CP2405 Assignment 1
CP2405 © 2019 – Information Technology @ James Cook University
CP2405 Assignment 1
Ontology design
Assignment breakdown
This assignment has been divided into two components. For the first task (PART 1), you are to design
a basic ontology given a number of axioms. For the second task (PART 2), you are given a scenario
where you are to use the Ontology Requirements Specification Framework to determine the main
elements and logical statements/axioms of a conceptual ontology model and the competency
questions of the ontology.
Note: This is not a group project. Each student must individually complete all parts of their submission.
Students must start with a new Protégé file and a new document and they must not have another
person’s file in their possession at any time. Each student must work on their assignment independently
and not show their work to other students.
Submissions that are detected to be too similar to another student’s work will be dealt with promptly
according to University procedures for handling plagiarism.
Deliverables
1) PART 1 – Hand in one OWL file (.owl) file created in Protégé 4.3. or later (earlier versions of Protégé are
not acceptable)
2) PART 2 – A single Word document (.doc or .docx) containing:
Section 1 scenario broken into main statements
Section 2 scenario in logical axioms; and
Section 3 a completed Ontology Requirements Specification Framework
• Please name the file like: FirstnameLastnameP1.owl (e.g. if your name were Robert Brown, the filename
would be RobertBrownP1.owl) and FirstnameLastnameP2.doc (e.g. if your name were Robert Brown, the
filename would be RobertBrownP2.doc)
• Submit your files by uploading it on LearnJCU under Assessment
Due
Submit your assignment by the date and time specified on LearnJCU.
Submissions received after this date will incur late penalties as described in the subject outline.
CP2405 Assignment 1
CP2405 © 2019 – Information Technology @ James Cook University
PART 1
Design an ontology based on the following sentences:
• Accidents can be categorised as chemical, electrical, fire, kinetic or liquid.
• An accident can only be one of the above types.
• An investigation is conducted for accidents.
• An investigation only covers one accident.
• Accidents can cause different types of injuries or damage, relating to the type of accident.
• A person may be involved with an accident as a victim, witness, or investigator. But an
investigator cannot be a witness or victim because they may suffer from a conflict of interests.
• An object may be damaged by an accident. A person who owns an object that is damaged is a
victim.
• A victim can be injured.
• An investigation can either be In Progress or Complete.
• An investigation can be conducted by only 1 investigator.
• Zach is conducting an investigation for a workshop fire.
• The workshop fire damaged a motor generator that cost $2000.
• The workshop fire caused a total of $15,000 damage.
• Accident Damage has 3 levels, low up to $1000, and high is anything over $10,000.
• Tom works at the workshop and got burnt on his legs during the fire.
• George is investigating the accident where Charlie slipped over in a laboratory.
• Charlie smashed a sensor valued at $800 when he slipped and also hurt his head.
• Allyssa is an electrician and she often investigates electrical accidents.
• Allyssa is investigating two accidents for the same air-compressor. The 1st accident occurred when
Sam plugged in the air compressor (while it was switched on) which shorted out the computer
and scales on the same circuit, doing $2000 damage to the computer and $500 damage to the
scales. The 2nd accident occurred when Hubert used the switch to turn the compressor on and
received a minor shock.
Complete the ontology by adding inverse, symmetric, and transitive properties and appropriate property,
instance and class restrictions to achieve correct inference.
You need to submit a .OWL file created in Protégé 4.3 or Protégé 5.X
CP2405 Assignment 1
CP2405 © 2019 – Information Technology @ James Cook University
PART 2
Context
Aussie Jobs is a company that provides a job seeking web portal. They would like to represent all their
information about jobs in Australia to be compliant for the Semantic Web. The scenario presented below is a
typical description of the kind of information that is present in the portal, and that should be contained in
(and queried from) a semantic knowledge base.
Scenario
Australia has six states and various territories. Canberra is the capital of Australia; it is located in the ACT,
which is a territory of Australia. Melbourne is the capital of the state of Victoria. Melbourne has two airports.
