Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

PRACTICE PROBLEM

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length2,285 words
  • Reading time10 min
Write My Assignment FREE

Statutory Interpretation 2020

PRACTICE PROBLEM

Question Paper

Problem

It is 2021 when your firm is approached for legal advice.

On 15 April 2021, Ngaire is the mother and responsible parent of Cassius. Cassius was born on 22 April 2003.

On 15 April 2021, Ngaire ceased to be an Australian citizen under s 34 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (“the 2007 Act”). This had followed a conviction for an offence, under s 50 of that Act, of making false and misleading statements in her application for citizenship. Assume the Minister’s decision under s 34 is valid.

On 16 April 2021, the Minister emails Ngaire and Cassius informing them that she (the Minister) is considering revoking the citizenship of Cassius under s 36 of the 2007 Act. The Minister informs Ngaire and Cassius that they have 14 days to give grounds on why the citizenship of Cassius should not be revoked, after which the Minister will make a decision. Assume the email from the Minister is sent to Ngaire and forwarded to Cassius.

On 22 April 2021 Cassius turns 18 years of age.

On 4 May 2021 the Minister, not having heard from Ngaire or Cassius, revokes, by writing, the citizenship of Cassius.

Ngaire and Cassius come to your firm for advice. Your manager in the firm in which you work asks you to answer this question: Is the Minister empowered at all to revoke Cassius’s citizenship?

In the course of answering this question, interpret the words “the child’s” in s 36(1)(c) of the 2007 Act. (In other words, assume that phrase is the central unit of inquiry, for which you are to determine the legal meaning and apply to the facts.) In the course of interpreting the central unit of inquiry, formulate opposing constructions of that unit of inquiry. One construction should favour the interests of Cassius. Another construction should support the decision of the Minister to revoke the citizenship of Cassius.

You are not expected to discuss the legality of the exercise of the Minister’s discretion in s 36(1)(c). Assume s 36(2) and (3) of the 2007 Actdo not apply to the circumstances.

Among other things, your answer must discuss at least one of the asterisked extrinsic materials set out below under Assessable Topics and Materials.

You must answer the question on the problem solving template attached to this Question Paper.

Assessment details

Please see Subject Learning Guide on LMS (v 3) for allocated marks, due date, word limit, intended learning outcomes, special consideration, and university policies that apply to graded assessment.

Assessable topics and materials

The assessable topics are Weeks 1-8 topics (in addition to assumed skills and knowledge).

The Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (“the 2007 Act”), as in force on 13 April 2020, is examinable.

The Australian Citizenship Bill 2005 (Cth), so far as it is relevant, is examinable.

If, to define a term in the 2007 Act, that Act relies on another Act, students are expected to examine that other Act as far as it is relevant.

Students are expected to obtain, and draw on, at least one of the following additional extrinsic materials:

  • *the Explanatory Memorandum to the Australian Citizenship Bill 2005 (Cth)
  • *the Minister’s speech, moving a motion in the Parliament that the Australian Citizenship Bill 2005 (Cth) be read a second time
  • *section 23 of the Australian Citizenship Act 1948 (Cth), version prepared 1 July 2006 (version in place prior to repeal by Act No 21 of 2007).

Apart from finding the above material, students are not expected to engage in legal research.

Preparatory steps

Before attempting the problem, it is recommended that students attempt one or more of the Practice Problem exemplar questions on the LMS and self-assess using the answers provided.

How the answer is to be produced

The Practice Problem is not a group assignment. You must produce it independently. Among other things, you must not work on the problem with another student, or distribute your written answer or a written draft to another student. See the Subject Learning Guide for further information.

Meaning of “interpret”

See also the assessment criteria for further details about interpretation.

Use of facts and information

If you think a material fact (“fact X”) pertaining to the problem is not set out on the Question Paper, you may consider fact X as if it exists or can be proved to exist, provided it is plausible and that you also consider the alternative situation where fact X does not exist or cannot be proved to exist. This is standard advice with legal problem solving and is not to be taken as a suggestion that a material fact is not stated in the problem.

