Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
MIS741 – Ethics of Digital Transformation
Trimester 1, 2020
Assessment 1 (individual): Part A Report (Research)
40%, Part B Video Recording 10%
| DUE DATE AND TIME: | Week 9, Monday 11 May 2020, 11:59PM (Deakin policy means that submissions 12:00 AM onwards are 1 day late) 50% (Part A = 40%, Part B = 10%) |
| PERCENTAGE OF FINAL GRADE: |
Learning Outcome Details
| Unit Learning Outcome (ULO) | Graduate Learning Outcome (GLO) |
| ULO 1: Justify resolutions to ethical dilemmas faced by IS professionals resulting from competing personal, organisational and client interests using ethical theories and frameworks. |
GLO1: Discipline‐specific knowledge and capabilities GLO8: Global Citizenship |
| ULO 2: Present convincing resolutions to ethical dilemmas in written and oral form. |
GLO2: Communication |
| ULO3: Apply digital technologies effectively to support researching, analysing and presenting complex information relating to information systems contexts. |
GLO1: Discipline‐specific knowledge and capabilities GLO3: Digital literacy |
Assessment Feedback
Students who submit their work by the due date will receive their marks and feedback on
CloudDeakin by Friday 29 May 2020, 5:30PM. Students who use the 1‐5 day late penalty period
(see Notes section) will receive their marks and feedback 1‐5 days later (respectively).
Extensions
No extensions will be considered unless a written request is submitted to and approved by the Unit
Chair before the due date and time. Extensions will only be considered if a draft assignment is
Page 2 of 7
Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
attached with your request for an extension, which shows progress has been made, and
documentary evidence for the extension. Applications after this date will not be accepted, and
submissions after the due date/time without an approved extension will be considered late.
Extensions are only granted in extreme circumstances, such as ongoing health, personal hardship or
work‐related problems. Temporary illnesses, normal work pressures, multiple assignments due at
the same time, failure to keep backups, technology failure, etc are not reasons for an extension.
Description / Requirements
This is an individual assignment where you will synthesise research sources on the following digital
transformation topic, and then produce a Research Report using the Ethical Decision‐Making
Framework introduced in topic 2 and an associated Video Recording:
Synthesis the extent research evidence shows that consumers/citizens do or do not know
the level of their privacy loss/risks when using social media, and what this implies could
be future privacy issues for consumers/citizens if current privacy levels continue.
Research the topic
The report is not about your personal moral views about the digital transformation topic. Instead,
research the topic by finding and synthesising credible academic resources sources (e.g. journal
articles, PhD theses, conference papers, credible research studies) and industry sources (e.g.
industry research reports from companies like Gartner Group, reports from relevant professional
bodies, etc). Quality and credible resource sources are those reporting empirical research (e.g.
experiments, surveys, case studies) about the topic (not opinions of the authors), or reporting on
the evidence about the topic from the perspective of a variety of stakeholder types.
The research you undertake should enable you to determine the answers to all the questions
(directly or indirectly) in the Ethical Decision‐Making Framework about how various stakeholders in
the topic 2 framework may be affected by the digital transformation topic. The report should not
consider short‐term issues (e.g. immediate profits), but rather the medium to long‐term (e.g. 10‐50
year) implications of the digital transformation on all stakeholders. Research sources can therefore
include evidence of past digital transformation issues, and used to justify how stakeholders might
be affected in future if the topic is not addressed by digital transformation professionals. Research
sources should be quality, which means “older” research is acceptable when combined with recent
research sources, but not low quality research sources. Evidence of GLO8 Global Citizenship will
include the quality of the research, and how well the framework is used, to justify the topic.
You must ensure that your research and analysis of the topic has balanced/even coverage of the
perspective of all stakeholder types in the topic 2 framework. A focus on organisation stakeholders
(e.g. shareholders, staff, immediate clients) is not balanced. Similarly, balanced research and
analysis will include equal coverage of the risks and benefits (not just benefits) relating to the topic
for each stakeholder type from the topic 2 framework. As required by the ACS Code of Professional
Conduct, the most important stakeholder group is “the public”, not organisation stakeholders, and
consideration of all the risks for the public. For this reason, a report with an unbalanced focus on
organisational stakeholders and benefits will not receive a good result in this assignment, because it
does not demonstrate good understanding of GLO8 Global Citizenship. A balanced analysis and
Page 3 of 7
Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
report on multiple stakeholder types, and benefits versus risks, will also result in a more convincing
justification (GLO2 Communication) of how the ethics of digital transformation can be improved.