Tullamarine airport is served by Qantas, Virgin and Tigerair flights, while Avalon is served by Qantas and
Virgin. Melbourne has several train stations, the main station is Melbourne Central. Brisbane is the capital of
the state of Queensland. Brisbane has several train stations, the main station is Brisbane Central located in
the centre of Brisbane, but there is also the South Brisbane station located across Brisbane River. When
getting around in Melbourne by public transport there are buses, trams and the railway line. Stations are
broken up into 2 Myki ticketing zones (some stations are in the overlap between the two zones (Zone 1 and
2), where tickets for either zone may be used), as well as the City Saver area, which is within Zone 1 and
covers the central business district. In Melbourne and Brisbane you can stay in a hotel. Hotels have different
ratings (from five to one star), and rates within a price range. Price ranges of the hotels differ depending on
the time of the year that you decide to visit Melbourne or Brisbane. Canberra, Melbourne and Brisbane are
full of sights, such as churches, monuments, museums and family attractions. For example, St. Patrick’s
Cathedral (Melbourne) is a popular church, the Shrine of Remembrance (Melbourne) is a popular monument
and the Melbourne Museum and the Australian War Museum (Canberra) are popular museums. Brisbane is
well known for its family attractions such as the Gold Coast theme parks and the Australian Zoo. The fee to
enter the Australian Zoo is $59AUD for adults and $35AUD for children, although a family pass with 2 children
and 2 adults is $172AUD. There are organised tours to see the sights of Melbourne and surrounding regions
such as the great ocean road and the Yarra valley wineries. While in Melbourne a visitor should take the
opportunity to visit one of the many events taking place there during different periods, such as theatre and
opera performances, and concerts. There are a number of travel guides available for Melbourne, Canberra or
Brisbane; many of them are available in several formats, for example as a guidebook or on a CD. Maps of
these cities can also be found in paper format or in an electronic format..
Section 1. Determine the main statements in the scenario
For example:
1. Australia has six states and various territories.
2. Canberra is the capital of Australia, it is located in the ACT.
3. etc
Section 2 . Determine the elements and logical statements/axioms of a conceptual ontology model.
For example:
1) Australia has six states and various territories.
• Australia has both states and regions
2) Canberra is the capital of Australia; it is located in the ACT, which is a territory of Australia.
• A city is the capital of a country.
• A city is located in a state or territory.
Section 3. Determine the competency questions of the ontology design using the Ontology Requirements
Specification Framework (provided).
Ontology requirements specification document template
| 1 | What is the Purpose of the ontology |
CP2405 Assignment 1
CP2405 © 2019 – Information Technology @ James Cook University
| 2 | What is the Scope of the ontology |
| 3 | What is the level of Formality |
| 4 | Who are the Intended Users |
| 5 | What are the Intended Uses |
| 6 | List the Groups of Competency Questions and answers (eg priorities) |
| 7 | Pre-Glossary of Terms |
| List terms included in the CQs and their frequencies” | |
| List objects and their frequencies |
Refer to the MethOntology examples on http://neon-project.org/nw/NeOn_Book.html and the lecture
materials.
Example Competency Questions:
1) Canberra is the capital of Australia; it is located in the ACT, which is a territory of Australia.
• A city is the capital of a country.
• A city is located in a state or territory.
CQs:
∗ What city is the capital of a certain country?
∗ In what territory or state is a certain city located?
Marking Rubric
CP2405 © 2019 – Information Technology @ James Cook University
Ensure that you follow the processes and guidelines taught in class to produce high quality work. This assessment rubric provides you with the characteristics of exemplary,
competent, marginal and unacceptable work in relation to task criteria.
