Design
Assignment – 2020
You
are to design a small-scale industry plate rolling machine for
rolling any aluminium alloy 1xxx series. The rolling mill produces
aluminium sheets of width 400mm wide and 20mm from 25mm thick
aluminium stock. The roll radius is about 300mm, and the rolls rotate
at 100rpm. The tolerance in thickness should be 0.01mm.
You may need to roll the stock material several times to produce the
required thickness.
The
power for running this mill comes from a motor running at 1500rpm.
You
should design the gears that drive the rollers to run the mill. The
gap between the rollers should be adjustable up to about 10mm. The
gap between the rollers should be held tight by power screws driven
by a motor or a belt drive for adjusting the gap size. The roller
bearings that hold the rollers in place must be designed to ensure a
smooth operation. You must work out the torque needed to run the
rollers and size the electric motor accordingly. The bolts that are
needed to hold the rollers should be able to take the load
accordingly. A clutch/braking mechanism must be designed to stop the
machine after the rolling is completed.
The
rolling machine is cycled about 100 times a day and this means, you
must design for fatigue life of all the components involved. For
comfort of workers the noise should not exceed 60dB.
Detail
what material you will use and the welding, if any, must be clearly
listed.
Your
design should be carried out on a CAD package, such as CREO, and all
the calculations must be made using a spreadsheet software. The CAD
package should be capable of producing animation. The machine should
be shown in animation through the software package.
Your
design should consider sustainability, modularity, and
maintainability.
You
should reference appropriate standards when designing the machine
elements. You must also use readily-purchased components from the
market place.
Your
design should consist of a gear box, gear-shaft, keys and
keyways, bearings, welds, threaded fasteners, clutches and brakes,
couplings and springs. You must specify tolerances and design for
fatigue and surface fatigue. You must follow industry standards and
use, where possible, modular design.
Assumptions
should be reasonable and justified.
You
should also produce a 3D printed part of the machine and should be
scaled suitably.
Marking
scheme
Assessment
items
Project
plan 10% Week 3
You
must show that you have done some preliminary research on this
design. You should show some calculations of the forces and torque
experienced in the design. You must also specify how you plan to
allocate work and who is going to do what. There should be schedule
for a pathway to completion.
Interim
report 20% week 6
This
report should consist of all design topics that were covered until
Week 5 (until Rivets and Welding). This should clearly tell which of
you did what part of the design. One may submit a more extensive
design too. The report should as a minimum cover CAD drawing and
animation of a gear box attached to a motor. You should also provide
clear evidence of your interaction with your team members and your
contributions to the team. You should mention how you provided your
individual portion on time, how you helped your team members, and
minutes of each meeting that you attend. You will need to submit
records of your meeting with all submissions.
|
Marking guidelines for Interim report – 20 marks Week 6 |
||||||
|
Area of report |
85-100% | 75-84% | 65-74% | 50-64% | 40-49% | <40% |
|
Individual contribution 65% |
Very good progress shown in the report and covers all the design topics until Week 5. The design of gear box is complete with animation using the CAD package. |
Good progress shown in the report and covers most aspects of the design topics until Week 5. The design of gear box is complete with animation using the CAD package. |
Good progress shown in the report and covers only some aspects of the design topics until Week 5. The design of gear box is complete with animation using the CAD package. |
Fair progress shown in the report and covers some aspects of the design. The design of gear box is partially complete using the CAD package. |
Some progress shown in the report and covers very few aspects of the design. The design of gear box is partially complete. No work using CAD package. |
Poor progress shown in the report and covers very few aspects of the design. The design of gear box is incomplete. No work using CAD package. |
|
Group report 25% |
The report is excellent and covers all aspects of the design until Week 5. The report is written very fluently, and the report flows very well. The report is well written and shows contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is very good and covers all aspects of the design until week 5. The report is written very fluently, and the report flows very well. The report is well written and shows contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written good and covers all aspects of the design until week 5. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report is well written and shows contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written fairly well and covers some aspects of the design until week 5. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report does not clearly show the contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written good and covers a few aspects of the design until week 5. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report does not clearly show the contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written good and covers a few aspects of the design until week 5. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report does not clearly show the contribution of each student in the group. |
|
Teamwork contribution 10% |
||||||
|
Contributions towards organising and correcting report and other aspects of project |