Similar advice applies to any information, set out in the problem on the Question Paper, which you regard as ambiguous. If the ambiguity is plausible, then make the most probable inference, or give alternative advice based on each scenario. This is standard advice with legal problem solving and is not to be taken as a suggestion that information in the problem is ambiguous.

Style and referencing

Follow the 4th edition of the Australian Guide to Legal Citation. See link at <http://latrobe.libguides.com/law>.

Word count 600 words

You must state the word count of your answer on the coversheet. The word count includes the headings in the template that you adopt in your submission. The word count does not include the coversheet. The word count does not include footnotes provided they are used for referencing purposes.

Before submitting your answer, delete explanatory material in square brackets that is on the template. You should also delete a heading or subheading that is on the template if there is nothing to say about it.

If a submission exceeds the word limit, and is 1-24 words over, the penalty is 0.5 marks. Thereafter, the following applies:

  • 25-74 words over: 1.5 marks penalty;
  • 75-124 words over: 2.5 marks penalty;
  • etc.

Identification

Do not put your name on the submission.

Extensions of time

Please email your tutor if you are seeking an extension of time. In your application you must specify the extension period you are seeking. Extensions cannot be granted beyond the expected date of release of results. This is the beginning of Week 12 (Monday 1 June). You may be required to send the tutor appropriate documentation.

Submission

Submit the completed coversheet and answer to the Turnitin link for the Practice Problem on the LMS.

Assessment criteria

(1) Proper handling of interpretative issue

The interpretative issue in the problem, together with its consequences (that is, application to facts), are well handled in that, as far as possible within the word constraints, the student:

  • identifies the central unit of inquiry if called upon
  • conducts any necessary analysis of the legislation
  • clearly and precisely formulates the rival contentions of meaning (“alternative constructions”) of the central unit of inquiry, and specifies the party whom a construction favours
  • for each alternative construction, identifies as widely as possible the indications of meaning that point to that construction (the “interpretative factors”)
  • considers the weight of each set of interpretative arguments and, to the extent possible, the strengths and weaknesses of each argument
  • interprets, where necessary, other provisions in the Act which (once their meaning is clarified) can be the subject of interpretative arguments in relation to the central unit of inquiry
  • reaches a conclusion as to what is most likely to be the legal meaning of the central unit of inquiry, and as clearly and precisely as possible states that meaning
  • gives cogent reasons in support of that conclusion
  • exercises good judgment in applying the law as interpreted to the facts
  • where required, states with as much clarity as possible what the legal position of the client is on the facts
  • in performing the above tasks, gives due recognition to any uncertainty in relation to the facts, the law, or the application of the law to the facts.

(2) Writing and referencing

The answer:

  • demonstrates clear thinking
  • uses paragraphs appropriately
  • is well structured and follows as far as possible the Problem Solving Template attached to this Question Paper
  • uses good syntax
  • is concisely expressed
  • is accurate in relation to spelling, punctuation and grammar
  • is well presented.

The answer is appropriately referenced, in that the student:

  • cites authority for all legal propositions requiring authority
  • includes precise and complete references, including references to legislation
  • employs a style that follows the style required by the Question Paper.

Marking guide and indicative examples

Assessment Criterion and ExampleGrade and Achievement Level

A GRADEB GRADE
C GRADE
D GRADE
N GRADE
Criterion 1: Handling of interpretative issue ILO 1, 3The interpretative issue is consistently handled wellWith minor exceptions, the interpretative issue is consistently handled wellThe interpretative issue is handled moderately well; at a middling level.The interpretative issue is handled at a marginally satisfactory level.The interpretative issue is not handled satisfactorily at all or on the whole
Indicative example 1Student evaluates alternative constructions, and provides detailed (but not necessarily comprehensive) supporting arguments together with cogent reasons why one construction ought to be preferred.Student provides arguments for each of the alternative constructions, but the arguments are not detailed.Student formulates plausible alternative constructions, but only provides supporting interpretative arguments for one of the constructions (one-sided).As for a C — one-sided. The answer also contains significant errors.Student does not identify unit of inquiry when called upon to do so, formulates no alternative constructions, and does not give interpretative arguments. The answer is concerned with different applications of the law to the facts.
Indicative example 2
Student provides arguments for each of the alternative constructions, but does not provide cogent reasons for preferring one construction.As for B grade examples 1 and 2. But the answer also contains significant errors (“curate’s egg”)The constructions are not adequately formulated. But it is apparent, taking account of the whole of the answer, that appropriate constructional choices have been thought of and plausible arguments for each side are made in addition to the literal reading.The answer sees the interpretative issue and provides potential arguments. But the answer does not formulate constructions and it contains numerous errors relating to the unit of inquiry, the constructions and interpretative arguments
Indicative example 3



