losses stays
within the upper and lower limits of the corridor, no amortization is required. In that
case, Callaway carries forward unchanged the accumulated OCI related to gains and
losses.
If amortization is required, the minimum amortization is the excess divided by the
average remaining service period of active employees who are expected to receive benefits under the plan. Callaway may use any systematic method of amortization of gains
and losses in lieu of the minimum, provided it is greater than the minimum. It must use
the method consistently for both gains and losses, and must disclose the amortization
method used.
Example of Gains/Losses
In applying the corridor, companies should include amortization of the net gain or loss
as a component of pension expense only if, at the beginning of the year, the net gain or
loss in Accumulated OCI exceeded the corridor. That is, if no net gain or loss exists in
Accumulated OCI at the beginning of the period, the company cannot recognize pension expense gains or losses in that period.
To illustrate the amortization of net gains and losses, assume the following information
for Soft-White, Inc.
ILLUSTRATION 20-16
Corridor Test and
Gain/Loss Amortization
Schedule

Minimum
Projected Amortization
of Loss
(For Current Year)
2017 $2,100,000 $2,600,000 $260,000 $ –0– $ –0–
2018 2,600,000 2,800,000 280,000 400,000 21,818c
2019 2,900,000 2,700,000 290,000 678,182d 70,579d
aAll as of the beginning of the period.
b10% of the greater of projected benefit obligation or plan assets’ market-related value.
c$400,000 – $280,000 = $120,000; $120,000 ÷ 5.5 = $21,818.
d$400,000 – $21,818 + $300,000 = $678,182; $678,182 – $290,000 = $388,182; $388,182 ÷ 5.5 = $70,579.

Benefit Plan Accumulated Year Obligationa Assetsa Corridorb OCI (G/L)a Soft-White recorded in Other Comprehensive Income actuarial losses of $400,000 in
2017 and $300,000 in 2018.
If the average remaining service life of all active employees is 5.5 years, the schedule
to amortize the net gain or loss is as shown in Illustration 20-16.
Beginning of the Year
2017 2018 2019
Projected benefit obligation $2,100,000 $2,600,000 $2,900,000
Market-related asset value 2,600,000 2,800,000 2,700,000
As Illustration 20-16 indicates, the loss recognized in 2018 increased pension expense
by $21,818. This amount is small in comparison with the total loss of $400,000. It indicates that the corridor approach dampens the effects (reduces volatility) of these gains
and losses on pension expense.
The rationale for the corridor is that gains and losses result from refinements in
estimates as well as real changes in economic value. Over time, some of these gains and
losses will offset one another. It therefore seems reasonable that Soft-White should not
fully recognize gains and losses as a component of pension expense in the period in
which they arise.
Gains and Losses 1135
However, Soft-White should immediately recognize in net income certain
gains and losses—if they arise from a single occurrence not directly related to the
operation of the pension plan and not in the ordinary course of the employer’s
business. For example, a gain or loss that is directly related to a plant closing, a disposal of a business component, or a similar event that greatly affects the size of the
employee work force should be recognized as a part of the gain or loss associated
with that event.
For example, at one time, Bethlehem Steel reported a quarterly loss of $477 million.
A great deal of this loss was attributable to future estimated benefits payable to workers
who were permanently laid off. In this situation, the loss should be treated as an adjustment to the gain or loss on the plant closing and should not affect pension cost for the
current or future periods.
Summary of Calculations for Asset Gain or Loss
The difference between the actual return on plan assets and the expected return on plan
assets is the unexpected asset gain or loss component. This component defers the difference between the actual return and expected return on plan assets in computing
current-year pension expense. Thus, after considering this component, it is really the
expected return on plan assets (not the actual return) that determines current pension expense.
Companies determine the amortized net gain or loss by amortizing the Accumulated OCI amount related to net gain or loss at the beginning of the year subject to the
corridor limitation. In other words, if the accumulated gain or loss is greater than
the corridor, these net gains and losses are subject to amortization. Soft-White computed this minimum amortization by dividing the net gains or losses subject to amortization by the average remaining service period. When the current-year unexpected
gain or loss is combined with the amortized net gain or loss, we determine the
current-year gain or loss. Illustration 20-17 summarizes these gain and loss
computations.
ILLUSTRATION 20-17
Graphic Summary of Gain
or Loss Computation

Current Year
Actual Return

=

Current Year
Unexpected Gain
or
Loss
+

=

Current Year
Amortized
Net Gain
or Loss
Current Year
Expected Return

Corridor
Average
Remaining
Service Life
Beginning-ofYear
Accumulated
OCI (G/L)
Current-Year Gain or Loss
=
In essence, these gains and losses are subject to triple smoothing. That is, companies
first smooth the asset gain or loss by using the expected return. Second, they do not
amortize the accumulated gain or loss at the beginning of the year unless it is greater
than the corridor. Finally, they spread the excess over the remaining service life of existing employees.
1136 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
2019 Entries and Worksheet
Continuing the Zarle Company illustration, the following facts apply to the pension
plan for 2019.
• Annual service cost is $13,000.
• Settlement rate is 10 percent; expected earnings rate is 10 percent.
• Actual return on plan assets is $12,000.
• Amortization of prior service cost (PSC) is $20,800.
• Annual funding contributions are $24,000.
• Benefits paid to retirees during the year are $10,500.
• Changes in actuarial assumptions resulted in an end-of-year projected benefit
obligation of $265,000.
The worksheet in Illustration 20-18 presents all of Zarle’s 2019 pension
entries and related information. The first line of the worksheet records the beginning
balances that relate to the pension plan. In this case, Zarle’s beginning balances are
the ending balances from its 2018 pension worksheet in Illustration 20-12 (page
1130).
Entries (m), (n), (o), (q), (r), and (s) are similar to the corresponding entries in 2017
or 2018.
EVOLVING ISSUE BYE BYE CORRIDOR
Many companies have signifi cant actuarial losses in their pension plans, which are presently deferred through use of the corridor approach. However, companies do have a choice—they
may select any method of accounting for these deferred losses
as long as it is systematic, rational, and consistently applied,
and meets a minimum for recognition in the income statement.
Some companies are now shifting away from the corridor
approach and recognizing actuarial losses immediately. For
example, AT&T, Verizon Communications, and Honeywell
International have changed accounting principles from
smoothing these losses to recognizing them in the year incurred.
Companies argue this approach provides more transparency for these losses that will directly affect pension expense in
the current period (and this accounting is also more similar to
IFRS). However, there is a silver lining for these companies—
they can charge many of these deferred losses to past years.
For example, the table at the top of the right-hand column indicates deferred losses as of 2009 for three major companies.
When AT&T changed to immediate recognition in 2010,
it restated its previous years. In 2008, for example, AT&T
increased its pension cost by $24.9 billion, which led to a net
loss in 2008 of $2.6 billion instead of a profi t of $12.9 billion. As
a result, in 2010 it recognized a much smaller pension cost of
$3 billion. Skeptics suggest that AT&T made this change to
charge these losses to prior periods. In other words, does anyone in 2011 care that the profi t in 2008 was changed to a loss?
In addition, once these losses are charged to prior periods,
they no longer affect current and future earnings.
Although earnings in the future will probably be more volatile due to fl uctuations in pension expense, more companies
are willing to move in the direction of immediate expensing to
eliminate large deferred losses which would be a drag on future
income.
Deferred Losses as Losses as % of
of 2009 (in billions) Pension Assets

$23.04 49%
43
$12.20
$7.57 55

AT&T
Verizon
Honeywell
Sources: Michael Rapoport, “Rewriting Pension History,” Wall Street Journal (March 9, 2011); and SEI, “Why Are Pension Plan Sponsors Switching
to Mark-to-Market Accounting?” (October 2013).
Gains and Losses 1137

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G H
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—2019.xls
1 General Journal Entries Memo Record
2
3 Other
Comprehensive Income
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 7 Prior Service
Cost
Gains/Losses
8 Balance, Jan. 1, 2019 212,700 Cr. 78,600 Cr. 134,100 Dr.
9 13,000 Dr. (m) Service cost 13,000 Cr.
10 21,270 Dr. (n) Interest cost 21,270 Cr.
11 12,000 Cr. (o) Actual return 12,000 Dr.
12 1,410 Cr. 1,410 Dr. (p) Unexpected loss
13 20,800 Dr. (q) Amortization of PSC 20,800 Cr.
14 (r) Contributions 24,000 Dr. 24,000 Cr.
15 (s) Benefts 10,500 Dr. 10,500 Cr.
16 28,530 Dr. (t) Liability increase 28,530 Cr.
17
18 41,660 Dr. 29,940 Dr. Journal entry for 2019 26,800 Cr. 24,000 Cr. 20,800 Cr.
19
20 0 Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2018 52,800 Dr.
21 29,940 Dr. Balance, Dec. 31, 2019* 265,000 Cr. 105,400 Cr. 159,600 Dr. 32,000 Dr.
22
23 $32,000 Dr. *Accumulated OCI (PSC)
24 29,940 Dr. Accumulated OCI (G/L)
25 $61,940 Dr. Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2019
26

ILLUSTRATION 20-18
Pension Worksheet—2019
ILLUSTRATION 20-19
Projected Benefi t Obligation
Balance (Unadjusted)

December 31, 2018, PBO balance
Service cost [entry (m)]
$212,700
13,000
Interest cost [entry (n)]
Benefits paid [entry (s)]
21,270
(10,500)

December 31, 2019, PBO balance (before liability increases) $236,470
Entries (o) and (p) are related. We explained the recording of the actual return in
entry (o) in both 2017 and 2018; it is recorded similarly in 2019. In both 2017 and 2018,
Zarle assumed that the actual return on plan assets was equal to the expected return
on plan assets. In 2019, the expected return of $13,410 (the expected rate of return of
10 percent times the beginning-of-the-year plan assets’ balance of $134,100) is higher
than the actual return of $12,000. To smooth pension expense, Zarle defers the unexpected loss of $1,410 ($13,410 – $12,000) by debiting the Other Comprehensive Income
(G/L) account and crediting Pension Expense. As a result of this adjustment, the
expected return on the plan assets is the amount actually used to compute pension
expense.
Entry (t) records the change in the projected benefit obligation resulting from the
change in the actuarial assumptions. As indicated, the actuary has now computed
the ending balance to be $265,000. Given the PBO balance at December 31, 2018, and
the related transactions during 2019, the PBO balance to date is computed as shown in
Illustration 20-19.
The difference between the ending balance of $265,000 and the balance of $236,470
before the liability increase is $28,530 ($265,000 – $236,470). This $28,530 increase in the
1138 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
employer’s liability is an unexpected loss. The journal entry on December 31, 2019, to
record the pension information is as follows.

Pension Expense 41,660
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L)
Cash
29,940 24,000
Other Comprehensive Income (PSC) 20,800
Pension Asset/Liability 26,800

As the 2019 worksheet indicates, the $105,400 balance in the Pension Asset/Liability
account at December 31, 2019, is equal to the net of the balances in the memo accounts.
Illustration 20-20 shows this computation.
14At a minimum, companies must disclose the amount of assets allocated to equities, government and
corporate bonds, mortgage-backed securities, derivatives, and real estate. Also, information on concentrations
of risk must be explained. Finally, fair value disclosures would be required, including classification of
amounts into levels of the fair value hierarchy. [6]
ILLUSTRATION 20-20
Pension Reconciliation
Schedule—December 31,
2019

Projected benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
$(265,000)
159,600

Pension asset/liability $(105,400)
REPORTING PENSION PLANS IN
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
As you might suspect, a phenomenon as significant and complex as pensions involves
extensive reporting and disclosure requirements. We will cover these requirements in
two categories: (1) those within the financial statements, and (2) those within the notes
to the financial statements.
Within the Financial Statements
Recognition of the Net Funded Status of the Pension Plan
Companies must recognize on their balance sheet the overfunded (pension asset) or
underfunded (pension liability) status of their defined benefit pension plan. The overfunded or underfunded status is measured as the difference between the fair value of
the plan assets and the projected benefit obligation.
Classifi cation of Pension Asset or Pension Liability
No portion of a pension asset is reported as a current asset. The excess of the fair value
of the plan assets over the benefit obligation is classified as a noncurrent asset. The rationale for noncurrent classification is that the pension plan assets are restricted. That is,
these assets are used to fund the projected benefit obligation, and therefore noncurrent
classification is appropriate.
The current portion of a net pension liability represents the amount of benefit payments to be paid in the next 12 months (or operating cycle, if longer), if that amount
cannot be funded from existing plan assets. Otherwise, the pension liability is classified
as a noncurrent liability.14
Aggregation of Pension Plans
Some companies have two or more pension plans. In such instances, a question arises as
to whether these multiple plans should be combined and shown as one amount on the
balance sheet. The Board takes the position that all overfunded plans should be combined and shown as a pension asset on the balance sheet. Similarly, if the company has
two or more underfunded plans, the underfunded plans are combined and shown as
one amount on the balance sheet.

LEARNING OBJECTIVE 5
Describe the requirements
for reporting pension plans
in financial statements.

Reporting Pension Plans in Financial Statements 1139
The FASB rejected the alternative of combining all plans and representing the net
amount as a single net asset or net liability. The rationale: A company does not have the
ability to offset excess assets of one plan against underfunded obligations of another
plan. Furthermore, netting all plans is inappropriate because offsetting assets and liabilities is not permitted under GAAP unless a right of offset exists.
To illustrate, assume that Cresci Company has three pension plans as shown in
Illustration 20-21.
ILLUSTRATION 20-21
Multiple Pension Plans’
Funded Status
Pension Assets Projected Benefit Pension
(at Fair Value) Obligation Asset/Liability
Plan A $400,000 $300,000 $100,000 Asset
Plan B 600,000 720,000 120,000 Liability
Plan C 550,000 700,000 150,000 Liability
In this case, Cresci reports a pension plan asset of $100,000 and a pension plan liability of
$270,000 ($120,000 + $150,000).
Actuarial Gains and Losses/Prior Service Cost
Actuarial gains and losses not recognized as part of pension expense are recognized as
increases and decreases in other comprehensive income. The same type of accounting is
also used for prior service cost. The Board requires that the prior service cost arising in
the year of the amendment (which increases the projected benefit obligation) be recognized by an offsetting debit to other comprehensive income. By recognizing both actuarial gains and losses and prior service cost as part of other comprehensive income, the
Board believes that the usefulness of financial statements is enhanced.
To illustrate the presentation of other comprehensive income and related accumulated OCI, assume that Obey Company provides the following information for the year
2017. None of the Accumulated OCI on January 1, 2017, should be amortized in 2017.
Net income for 2017 $100,000
Actuarial liability loss for 2017 60,000
Prior service cost adjustment to provide additional
benefits in December 2017 15,000
Accumulated OCI, January 1, 2017 40,000
Both the actuarial liability loss and the prior service cost adjustment decrease the
funded status of the plan on the balance sheet. This results because the projected benefit
obligation increases. However, neither the actuarial liability loss nor the prior service
cost adjustment affects pension expense in 2017. In subsequent periods, these items will
impact pension expense through amortization.
For Obey Company, the computation of “Other comprehensive loss” for 2017 is as
follows.

Actuarial liability loss
Prior service cost benefit adjustment
Other comprehensive loss
$60,000
15,000
$75,000

ILLUSTRATION 20-22
Computation of Other
Comprehensive Income
ILLUSTRATION 20-23
Computation of
Comprehensive Income

Net income
Other comprehensive loss
Comprehensive income
$100,000
75,000
$ 25,000

The computation of “Comprehensive income” for 2017 is as follows.
As discussed in Chapter 4, the components of other comprehensive income must be
reported in one of two ways: (1) in a second income statement, or (2) in a combined
statement of comprehensive income. Regardless of the format used, net income must be
1140 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
added to other comprehensive income to arrive at comprehensive income. For homework
purposes, use the second income statement approach unless stated otherwise. Earnings per
share information related to comprehensive income is not required.
To illustrate the second income statement approach, assume that Obey Company
has reported a traditional income statement. The comprehensive income statement is
shown in Illustration 20-24.
ILLUSTRATION 20-24
Comprehensive Income
Reporting
OBEY COMPANY
COMPREHENSIVE INCOME STATEMENT
FOR THE YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2017
Net income $100,000
Other comprehensive loss
Actuarial liability loss $60,000
Prior service cost 15,000 75,000
Comprehensive income $ 25,000
The computation of “Accumulated other comprehensive income” as reported in stockholders’ equity at December 31, 2017, is as follows.
ILLUSTRATION 20-25
Computation of
Accumulated Other
Comprehensive Income

Accumulated other comprehensive income, January 1, 2017
Other comprehensive loss
Accumulated other comprehensive loss, December 31, 2017
$40,000
75,000
$35,000

Regardless of the display format for the income statement, the accumulated other
comprehensive loss is reported in the stockholders’ equity section of the balance sheet
of Obey Company as shown in Illustration 20-26. (Illustration 20-26 uses assumed data
for the common stock and retained earnings information.)
ILLUSTRATION 20-26
Reporting of
Accumulated OCI
OBEY COMPANY
BALANCE SHEET
AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2017
(STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY SECTION)
Stockholders’ equity
Common stock $100,000
Retained earnings 60,000
Accumulated other comprehensive loss 35,000
Total stockholders’ equity $125,000
By providing information on the components of comprehensive income as well as total accumulated other comprehensive income, the company communicates all changes in net assets.
In this illustration, it is assumed that the accumulated other comprehensive income
at January 1, 2017, is not adjusted for the amortization of any prior service cost or actuarial gains and losses that would change pension expense. As discussed in the earlier
examples, these items will be amortized into pension expense in future periods.
Within the Notes to the Financial Statements
Pension plans are frequently important to understanding a company’s financial position, results of operations, and cash flows. Therefore, a company discloses the following
information, either in the body of the financial statements or in the notes. [7]
1. A schedule showing all the major components of pension expense. Rationale: Information provided about the components of pension expense helps users better
understand how a company determines pension expense. It also is useful in forecasting a company’s net income.
Reporting Pension Plans in Financial Statements 1141
2. A reconciliation showing how the projected benef t obligation and the fair value of
the plan assets changed from the beginning to the end of the period. Rationale:
Disclosing the projected benef t obligation, the fair value of the plan assets, and
changes in them should help users understand the economics underlying the obligations and resources of these plans. Explaining the changes in the projected beneft
obligation and fair value of plan assets in the form of a reconciliation provides a
more complete disclosure and makes the f nancial statements more understandable.
3. A disclosure of the rates used in measuring the benef t amounts (discount rate,
expected return on plan assets, rate of compensation). Rationale: Disclosure of
these rates permits users to determine the reasonableness of the assumptions
applied in measuring the pension liability and pension expense.
4. A table indicating the allocation of pension plan assets by category (equity securities, debt securities, real estate, and other assets), and showing the percentage of the
fair value to total plan assets. In addition, a company must include a narrative
description of investment policies and strategies, including the target allocation
percentages (if used by the company). Rationale: Such information helps fnancial
statement users evaluate the pension plan’s exposure to market risk and possible
cash flow demands on the company. It also will help users better assess the reasonableness of the company’s expected rate of return assumption.
5. The expected beneft payments to be paid to current plan participants for each of
the next fve fscal years and in the aggregate for the fve fscal years thereafter. Also
required is disclosure of a company’s best estimate of expected contributions to be
paid to the plan during the next year. Rationale: These disclosures provide information related to the cash outfl ows of the company. With this information, fnancial
statement users can better understand the potential cash outflows related to the
pension plan. They can better assess the liquidity and solvency of the company,
which helps in assessing the company’s overall fnancial flexibility.
6. The nature and amount of changes in plan assets and beneft obligations recognized
in net income and in other comprehensive income of each period. Rationale: This
disclosure provides information on pension elements affecting the projected beneft
obligation and plan assets and on whether those amounts have been recognized in
income or deferred to future periods.
7. The accumulated amount of changes in plan assets and beneft obligations that have
been recognized in other comprehensive income and that will be recycled into net
income in future periods. Rationale: This information indicates the pension-related
balances recognized in stockholders’ equity, which will affect future income.
8. The amount of estimated net actuarial gains and losses and prior service costs and
credits that will be amortized from accumulated other comprehensive income into
net income over the next fscal year. Rationale: This information helps users predict
the impact of deferred pension expense items on next year’s income.
In summary, the disclosure requirements are extensive, and purposely so. One factor
that has been a challenge for useful pension reporting has been the lack of consistent terminology. Furthermore, a substantial amount of offsetting is inherent in the measurement
of pension expense and the pension liability. These disclosure requirements are designed
to address these concerns and take some of the mystery out of pension reporting.15
INTERNATIONAL
PERSPECTIVE
The FASB’s proposed
Accounting Standards
Update on presentation
of pension expense,
if adopted, will align
GAAP with IFRS.
UNDERLYING
CONCEPTS
Does it make a difference
to users of fi nancial
statements whether
companies recognize
pension information in
the fi nancial statements
or disclose it only in the
notes? The FASB was
unsure, so in accord
with the full disclosure
principle, it decided to
provide extensive pension plan disclosures.
15As part of its Disclosure Framework project, the FASB has issued two proposed Accounting Standards Updates
(ASUs) intended to improve financial reporting of pensions and other postretirement benefits (discussed in
Appendix 20A). The first ASU would make defined benefit plan disclosures more useful by adding disclosure
requirements (e.g., descriptions of plan benefits and the reasons for significant gains and losses) as requested by
users. The ASU also eliminates less-useful disclosures as indicated by users (e.g., the amount of the accumulated
benefit obligation). The second proposed ASU requires that the servie cost component of pension expense be
reported with other compensation costs. This change in classification will result in only the service cost component
to be eligible for capitalization, for example, as a cost of internally manufactured inventory or a self-constructed
asset. Other components of net pension expense (e.g., interest cost, prior servie cost amortization) will be presented
in the income statement as part of “Other expenses and losses.” The FASB concluded that this change will result in
more useful information, based on input from users indicating that the service cost component of pension expense
is analyzed differently and has different predictive value from the other pension expense components.
1142 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Example of Pension Note Disclosure
In the following sections, we provide examples and explain the key pension disclosure
elements.
Components of Pension Expense
The FASB requires disclosure of the individual pension expense components (derived
from the information in the pension expense worksheet column): (1) service cost,
(2) interest cost, (3) expected return on assets, (4) other gains or losses component, and
(5) prior service cost component. The purpose of such disclosure is to clarify to more
sophisticated readers how companies determine pension expense. Providing information on the components should also be useful in predicting future pension expense.
Illustration 20-27 presents an example of this part of the disclosure. It uses the information from the Zarle illustration, specifically the expense component information from
the worksheets in Illustrations 20-8 (page 1127), 20-12 (page 1130), and 20-18 (page 1137).
ILLUSTRATION 20-27
Summary of Expense
Components—2017,
2018, 2019

ZARLE COMPANY
2017 2018 2019
Components of pension expense
Service cost $ 9,000 $ 9,500 $13,000
Interest cost 10,000 19,200 21,270
Expected return on plan assets (10,000) (11,100) (13,410)*
Amortization of prior service cost –0– 27,200 20,800
Pension expense $ 9,000 $44,800 $41,660
*Note that the expected return must be disclosed, not the actual return. In 2019, the expected
return is $13,410, which is the actual gain ($12,000) adjusted by the unrecognized loss ($1,410).

