General feedback for task 1
Methodology Comparison
The first part of task 1 is meant to encourage you to undertake research on the different penetration testing methodologies such as PTES and OSSTMM. This research will help you to identify all of the different activities that form part of a penetration test. Your research findings will inform the development of your SOP.
We really wanted you to compare pen testing standards (a methodology may be a subset of a standard). Some of you discussed black/white/grey box methodology. Some of you discussed OWASP, NIST and others as per the example bellow. We appreciate the ambiguity and, strictly speaking, you are correct in some regard. However, it’s not what we’re after. We are looking for a comparison.
Your comparison should identify the best methodology to use as a benchmark for your SOP. Make use of a table when comparing pen testing methodologies. This not only reduces word count but forces you to compare standards. Additionally, when comparing, you need something to compares against. You require comparison criteria. This criteria must be well justified and allow for the identification of a benchmark methodology as discussed above.
The examples below will help you to understand what we are looking for.
Example 1
Broad description of standards, not really any comparison. Quite superficial. They are also unreferenced (more on that below). Likely to only score a passing mark if had appropriate referencing.
Example 2
Better – better comparison of goal and scope, plus a short description. Still not exactly clear on comparison criteria; but it’s a merit worthy table (with appropriate references)
Ethical and legal discussion
The second part of task 1 is the ethical discussion. This is another research-based element that is meant to also inform the development of the SOP. The research findings should allow you to identify activities and decisions you will have to include in your SOP. In general, there was little decent discussion on legal issues or not appropriate discussion at all. Take this as an opportunity to talk about the Computer Misuse Act 1990, particularly “unauthorised access” which underpins much of that law. What about data protection/GDPR? Some laws discussed in submissions were not specific to UK/Europe, either. Cyber security operations like pentesting know no boundaries. It’s fine to talk about American law, for example, but balance it out with laws closer to home (i.e. UK). We are in the UK and you are studying in a UK HEI.
- Statute law: that is, laws created by parliament.
- Case laws/precedents: law created by judges after a case. ‘Setting a precedent’.
- Civil law: non-criminal law. For example, contracts between parties or a parking ticket.
Good example. Clearly outlines appropriate, relevant statues in relation to the UK (perhaps even a link the law itself would be good as a reference)
Weak example. According to what laws exactly. This is a superficial statement.
Please note that you need to be specific about these legal and ethical issues in regard to being a penetration tester. Put yourselves in the shoes of a pen tester. What legal and ethical issues may you face? Simply listing laws is not directly answering the question presented by the assessment.
Standard Operating Procedure
The SOP is the third part of task 1. A very quick search on Google gives the following definition:
“A standard operating procedure (SOP) is a set of step-by-step instructions to help workers carry out complex routine operations. SOPs aim to achieve efficiency, quality output and uniformity of performance, while reducing miscommunication and failure to comply with regulations and business operations”
There is not a single correct SOP. Your SOP will be unique to you, stating how you will undertake the penetration test of a single Linux server that is not connected to the internet (as per the case study discussed in Unit 3). The identified activities should be grouped in Processes and processes should be grouped in phases. Every activity must be specified by stating: inputs, function, tool, output, description.
The following is an extract from an SOP. Dmitry is an OSINT tool but it is in its own unnamed process. Make sure you understand the difference between phase, process and activity.
Phase1: intelligence gathering
Process 1.1: Open source search
Activity: 1.1.1
Input: Target the URL (uniform resource locator)
Tool: wget
Expected Output: Find Information that is close to the target
Description: Match Targets web page and review source code
Process 1.2
Activity: 1.2.1
Input: Target the IP address
Tool: DMitry
Expected Output: To find more information on the target
Description: find possible email addresses, subdomains etc.
The following is an extract from an SOP. Where is Scanning and Enumeration as Processes? Good breakdown of activities. Of course, what is illustrated underneath is not the full SOP developed by the student.
Phase 1: Target Profiling /Information Gathering
Process 1.1: Foot printing
1.1.1: Activity: See if IP Address is alive
Input:
Tool/s:
Expected Result:
Instruction to user:
1.1.2: Network reconnaissance
1.1.3: DNS Interrogation
Phase 2: Vulnerability Identification
Process 2.1: Identify target vulnerabilities
The following is an extract from an SOP
Process 1.1 Information Gathering
Activity 1.1.1 Identify hostile actors or groups
Tools: Net reconnaissance (Social media, competitors)
Expected output: Evidence of intent/motivation
Activity 1.1.2 Victim Investigation
Tools: TheHarvester, Net reconnaissance (Social media, Employee behavior, Email addresses), Inspect Devices
Expected output: Gather employee activity
Activity 1.1.3 Infrastructure investigation
Tools: public records (land owner, business Partners)
Expected Output: Locate properties, identify Business partners, owners, tax records.
Activity 1.1.4 Capabilities
Tools: Net Recon
Expected output: Identify Malware that is potentially harmful to target system
Process 1.2 Target Profiling
Activity 1.2.1 Current Security test
Tools: Automated scanner, Public record
Expect output: Identify current security protocols and response times
Activity 1.2.2 What can outsider see?
Tools: Net Recon, Job openings
Expected output: Discover insider details from outside knowledge
Activities specified above are outside the scope of the task. The above is the result of a superficial critique.
As discussed during the lectures, the SOP will state what you are going to do during a penetration test. It does not state how you are going to do the penetration test. For stating how you will do a penetration test you need to develop a decision-making tree. A quick search in Google gives the following definition:
“A decision tree is a decision support tool that uses a tree-like model of decisions and their possible consequences”.
The above is an extract of a decision tree. What is Intelligence Gathering (the box)? Is it a decision? Is it an activity defined in the SOP? If not, then it has no place in the Tree.
What is wrong with the following Tree?
It lists phases? It should be listing activities and decisions. Apropos, very good attempt.
General Observations
Finally, some general observation of writing style and formatting. You must be able to convey your thoughts using appropriate academic English. We have identified poor use of English/grammar in too many instances.
Regarding referencing, “I don’t know how to reference” is not acceptable and is a poor excuse. There are ample resources online and on the UH website. You can’t take swathes of text and not quote or attribute it. That is plagiarism. Taken something? Quote and reference. If you make a claim, then you must evidence. At best, your work is marked as superficial and unlikely to obtain a passing grade. At worst, you have a charge of academic misconduct to face.
Please make use of the following good example:
Bad (or non-existent) use of referencing – very common, don’t take it personally
Please note that simply having a reference list at the end is not enough. Most reports had a reference list at the end of the report, though few actually placed the reference in the text so as to associate that reference with the statement they were making (or diagram / plot they were using). One report even referenced Wikipedia articles, with an “anon” author… Wikipedia is not considered a good quality source. Good quality sources are peer-reviewed sources like journal papers, conference papers and books.
The post Methodology Comparison appeared first on My Assignment Online.