The answer attempts to follow the required format but is contradictory throughout.
Indicative example 4



The answer attempts to follow the required format but contains numerous errors.
Indicative example 5



The answer attempts to follow the required format and a key argument is made. But no constructions, or interpretative arguments for the other side, are put.
Indicative example 6



One or two potential arguments for one side are made. But no constructions are formulated, and it is not evident that the student saw the interpretative issue or constructional choice.






Criterion 2: Writing and referencing
ILO 4
Consistently well written and referencedWith minor exceptions, it is consistently well written and referencedThe writing and referencing is at a moderate or middling levelThe writing and referencing is marginally satisfactoryThe essay is not satisfactorily written and referenced at all or on the whole
Indicative example 1
Well written, but a number of deficiencies concerning AGLC style
The writing clearly meets a satisfactory standard, but very little or no attempt is made to reference sources.The writing is not generally clear or coherent.
Indicative example 2



The writing contains numerous writing errors of various kinds.

Feedback

Brief online feedback addressing each of the assessment criteria will be given to each student. In addition, detailed group feedback will be given via the LMS. After a student has studied the individual and group feedback, the student may also approach the person who marked their submission for additional feedback.

[Statutory Interpretation]

[PROBLEM SOLVING TEMPLATE]

[Version 2]

[Before submitting, omit all explanatory material in square brackets]

1. Question Presented

[The question posed in the Question Paper; optional.]

2. Answer in Brief

[The Answer to the question posed in the Question Paper. This section must be answered.]

3. Discussion

3.1 Facts

[Consider if this section is needed, and omit if not needed.]

3.2 Unit of inquiry

3.3 Opposing constructions of unit of inquiry

[The object is to consider all constructions that might be considered by a court — see section 3.7. Normally, the opposing constructions which are considered by a lawyer asked to give an Opinion are those in favour of each of the Parties. They are accordingly the constructions put by, or which could be put by, each Party. However, uncommonly, it may be appropriate to consider a third construction — one that is not in favour of either Party. In that case, that construction could be (but need not be) the construction that is ultimately preferred.]

(a) Construction for Party A

[The construction in favour of Party A, but which is not ultimately preferred at section 3.7; when answering, give the name of Party A at this point.]

(b) Construction for Party B

[The construction in favour of Party B and which is the construction that is ultimately preferred at section 3.7; when answering, give the name of Party B at this point.]

3.4 Arguments for Party A’s construction

[When answering, give the name of Party A at this point.]

Unit of Inquiry:

Remainder of Act:

Legislative history:

Wider context:

3.5 Arguments for Party B’s construction

[When answering, give the name of Party B at this point.]

Unit of inquiry:

Remainder of Act:

Legislative history:

Wider context:

3.6 Evaluation of the parties’ arguments

[Brief reasons why one construction is preferable to the other; not a regurgitation of 3.4 and 3.5.]

3.7 Which construction is preferred

[In an Opinion given by a lawyer, the preferred construction is the construction that the lawyer judges would be preferred by a court, assuming the matter came to the court for resolution.]

4. Application of the law as interpreted to the facts

[This section normally requires discussion if you are asked for a person’s legal position, as distinct from a situation where you asked only a question of interpretation. However, omit this section if it is the same as the Answer in Brief.]

The post PRACTICE PROBLEM appeared first on My Assignment Online.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order