Funded Status of Plan
Having a reconciliation of the changes in the assets and liabilities from the beginning
of the year to the end of the year, statement readers can better understand the underlying economics of the plan. In essence, this disclosure contains the information in the
pension worksheet for the projected benefit obligation and plan asset columns. Using
the information for Zarle, the schedule in Illustration 20-28 provides an example of the
reconciliation.
UNDERLYING
CONCEPTS
This represents another
compromise between
relevance and faithful
representation. Disclosure
attempts to balance
these objectives.
ILLUSTRATION 20-28
Pension Disclosure for
Zarle Company—2017,
2018, 2019
ZARLE COMPANY
2017 2018 2019
Change in benefit obligation
Benefit obligation at beginning of year $100,000 $112,000 $ 212,700
Service cost 9,000 9,500 13,000
Interest cost 10,000 19,200 21,270
Amendments (Prior service cost) –0– 80,000 –0–
Actuarial loss –0– –0– 28,530
Benefits paid (7,000) (8,000) (10,500)

Benefit obligation at end of year
Change in plan assets
Fair value of plan assets at beginning of year
Actual return on plan assets
112,000
100,000
10,000
Contributions
Benefits paid
8,000
(7,000)

20,000 24,000
Fair value of plan assets at end of year 111,000 134,100 159,600
Funded status (Pension asset/liability) $ (1,000) $ (78,600) $(105,400)
PENSION DISCLOSURE
Reporting Pension Plans in Financial Statements 1143
The 2017 column reveals that Zarle underfunds the projected benefit obligation by
$1,000. The 2018 column reveals that Zarle reports the underfunded liability of $78,600
in the balance sheet. Finally, the 2019 column indicates that Zarle recognizes the underfunded liability of $105,400 in the balance sheet.
2020 Entries and Worksheet—A Comprehensive Example
Incorporating the corridor computation and the required disclosures, we continue the
Zarle Company pension plan accounting based on the following facts for 2020.
• Service cost is $16,000.
• Settlement rate is 10 percent; expected rate of return is 10 percent.
• Actual return on plan assets is $22,000.
• Amortization of prior service cost is $17,600.
• Annual funding contributions are $27,000.
• Benefits paid to retirees during the year are $18,000.
• Average service life of all covered employees is 20 years.
Zarle prepares a worksheet to facilitate accumulation and recording of the components of pension expense and maintenance of amounts related to the pension plan. Illustration 20-29 shows that worksheet, which uses the basic data presented above. Beginningof-the-year 2020 account balances are the December 31, 2019, balances from Zarle’s 2019
pension worksheet in Illustration 20-18 (on page 1137). ILLUSTRATION 20-29
Comprehensive Pension
Worksheet—2020

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G H
P18 fx
Comprehensive Pension Worksheet—2020.xls
1 General Journal Entries Memo Record
2
3 Other
Comprehensive Income
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 7 Prior Service
Cost
Gains/Losses
8 Balance, Dec. 31, 2019 265,000 Cr. 105,400 Cr. 159,600 Dr.
9 16,000 Dr. (aa) Service cost 16,000 Cr.
10 26,500 Dr. (bb) Interest cost 26,500 Cr.
11 22,000 Cr. (cc) Actual return 22,000 Dr.
12 6,040 Dr. 6,040 Cr. (dd) Unexpected gain
13 17,600 Dr. (ee) Amortization of PSC 17,600 Cr.
14 (ff) Contributions 27,000 Dr. 27,000 Cr.
15 (gg) Benefts 18,000 Dr. 18,000 Cr.
16 172 Dr. 172 Cr. (hh) Amortization of loss
17
18 44,312 Dr. 6,212 Cr. Journal entry for 2020 6,500 Dr. 27,000 Cr. 17,600 Cr.
19
20 29,940 Dr. Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2019 32,000 Dr.
21 23,728 Dr. Balance, Dec. 31, 2020* 289,500 Cr. 98,900 Cr. 190,600 Dr. 14,400 Dr.
22
23 $14,400 Dr. *Accumulated OCI (PSC)
24 23,728 Dr. Accumulated OCI (G/L)
25 $38,128 Dr. Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2020
26

1144 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Worksheet Explanations and Entries
Entries (aa) through (gg) are similar to the corresponding entries previously explained
in the prior years’ worksheets, with the exception of entry (dd). In 2019, the expected
return on plan assets exceeded the actual return, producing an unexpected loss. In 2020,
the actual return of $22,000 exceeds the expected return of $15,960 ($159,600 × 10%),
resulting in an unexpected gain of $6,040, entry (dd). By netting the gain of $6,040
against the actual return of $22,000, pension expense is affected only by the expected
return of $15,960.
A new entry (hh) in Zarle’s worksheet results from application of the corridor test
on the accumulated balance of net gain or loss in accumulated other comprehensive
income. Zarle Company begins 2020 with a balance in the net loss account of $29,940.
The company applies the corridor criterion in 2020 to determine whether the balance is
excessive and should be amortized. In 2020, the corridor is 10 percent of the larger of the
beginning-of-the-year projected benefit obligation of $265,000 or the plan asset’s
$159,600 market-related asset value (assumed to be fair value). The corridor for 2020 is
$26,500 ($265,000 × 10%). Because the balance in Accumulated OCI is a net loss of
$29,940, the excess (outside the corridor) is $3,440 ($29,940 – $26,500). Zarle amortizes
the $3,440 excess over the average remaining service life of all employees. Given an
average remaining service life of 20 years, the amortization in 2020 is $172 ($3,440 ÷ 20).
In the 2020 pension worksheet, Zarle debits Pension Expense for $172 and credits that
amount to Other Comprehensive Income (G/L). Illustration 20-30 shows the computation of the $172 amortization charge.
ILLUSTRATION 20-30
Computation of 2020
Amortization Charge
(Corridor Test)
2020 Corridor Test
Net (gain) or loss at beginning of year in accumulated OCI $29,940
10% of larger of PBO or market-related asset value of plan assets (26,500)

Amortizable amount
Average service life of all employees
2020 amortization ($3,440 ÷ 20 years)
$ 3,440
20 years
$172

Zarle formally records pension expense for 2020 as follows.
2020

Pension Expense 44,312
Pension Asset/Liability
Cash
6,500 27,000
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) 6,212
Other Comprehensive Income (PSC) 17,600

Note Disclosure
Illustration 20-31 shows the note disclosure of Zarle’s pension plan for 2020. Note that
this example assumes that the pension liability is noncurrent and that the 2021 adjustment for amortization of the net gain or loss and amortization of prior service cost are
the same as 2020.
Special Issues
The Pension Reform Act of 1974
A classic example of the unfortunate consequences of an underfunded pension plan
is the 1963 shutdown of the Studebaker Automobile operations in South Bend,
Indiana, in which 4,500 workers lost 85 percent of their vested benefits. As a result
of such situations, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974—ERISA—
was passed. The legislation affects virtually every private retirement plan in the
Reporting Pension Plans in Financial Statements 1145
United States. It attempts to safeguard employees’ pension rights by mandating
many pension plan requirements, including minimum funding, participation, and
vesting.
These requirements can influence the employers’ cash flows significantly. Under
this legislation, annual funding is no longer discretionary. An employer now must fund
the plan in accordance with an actuarial funding method that over time will be

ZARLE COMPANY
NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Note D. The company has a pension plan covering substantially all of its employees. The plan is noncon
tributory and provides pension benefits that are based on the employee’s compensation during the three
years immediately preceding retirement. The pension plan’s assets consist of cash, stocks, and bonds.
The company’s funding policy is consistent with the relevant government (ERISA) and tax regulations.
Pension expense for 2020 is comprised of the following components of pension cost.
Total recognized in pension expense and other comprehensive income $20,500
The estimated net actuarial loss and prior service cost for the defined benefit pension plan that will be
amortized from accumulated other comprehensive into pension expense over the next year are estimated
to be the same as this year.
The amount recognized as a long-term liability in the balance sheet is as follows:
Noncurrent liability
Total $38,128
Change in benefit obligation
Benefit obligation at beginning of year $265,000
Service cost 16,000
Interest cost 26,500
Amendments (Prior service cost) –0–
Actuarial gain –0–
Benefits paid (18,000)
Fair value of plan assets at end of year 190,600
Funded status (liability) $ 98,900
The weighted-average discount rate used in determining the 2020 projected benefit obligation
was 10 percent. The rate of increase in future compensation levels used in computing the 2020 projected
benefit obligation was 4.5 percent. The weighted-average expected long-term rate of return on the
plan’s assets was 10 percent.

Service cost $16,000
Interest on projected benefit obligation 26,500
Expected return on plan assets (15,960)
Amortization of prior service cost 17,600
Amortization of net loss 172
Pension expense $44,312
Other changes in plan assets and benefit obligations
recognized in other comprehensive income
Net actuarial gain $ 6,212
Amortization of prior service cost 17,600
Total recognized in other comprehensive income (23,812)
Pension liability $98,900
The amounts recognized in accumulated other comprehensive income related to pensions consist of:
Net actuarial loss $23,728
Prior service cost 14,400
Benefit obligation at end of year 289,500
Change in plan assets
Fair value of plan assets at beginning of year 159,600
Actual return on plan assets 22,000
Contributions 27,000
Benefits paid (18,000)
Components of pension
expense
Amounts recognized in other
comprehensive income
Amounts recognized in the
balance sheet
Reconciliations of pension
liability and plan assets
Funded status of plan
Rates used to estimate
plan elements
ILLUSTRATION 20-31
Minimum Note Disclosure
of Pension Plan, Zarle
Company, 2020
1146 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
sufficient to pay for all pension obligations. If companies do not fund their plans in a
reasonable manner, they may be subject to fines and/or loss of tax deductions.16
The law requires plan administrators to publish a comprehensive description and
summary of their plans, along with detailed annual reports that include many supplementary schedules and statements.
Another important provision of the act is the creation of the Pension Benefit
Guaranty Corporation (PBGC). The PBGC’s purpose is to administer terminated
plans and to impose liens on an employer’s assets for certain unfunded pension liabilities. If a company terminates its pension plan, the PBGC can effectively impose a
lien against the employer’s assets for the excess of the present value of guaranteed
vested benefits over the pension fund assets. This lien generally has had the status of
a tax lien; it takes priority over most other creditorship claims. This section of the act
gives the PBGC the power to force an involuntary termination of a pension plan whenever the risks related to nonpayment of the pension obligation seem too great. Because
ERISA restricts to 30 percent of net worth the lien that the PBGC can impose, the PBGC
must monitor all plans to ensure that net worth is sufficient to meet the pension benefit obligations.
A large number of terminated plans have caused the PBGC to pay out substantial
benefits. Currently the PBGC receives its funding from employers, who contribute a
certain dollar amount for each employee covered under the plan.17
16In 2006, Congress passed the Pension Protection Act. This law has many provisions. One important
aspect of the act is that it forced many companies to expedite their contributions to their pension plans.
One group estimates that companies in the S&P 500 would have had to contribute $47 billion to their
pension plans if the new rules were fully phased in for 2006. That amount is about 57 percent more than
the $30 billion that companies were expecting to contribute to their plans that year. Subsequently,
Congress continues to provide pension funding relief. For example, in the “Moving Ahead for Progress
in the 21st Century” Act (enacted July 6, 2012), companies can use a higher discount rate based on
high-grade bond yields averaged over 25 years, which helps reduce the pension liability and required
contributions.
17Pan American Airlines is a good illustration of how difficult it is to assess when to terminate. When Pan
Am filed for bankruptcy in 1991, it had a pension liability of $900 million. From 1983 to 1991, the IRS gave it
six waivers so it did not have to make contributions. When Pan Am terminated the plan, there was little net
worth left upon which to impose a lien. An additional accounting problem relates to the manner of
disclosing the possible termination of a plan. For example, should Pan Am have disclosed a contingent
liability for its struggling plan? At present this issue is unresolved, and considerable judgment is needed to
analyze a company with these contingent liabilities.
UNDERLYING
CONCEPTS
Many plans are underfunded but still quite
viable. For example, at
one time Loews Corp.
had a $159 million
shortfall, but also had
earnings of $594 million
and a good net worth.
Thus, the going concern
assumption permits
us to ignore pension
underfundings in some
cases because in the
long run they are not
signifi cant.
WHAT DO THE NUMBERS MEAN? WHO GUARANTEES THE GUARANTOR?
The Pension Benefi t Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) in a
recent annual report indicates that its primary mission is to
encourage the continuation and maintenance of voluntary private pension plans. It‘s an obligation which the PBGC takes
seriously. However, the trends are ominous:
• Americans today are spending more years in retirement.
They’re healthier and more active, which is great news.
Unfortunately, pensions haven’t kept up.
• Many businesses, for competitive and other reasons, continue to reduce their support for retirement plans. Some
have switched from a defi ned benefi t plan to a defi ned
contribution plan which costs less and comes with fewer
obligations. Others offer lump-sum cash payments to employees or retirees to settle the employer’s obligations.
• Left on their own, many people save less, as well as invest
and plan less well. They also pay higher fees and they get
lower returns.
• Many people defer retirement but still don’t have enough
money for retirement—and they’re worried. One poll cited
by the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions
Committee says that 92 percent of people think there’s a
retirement crisis. They’re right to be concerned.
Add to these concerns that obligations in pension plans today
greatly exceed pension assets. Finally, the PBGC has a problem as well—a large defi cit in its accounts. The following chart
indicates that downward spiral in the net worth of the PBGC
over the last 12 years as pension payments have exceeded
premiums received.
Reporting Pension Plans in Financial Statements 1147
Pension Terminations
A congressman at one time noted, “Employers are simply treating their employee pension plans like company piggy banks, to be raided at will.” What this congressman was
referring to is the practice of paying off the projected benefit obligation and pocketing
any excess. ERISA prevents companies from recapturing excess assets unless they pay
participants what is owed to them and then terminate the plan. As a result, companies
were buying annuities to pay off the pension claimants and then used the excess funds
for other corporate purposes.18
For example, at one time, pension plan terminations netted $363 million for Occidental Petroleum Corp., $95 million for Stroh’s Brewery Co., $58 million for Kellogg
Co., and $29 million for Western Airlines. Recently, many large companies have terminated their pension plans and captured billions in surplus assets. The U.S. Treasury also
benefits: Federal legislation requires companies to pay an excise tax of anywhere from
20 percent to 50 percent on the gains. All of this is quite legal.19
The accounting issue that arises from these terminations is whether a company
should recognize a gain when pension plan assets revert back to the company (often
called asset reversion transactions). The issue is complex. In some cases, a company
starts a new defined benefit plan after it eliminates the old one. Thus, some contend that
there has been no change in substance but merely a change in form. However, the FASB
18A question exists as to whose money it is. Some argue that the excess funds belong to the employees, not
the employer. In addition, given that the funds have been reverting to the employer, critics charge that
cost-of-living increases and the possibility of other increased benefits are reduced because companies will be
reluctant to use those remaining funds to pay for such increases.
19Another way that companies have reduced their pension obligations is through adoption of cash-balance
plans. These are hybrid plans combining features of defined benefit and defined contribution plans.
Although these plans permit employees to transfer their pension benefits when they change employers (like
a defined contribution plan), they are controversial because the change to a cash-balance plan often reduces
benefits to older workers.
The accounting for cash-balance plans is similar to that for defined benefit plans, because employers bear the
investment risk in cash-balance plans. However, when an employer adopts a cash-balance plan, the measurement
of the future benefit obligation to employees generally is lower, compared to a traditional defined benefit plan.
See A. T. Arcady and F. Mellors, “Cash-Balance Conversions,” Journal of Accountancy (February 2000), pp. 22–28.
PBGC’s Defcit Continues to Rise
(In billions)
2014
5
$10
(5)
(10)
(15)
(20)
(25)
(30)
(35)
(60)
(65)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Surplus Defcit
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
0
Source: http://www.pbgc.gov/about/reports/ar2014.html.
1148 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
disagrees. It requires recognition in earnings of a gain or loss when the employer settles
a pension obligation either by lump-sum cash payments to participants or by purchasing nonparticipating annuity contracts. [8]20
Concluding Observations
Hardly a day goes by without the financial press analyzing in depth some issue related
to pension plans in the United States. This is not surprising, since pension funds exceed
over $22 trillion in assets globally. As you have seen, the accounting issues related to
pension plans are complex. The FASB has clarified many of these issues which should
help users understand the financial implications of a company’s pension plans on its
financial position, results of operations, and cash flows.
20Some companies have established pension poison pills as an anti-takeover measure. These plans require asset
reversions from termination of a plan to benefit employees and retirees rather than the acquiring company. For
a discussion of pension poison pills, see Eugene E. Comiskey and Charles W. Mulford, “Interpreting Pension
Disclosures: A Guide for Lending Officers,” Commercial Lending Review (Winter 1993–94), Vol. 9, No. 1.
21Accounting Trends and Techniques indicates that of its 500 surveyed companies, 317 reported benefit plans
that provide postretirement healthcare benefits. In response to rising healthcare costs and higher premiums
on healthcare insurance, companies are working to get their postretirement benefit costs under control.
22“OPEB” is the acronym frequently used to describe postretirement benefits other than pensions. This term
came into being before the scope of guidance was narrowed from “other postemployment benefits” to
“other postretirement benefits,” thereby excluding postemployment benefits related to severance pay or
wage continuation to disabled, terminated, or laid-off employees.
YOU WILL
WANT TO
READ
THE IFRS
INSIGHTS ON
PAGES 1180–1193
For discussion of
IFRS related to
pension accounting.
IBM’s adoption of the GAAP requirements on postretirement benefits resulted in a
$2.3 billion charge and a historical curiosity—IBM’s first-ever quarterly loss. General
Electric disclosed that its charge for adoption of the same GAAP rules would be
$2.7 billion. AT&T absorbed a $2.1 billion pretax hit for postretirement benefits upon
adoption. What is GAAP in this area, and how could its adoption have so grave an
impact on companies’ earnings?
ACCOUNTING GUIDANCE
After a decade of study, the FASB in December 1990 issued GAAP for “Employers’
Accounting for Postretirement Benefits Other Than Pensions.” [9] It alone was the
cause for the large charges to income cited above. These rules cover healthcare and other
“welfare benefits” provided to retirees, their spouses, dependents, and beneficiaries.21
These other welfare benefits include life insurance offered outside a pension plan;
medical, dental, and eye care; legal and tax services; tuition assistance; day care; and
housing assistance.22 Because healthcare benefits are the largest of the other postretirement benefits, we use this item to illustrate accounting for postretirement benefits.
For many employers (about 95 percent), these GAAP rules required a change from
the predominant practice of accounting for postretirement benefits on a pay-as-you-go
(cash) basis to an accrual basis. Similar to pension accounting, the accrual basis necessitates measuring the employer’s obligation to provide future benefits and accrual of
the cost during the years that the employee provides service.
One of the reasons companies had not prefunded these benefit plans was that payments
to prefund healthcare costs, unlike excess contributions to a pension trust, are not taxdeductible. Another reason was that postretirement healthcare benefits were once perceived
LEARNING OBJECTIVE *6
Identify the differences
between pensions and
postretirement healthcare
benefits.
APPENDIX 20A ACCOUNTING FOR POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS
Appendix 20A: Accounting for Postretirement Benefi ts 1149
to be a low-cost employee benefit that could be changed or eliminated at will and therefore
were not a legal liability. Now, the accounting definition of a liability goes beyond the notion
of a legally enforceable claim; the definition now encompasses equitable or constructive
obligations as well, making it clear that the postretirement benefit promise is a liability.23
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PENSION BENEFITS
AND HEALTHCARE BENEFITS
The FASB used the GAAP rules on pensions as a reference for the accounting prescribed
for healthcare and other nonpension postretirement benefits.24 Why didn’t the FASB
cover these other types of postretirement benefits in the earlier pension accounting
statement? Because the apparent similarities between the two benefits mask some significant differences. Illustration 20A-1 shows these differences.25
23“Elements of Financial Statements,” Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 6 (Stamford, Conn.: 1985),
p. 13, footnote 21.
24Other postemployment (but before retirement) benefits include, but are not limited to, salary continuation,
disability-related benefits, severance benefits, and continuance of healthcare benefits and life insurance for
inactive or former (e.g., terminated, disabled, or deceased) employees or their beneficiaries. These benefits
are accounted for similar to accounting for compensated absences (see Chapter 13). [10]
25D. Gerald Searfoss and Naomi Erickson, “The Big Unfunded Liability: Postretirement Health-Care Benefits,”
Journal of Accountancy (November 1988), pp. 28–39.

