1
Brunel University
MSc Building Services Engineering Programme
Energy Conversion Technologies
Energy Conversion Technologies – Assignment 2019/20
Submission date: 30th April 2020
The assignment should be submitted online via WISEflow. Submission of this assignment after 12
December 2019 will not be accepted unless a later date has been agreed, in advance. Any
request for late submission must be made through the Distance Learning Office. Such
requests will only be accepted if received before 30.04.20.
Introduction
This assignment is concerned with the investigation of the performance characteristics of
commercial chillers. Before embarking on the assignment make sure you have studied the
material of Chapters 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 of the Energy Conversion Technologies – Part 1 course
book.
Make sure you read the assignment carefully before you begin and you are clear of what is
required from each question.
Learning Outcomes for the Assessment
(Refer to the appropriate module learning outcomes)
This assignment is designed to assess the following:
| i. | Your understanding of the operating characteristics and thermodynamic performance of commercial reciprocating chillers. Your ability to plot and interpret experimental data. Your understanding of the physical, thermodynamic and technological parameters that quantitatively determine the optimal operating conditions for reciprocating chillers. Your ability to interpret your results and present your findings in a structured written report |
| ii. iii. |
|
| iv. |
2
Assignment
Assume that you are a refrigeration engineer and you are required to produce a written report
on the energy performance of the refrigeration system you have tested in the laboratory. You
have carried out steady state tests for three condenser water leaving temperatures
(approximately constant refrigerant condensing temperatures (saturated vapour)) and a range
of evaporator water leaving temperatures (constant refrigerant evaporating temperatures
(saturated vapour)). You are expected to:
Task 1 – Plot the performance characteristics (performance maps) of the refrigeration system
as functions of the condenser water leaving and evaporator water leaving temperatures. These
characteristics should include power consumption, cooling capacity and COP.
Task 2 – Calculate and plot other characteristics (efficiencies) that you may feel are relevant
to your discussion and the performance evaluation of the system.
Task 3 – Calculate and Plot the Carnot COP and compare it with the actual COP of the system
discussing the main reasons for the difference in the two values.
Task 4 – Discuss the performance characteristics of the system and their implications with
respect to system design and optimal operation.
Indicative Reading List:
1. Energy Conversion Technologies Lecture Notes (Part 1)
2. M.J. Gordon and K.C. Ng, Cool Thermodynamics: The Engineering and Physics of Predictive, Diagnostic and
Optimization Methods for Cooling Systems – Cambridge International Science Publishing (2000). ISBN:
1898326908
3. ASHRAE Handbook – Fundamentals (SI Units), American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and AirConditioning Engineers (2005). ISBN: 1931862710
OTHER
4. James B. Rishel, Thomas H. Durkin and Benny L. Kincaid. HVAC Pump Handbook – McGraw-Hill Handbooks,
second edition (2006). ISBN: 0-07-145784-4
5. T. D. Eastop and A. McConkey, Applied Thermodynamics for Engineering Technologists – Prentice Hall, fifth
edition (1996). ISBN: 0582091934
6. Applied Thermal Engineering: Design, Processes, Equipment and Economics – ELSEVIER (2009). ISSN:
1359-4311
Advice
Try to address all the above points in your report. Your main report should not be more than 10 pages
A4 size (including graphs) and should be typed or produced on a word processor; sample calculations
which should be included in an Appendix may be hand written.
You may use a spreadsheet package to facilitate your calculations. All the experimental results are
written in Excel format on the disk provided. For your calculations you will need the properties of
R404A. You can read these properties from the property tables given in the attached file
(R404A_Properties.pdf) or the P-h Chart shown in Appendix C. Please note that the pressures in the
tables and chart are in absolute values. The pressure readings in the Excel file on your disk have already
been converted to absolute values. In addition, R404A is a near-azeotropic mixture of HFC-
125/143a/134a, 44/52/4% by weight. It is a non-ozone depleting compound, designed to serve as a longterm alternative to R502 and R22 in commercial refrigeration applications. Compared to pure refrigerant,
at constant temperature in saturation region, the R404A pressures of saturated vapour and liquid are
3
slightly different, as shown in the provided property table and p-h Chart in Appendix C. On the other
hand, at constant pressure in saturation region, the R404A temperatures of saturated vapour and liquid
are also a little varied.