| Criteria | Exemplary | Competent | Satisfactory | Limited | Very Limited |
| Part 1 | |||||
| Program Execution Correct format |
5 Ontology using OWL load correctly in Protégé 4.3 or 5.X with no anonymous classes and reasonable description comment |
4 Ontology using OWL load correctly in Protégé 4.3 but has anonymous classes or no description comment |
3 Ontology using OWL load correctly in Protégé 4.3 but has anonymous classes and no description comment |
2 Ontology using OWL is available but will not validate and does not load correctly in Protégé 4.3/5.X |
1-0 No .OWL file available for marking or wrong version of Protégé used. |
| Classes and instances | 10-9 All classes and instances declared and are appropriate and efficient. All appropriate constructs and set operators have been applied on classes and instances including good logical choices |
8-7 Most classes and instances declared. Constructs and Set operators have been applied on all available classes and instances. |
6-5 Some classes declared used with some constructs applied. Some instances declared with some constructs applied. |
4-2 Few Classes or instances available for marking, not enough to represent scenario outlined in task. |
1-0 No Classes or instances available for marking. |
| Property restrictions and data quantifiers |
10-9 Appropriate and efficient inverse, symmetric, and transitive property characteristics used, including good logical choices. Appropriate restrictions on object properties and data properties. |
8-7 Inverse, symmetric, and transitive property characteristics used, data properties set, includes good logical choices |
6-5 Some attempt at data and object property characteristics used but are not logically correct. |
4-2 Few property characteristics available for marking. Not logically correct. Attempted but does not represent scenario. |
1-0 No property characteristics available for marking. |
| Logical correctness | 5 Reasoner subsumes correct sub classes to super classes. Reasoner subsumes correct instances to inferred classes |
4 Reasoner subsumes most sub classes to super classes. Reasoner subsumes some correct instances to inferred classes |
3 Reasoner subsumes most sub classes to super classes. Reasoner subsumes some correct instances to inferred classes. Some of the ontology is not satisfiable (some classes are turned red post reasoning). |
2 Ontology is not satisfiable (some classes are turned red post reasoning). |
1-0 Reasoner crashes or refuses to run due to errors. |
| Identifier naming | 5 All classes, properties and instance names are in the correct format, appropriate, meaningful and consistent. |
4 One or two classes, properties and instance names are not in the correct format, appropriate, meaningful or consistent. |
3 Three or four classes, properties and instance names are not in the correct format, appropriate, meaningful or consistent. |
2 More than four classes, properties and instance names are not in the correct format, appropriate, meaningful or consistent. |
1-0 All classes, properties and instance names are incorrectly formatted, poorly named and do not follow naming convention. |
Marking Rubric
CP2405 © 2019 – Information Technology @ James Cook University
| Part 2 | |||||
| Section 1 – Scenario breakdown |
10-9 The problem is divided into all sub parts effectively. Clear, explicit and specific statements drawn from the scenario |
8-7 The problem is divided into at least 3/4s of its sub-parts effectively. Clear, explicit and specific statements drawn from the scenario |
6-5 The problem is divided into at least 1/2 of its sub-parts effectively. Clear, explicit and specific statements drawn from the scenario |
4-2 A limited attempt has been made to divide the scenario into sub parts. |
1-0 Very limited or No attempt has been made to divide the scenario into sub-parts. |
| Section 2 Determine the logical statements/axioms of a conceptual ontology model |
10-9 All sub-part statements are declared using explicit logical statements and/or axioms that translate directly to an ontology model |
8-7 3/4s of the sub-part statements have been declared using explicit logical statements and/or axioms that translate directly to an ontology model |
6-5 1/2 of the sub-part statements have been declared using explicit logical statements and/or axioms that translate directly to an ontology model |
4-2 A limited attempt has been made to declare sub-parts using explicit logical statements and/or axioms that translate directly to an ontology model |
1-0 No attempt has been made to declare sub-parts using explicit logical statements and/or axioms that translate directly to an ontology model |
| Section 3 Ontology Requirements Specification – purpose, scope and user analysis |
10-9 Clear, concise and effective description of the purpose. Clear, concise and effective description of what the ontology aims to achieve Explicit and specific description of the intended end user and uses. |
8-7 Fairly clear description of the purpose. Fairly clear description of what the ontology aims to achieve. Fairly specific description of the intended end user and uses. |
6-5 Basic attempt to describe the purpose. Basic attempt to describe what the ontology aims to achieve Basic attempt to describe the intended end user and uses. |
4-2 Limited attempt, poorly articulated |
1-0 Very limited or No attempt made |
| Competency questions | 15-13 Clear, concise and effective list of competency questions. The CQ list is comprehensive A comprehensive glossary of terms is available. |
12-10 A clear list of many competency questions. The CQ list is comprehensive but missing a small number. A glossary of terms is available but not all terms in the CQs are listed. |
9-7 A list of some competency questions. There are many CQs missing in the list. A glossary of terms has been attempted but many terms in the CQs are not listed. |
6-3 Limited attempt. |
2-0 Very limited or No attempt at competency questions |
The post CP2405 Assignment 1 appeared first on My Assignment Online.