Item
Funding
Benefit
Beneficiary
Benefit payable
Predictability
Pensions Healthcare Benefits

Generally funded. Generally not funded.
Well-defined and level dollar Generally uncapped and great
amount. variability.
Retiree (maybe some benefit Retiree, spouse, and other
to surviving spouse). dependents.
Monthly. As needed and used.
Variables are reasonably Utilization difficult to predict.
predictable. Level of cost varies
geographically and fluctuates
over time.
ILLUSTRATION 20A-1
Differences Between
Pensions and
Postretirement
Healthcare Benefi ts
Two of the differences in Illustration 20A-1 highlight why measuring the future
payments for healthcare benefit plans is so much more difficult than for pension plans.
1. Many postretirement plans do not set a limit on healthcare benef ts. No matter how
serious the illness or how long it lasts, the benef ts continue to fl ow. (Even if the
employer uses an insurance company plan, the premiums will escalate according to
the increased benefts provided.)
2. The levels of healthcare beneft use and healthcare costs are diffcult to predict.
Increased longevity, unexpected illnesses (e.g., AIDS, SARS, and avian flu), along
with new medical technologies and cures, cause changes in healthcare utilization.
Additionally, although the fiduciary and reporting standards for employee benefit
funds under government regulations generally cover healthcare benefits, the stringent
minimum vesting, participation, and funding standards that apply to pensions do not
apply to healthcare benefits. Nevertheless, as you will learn, many of the basic concepts
of pensions, and much of the related accounting terminology and measurement methodology, do apply to other postretirement benefits. Therefore, in the following discussion and illustrations, we point out the similarities and differences in the accounting
and reporting for these two types of postretirement benefits.
1150 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS
ACCOUNTING PROVISIONS
Healthcare and other postretirement benefits for current and future retirees and their
dependents are forms of deferred compensation. They are earned through employee
service and are subject to accrual during the years an employee is working.
The period of time over which the postretirement benefit cost accrues is called the
attribution period. It is the period of service during which the employee earns the benefits under the terms of the plan. The attribution period, shown in Illustration 20A-2 for
a hypothetical employee, generally begins when an employee is hired and ends on the
date the employee is eligible to receive the benefits and ceases to earn additional benefits by performing service, the vesting date.26
WHAT DO THE NUMBERS MEAN? OPEBS—HOW BIG ARE THEY?
For many companies, other postretirement benefi t obligations
(OPEBs) are substantial. Generally, OPEBs are not well funded
because companies are not permitted a tax deduction for contributions to the plan assets, as is the case with pensions. That
is, the company may not claim a tax deduction until it makes a
payment to the participant (pay-as-you-go).
Presented below are companies with the largest OPEB
obligations, indicating their relationship with other fi nancial items.
Source: Company reports.
For Year Ended Benef t Obligation % Obligation as a % of
12/31/2014 (in millions) Underfunded Stockholders’ Equity
General Motors

$ 6,625
6,388
100.00%
100.00
30,709 74.45
27,097 91.01
7,306 98.07
4,541 85.22

18.68%
Ford Motor AT&T Verizon Communications Boeing Alcatel-Lucent 76.08
So, how big are OPEB obligations? REALLY big.

Date
of
Hire
(age 29)
Prio
Plan
Amendment
Date
(age 34)
Beginning of
Eligibility
Period
(age 45)
Eligibility
(Vesting)
Date
(age 55)
FASB A ttribut ion Period
r Ser
vice Cost

Estimated
Retirement
Date
(age 61)
ILLUSTRATION 20A-2
Range of Possible
Attribution Periods
26This is a benefit-years-of-service approach (the projected unit credit actuarial cost method). The FASB found no
compelling reason to switch from the traditional pension accounting approach. It rejected the employee’s full
service period (i.e., to the estimated retirement date) because it was unable to identify any approach that would
appropriately attribute benefits beyond the date when an employee attains full eligibility for those benefits.
Employees attain full eligibility by meeting specified age, service, or age and service requirements of the plan.
Obligations Under Postretirement Benefits
In defining the obligation for postretirement benefits, the FASB maintained many concepts similar to pension accounting. It also designed some new and modified terms
specifically for postretirement benefits. Two of the most important of these specialized
Appendix 20A: Accounting for Postretirement Benefi ts 1151
terms are (a) expected postretirement benefit obligation and (b) accumulated postretirement benefit obligation.
The expected postretirement benefit obligation (EPBO) is the actuarial present
value as of a particular date of all benefits a company expects to pay after retirement
to employees and their dependents. Companies do not record the EPBO in the financial
statements, but they do use it in measuring periodic expense.
The accumulated postretirement benefit obligation (APBO) is the actuarial present value of future benefits attributed to employees’ services rendered to a particular
date. The APBO is equal to the EPBO for retirees and active employees fully eligible for
benefits. Before the date an employee achieves full eligibility, the APBO is only a portion
of the EPBO. Or stated another way, the difference between the APBO and the EPBO is
the future service costs of active employees who are not yet fully eligible.
Illustration 20A-3 contrasts the EPBO and the APBO. At the date an employee is
fully eligible (the end of the attribution period), the APBO and the EPBO for that
employee are equal.

EPBO

APBO
Present value of
future benefts
at a particular date
Retirees and dependents
receiving benefts
Active employees fully
eligible for benefts
Active employees not
yet eligible for benefts
ILLUSTRATION 20A-3
APBO and EPBO
Contrasted
Postretirement Expense
Postretirement expense is the employer’s annual expense for postretirement benefits.
Also called net periodic postretirement benefit cost, this expense consists of many of
the familiar components used to compute annual pension expense. The components of
net periodic postretirement benefit cost are as follows. [11] 27
1. Service cost. The portion of the EPBO attributed to employee service during the
period.
2. Interest cost. The increase in the APBO attributable to the passage of time. Companies compute interest cost by applying the beginning-of-the-year discount rate to
the beginning-of-the-year APBO, adjusted for benef t payments to be made during
the period. The discount rate is based on the rates of return on high-quality, fxedincome investments that are currently available.28
27See James R. Wilbert and Kenneth E. Dakdduk, “The New FASB 106: How to Account for Postretirement
Benefits,” Journal of Accountancy (August 1991), pp. 36–41.
28The FASB concluded that the discount rate for measuring the present value of the postretirement benefit
obligation and the service cost component should be the same as that applied to pension measurements. It
chose not to label it the settlement rate, in order to clarify that the objective of the discount rate is to measure
the time value of money.
1152 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
3. Actual return on plan assets. The change in the fair value of the plan’s assets
adjusted for contributions and beneft payments made during the period. Because
companies charge or credit the postretirement expense for the gain or loss on plan
assets (the difference between the actual and the expected return), this component
is actually the expected return.
4. Amortization of prior service cost. The amortization of the cost of retroactive benefts resulting from plan amendments. The typical amortization period, beginning
at the date of the plan amendment, is the remaining service periods through the full
eligibility date.
5. Gains and losses. In general, changes in the APBO resulting from changes in
assumptions or from experience different from that assumed. For funded plans, this
component also includes the difference between actual return and expected return
on plan assets.
ILLUSTRATIVE ACCOUNTING ENTRIES
Like pension accounting, the accounting for postretirement plans must recognize in
the accounts and in the financial statements effects of several significant items. These

items are: LEARNING OBJECTIVE *7
Contrast accounting for
pensions to accounting
for other postretirement
benefits.

1. Expected postretirement benef t obligation (EPBO).
2. Accumulated postretirement benef t obligation (APBO).
3. Postretirement benef t plan assets.
4. Prior service cost.
5. Net gain or loss.
The EPBO is not recognized in the financial statements or disclosed in the notes.
Companies recompute it each year, and the actuary uses it in measuring the annual
service cost. Because of the numerous assumptions and actuarial complexity involved
in measuring annual service cost, we have omitted these computations of the EPBO.
Similar to pensions, companies must recognize in the financial statements items 2
through 5 listed above. In addition, as in pension accounting, companies must know the
exact amount of these items in order to compute postretirement expense. Therefore,
companies use the worksheet like that for pension accounting to record both the formal
general journal entries and the memo entries.
2017 Entries and Worksheet
To illustrate the use of a worksheet in accounting for a postretirement benefits plan,
assume that on January 1, 2017, Quest Company adopts a healthcare benefit plan. The
following facts apply to the postretirement benefits plan for the year 2017.
• Plan assets at fair value on January 1, 2017, are zero.
• Actual and expected returns on plan assets are zero.
• Accumulated postretirement benefit obligation (APBO), January 1, 2017, is zero.
• Service cost is $54,000.
• No prior service cost exists.
• Interest cost on the APBO is zero.
• Funding contributions during the year are $38,000.
• Benefit payments to employees from plan are $28,000.
Using that data, the worksheet in Illustration 20A-4 presents the postretirement
entries for 2017.

Appendix 20A: Accounting for Postretirement Benefi ts 1153
Entry (a) records the service cost component, which increases postretirement
expense $54,000 and increases the liability (APBO) $54,000. Entry (b) records Quest’s
funding of assets to the postretirement fund. The funding decreases cash $38,000 and
increases plan assets $38,000. Entry (c) records the benefit payments made to retirees,
which results in equal $28,000 decreases to the plan assets and the liability (APBO).
Quest’s December 31 adjusting entry formally records the postretirement expense
in 2017, as follows.
December 31, 2017

Postretirement Expense 54,000
Cash 38,000
Postretirement Asset/Liability 16,000

The credit to Postretirement Asset/Liability for $16,000 represents the difference
between the APBO and the plan assets. The $16,000 credit balance is a liability because
the plan is underfunded. The Postretirement Asset/Liability account balance of $16,000
also equals the net of the balances in the memo accounts.
Illustration 20A-5 shows the funded status reported in the balance sheet. (Notice its
similarity to the pension schedule.)

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F
P18 fx
Postretirement Worksheet—2017.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 Postretirement
Asset/Liability
APBO Items Plan Assets Annual
Postretirement
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017
7 54,000 Dr. (a) Service cost 54,000 Cr.
8 (b) Contributions 38,000 Dr. 38,000 Cr.
9 (c) Benefits 28,000 Dr. 28,000 Cr.
10
11 54,000 Dr. Journal entry for 2017 38,000 Cr. 16,000 Cr.*
12 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 26,000 Cr. 10,000 Dr. 16,000 Cr.**
13
14 *$54,000 – $38,000 = $16,000
15 **$26,000 – $10,000 = $16,000
16

ILLUSTRATION 20A-4
Postretirement
Worksheet—2017

Accumulated postretirement benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
Postretirement asset/liability (Credit)
$(26,000)
10,000
$(16,000)

ILLUSTRATION 20A-5
Postretirement
Reconciliation Schedule—
December 31, 2017
Recognition of Gains and Losses
Gains and losses represent changes in the APBO or the value of plan assets. These changes
result either from actual experience different from that expected or from changes in actuarial assumptions. The amortization of these gains and losses follows the approach used
for pensions. That is, the gains and losses are recorded in other comprehensive income.
The Corridor Approach
Consistent with pension accounting, companies amortize the gains and losses in accumulated other comprehensive income as a component of postretirement expense if, at the
1154 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
beginning of the period, they exceed a “corridor” limit. The corridor is measured as the
greater of 10 percent of the APBO or 10 percent of the market-related value of plan assets.
The intent of the corridor approach is to reduce volatility of postretirement expense
by providing a reasonable opportunity for gains and losses to offset over time without
affecting net periodic expense.
Amortization Methods
If the company must amortize gains and losses (beyond the corridor) on postretirement
benefit plans, the minimum amortization amount is the excess gain or loss divided by the
average remaining service life to expected retirement of all active employees. Companies
may use any systematic method of amortization provided that: (1) the amount amortized in
any period is equal to or greater than the minimum amount, (2) the company applies the
method consistently, and (3) the company applies the method similarly for gains and losses.
The company must recompute the amount of gain or loss in accumulated other
comprehensive income each year and amortize the gain or loss over the average remaining service life if the net amount exceeds the “corridor.”
2018 Entries and Worksheet
Continuing the Quest Company illustration into 2018, the following facts apply to the
postretirement benefits plan for the year 2018.
• Actual return on plan assets is $600.
• Expected return on plan assets is $800.
• Discount rate is 8 percent.
• Increase in APBO due to change in actuarial assumptions is $60,000.
• Service cost is $26,000.
• Funding contributions during the year are $18,000.
• Benefit payments to employees during the year are $5,000.
• Average remaining service to expected retirement: 25 years.
The worksheet in Illustration 20A-6 presents all of Quest’s postretirement benefit
entries and information for 2018. The beginning balances on the first line of the

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G
P18 fx
Postretirement Benefits Worksheet—2018.xls
1 Memo Record
General Journal Entries
2
3 Postretirement
Asset/Liability
Other
Comprehensive
Income (G/L)
APBO Items Plan Assets Annual
Postretirement
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 26,000 Cr. 10,000 Dr. Balance, Jan. 1, 2018 16,000 Cr.
7 26,000 Dr. 26,000 Cr. (d) Service cost
8 2,080 Dr. 2,080 Cr. (e) Interest cost
9 600 Cr. 600 Dr. (f) Actual return
10 200 Cr. (g) Unexpected loss 200 Dr.
11 18,000 Dr. (h) Contributions 18,000 Cr.
12 5,000 Dr. 5,000 Cr. (i) Benefts
13 60,000 Cr. (j) Increase in APBO (Loss) 60,000 Dr.
14 27,280 Dr. Journal entry for 2018 18,000 Cr. 60,200 Dr. 69,480 Cr.
15
16 Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2017 0
17 109,080 Cr. 23,600 Dr. Balance, Dec. 31, 2018 60,200 Dr. 85,480 Cr.
18

ILLUSTRATION 20A-6
Postretirement Benefi ts
Worksheet—2018
Appendix 20A: Accounting for Postretirement Benefi ts 1155
worksheet are the ending balances from Quest’s 2017 postretirement benefits worksheet
in Illustration 20A-4 (on page 1153).
Entries (d), (h), and (i) are similar to the corresponding entries previously explained
for 2017. Entry (e) accrues the interest expense component, which increases both the
liability and the postretirement expense by $2,080 (the beginning APBO multiplied by
the discount rate of 8%). Entries (f) and (g) are related. The expected return of $800 is
higher than the actual return of $600. To smooth postretirement expense, Quest defers
the unexpected loss of $200 ($800 – $600) by debiting Other Comprehensive Income
(G/L) and crediting Postretirement Expense. As a result of this adjustment, the expected
return on the plan assets is the amount actually used to compute postretirement expense.
Entry (j) records the change in the APBO resulting from a change in actuarial
assumptions. This $60,000 increase in the employer’s accumulated liability is an unexpected loss. Quest debits this loss to Other Comprehensive Income (G/L).
On December 31, Quest formally records net periodic expense for 2018 as follows.
December 31, 2018

Postretirement Expense 27,280
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L)
Cash
60,200 18,000
Postretirement Asset/Liability 69,480

The balance of the Postretirement Asset/Liability account at December 31, 2018, is
$85,480. This balance is equal to the net of the balances in the memo accounts as shown
in the reconciliation schedule in Illustration 20A-7.

Accumulated postretirement benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
Postretirement asset/liability (Credit)
$(109,080)
23,600
$ (85,480)

ILLUSTRATION 20A-7
Postretirement Benefi ts
Reconciliation Schedule—
December 31, 2018
Amortization of Net Gain or Loss in 2019
Quest has a beginning balance in Accumulated OCI related to losses of $60,200. Therefore, Quest must apply the corridor test for amortization of the balance for 2019. Illustration 20A-8 shows the computation of the amortization charge for the loss.
ILLUSTRATION 20A-8
Computation of
Amortization Charge
(Corridor Test)—2019
2019 Corridor Test

Accumulated OCI at beginning of year
10% of greater of APBO or market-related value
of plan assets ($109,080 ×.10)
Amortizable amount
Average remaining service to expected retirement
2019 amortization of loss ($49,292 ÷ 25)
$60,200
(10,908)
$49,292
25 years
$1,972

DISCLOSURES IN NOTES TO THE
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
The disclosures required for other postretirement benefit plans are similar to and just as
detailed and extensive as those required for pensions. The note disclosure for Tootsie
Roll, Inc. in Illustration 20A-9 (page 1156) provides a good example of the extensive
disclosure required for other postretirement benefit plans.
As indicated in Illustration 20A-9, Tootsie Roll shows the impact of the postretirement benefit plan on income, the balance sheet, and the cash flow statement, and it
1156 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
ILLUSTRATION 20A-9
Postretirement Benefi t
Disclosure
Amounts recognized in other
comprehensive income
Reconciliation of OPEB
liability
Components of OPEB
expense
Expected benefit
payments
Tootsie Roll Industries, Inc.
Notes to Financial Statements
Note 7 Employee Benefit Plans (partial)
Postretirement health care benefit plans:
During fourth quarter 2013, the Company restructured and amended its post-retirement health benefits
plan provided to corporate office and management employees. These changes resulted in a negative plan
amendment, as defined by accounting guidance, resulting in a $10,425 reduction in the Company’s benefit obligation as of December 31, 2013. The plan changes generally limited future annual cost increases
in health benefits to 3%, restricted this benefit to current employees with long-term service with the
Company, eliminated the Company provided life insurance benefit and required retirees to pay the full
cost of life insurance, and eliminated all post-retirement benefits for future employees effective April 1,
2014. Post-retirement benefits liabilities (as amended) were $12,311 and $9,176 at December 31, 2014
and 2013, respectively. The aforementioned increase reflects actuarial losses relating to an 86 basis point
decrease in the discount rate (3.83% discount rate used at December 31, 2014) which generally reflects
lower market interest rates, and an update of the mortality table based on the Society of Actuaries’ research that indicates that retirees are living longer.
Amounts recognized in accumulated other comprehensive loss (pre-tax) at December 31, 2014 are as
follows:

Prior service credit
Net actuarial loss
$ (9,449)
(892)

