PHIL 241 Ethics in Modern Society
Spring 2020
How to Think about
Morality?
Slaviša Janković, PhD
Middle East University
How to Think about Morality?
o People employ a wide variety of methods of
moral reasoning when they wrestle with
ethical decisions in contemporary culture.
o Imagine!
How to Think about Morality?
o Imagine a panel discussion on the morality of
physician-assisted suicide. The participants are:
1. an eighty-year-old with terminal cancer and
approximately six months to live, ethical egoist
2. the head of the local chapter of the Hemlock Society,
an organization that advocates assisted suicide,
deontologist
3. a physician who specializes as an oncologist, that is,
a cancer specialist, utilitarian
How to Think about Morality?
4. a Catholic priest who is an outspoken
opponent of euthanasia,
5. an atheistic philosophy professor from the
local college
6. an attorney
7. a Protestant minister
How to Think about Morality?
o Moral reasoning can be divided into two
primary categories:
1. Cognitive view of morality
2. Noncognitive view of morality
o .
o .
How to Think about Morality?
o Noncognitive views, such as emotivism,
maintain that moral statements do not convey
a truth-value—they are only expressions of
approval or disapproval.
o Cognitive views of morality maintain that
moral statements do indeed have truth-value.
How to Think about Morality?
o The cognitive views we will examine
understand them as follows:
1. Utilitarianism—truth telling maximizes the
greatest good for the greatest number
2. Deontological ethics—truth telling is a moral
duty, based on reason, natural law, or God’s
commands
How to Think about Morality?
3. Ethical egoism—truth telling maximizes one’s
self-interest
4. Virtue ethics—truth telling is essential for
human and societal flourishing
How to Think about Morality?
o Cognitive views of morality can be grouped into
two additional categories—those that view morality
as objective or those that view it as subjective.
o Objective morality refers to moral statements and
obligations that are true regardless of how one
feels about them
How to Think about Morality?
o Subjective morality, the truth of the
statement and obligation is determined by
how one feels about them.
o In subjective views of morality, moral
statements and obligations have been reduced
to matters of subjective preference or opinion.
How to Think about Morality?
o Objective views of morality knows two categories.
1. Morality as something that is created by human
beings
2. Morality as something that transcends human
nature—that is, morality is not a human creation
but is discovered by human beings through a
variety of means (e.g., reason, intuition, or divine
revelation).
How to Think about Morality?
o Christian ethics is a blend of virtues and
principles, and it employs some other types of
moral reasoning in order to support the
primary role of virtues and principles.
OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTIVE
o It is very common today for people to assert
that someone’s moral views are simply
matters of subjective opinion, particularly in
private moral matters such as sexual ethics.
OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTIVE
o Objective statements are either true or false
regardless of how anyone feels about them.
o By contrast, subjective statements are true or
false depending on how someone feels about
them.
OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTIVE
o Which of the following statements are objective,
and which are subjective?
1. My newborn baby is the cutest child in the entire
city.
2. Abraham Lincoln was the sixteenth president of
the United States
3. Stage plays are more entertaining than movies.
OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTIVE
4. Chocolate ice cream tastes better than vanilla.
5. Salads have fewer calories than cheesecake.
6. I (in my 60’s) am able to run a sub-four-minute
mile.
7. The earth is the center of the solar system
8. The Los Angeles Dodgers will win the World
Series this year.
OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTIVE
o Things get complicated:
1. Abortion, unless it is necessary to save the
mother’s life, is immoral.
2. Racial discrimination is morally wrong.
3. Sexual assault is morally acceptable.
OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTIVE
o Morality being objective, a view known as
moral realism.
o Adherents of objective morality are much
more passionate in communicating their
views than proponents of subjective morality
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
Moral objectivism is an opinion that “there are
moral truths not of our own making, moral
claims that are true independently of what
anyone, anywhere, happens to think of them.”
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
From within a Christian worldview, which posits
God as the ultimate source for morality, objective
morality originates from a transcendent source,
although there are accounts of objective morality
that do not depend on belief in God.
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
o Philosopher Russ Shafer-Landau concluded, “Were
we convinced that there was no truth of the matter,
most would see their continued disagreement as
pointless; as pointless as, say, entering an intractable
debate about whether red or orange was really the
most beautiful color.”
o If morality is nothing more than an expression of our
personal tastes and preferences, it is very difficult to
make sense of the way we debate moral issues.
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
o All great moral reformers had to appeal to a
transcendent, objective, and universal moral law
that opposed the existing moral consensus of the
culture.
o Think of Nelson Mandela and his overcoming
apartheid in South Africa.
o Think what William Wilberforce did in leading the
fight to abolish slavery in the British empire.
