Definitions
Charles Sturt University
Two Compartment Model
•(lean mass) such as muscle, connective tissue, organs, brain/CNS tissue, blood and bodily fluids, including water
•(fat mass) including essential, and stored fat.
•total body mass, expressed relative to body volume
Charles Sturt University
Models of Body Composition
Charles Sturt University
•Although the two-compartment model is well accepted and used extensively in research and clinical settings, it is not without problems.
•The technique relies on two main assumptions:
(1) the density of fat tissue is 0.9007 g·cm3, while the density of fat-free tissue is 1.100 g·cm3, which remains consistent at different sites within the same individual and between different individuals.
(2) each tissue type represents a constant proportion of the fat-free mass. It is assumed that fat-free mass is composed of:
-protein (20.5%)
-bone mineral (7.1%)
-water (72.4%)
Fat-Free Mass
Charles Sturt University
Normative-Descriptive Methods
Charles Sturt University
•Involvesthemeasurementoftheindividualsheightandweight
•Basedonprinciplethataperson’sweightshouldbeproportionaltotheirheight
•Height/weightstandardswerefirstdevelopedbyMetropolitanLifeInsuranceCompany(USA)–1912(observationof5millionpolicyholdersforupto20yrs)basedupontheheightsandweightsassociatedwiththelowestrateofmortality.
•1983newtablespublishedfromnewstudywhichincludedframesize&pre-existingdiseaseexcluded
•Problems:notpopulationspecific;noconsiderationforsmokers;muscularindividualsmisclassified
Height/Weight Standards
Charles Sturt University
Limitation -body weight does not provide information about the body composition -does not identify the source of the excess weight.
I am the perfect
weight if I were
13 feet tall.
Charles Sturt University
*
*
Muscular individuals may be misclassified
Charles Sturt University
Body Mass Index (BMI)
•The central distribution of body fat significantly increases the risk of a range of diseases eg.Type 2 Diabetes.
•BMI measure was developed to classify obesity-related disease risk within populations; therefore there is a significant limitation when interpreting individual results.
•Individual feedback should only be provided in combination with other measures
Charles Sturt University
Body Mass Index (BMI)
•Based on the principle of a desired ratio between height and weight
[Wt. (kg) / Ht.2(m)]
•Attempt to adjust weight for height and obtain a height free measure of obesity
•A number of indices have been developed
-most widely used & correlates well with body fat by hydrostatic weighing (r = 0.7)
•Simple, non-invasive and low cost
eg.BMI = 70 kg = 23.4 kg.m-2
(1.73)2m
This places the individual in healthy weight range BUT
Charles Sturt University
BMI Classification
< 18.5Underweight
18.5-24.9Normal weight
25.0-29.9Overweight
30.0-34.9Obesity
Values do not apply to athletes and body builders, pregnant and nursing women, the frail or elderly, or people under 18 (children). Why?
•does not differentiate fat and muscle
•Index was designed for population study not to compare individuals
Charles Sturt University
BMI Limitations
•Fat around heart and liver which is associated with diabetes…this is not picked up with BMI estimates
•Evidence suggests association between BMI and fat distribution differs across ethnic groups
•BMI age percentage charts should be used
•Large amount of muscle mass will influence results
•Designed for population studies not the individual
Charles Sturt University
Girths -Waist and Hip Circumferences
•Waist and hip circumferences can be used as a measure of body fat distribution .
•Higher values of waist relative to hip circumference indicate greater adiposity in the abdominal region
•Lower values indicate greater adiposity in the hip/gluteal region
Charles Sturt University
Data Analysis of Girth Measures
•Perform the waist and gluteal circumferences for two trials. If there is < 1.5% difference between the two measures, record the mean of the two measures. If >1.5% difference, perform a third measure and record the median of 3 values.
