Nurse Leadership Reflection Paper: Ethical and Unethical Leadership, Integrity and Professional Accountability
Reflect on a situation from your professional or academic experience that raised questions of leadership, ethics or professional accountability. Address:
- What aspects of the situation stood out as examples of ethical and unethical leadership? Provide context and describe the leadership behaviors you observed.
- How did the experience shape or challenge your beliefs about leading with integrity, accountability and fairness in nursing or healthcare?
- How does the situation inform your growth as a nurse leader? What will you apply, how will it influence future leadership challenges and which strategies or frameworks from the course (such as transformational or servant leadership) will you incorporate?
Medication error, two responses
Transparency, support, systems focus
Hiding errors, public blame
Accountability includes systems
Transformational, servant, just culture
Download the APA reflection paper (.docx)
Model reflection
Original example for study purposes (about 800 words). The scenario is a composite; write about your own experience in the first person and de-identify people and places.
Introduction
Leadership is tested most when ethical choices carry personal or professional risk. This paper reflects on a situation from my clinical experience that raised questions of ethical leadership and accountability, examines how it shaped my beliefs about leading with integrity and identifies strategies I will apply as a nurse leader. [Sample reflection based on a composite scenario; replace it with your own experience and remove identifying details.]
The Situation: Ethical and Unethical Leadership
While working on a busy medical-surgical unit, I observed a medication error: a nurse gave a patient a second dose of an anticoagulant because the first dose had not been documented promptly. The patient was monitored and was not harmed. Two leaders responded very differently.
The charge nurse on duty modeled ethical leadership. She immediately ensured the patient’s safety, notified the provider, told the patient and family what had happened, completed an incident report and supported the nurse involved, who was visibly shaken. She described the error as a system problem, noting that documentation delays were common during shift change, and suggested a discussion at the next staff meeting. Her actions reflected honesty, fairness and concern for both patient and staff, behaviors that characterize ethical leaders (Brown et al., 2005).
The unit manager’s response raised concerns. She initially suggested that the event did not need an incident report because “no harm was done” and later reprimanded the nurse in front of colleagues. These behaviors reflected unethical or ineffective leadership: discouraging transparency undermines patient safety and organizational learning, and public blame damages trust and makes staff less likely to report future errors. The contrast between the two leaders showed me that integrity is demonstrated through specific actions, especially under pressure.
How the Experience Shaped My Beliefs
Before this experience, I associated accountability mainly with individual responsibility: if you make a mistake, you own it. I still believe that, but I now see that accountability also belongs to leaders and systems. A just culture distinguishes between human error, at-risk behavior and reckless behavior and responds to each appropriately, consoling people who make human errors, coaching those who take risks and reserving discipline for reckless choices (Marx, 2001). The nurse’s error was a human error made in a flawed system; the fair response was support and system redesign, not public blame.
The experience also reinforced that transparency is not optional. The Code of Ethics for Nurses calls on nurses to promote, advocate for and protect the rights, health and safety of patients and to foster ethical work environments (American Nurses Association [ANA], 2025). Discouraging error reporting conflicts with these obligations. I came away believing that leading with integrity means telling the truth even when it is uncomfortable, treating people fairly and protecting patients first.
Implications for My Growth as a Nurse Leader
This situation gave me a clear picture of the leader I want to be. I will apply several strategies and frameworks from this course:
- Transformational leadership: I will model the values I expect, such as transparency and accountability, and use individualized consideration to support staff after adverse events (Bass & Riggio, 2006). Inspiring a shared commitment to safety is more effective than enforcing compliance through fear.
- Servant leadership: Greenleaf (1977) described leaders who serve first and prioritize the growth and well-being of others. In practice, I will ask what my team needs to work safely, such as staffing, tools or training, and remove barriers.
- Just culture principles: I will respond to errors by examining systems, consoling and coaching staff and encouraging reporting of errors and near misses (Marx, 2001).
- Ethical decision-making: When facing dilemmas, I will use a structured approach: identify the facts and stakeholders, consider the ethical principles and professional code, weigh options and their consequences, act and reflect on the outcome.
- Psychological safety: I will hold private, respectful conversations when correcting behavior and publicly thank staff who speak up about safety concerns.
In the future, when I face leadership challenges, such as pressure to meet productivity targets or conflict between staff and administration, I will ask three questions drawn from this experience: Is this transparent? Is this fair to everyone involved? Does this protect patients? Using these questions as a guide will help me act consistently with my values even when the easier path is tempting.
Conclusion
Observing two leaders respond differently to the same medication error showed me that ethical leadership is defined by actions: honesty, fairness, support for staff and commitment to patient safety. The experience broadened my understanding of accountability to include leaders and systems and strengthened my commitment to just culture. By combining transformational and servant leadership with just culture principles and a structured approach to ethical decisions, I will work to create environments where nurses feel safe to speak up and patients receive the safest possible care.
References
American Nurses Association. (2025). Code of ethics for nurses. https://codeofethics.ana.org
Bass, B. M., & Riggio, R. E. (2006). Transformational leadership (2nd ed.). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Brown, M. E., Treviño, L. K., & Harrison, D. A. (2005). Ethical leadership: A social learning perspective for construct development and testing. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 97(2), 117–134. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2005.03.002
Greenleaf, R. K. (1977). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. Paulist Press.
Marx, D. (2001). Patient safety and the “just culture”: A primer for health care executives. Columbia University.
Tip: describe observable behaviors, such as what the leader said and did, rather than judging personalities; this keeps the reflection professional and analytical.
Frequently asked questions
What is a just culture?
An approach that distinguishes human error, at-risk behavior and reckless behavior, focusing on system improvement while maintaining accountability.
Can I write about a leader I disagreed with?
Yes, but describe behaviors objectively, protect their identity and focus on what you learned.
More model assignments posted today
- Bioethics in nursing CEU answers