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
o Think what Abraham Lincoln appealed to in
ending slavery in America. It’s difficult to
refer to what they did as moral progress
unless there is an objective moral law that can
be known.
o Think of Martin Luther King Jr., with his civil
rights leadership and calling the United States
to a moral standard of equality and dignity
that he assumed was objective.
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
o The very idea of moral progress assumes an
objective moral standard against which
individuals and institutions can be measured, and
if morality is nothing more than subjective
opinion, then the whole notion of moral reformers
makes little sense.
o Unless there is such a thing as moral truth that
can be known, it is virtually impossible to make a
moral assessment on the tyrants of history, which
we have obviously done so already.
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
o Objective morality is not undermined by
moral diversity in the world or in any given
culture.
o Science is subject to empirical verification
methods, while moral philosophy depends on
good reasons, sound argument, and other
types of reasoning that is different from
empirical data.
OBJECTIVE MORALITY
o Objective morality best accounts for the kind
of moral world in which we live.
o George Mavrodes puts it, “Reality itself is
committed to morality in some deep way. It
makes sense only if there is moral demand on
the world too, and only if reality will in the
end satisfy that demand.”
Evolutionary Origins for Morality
o Morality may be objective, but instead of
coming from a transcendent source, such as
God, it may originate from evolutionary
adaptation. That is, morality is simply the
product of evolutionary processes that
provide adaptive advantages to groups and
societies.
o Moral behavior is advantageous to survival,
particularly in a group.
Evolutionary Origins for Morality
o However, values such as altruism and selfsacrifice, especially the kind of sacrifice that
societies have long held up as heroic, such as
giving up one’s life for another (that person
would actually be a loser in the evolutionary
scheme of things), compassion, forgiveness,
and unconditional love, can all be seen as
putting both individuals and communities at a
competitive disadvantage when it comes to
survival and reproduction.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o Emotivism is a theory about metaethics,
specifically, the language of morality. It is not
considered a normative system because it
does not aim at producing moral norms for
governing behavior.
o That moral language simply expresses a
person’s emotions about a subject.
o Moral language cannot be true or false.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o Alike, there is an essential difference between
the moral subjectivist and the emotivist.
o For the subjectivist, moral judgments are
reports or statements of fact about the
feelings and preferences of the person who
says them, which can either be verified or
falsified.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o For the emotivist, moral judgments are not facts at
all, but emotional expressions about an action or
person.
o The subjectivist will say, “Capital punishment is
wrong!” This means, “I feel that capital punishment is
wrong.”
o For the emotivist, the same statement means,
“Capital punishment, yuck! Boo!” Emotivism is thus a
more sophisticated theory than subjectivism.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o A major philosophical development that
contributed to emotivism was the rise of
logical positivism.
o Logical positivists claimed that only two types
of statements that have truth-value are
possible: (1) analytical statements, such as
definitions, and (2) factual statements that
are empirically verifiable.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o Moral judgments are more than definitions
and are not empirically verifiable; therefore,
they cannot be factual statements. All they
can be are statements that express and
arouse emotion.
o Three points of critique of Emotivism
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o First, the verification theory of meaning,
which is the foundation of logical positivism,
has problems. Specifically, it fails its own test
of meaning. Emotivism maintains that the
only statements capable of having meaning
are those that are empirically verifiable, but
this underlying principle is itself not
empirically verifiable. There is no good
reason to limit meaningful statements to
those that are verified empirically.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o Second, emotivism is actually a theory of the use of moral
language, not of its meaning.
o The emotivist has jumped from a theory of use to a theory
of meaning without any justification for that leap.
o Third, emotivism cannot adequately account for the place
of reason in ethics. Emotivism sets up a false dichotomy,
as the following demonstrates:
o a. Either there are moral facts like there are scientific
facts, or b. values are nothing more than expressions of
our subjective feelings.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Emotivism
o But there is another possibility; namely, moral
truths are truths of reason, or a moral
judgment is true if it is supported by better
reasons than the alternatives. From a
Christian worldview, we would also say that
moral truths are also truths of revelation,
both in general revelation in God’s created
world, and in the special revelation of the
Bible.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Teleological Ethics
o Teleological ethics determines what is moral
by the end that the action achieves.
