LETTER OF ENGAGEMENT
Mr Kris Iyer
We are pleased to present this letter to confirm the submission of this report of
appraisal between Nike Inc. and Adidas AG. This letter summarises the nature and
the outcome of the report provided.
Objective of The Report
This assignment’s purpose is to make use of the skills nurtured to give a
knowledgeable appraisal to determine which company Nike or Adidas is
recommended for investment
Assessment Criteria and Output of The Engagement
The report will assess each company using vertical and horizontal financial analysis
calculations. This includes the use of ratio analysis including the companies’ ability to
maintain liquidity, solvency, and profitability as well as a comprehensive check on
horizontal percentage analysis to also quantify the differences between 2015 and 2016
financial results. All the methods used will have the purpose of successfully obtaining
a well-rounded scope of both companies and determine their worth. As a result, this
report will draw appropriate advice to the most thriving organisation.
Outsourced Services
To gather secondary data for this report the author has made use of official company
websites and use other similar trustworthy evidence supporting sources for research
purposes.
INTRODUCTION
Financial analysis is a tool which is used to know the financial strengths and weaknesses of a
firm. It can also be used to obtain understanding in which company to invest in. In this report,
the two companies are NIKE Inc and Adidas AG. Nike is an American multinational company
(Nike, 2016), which designs sports shoes and sports apparels. The company is headquartered
in Bevatron Oregon in Portland Metropolitan area. It’s the largest manufacturer of sports goods
with a business turnover of US$30.601 Billion in the fiscal year 2015. On the other hand,
Adidas is a German multinational company (Adidas, 2016), which designs and manufactures
sports equipment’s, clothing, and other commodities. It is considered largest in Europe and
second largest in the world with a revenue turnover of £19.291 as of 2016.
According to Fortune Retail, the world’s second largest sports goods manufacturer Adidas has
delivered proof of its success towards its path of victory by recording a jump of 23% compared
to 20% of Nike in the fiscal of second quarter in the North American markets, following the
double digits gain in the year 2015” (Kell, 2016). This shows that Adidas is outperforming Nike
based on sales growth percentage. This news builds confidence on Adidas investors and more
people are beginning to trust the brand. As an investor, however, knowing this, should only be
considered as information on the surface. And, it is not enough to make decisions whether a
company is good for investments. This case study will show the financial strengths and
weaknesses of both companies based on financial analysis. Analysing both companies’
liquidity, solvency, and profitability together with vertical and horizontal analysis provides
better decision making.
VERTICAL ANALYSIS 2016
Vertical Analysis – Liquidity
Current ratio
Nike 2.8
Adidas 1.31
Quick ratio
Nike 1.62
Adidas 0.66
Accounts receivable ratio
Nike 9.81
Adidas 9.08
No of Days Sales’ in Receivables
Nike 38
Adidas 41
Inventory Turnover
Nike 3.79
Adidas 2.88
No of Days’ Sales in Inventory
Nike 97
Adidas 127
Vertical Analysis – Solvency
Ratio of Fixed Assets to Long Term Liabilities
Nike 0.42
Adidas 0.76
Ratio of Liabilities to Stockholders’ Equity
Nike 0.74
Adidas 1.05
Number of Times Interest Rate changes are
Earned
Nike 244.30
Adidas 21.66
Vertical Analysis – Profitability
Ratio of Net Sales to Assets
Nike 1.5
Adidas 0.41
Rate Earned on Total Assets
Nike 0.17
Adidas 0.12
Rate Earned on Stockholders’ Equity
Nike 0.22
Adidas 0.14
LIQUIDITY
Liquidity is very important for the company to run the business. Adalsteinsson (2014)
stated that liquidity is a company capability for obtaining cash when needed. Cash
availability determines whether the company should efficient the budget or invest it
and whether it is profitable or unprofitable. There are three components in liquidity
ratios, current ratios, quick ratios, and accounts receivable turnover.
Table 1. Vertical Analysis Liquidity Ratios Adidas and Nike in 2016 (Personal
Collection)
Current ratios between Adidas and Nike in 2016 are 1.31:2.8. The current ratio is using
for indicating a firm’s capability to complete its short-term obligation (Stickney, Weil,
Schipper, & Francis, 2009, p. 266). Nike’s current ratio explained that the company is
strongly capable of paying their debts. Tracy (2011, p. 287) stated that a company with
above 2 current ratio should not worry about the debts payment. Nike could develop
its cash faster because the number of sales in receivable of Nike is only 38 days so
that Nike could produce better cash flow.
