Th ere are a range of frameworks, standards and codes, which organisations can
draw on to provide guidance for the process of stakeholder engagement and which
aim to improve the sustainability performance of the organisation. Th ese include
the GRI Sustainability Reporting Guidelines (on reporting), SA8000 (on labour
standards compliance), the AA1000 Series (on systematic accountability, including
engagement), and the EFQM Excellence Model (on quality management). At
the national level various bodies have issued guidance and standards on social
responsibility, for example the SD21000 in France, SIGMA in the UK, AS8003
in Australia and Standard SI 10000 in Israel. At an international level, these will be
complemented by the current ISO process to develop international guidance on
social responsibility, in which stakeholder engagement will feature prominently.
Th ere are also a number of useful resources from organisations including Th e World
Business Council for Sustainable Development, Business for Social Responsibility,
CSR Europe, Th e Future 500 Initiative, the UK Environment Council, the South
African Calabash Project, the Brazilian Instituto Ethos, the Indian Development
Alternatives Group and the International Association for Public Participation. Such
sources of guidance are highlighted throughout the handbook, wherever relevant
and also in the resource list in Annex 1.
Th e achievement of procedural quality in stakeholder engagement does not
necessarily translate to a connection with the company’s core business activities or
material issues. While many standards, frameworks and sources of practical guidance
(including those from the fi elds of public and civil society participation) can help to
measure and achieve such procedural quality, many of them provide less guidance on
identifying and addressing the specifi c, important issues for each individual business.
Th e AA1000 Series, especially the AA1000 Stakeholder Engagement Standard
Exposure Draft provides guidance in how to use stakeholder engagement to deal
with issues of material signifi cance to the business and its stakeholders, and how to
align stakeholder engagement with an organisation’s core strategy. Th erefore it is
used as the framework for this handbook.
Th e AA1000 2 Series guides organisations in establishing systematic accountability
processes that involve stakeholders in the generation of strategies, policies and
programmes as well as associated indicators, targets and communication systems,
which eff ectively guide decisions, activities and overall organisational performance.
Th e AA1000 Framework is organised around the overarching principle of
‘inclusivity’.
“Striving for inclusivity means that an organisation is committed to refl ect, at all
stages of a process, the views and needs of all Stakeholder groups. Stakeholder views
are obtained through an engagement process that allows them to be expressed
without fear or restriction. Inclusivity requires the consideration of ‘voiceless’
stakeholders including future generations and the environment”.
2 The A11000 Series includes the AA1000 Assurance Standard, as well as the AA1000 Stakeholder Engagement Standard.
Stakeholder engagement is central to all components of the AA1000 series.
Introduction
Inclusivity can be achieved by adherence to the following three principles:
Materiality:
requires knowing what concerns and is important to you and your stakeholders.
Completeness:
requires understanding and management of material impacts and associated
stakeholder views, needs, and performance perceptions and expectations.
Responsiveness:
requires coherently responding to stakeholders’ and the organisation’s material
issues.
Th ese principles are not unique to the AA1000 Series and will need to be integrated
with your own language and existing frameworks. For example, Altria developed
their stakeholder engagement process on the basis of these principles, but defi ned
their own principles for stakeholder engagement under the headings involvement,
candor, relevance, learning and action. Th e Global Reporting Initiative’s
Sustainability Reporting Guidelines also use the principle of “inclusiveness” as a key
one in forming the framework of a sustainability report, referring to the systematic
engagement of stakeholders in sustainability report development and improvement.
Th e GRI defi nes the principle of “completeness” diff erently, applied in the context
of reporting, to refer to the scope (in terms of time, issues and organisational entities
covered) of what is included in a report. Th is can again be linked with the abovelisted
principles applied in the context of stakeholder engagement, namely the
challenge to engage with stakeholders on an agenda that is clearly demarcated in
terms of time frame, issues and operational entities covered.
The Accountability Commitment
‘Inclusivity’
Principles
“acknowledging stakeholders right to be heard, and accounting for one’s actions to stakeholders”
Hear that means: The organisation identifi es and addresses the most signifi cant impacts related to
it’s business operations and the stratergy, as well as the stakeholders that organisation identifi es and
sddresses the stakeholders with signifi cant potential to infl uence the organisation.
