A development program evaluation entails a systematic inquiry to determine the value of the program, both in terms of process and content. It draws on a number of sources to determine whether the activity provided the required skills for selected employees to undertake performance feedback.
Evaluation requires feedback on the program from the participants at the end of the activity. Generally, learners are asked to complete a questionnaire or feedback form about both the process and content of the training. Feedback is sought on the suitability of the arrangements for the activity, including the environment and training methodologies for successful learning.
Evaluation also needs to incorporate collated information and analysis from individual assessments. If the attainment of a qualification was involved, then the numbers of subsequent successes or failures will provide a measure of success. For example:
• Are there too many instances of individuals unable to perform certain skills?
• Are there any individuals who are unable to perform an unacceptable number of skills?
When this information is analysed, it can provide a basis for taking remedial action.
Monitoring the Learning and Development Activities
Once you have established the goals, timeframes, and specifics of the learning and development plan, you must monitor the means used to deliver the learning. Whether this is through an external provider or in-house, it must be monitored to ensure compliance with the quality standards and agreed outcomes.
A simple way for this to be done is to consider a four-step process.
- Establish the Needs
First, establish what learning and development is required to support the individual to undertake their role to meet individual, team, area, and organisational objectives. While this is completed prior to learning and
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
development activity, it is the source of the goals for the activity against which progress will be measured. - Understand the Reaction
Learning and development activity satisfaction must be assessed and usually involves using feedback forms completed at the end of the activity. - What Was Learned
What did the individual gain from the learning and development activity in relation to their job two or three weeks after the activity? - Level 3 – Impact
What changes have been made by the individual that have made an impact on local processes, their performance, or that of their team or area? This is undertaken selectively and is completed after at least six months.
The information taken from this process reflects specifically on the learning. But there are other aspects to be considered also.
• Budget
It is important that the learning and development activity stayed on budget and did not ‘blow out’. If it did run over budget, an investigation and report should be completed explaining the reasons and making recommendations for future learning and development activities in this area.
• Timeframes
Was the training completed as agreed and within the allocated timeframe? If not, or if there were signs that it was too short or too long a timeframe, this should be noted.
Depending on the organisation, and the learning and development activity, there may be other consideration that should be monitored and addressed. In every case, appropriate managers must be kept informed of the progress and success rate of the activities. A written report, at the completion contributes strongly to the continuous
improvement of any organisation.
Taking Remedial Action
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
A remedial action is a change made to a non-conforming product or service to address the deficiency. ‘Rework’ and ‘repair’ are generally the remedial actions taken on products, while services usually require additional services to be performed to ensure satisfaction.
In the case of development activities, if the agreed outcomes are not achieved, then the cause must be investigated. If the fault is found to be that of the provider, then re-training, refunds of expenses, or other recompense may be requested. This would usually involve the person in charge of the arrangements for the activity negotiating a solution with the principal of the activity provider.
If the organisation has a department which handles purchases, the department would have the responsibility of attaining a remedial action. Check with your organisation, you may have a process, or you may be required to have the approval of a superior before initiating action.
Negotiating Remedial Action
If there was a shortfall in the transference of skills, budget, or time, remedial action may need to be taken. Non-conformance and any necessary corrective actions will require: - Assess evidence of non-compliance – be thoroughly educated and informed before citing non-compliance.
You need to do two things: play devil’s advocate and research similar non- compliances made in the past. Think about why the other side might argue against your complaint and act like they’re right. Come up with the best arguments they have against why they should help you and prepare your rebuttals. - Review evidence of non-compliance – you must remain objective and reasonable at all times.
When you want to complain, generally the emotion attached to that complaint is anger. Anger is a powerful motivator, but it’s terrible and useless in an argument. Anger just breeds more anger, and that heightened emotional state prevents you, as well as the person you’re complaining to, from seeing logic and reason. Be firm about the resolution you want, but you should always be kind. - Consideration of any remedies suggested by provider.
Although you shouldn’t be vague about what you want, it’s best to prime
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
the provider to feel more like they’re on your side. Often you can move forward by asking them what they would do if they were in your position. You can also ask what kind of resolution they think is fair, how they think this problem can best be solved, and anything else that can (politely) help a customer service representative understand what it’s like for you.
In some cases, you’ll need to ask to escalate the issue to a superior – which is often what needs to happen in order to get the resolution you want in the first place, so don’t be afraid to ask – you may be able to get where you want to be by simply getting the provider to think about where you’re coming from.
While questions are important, you don’t want to lose sight of your goal. It is perfectly fine to state your ideal resolution. What you want to avoid is making demands. It’s OK to say, “this is what I’d like to see happen”, followed by an outline of your ideal resolution in a concise and polite fashion. What’s not OK, is to demand that you get this or that with an implied ‘or else’. Demands kill a negotiation and make you an unreasonable, hostile person. Just because you don’t demand something, doesn’t mean you won’t get it. When you make a demand, the other side will feel they’ve heard everything they need to hear. They know the only condition you’re willing to accept and will act accordingly.