On the other hand, Adidas showed current ratio 1.31 in 2016. It meant that Adidas still
able to pay their debts, but they might do not have a big amount of money left to use
for their cash flow compared to Nike. Adidas needed 41 days to get their cash back
so that they could manage the money for better cash flow. Although Adidas’s number
2.8
1.62
9.81
1.31
0.66
9.08
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Current Ratio Quick Ratio Accounts Receivable Ratio
Chart Title
Nike Adidas
of sales receivable was behind Nike, Adidas showed significant progress from 2015
with 48 days to 41 days in 2016.
According to Delaney and Whittington (2009, p. 327), quick ratio is the ability of the
company for fulfilling current liabilities using quick assets. Quick assets are easy to
convert into cash, for instances, cash, account receivable, and short-term investment.
Quick ratios between Adidas and Nike in 2016 are 0.66:1.62. Nike’s quick ratio stated
that $1.62 was available in Nike’s liquid assets to pay every $1 current liabilities. Nike
could pay their current liabilities and they have extra funds. On the other side, Adidas
had quick ratio 0.66 in 2016. An ideal quick ratio is 1:1 as a comparison between quick
ratio results (Thukaram, 2007, p. 87). Adidas had only $0.66 liquid assets to cover
every $1 current liabilities. There were several issues that make quick assets of Adidas
is low, for instances, Number of sales in receivable Adidas is 41 days, which is need
more time to receive the cash, and the number of fixed assets was bigger than quick
assets (see table on page 4). Adidas had to increase their sales and reducing
overhead costs to cover those liabilities.
Account receivable turnover is indicating the ability of the company to collect cash
quickly (Stickney et al., 2009, p. 251). Adidas and Nike had account receivable
turnover ratio with 9.08:9.81. Nike collected receivable 9.81 times per year so that
about 9.81 times Nike could receive those cash from the buyers in one year. However,
Nike’s current ratio was high, so that it would not affect Nike’s cash flow system.
Adidas had 9.08 turnover ratios so that they could receive cash from the receivable
about 9.08 times per year. It potentially became a problem for Adidas because they
have a low current ratio so that they were late for getting cash. However, if Adidas
could produce more quick assets, Adidas can get more comfortable with managing
the money.
Inventory Turnover Ratio
Table 2: Nike and Adidas Inventory Turnover Ratio in the year 2016 (Personal
Collection)
Inventory turnover ratio shows how many times a company inventories are sold and
replaced over a period of time. Also, It is a critical key indicator, which allows us to
examine a business performance based on how fast the products are sold. Based on
the figure above, Nike has higher inventory turnover ratio compared to Adidas with
3.79 versus 2.88. It implies that Nike’s products are sold faster and shows better
business performance. However, having high turnover ratio would not always mean
that the business is profitable.
Number of Days Sales in Inventory
Table 3: Nike and Adidas Number of Sales in Inventory In the year 2016
(Personal Collection)
3.79
2.88
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
Inventory Turnover Ratio
Nike
adidas
96.31
126.74
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Number of Days Sales in Inventory
Nike
adidas
The number of days sales in inventory shows how long all inventories are converted
into sales. The rate of how fast inventories are sold can be utilised for stock clearing
or analysing future projections. Also, this analysis can be used in forecasting for par
stock levels and input levels of inventories. The chart shows that Adidas needs 127
days to sell all their inventories compare to Nike with only 97 days. In financial
perspective, this data favours Nike on being able to sell its inventories faster than
Adidas which also implies better liquidity.
SOLVENCY
This analysis shows the capacity of both companies on their long-term capability to
stay in business and the ability to pay their longstanding debts to banks or other
creditors. According to Mande, Park and Son (2012), having debt are not necessarily
bad for the business. It is a way to utilised resources from others to gain more profit.
Also, It is an opportunity to buy time and start capitalising future projects. However,
there are considerable risks of using debt for the company due to the possibility of not
earning enough profit to cover it. Hence, it may slow down the operation or lead to
bankruptcy. A good debt is a well-managed debt. Having the ability to use other
people’s money to make more money is a crucial skill for business to prosper. On the
other hand, as an investor, he or she should be able to determine the solvency of the
company to examine if its low risk or high risk in terms of company’s long-term
strength. Knowing and understanding the ratio of debt to asset, debt to equity and
times interest earned will help an individual to check the health of the company if it is
a solvent or not.