Clear evidence of strong leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Strong evidence of collaboration. Strong evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Clear evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Clear evidence of collaboration. Clear evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Evidence of sufficient leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Evidence of sufficient level of collaboration. Evidence of contributions to the report development and organization |
Evidence of adequate leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Evidence of adequate level of collaboration. Evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Insufficient evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Insufficient evidence of adequate level of collaboration. Insufficient evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Little or no evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Little or no evidence of collaboration. Little or no evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Presentation
30% Week 9 Poster produced on a slide (A1 size) and oral presentation
– 3 minutes (individual) + 1000-word report
|
Marking guidelines for Presentation and report – 30 marks Week 9 |
||||||
|
Area of report |
85-100% | 75-84% | 65-74% | 50-64% | 40-49% | <40% |
|
Individual presentation 45%. You must do a oral presentation of your part. |
Very good fluent presentation and very good progress shown in the report and covers all the design topics until Week 8. |
Good fluent presentation and Good progress shown in the report and covers most aspects of the design topics until Week 8. |
Good fluent presentation and Good progress shown in the report and covers only some aspects of the design topics until Week 8. |
Fairly fluent presentation and fair progress shown in the report and covers some aspects of the design. |
Some fluency in presentation and some progress shown in the report and covers very few aspects of the design.. |
Poor presentation and poor progress shown in the report and covers very few aspects of the design. The design of gear box is incomplete. No work using CAD package. |
|
Group report 45% |
The report is excellent and covers all aspects of the design until Week 8. The report is written very fluently, and the report flows very well. The report is well written and shows contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is very good and covers all aspects of the design until week 8. The report is written very fluently, and the report flows very well. The report is well written and shows contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written good and covers all aspects of the design until week 8. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report is well written and shows contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written fairly well and covers some aspects of the design until week 8. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report does not clearly show the contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written good and covers a few aspects of the design until week 8. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report does not clearly show the contribution of each student in the group. |
The report is written good and covers a few aspects of the design until week 8. The report is written fluently, and the report flows well. The report does not clearly show the contribution of each student in the group. |
|
Teamwork contribution 10% |
||||||
|
Contributions towards organising and correcting report and other aspects of project |
Clear evidence of strong leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Strong evidence of collaboration. Strong evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Clear evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Clear evidence of collaboration. Clear evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Evidence of sufficient leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Evidence of sufficient level of collaboration. Evidence of contributions to the report development and organization |
Evidence of adequate leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Evidence of adequate level of collaboration. Evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Insufficient evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Insufficient evidence of adequate level of collaboration. Insufficient evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Little or no evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Little or no evidence of collaboration. Little or no evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
|
ENG338 Machine Design Principles – Detailed Design Marking guidelines – FINAL REPORT 40 marks |
||||||
|
Area of report and value |
85 – 100% |
75 – 84% |
65 – 74% |
50 – 64% |
40 – 49% |
< 40% |
|
Design calculations and Report structure, fluency and accuracy 40% |
Design is based on equations from text book appropriately referenced. Appropriate materials selection and properties, safety factors considered. Layout and structure of the report is excellent with document having clear and logical flow from section to section. The document is very easy to follow with fluent sentences, free of punctuation and spelling errors. Subject specific vocabulary confidently used. Design is fully in SI units. All specs are met. All aspects of the machine and the design specifications for each machine element are covered. The design is clearly described with the aid of appropriate diagrams. Industry Standards are followed. Design based on costings, modularity, sustainability and maintainability. |
