La Trobe University
La Trobe Law School
LAW2STA
Statutory Interpretation
Exemplar
Child Employment Act 2003 (Vic) — Jack, Jill, Merve and Mervin
examiner’s answer (591 WORDS including footnotes)
Answer in brief
The parents — Jack and Jill; Merve and Mervin — should plead not guilty to a breach of s 26 of the Child Employment Act 2003 (Vic) (‘the Act’).
Constructions of s 26
Construction for prosecution
‘Directly supervised in that employment’ means supervision during the whole course of the employment.
Construction for parents
‘Directly supervised in that employment’ means direct supervision, by a parent or guardian, of such a nature and extent that (a) is compatible with the employment in question and (b) adequately protects the child from dangers. It does not uniformly require, for every employment, that students are overseen at each stage of the work.
Arguments for prosecution
Provision Section 26 says ‘in that employment’.
Provision If it were intended that children be left without supervision during the course of the employment, alternative words could have been used. Similar words to s 19(1)(b) could have been used in s 26.
Act and wider context It is not unreasonable to impose greater regulation for family businesses. This is because no permit is required: see s 9(3).
Arguments for parents
Provision The word ‘directly’ merely indicates such supervision, as is appropriate in the circumstances, is to be direct and directly by the parent, not someone else.
Provision and Act Section 26 does not say the supervision is to occur ‘at all times’ (as it does in s 19(1)).
Act If the provision means what the prosecution says, then both types of employment are not effectively allowed or practicable in a family business. Yet:
- In the case of deliveries of newspapers, this employment is sanctioned, even for children as young as 11.1
- In the case of babysitting, the Act gives indirect indications it is sanctioned.2
Act The principal difference between s 26 and s 19(1)(b) is drafting style only. One is general principles drafting; the other is detailed.
Legislative history The Minister made plain that employment on family farms would be allowed without a permit.3 But, given the nature of farm life, realistically, employment of children on farms must often lack supervision in the sense of directly overseen at all times. In other words, the mischief is not children working without being overseen.
Wider context Why would the Act lay down a greater requirement of supervision in relation to family businesses (according to the prosecution) than it does with non family businesses? This would be an odd and anomalous consequence.
Wider context The prosecution construction would rule out much employment by children in family businesses, other than in shops and businesses where the parent is in attendance at all times.
Evaluation of competing constructions
Both constructions are textually open. However, the argument from s 19 and the consequential arguments for the parents are strong. The construction favouring the parents is clearly weightier overall.
Application to the facts
Having regard to the independent nature of the work (deliveries; babysitting), to the age of the children (14), to the Act allowing newspaper deliveries from the age of 114, and to the evidence that the children appear to have sufficient maturity for the tasks in question (no problem has been encountered), the level of supervision by both sets of parents did not breach the requisite standard imposed by s 26.
1 See s 10(1)(a)(i) of the Act.
2 See s 4(3)(e) of the Act and the statement of purpose that babysitting for a commercial agency is regulated: Victoria, Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 9 April 2003, 946 (Mr Hulls).
3 See, Victoria, Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 9 April 2003, 948 (Mr Hulls).
4 Section 10(1)(a) of the Act.
The post LAW2STA Statutory Interpretation appeared first on My Assignment Online.