Table 4. Nike and Adidas Debt to Asset and Debt to Equity Ratio (Personal
Collection)
The debt to asset ratio of both companies has increased from 2015 -2016 but
remained low. It is less risky on their capital structure with Adidas 0.72 – 0.76 and Nike
0.41 – 0.42. These means that both companies do not incur debt more than what they
have in assets. In a worst-case scenario, this shows that the value of the company is
enough to pay all the debts. In investor or creditor’s perspective, he or she can be
assured that the money they put in the business can be paid.
The debt to equity ratio of Adidas and Nike has increased from 2015-2016, with Adidas
0.95-1.05 and Nike 0.69 -0.74. Nike has a better debt to equity ratio due to the fact
that most of its equity came from investors. On the other hand, Adidas has incurred
debt more than its investor’s money in the year 2016. This is considered to be riskier
because having funded with more debt would mean more interest expense and would
oblige the company to put pressure on sales.
0.42
0.76 0.74
1.05
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
Debt to Asset Debt to Equity
Nike adidas
Table 5: Nike and Adidas Times Interest Earn Ratio (Personal Collection)
The time’s interest earned ratio of both companies have a significant increase in the
year 2015-2016; with Adidas 16.28 – 21.66 and Nike 151.17 – 244.3. Nike has a large
difference compared to Adidas. This shows that Nike has the stronger capacity to pay
off debt based on profit and has a better long-term financial strength.
PROFITABILITY
Out of the three aspects of Vertical Analysis, Profitability is more useful for investors
as they get an overall understanding on how the company is performing. Profitability
is measured in different aspects – Return on Equity Ratio, Return on Asset Ratio
and Profit Margin Ratio, these ratios helps us understand how much profit is
generated on shareholders’ investment, how well the assets are used by the
management and profit generated over net sales respectively.
In this scenario of Nike vs Adidas, Nike is outrunning Adidas by a considerable margin
in all the facets.
244.3
21.66
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Times Inerest Earned
Nike Adidas
Table 6: Vertical Analysis – Profitability (Personal Collection)
Rate Earned on Total Assets (Return on Assets) is the ratio which helps us measure
the efficiency of how the company is managing its assets (Nasdaq, 2017). Based on
the table we can see that both the companies are doing above the industry average,
but Adidas just above the margin and Nike with a better asset management. But when
compared to growth among the companies Adidas is increasing at a quicker rate.
Investors consider this ratio as it shows how effectively the company is using the
resources, i.e. the value, in this case, shows that on every 1 dollar invested in
purchasing the assets, 17% is gained as net income.
Rate Earned on Total Assets (%)
Year NIKE ADIDAS Industry
Avg.
2016 17 12 10.29
2015 16 8 8.39
17%
22%
12%
14%
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Rate Earned on Total Assets Rate Earned on Stockholders’ Equity
Vertical Analysis – 2016
Nike Adidas
Rate Earned on Shareholders’ Equity (Return on Equity) is used to measure the
efficiency of shareholders money to generate profits, unlike Return on Assets which
includes both equity and debt, whereas Return on equity is from an investors point of
view (Lexicon, 2017). From the table, we can see that Nike is above the industry
average but radically declined from 37% to 22% on its return from 2015 to 2016
whereas Adidas is below the industry average but its returns are increasing from 9%
to 14%. When looking from the investors perspective neither of the companies are
doing well.
Comparing both ‘Return on Assets’ and ‘Return on Equity’ we can realise that Nike
though being higher is gradually decreasing and Adidas improving, in our opinion Nike
would be a better option to invest if they improve their management and implement
some plans to increase their productivity.
Table 7: Asset Turnover Ratio (Personal Collection)
The Asset turnover ratio gives us how
many net sales is earned on the total
assets (Hussain, 1996). Nike is higher
than Adidas which states Nike is more
competent in utilising resources to
create sales. Adidas is not producing
enough business in proportion to its
assets. The Apparel and Footwear
industry has an asset turnover of 1.28
average in 2016 compared to that Nike
is doing well, on another hand, Adidas
is below the margin.
Rate Earned on Shareholders’ Equity (%)
Year NIKE ADIDAS Industry
Avg.