o There are two primary types of teleological
ethics—utilitarianism and ethical egoism.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Teleological Ethics
Utilitarianism commonly argues that the moral
choice is the one that produces the greatest good
for the greatest number of people, or the moral
choice is the course of action that produces more
good consequences than harmful ones.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Teleological Ethics
o Utilitarianism has its roots in the philosophies
of Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832) and John
Stuart Mill (1806–73).
o He held to what has been called a hedonistic
utilitarianism, which maintains that the most
moral acts are those that maximize pleasure
and minimize pain.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Teleological Ethics
o Mill moved his approach away from hedonism and
toward a more general concept of maximizing the
general happiness or the greatest good for the
greatest number.
o When it was proposed, utilitarianism was a radical
theory, since it divorced morality from divine
revelation and from any view of nature. According
to utilitarianism, moral behavior no longer
required faithfulness to divine ordinances and rigid
moral rules.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Teleological Ethics
o First, it is a relatively simple theory to apply.
o Second, it avoids the rigidity of deontology, that is,
it keeps morality from being reduced to abstract
principles that must be strictly followed, regardless
of consequences produced by them.
o Third, it doesn’t require special appeal to any
religious authority for morality; rather, it claims to
appeal to nonmoral criteria for determining the
good.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Teleological Ethics
o The most common charge against utilitarianism is
that it cannot protect the rights of minorities, and
sometimes it can even justify obvious injustices
when the greater good is served.
o Also, utilitarianism can justify obvious injustices,
such as creating evidence against an innocent
person to prevent widespread social unrest that
would result in loss of life and substantial property
damage.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o The theory that the morality of an act is
determined by one’s self-interest. Actions that
advance self-interest are moral, and those
that do not are not moral.
o A common misunderstanding is that an
ethical egoist is merely being egotistical.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o Medical doctors frequently make treatment
and testing decisions based on their potential
exposure to medical malpractice suits.
o Blowing the whistle. An employee’s superiors
ask the employee to do something that the
employee believes is immoral, such as
falsifying data, offering bribes, or deceiving
customers or regulators.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o The employee may refuse to fulfill the request and
instead instead may “blow the whistle” on the
company, revealing the immoral and, at times,
illegal practice that they have been asked to do.
o Appeal to rational self-interest is used in the Bible
as a way of motivating people to be obedient to
God. Lev 26, Deut 28
o In ethical egoism one’s only moral duty is to one’s
own self-interest.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o First, egoism, not altruism, treats others with
dignity. Egoists see altruism as fundamentally
demeaning to the recipient of charity.
o Egoists maintain that people who are mutually
pursuing their self-interest treat the other with a
dignity that charity cannot.
o Second, ethical egoism is the only moral system
that respects the importance of the individual
human life.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o Egoism allows each person to view his own life
as having ultimate value thus taking the
individual human seriously.
o Third, egoism makes the best sense of our
widely accepted moral duties.
o The egoist accepts that people can genuinely
look out for others yet tries to explain it as an
outworking of self-interest.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o First, egoism has no means to settle conflicts of
interest between individuals and groups.
o Second, ethical egoism ultimately collapses into
anarchy.
o Third, ethical egoism is often built on the false
premise of psychological egoism, that is, the notion
that individuals are only capable of acting in their
self-interest, and that genuine altruism does not
exist. You should notice that if psychological egoism
is true, then ethical egoism is unnecessary.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Ethical Egoism
o Fourth, ethical egoism as a sufficient system
ignores the fact that the Bible calls people to a
balance of self-interest and altruism. We are
called to care for the needs of others because
they are comparable to our own and because a
significant part of being a disciple of Christ is
following his altruistic example.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Deontological systems of ethics are principle-based
systems, in which actions are intrinsically right
or wrong, dependent on adherence to the relevant
moral principles or values.
o What distinguishes various types of deontological
systems is the source of the principles that
determine morality.
o Divine command and natural law as both important
components of Christian Ethics.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Ethical rationalism, the moral theory of Immanuel Kant
is not based on divine command nor natural law.
o 3 foundational assumptions of ER:
o First, to have a valid moral system, one must have power to
constrain people without being deterministic.
o Freedom of choice
o In contrast to Hume, reason governs the passions, not vice
versa.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Second, what is a valid duty in circumstance X is the
same for all rational beings.
o This is his principle of fairness and is foundational to
his central concept known as the categorical
imperative.
o He does acknowledge relevant differences among
people, but the point is that moral obligations do not
vary based on the circumstances.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Third, people cannot change their moral
obligations or duties merely by changing their
desires.
o Moral imperatives based on desire are what
he called hypothetical imperatives.
o A true moral imperative is what he called
categorical, since it is not based on some
desire.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Kant’s system revolved around the notion of
the good will.