Net amount recognized in accumulated other comprehensive (gain) loss $(10,341)
The estimated actuarial loss (gain) and prior service credit (gain) to be amortized from accumulated other
comprehensive loss (gain) into net periodic benefit cost during 2015 are $(101) and $(1,352), respectively.
The changes in the accumulated postretirement benefit obligation at December 31, 2014 and 2013 consist of the following:
December 31
2014 2013
Benefit obligation, beginning of year $ 9,176 $27,381
Service cost 342 1,036
Interest cost 423 1,060
Plan amendments — (10,425)
Actuarial (gain)/loss 2,611 (9,734)
Benefits paid (241) (142)
Benefit obligation, end of year $12,311 $ 9,176
Net periodic postretirement benefit cost included the following components:
2014 2013 2012
Service cost—benefits attributed to service during the period $ 342 $1,036 $1,034
Interest cost on the accumulated postretirement benefit obligation 423 1,060 1,113
Net amortization (1,804) 671 1,036
Net periodic postretirement benefit cost (income) $(1,039) $2,767 $3,183
The Company estimates future benefit payments will be $328, $367, $412, $451 and $501 in 2015 through
2019, respectively, and a total of $3,119 in 2020 through 2024. As a result of the plan changes, the Company will no longer qualify for the Medicare Part D retiree drugs subsidy which have historically not been
significant.
provides information on important assumptions used in the measurement of the postretirement benefit obligation. Also note that given no tax incentives for funding, Tootsie
Roll (like many companies) does not have any assets set aside for its other postretirement benefit obligations.
While Tootsie Roll has only an other postretirement benefit plan, many companies
sponsor both defined benefit pension and other postretirement plans. Given the
Appendix 20A: Accounting for Postretirement Benefi ts 1157
similarities in accounting for these plans, companies can combine pension and other
postretirement benefit disclosures.
ACTUARIAL ASSUMPTIONS
AND CONCEPTUAL ISSUES
Measurement of the EPBO, the APBO, and the net periodic postretirement benefit cost
is involved and complex. Due to the uncertainties in forecasting healthcare costs, rates
of use, changes in government health programs, and the differences employed in nonmedical assumptions (e.g., discount rate, employee turnover, rate of pre-65 retirement,
spouse-age difference), estimates of postretirement benefit costs may have a large margin of error. Is the information relevant, reliable, or verifiable? The FASB concluded that
“the obligation to provide postretirement benefits meets the definition of a liability, is
representationally faithful, is relevant to financial statement users, and can be measured
with sufficient reliability at a justifiable cost.” [12] Failure to accrue an obligation and
an expense prior to payment of benefits would result in an unfaithful representation of
what financial statements should represent.
The FASB took a momentous step by requiring recognition of a postretirement
liability. Many opposed the requirement, warning that the GAAP rules would devastate
earnings. Others argued that putting these numbers on the balance sheet was inappropriate. Others noted that the requirement would force companies to curtail postretirement benefits to employees.
The authors believe that the FASB deserves special praise. Because the Board
addressed this issue, companies now recognize the magnitude of these costs. This recognition has led to efforts to control escalating healthcare costs. As John Ruffle, a former
president of the Financial Accounting Foundation noted, “The Board has done American
industry a gigantic favor. Over the long term, industry will look back and say thanks.”
WHAT DO THE NUMBERS MEAN? WANT SOME BAD NEWS?
Many companies have underfunded pension and other postretirement plans. Unfortunately, many governmental entities also
have the same problem but on a much larger scale. Here are
some examples.
• The actual liabilities of the federal government—including
Social Security, Medicare, and federal employees’ future
retirement benefi ts—is estimated to be over $100 trillion.
When the accrued expenses of the government’s entitled programs are counted, we need to collect well over
$8 trillion in tax revenues annually. Even if you take all the
taxable income of corporations and of individuals earning
over approximately $66,000, that still falls short of the
$8 trillion.
• A State Budget Crisis Task Force declared underfunded
retirement promises as one of the six major threats to
states’ “fi scal sustainability.”
• State-run pension funds faced a $968 billion shortfall
in 2013, up $54 billion from 2012. When local pension
shortfalls are factored in, the total pension funding gap
surpasses $1 trillion.
So what does all this have to do with accounting? Similar
to the FASB, there is an organization called the Governmental
Accounting Standards Board (GASB), which establishes standards of fi nancial accounting and reporting for state and local
governmental agencies.
Until recently, the GASB went about its work in relative
obscurity. How did the GASB get everyone’s attention? It
recently required that governmental units recognize postretirement benefi ts on their balance sheets on an accrual basis.
Some states do not like this requirement and have proposed
legislation that will allow them to ignore GASB standards.
However, the GASB, with the support of users of government
reports, has pushed for the change. They are concerned that
without the new requirements, governments will continue to
misrepresent the true cost of their retirement-related promises
to public employees. In their view, the new accounting rules are
in the best interests of municipal bondholders and the public
in general. Thus, it appears that the FASB is not the only
standard-setter subject to political pressure.
Sources: R. H. Attmore, “Who Do Texas Elected Officials Think They Are Fooling?” The Bond Buyer (June 18, 2007); Chris Cox and Bill Archer, “Why
$16 Trillion Only Hints at the True U.S. Debt,” Wall Street Journal (November 27, 2012); “More Bad News for Public Pensions,” Wall Street Journal
(July 12, 2012); and http://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/issue-briefs/2015/07/the-state-pensions-funding-gap-challenges-persist. For
more information on the GASB, go to www.gasb.org/.
1158 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
REVIEW AND PRACTICE
KEY TERMS REVIEW
accumulated benefit
obligation, 1121
accumulated postretirement *
benefit obligation
(APBO), 1151
actual return on plan
assets, 1125
actuarial present value, 1122(n)
actuaries, 1121
asset gains and losses, 1132
*attribution period, 1150
cash-balance plans, 1147(n)
components of pension
expense, 1124
contributory pension
plan, 1118
corridor approach, 1133, 1154
defined benefit plan, 1119
defined contribution
plan, 1119
ERISA, 1144
*expected postretirement
benefit obligation
(EPBO), 1151
expected rate of return, 1131
expected return on plan
assets, 1132
fair value of plan
assets, 1126
funded pension plan, 1118
funded status (overfunded
or underfunded), 1122
interest on the liability
(interest expense), 1125
liability gains and losses,
1132
market-related asset
value, 1132
noncontributory pension
plan, 1118
Other Comprehensive
Income (G/L), 1132
Other Comprehensive
Income (PSC), 1131
pension asset/liability,
1126
pension plan, 1118
pension worksheet, 1126
prior service cost (PSC), 1128
projected benefit
obligation, 1121
qualified pension plan, 1118
reconciliation, 1141
retroactive benefits, 1128
service cost, 1124
settlement rate, 1125
unexpected gain or
loss, 1132
vested benefit obligation,
1121
vested benefits, 1121
years-of-service method,
1129
LEARNING OBJECTIVES REVIEW
1 Understand the fundamentals of pension plan accounting. The company or employer is the organization sponsoring the
pension plan. It incurs the cost and makes contributions to the pension fund. The fund or plan is the entity that receives the contributions from the employer, administers the pension assets, and makes the benefit payments to the pension recipients (retired employees). The fund should be a separate legal and accounting entity; it maintains a set of books and prepares financial statements.
The two most common types of pension arrangements are as follows. (1) Defined contribution plans: The employer
agrees to contribute to a pension trust a certain sum each period based on a formula. This formula may consider such factors
as age, length of employee service, employer’s profits, and compensation level. Only the employer’s contribution is defined;
no promise is made regarding the ultimate benefits paid out to the employees. (2) Defined benefit plans: These plans define
the benefits that the employee will receive at the time of retirement. The formula typically provides for the benefits to be a
function of the employee’s years of service and the compensation level when he or she nears retirement.
Alternative measures for valuing the pension obligation may be used. One measure bases the pension obligation only
on the benefits vested to the employees. Vested benefits are those that the employee is entitled to receive even if he or she
renders no additional services under the plan. Companies compute the vested benefit pension obligation using current
salary levels; this obligation includes only vested benefits. Another measure of the obligation, called the accumulated benefit
obligation, computes the deferred compensation amount based on all years of service performed by employees under the
plan—both vested and nonvested—using current salary levels. A third measure, called the projected benefit obligation,
bases the computation of the deferred compensation amount on both vested and nonvested service using future salaries.
Pension expense is a function of the following components: (1) service cost, (2) interest on the liability, (3) return on plan
assets, (4) amortization of prior service cost, and (5) gain or loss.
2 Use a worksheet for employer’s pension plan entries. Companies may use a worksheet unique to pension accounting.
This worksheet records both the formal entries and the memo entries to keep track of all the employer’s relevant pension plan
items and components.
3 Describe the accounting and amortization of prior service costs. An actuary computes the amount of the prior
service cost, and the company then records it as an adjustment to the projected benefit obligation and other comprehensive
income. It then amortizes it, generally using a “years-of-service” amortization method, similar to a units-of-production computation. First, the company computes total estimated number of service-years to be worked by all of the participating
employees. Second, it divides the accumulated prior service cost by the total number of service-years, to obtain a cost per
service-year (the unit cost). Third, the company multiplies the number of service-years consumed each year times the cost per
service-year, to obtain the annual amortization charge.
4 Explain the accounting and amortization for unexpected gains and losses. In estimating the projected benefit
obligation (the liability), actuaries make assumptions about such items as mortality rate, retirement rate, turnover rate,
disability rate, and salary amounts. Any change in these actuarial assumptions affects the amount of the projected benefit
obligation. These unexpected gains or losses from changes in the projected benefit obligation are liability gains and losses.
Liability gains result from unexpected decreases in the liability balance; liability losses result from unexpected increases. Companies also incur asset gains or losses. Both types of actuarial gains and losses are recorded in other comprehensive income
and adjust either the projected benefit obligation or the plan assets.
The FASB set a limit for the size of an accumulated net gain or loss balance. That arbitrarily selected limit (called a corridor)
is 10 percent of the larger of the beginning balances of the projected benefit obligation or the market-related value of the plan
assets. Beyond that limit, an accumulated net gain or loss balance is considered too large and must be amortized. If the balance
of the accumulated net gain or loss account stays within the upper and lower limits of the corridor, no amortization is required.
5 Describe the requirements for reporting pension plans in financial statements. Currently, companies must disclose the following pension plan information in their financial statements. (1) The components of pension expense for the
period. (2) A schedule showing changes in the benefit obligation and plan assets during the year. (3) The amount of prior
service cost and net gains and losses in accumulated OCI, including the estimated prior service cost and gains and losses that
will affect net income in the next year. (4) The weighted-average assumed discount rate, the rate of compensation increase
used to measure the projected benefit obligation, and the weighted-average expected long-term rate of return on plan assets.
(5) A table showing the allocation of pension plan assets by category and the percentage of the fair value to total plan assets.
(6) The expected benefit payments for current plan participants for each of the next five fiscal years and for the following five
years in aggregate, along with an estimate of expected contributions to the plan during the next year.
6 Identify the differences between pensions and postretirement healthcare benefits. Pension plans are generally
funded, but healthcare benefit plans are not. Pension benefits are generally well-defined and level in amount; healthcare benefits are generally uncapped and variable. Pension benefits are payable monthly; healthcare benefits are paid as needed and
used. Pension plan variables are reasonably predictable, whereas healthcare plan variables are difficult to predict.
7 Contrast accounting for pensions to accounting for other postretirement benefits. Many of the basic concepts,
accounting terminology, and measurement methodology that apply to pensions also apply to other postretirement benefit
accounting. Because other postretirement benefit plans are unfunded, large obligations can occur. Two significant concepts
peculiar to accounting for other postretirement benefits are (1) expected postretirement benefit obligation (EPBO) and
(2) accumulated postretirement benefit obligation (APBO).
* *
Practice Problem 1159
ENHANCED REVIEW AND PRACTICE
Go online for multiple-choice questions with solutions, review exercises with solutions, and a full
glossary of all key terms.
PRACTICE PROBLEM
Jablonski Corp. sponsors a defined benefit pension plan for its employees. On January 1, 2017, the following balances related to
this plan.

Plan assets (market-related value)
Projected beneft obligation
Pension asset/liability
Prior service cost
$170,000
340,000
170,000 Cr.
100,000
OCI—Loss 39,000

As a result of the operation of the plan during 2017, the actuary provided the following additional data at December 31, 2017.

Service cost for 2017
Actual return on plan assets in 2017
$45,000
27,000
Amortization of prior service cost 20,000
Contributions in 2017 85,000
Benef ts paid retirees in 2017
Settlement rate
Expected return on plan assets
Average remaining service life of active employees
51,000
7%
8%
10 years

Instructions
(a) Compute pension expense for Jablonski Corp. for the year 2017 by preparing a pension worksheet that shows the journal
entry for pension expense.
(b) Indicate the pension amounts reported in the financial statements.
1160 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
SOLUTION
(a)

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G H
P18 fx
Jablonski Corp.xls
1 Memo Record JABLONSKI CORP.
Pension Worksheet—2017
General Journal Entries
2
3
4
5 Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash Other
Comprehensive Income
6
7 Prior Service Cost Gain/Loss
8 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017 340,000 Cr. 170,000 Cr. 170,000 Dr.
9 45,000 Dr. Service cost 45,000 Cr.
10 23,800 Dr. Interest cost* 23,800 Cr.
11 27,000 Cr. Actual return 27,000 Dr.
12 13,400 Dr. 13,400 Cr. Unexpected gain**
13 20,000 Dr. Amortization of PSC 20,000 Cr.
14 500 Dr. 500 Cr. Amortization of loss***
15 Contributions 85,000 Dr. 85,000 Cr.
16 Benefts 51,000 Dr. 51,000 Cr.
17 75,700 Dr. 13,900 Cr. Journal entry for 2017 43,200 Dr. 85,000 Cr. 20,000 Cr.
18 39,000 Dr. Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2016 100,000 Dr.
19 25,100 Dr. Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 357,800 Cr. 126,800 Cr. 231,000 Dr. 80,000 Dr.
20
21 *$23,800 = $340,000 × .07
22 **$13,400 = ($170,000 × .08) – $27,000
23 ***
1/1 Projected
Minimum
24 Beneft Value of 1/1 10% Accumulated Amortization of Loss for
25 Year
Obligation
Plan Assets Corridor OCI (G/L), 1/1 2017
26 2017
$340,000
$170,000 $34,000 $39,000 $500****
27 **** ($39,000 – $34,000) = $5,000 ÷ 10 = $500

2017

Pension Expense 75,700
Pension Asset/Liability 43,200

Other Comprehensive Income (PSC) 20,000
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) 13,900
Cash 85,000
(b) The pension amounts reported in the 2017 f nancial statements are as follows.
Income Statement
Pension expense $ 75,700
Comprehensive Income Statement
Net income $ XXXX
Other comprehensive income

Asset gain
Amortization of loss
$13,400
500
Prior service cost amortization
Comprehensive income
20,000
Balance Sheet
Liabilities

$ XXXX
Pension liability $126,800
Stockholders’ equity
Accumulated other comprehensive loss (PSC) 80,000
Accumulated other comprehensive loss (G/L) 25,100
Note: All asterisked Questions, Exercises, and Problems relate to material in the appendix to the chapter.
QUESTIONS
1. What is a private pension plan? How does a contributory
pension plan differ from a noncontributory plan?
2. Differentiate between a defined contribution pension
plan and a defined benefit pension plan. Explain how the
employer’s obligation differs between the two types of
plans.
3. Differentiate between “accounting for the employer” and
“accounting for the pension fund.”
4. The meaning of the term “fund” depends on the context
in which it is used. Explain its meaning when used as a
noun. Explain its meaning when it is used as a verb.
5. What is the role of an actuary relative to pension plans?
What are actuarial assumptions?
6. What factors must be considered by the actuary in measuring the amount of pension benefits under a defined
benefit plan?
7. Name three approaches to measuring benefit obligations
from a pension plan and explain how they differ.
8. Explain how cash-basis accounting for pension plans differs from accrual-basis accounting for pension plans.
Why is cash-basis accounting generally considered unacceptable for pension plan accounting?
9. Identify the five components that comprise pension
expense. Briefly explain the nature of each component.
10. What is service cost, and what is the basis of its measurement?
11. In computing the interest component of pension expense,
what interest rates may be used?
12. Explain the difference between service cost and prior service cost.
13. What is meant by “prior service cost”? When is prior service cost recognized as pension expense?
14. What are “liability gains and losses,” and how are they
accounted for?
15. If pension expense recognized in a period exceeds the
current amount funded by the employer, what kind of
account arises, and how should it be reported in the
financial statements? If the reverse occurs—that is, current funding by the employer exceeds the amount recognized as pension expense—what kind of account arises,
and how should it be reported?
16. Given the following items and amounts, compute the
actual return on plan assets: fair value of plan assets at
the beginning of the period $9,500,000; benefits paid during the period $1,400,000; contributions made during the
period $1,000,000; and fair value of the plan assets at the
end of the period $10,150,000.
17. How does an “asset gain or loss” develop in pension
accounting? How does a “liability gain or loss” develop
in pension accounting?
18. What is the meaning of “corridor amortization”?
19. At the end of the current period, Agler Inc. had a
projected benefit obligation of $400,000 and pension
plan assets (at fair value) of $350,000. What are the
accounts and amounts that will be reported on the
company’s balance sheet as pension assets or pension
liabilities?
20. At the end of the current year, Pociek Co. has prior service cost of $9,150,000. Where should the prior service
cost be reported on the balance sheet?
21. Describe the accounting for actuarial gains and losses.
22. Boey Company reported net income of $25,000 in 2018. It
had the following amounts related to its pension plan in
2018: Actuarial liability gain $10,000; Unexpected asset
loss $14,000; Accumulated other comprehensive income
(G/L) (beginning balance), zero. Determine for 2018
(a) Boey’s other comprehensive income, and (b) comprehensive income.
23. Describe the reporting of pension plans for a company
with multiple plans, some of which are underfunded and
some of which are overfunded.
24. Determine the meaning of the following terms.
(a) Contributory plan.
(b) Vested benefits.
(c) Retroactive benefits.
(d) Years-of-service method.
25. A headline in the Wall Street Journal stated, “Firms
Increasingly Tap Their Pension Funds to Use Excess
Assets.” What is the accounting issue related to the use of
these “excess assets” through plan terminations?
26. What are postretirement benefits other than pensions?
27. Why didn’t the FASB cover both types of postretirement
benefits—pensions and healthcare—in the earlier pension
accounting rules?
28. What are the major differences between postretirement
healthcare benefits and pension benefits?
29. What is the difference between the APBO and the
EPBO? What are the components of postretirement
expense?
* * * *
Exercises, Problems, Problem Solution Walkthrough Videos, and many more assessment
tools and resources are available for practice in WileyPLUS.
Questions 1161
1162 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
BRIEF EXERCISES
BE20-1 (L01) AMR Corporation (parent company of American Airlines) reported the following (in millions).
Service cost $366
Interest on P.B.O. 737
Return on plan assets 593
Amortization of prior service cost 13
Amortization of net loss 154
Compute AMR Corporation’s pension expense.
BE20-2 (L01) For Warren Corporation, year-end plan assets were $2,000,000. At the beginning of the year, plan assets were
$1,780,000. During the year, contributions to the pension fund were $120,000, and benefits paid were $200,000. Compute
Warren’s actual return on plan assets.
BE20-3 (L02) At January 1, 2017, Hennein Company had plan assets of $280,000 and a projected benefit obligation of the same
amount. During 2017, service cost was $27,500, the settlement rate was 10%, actual and expected return on plan assets were
$25,000, contributions were $20,000, and benefits paid were $17,500. Prepare a pension worksheet for Hennein Company for 2017.
BE20-4 (L02) Campbell Soup Company reported pension expense of $73 million and contributed $71 million to the pension
fund. Prepare Campbell Soup Company’s journal entry to record pension expense and funding, assuming Campbell has no OCI
amounts.
BE20-5 (L03) Mancuso Corporation amended its pension plan on January 1, 2017, and granted $160,000 of prior service costs
to its employees. The employees are expected to provide 2,000 service years in the future, with 350 service years in 2017. Compute prior service cost amortization for 2017.
BE20-6 (L03) At December 31, 2017, Besler Corporation had a projected benefit obligation of $560,000, plan assets of $322,000,
and prior service cost of $127,000 in accumulated other comprehensive income. Determine the pension asset/liability at December 31, 2017.
BE20-7 (L04) Shin Corporation had a projected benefit obligation of $3,100,000 and plan assets of $3,300,000 at January 1,
2017. Shin also had a net actuarial loss of $465,000 in accumulated OCI at January 1, 2017. The average remaining service period
of Shin’s employees is 7.5 years. Compute Shin’s minimum amortization of the actuarial loss.
BE20-8 (L05) Hawkins Corporation has the following balances at December 31, 2017.

Projected beneft obligation
Plan assets at fair value
$2,600,000
2,000,000
Accumulated OCI (PSC) 1,100,000

How should these balances be reported on Hawkins’ balance sheet at December 31, 2017?
BE20-9 (L05) Norton Co. had the following amounts related to its pension plan in 2017.

Actuarial liability loss for 2017
Unexpected asset gain for 2017
Accumulated other comprehensive income (G/L) (beginning balance)
$28,000
18,000
7,000 Cr.

Determine for 2017 (a) Norton’s other comprehensive income (loss) and (b) comprehensive income. Net income for 2017 is
$26,000; no amortization of gain or loss is necessary in 2017.
BE20-10 (L05) Lahey Corp. has three defined benefit pension plans as follows.

Pension Assets Projected Beneft
(at Fair Value) Obligation
Plan X
Plan Y
$600,000
900,000
$500,000
720,000
Plan Z 550,000 700,000

How will Lahey report these multiple plans in its financial statements?
BE20-11 (L06,7) Manno Corporation has the following information available concerning its postretirement benefit plan
for 2017.

Service cost
Interest cost
$40,000
47,400
Actual and expected return on plan assets 26,900

Compute Manno’s 2017 postretirement expense.
*
*BE20-12 (L06,7) For 2017, Sampsell Inc. computed its annual postretirement expense as $240,900. Sampsell’s contribution to
the plan during 2017 was $180,000. Prepare Sampsell’s 2017 entry to record postretirement expense, assuming Sampsell has no
OCI amounts.
EXERCISES
E20-1 (L01,2) EXCEL (Pension Expense, Journal Entries) The following information is available for the pension plan of
Radcliffe Company for the year 2017.

Actual and expected return on plan assets
Benef ts paid to retirees
$ 15,000
40,000
Contributions (funding)
Interest/discount rate
Prior service cost amortization
90,000
10%
8,000
Projected benef t obligation, January 1, 2017
Service cost
500,000
60,000

Instructions
(a) Compute pension expense for the year 2017.
(b) Prepare the journal entry to record pension expense and the employer’s contribution to the pension plan in 2017.
E20-2 (L01,2,3) (Computation of Pension Expense) Veldre Company provides the following information about its defined
benefit pension plan for the year 2017.

Service cost
Contribution to the plan
$ 90,000
105,000
Prior service cost amortization 10,000
Actual and expected return on plan assets 64,000
Benefts paid 40,000
Plan assets at January 1, 2017 640,000
Projected benef t obligation at January 1, 2017
Accumulated OCI (PSC) at January 1, 2017
Interest/discount (settlement) rate
700,000
150,000
10%

Instructions
Compute the pension expense for the year 2017.
E20-3 (L01,2,3) (Preparation of Pension Worksheet) Using the information in E20-2, prepare a pension worksheet inserting January 1, 2017, balances, showing December 31, 2017, balances, and the journal entry recording pension expense.
E20-4 (L01,2) (Basic Pension Worksheet) The following facts apply to the pension plan of Boudreau Inc. for the year 2017.

Plan assets, January 1, 2017
Projected benef t obligation, January 1, 2017
Settlement rate
Service cost
$490,000
490,000
8%
40,000
Contributions (funding) 25,000
Actual and expected return on plan assets 49,700
Benef ts paid to retirees 33,400

Instructions
Using the preceding data, compute pension expense for the year 2017. As part of your solution, prepare a pension worksheet
that shows the journal entry for pension expense for 2017 and the year-end balances in the related pension accounts.
E20-5 (L03) (Application of Years-of-Service Method) Andrews Company has five employees participating in its defined
benefit pension plan. Expected years of future service for these employees at the beginning of 2017 are as follows.
Future
Employee Years of Service
Jim 3
Paul 4
Nancy 5
Dave 6
Kathy 6
On January 1, 2017, the company amended its pension plan, increasing its projected benefit obligation by $72,000.
Exercises 1163
1164 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Instructions
Compute the amount of prior service cost amortization for the years 2017 through 2022 using the years-of-service method, setting up appropriate schedules.
E20-6 (L01) (Computation of Actual Return) Gingrich Importers provides the following pension plan information.

Fair value of pension plan assets, January 1, 2017
Fair value of pension plan assets, December 31, 2017
Contributions to the plan in 2017
$2,400,000
2,725,000
280,000
Benef ts paid retirees in 2017 350,000

Instructions
From the data above, compute the actual return on the plan assets for 2017.
E20-7 (L01,2,3) EXCEL (Basic Pension Worksheet) The following defined pension data of Rydell Corp. apply to the year 2017.

Projected benef t obligation, 1/1/17 (before amendment)
Plan assets, 1/1/17
$560,000
546,200
Pension liability
On January 1, 2017, Rydell Corp., through plan amendment,
grants prior service benef ts having a present value of
Settlement rate
Service cost
13,800
120,000
9%
58,000
Contributions (funding) 65,000
Actual (expected) return on plan assets 52,280
Benef ts paid to retirees 40,000
Prior service cost amortization for 2017 17,000

Instructions
For 2017, prepare a pension worksheet for Rydell Corp. that shows the journal entry for pension expense and the year-end balances in the related pension accounts.
E20-8 (L04) (Application of the Corridor Approach) Kenseth Corp. has the following beginning-of-the-year present values
for its projected benefit obligation and market-related values for its pension plan assets.