If you’re willing to discuss the situation politely, you’re more likely to get what you want. This way you have an opportunity to argue why what you want is the most fair and a lesser resolution won’t work. Demands take all of those options off the table. - Report to HR setting out findings, remedies agreed with the provider, and any further recommendations of either further remedial action or otherwise.
So much of our communication is informed with body language, so you give yourself a huge advantage by showing up in person and kindly asking for your ideal resolution. But it is also crucial that you document each step including the resolution. This information will be used to improve the system and ensure a better outcome on the next occasion.
Sometimes complaining directly to the provider will get you nowhere. There is no strategy you can have that will always be effective. However, the HR unit will know what the organisational policy is on taking further action and be in a position to act.
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
Reporting
It is essential to keep stakeholders ‘in the loop’, regular emails or meetings are important, as are more formal reports, to the supervisors and managers of those undertaking development activities. The outcomes of the activity should be noted in the report and on the file of the learner. Any issues or examples of above-standard, below-standard, or non-compliance should also be noted.
Evaluate Performance Management Systems
It is essential that performance management systems are reviewed. Evaluation can determine the value and worth of performance management systems to the organisation. To be effective, evaluation must be carried out in such a way that a judgement can be made regarding whether or not the systems are delivering what they are expected to deliver. The following areas need to be examined: - The extent to which performance management systems support the organisation’s strategic:
• Mission
• Goals and objectives
• Key result areas (KRA). - The extent to which performance management systems empower functional teams to address their:
• Key performance areas
• KPI
• Performance targets
• Performance objectives. - The extent to which performance management systems enable individual employees to:
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
• Relate job descriptions to performance expectations
• Set performance objectives
• Develop action plans. - The extent to which performance management systems encourage employee development.
- The ability of performance management systems to intervene to rectify unacceptable performance.
- The degree of difficulty in using and administering performance management systems.
Methods of Evaluation
You can use any one or a number of the following methods to evaluate performance management systems:
• Questionnaires
• Observation
• Surveys
• Focus groups
• Diagnostic checklists
• Audits
• Statistical analysis.
Questionnaires
Questionnaires check the understanding, attitudes, processes, and content of performance management systems. They can be completed by teams as a combined effort or by individuals. Questionnaires can ask straight questions, such as “What is the business focus of your organisation?” with multiple-choice tick boxes to answer.
Or, a questionnaire can be in the form of a rating scale ranging from ‘strongly agree’ to ‘strongly disagree’ in answer to a statement like, “Performance management systems motivate you to perform exceptionally well?”
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
Observation
Observation with the use of checklists can evaluate practices and procedures. This could be a useful method for making a judgement on team processes. You can arrange with a team to observe, using a checklist to identify and develop key performance areas, KPIs, performance targets, and performance objectives.
Surveys
Surveys can be used to determine attitudes or behavioural responses towards performance management systems or any component of the systems, such as review processes. Similarly, surveys can be done to discover the extent of understanding by staff of performance management systems or systems components.
Focus groups
Focus groups are structured and facilitated groups, formed for the purpose of discussing planned and open-ended questions to gain information. Such groups, when in the hands of skilled Trainers, are considered time-efficient and able to yield high quality information, particularly in the early stages of research. Focus groups are a useful means for evaluating the initial introduction, implementation, and management of your systems.
Diagnostic Checklists
Use diagnostic checklists to check all aspects of performance management systems. For instance, check whether:
Business College at International House
RTO Code: 91109 CRICOS 02623G
Level 1, 203 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 2000 | Floor 1, 237 Oxford St, Bondi Junction NSW 2022
3 Searcy St, Darwin NT 0800 | Level 6, 601 Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000
info@ihBC.edu.au| www.ihBC.edu.au
• Organisational culture is ready for performance management systems
• Teams are sufficiently empowered to develop KRAs and KPIs
• Performance measures determined by an individual can be undertaken according to the skills of the individual identified in the job description.
Audits
Audits are inspections and investigations. Audits can be conducted, for example, to investigate whether International Organisation for Standardisation (ISO) standards are being upheld and to assess behaviour in a client relationship. Audits can be used as planned activities or randomly. They may be used randomly, for example, to:
• Monitor progress in achieving outputs
• Inspect measurement tools for safety purposes
• Scrutinise work practices for legal compliance.
Statistical Analysis
Statistical analysis can be undertaken using computer generated data. For example, evaluation of legal compliance or non-compliance data records provides evidence of the ability of performance management systems to reduce non-compliant behaviour or practices. The response to this would be to improve on an unacceptable record.
Statistical analysis can also be used to evaluate timeframes for team implementation of any element of performance management systems. This could provide evidence that indicates a need to work with teams struggling with timeframes.
Statistical analysis can also be used to evaluate the ability of performance management systems to address individual performance.
Consider statistics compiled for performance learning and development activities on employees. Are there reductions or additions to the number of individuals activity engaged in tertiary study programs on a year-by-year basis? If so, should an effort be made to improve on this and for what reason?
The post Monitoring and Evaluating Learning and Development Activities appeared first on My Assignment Online.