o This is his first proposition on the nature of
morality.
o The good will is seen as being the key to being
worthy of happiness.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Kant reversed the emphasis of the classical
Greek philosophers that virtue would
essentially bring one well-being.
o For Kant, happiness followed if one was
morally worthy of possessing it.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Kant reasoned that since one cannot control all the
consequences, moral worth cannot depend on things that are
beyond the control of the individual making the moral decision.
o The good will is the will that acts for the sake of duty.
o One’s duty can be contrary to one’s inclination but does not have
to be.
o For Kant, being moral is more than acting according to one’s
inclinations.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Actions are determined either by desire, or by inclination, or
by what Kant calls a maxim.
o A maxim is the plan of action where an individual in
circumstance X does act A to bring about result R.
o But the result is not what gives the act worth because one
does not control all the results of one’s actions.
o The good will is the only unconditional good. The good will is
one that acts from duty alone.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o The value of an act done from duty is not in its
consequences. So it must be from its maxim.
o The good maxim must be able to motivate every
rational being in the specified circumstance. Thus it
must have something that is the “same for all.”
o Moral maxims must be categorical, that is, they must
be binding and independent of one’s desires.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Categorical imperative actually has four different
formulations:
o 1. Act only according to that maxim by which you can at the
same time will that it should become a universal law.
o 2. Act as though the maxim of your action were by your will to
become a universal law of nature.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o 3. Act so that you treat humanity, whether in your own
person or in that of another, always as an end and never as a
means only. From this formulation the fundamental principle
of respect for persons is derived.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o 4. Do no action according to any maxim that would be
inconsistent with its being universal, and thus act only so that
the will through its maxims could regard itself at the same
time as universally law-giving. This is what he calls his
principle of autonomy. Since we derive the principles from our
own rational nature, we are autonomous and self-determined,
and thus by our actions we “legislate” morality. Moral
constraint is thus possible without individuals losing their
genuine freedom of moral choice.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o No will is morally good because it does what it
wants to do. A motive other than the passions
must exist: respect for law.
o Free from determination, the rational will acts
on the basis of respect for law.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o But since not all are purely rational beings,
human beings ought to act under the
constraint of the categorical imperative.
o The moral purpose of reason is to illuminate
us to our “ought,” independent of sensation.
o The highest good for Kant is both happiness
and being worthy of it. That is achieved by
adherence to duty.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics – Critique
o First, Kant appears to have been overly optimistic
about the ability of reason to formulate universal
absolutes.
o Kant held that rational persons using their faculties
could reason themselves to precisely the same moral
rules.
o This seems to run counter to the degree of moral
diversity that exists in the world today.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Second, the results of the categorical
imperative.
o According to Kant, when properly applied, the
categorical imperative provides absolute
moral rules, which is the goal.
o It produces an exception-less moral system—
there are never exceptions to Kantian
formulated moral rules.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Kant himself suggests that even when
confronted with the need to lie in order to
protect an innocent person who is about to be
killed, one still has an unqualified duty to tell
the truth.
o Yet this seems problematic and illustrates one
of the tensions of absolutist deontological
moral systems in general—they cannot deal
with scenarios when principles conflict.
Types of Moral Reasoning:
Deontological Ethics
o Third, a final criticism of Kant is that his categorical
imperative is only a procedural morality and does not offer
any guidance in terms of the content of morality.
o That is, it is a necessary part of formulating moral rules but
not sufficient to tell us what the rules ought to be. One can
properly devise consistent absolutes, but the categorical
imperative cannot tell us why those absolutes may be
considered right or wrong.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Ethical relativism became popular as a result of the
findings of cultural anthropologists at the turn of
the twentieth century, who observed that different
cultures have widely varying moral codes and
concepts of right and wrong.
o As these scholars studied different cultures, they
discovered the lack of a uniform concept of right
and wrong.
o polygamy vs monogamy
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Some cultures consider it a moral obligation to give
one of their children to an infertile couple.
o Some cultures, such as certain Eskimo groups,
practice euthanasia and infanticide in ways that seem
ghastly and immoral to many other cultures.
o Among the Auca Indians of South America, treachery
was considered the highest virtue.
o Today, female circumcision, a practice many
Westerners refer to as mutilation, is practiced widely
in Africa and the Middle East.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o In view of such moral diversity, they suggested that
it was impossible to believe in universal moral
values that transcend time and culture.
o Such moral diversity called into question ethical
systems that posited absolute, unchanging moral
principles that could be universally applied.