Projected Plan
Beneft Assets
Obligation
$2,000,000
Value
$1,900,000
2016

2017 2,400,000 2,500,000
2018 2,950,000 2,600,000
2019 3,600,000 3,000,000
The average remaining service life per employee in 2016 and 2017 is 10 years and in 2018 and 2019 is 12 years. The net gain or
loss that occurred during each year is as follows: 2016, $280,000 loss; 2017, $90,000 loss; 2018, $11,000 loss; and 2019, $25,000 gain.
(In working the solution, the gains and losses must be aggregated to arrive at year-end balances.)
Instructions
Using the corridor approach, compute the amount of net gain or loss amortized and charged to pension expense in each of the
four years, setting up an appropriate schedule.
E20-9 (L05) (Disclosures: Pension Expense and Other Comprehensive Income) Taveras Enterprises provides the following
information relative to its defined benefit pension plan.
Balances or Values at December 31, 2017

Projected beneft obligation
Accumulated beneft obligation
$2,737,000
1,980,000
Fair value of plan assets 2,278,329
Accumulated OCI (PSC) 210,000
Accumulated OCI—Net loss (1/1/17 balance, –0–) 45,680
Pension liability
Other pension plan data for 2017:
Service cost
458,671
94,000
Prior service cost amortization 42,000
Actual return on plan assets 130,000
Expected return on plan assets 175,680
Interest on January 1, 2017, projected beneft obligation 253,000
Contributions to plan 93,329
Benefts paid 140,000

Instructions
(a) Prepare the note disclosing the components of pension expense for the year 2017.
(b) Determine the amounts of other comprehensive income and comprehensive income for 2017. Net income for 2017 is $35,000.
(c) Compute the amount of accumulated other comprehensive income reported at December 31, 2017.
E20-10 (L01,2,3,4) (Pension Worksheet) Webb Corp. sponsors a defined benefit pension plan for its employees. On
January 1, 2017, the following balances relate to this plan.

Plan assets
Projected beneft obligation
Pension asset/liability
Accumulated OCI (PSC)
$480,000
600,000
120,000
100,000 Dr.

As a result of the operation of the plan during 2017, the following additional data are provided by the actuary.

Service cost
Settlement rate, 9%
Actual return on plan assets
$90,000
55,000
Amortization of prior service cost 19,000
Expected return on plan assets
Unexpected loss from change in projected beneft obligation,
due to change in actuarial predictions
52,000
76,000
Contributions
Benef ts paid retirees
99,000
85,000

Instructions
(a) Using the data above, compute pension expense for Webb Corp. for the year 2017 by preparing a pension worksheet.
(b) Prepare the journal entry for pension expense for 2017.
E20-11 (L01,2,3,4,5) (Pension Expense, Journal Entries, Statement Presentation) Henning Company sponsors a defined benefit
pension plan for its employees. The following data relate to the operation of the plan for the year 2017 in which no benefits were paid.
1. The actuarial present value of future benefits earned by employees for services rendered in 2017 amounted to $56,000.
2. The company’s funding policy requires a contribution to the pension trustee amounting to $145,000 for 2017.
3. As of January 1, 2017, the company had a projected benefit obligation of $900,000, an accumulated benefit obligation of
$800,000, and a debit balance of $400,000 in accumulated OCI (PSC). The fair value of pension plan assets amounted to
$600,000 at the beginning of the year. The actual and expected return on plan assets was $54,000. The settlement rate was
9%. No gains or losses occurred in 2017 and no benefits were paid.
4. Amortization of prior service cost was $50,000 in 2017. Amortization of net gain or loss was not required in 2017.
Instructions
(a) Determine the amounts of the components of pension expense that should be recognized by the company in 2017.
(b) Prepare the journal entry or entries to record pension expense and the employer’s contribution to the pension trustee in 2017.
(c) Indicate the amounts that would be reported on the income statement and the balance sheet for the year 2017.
E20-12 (L01,2,3,4,5) (Pension Expense, Journal Entries, Statement Presentation) Ferreri Company received the following selected information from its pension plan trustee concerning the operation of the company’s defined benefit pension plan
for the year ended December 31, 2017.

January 1,
2017
$1,500,000
800,000
1,600,000
–0–
December 31,
2017
$1,527,000
1,130,000
1,720,000
(200,000)
Projected beneft obligation
Market-related and fair value of plan assets
Accumulated beneft obligation
Accumulated OCI (G/L)—Net gain

The service cost component of pension expense for employee services rendered in the current year amounted to $77,000 and the
amortization of prior service cost was $120,000. The company’s actual funding (contributions) of the plan in 2017 amounted to
$250,000. The expected return on plan assets and the actual rate were both 10%; the interest/discount (settlement) rate was 10%.
Accumulated other comprehensive income (PSC) had a balance of $1,200,000 on January 1, 2017. Assume no benefits paid in 2017.
Instructions
(a) Determine the amounts of the components of pension expense that should be recognized by the company in 2017.
(b) Prepare the journal entry to record pension expense and the employer’s contribution to the pension plan in 2017.
(c) Indicate the pension-related amounts that would be reported on the income statement and the balance sheet for Ferreri
Company for the year 2017.
Exercises 1165
1166 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
E20-13 (L01,2,4) (Computation of Actual Return, Gains and Losses, Corridor Test, and Pension Expense) Erickson Company sponsors a defined benefit pension plan. The corporation’s actuary provides the following information about the plan.
January 1, December 31,
2017 2017
Vested beneft obligation $1,500 $1,900
Accumulated beneft obligation 1,900 2,730
Projected beneft obligation 2,500 3,300
Plan assets (fair value) 1,700 2,620
Settlement rate and expected rate of return 10%
Pension asset/liability 800 ?
Service cost for the year 2017 400
Contributions (funding in 2017) 700
Benef ts paid in 2017 200
Instructions
(a) Compute the actual return on the plan assets in 2017.
(b) Compute the amount of the other comprehensive income (G/L) as of December 31, 2017. (Assume the January 1, 2017,
balance was zero.)
(c) Compute the amount of net gain or loss amortization for 2017 (corridor approach).
(d) Compute pension expense for 2017.
E20-14 (L01,2,4) (Worksheet for E20-13) Using the information in E20-13 about Erickson Company’s defined benefit pension
plan, prepare a 2017 pension worksheet with supplementary schedules of computations. Prepare the journal entries at December 31,
2017, to record pension expense and related pension transactions. Also, indicate the pension amounts reported in the balance sheet.
E20-15 (L01,2,5) (Pension Expense, Journal Entries) Latoya Company provides the following selected information related
to its defined benefit pension plan for 2017.

Pension asset/liability (January 1)
Accumulated benef t obligation (December 31)
Actual and expected return on plan assets
$ 25,000 Cr.
400,000
10,000
Contributions (funding) in 2017 150,000
Fair value of plan assets (December 31)
Settlement rate
Projected benef t obligation (January 1)
800,000
10%
700,000
Service cost 80,000

Instructions
(a) Compute pension expense and prepare the journal entry to record pension expense and the employer’s contribution
to the pension plan in 2017. Preparation of a pension worksheet is not required. Benefits paid in 2017 were $35,000.
(b) Indicate the pension-related amounts that would be reported in the company’s income statement and balance sheet
for 2017.
E20-16 (L04) (Amortization of Accumulated OCI (G/L), Corridor Approach, Pension Expense Computation) The actuary
for the pension plan of Gustafson Inc. calculated the following net gains and losses.
Incurred

during the Year
2017
(Gain) or Loss
$300,000

2018 480,000
2019 (210,000)
2020 (290,000)
Other information about the company’s pension obligation and plan assets is as follows.

Projected Beneft
Obligation
Plan Assets
(market-related asset value)
As of January 1,

2017 $4,000,000 $2,400,000
2018 4,520,000 2,200,000
2019 5,000,000 2,600,000
2020 4,240,000 3,040,000
Gustafson Inc. has a stable labor force of 400 employees who are expected to receive benefits under the plan. The total serviceyears for all participating employees is 5,600. The beginning balance of accumulated OCI (G/L) is zero on January 1, 2017. The
market-related value and the fair value of plan assets are the same for the 4-year period. Use the average remaining service life
per employee as the basis for amortization.
Instructions
(Round to the nearest dollar.)
Prepare a schedule which reflects the minimum amount of accumulated OCI (G/L) amortized as a component of net periodic
pension expense for each of the years 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2020. Apply the “corridor” approach in determining the amount to
be amortized each year.
E20-17 (L01,4,5) (Amortization of Accumulated OCI Balances) Keeton Company sponsors a defined benefit pension plan
for its 600 employees. The company’s actuary provided the following information about the plan.
January 1, December 31,
2017 2017 2018

Projected beneft obligation
Accumulated beneft obligation
Plan assets (fair value and market-related
asset value)
Accumulated net (gain) or loss (for purposes
of the corridor calculation)
Discount rate (current settlement rate)
Actual and expected asset return rate
Contributions
$2,800,000
1,900,000
$3,650,000
2,430,000
$4,195,000
2,900,000
1,700,000 2,900,000 3,790,000
–0– 198,000
9%
10%
1,030,000
(24,000)
8%
10%
600,000

The average remaining service life per employee is 10.5 years. The service cost component of net periodic pension expense for
employee services rendered amounted to $400,000 in 2017 and $475,000 in 2018. The accumulated OCI (PSC) on January 1, 2017,
was $1,260,000. No benefits have been paid.
Instructions
(Round to the nearest dollar.)
(a) Compute the amount of accumulated OCI (PSC) to be amortized as a component of net periodic pension expense for
each of the years 2017 and 2018.
(b) Prepare a schedule which reflects the amount of accumulated OCI (G/L) to be amortized as a component of pension
expense for 2017 and 2018.
(c) Determine the total amount of pension expense to be recognized by Keeton Company in 2017 and 2018.
E20-18 (L01,2,3,4) (Pension Worksheet—Missing Amounts) The accounting staff of Usher Inc. has prepared the following pension worksheet. Unfortunately, several entries in the worksheet are not decipherable. The company has asked your
assistance in completing the worksheet and completing the accounting tasks related to the pension plan for 2017.

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G H
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—Usher Inc.xls
1 General Journal Entries Memo Record
2
3 OCI—Prior
Service Cost
OCI—
Gain/Loss
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017 2,800 1,100 Cr. 1,700
7 (1) Service cost 500
8 (2) Interest cost 280
9 (3) Actual return 220
10 150 (4) Unexpected gain
11 (5) Amortization of PSC 55
12 Contributions 800 800
13 Benefts 200 200
14 (6) Liability increase 365
15 (7) (10) Journal entry (11) (8) (9)
16
17 0 Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2016 1,100
18 215 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 3,745 1,225 2,520 1,045
19

Exercises 1167
1168 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Instructions
(a) Determine the missing amounts in the 2017 pension worksheet, indicating whether the amounts are debits or credits.
(b) Prepare the journal entry to record 2017 pension expense for Usher Inc.
(c) The accounting staff has heard of a pension accounting procedure called “corridor amortization.” Is Usher required to
record any amounts for corridor amortization in (1) 2017? In (2) 2018? Explain.
*E20-19 (L06,7) (Postretirement Benefit Expense Computation) Kreter Co. provides the following information about its
postretirement benefit plan for the year 2017.

Service cost
Contribution to the plan
$ 45,000
10,000
Actual and expected return on plan assets 11,000
Benefts paid 20,000
Plan assets at January 1, 2017
Accumulated postretirement beneft obligation
at January 1, 2017
Discount rate
110,000
330,000
8%

Instructions
Compute the postretirement benefit expense for 2017.
*E20-20 (L06,7) (Postretirement Benefit Worksheet) Using the information in E20-19, prepare a worksheet inserting January 1, 2017, balances, and showing December 31, 2017, balances. Prepare the journal entry recording postretirement benefit
expense.
*E20-21 (L06,7) (Postretirement Benefit Expense Computation) Garner Inc. provides the following information related to
its postretirement benefits for the year 2017.
Accumulated postretirement beneft obligation

at January 1, 2017
Actual and expected return on plan assets
$710,000
34,000
Prior service cost amortization
Discount rate
Service cost
21,000
10%
83,000

Instructions
Compute postretirement benefit expense for 2017.
*E20-22 (L06,7) (Postretirement Benefit Expense Computation) Englehart Co. provides the following information about its
postretirement benefit plan for the year 2017.

Service cost
Prior service cost amortization
$ 90,000
3,000
Contribution to the plan 56,000
Actual and expected return on plan assets 62,000
Benefts paid 40,000
Plan assets at January 1, 2017
Accumulated postretirement beneft obligation
at January 1, 2017
Accumulated OCI (PSC) at January 1, 2017
Discount rate
710,000
760,000
100,000 Dr.
9%

Instructions
Compute the postretirement benefit expense for 2017.
*E20-23 (L06,7) (Postretirement Benefit Worksheet) Using the information in E20-22, prepare a worksheet inserting
January 1, 2017, balances, showing December 31, 2017, balances, and the journal entry recording postretirement benefit
expense.
*E20-24 (L06,7) (Postretirement Benefit Worksheet—Missing Amounts) The accounting staff of Holder Inc. has prepared the following postretirement benefit worksheet. Unfortunately, several entries in the worksheet are not decipherable.
The company has asked your assistance in completing the worksheet and completing the accounting tasks related to the
pension plan for 2017.
Instructions
(a) Determine the missing amounts in the 2017 postretirement worksheet, indicating whether the amounts are debits or
credits.
(b) Prepare the journal entry to record 2017 postretirement expense for Holder Inc.
(c) What discount rate is Holder using in accounting for the interest on its other postretirement benefit plan? Explain.
PROBLEMS
P20-1 (L01,2,3,4) EXCEL (2-Year Worksheet) On January 1, 2017, Harrington Company has the following defined benefit
pension plan balances.

Projected beneft obligation
Fair value of plan assets
$4,500,000
4,200,000

The interest (settlement) rate applicable to the plan is 10%. On January 1, 2018, the company amends its pension agreement so that
prior service costs of $500,000 are created. Other data related to the pension plan are as follows.

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G
P18 fx
Postretirement Benefit Worksheet—Holder Inc.xls
1 Memo Record
General Journal Entries
2
3 Postretirement
Asset/Liability
Other
Comprehensive
Income—PSC
APBO Items Plan Assets Annual
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 410,000 120,000 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017 290,000
7 (1) 56,000 Service cost
8 (2) 36,900 Interest cost
9 (3) 2,000 Actual/Expected return
10 (4) Contributions 66,000
11 5,000 5,000 Benefts
12 3,000 Amortization of PSC (5)
13 (6) Journal entry for 2017 (7) (8) (9)
14
15 Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2016 30,000 Dr.
16 497,900 Cr. 183,000 Dr. Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 27,000 Dr. 314,900 Cr.
17

2017 2018

Service cost
Prior service cost amortization
Contributions (funding) to the plan
Benefts paid
$150,000
–0–
240,000
200,000
$180,000
90,000
285,000
280,000
Actual return on plan assets
Expected rate of return on assets
252,000
6%
260,000
8%

Instructions
(a) Prepare a pension worksheet for the pension plan for 2017 and 2018.
(b) For 2018, prepare the journal entry to record pension-related amounts.
P20-2 (LO1,2,3,4,5) GROUPWORK (3-Year Worksheet, Journal Entries, and Reporting) Jackson Company adopts acceptable accounting for its defined benefit pension plan on January 1, 2016, with the following beginning balances: plan assets
$200,000; projected benefit obligation $250,000. Other data relating to 3 years’ operation of the plan are as follows.
Problems 1169
1170 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Instructions
(a) Prepare a pension worksheet presenting all 3 years’ pension balances and activities.
(b) Prepare the journal entries (from the worksheet) to reflect all pension plan transactions and events at December 31 of
each year.
(c) Indicate the pension-related amounts reported in the financial statements for 2018.
P20-3 (LO1,2,3,4,5) (Pension Expense, Journal Entries, Amortization of Loss) Gottschalk Company sponsors a defined
benefit plan for its 100 employees. On January 1, 2017, the company’s actuary provided the following information.

Accumulated other comprehensive loss (PSC)
Pension plan assets (fair value and market-related asset value)
Accumulated beneft obligation
$150,000
200,000
260,000
Projected beneft obligation 380,000

The average remaining service period for the participating employees is 10 years. All employees are expected to receive benefits
under the plan. On December 31, 2017, the actuary calculated that the present value of future benefits earned for employee services rendered in the current year amounted to $52,000; the projected benefit obligation was $490,000; fair value of pension assets
was $276,000; the accumulated benefit obligation amounted to $365,000. The expected return on plan assets and the discount rate
on the projected benefit obligation were both 10%. The actual return on plan assets is $11,000. The company’s current year’s contribution to the pension plan amounted to $65,000. No benefits were paid during the year.
Instructions
(a) Determine the components of pension expense that the company would recognize in 2017. (With only one year involved,
you need not prepare a worksheet.)
(b) Prepare the journal entry to record the pension expense and the company’s funding of the pension plan in 2017.
(c) Compute the amount of the 2017 increase/decrease in gains or losses and the amount to be amortized in 2017 and
2018.
(d) Indicate the pension amounts reported in the financial statement as of December 31, 2017.
P20-4 (L01,2,3,4) EXCEL (Pension Expense, Journal Entries for 2 Years) Gordon Company sponsors a defined benefit
pension plan. The following information related to the pension plan is available for 2017 and 2018.
2016 2017 2018
Annual service cost $16,000 $ 19,000 $ 26,000
Settlement rate and expected rate of return 10% 10% 10%
Actual return on plan assets 18,000 22,000 24,000
Annual funding (contributions) 16,000 40,000 48,000
Benefts paid 14,000 16,400 21,000
Prior service cost (plan amended, 1/1/17) 160,000
Amortization of prior service cost 54,400 41,600
Change in actuarial assumptions establishes
a December 31, 2018, projected benef t obligation of: 520,000
2017 2018
Plan assets (fair value), December 31 $699,000 $849,000
Projected benef t obligation, January 1 700,000 800,000
Pension asset/liability, January 1 140,000 Cr. ?
Prior service cost, January 1 250,000 240,000
Service cost 60,000 90,000
Actual and expected return on plan assets 24,000 30,000
Amortization of prior service cost 10,000 12,000
Contributions (funding) 115,000 120,000
Accumulated benef t obligation, December 31 500,000 550,000
Interest/settlement rate 9% 9%
Instructions
(a) Compute pension expense for 2017 and 2018.
(b) Prepare the journal entries to record the pension expense and the company’s funding of the pension plan for both years.
P20-5 (LO2,3,4) (Computation of Pension Expense, Amortization of Net Gain or Loss–Corridor Approach, Journal
Entries for 3 Years) Hiatt Toothpaste Company initiates a defined benefit pension plan for its 50 employees on January 1, 2017.
The insurance company which administers the pension plan provided the following selected information for the years 2017,
2018, and 2019.
There were no balances as of January 1, 2017, when the plan was initiated. The actual and expected return on plan assets was 10%
over the 3-year period, but the settlement rate used to discount the company’s pension obligation was 13% in 2017, 11% in 2018,
and 8% in 2019. The service cost component of net periodic pension expense amounted to the following: 2017, $60,000; 2018,
$85,000; and 2019, $119,000. The average remaining service life per employee is 12 years. No benefits were paid in 2017, $30,000 of
benefits were paid in 2018, and $18,500 of benefits were paid in 2019 (all benefits paid at end of year).
Instructions
(Round to the nearest dollar.)
(a) Calculate the amount of net periodic pension expense that the company would recognize in 2017, 2018, and 2019.
(b) Prepare the journal entries to record net periodic pension expense, employer’s funding contribution, and related pension amounts for the years 2017, 2018, and 2019.
P20-6 (LO3,4) GROUPWORK (Computation of Prior Service Cost Amortization, Pension Expense, Journal Entries, and
Net Gain or Loss) Aykroyd Inc. has sponsored a noncontributory, defined benefit pension plan for its employees since 1994. Prior
to 2017, cumulative net pension expense recognized equaled cumulative contributions to the plan. Other relevant information
about the pension plan on January 1, 2017, is as follows.
1. The company has 200 employees. All these employees are expected to receive benefits under the plan. The average remaining
service life per employee is 12 years.
2. The projected benefit obligation amounted to $5,000,000 and the fair value of pension plan assets was $3,000,000. The
market-related asset value was also $3,000,000. Unrecognized prior service cost was $2,000,000.
On December 31, 2017, the projected benefit obligation and the accumulated benefit obligation were $4,850,000 and $4,025,000,
respectively. The fair value of the pension plan assets amounted to $4,100,000 at the end of the year. A 10% settlement rate and a
10% expected asset return rate were used in the actuarial present value computations in the pension plan. The present value of
benefits attributed by the pension benefit formula to employee service in 2017 amounted to $200,000. The employer’s contribution
to the plan assets amounted to $775,000 in 2017. This problem assumes no payment of pension benefits.
Instructions
(Round all amounts to the nearest dollar.)
(a) Prepare a schedule, based on the average remaining life per employee, showing the prior service cost that would be
amortized as a component of pension expense for 2017, 2018, and 2019.
(b) Compute pension expense for the year 2017.
(c) Compute the amount of the 2017 increase/decrease in net gains or losses and the amount to be amortized in 2017 and
2018.
(d) Prepare the journal entries required to report the accounting for the company’s pension plan for 2017.
P20-7 (LO2,3,4) (Pension Worksheet) Hanson Corp. sponsors a defined benefit pension plan for its employees. On January
1, 2017, the following balances related to this plan.

Plan assets (market-related value)
Projected beneft obligation
Pension asset/liability
Prior service cost
$520,000
700,000
180,000 Cr.
81,000
Net gain or loss (debit) 91,000

As a result of the operation of the plan during 2017, the actuary provided the following additional data for 2017.