Design is generally based on equations from text book appropriately referenced. Appropriate materials selection and properties, safety factors considered. Layout and structure of the report is very good with document having clear and logical flow from section to section. The document is easy to follow with well-formed sentences, mostly free of punctuation and spelling errors. Subject specific vocabulary is generally used. Design is fully in SI units. All specs are met. All aspects of the machine and the design specifications for each machine element are covered. The design is clearly described with the aid of appropriate diagrams. Design based on costings, modularity, sustainability and maintainability. |
Design is generally based on equations from text book and, at times, appropriately referenced. Appropriate materials selection and properties, safety factors considered. Layout and structure of the report makes document readable and accessible. Flow is mostly logical. The flow from section to section can be improved. Some successful use of subject specific vocabulary. Design is fully in SI units. All aspects of the machine and some of the design specifications for each machine element are covered. Some mention of costings, modularity, sustainability and maintainability. The design is clearly described with the aid of appropriate diagrams. |
Design is generally based on equations from text book and, not appropriately referenced. Some flaws in presentation. Adequate materials selection and properties, safety factors considered. Structure and layout interfere with clarity and readability. Some grammatical, spelling, and punctuation inaccuracies. Word choice and use of subject specific vocabulary unsure. Design is not fully in SI units. All aspects of the machine and some of the design specifications for each machine element are covered. The design is described with the aid of appropriate diagrams. |
Inadequate coverage of design calculations. Failure to present or to control different sections of the report. Many inaccuracies of grammar and/or punctuation and/or spelling and calculations. Limited vocabulary. Design is not fully in SI units. Design specs poorly met. Inappropriate materials selection and properties, safety factors considered. |
Very poor design with references to equations. Structure detracts from understanding. Numerous mistakes in spelling and grammar and calculations. Design is not fully in SI units. No understanding of how specs are to be met. Inappropriate materials selection and properties, safety factors considered. |
|
CAD drawing (25%) |
Clear and comprehensive CAD drawings. Demonstrates excellent understanding of methods used by CAD software. Each machine element can be seen as a part and as assembly. |
Clear and complete CAD drawings. Demonstrates very good understanding of methods used by CAD software. Each machine element can be seen as a part and as assembly. |
Clear depiction using CAD drawings. Demonstrates good understanding of methods used by CAD software. Each machine element can be seen as a part and as assembly. |
Adequate CAD drawings. Demonstrates fair understanding of methods used by CAD software. Each machine element can be seen as a part and as assembly. |
Inadequate CAD drawings. Demonstrates poor understanding of methods used by CAD software. Each machine element cannot be seen as a part and as assembly. |
Inadequate CAD drawings. Demonstrates very poor understanding of methods used by CAD software. Each machine element cannot be seen as a part and as assembly. |
|
Animation (10%) |
Clear and detailed animation that can be broken in to several sub-assemblies. All the different machine elements can be easily seen to be working together. |
Clear animation that can be broken in to several sub-assemblies. All the different machine elements can be easily seen to be working together. |
Clear animation that can be broken in to several sub-assemblies. All the different machine elements can be fairly seen to be working together. |
Animation shows that demonstrating some control over the CAD software. Sub-assemblies are not very clear. |
Poor animation with little demonstration of CAD software. No subassemblies seen |
Unclear or no animation. |
|
3D printing of machine 15%) |
Clear and comprehensive 3D printed scaled-down model. Meets the design specs. The design is innovative. The design is clearly described with different coloured parts. |
Very good 3D printed scaled-down model. Meets the design specs. The design is very good. The design is clearly described with different coloured parts. |
Good 3D printed scaled-down model. Meets the design specs. The design is good. |
Adequate 3D printed scaled-down model. Meets some of design specs. The design is fair. |
Incomplete 3D printed scaled-down model. Some design specs not met. The design is poor. |
Incomplete 3D printed scaled-down model. Design specs not met. The design is very poor. |
|
Teamwork contribution 10% |
||||||
|
Contributions towards organising and correcting report and other aspects of project |
Clear evidence of strong leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Strong evidence of collaboration. Strong evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Clear evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Clear evidence of collaboration. Clear evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Evidence of sufficient leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Evidence of sufficient level of collaboration. Evidence of contributions to the report development and organization |
Evidence of adequate leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Evidence of adequate level of collaboration. Evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Insufficient evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Insufficient evidence of adequate level of collaboration. Insufficient evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
Little or no evidence of leadership and initiative in group’s activities. Little or no evidence of collaboration. Little or no evidence of contributions to the report development and organization. |
The post Design Assignment appeared first on My Assignment Online.