Materiality Completeness Responsiveness
“Demonstraiting adequate
response”
“Understanding your impact
& what people think of you”
“Knowing what is important
to you and stakeholders”
THE ACCOUNTABILITY COMMITMENT AND PRINCIPLES
THE PRACTITIONER’S HANDBOOK ON STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT | 15
Materiality
Completeness
Responsiveness
Think Strategically Analyse and Plan Strengthen Capacities Engage with Stakeholders Act and Review
In the context of this manual, these three principles are understood to relate to the
key questions that people (both inside and outside of the organisation) will ask you
when considering your relationships and engagement with stakeholders:
- Firstly “Is it genuine?” Are you just going through the motions of consultation
for public relations purposes, or are you serious about getting a complete and
balanced picture of your organisation’s material impacts? - Secondly “Is it fair and well informed?” Does the process of engagement allow
all stakeholders to be considered or are signifi cantly impacted stakeholders
ignored? Are internal and external processes in place that enable the organisation
to gain a good understanding of its impacts and what its stakeholders think of it? - And fi nally “What diff erence does it make?” What are you going to do about the
issues raised, how does this impact on other aspects of your performance, and
how does it benefi t your business? Are you willing to make the changes that
are required to integrate possibly new issues into your management processes
and strategy? Also: In which way does this benefi t your business?
Th e handbook will guide you through an approach to stakeholder engagement that
stands fi rm when assessed against these questions. Whilst each of the three principles
applies at each Stage, they have particular relevance at diff erent points in the overall
process. Th e dark cells in the table below indicate which principle is most important
in each Stage. At the beginning of each chapter there is also an interpretation of these
principles as they apply to that Stage.
Introduction
PRINCIPLES AND STANDARDS FOR STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
Stakeholder Engagement Stage
THE RELEVANCE OF MATERIALITY, COMPLETENESS AND RESPONSIVENESS TO THE FIVE STAGES
OF STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
Dominant
Principle
Stage
• Stakeholder map (p25)
Look at all the stakeholders and issues that affect or are affected by your
organisation (or policy decision/project/site business unit etc.)
Work out who the stakeholders are.
Identify and consider strategic engagement risks, opportunities
and objectives.
Identify your strategic objectives, the underlying issues and how
important they seem to different stakeholder groups. Prioritise.
This Stage is crucial to ensuring the identifi cation of material issues and stakeholders:
Have you identifi ed which issues and stakeholders appear to be most important for
long-term success and sustainability?
To identify the strategic priorities for stakeholder engagement in your organisation.
STAGE 1
Think Strategically
Aim
Principles
Key Steps Methodology
& Template
Tools and Resources
• Benefi ts of engagement (p9, p30)
• 5-part materiality test (p35)
• 4 stages of issue maturity (p41)
• Stakeholder infl uence and dependency
matrix (p43)
M2 – T2(p34)
M1 – T1(p25)
M3 – T3(p38)
M4 – T4(p46)
• Changing drivers of engagement (p29)
This Stage is crucial to developing your understanding of the materiality of issues and
stakeholders and to allow for completeness in addressing them:
Do you understand the issues and stakeholders enough to design an enagement process
that really adresses stakeholder expectations and robust?
To build up a basis of knowledge about the organisation and its stakeholders in order to
prioritise further and develop a plan for engagement.
Increase your understanding of the potentially material issues and
stakeholders identifi ed as strategic priorities in Stage 1.
• Organisational learning stages (p52)
M6
M5 – T5(p55)
M7
M8 – T8(p69)
Review how these issues are currently managed within your
organisation.
Draw on learning from other organisations and networks about how
best to respond to these issues.
Review the current state of your relationships with these stakeholders.
Build up a profi le of your stakeholders – their expectations, infl uence,
characteristics and preferred approaches to engagement.
Consider what the organisation is and is not able to do in relation to
these issues and expectations.
Develop a strategic engagement plan which lays out which groups of
stakeholders you need to engage with, at what level and what you hope
to achieve.
• Issue / Response Matrix (p53)
• Links into Learning Networks (p59)
• Further Resources (Annex)
• Levels of Engagement (p60)
• Stakeholder Profi le – Key Issues (p66)
M9 – T9(p74)
M10 – T10
(p76)
STAGE 2
Analyse and Plan
Aim
Principles
Key Steps Methodology
& Template
Tools and Resources
PROCESS SUMMARY
THE PRACTITIONER’S HANDBOOK ON STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT | 17
Engage with your stakeholders.
Decide the best way to engage with your stakeholders. • Levels of engagement (p87)
Set up the process of engagement itself:
Design and prepare for the engagement process.