GLO3 Digital Literacy will be assessed on how well you have used digital literacy skills to research
and analysis the topic. Evidence of digital literacy with regards to research will be shown by
submitting full‐text copies of your research sources in PDF format, so ensure all sources are
downloaded. This means there must be a PDF file for each reference in the reference list of the
report. You are not permitted to use books, electronic books (due to copyright restrictions), videos,
audio, etc for your resource sources. Only articles or reports which can be submitted as a PDF file.
The Deakin Library has full‐text versions of journal articles and conference papers, and these are
almost always available in PDF format. Download the PDF version and read the article/paper in that
form. For industry reports, these are typically provided in PDF format as well. If an industry report is
only available as a webpage, then use the “print‐to‐PDF” option in your web browser.
See the Submission instructions section for details on how to name each research source’s PDF file.
If you use a software product like Endnote to store the details about each research source, and to
create your citations and reference list (see below), then submit this with your report as evidence
of the GLO Digital Literacy capabilities. Using such software is optional, but highly recommended.
Create a research synthesis matrix for the topic
You will analyse and synthesise the research sources into a research synthesis matrix (e.g. a Word
or Excel document), which can have a column for each stakeholder type. You will know when you
have identified a good research source, if it considers multiple stakeholder types (or has multiple
columns in the matrix). Resource sources which consider organisation stakeholders only, and also
benefits relating to the topic only, should be avoided/minimised for your research synthesis.
The following shows an example extract of a research synthesis matrix with a single column (or
theme) for the research topic: What impact does the differences in definitions in research articles
about small and medium enterprises (SMEs) have for understanding the best way to help SMEs
adopt digital transformation tools successfully? This topic is not relevant to this assignment.
| Source number: Author, year, ‘title’ | SME definition theme – revenue |
| Source 1: Lee, S, Park, SB & Lim, GG 2013 ‘Using balanced scorecards for the evaluation of “Software‐as‐a‐service”’ |
Does not state any maximum revenue to be an SME |
| Source 2: Zhang, M, Sarker, S & Sarker, S 2013 ‘Drivers and export performance impacts of IT capability in ‘born‐global’ firms: a cross‐ national study’ |
Does not state any maximum revenue to be an SME |
| Source 3: Alonso‐Mendo, F, Fitzgerald, G & Frias‐Martinez, E 2009 ‘Understanding web site redesigns in small‐ and medium‐sized enterprises (SMEs): a U.K.‐based study on the applicability of e‐commerce Stage Models’ |
Organisations with revenue < 50 million. Does not distinguish SMEs on revenue |
| Source 4: Bidan, M, Rowe, F & Truex, D 2012 ‘An empirical study of IS architectures in French SMEs: integration approaches’ |
Does not state any maximum revenue to be an SME |
| Source 5: Levenburg, NM & Klein, HA 2006 ‘Delivering customer services online: identifying best practices of medium‐sized enterprises’ |
Does not state any maximum revenue to be an SME |
| Source 6: Bergeron, F, Raymond, L & Rivard, S 2004 ‘Ideal patterns of strategic alignment and business performance’ |
Organisations with sales < 50 million. Does not distinguish SMEs on sales. |
| Sources 7‐20 |
Page 4 of 7
Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
You will use the matrix document to write a completely separate report document (i.e. Word file).
The following is an example paragraph written about the theme/column by finding similarities and
differences among the research sources, which would be written in the report document.
It is unclear from existing research whether differences in revenue of SMEs has an impact on
their ability to adopt IS. This is because most studies (Bidan et al. 2012; Lee et al. 2013;
Levenburg & Klein 2006; Zhang et al. 2013) did not state any maximum revenue to be an SME, or
differentiate SME sizes on the basis of revenue. Only two studies, by contrast, stated that
organisations must have less than 50 million Euros in revenue (Alonso‐Mendo et al. 2009, p268)
or Canadian dollars in sales (Bergeron et al. 2004, p1007) to be considered an SME, but neither
article differentiates SMEs on the basis of revenue or sales. The fact that most studies did not
state the maximum revenue to be an SME, or differentiate SMEs based on revenue, may be due
to limitations of the definition of SMEs used or cited in the studies. It was therefore not possible
to identify the extent to which revenue affects if/how SMEs adopt IS, or what revenue‐related
support that different types of SMEs may need.