o Rather than being universal, morality was seen as
relative to the cultural consensus.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Some anthropologists, however, merely pointed out the
differences between the moral codes of various
cultures, “descriptive ethics.”
o They looked at the diversity of ethical standards and
concluded that different cultures in the world have
widely differing standards of right and wrong.
o But many other anthropologists espoused a normative
form of relativism called cultural relativism. This is
the primary form of relativism; it molds the culture,
determines the values, and sets the moral norms.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o So the cultural consensus determines morality for that
culture.
o Consequently, there are no objective, universal moral
principles that are binding for all cultures and times.
o Cultural relativism is sometimes referred to as
conventionalism, which maintains that cultural
acceptance determines the validity of moral norms.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o A second form of relativism practiced today is moral
subjectivism, which says that morality is determined by
the individual’s own tastes and preferences.
o This view of morality is often applied to sexual morality
where one’s moral code for sexual behavior is considered
a private matter and where one can subjectively and
individually determine what is right.
o It’s not hard to see how cultural relativism could reduce
to subjectivism; as the size of the relevant culture
shrinks, it ultimately ends up as a culture of one person—
hence subjectivism. (bribe, construction regulations…)
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o The first appeal of relativism is based on the
important idea that morality does not develop in a
sociological vacuum.
o This is wrong; slavery,
o A second appeal of relativism comes from the way
it is presented. Frequently relativism is presented
as though it and its opposite, complete absolutism,
are the only two valid alternatives.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o However, one can hold to objective moral principles and
not be a complete absolutist, that is, one can be what is
called a prima facie absolutist. While recognizing the
importance of unchanging, objective, moral principles, the
prima facie absolutist allows for periodic exceptions to
general principles. (abortion)
o A third appeal of relativism comes from the emphasis on
cultural diversity. This trend emphasizes tolerance for the
distinctives of other cultures, including its moral values,
which are at the core of any culture.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Yet most people realize that limits must be drawn
somewhere and that some standards must
transcend culture if society is to arbitrate between
competing cultural values.
o This has deeper philosophical roots in a
postmodern view of truth, knowledge, and morality.
o Postmodernism insists that all knowledge is
received through one’s cultural lenses. As a result,
it is impossible to have an objective view of truth.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Two primary criticisms have been raised of
postmodernism.
o The first is to insist that just because one sees the
world through a particular set of lenses (or biases), it
does not mean that he or she is incapable of rationality
or objectivity. It may make being rational and objective
more difficult, but it does not make it impossible.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o A second problem with postmodernism as a worldview is
that it is self-refuting.
o Either the postmodernist thinker presents his or her
views as being true and rational, and thereby sensible
and worth adopting, which denies the central premises
of postmodernism,
o or the postmodernist advocate does not offer his or her
position as true, which does not provide any compelling
reasons for accepting it over other worldviews.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Challenges of Realitivism:
o First, in terms of the observations of the cultural
anthropologists who developed relativism, the degree
of moral diversity is overstated and the degree of
moral consensus is understated. A good deal more
moral consensus exists among cultures than was first
believed.
o Second: Many of the observations of moral diversity
were differences in moral practices. (Euthanasia)
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o Third challenge to relativism is that cultural
relativism as a normative system cannot be drawn
from the observations of the cultural relativist.
o Just because different cultures have different
moral standards—even if the degree of moral
diversity is not overstated—it does not follow that
there is no such thing as absolute values that
transcend culture.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Relativism
o A fourth challenge to relativism is that it provides
no way to arbitrate among competing cultural
value claims. This is important as many countries
recognize the high degree of cultural diversity in
their populations and therefore the inevitable clash
of cultures.
o Fifth and most serious charge against relativism is
that the relativist cannot morally evaluate any
clearly oppressive culture or, more specifically, any
obvious tyrant.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Virtue Ethics
o All the normative theories examined thus far have
been action-oriented ethical systems.
o The exception to this is emotivism
o Virtue theory, which is also called aretaic ethics
(from the Greek term arete, “virtue”), holds that
morality is more than simply doing the right thing.
o Moral agent, person doing action.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Virtue Ethics
o Dating back to Plato and Aristotle, the tradition of
virtue theory is a long one, including the
Epicureans, the Stoics, the New Testament Gospels,
and Thomas Aquinas. With the collapse of the
medieval worldview during the Renaissance and
Enlightenment periods, one of the unfortunate
casualties was Aquinas’ emphasis on Aristotelian
virtue theory.
Types of Moral Reasoning: Virtue Ethics
o .
The post PHIL 241 Ethics in Modern Society appeared first on My Assignment Online.