• Common stakeholder
engagement approaches (p109)
M14
M15 – T15
(p116)
(Specifi c
engagement
method
decided
in M14)
• Questions for selecting
engagement methods (p88)
• Practical issues checklist (p110)
• Guidance on when to use
a facilitator (p112)
This Stage is crucial to ensuring materiality, completeness and responsiveness:
Does the engagement processes meet the needs of both organisation and it’s
stakeholders?
To plan and effectively carry out engagement activities with stakeholders.
STAGE 4
Design the Process and Engage with Stakeholders
Aim
Principles
Key Steps Methodology
& Template
Tools and Resources
Introduction
PROCESS SUMMARY
This Stage is crucial to ensuring that your organisation is able to understand (completeness)
and respond (responsiveness) in a coherent manner:
Does your organisation have the capacity to understand the issues, engage effectively
and act on that engagement?
Develop and carry out plan to strengthen the capacities needed to
engage effectively.
Consider the capacities and practical issues of your stakeholders
and identify ways to address these.
Consider the individual skills and capacities needed for
engagement and identify areas for improvement.
Consider the strength of your organisational systems and
identify gaps.
• Organisational learning stages (p52)
Look at your own organisation as well as your Stakeholders:
• Stakeholder Engagement
skills and characteristics map (p87)
• Obstacles to participation (p91)
M12-T12(p89)
M11-T11(p85)
M13
M11, M12, M13,
T11(p85)
T12(p89)
• Strengthening enablers (p82)
To develop the individual skills and organisational sysytems needed to engage effectively
with stakeholders.
STAGE 3
Strengthen Capacities for Engagement
Aim
Principles
Key Steps Methodology
& Template
Tools and Resources
THE PRACTITIONER’S HANDBOOK ON STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT | 19
Put learning into action.
Review the process itself to improve future management.
Report back to stakeholders.
Develop a plan of action. • SMART Targets (p122)
Looking at the results of the engagement process:
• AA1000 Assurance Standard
Checklist (p128)
• Thinking about assurance (p131)
M17
M16 – T16
M18 – T18
(p133)
M16, M17, M18
• Impacts of reporting framework (p126)
To translate new learning, insights and agreements into action.
STAGE 5
Act, Review and Report
Aim
Principles
Key Steps Methodology
& Template
Tools and Resources
This Stage is crucial to ensuring that you respond adequately (responsiveness) and
for validating your understanding of the materiality of issues:
Are you able to respond to, and learn from stakeholders’ concerns and opinions?
Defi ne overall scope
The process outlined in this handbook can be
applied at a number of levels. Specify how you
intend to use it in this instance:
To cover the entire company
To focus on a single business line
(or business unit or department):
To focus on a specifi c program, initiative
or product:
Secure overall organisational commitment
to stakeholder engagement at this level.
You need to have basic commitment to the idea
of stakeholder engagement before embarking
on the process. This commitment will need to be
revisited throughout the process as the
particular costs, benefi ts and demands of the
engagement process become clearer.
Develop an understanding of the principles
of materiality, completeness and
responsiveness, how these relate to
stakeholder engagement and to your own
organisational values.
Do you understand these principles?
How do they differ from or relate to your
organisation’s guiding principles and
working practices?
How can they best be communicated and
applied in your context?
Assemble a cross functional group of
relevant people from within the organisation
and outside.
Stakeholder engagement should ideally begin
with a process of internal learning and
engagement. Those who have knowledge about
the organisation, the issues of concern or the
stakeholder groups involved as well as those in
charge of putting insights and agreements into
action need to be involved in the process at each
step. Start by identifying these people – the list
may change and grow throughout the process.
It might include company insiders from the
strategic planning, the legal department, risk
management, external communications,
operations, marketing, EHS, HR or investor
relations. It could also include external
consultants or stakeholders you already engage
with. At many stages you will need to gather
information and initiate discussion with these
people through interviews, workshops or
meetings as well as involving or keeping them
informed of the engagement process itself. You
may also want to formally convene a group to
steer the process.
Consider how you will keep track of
information.
The process outlined in this handbook has
the potential of generating a mass of information
– fi rst about general categories such as
stakeholders and issues, and later about
specifi c stakeholders, information sources,
benchmarks and viewpoints.
You will need a robust mechanism for organising
this information both in order to make it useful
and available to stakeholders and managers
and to enable external assurance of the process
if necessary.