GLO3 Digital Literacy will be assessed on how well you evidence that you have used digital literacy
skills to research and analysis the topic. This will involve using a digital tool to create the research
synthesis matrix, which could be a spreadsheet, Word document, etc. You will be assessed on how
well you have used the digital tool to analyse the research sources.
The matrix will be submitted as a separate file, and the report will be a different file. You do not put
the matrix (or table) in the report document. The matrix is used to synthesise the similarities and
differences among the research sources. The outcome of the synthesis, in paragraph form, will go
in the report. The report and matrix are different, and therefore will be submitted as separate files.
What to include in the Research Report?
You will write an individual Research Report, where the audience is the academic marker, as follows
(after researching the topic and creating the research synthesis matrix):
A cover page with the assignment title (“Assessment 1 – Research Report”), unit code and
name, your name and student ID, and the word count. This cover page is not included in the
word count.
A maximum of 2,500 words for the report body, using the Ethical Decision‐Making
Framework introduced in topic 2, to analyse the topic stated above.
o The report will have a very short introduction (approximately 50 words), multiple
sections/subsections, and very short conclusion (approximately 50 words). Note that
in‐text citations (see details below) are included in the word count.
A reference list including at least twenty (20) high quality research sources cited in the
report body in the Harvard format style using the “(Author, Year)” approach to in‐text
citation. This reference list is not included in the word count.
Word limit
See the rubric for word limit penalties. The word count is calculated by selecting the text of
assignment (see above), and using MS Word’s word count feature and unchecking the “Include
textboxes, footnotes and endnotes”.
Page 5 of 7
Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
In separate files, which are not included in the word count, you will submit (see the Submission
instructions section below):
Your research synthesis matrix (not included in the word count).
Complete, full text PDF copy of every research source in the reference list.
You must cite the minimum research sources (see the ‘Research work…’ section) in the body of the
report using “(Author, Year)” or “Author (Year)” in‐text citations following the Harvard format:
http://www.deakin.edu.au/students/studying/study‐support/referencing/harvard
Further requirements for the report are as follows:
The report cannot include any quotes, images/figures, summarises or paraphrasing from
any other sources (even if the source is cited). The entire report must be your own original
work created as a result of research synthesis.
You cannot scan tables (or images with text) and insert this in your report. All text in the
body of the report, even if it is scanned, will be added to your word count. Please see rubric
for details of the penalties which apply to exceeding the word count for this report.
What to include in the Video Recording?
You will create an individual Video Recording, no more than 5 minutes, to convince the marker
about what changes social media organisation should make, and why, to resolve/improve the
ethical problems discussed in the report. The Video Recording will summarise the medium‐to‐long‐
term consequences if social media organisations do not implement the changes (GLO8 Global
Citizenship). The changes can include, for instance, modifying their revenue model, use of digital
transformation technologies (e.g. AI, machine learning, business analytics), or any other changes.
The video will be a slideshow of text and graphics and voice‐over explaining each slide. The graphics
can be graphs or images (not videos). GLO2 Communication will be assessed on how convincing
your argument is, and how well you use your voice (e.g. tone, modulation, speed). You are not
required to include your body or face in the video, but you are free to do so if you feel it will
improve GLO2 Communication.
You must demonstrate your ability to use digital tools effectively to create the Video Recording to
demonstrate GLO3 Digital Literacy. Only basic digital tools are needed. For example, you can add
text and graphics to a slideshow format using Powerpoint (or equivalent). You can record the
slideshow and your voice‐over using Kaltura Capture.
Details on downloading and installing Kaltura Capture can be found at the following webpage under
the “Contribute content via webcam” tab. Even though the tab title says only “via webcam”, you
can also record screens and voice‐over and webcam using Kaltura.
https://www.deakin.edu.au/students/help/about‐clouddeakin/help‐guides/video‐and‐audio/deakinair
There is a video on how to install and use it (https://video.deakin.edu.au/media/t/1_kf47957p),
including a brief example of optional in‐built tools for annotating the screen during recording.
Page 6 of 7
Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
Submission Instructions
The following sections explain what to submit and how. Deakin policy means that assignments even
1 minute late are considered to be 1 day late. You must therefore allow plenty of time (e.g. 4‐5
hours) to upload all the files required.