2016 22 14 20.06
2015 37 9 15.75
1.5
0.41
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
2016
Asset Turnover Ratio
Nike Adidas
HORIZONTAL ANALYSIS
Horizontal Analysis – Income Statement Nike ($ In Millions)
Revenue 2015 2016 Change % Change
Total Revenue 30,601 32,376 1,775 5.8
Cost of Sales 16,534 17,405 871 5.2
Gross Profit 14,067 14,971 904 6.4
Operating Expense
Demand Creation Expense 3,213 3,278 65 2
Operating Overhead Expense 6,679 7,191 512 7.6
Total Selling and Administrative
Expense
9,892 10,469 577 5.8
Income from Continuing
Operations
Income before Interest and Tax 4,175 4,502 327 7.8
Interest Expense 28 19 -9 -32
Other (Income) Expense (58) (140) (82) 141.37
Income before Income Taxes 4,205 4,623 418 9.9
Income Tax Expense 932 863 -69 -7.4
Net Income 3,273 3,760 487 14.8
Horizontal Analysis – Balance Sheet Nike
ASSETS 2015 2016 Change % Change
Current Assets
Cash and Equivalents 3,852 3,138 -714 -1.8
Short Term Investments 2,072 2,319 247 11.9
Accounts Receivables 3,358 3,241 -117 -3.4
Inventories 4,337 4,838 501 11.5
Prepaid Expenses and Other Current
Assets
1,968 1,489 -479 -24.3
Total Current Assets 15,587 15,025 -562 -3.6
Property, Plant, and Equipment 3,011 3,520 509 16.9
Identifiable Intangible Assets 281 281 0 0
Goodwill 131 131 0 0
Deferred income taxes and other
assets
2,587 2,439 -148 -5.7
TOTAL ASSETS 21,597 21,396 -201 -0.93
Liabilities and Shareholders’
Equity
Current Liabilities
Current position of Long Term Debt 107 44 -63 -58.8
Notes Payable 74 1 -73 -98.6
Accounts Payable 2,131 2,191 60 2.8
Accrued Liabilities 3,949 3,037 -912 -23.1
Income Taxes Payable 71 85 14 19.7
Total Current Liabilities 6,332 5,358 -974 -15.4
Long-Term Debt 1,079 2,010 931 86.2
Deferred Income taxes and Other
Liabilities
1,479 1,770 291 19.6
Commitments and Contingencies
Redeemable preferred stock
STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY
Common stock at Stated value: 3 3 0 0
Capital in excess stated value 6,773 7,786 1,013 14.9
Horizontal Analysis – Income Statement Adidas ($ in Millions)
Revenue 2015 2016 Change %
Change
Net Sales 16,915 19,291 2,376 14
Cost of Sales 8,748 9,912 1,164 13.3
Gross Profit 8,168 9,379 1,211 14.8
Royalty and Commission Income 119 109 -10 -8
Other Operating Income 96 266 170 175.2
Other Operating Expenses 7,289 8,263 974 13.4
Goodwill Impairment Losses 34 – -34 -100
Operating Profit 1,059 1,491 432 40.7
Financial Income 46 28 -18 -40.1
Financial Expenses 67 74 7 11.3
Income before Taxes 1,039 1,444 405 39
Income Taxes 353 426 73 20.6
Net Income from Continuing
Operations
686 1,019 333 48.5
Gains/(Losses) from Discontinued
Operations
(46) 1 n.a. n.a.
Net Income 640 1,020 380 59.3
Accumulated other comprehensive
income
1,246 318 -928 -74.5
Retained Earnings 4,685 4,151 -534 -11.4
Total Shareholders’ Equity 12,707 12,258 -449 -3.5
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’
EQUITY
21,597 21,396 -201 -0.93
Horizontal Analysis – Balance Sheet Adidas ($ in Millions)
Assets 2015 2016 Change %
Change
Cash and Equivalents 1,365 1,510 10.6
Short-Term Assets 5 5 2.5
Accounts Receivables 2,049 2,200 7.4
Other Current Financial Assets 367 729 98.7
Inventories 3,113 3,763 20.9
Income tax Receivables 97 98 1.1
Other Current Assets 489 580 18.5
Assets classified as held for sale 12 – -100
Total Current Assets 7,497 8,886 18.5
Property, Plant, and Equipment 1,638 1,915 16.9
Goodwill 1,392 1,412 1.4
Trademarks 1,628 1,680 3.2
Other Intangible Assets 188 167 -11.5
Long-Term Financial Assets 140 194 38.3
Other Non-Current Financial Assets 99 96 -2.6
Deferred Tax Assets 637 732 14.9
Other Non-Current Assets 124 94 -23.9
Total Non-Current Assets 5,846 6,290 7.6
Total Assets 13,343 15,176 13.7
Liabilities and Equity
Short-Term Borrowings 366 636 73.7
Accounts Payable 2,024 2,496 23.3
Other Current Financial Liabilities 143 201 40.7
Income Taxes 359 402 12.1
Other Current Provisions 456 573 25.6
Current Accrued Liabilities 1,684 2,023 20.1
Other Current Liabilities 331 434 31.1
Liabilities Classified as Held for Sale 0 – -100
Total Current Liabilities 5,364 6,765 26.1
Long-Term Borrowings 1,463 982 -32.9
Other Non-Current Financial
Liabilities