Please also note that enthalpy and entropy properties taken from the tables and the Chart for a given
refrigerant state may be different. This is because different refrigerant manufacturers use different
origins to calculate enthalpies and entropies. Irrespective of whether you use the chart or tables you
should arrive at the same answer because although the absolute values of the properties may be different
the difference between the absolute values at the beginning and end of a process will be the same. What
is of the interest is the change in enthalpy or entropy during a process and not the absolute values at the
beginning and end of the process. It is important therefore not to mix enthalpy and entropy properties
taken from the charts or tables if these have been produced by different chemical companies.
The experimental test facility and experimental method are described in Appendices A and B
respectively.
You can make your own assumptions where necessary but make sure to specify these assumptions and
clearly justify them in your report.
Method of assessment
Your report will be marked on the clarity of your presentation, the accuracy of your calculations, the
logic underlying the justifications of any assumptions you make, and the quality of your discussion and
conclusions.
The breakdown of the marks is as follows:
Presentation – (10%),
(This will include the following: structure of report; clarity of structure (including sections such as
executive summary, glossary, notation etc); frequency and format of referencing; appropriate length;
language – grammar, spelling, and syntax).
Task 1 – (20%)
Task 2 – (30%)
Task 3 – (20%)
Task 4 – (20%)
4
APPENDIX A
Experimental test facility
The test facility is based around a chiller of nominal cooling capacity of 25 kW. The chiller is
equipped with shell and tube heat exchangers, an externally equalised thermostatic expansion
valve, a 4 cylinder hermetic compressor designed for use with R404A and appropriate controls.
The compressor displacement is 45.07 m3/hr at 1450 rpm. A Danfoss DQ5 electronic expansion
valve is mounted in parallel to the thermostatic valve to enable performance comparison of the
two valves to be carried out. Modifications carried out on the system enable easy introduction
and testing of alternative types of compressor and variable speed drives. Test conditions on the
chiller are achieved through two water-storage tanks and 3-way mixing valves. The valves mix
appropriate quantities of chilled and hot water from the respective tanks to achieve the required
temperatures at the condenser and evaporator. A recirculatory air tunnel acts as a balancing
mechanism between the hot and cold sides of the system. The tunnel can also be used to
simulate ambient conditions for air cooled evaporators and condensers.
The test facility is comprehensively instrumented to provide the necessary data for control and
optimisation studies. Data logging is performed automatically with a microcomputer based data
logging system. The computer records refrigerant temperatures and pressures at four points in
the cycle, before and after each major component, water temperatures at the inlet and outlet of
the condenser and evaporator, water flow rates in the condenser and evaporator and the power
consumption of the compressor motor. The system is very flexible, allowing variation in the
number of the logged cycles and the logging cycle time. The logging time used in the
experiment was 4 s per cycle. The system is capable of producing all the measured data in an
Excel format for subsequent analysis. The instrumentation points are shown in Figure 1. The
experimental test facility is shown in Figure 2.
5
6
APPENDIX B
Experimental Method
Three sets of experimental tests were carried out for condenser water leaving temperatures of
30°C, 35C and 40C. The condenser water leaving temperature approximately corresponds to
a constant refrigerant condensing temperature (saturated vapour). For each condenser water
leaving temperature the evaporator water leaving temperature which approximately
corresponds to a constant refrigerant evaporating temperature (saturated vapour) was varied
from 5C to 10C in steps of approximately 1C. In experimental investigations it is very
difficult to ensure that conditions are kept constant at exactly the required value and you will
see from the results (temperature T8) that the evaporator water leaving temperature fluctuates
between +/- 0.25C about the set point.
A number of readings were taken for each set-point and to produce accurate results you will
need to average these values. This can be done using a spreadsheet package such as Excel. Sets
of readings which deviate considerably from the set point can be disregarded.
After averaging the readings you should end up with 6 sets of readings for each condenser water
leaving temperature. All graphs plotted should be based on these readings.
The reading for the refrigerant mass flow should be disregarded. Calculation of the
refrigerant mass flow rate should be based on an energy balance between the refrigerant
and the water across the condenser.
For convenience you can perform all the analysis and plot all the required graphs using Excel
or a similar package. Manual calculations and graph plotting will also be accepted.
7
APPENDIX C
R404A Pressure-Enthalpy Diagram
The post MSc Building Services Engineering Programme appeared first on My Assignment Online.