Service cost
Settlement rate, 9%; expected return rate, 10%
Actual return on plan assets
$108,000
48,000
Amortization of prior service cost 25,000
Contributions
Benef ts paid retirees
Average remaining service life of active employees
133,000
85,000
10 years

For Year Ended December 31,
2017 2018 2019
Plan assets (fair value) $50,000 $ 85,000 $180,000
Accumulated beneft obligation 45,000 165,000 292,000
Projected beneft obligation 60,000 200,000 324,000
Net (gain) loss (for purposes of corridor
calculation) –0– 78,400 81,033
Employer’s funding contribution (made at end of year) 50,000 60,000 105,000
Problems 1171
1172 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Instructions
Using the preceding data, compute pension expense for Hanson Corp. for the year 2017 by preparing a pension worksheet that
shows the journal entry for pension expense. Use the market-related asset value to compute the expected return and for corridor
amortization.
P20-8 (LO1,2,3,4,5) GROUPWORK (Comprehensive 2-Year Worksheet) Lemke Company sponsors a defined benefit
pension plan for its employees. The following data relate to the operation of the plan for the years 2017 and 2018.
2017 2018

Projected benef t obligation, January 1
Plan assets (fair value and market-related value), January 1
Pension asset/liability, January 1
Prior service cost, January 1
$600,000
410,000
190,000 Cr.
160,000
Service cost
Settlement rate
Expected rate of return
Actual return on plan assets
40,000
10%
10%
36,000
$ 59,000
10%
10%
61,000
Amortization of prior service cost 70,000 50,000
Annual contributions 97,000 81,000
Benef ts paid retirees
Increase in projected benef t obligation due to
changes in actuarial assumptions
Accumulated benef t obligation at December 31
Average service life of all employees
Vested benef t obligation at December 31
31,500 54,000
87,000
721,800
–0–
789,000
20 years
464,000

Instructions
(a) Prepare a pension worksheet presenting both years 2017 and 2018 and accompanying computations and amortization
of the loss (2018) using the corridor approach.
(b) Prepare the journal entries (from the worksheet) to reflect all pension plan transactions and events at December 31 of
each year.
(c) For 2018, indicate the pension amounts reported in the financial statements.
P20-9 (LO1,2,3,4,5) GROUPWORK (Comprehensive 2-Year Worksheet) Hobbs Co. has the following defined benefit
pension plan balances on January 1, 2017.

Projected beneft obligation
Fair value of plan assets
$4,600,000
4,600,000

The interest (settlement) rate applicable to the plan is 10%. On January 1, 2018, the company amends its pension agreement so that
prior service costs of $600,000 are created. Other data related to the pension plan are:

2017
$150,000
–0–
200,000
220,000
2018
$170,000
90,000
184,658
280,000
Service cost
Prior service cost amortization
Contributions (funding) to the plan
Benefts paid
Actual return on plan assets
Expected rate of return on assets
252,000
6%
350,000
8%

Instructions
(a) Prepare a pension worksheet for the pension plan in 2017.
(b) Prepare any journal entries related to the pension plan that would be needed at December 31, 2017.
(c) Prepare a pension worksheet for 2018 and any journal entries related to the pension plan as of December 31, 2018.
(d) Indicate the pension-related amounts reported in the 2018 financial statements.
P20-10 (LO1,2,3,4) (Pension Worksheet—Missing Amounts) Kramer Co. has prepared the following pension worksheet.
Unfortunately, several entries in the worksheet are not decipherable. The company has asked your assistance in completing the
worksheet and completing the accounting tasks related to the pension plan for 2017.
Instructions
(a) Determine the missing amounts in the 2017 pension worksheet, indicating whether the amounts are debits or credits.
(b) Prepare the journal entry to record 2017 pension expense for Kramer Co.
(c) Determine the following for Kramer for 2017: (1) settlement rate used to measure the interest on the liability and
(2) expected return on plan assets.
P20-11 (LO1,2,3,4,5) (Pension Worksheet) The following data relate to the operation of Kramer Co.’s pension plan in 2018.
The pension worksheet for 2017 is provided in P20-10.

Service cost
Actual return on plan assets
$59,000
32,000
Amortization of prior service cost 28,000
Annual contributions 51,000
Benef ts paid retirees
Average service life of all employees
27,000
25 years

For 2018, Kramer will use the same assumptions as 2017 for the expected rate of returns on plan assets. The settlement rate for
2018 is 10%.
Instructions
(a) Prepare a pension worksheet for 2018 and accompanying computations and amortization of the loss, if any, in 2018
using the corridor approach.
(b) Prepare the journal entries (from the worksheet) to reflect all pension plan transactions and events at December 31.
(c) Indicate the pension amounts reported in the financial statements.
P20-12 (LO1,2,3,4,5) (Pension Worksheet) Larson Corp. sponsors a defined benefit pension plan for its employees. On
January 1, 2018, the following balances related to this plan.

Plan assets (market-related value)
Projected beneft obligation
Pension asset/liability
Prior service cost
$270,000
340,000
70,000 Cr.
90,000
OCI—Loss 39,000
Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G H
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—Kramer Co.xls
1 General Journal Entries Memo Record
2
3 OCI—
Gain/Loss
OCI—Prior
Service Cost
Projected
Beneft
Obligation
Pension
Asset/
Liability
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017 325,000 120,000 205,000 Dr.
7 (1) Service cost 20,000
8 (2) Interest cost 26,000
9 (3) Actual return 18,000 Dr.
10 2,500 (4) Unexpected loss
11 (5) Amortization of PSC 35,000
12 Contributions 41,000 Dr. 41,000
13 Benefts 15,000 15,000 Cr.
14 (6) Increase in PBO 43,500
15 (7) (10) Journal entry for 2017 (11) (8) (9)
16 0 Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2016 80,000
17 46,000 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 399,500 Cr. 150,500 Cr. 249,000 Dr. 45,000
18

Problems 1173
1174 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
As a result of the operation of the plan during 2018, the actuary provided the following additional data for 2018.

Service cost
Actual return on plan assets
$45,000
27,000
Amortization of prior service cost 12,000
Contributions
Benef ts paid retirees
Settlement rate
Expected return on plan assets
Average remaining service life of active employees
65,000
41,000
7%
8%
10 years

Instructions
(a) Compute pension expense for Larson Corp. for the year 2018 by preparing a pension worksheet that shows the journal
entry for pension expense.
(b) Indicate the pension amounts reported in the financial statements.
*P20-13 (LO6,7) GROUPWORK (Postretirement Benefit Worksheet) Hollenbeck Foods Inc. sponsors a postretirement medical and dental benefit plan for its employees. The following balances relate to this plan on January 1, 2017.

Plan assets
Expected postretirement beneft obligation
$200,000
820,000
Accumulated postretirement beneft obligation
No prior service costs or OCI balances exist.
200,000

As a result of the plan’s operation during 2017, the following additional data are provided by the actuary.
Service cost is $70,000
Discount rate is 10%
Contributions to plan are $65,000
Expected return on plan assets is $10,000
Actual return on plan assets is $15,000
Benef ts paid to employees are $44,000
Average remaining service to full eligibility: 20 years
Instructions
(a) Using the preceding data, compute the net periodic postretirement benefit cost for 2017 by preparing a worksheet that
shows the journal entry for postretirement expense and the year-end balances in the related postretirement benefit
memo accounts. (Assume that contributions and benefits are paid at the end of the year.)
(b) Prepare any journal entries related to the postretirement plan for 2017 and indicate the postretirement amounts reported
in the financial statements for 2017.
*P20-14 (LO6,7) (Postretirement Benefit Worksheet—2 Years) Elton Co. has the following postretirement benefit plan balances on January 1, 2017.

Accumulated postretirement beneft obligation
Fair value of plan assets
$2,250,000
2,250,000

The interest (settlement) rate applicable to the plan is 10%. On January 1, 2018, the company amends the plan so that prior service
costs of $175,000 are created. Other data related to the plan are:

2017
$ 75,000
–0–
45,000
40,000
2018
$ 85,000
12,000
35,000
45,000
Service costs
Prior service costs amortization
Contributions (funding) to the plan
Benefts paid
Actual return on plan assets
Expected rate of return on assets
140,000
8%
120,000
6%

Instructions
(a) Prepare a worksheet for the postretirement plan in 2017.
(b) Prepare any journal entries related to the postretirement plan that would be needed at December 31, 2017.
(c) Prepare a worksheet for 2018 and any journal entries related to the postretirement plan as of December 31, 2018.
(d) Indicate the postretirement-benefit–related amounts reported in the 2018 financial statements.
CONCEPTS FOR ANALYSIS
CA20-1 (Pension Terminology and Theory) Many business organizations have been concerned with providing for the retirement of employees since the late 1800s. Increase in this concern resulted in the establishment of private pension plans in most large
companies and in many medium- and small-sized ones.
The substantial growth of these plans, both in numbers of employees covered and in amounts of retirement benefits, has increased the significance of pension costs in relation to the financial position, results of operations, and cash flows of many companies. In examining the costs of pension plans, a CPA encounters certain terms. The components of pension costs that the terms
represent must be dealt with appropriately if generally accepted accounting principles are to be reflected in the financial statements of entities with pension plans.
Instructions
(a) Define a private pension plan. How does a contributory pension plan differ from a noncontributory plan?
(b) Differentiate between “accounting for the employer” and “accounting for the pension fund.”
(c) Explain the terms “funded” and “pension liability” as they relate to:
(1) The pension fund.
(2) The employer.
(d) (1) Discuss the theoretical justification for accrual recognition of pension costs.
(2) Discuss the relative objectivity of the measurement process of accrual versus cash (pay-as-you-go) accounting for
annual pension costs.
(e) Distinguish among the following as they relate to pension plans.
(1) Service cost.
(2) Prior service costs.
(3) Vested benefits.
CA20-2 WRITING (Pension Terminology) The following items appear on Brueggen Company’s financial statements.
1. Under the caption Assets:
Pension asset/liability.
2. Under the caption Liabilities:
Pension asset/liability.
3. Under the caption Stockholders’ Equity:
Prior service cost as a component of Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income.
4. On the income statement:
Pension expense.
Instructions
Explain the significance of each of the items above on corporate financial statements. (Note: All items set forth above are not necessarily to be found on the statements of a single company.)
CA20-3 (Basic Terminology) In examining the costs of pension plans, Helen Kaufman, CPA, encounters certain terms. The components of pension costs that the terms represent must be dealt with appropriately if generally accepted accounting principles are
to be reflected in the financial statements of entities with pension plans.
Instructions
(a) (1) Discuss the theoretical justification for accrual recognition of pension costs.
(2) Discuss the relative objectivity of the measurement process of accrual versus cash (pay-as-you-go) accounting for
annual pension costs.
(b) Explain the following terms as they apply to accounting for pension plans.
(1) Market-related asset value.
(2) Projected benefit obligation.
(3) Corridor approach.
(c) What information should be disclosed about a company’s pension plans in its financial statements and its notes?
(AICPA adapted)
CA20-4 WRITING (Major Pension Concepts) Davis Corporation is a medium-sized manufacturer of paperboard containers
and boxes. The corporation sponsors a noncontributory, defined benefit pension plan that covers its 250 employees. Sid Cole has
Concepts for Analysis 1175
1176 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
recently been hired as president of Davis Corporation. While reviewing last year’s financial statements with Carol Dilbeck, controller, Cole expressed confusion about several of the items in the footnote to the financial statements relating to the pension plan. In
part, the footnote reads as follows.
Note J. The company has a defned beneft pension plan covering substantially all of its employees. The benef ts are based
on years of service and the employee’s compensation during the last four years of employment. The company’s funding
policy is to contribute annually the maximum amount allowed under the federal tax code. Contributions are intended to
provide for benef ts expected to be earned in the future as well as those earned to date.
The net periodic pension expense on Davis Corporation’s comparative income statement was $72,000 in 2017 and $57,680 in 2016.
The following are selected figures from the plan’s funded status and amounts recognized in the Davis Corporation’s Statement of Financial Position at December 31, 2017 ($000 omitted).
Actuarial present value of beneft obligations:
Accumulated beneft obligation

(including vested benef ts of $636)
Projected beneft obligation
Plan assets at fair value
Projected benef t obligation in
excess of plan assets
$ (870)
$(1,200)
1,050
$ (150)

Given that Davis Corporation’s work force has been stable for the last 6 years, Cole could not understand the increase in the
net periodic pension expense. Dilbeck explained that the net periodic pension expense consists of several elements, some of which
may increase or decrease the net expense.
Instructions
(a) The determination of the net periodic pension expense is a function of five elements. List and briefly describe each of
the elements.
(b) Describe the major difference and the major similarity between the accumulated benefit obligation and the projected
benefit obligation.
(c) (1) Explain why pension gains and losses are not recognized on the income statement in the period in which they arise.
(2) Briefly describe how pension gains and losses are recognized.
(AICPA adapted)
CA20-5 WRITING (Implications of GAAP Rules on Pensions) Jill Vogel and Pete Dell have to do a class presentation on
GAAP rules for reporting pension information. In developing the class presentation, they decided to provide the class with a series
of questions related to pensions and then discuss the answers in class. Given that the class has all read the rules related to pension
accounting and reporting, they felt this approach would provide a lively discussion. Here are the questions:
1. In an article in Businessweek prior to new rules related to pensions, it was reported that the discount rates used by the largest
200 companies for pension reporting ranged from 5% to 11%. How can such a situation exist, and does GAAP alleviate this
problem?
2. An article indicated that when new GAAP rules were issued related to pensions, it caused an increase in the liability for
pensions for approximately 20% of companies. Why might this situation occur?
3. A recent article noted that while “smoothing” is not necessarily an accounting virtue, pension accounting has long been
recognized as an exception—an area of accounting in which at least some dampening of market swings is appropriate.
This is because pension funds are managed so that their performance is insulated from the extremes of short-term market
swings. A pension expense that reflects the volatility of market swings might, for that reason, convey information of little
relevance. Are these statements true?
4. Understanding the impact of the changes required in pension reporting requires detailed information about its pension
plan(s) and an analysis of the relationship of many factors, particularly the:
(a) Type of plan(s) and any significant amendments.
(b) Plan participants.
(c) Funding status.
(d) Actuarial funding method and assumptions currently used.
What impact does each of these items have on financial statement presentation?
5. An article noted “You also need to decide whether to amortize gains and losses using the corridor method, or to use some
other systematic method. Under the corridor approach, only gains and losses in excess of 10% of the greater of the projected
benefit obligation or the plan assets would have to be amortized.” What is the corridor method and what is its purpose?
Instructions
What answers do you believe Jill and Pete gave to each of these questions?
CA20-6 WRITING (Gains and Losses, Corridor Amortization) Vickie Plato, accounting clerk in the personnel office of
Streisand Corp., has begun to compute pension expense for 2019 but is not sure whether or not she should include the amortization
of unrecognized gains/losses. She is currently working with the following beginning-of-the-year present values for the projected
benefit obligation and market-related values for the pension plan:

Projected Plan
Beneft Assets
Obligation Value

2016 $2,200,000 $1,900,000
2017 2,400,000 2,500,000
2018 2,900,000 2,600,000
2019 3,900,000 3,000,000
The average remaining service life per employee in 2016 and 2017 is 10 years and in 2018 and 2019 is 12 years. The net gain or loss
that occurred during each year is as follows.
2016 $280,000 loss
2017 85,000 loss
2018 12,000 loss
2019 25,000 gain
(In working the solution, you must aggregate the unrecognized gains and losses to arrive at year-end balances.)
Instructions
You are the manager in charge of accounting. Write a memo to Vickie Plato, explaining why in some years she must amortize some
of the net gains and losses and in other years she does not need to. In order to explain this situation fully, you must compute the
amount of net gain or loss that is amortized and charged to pension expense in each of the 4 years listed above. Include an appropriate amortization schedule, referring to it whenever necessary.
CA20-7 ETHICS (Nonvested Employees—An Ethical Dilemma) Thinken Technology recently merged with College Electronix (CE), a computer graphics company. In performing a comprehensive audit of CE’s accounting system, Gerald Ott, internal
audit manager for Thinken Technology, discovered that the new subsidiary did not record pension assets and liabilities, subject to
GAAP.
The net present value of CE’s pension assets was $15.5 million, the vested benefit obligation was $12.9 million, and the projected
benefit obligation was $17.4 million. Ott reported this audit finding to Julie Habbe, the newly appointed controller of CE. A few days
later, Habbe called Ott for his advice on what to do. Habbe started her conversation by asking, “Can’t we eliminate the negative income
effect of our pension dilemma simply by terminating the employment of nonvested employees before the end of our fiscal year?”
Instructions
How should Ott respond to Habbe’s remark about firing nonvested employees?
USING YOUR JUDGMENT
Financial Reporting Problem
The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G)
The financial statements of P&G are presented in Appendix B. The company’s complete annual report, including the notes to
the financial statements, is available online.
Instructions
Refer to P&G’s financial statements and the accompanying notes to answer the following questions.
(a) What kinds of pension plans does P&G provide its employees?
(b) What was P&G’s pension expense for 2014, 2013, and 2012 related to its defined benefit plan?
(c) What is the impact of P&G’s pension plans for 2014 on its financial statements?
(d) What information does P&G provide on the target allocation of its pension assets? (Compare the asset allocation for
“Pensions and Other Retiree Benefits.”) How do the allocations relate to the expected returns on these assets?
Using Your Judgment 1177
Comparative Analysis Case
The Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo, Inc.
The financial statements of Coca-Cola and PepsiCo are presented in Appendices C and D, respectively. The companies’ complete
annual reports, including the notes to the financial statements, are available online.
Instructions
Use the companies’ financial information to answer the following questions.
(a) What kind of pension plans do Coca-Cola and PepsiCo provide their employees?
(b) What net periodic pension expense (cost) did Coca-Cola and PepsiCo report in 2014?
(c) What is the year-end 2014 funded status of Coca-Cola’s and PepsiCo’s plans (include international)?
(d) What relevant rates were used by Coca-Cola and PepsiCo in computing their pension amounts?
(e) Compare the expected benefit payments and contributions for Coca-Cola and PepsiCo.
*Financial Statement Analysis Case
General Electric
A Wall Street Journal article discussed a $1.8 billion charge to income made by General Electric for postretirement benefit costs.
It was attributed to previously unrecognized healthcare and life insurance cost. As financial vice president and controller for
Peake, Inc., you found this article interesting because the president recently expressed interest in adopting a postemployment
benefit program for Peake’s employees, to complement the company’s existing defined benefit plan. The president, Martha
Beyerlein, wants to know how the expense on the new plan will be determined and what impact the accounting for the plan will
have on Peake’s financial statements.
Instructions
(a) As financial vice president and controller of Peake, Inc., explain the calculation of postemployment benefit expense
under GAAP, and indicate how the accounting for the plan will affect Peake’s financial statements.
(b) Discuss the similarities and differences in the accounting for the other postemployment benefit plan relative to the
accounting for the defined benefit plan.
Accounting, Analysis, and Principles
PENCOMP’s balance sheet at December 31, 2017, is as follows.
1178 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts

PENCOMP, INC.
BALANCE SHEET
AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2017
Assets
Total assets $3,998
Liabilities
Notes payable $1,000
Pension liability 344
Total liabilities 1,344
Stockholders’ equity
Common stock 2,000
Retained earnings 896
Accumulated other comprehensive income (242)
Total stockholders’ equity 2,654
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity $3,998
Additional information concerning PENCOMP’s defned beneft pension plan is as follows.

