Lab 1 Motor Skill Classification
Introduction
One dimensional (1D) classification systems categorise motor skills based on one underlying skill characteristic. Classifying motor skills using 1D classification systems can assist the instructor to evaluate the demands placed on a performer during motor skill execution. That is to say, 1D classification systems provide the instructor with information regarding the elements that are important for successful motor skill performance. There are three 1D systems that can be used by instructors to evaluate motor skills:
Precision of the movement: This system classifies skills based on the size of the muscles used during the performance. Skills can range from fine (mainly involves small muscle groups) to gross (mainly involves large muscle groups)
Organisation of the skill: This system classifies skills according to how the motor elements are organised. Skills can be classified as discrete (movements with a defined beginning and end), serial (several discrete actions connected in a sequence), or continuous (no discernible beginning or end, and are typically repetitive or rhythmic
Stability of the environment: This system classifies skills based on the stability of the performance environment. Skills range from open (unstable or changing environment) to closed skills (stable or unchanging environment)
How a skill is classified using the 1D classification systems depends on factors relating to the motor skill situation:
- Who is the learner? Personal characteristics that will affect performance and learning (e.g. level of experience, age, physical capacities, tactile knowledge, personality, motivation, etc.)
- What are the demands of the task? Requirements imposed by the task itself that must be met for successful performance (e.g. open skill, discrete skill, fine motor skill etc.)
- Where and when is the task to be performed? Aspects of the environment that will affect performance (e.g. rain, high humidity, indoor facility, championship playoff, moving environment etc.)
Gentile’s two-dimensional (2D) taxonomy classifies motor skills according to both task requirements and the environmental context. Classifying motor skills using Gentile’s 2D taxonomy can assist the instructor to evaluate the functional requirements associated with performing a motor skill, which can assist in assessing performer capabilities and limitations, charting an individual’s progress through skill development or rehabilitation, and selecting functionally appropriate practice activities for motor skill development. The two dimensions considered in Gentile’s taxonomy each include two sub-dimensions. Specifically, the dimensions of Gentile’s taxonomy include:
Action function: This dimension categorises skills based on the requirements of the task according to body orientation (body stability or body transport) and object manipulation (absent or present)
Environmental context: Categorises skills based on the requirements of the task according to the regulatory conditions (stationary or in-motion) and inter-trial variability (absent or present)
Gentile’s 2D taxonomy results in 16 skill categories that can be used to categorise tasks according to their functional requirements. It is important to note that this system does NOT compare task
3
difficulty; it only determines whether or not a functional element is present. For example, a handstand would be categorised in box 1D and walking across the road while carrying a grocery bag would be categorised into box 4D. Although walking across the road while carrying a bag of groceries has greater functional requirements, holding a handstand is likely a more difficult task.
In this class you will classify motor skills using the 1D classification systems to evaluate the demands placed on the performer during motor skill execution. You will then examine how changing who, what or where factors may influence skill classification and thus the performance demands associated with motor skill execution. Finally, we will categorise motor skills using Gentile’s 2D taxonomy and development a series of functional progression activities for a task of your choice.
Procedure
Task 1: 1D Motor Skill Classifications
Identify two motor skills and classify each in terms of the three 1D classification systems using the schematic provided. Select activities that are relatively different from one another. For the precision of the movement and stability of the environment classifications, place an X on the continuum that represents where you think the skill falls. For the organisation of the skill, circle the classification (discrete, serial, or continuous). Provide a rationale for your decisions. Then for each task, describe one change to a who, what, or where factor and describe how that change may influence motor skill classification and the demands placed on the performer during motor skill execution.
4
Motor Skill 1:
Fine ————– Gross | Discrete —— (Serial) ——- Continuous | Open ————– Closed
Rationale:
Change to who, what or where factors:
Motor Skill 2:
Fine ————– Gross | Discrete —— (Serial) ——-Continuous | Open ————– Closed
Rationale:
Change to who, what or where factors:
5
Task 2: Categorising Motor Skills Using Gentile’s Taxonomy
Identify which of the 16 skill categories associated with Gentile’s taxonomy best describe the functional requirements for each of the tasks described below (e.g. box 1D, box 2A, etc.)
Performing repetitive bench presses of 30 kg using the universal bench press machine not free weights
Hitting a ball off a tee when the performer is stationary but swings at the ball with a bat
Performing forehand drives in tennis off a ball machine where the ball comes over the net at the same speed and location
Shadow boxing without gloves nor an opponent. Pretending to box another boxer.
Scrimmage in volleyball with the ball, opponents, and teammate
The football coach develops offensive play that is executed the same way 5 times in arrow with the ball against defenders that move
The tennis teacher developed a drill where he/she throws the tennis ball at different locations of the court and student is required to move and pretend to hit the ball without the racquet from the different locations
Runner performs a fartlek workout (where running speed is randomly varied throughout running) on a treadmill
In physical therapy, the client is required to carry a weight while they walk on carpet, then a tile floor, and then on wooden floor
Stationary balance on one leg for 20 seconds on a low balance beam
Task 3: Developing a Functionally Appropriate Skills Progression.
Demonstrate your understanding of Gentile’s Taxonomy by developing a functionally appropriate progression for a motor skill of your choice. How you develop functionally appropriate skills progression is by categorising the skill into the appropriate box (e.g. box 4D) and working backward by appropriately modifying the skill that the functional demands are reduced until to you reach the least demanding box (e.g. box 1A). For example, describe how you could change the motor skill described in box 4D to fit the characteristics of Box 4C. Then describe how you could change the skill described in box 4D to fit the characteristics of Box 4B and so on. If you do this correctly you will have developed a “profile of competencies” that can be used to develop a series of functionally appropriate progression activities to assist skill learning (typically skills progressions would be developed by moving down columns A, B, C or D depending on the action function requirements of the task; that is to say, general skills progressions only modify the environmental context requirements).
6
FUNCTION OF THE ACTION
Body Stability Body Transport
ENVIRONMENTAL CONTEXT
No Object Manipulation
Object Manipulation
No Object Manipulation
Object Manipulation
Stationary Regulatory Conditions
No Intertrial
Variability
1A.
1B.
1C.
1D.
Intertrial
Variability
2A.
2B.
2C.
2D.
In-Motion Regulatory Conditions
No Intertrial
Variability
3A.
3B.
3C.
3D.
Intertrial
Variability
4A.
4B.
4C.
4D.
Discussion - How do 1D classification systems evaluate the demands placed on the performer during motor skill execution?
- How does modifying who, what or where factors influence the demands placed on the performer? What applications does this have for the instructor?
- Describe how Gentile’s 2D taxonomy evaluates the functional requirements of a task:
- Describe how Gentile’s 2D taxonomy can be applied in instructional settings to develop a profile of competencies or functionally appropriate motor skills progressions:
The post EHR214 Skill Acquisition Lab Manual 2020 appeared first on My Assignment Online.