18 22 23.6
Pensions and Similar Obligations 273 355 30.4
Deferred Tax Liabilities 368 387 5.2
Other Non-Current Provisions 50 44 -11.1
Non-Current Accrued Liabilities 120 120 -0.2
Other Non-Current Liabilities 40 46 14.2
Total Non-Current Liabilities 2,332 1,957 -16.1
Share Capital 200 201 0.6
Reserves 592 749 26.5
Retained Earnings 4,874 5,521 13.3
Shareholders’ Equity 5,666 6,472 14.2
Non- Controlling Interests (18) (17) 4
Total Equity 5,648 6,455 14.3
Total Liabilities and Equity 13,343 15,176 13.7
Nike had an increase of 14.8% net income whereas Adidas had an increase of 59.3%
from the year 2015 to 2016. Nike’s sales increase is because of Rio Olympics (Kell,
Rio Olympics Gives Nike a Sales Boost, 2016), on the other hand, one of the reason
Adidas’s increase was because of collaborations with some of the major sports clubs
in the world, for instance, Manchester United made deal with Adidas as their main
sponsor which replaced Nike (Wilson, 2014). Net income of Adidas was exponentially
higher (59.3%) compared to Nike (14.8%). Considering the short-term and long-term
liabilities, Nike could pay almost half their debts whereas for Adidas short-term debt
increased by 73.3%. This might be for expansion into different markets or investments
to grow, they must be careful in what to invest, despite clearing 33% of their long-term
debts, they still have a large amount to clear. The shareholders’ equity of Nike has
fallen as we have seen earlier in the vertical analysis of slow decline, on the other
hand, Adidas’s shareholder equity has increased, we think this is because of their
rapid growth it may be because of their investments into sports clubs’ collaborations
with Music stars, etc.
CONCLUSION
Nike is a giant in the market but in the past few years its losing investors whereas
Adidas is growing at an exponentially rate in the past 2 years. We can say that Adidas
has increased because of its sales through marketing strategy i.e. sponsorships,
endorsements, etc., which lead to faster sales. On the other side, Adidas has a lot of
debt which should be cleared quickly to increase their cash flows to strengthen their
liquidity and solvency. Nike though a giant is losing its market share, they should
market innovative products to maintain their market share. We think depending on the
investors they can invest in either of the companies, if the investors want stability they
can invest in Nike as they have a steady growth, on the other hand who wants a high
return on investment it is viable to invest in Adidas because of its faster growth rate.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Adidas. (2016). Adidas Annual Report 2016.
Delaney, P., & Whittington, O. (2009). Financial Accounting and Reporting. USA: John Wiley & Sons.
Hussain, A. (1996). A textbook of Business Finance. Kenya: East African Educational Publishers Ltd.
Kell, J. (2016, September 28). Rio Olympics Gives Nike a Sales Boost. Retrieved from Fortune:
http://fortune.com/2016/09/27/nike-olympics-sales-boost/
Kell, J. (2016, August 05). Why Adidas Is Outperforming Nike, Under Armour. Retrieved from Fortune
Retail: http://fortune.com/2016/08/04/adidas-outperforming-nike-ua/
Lexicon. (2017). Definition of Return on Equity ROE. Retrieved from Financial Times:
http://lexicon.ft.com/Term?term=return-on-equity–roe
Mande, V., Park, Y., & Son, M. (2011). Equity or Debt Financing: Does Good Corporate Governance
Matter? . Corporate Governance An International Review, 195-211.
Nasdaq. (2017). Return on Assets. Retrieved from Nasdaq:
http://www.nasdaq.com/investing/glossary/r/return-on-assets
Nike. (2016). NIKE, INC. REPORTS FISCAL 2016 FOURTH QUARTER. Nike.
Stickney, C., Weil, R., Schipper, K., & & Francis, J. (2009). Financial Accounting: An INtroduction to
Concepts, Methods, and Uses. Australia: Cengage Learning.
Tracy, J. (2011). Accounting for Dummies. USA: John Wiley & Sons.
Wilson, B. (2014, July 14). Manchester Unioted And Adidas in 750m deeal over 10 years. Retrieved
from BBC News: http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28282444
The post LETTER OF ENGAGEMENT NIKE & ADIDAS appeared first on My Assignment Online.