Cash $ 438
Inventory 1,800
Total current assets 2,238
Plant and equipment 2,000
Accumulated depreciation (240)
1,760
Projected benef t obligation at 12/31/17 $ 820.5
Plan assets (fair value) at 12/31/17 476.5
Unamortized past service cost at 12/31/17 150.0
Amortization of past service cost during 2018 15.0
Service cost for 2018 42.0
Discount rate 10%
Expected rate of return on plan assets in 2018 12%
Actual return on plan assets in 2018 10.4
Contributions to pension fund in 2018 70.0
Benef ts paid during 2018 40.0
Unamortized net loss due to changes in actuarial assumptions

and deferred net losses on plan assets at 12/31/17
Expected remaining service life of employees
Average period to vesting of prior service costs
Other information about PENCOMP is as follows.
Salary expense, all paid with cash during 2018
Sales, all for cash
Purchases, all for cash
Inventory at 12/31/18
92.0
15.0
10.0
$ 700.0
3,000.0
2,000.0
1,800.0

Property originally cost $2,000 and is depreciated on a straight-line basis over 25 years with no residual value.
Interest on the note payable is 10% annually and is paid in cash on 12/31 of each year.
Dividends declared and paid are $200 in 2018.
Accounting
Prepare an income statement for 2018 and a balance sheet as of December 31, 2018. Also, prepare the pension expense journal
entry for the year ended December 31, 2018. Round to the nearest tenth (e.g., round 2.87 to 2.9).
Analysis
Compute return on equity for PENCOMP for 2018 (assume stockholders’ equity is equal to year-end average stockholders’ equity). Do you think an argument can be made for including some or even all of the change in accumulated other comprehensive
income (due to pensions) in the numerator of return on equity? Illustrate that calculation.
Principles
Explain a rationale for why the FASB has (so far) decided to exclude from the current period income statement the effects of
pension plan amendments and gains and losses due to changes in actuarial assumptions.
Bridge to the Profession 1179
BRIDGE TO THE PROFESSION
FASB Codification References
[1] FASB ASC 960. [Predecessor literature: “Accounting and Reporting by Defined Benefit Pension Plans,” Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 35 (Stamford, Conn.: FASB, 1979).]
[2] FASB ASC 715-70-50-1. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Pension Plans,” Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 87 (Stamford, Conn.: FASB, 1985), paras. 63–66.]
[3] FASB ASC 715-30-25-1. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Defined Benefit Pension and Other Postretirement Plans: An Amendment to SFAS Nos. 87, 88, 106, and 132(R),” Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 158
(Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 2006).]
[4] FASB ASC 715-30-35-22. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Pension Plans,” Statement of Financial Accounting
Standards No. 87 (Stamford, Conn.: FASB, 1985), par. 30.]
[5] FASB ASC 220-10-45-13. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Defined Benefit Pension and Other Postretirement Plans: An Amendment of SFAS Nos. 87, 88, 106, and 132(R),” Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 158
(Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 2006), par. B41.]
[6] FASB ASC 715-20-50-1. [Predecessor literature: None.]
[7] FASB ASC 715-20-50-1. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Disclosure about Pensions and Other Postretirement Benefits,”
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 132 (Stamford, Conn.: FASB, 1998; revised 2003); and “Employers’ Accounting for Defined Benefit Pension and Other Postretirement Plans: An Amendment of SFAS Nos. 87, 88, 106, and 132(R),”
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 158 (Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 2006).]
[8] FASB ASC 715-30-05-9. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Settlements and Curtailments of Defined Benefit
Pension Plans and for Termination Benefits,” Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 88 (Stamford, Conn.: FASB, 1985).]
[9] FASB ASC 715-60. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Postretirement Benefits Other Than Pensions,”
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 106 (Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 1990).]
[10] FASB ASC 712-10-05. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Postemployment Benefits,” Statement of Financial
Accounting Standards No. 112 (Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 1992).]
[11] FASB ASC 715-60-35-9. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Postretirement Benefits Other Than Pensions,”
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 106 (Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 1990), paras. 46–66.]
[12] FASB ASC 715-60-25. [Predecessor literature: “Employers’ Accounting for Postretirement Benefits Other Than Pensions,”
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 106 (Norwalk, Conn.: FASB, 1990), par. 163.]
Codification Exercises
If your school has a subscription to the FASB Codification, go to http://aaahq.org/ascLogin.cfm to log in and prepare responses to
the following. Provide Codification references for your responses.
CE20-1 Access the glossary (“Master Glossary”) to answer the following.
(a) What is an accumulated benefit obligation?
(b) What is a defined benefit postretirement plan?
(c) What is the definition of “actuarial present value”?
(d) What is a prior service cost?
CE20-2 In general, how can an employer choose an appropriate discount rate for its pension plan? What information could an
employer use in choosing a discount rate?
CE20-3 If an employer has a defined benefit pension plan, what components would make up its net periodic pension cost?
CE20-4 What information about its pension plan must a publicly traded company disclose in its interim financial statements?
Codifi cation Research Case
Monat Company has grown rapidly since its founding in 2004. To instill loyalty in its employees, Monat is contemplating establishment of a defined benefit plan. Monat knows that lenders and potential investors will pay close attention to the impact of the
pension plan on the company’s financial statements, particularly any gains or losses that develop in the plan. Monat has asked
you to conduct some research on the accounting for gains and losses in a defined benefit plan.
Instructions
If your school has a subscription to the FASB Codification, go to http://aaahq.org/ascLogin.cfm to log in and prepare responses to
the following. Provide Codification references for your responses.
(a) Briefly describe how pension gains and losses are accounted for.
(b) Explain the rationale behind the accounting method described in part (a).
(c) What is the related pension asset or liability that will show up on the balance sheet? When will each of these situations
occur?
ADDITIONAL PROFESSIONAL RESOURCES
Go to WileyPLUS for other career-readiness resources, such as career coaching, internship
opportunities, and CPAexcel prep.
1180 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
IFRS Insights

The accounting for va
Benefits”) and IFRS 2
of compensation elem
The underlying conce
and IFRS—both GA
deferred compensatio
LEARNING OBJECTIVE 8
Compare the accounting
for pensions under GAAP
and IFRS.

IAS 19 (“Employee
(“Share-Based Payment”). IAS 19 addresses the accounting for a wide range
visions as applied to these plans.
RELEVANT FACTS
Following are the key similarities and differences between GAAP and IFRS related to pensions.

IFRS Insights 1181
Similarities
• IFRS and GAAP separate pension plans into def ned contribution plans and defned benef t
plans. The accounting for def ned contribution plans is similar.
• IFRS and GAAP recognize a pension asset or liability as the funded status of the plan (i.e.,
defned beneft obligation minus the fair value of plan assets). (Note that defned benef t obligation is referred to as the projected benef t obligation in GAAP.)
• IFRS and GAAP compute unrecognized past service cost (PSC) (referred to as prior service cost
in GAAP) in the same manner. However, IFRS recognizes past service cost as a component of
pension expense in income immediately. GAAP amortizes PSC over the remaining service lives
of employees.
Differences
• IFRS and GAAP include interest expense on the liability in pension expense. Regarding asset
returns, IFRS reduces pension expense by the amount of interest revenue (based on the discount rate times the beginning value of pension assets). GAAP includes an asset return component based on the expected return on plan assets.
• Under IFRS, companies recognize both liability and asset gains and losses (referred to as remeasurements) in other comprehensive income. These gains and losses are not “recycled” into
income in subsequent periods. GAAP recognizes liability and asset gains and losses in “Accumulated other comprehensive income” and amortizes these amounts to income over remaining
service lives, using the “corridor approach.”
• The accounting for pensions and other postretirement benef t plans is the same under IFRS.
GAAP has separate standards for these types of benef ts, and signif cant differences exist in the
accounting.
ABOUT THE NUMBERS
Accounting for Pensions
Net Defined Benefit Obligation (Asset)
As in GAAP, under IFRS the net defined benefit liability (asset) is the deficit or surplus related
to a defined benefit pension plan. The deficit or surplus is measured as follows.
Defined Benefit Obligation – Fair Value of Plan Assets (if any)
The deficit or surplus is often referred to as the funded status of the plan.
If the defined benefit obligation is greater than the plan assets, the pension plan has a deficit.
Conversely, if the defined pension obligation is less than the plan assets, the pension plan has a
surplus. Illustration IFRS20-1 shows these relationships.
ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-1
Presentation of Funded
Status
Deficit Surplus
Defined benefit obligation $1,000,000 Defined benefit obligation $150,000
Plan assets 900,000 Plan assets 200,000
Net defined benefit obligation $ 100,000 Net defined benefit asset $ 50,000
The net defined benefit obligation (asset) is often referred to simply as the pension liability or the
pension asset on the statement of financial position.
As indicated, companies should report either a pension asset or pension liability related to a
pension plan on the statement of financial position (often referred to as the net approach). To
illustrate, assume that at year-end Acer Company has a defined pension obligation of $4,000,000
and plan assets of $3,700,000. In this case, Acer reports $300,000 ($4,000,000 – $3,700,000) as a pension liability on its statement of financial position.
Some believe that companies should report separately both the defined benefit obligation
and the plan assets on the statement of financial position. This approach (often referred to as the
gross approach) would report Acer’s defined benefit obligation of $4,000,000 and its plan assets
of $3,700,000 on the statement of financial position. The IASB disagrees, indicating that
1182 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
offsetting these amounts is consistent with its standard on when assets and liabilities should be
netted.29
Reporting Changes in the Defined Benefit Obligation (Asset)
The IASB requires that all changes in the defined benefit obligation and plan assets in the current
period be recognized in comprehensive income. The Board believes that immediate recognition of
the effects of these changes in the statement of comprehensive income provides the most understandable and useful information to financial statement users. The IASB requires that companies
report changes arising from different elements of pension liabilities and assets in different sections of the statement of comprehensive income, depending on their nature.
In the past, companies often reported only a single pension expense number in the comprehensive income statement. Providing additional segmentation of the components of pension cost provides additional transparency about the nature of these costs. The three components are as follows.
• Service cost. Service cost is either current service cost or past service cost. Current service cost
is the increase in the present value of the defned beneft obligation from employee service in
the current period. Past service cost is the change in the present value of the defned benef t
obligation for employee service for prior periods—generally resulting from a plan amendment
(e.g., changes to the plan). This component is reported in the statement of comprehensive
income in the operating section of the statement and affects net income.
• Net interest. Net interest is computed by multiplying the discount rate by the funded status of the
plan (defned beneft obligation minus plan assets). If the plan has a net defned benef t obligation,
the company reports interest expense. Conversely, if it has a net defned beneft asset, it reports
interest revenue. This approach is justif ed on the basis of its simplicity and that any fnancing
costs should be based on the funded status of the plan. This amount is often shown below the
operating section of the income statement in the f nancing section and affects net income.
• Remeasurements. Remeasurements are gains and losses related to the defned benef t obligation (changes in discount rate or other actuarial assumptions) and gains or losses on the
fair value of the plan assets (actual rate of return less interest revenue included in the fnance
component). This component is reported in other comprehensive income, net of tax. These
remeasurement gains or losses therefore affect comprehensive income but not net income.
Illustration IFRS20-2 shows the components of changes in the pension liability (asset) and their
placement on the statement of comprehensive income.
29IAS 32 states that a financial asset and a financial liability should be offset and the net amount reported in
the statement of financial position when a company (a) has a legally enforceable right to set off the recognized
amounts and (b) intends either to settle on a net basis, or to realize the asset and settle it simultaneously.

Service Cost
Net Interest
Interest expense greater than interest revenue
or
Interest expense less than interest revenue
Remeasurements

Net Income
Other Comprehensive Income
ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-2
Reporting Changes in the
Pension Obligation (Assets)
As indicated in Illustration IFRS20-2, service cost and net interest are reported in net income.
We discuss determination of each of these components in the following section. Remeasurements,
which are reported in other comprehensive income, are discussed in a later section.
Service Cost. To determine current service cost and the related increase in the defined benefit
obligation, companies must:
IFRS Insights 1183
1. Apply an actuarial valuation method.
2. Assign benef ts to period of service.
3. Make actuarial assumptions.30
In applying an actuarial valuation method, the IASB concluded that companies must consider
future compensation levels in measuring the present obligation and periodic pension expense if
the plan benefit formula incorporates them. In other words, the present obligation resulting from
a promise to pay a benefit of 1 percent of an employee’s final pay differs from the promise to pay 1
percent of current pay. To overlook this fact is to ignore an important aspect of pension expense.
Thus, the Board adopts the projected unit credit method (often referred to as the benefits/years-ofservice method), which determines pension expense based on future salary levels.
Some object to this determination, arguing that a company should have more freedom to
select an expense recognition pattern. Others believe that incorporating future salary increases
into current pension expense is accounting for events that have not yet happened. They argue that
if a company terminates the plan today, it pays only liabilities for accumulated benefits. Nevertheless, the IASB indicates that the defined benefit obligation provides a more realistic measure of the employer’s obligation under the plan on a going concern basis and, therefore, companies should use it as the basis for determining service cost.
The assignment of benefits to periods of service is based on the actuarial valuation method.
The actuary then allocates the cost of the pension benefits over the expected service life of the
company’s employees. In determining the proper service cost for a period, the actuary makes
actuarial assumptions related to such factors as mortality; rates of employee turnover, disability,
and early retirement; discount rate; benefit levels; and future salary levels. While IAS 19 does not
require use of an actuary, given the complexity of these estimates, just about all companies rely on
an actuary to determine service cost and related other defined benefit measures.
Net Interest. In computing net interest, companies assume that the discount rate, the net defined
benefit obligation, and the pension asset are determined at the beginning of the year.31 The discount rate is based on the yields of high-quality bonds with terms consistent with the company’s
pension obligation. Net interest is then computed as indicated in the following equation.
Net Interest = (Defined Benefit Obligation × Discount Rate) – (Plan Assets × Discount Rate)
That is, net interest is determined by multiplying the net defined pension obligation (asset) by the
discount rate.
Because payment of the pension obligation is deferred, companies record the pension liability on a discounted basis. As a result, the liability accrues interest over the service life of the
employee (passage of time), which is essentially interest expense (interest on the liability). Similarly, companies earn a return on their plan assets. That is, a company assumes that it earns interest based on multiplying the discount rate by the plan assets. While the IASB recognizes that the
actual return on plan assets may differ from the assumed interest revenue computed, it believes
that the change in plan assets can be divided into an amount that arises from the passage of time
and amounts that arise from other changes. As we discuss in the next section, changes not related
to the passage of time are reported in other comprehensive income as remeasurements. Thus, the
growth in the plan assets should mirror the growth in the defined benefit obligation. In other
words, the assumed interest revenue on the plan assets based on the passage of time offsets the
interest expense on the defined benefit obligation.
In summary, pension expense is comprised of two components: (1) service cost and (2) net interest. Companies report each of these components in the statement of comprehensive income. In some
cases, companies may choose to report these components in one section of the statement of comprehensive income and report total pension expense. Other companies may choose to report the service
cost component in operating income and the net interest in a separate section related to financing.32
30As indicated earlier, service cost is comprised of current and past service cost. Determination of past
service cost is based on the same actuarial valuation model as that used for current service cost. We discuss
recognition of past service cost in a later section.
31The IASB indicates that if the beginning of the year amount changes materially (due to contributions to or
payments out of the plan), an adjustment to the beginning balances should be made. For homework purposes,
unless information indicates that balances have changed materially, use the beginning of the year balances.
32The IASB does not provide guidance on which of these two approaches is preferred. For homework purposes,
report pension expense as a single total in income from operations in the statement of comprehensive income.
1184 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
Plan Assets and Actual Return
Pension plan assets are usually investments in shares, bonds, other securities, and real estate that
a company holds to earn a reasonable rate of return. Plan assets are reported at fair value. Companies generally hold these assets in a separate legal entity (a pension fund) that exists only to
administer the employee benefit plan. These assets held by the pension fund are therefore not
available to the company’s own creditors (even in bankruptcy). Employer contributions and the
actual return on plan assets increase pension plan assets. Actual return on plan assets is the
increase in the pension fund assets arising from interest, dividends, and realized and unrealized
changes in the fair value of the plan. Benefits paid to retired employees decrease plan assets.
To illustrate, assume that Hasbro Company has pension plan assets of $4,200,000 on January 1,
2017. During 2017, Hasbro contributed $300,000 to the plan and paid out retirement benefits of
$250,000. Its actual return on plan assets was $210,000 for the year. Hasbro’s plan assets at December 31, 2017, are $4,460,000, computed as shown in Illustration IFRS20-3.

Plan assets, January 1, 2017
Contributions by Hasbro to plan
$4,200,000
300,000
Actual return
Benefits paid to employees
Plan assets, December 31, 2017
210,000
(250,000)
$4,460,000

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-3
Determination of Pension
Assets
In some cases, companies compute the actual return by adjusting the change in plan assets
for the effect of contributions during the year and benefits paid during the year. The equation in
Illustration IFRS20-4, or a variation thereof, can be used to compute the actual return.
Stated another way, the actual return on plan assets is the difference between the fair value of the
plan assets at the beginning of the period and at the end of the period, adjusted for contributions
and benefit payments. Illustration IFRS20-5 uses the equation above to compute actual return,
using the information provided in Illustration IFRS20-3.
Plan assets, December 31, 2017 $4,460,000
Plan assets, January 1, 2017 (4,200,000)
Increase in fair value of plan assets 260,000
Deduct: Contributions to plan $300,000
Add: Benefit payments to employees 250,000 (50,000)
Actual return $ 210,000
ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-5
Computation of Actual
Return on Plan Assets
In this case, Hasbro has a positive actual return on plan assets. Recently, some pension plans have
experienced negative actual returns due to the increased volatility in global securities markets.
Using a Pension Worksheet
We will now illustrate the basic computation of pension expense using the first two components:
(1) service cost and (2) net interest. We discuss remeasurements in later sections.
Companies often use a worksheet to record pension-related information. As its name suggests, the worksheet is a working tool. A worksheet is not a permanent accounting record: It is
neither a journal nor part of the general ledger. The worksheet is merely a device to make it easier
to prepare entries and the financial statements.33 Illustration IFRS20-6 shows the format of the
pension worksheet.
The “General Journal Entries” columns of the worksheet (near the middle) determine the
entries to record in the formal general ledger accounts. The “Memo Record” columns (on the right
33The use of a pension entry worksheet is recommended and illustrated by Paul B. W. Miller, “The New Pension
Accounting (Part 2),” Journal of Accountancy (February 1987), pp. 86–94.

Actual Assets
Assets
Return = – (Contributions – Benefits Paid)
Ending
Beginning
( – (
Plan Plan

Balance
Balance
ILLUSTRATION IFRS20-4 Equation for Computing Actual Return
IFRS Insights 1185

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 Pension
Asset/
Liability
Defned
Beneft
Obligation
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-6
Basic Format of Pension
Worksheet
side) maintain balances in the defined benefit obligation and the plan assets. The difference
between the defined benefit obligation and the fair value of the plan assets is the pension asset/
liability, which is shown in the statement of financial position. If the defined benefit obligation is
greater than the plan assets, a pension liability occurs. If the defined benefit obligation is less than
the plan assets, a pension asset occurs.
On the first line of the worksheet, a company enters the beginning balances (if any). It then
records subsequent transactions and events related to the pension plan using debits and credits,
using both sets of columns as if they were one. For each transaction or event, the debits must equal
the credits. The ending balance in the Pension Asset/Liability column should equal the net balance in the memo record.
2017 Entries and Worksheet
To illustrate the use of a worksheet and how it helps in accounting for a pension plan, assume that
on January 1, 2017, Zarle Company provides the following information related to its pension plan
for the year 2017.
• Plan assets, January 1, 2017, are $100,000.
• Defned beneft obligation, January 1, 2017, is $100,000.
• Annual service cost is $9,000.
• Discount rate is 10 percent.
• Funding contributions are $8,000.
• Benefts paid to retirees during the year are $7,000.
Using the data presented above, the worksheet in Illustration IFRS20-7 (page 1186) presents the
beginning balances and all of the pension entries recorded by Zarle in 2017. Zarle records the beginning balances for the defined benefit obligation and the pension plan assets on the first line of the
worksheet in the memo record. Because the defined benefit obligation and the plan assets are the
same at January 1, 2017, the Pension Asset/Liability account has a zero balance at January 1, 2017.
Entry (a) in Illustration IFRS20-7 records the service cost component, which increases pension
expense by $9,000 and increases the liability (defined benefit obligation) by $9,000. Entry (b) accrues
the interest expense component, which increases both the liability and the pension expense by
$10,000 (the beginning defined benefit obligation multiplied by the discount rate of 10 percent).
Entry (c) records the interest revenue component, which increases plan assets and decreases pension expense by $10,000. This is computed by multiplying the beginning plan assets by the discount rate of 10 percent. As a result, net interest expense (income) is zero in 2017. Entry (d) records
Zarle’s contribution (funding) of assets to the pension fund, thereby decreasing cash by $8,000 and
increasing plan assets by $8,000. Entry (e) records the benefit payments made to retirees, which
results in equal $7,000 decreases to the plan assets and the defined benefit obligation.
Zarle makes the “formal journal entry” on December 31, which records the pension expense
in 2017, as follows.
2017

Pension Expense 9,000
Cash 8,000
Pension Asset/Liability 1,000

1186 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—2017.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 Pension
Asset/
Liability
Defned
Beneft
Obligation
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2017 100,000 Cr. 100,000 Dr. —
7 (a) Service cost 9,000 Dr. 9,000 Cr.
8 (b) Interest expense 10,000 Dr. 10,000 Cr.
9 (c) Interest revenue 10,000 Cr. 10,000 Dr.
10 (d) Contributions 8,000 Cr. 8,000 Dr.
11 (e) Benefts 7,000 Dr. 7,000 Cr.
12
13 Journal entry for 2017 9,000 Dr. 8,000 Cr. 1,000 Cr.*
14 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 112,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr. 1,000 Cr.**
15
16 *$9,000 – $8,000 = $1,000
17 **$112,000 – $111,000 = $1.000

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-7
Pension
Worksheet—2017
The credit to Pension Asset/Liability for $1,000 represents the difference between the 2017
pension expense of $9,000 and the amount funded of $8,000. Pension Asset/Liability (credit) is a
liability because Zarle underfunds the plan by $1,000. The Pension Asset/Liability account balance of $1,000 also equals the net of the balances in the memo accounts. Illustration IFRS20-8
shows that the defined benefit obligation exceeds the plan assets by $1,000, which reconciles to
the pension liability reported in the statement of financial position.

Defined benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
Pension asset/liability (Credit)
$(112,000)
111,000
$ (1,000)

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-8
Pension Reconciliation
Schedule—December 31,
2017
If the net of the memo record balances is a credit, the reconciling amount in the Pension
Asset/Liability column will be a credit equal in amount. If the net of the memo record balances is
a debit, the Pension Asset/Liability amount will be a debit equal in amount. The worksheet is
designed to produce this reconciling feature, which is useful later in the preparation of the financial statements and required note disclosure related to pensions.
In this illustration (for 2017), the debit to Pension Expense exceeds the credit to Cash, resulting in a credit to Pension Asset/Liability—the recognition of a liability. If the credit to Cash
exceeded the debit to Pension Expense, Zarle would debit Pension Asset/Liability—the recognition of an asset.34
Past Service Cost
Past service cost is the change in the present value of the defined benefit obligation resulting from
a plan amendment or a curtailment.35 For example, a plan amendment arises when a company
decides to provide additional benefits to existing employees for past service. Conversely, the company may decide that it is necessary to reduce its benefit package retroactively for existing
employees, thereby reducing their pension benefit. A curtailment occurs when the company has
34The IASB in IAS 19 limits the amount of a pension asset that is recognized, based on a recoverability test.
This test, which has been further clarified in IFRIC 14, limits the amount of the pension asset to the sum of
unrecognized actuarial gains and losses (discussed later) and amounts that will be received by the company
in the form of refunds or reduction of future contributions. For purposes of homework, assume that a pension
asset, if present, meets the criteria for full recognition.
35The IASB also indicates that gains and losses on non-routine settlements are considered past service costs.
A settlement is a payment of benefits that is not set out in the terms of the plan.
IFRS Insights 1187
a significant reduction in the number of employees covered by the plan. Because a curtailment has
the same effect as a reduction in benefits due to an amendment to the plan, these situations are
accounted for in the same way. Illustration IFRS20-9 summarizes the nature of past service costs.