Submission of the Research Report
The final submission for the Research Report must be one (1) single file, named
surname_MIS741_T1_year_report (e.g. Liang_MIS741_T1_2020_report), including:
A cover page with the assignment title (“Assessment 1 – Research report”), unit code and
name, your name and student ID, and the word count.
The Research Report
Submission of the research synthesis matrix
The submission of your research synthesis matrix will be a separate file, named:
surname_MIS741_T1_year_matrix (e.g. Liang_MIS741_T1_2020_matrix)
If you used Endnote (or similar software) to manage your library of research sources for the
assignment, submit this as a separate file also, named:
surname_MIS741_T1_year_library (e.g. Liang_MIS741_T1_2020_library)
Submission of the Video Recording
Submit the Video Recording via DeakinAir by following the instructions under the “Contribute
content” tab at the following webpage. Take particular note of the upload size limit for the video
file, and also use the “Link to Media Page” option for step 10 to submit your video:
https://www.deakin.edu.au/students/help/about‐clouddeakin/help‐guides/video‐and‐audio/deakinair
Start the submission process at least four or five (4‐5) hours before the due time so you upload the
video to CloudDeakin on time. Deakin policy means that assignments even 1 minute late are
considered to be 1 day late.
Submission of the full‐text research sources
Name each PDF file, for each research source, as “author(s) (year) source type” (source types
include “journal article”, “conference paper”, “industry report”, “web page”). For e.g.:
Smith (2018) journal article
Gartner Group (2019) industry report
Once you have named all the PDF files for every research source used, use 7‐Zip (or any other Zip
tool) to create a .zip file containing all the PDF files in the one .zip file. Download 7‐Zip from:
http://software.deakin.edu.au/2018/05/24/7‐zip/
Page 7 of 7
Deakin’s Bachelor of Commerce and MBA are internationally EPAS accredited.
Deakin Business School is accredited by AACSB and EQUIS.
The submission of your .zip file will be a separate file, named:
surname_MIS741_T1_year_zipPDFs (e.g. Liang_MIS741_T1_2020_zipPDFs)
Start the submission process at least four or five (4‐5) hours before the due time so you upload the
research sources to CloudDeakin on time. Deakin policy means that assignments even 1 minute
late are considered to be 1 day late.
The submission folder
The submission folder under Assessments tab, then Assignments in CloudDeakin is available now.
You must keep a backup copy of every assignment you submit, until the marked assignment has
been returned to you. In the unlikely event that one of your assignments is misplaced, you will
need to submit your backup copy.
Any work you submit may be checked by electronic or other means for the purposes of detecting
collusion and/or plagiarism.
When you submit an assignment through your CloudDeakin unit site, you will receive an email to
your Deakin email address confirming that it has been submitted. You should check that you can
see your assignment in the Submissions view of the Assignment dropbox folder after upload, and
check for, and keep, the email receipt for the submission.
Notes
Penalties for late submission: The following marking penalties will apply if you submit an
assessment task after the due date without an approved extension: 5% will be deducted
from available marks for each day up to five days, and work that is submitted more than five
days after the due date will not be marked. You will receive 0% for the task. ‘Day’ means
working day for paper submissions and calendar day for electronic submissions. The Unit
Chair may refuse to accept a late submission where it is unreasonable or impracticable to
assess the task after the due date.
For more information about academic misconduct, special consideration, extensions, and
assessment feedback, please refer to the document Your rights and responsibilities as a
student in this Unit in the first folder next to the Unit Guide of the Resources area in the
CloudDeakin unit site.
Building evidence of your experiences, skills and knowledge (Portfolio) ‐ Building a
portfolio that evidences your skills, knowledge and experience will provide you with a
valuable tool to help you prepare for interviews and to showcase to potential employers.
There are a number of tools that you can use to build a portfolio. You are provided with
cloud space through OneDrive, or through the Portfolio tool in the Cloud Unit Site, but you
can use any storage repository system that you like. Remember that a Portfolio is YOUR
tool. You should be able to store your assessment work, reflections, achievements and
artefacts in YOUR Portfolio. Once you have completed this assessment piece, add it to your
personal Portfolio to use and showcase your learning later, when applying for jobs, or
further studies. Curate your work by adding meaningful tags to your artefacts that describe
what the artefact represents.