Each Stage includes a number of summary
templates which provide useful means to record
outputs at key stages in the process. You may
also want to develop a database to track
individual stakeholder contact details
and concerns.
BEFORE YOU START
Introduction
Before you start
STAGE 1
Think strategically about engagement
STAGE 1
PURPOSE
Th e aim of this fi rst Stage is to identify your reasons for stakeholder engagement
and the key stakeholder groups and issues that relate to your organisation. Th is
will provide a basis for ensuring that stakeholder engagement informs and
becomes part of your business strategy.
It is important not to jump directly into engagement but to think strategically
fi rst: Why do you and your stakeholders want to engage? Who do you need to
engage with? About what issues? What do you want to achieve, and how will you
know if you are successful?
PRINCIPLES
Th e key principle at this Stage is materiality.
‘Inclusivity’
Principles
“acknowledging stakeholders right to be heard, and accounting for one’s actions to stakeholders’”
Here that means: The organisation identifi es and addresses the most material impacts related
to it’s business operations and the stratergy, as well as the stakeholders that are subject to these
impacts. Futhermore, the organisation identifi es and addresses the stakeholders with signifi cant
potential to infl uence the organisation.
Materiality Completeness Responsiveness
Think Strategically
THE PRACTITIONER’S HANDBOOK ON STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT | 21
PROCESS
Th e actions and tools outlined in this Stage are based on three linked questions
which need to be answered in order to align your stakeholder engagement
processes with your organisation’s strategic objectives.
You do not have to work through this Stage in the order presented in this
chapter – where you start will depend on your own context, and on whether you
are already engaging or are a newcomer. Th e four examples below highlight the
routes taken by four diff erent organisations each starting from a diff erent point.
Th ink Strategically
Branded sportswear company
Why? We need to respond to
criticisms and campaigns,
which are damaging our
reputation.
What issue? Labour standards
in our supply chains.
Who? Which NGOs and other
groups can we work with
constructively?
Global retailer
Who? Potential new customers,
staff and communities in
emerging markets.
Why? To understand them
and their social and cultural
expectations.
What issues? Identify issues
considered important by
stakeholder groups.
Industry association
Why? To develop and gain
support for sector level
sustainability strategy.
Who? Member companies and
wider stakeholders.
What issues? Identify issues
and challenges relevant to
sector sustainability with
stakeholders.
Cement manufacturer
What issue?
Where should we site a new
factory?
Why? Engage with local
community to help identify
issues related to different sites
and reduce risk of planning
permission being blocked.
Who? Local groups and
individuals.
Example sequences in approaching stakeholder engagement strategically:
STAGE 1. THINK STRATEGICALLY.
Why
engage?
Who to
engage with
What to
engage about
Strategic
Alignment
Stage 1
Think
Strategically
STAGE 1
Th e process outlined in this Stage is for developing a comprehensive overview of
material issues and relevant stakeholder groups. Th is does not necessarily need
to be undertaken at the start of every individual engagement process. Often you
need to react fl exibly and swiftly to a specifi c stakeholder group or issue, which
arises unexpectedly. However, an understanding of the materiality of the issue is
always important in guiding your responses. A strategic approach to stakeholder
engagement ensures that your organisation is able to understand and respond to
the full range of material issues and challenges facing it, not just lurch from crisis
to crisis.
Th e full process outlined here aims to provide a comprehensive and forward
looking pre-assessment that helps companies to gain an overview and an
understanding of the relative importance of the key issues and stakeholder groups
that it should endeavour to address. A company does not necessarily have to go
through the whole process, but it should ensure that it has answers for the most
important questions:
– Who are it’s stakeholders?
– Which are the most important objectives that stakeholder engagement should
help us and others to achieve?
– What is the societal Stage of maturity of the key issues that the company needs
to address? [see p40 for further discussion on issue maturity].
Telefónica Partners with Main Representative Association of Disabled People
As part of it’s wider Telefónica Accessible initiative, the telecommunications company has formed a partnership with CERMI, Spain’s
largest organisation of disabled people, representing 3.5 million disabled people and their families. This collaboration enables it to fully
understand their needs and expectancies, while helping Telefónica to learn from and innovate for the benefi t of disabled people, and
ensuring the suitability of developed products and helping in the anticipation of future regulatory developments regarding accessibility.
The post PRINCIPLES AND STANDARDS FOR STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT appeared first on My Assignment Online.