•Calculating reliability = largest measure X 100-100
smallest measure
= 71 X 100 -100 = 0.7%
70.5
ie. acceptable range (< 1.5%) so no need for 3rdmeasure
•Using table 43. (p. 68) lower end of “Low” risk category for obesity related diseases
Charles Sturt University
•Calculate Hip to Waist ratio (WHR) using the mean of waist and hip circumferences in the equation: WHR = Waist (cm)/ Hip (cm)
•Waist to height ratio or central obesity index (ICO) is also used.
•An ICO of 0.5 or more indicates increased health risk, independent of ethnicity, gender and possibly age.
•However multiple assessments of body composition egBMI, waist circumference, WHR, skinfoldsare encouraged to minimise the limitations of each test
Calculate Hip to Waist ratio (WHR)
Charles Sturt University
Measurement of Body Fat
1.Hydrostatic weighing
2.Skin folds
3.Bio-electrical impedance
4.Dual x-ray absorptiometry
5.MRI
6.CT scans
7.Bio-Pod chamber
Charles Sturt University
Hydrostatic Weighing or (Hydro) densitometry
•Whole body density is calculated from body volume
Density =
So how does this give us a body composition measure?
Mass
Volume
Charles Sturt University
2.Bio-Electrical Impedance Analysis (BIA)
•Has become increasingly popular as a tool for assessing body composition due to ease of use, portability and cost effectiveness
•Involves the resistance (impedance) of an electrical current transmitted through the body
•The bio-electrical properties of hydrous and anhydrous tissue are studied.
•It is a safe and non invasive method based on differing electrical conductivity of FM and FFM
**FFM contains nearly all the water and electrolytes of the body, and is thus, almost, totally responsible for the conductance of electrical current, whereas impedance is by anhydrous tissue
Charles Sturt University
Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DEXA)
•Involves the scanning of the body by an x-ray source, which compartmentalises the body by tissue densities (fat, lean, bone).
•Based on the principle that the relative density of the body tissues will selectively attenuate the x-ray beam. This method does not require assumptions about the biological constancy of the fat and fat-free components as does hydrostatic weighing.
Charles Sturt University
DEXA
•Allows simultaneous measurement of bone mineral, fat and non-bone tissue
•Low radiation dose
•Rapid (approx30 mins)
•More work on validation and population specific equations
•High cost -research method
Charles Sturt University
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
•Cross-sectional slice
•High quality image and can accurately quantify both subcutaneous and visceral fat
•Relatively rapid (approx30 mins)
•No metal pins or plates as magnet may alter positioning
•Expensive
Charles Sturt University
ComputerisedTomography (CT Scanning)
•Cross sectional measurement
•Can calculate lean and fat area of slice
•Good for measuring visceral fat
•High radiation dose problem with repeated measures
•Unable to be used for general screening
Charles Sturt University
BOD POD –Alternate to UWW
•Works on the gas law -expansion of Boyles Law
•Changes in pressure can be used to calculate volume and then density
•Error range is 1-2% similar to UWW
•Takes 5 minutes
•Can accommodate persons up to 500 kg
•Has been used on NFL & NBA teams
Charles Sturt University
Validity of Measures
1.Cadaver dissection –total body fat; only truly valid measures of body fat!
2.Quantity other than body fat is measured (body density through DEXA scans) and a quantitative relationship determined, to give us an estimation of body fat.
3.Hydrostatic weighing (UWW), once considered ‘gold standard’ but indirect
4.Skin-folds –doubly indirect
Charles Sturt University
The measurement of body composition has become a popular and standard practice for many physicians, athletic trainers, and health professionals.
Evidence supports the notion that having excess body fat is associated with:
•musculoskeletal injury
•non-adherence to exercise training
•reduced athletic performance
•many health problems such as:
-hypertension
-diabetes mellitus
-depression
-hyperlipidemia
-coronary heart disease
-osteoarthritis
Why Measure?
Charles Sturt University
Summary
•No perfect method
•Understand limitations of each method
•Choose method(s) appropriate for the patient/subject and design of test
The post Measurement of Body Composition appeared first on My Assignment Online.