LAW2STA
Statutory Interpretation 2019
PRACTICE PROBLEM
EXAMINER’S ANSWER
(597 words)
Answer in Brief
The Commissioner erred. ‘Incorrect’ in s 9(1) of the Back to Work Act 2015 (Vic) (‘the Victorian Act’) means incorrect as to fact, that is, the claimant was not entitled to the back to work payment.
As Wilma was entitled to the payment, the decision could not be reversed and she is under no obligation to repay the amount sought under s 37 of the Victorian Act.
Discussion
Unit of inquiry
Section 9(1) of the Victorian Act. The focus is on the word ‘incorrect’.
Opposing constructions
Construction for the Commissioner
‘Incorrect’ includes improper.
If this is the law, the decision is incorrect as it is improper to receive dual back to work payments. (Weak, as retrospectively imposed.)
Construction for Wilma
‘Incorrect’ means the payment was not properly made by reason the claimant was not entitled to the payment.
If this is the law, the payment was not incorrect as Wilma was entitled to the payment.
Arguments for Commissioner’s construction
Provision
The provision does not state the precise basis for being ‘incorrect’. Therefore it may be interpreted widely. (Not strong, as it is subject to context).
An ordinary meaning of ‘incorrect’ is ‘improper’: Macquarie Dictionary (online edition) (Not strong; second meaning).
Section 9 requires the Commissioner to be ‘satisfied … that the decision is incorrect’. This suggests that the basis for a s 9 decision is not entirely objectively based in factual error. (Weak; concedes objectivity)
Remainder of Act
Section 37(1)(b) refers to a reversal ‘for any other reason’. This is open-ended. (Lacks cogency — rebutted below).
Arguments for Wilma’s construction
Provision
The primary dictionary meaning of ‘incorrect’ is ‘not correct as to fact’: Macquarie Dictionary (online edition). Eligibility is a fact.
The provision refers to ‘decides a claim’ — hence the immediate context (noscitur a sociis) references decisions under s 7 with respect to the eligibility criteria.
Remainder of Act
The context and arrangement of the neighbouring provisions suggest a concern for eligibility. Section 9 is preceded by provisions on eligibility: ss 5 and 7. Section 9 is in Division 2, ‘Decision on Claims’.
Section 9(2), in referring to eligibility of the claimant, suggests the section is about eligibility.
Section 29(a), which concerns investigations, suggests a purpose of investigations and of corrections. It refers to ‘whether a claim has been properly made’.
The specific reason specified in s 37 as grounding repayment (‘error’: (1)(a)) is consistent with Wilma’s construction.
Section 37(1)(b) (‘any other reason’) does not extend s 9 in terms of grounds of reversal. Section 9, not s 37, is the source of the power to reverse. Hence, read in context of the purpose of s 9, a s 37(1)(b) ‘other reason’ impliedly refers only to some other reason which may be the basis for a reversal under s 9.
Legislative history
The Statement of Compatibility relating to the Back to Work Bill 2014 (Vic) refers to the mischief underlying ss 9 and 37: ‘The repayment represents an amount to which the claimant was not entitled’: Victoria, Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 11 February 2015, 167.
Wider context
To reverse a decision, and require repayment, in respect of a person, when the person’s entitlement has never been in question, would be manifestly unfair and a breach of property rights.
Evaluation of the arguments
As shown above, the arguments for the Commissioner are weak. Wilma’s case (especially from the Act) is clearly stronger.
Preferred construction
Wilma’s construction is preferred.
Application of the Law as Interpreted
There was no power to reverse the decision under s 9. This means that the repayment cannot be required under s 37.
The post LAW2STA PRACTICE PROBLEM appeared first on My Assignment Online.