PAST SERVICE COSTS
(EXPENSE IN CURRENT PERIOD)
Plan Amendments
• Introduction of a plan.
• Withdrawal of a plan.
• Changes to a plan.
Curtailments
• Significant reduction in the
number of employees covered
by the plan.

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-9
Types of Past Service Costs
The accounting for past service cost is straightforward—expense past service cost in the
period of the amendment or curtailment. As a result, a substantial increase (decrease) in pension
expense and the defined benefit obligation often results when a plan amendment or curtailment
occurs. Because current and past service costs relate directly to employment, they are reported in
the operating section of the statement of comprehensive income.
Some disagree with the IASB position of expensing these costs in the year a plan is amended
or curtailed. They argue that a company would not provide these additional benefits for past
years of service unless it expects to receive benefits in the future. According to this reasoning, a
company should not recognize the full past service cost in the year of the amendment. Instead, the
past service cost should be spread out over the remaining service life of employees who are
expected to benefit from the changes in the plan. Others believe that if they are truly past service
costs, they should be treated retroactively as an adjustment made to prior periods.
However, the IASB decided that any changes in the defined benefit obligation or plan assets
should be recognized in the current period. To do otherwise is not informative and leads to
delayed recognition of costs or reduced benefits which are neither assets nor liabilities.
It is also possible to decrease past service costs by decreasing the defined benefit obligation
(referred to as negative past service cost). Negative past service cost arises when an entity changes
the benefits attributable to past service cost so that the present value of the defined benefit obligation decreases. In that case, pension expense is decreased. Both positive (increased pension
expense) and negative (decreased pension expense) past service cost adjustments are handled in
the same manner; that is, adjust pension expense immediately.
2018 Entries and Worksheet
Continuing the Zarle Company illustration into 2018, we note that the company amends the pension plan on January 1, 2018, to grant employees past service benefits with a present value of
$81,600. The following additional facts apply to the pension plan for the year 2018.
• Annual service cost is $9,500.
• Discount rate is 10 percent.
• Annual funding contributions are $20,000.
• Benefts paid to retirees during the year are $8,000.
Illustration IFRS20-10 (on page 1188) presents a worksheet of all the pension entries and
information recorded by Zarle in 2018.
The first line of the worksheet shows the beginning balances of the Pension Asset/Liability
account and the memo accounts. Entry (f) records Zarle’s granting of past service cost, by adding
$81,600 to the defined benefit obligation and to Pension Expense. Entry (g) records the current
service cost; entry (h) records interest expense for the period. Because the past service cost
occurred at the beginning of the year, interest is computed on the January 1, 2018, balance of the
defined benefit obligation, adjusted for the past service cost. Interest expense is therefore $19,360
($193,600 × 10%). Entry (i) records interest revenue for the period of $11,100 ($111,000 × 10%).
Entries (j) and (k) are similar to the corresponding entries in 2017.
Zarle makes the following journal entry on December 31 to formally record the 2018 pension
expense—the sum of the annual pension expense column.
2018

Pension Expense 99,360
Cash 20,000
Pension Asset/Liability 79,360

1188 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—2018.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 Pension
Asset/
Liability
Defned
Beneft
Obligation
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash
4
5
6 Balance, Dec. 31, 2017 112,000 Cr. 111,000 Dr. 1,000 Cr.
7 (f) Additional PSC, 1/1/2018 81,600 Dr. 81,600 Cr.
8 Balance, Jan. 1, 2018 193,600 Cr.
9 (g) Service cost 9,500 Dr. 9,500 Cr.
10 (h) Interest expense 19,360 Dr. 19,360 Cr.
11 (i) Interest revenue 11,100 Cr. 11,100 Dr.
12 (j) Contributions 20,000 Cr. 20,000 Dr.
13 (k) Benefts 8,000 Dr. 8,000 Cr.
14 Journal entry for 2018 99,360 Dr. 20,000 Cr. 79,360 Cr.
15 Balance, Dec. 31, 2018 214,460 Cr. 134,100 Dr. 80,360 Cr.
16

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-10
Pension
Worksheet—2018
Because the expense exceeds the funding, Zarle credits the Pension Asset/Liability account
for the $79,360 difference. That account is a liability. In 2018, as in 2017, the balance of the Pension
Asset/Liability account ($80,360) is equal to the net of the balances in the memo accounts, as
shown in Illustration IFRS20-11.

Defined benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
Pension asset/liability (Credit)
$(214,460)
134,100
$ (80,360)

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-11
Pension Reconciliation
Schedule—December 31,
2018
The reconciliation is the formula that makes the worksheet work. It relates the components
of pension accounting, recorded and unrecorded, to one another.
Remeasurements
Of great concern to companies that have pension plans are the uncontrollable and unexpected
swings that can result from (1) sudden and large changes in the fair value of plan assets and
(2) changes in actuarial assumptions that affect the amount of the defined benefit obligation. How
should these changes (referred to as remeasurements) affect the financial statements, most notably pension expense? The IASB believes that the most informative way is to recognize the remeasurement in other comprehensive income. The rationale for this reporting is that the predictive
nature of remeasurements is much different than the other two components of pension benefit
cost—service cost and net interest.
Remeasurements are generally of two types:
1. Gains and losses on plan assets.
2. Gains and losses on the defned benef t obligation.
Asset Gains and Losses. The gains and losses on plan assets (referred to as asset gains and losses)
is the difference between the actual return and the interest revenue computed in determining net
interest. Asset gains occur when actual returns exceed the interest revenue. Asset losses occur
when the actual returns are less than interest revenue. To illustrate, assume that Shopbob Company has plan assets at January 1, 2017, of $100,000. The discount rate for the year is 6 percent, and
the actual return on the plan assets for 2017 is $8,000. In 2017, Shopbob should record an asset gain
of $2,000, computed as follows.
IFRS Insights 1189

Actual return
Less: Interest revenue ($100,000 × 6%)
Asset gain
$8,000
6,000
$2,000

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-12
Computation of Asset Gain
Shopbob therefore debits plan assets for the asset gain of $2,000 and credits Other Comprehensive
Income (G/L) for the same amount. If interest revenue exceeds the actual return, Shopbob debits
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) for the asset loss and credits plan assets.
Liability Gains and Losses. In estimating the defined benefit obligation (the liability), actuaries
make assumptions about such items as mortality rate, retirement rate, turnover rate, disability
rate, and salary amounts. Any change in these actuarial assumptions affects the amount of the
defined benefit obligation. Seldom does actual experience coincide exactly with actuarial predictions. These gains or losses from changes in the defined benefit obligation are called liability
gains and losses.
Companies report liability gains (resulting from unexpected decreases in the liability balance) and liability losses (resulting from unexpected increases in the liability balance) in
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L). Companies combine the liability gains and losses in the
same Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) account used for asset gains and losses. They accumulate the asset and liability gains and losses from year to year in Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income.36 This amount is reported on the statement of financial position in the
equity section.
2019 Entries and Worksheet
Continuing the Zarle Company illustration, the following facts apply to the pension plan for 2019.
• Annual service cost is $13,000.
• Discount rate is 10 percent.
• Actual return on plan assets is $12,000.
• Annual funding contributions are $24,000.
• Benefts paid to retirees during the year are $10,500.
• Changes in actuarial assumptions establish the end-of-year defned beneft obligation at
$265,000.
The worksheet in Illustration IFRS20-13 (on page 1190) presents all of Zarle’s 2019 pension
entries and related information. The first line of the worksheet records the beginning balances that
relate to the pension plan. In this case, Zarle’s beginning balances are the ending balances from its
2018 pension worksheet in Illustration IFRS20-10.
Entries (l), (m), (n), (o), and (p) are similar to the corresponding entries in 2017 or 2018.
Entries (m) and (n) are related. Entry (m) records the interest expense of $21,446 ($214,460 ×
10%). Entry (n) records interest revenue of $13,410 ($134,100 × 10%). Therefore, net interest
expense is $8,036 ($21,446 – $13,410). Entries (o) and (p) are recorded similarly in 2019 as those in
2017 and 2018.
Entries (q) and (r) need additional explanation. As indicated, the actual return on plan assets
for 2019 was $12,000. However, as indicated in entry (n), pension expense was decreased $13,410
as a result of multiplying the beginning plan assets by the discount rate to arrive at an assumed
interest revenue of $13,410. As a result, Zarle has an asset loss of $1,410 ($13,410 – $12,000) because
the assumed interest revenue is greater than the actual return. This asset loss is debited to Other
Comprehensive Income (G/L) and credited to plan assets. Pension plan assets are then properly
stated at their fair value.
Entry (r) records the change in the defined benefit obligation resulting from the changes in
the actuarial assumptions related to this obligation. As indicated in the facts above, the actuary
has determined that the ending balance in the defined benefit obligation should be $265,000 at
December 31, 2019. However, the balance at December 31, 2019, before any adjustment for
36The IASB is silent as to whether the account “Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income” should be used
instead of another equity account, like Retained Earnings. For homework purposes, use an Accumulated Other
Comprehensive Income account. The IASB also permits the transfer of the balance in the Accumulated Other
Comprehensive Income account to other equity accounts at a later date.
1190 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G
P18 fx
Pension Worksheet—2019.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 OCI—
Gain/Loss
Defned
Beneft
Obligation
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash Pension
Asset/
Liability
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2019 214,460 Cr. 134,100 Dr. 80,360 Cr.
7 (l) Service cost 13,000 Dr. 13,000 Cr.
8 (m) Interest expense 21,446 Dr. 21,446 Cr.
9 (n) Interest revenue 13,410 Cr. 13,410 Dr.
10 (o) Contributions 24,000 Cr. 24,000 Dr.
11 (p) Benefts 10,500 Dr. 10,500 Cr.
12 (q) Asset loss 1,410 Cr. 1,410 Dr.
13 (r) Liability loss 26,594 Cr. 26,594 Dr.
14 Journal entry for 2019 21,036 Dr. 24,000 Cr. 28,004 Dr. 25,040 Cr.
15
16 Accumulated OCI, Dec. 31, 2018 0
17 Balance, Dec. 31, 2019 265,000 Cr. 159,600 Dr. 28,004 Dr. 105,400 Cr.
18

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-13
Pension Worksheet—2019
actuarial gains and losses related to the defined benefit obligation is $238,406, as shown in Illustration IFRS20-14.

December 31, 2018, DBO balance
Service cost [entry (l)]
$214,460
13,000
Interest expense [entry (m)]
Benefits paid [entry (p)]
December 31, 2019, DBO balance (before liability increases)
21,446
(10,500)
$238,406

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-14
Defi ned Benefi t
Obligation Balance
(Unadjusted)
The difference between the ending balance of $265,000 as determined by the actuary and the
present balance of $238,406 is $26,594 (a liability loss on the defined benefit liability). This liability
loss is debited to Other Comprehensive Income (G/L) and credited to the defined benefit obligation. After this worksheet adjustment, the defined benefit obligation is stated at its actuarial value
of $265,000. The journal entry to record the information related to the pension plan at December
31, 2019, based on the pension worksheet in Illustration IFRS20-13, is as follows.

Pension Expense 21,036
Other Comprehensive Income (G/L)
Cash
28,004 24,000
Pension Asset/Liability 25,040

As the 2019 worksheet indicates, the $105,400 balance in the Pension Asset/Liability account
at December 31, 2019, is equal to the net of the balances in the memo accounts. Illustration
IFRS20-15 shows this computation.

Defined benefit obligation (Credit)
Plan assets at fair value (Debit)
$(265,000)
159,600

Pension asset/liability $(105,400)
ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-15
Pension Reconciliation
Schedule—December 31,
2019
Zarle carries the 2019 ending balances for Pension Asset/Liability and Accumulated Other
Comprehensive Income forward as the beginning balances for pension plan accounting in 2020.
These balances will be adjusted by changes in the defined benefit obligation and plan assets as
shown in the prior examples. For example, assume that Zarle’s pension plan had the following
activity in 2020:
IFRS Insights 1191
Service cost $10,072 Contributions $32,000
Pension expense 17,450 Benefits 11,000
Asset gain 13,150 Decrease in Pension Asset/Liability 27,700
Discount rate 7%
The ending balances for the defined benefit obligation and plan assets are $282,622 and $204,922,
respectively. These elements are summarized in the partial 2020 pension worksheet shown in
Illustration IFRS20-16.

Insert Page Layout Formulas Data Review View
Home
A B C D E F G
P18 fx
Partial Pension Worksheet—2020.xls
1 Memo Record General Journal Entries
2
3 OCI—
Gain/Loss
Defned
Beneft
Obligation
Items Plan Assets Annual
Pension
Expense
Cash Pension
Asset/
Liability
4
5
6 Balance, Jan. 1, 2020 265,000 Cr. 159,600 Dr. 28,004 Dr. 105,400 Cr.
7
8
9 Journal entry for 2020 17,450 Dr. 32,000 Cr. 13,150 Cr. 27,700 Dr.
10
11 Accumulated OCI, Jan. 1, 2020 28,004 Dr.
12 Balance, Dec. 31, 2020 282,622 Cr. 204,922 Dr. 14,854 Dr. 77,700 Cr.
13

ILLUSTRATION
IFRS20-16
Partial Pension
Worksheet—2020
Focusing on the “Journal Entry” row, in 2020 Zarle records pension expense of $17,450 and a
decrease in Pension Asset/Liability of $27,700. The reduction in Pension Asset/Liability is due in
part to the asset gain of $13,150 recorded in 2020. As a result, Zarle’s 2020 ending balances (which
become the 2021 beginning balances) are $77,700 for Pension Asset/Liability and Accumulated
Other Comprehensive Income $14,854 (beginning Accumulated OCI of $28,004 – gain of $13,150).
ON THE HORIZON
The IASB and the FASB have been working collaboratively on a postretirement benefit project.
The recent amendments issued by the IASB moves IFRS closer to GAAP with respect to recognition of the funded status on the statement of financial position. However, as illustrated in the
About the Numbers section above, significant differences remain in the components of pension
expense. The FASB is expected to begin work on a project that will reexamine expense measurement of postretirement benefit plans. The FASB likely will consider the recent IASB amendments
in this area, which could lead to a converged standard.
1. At the end of the current period, Oxford Ltd. has a defined
benefit obligation of $195,000 and pension plan assets with a
fair value of $110,000. The amount of the vested benefits for the
plan is $105,000. What amount related to its pension plan will
be reported on the company’s statement of financial position?

(a) $5,000.
(b) $90,000.
(c) $85,000.
(d) $20,000.

2. At the end of the current year, Kennedy Co. has a defined
benefit obligation of $335,000 and pension plan assets with
a fair value of $245,000. The amount of the vested benefits
for the plan is $225,000. Kennedy has an actuarial gain of
$8,300. What account and amount(s) related to its pension
plan will be reported on the company’s statement of financial position?
(a) Pension Liability and $74,300.
(b) Pension Liability and $90,000.
(c) Pension Asset and $233,300.
(d) Pension Asset and $110,000.
3. For 2017, Carson Majors Inc. had pension expense of $77
million and contributed $55 million to the pension fund.
Which of the following is the journal entry that Carson Majors
would make to record pension expense and funding?

(a) Pension Expense
Pension Asset/Liability
Cash
(b) Pension Expense
Pension Asset/Liability
Cash
77,000,000
22,000,000
55,000,000
77,000,000
22,000,000
99,000,000

IFRS SELF-TEST QUESTIONS
1192 Chapter 20 Accounting for Pensions and Postretirement Benefi ts
IFRS CONCEPTS AND APPLICATION
IFRS20-1 What is net interest? Identify the elements of net interest and explain how they are computed.
IFRS20-2 What is service cost, and what is the basis of its measurement?
IFRS20-3 What is meant by “past service cost”? When is past service cost recognized as pension expense?
IFRS20-4 Bill Haley is learning about pension accounting. He is convinced that in years when companies record liability gains
and losses, total comprehensive income will not be affected. Is Bill correct? Explain.
IFRS20-5 At the end of the current year, Joshua Co. has a defined benefit obligation of $335,000 and pension plan assets with
a fair value of $345,000. The amount of the vested benefits for the plan is $225,000. Joshua has a liability gain of $8,300 (beginning
accumulated OCI is zero). What amount and account(s) related to its pension plan will be reported on the company’s statement
of financial position?
IFRS20-6 Villa Company has experienced tough competition, leading it to seek concessions from its employees in the company’s pension plan. In exchange for promises to avoid layoffs and wage cuts, the employees agreed to receive lower pension
benefits in the future. As a result, Villa amended its pension plan on January 1, 2017, and recorded negative past service cost of
$125,000. Current service cost for 2017 is $26,000. Interest expense is $9,000, and interest revenue is $2,500. Actual return on
assets in 2017 is $1,500. Compute Villa’s pension expense in 2017.
IFRS20-7 Tevez Company experienced an actuarial loss of $750 in its defined benefit plan in 2017. For 2017, Tevez’s revenues
are $125,000, and expenses (excluding pension expense of $14,000, which does not include the actuarial loss) are $85,000. Prepare
Tevez’s statement of comprehensive income for 2017.
IFRS20-8 The following defined pension data of Doreen Corp. apply to the year 2017.

Defned beneft obligation, 1/1/17 (before amendment)
Plan assets, 1/1/17
Pension asset/liability
On January 1, 2017, Doreen Corp., through plan amendment,
grants past service benef ts having a present value of
Discount rate
Service cost
$560,000
546,200
13,800 Cr.
120,000
9%
58,000
Contributions (funding) 65,000
Actual return on plan assets 49,158
Benef ts paid to retirees 40,000

Instructions
For 2017, prepare a pension worksheet for Doreen Corp. that shows the journal entry for pension expense and the year-end
balances in the related pension accounts.
IFRS20-9 Buhl Corp. sponsors a defined benefit pension plan for its employees. On January 1, 2017, the following balances
relate to this plan.

Plan assets
Defned benef t obligation
$480,000
600,000
Pension asset/liability 120,000

As a result of the operation of the plan during 2017, the following additional data are provided by the actuary.

(c) Pension Expense
Pension Asset/Liability
Cash
(d) Pension Expense
Pension Asset/Liability
Cash
55,000,000
22,000,000
77,000,000
22,000,000
55,000,000
77,000,000

4. At January 1, 2017, Wembley Company had plan assets of
$250,000 and a defined benefit obligation of the same amount.
During 2017, service cost was $27,500, the discount rate was
10%, actual return on plan assets was $25,000, contributions
were $20,000, and benefits paid were $17,500. Based on this
information, what would be the defined benefit obligation for
Wembley Company at December 31, 2017?

(a) $277,500.
(b) $285,000.
(c) $27,500.
(d) $302,500.

5. Towson Company has experienced tough competition for
its talented workforce, leading it to enhance the pension benefits provided to employees. As a result, Towson amended its
pension plan on January 1, 2017, and granted past service costs
of $250,000. Current service cost for 2017 is $52,000. Interest
expense is $18,000, and interest revenue is $5,000. Actual
return on assets in 2017 is $3,000. What is Towson’s pension
expense for 2017?

(a) $65,000.
(b) $302,000.
(c) $317,000.
(d) $315,000.

IFRS Insights 1193
Service cost for 2017 $90,000
Discount rate, 6%
Actual return on plan assets in 2017 55,000
Unexpected loss from change in defned benef t obligation,
due to change in actuarial predictions 76,000
Contributions in 2017 99,000
Benef ts paid retirees in 2017 85,000
Instructions
(a) Using the data above, compute pension expense for Buhl Corp. for the year 2017 by preparing a pension worksheet.
(b) Prepare the journal entry for pension expense for 2017.
IFRS20-10 Linda Berstler Company sponsors a defined benefit pension plan. The corporation’s actuary provides the following information about the plan.
January 1, December 31,
2017 2017
Defned benef t obligation $2,500 $3,300
Plan assets (fair value) 1,700 2,620
Discount rate 10%
Pension asset/liability 800 ?
Service cost for the year 2017 400
Contributions (funding in 2017) 700
Benef ts paid in 2017 200
Instructions
(a) Compute the actual return on the plan assets in 2017.
(b) Compute the amount of other comprehensive income (G/L) as of December 31, 2017. (Assume the January 1, 2017, balance was zero.)
Professional Research
IFRS20-11 Jack Kelly Company has grown rapidly since its founding in 2007. To instill loyalty in its employees, Kelly is contemplating establishment of a defined benefit plan. Kelly knows that lenders and potential investors will pay close attention to
the impact of the pension plan on the company’s financial statements, particularly any gains or losses that develop in the plan.
Kelly has asked you to conduct some research on the accounting for gains and losses in a defined benefit plan.
Instructions
Access the IFRS authoritative literature at the IASB website (http://eifrs.iasb.org/). (Click on the IFRS tab and then register for free
eIFRS access if necessary.) When you have accessed the documents, you can use the search tool in your Internet browser to
respond to the following questions. (Provide paragraph citations.)
(a) Briefly describe how pension gains and losses are accounted for.
(b) Explain the rationale behind the accounting method described in part (a).
(c) What is the related pension asset or liability that may show up on the statement of f nancial position? When will each
of these situations occur?
International Financial Reporting Problem
Marks and Spencer plc (M&S)
IFRS20-12 The financial statements of M&S are presented in Appendix E. The company’s complete annual report,
including the notes to the financial statements, is available online.
Instructions
Refer to M&S’s financial statements and the accompanying notes to answer the following questions.
(a) What kind of pension plan does M&S provide its employees?
(b) What was M&S’s pension expense for 2015 and 2014?
(c) What is the impact of M&S’s pension plans for 2015 on its financial statements?
(d) What information does M&S provide on the target allocation of its pension assets? How do the allocations relate
to the expected returns on these assets?
ANSWERS TO IFRS SELF-TEST QUESTIONS
1. c 2. b 3. a 4. b 5. d

The post companies have benefit plans appeared first on My Assignment Online.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order