MIS741 – Ethics of Digital Transformation (Trimester 1, 2020)
Assessment 1 (Individual): Research Report and Video Recording (Rubric/Feedback)
| Criteria | N (0-29%) | N (30-49%) | P (50-59%) | C (60-69%) | D (70-79%) | HD (80-100%) |
| Ethical knowledge in report/video (ULO No. 1, GLO1/8) Out of 40 |
Little/no source synthesis on the topic, knowledge/use of ethical framework (report), about little/no stakeholder types and/or medium-long term risk.(0-11.9) |
Superficial synthesis of sources on the topic, knowledge/ use of ethical framework (report), about limited stakeholder types and/or medium-long term risk issues. (12-19.9) |
Some synthesis of sources on the topic (lacks depth, many major issues omitted), use/knowledge of ethical framework (report, many major errors), considering some relevant stakeholder types and medium-long term risks (quite biased, short-term and/or benefit focused). (20-23.9) |
Adequate synthesis of sources on the topic (some omitted major issues, shallowness), knowledge/ use of ethical framework (report, some major errors), considering most relevant stakeholder types and medium-long-term risks (a little biased, short-term and/or benefit focused). (24-27.9) |
Quite thorough synthesis of sources on the topic, and knowledge/use of ethical framework (report, but minor errors), focused quite well on medium-long term issues relevant to quite balanced coverage of all relevant stakeholder types and risks versus benefits. (28-31.9) |
Very thorough synthesis of sources on the topic, and knowledge/use of ethical framework (report), to analyse the medium-long term issues relevant to a balanced coverage of all relevant stakeholder types and risks/benefits. (32-40) |
| Digital literacy (ULO No. 1, GLO1/3) Out of 40 |
Poor use of digital tools to manage/synthesise few/no sources cited and/or in PDF form, and/or to present information in the video. (0-11.9) |
Limited use of digital tools to manage and synthesise fewer than minimum sources cited and in PDF form, and to show information in the video. (12-19.9) |
Evidences some use of digital tools to manage and synthesise the minimum sources cited and in PDF form, and to present information in the video. Many improvements needed in digital tool use and/or synthesis. (20- 23.9) |
Evidences enough digital tools use to manage and synthesise enough credible, relevant and quality sources (add more sources than minimum cited and in PDF form), and to present information in the video. Some improvement needed in digital tool use and/or synthesis. (24-27.9) |
Evidences good use of digital tools to manage and synthesise well the credible, relevant and quality sources (above minimum quantity cited and in PDF form), and to present information in the video. Minor improvements needed with using digital tools. (28-31.9) |
Evidences excellent use of digital tools to manage and synthesis comprehensively the credible, relevant and quality sources (way above minimum quantity cited and in PDF form), and to present information in the video. (32- 40) |
| Report/video commun ication (ULO No. 2, GLO2) Out of 30 |
Little/no clarity and/or argument using little/no skills in report writing and oral presentation (0-8.9) |
Not convincing/clear argument and/or minimal skills in report writing and oral presentation. (9-14.9) |
Attempted but mainly unclear/ unconvincing argument with some report writing (e.g. formal writing, spelling, reference format) and oral presentation skills (e.g. tone, modulation, speed). Various areas need attention. (15-17.9) |
Somewhat convincing/clear argument with mostly okay report writing (e.g. formal writing, spelling, reference format) and oral presentation skills (e.g. tone, modulation, speed). Some areas need attention. (18-20.9) |
Quite convincing, clear argument with good report writing (e.g. formal writing, spelling, reference format) and oral presentation skills (e.g. tone, modulation, speed) with minor issues. (21- 23.9) |
Very convincing, clear argument using excellent report writing (e.g. formal writing, spelling, reference format) and oral presentation skills (e.g. tone, modulation, speed). (24-30) |
| Report word count penalty |
150+ over text word limit, and/or 4+ scanned tables/ text or figures. – 20 marks |
101-150 over text word limit, and/or 2-3 scanned tables/ text or figures. -15 marks |
51-100 over text word limit, and/or 1 scanned text/table or figure. -10 marks |
11-50 over text word limit, but has no scanned text/tables or figures. -5 marks |
1-10 words over text word limit, but has no scanned text/tables or figures. -2 marks |
Under/exactly on text word limit, no scanned text/tables or figures. No penalty |
The post MIS741 – Ethics of Digital Transformation appeared first on My Assignment Online.