Introduction: The relationship between high or low morale in employees and the productivity or standard of work, can positively or negatively affect any organisation (Day, Minichiello, & Madison, 2006). This relationship is of particular importance within the healthcare setting due to professional standards directly affecting patient health outcomes. As Totman et al. (2011) argue, low staff morale in the health care setting has the ability to impact the implementation of improvement practices around patient care and experiences. Therefore, health organisations should invest significant time into understanding what affects staff morale and what strategies can be used to improve it. The definition of morale within the academic realm is heavily interchangeable. For the purpose of this discussion the following definition will be used: Morale is the degree to which an employee exhibits a positive or motivated psychological state. It can manifest itself as pride in the organisation and its goals, faith in its leadership, and a sense of shared purpose with, and loyalty to, others in the organisation (McFadzean & McFazdean, 2005). This paper will review leadership theories and the way in which both past and current leadership theories relate to staff morale in healthcare settings today. A case study will be discussed regarding the recently published report, Child and Adolescent Health Service (CAHS) Review of the morale and engagement of clinical staff at Princess Margaret Hospital (PMH) (Geelhoed, Keenan, Miller, & Munyard, 2017), which outlines significant leadership and employee moral issues at PMH in Perth. Strategies used by organisations to improve staff morale will be presented, along with recommendations for improvement of staff morale at PMH. Leadership Theories: In the text chapter, Leadership: Power and influence (2013), Guy Curtis provides a concise review of the evolution of leadership theories. A worthwhile perspective to consider for the case study analysis is the distinction between leadership and management. Leadership focuses on ‘big-picture’ issues, involves influencing and inspiring others, and guiding goals and directions in the context of tasks, ideas, beliefs and values. Whereas management focuses on administrative, day to day tasks of running the organisation (Curtis, 2013, p. 292). Healthcare, like other large, complex organisations, is comprised of widely diverse employee skill sets ranging from entry level positions, requiring minimal previous training, to highly specialized roles that require high level training and extensive experience. The primary shared goal of a hospital is quality patient care, but the paths to achieve this goal are very different depending on one’s role and, therefore, effective leadership strategies will vary with different situations. Leadership of, and management within, organisations must also be flexible and adaptive to the variety and pace of change (Yukl & Mahsud, 2010), and this necessity is further magnified by the complexities within healthcare institutions. Early leadership theories focused on leadership traits, primarily describing the characteristics that leaders have, including intellectual and personality traits (Curtis, 2013, p. 291). In healthcare, intellectual traits are most prominently demonstrated in technical knowledge and skill. Practitioners who also exhibit personality traits positively associated with leadership, in addition to their clinical expertise, may be more likely to pursue and achieve leadership roles. Curtis (2013) cites the observation, of Simonton (1985), that effective communication between leaders and followers requires that there is not a large gap in levels of intelligence. This assertion would support the hierarchical structure present in hospitals, but does not provide the flexibility required to lead the diverse workforce essential to quality patient care. Other trait theories are similarly inflexible, such as McGregor’s Theory X versus Y, in which human nature is oversimplified to the assumptions that people are either inherently lazy and must be controlled or inherently independent and motivated (Curtis, 2013, p. 293). Later theories explored behaviors of leaders and expanded the context to be less deterministic and more open what may be more adaptable to training and development. These theories also maintain relatively simplified categorizations of task-oriented and people-oriented behaviors, similar to theory X and Y, but provide better understanding of how different styles of leadership lead to outcomes. Yukl and Mahsud (2010) summarized four categories of behaviours leaders engage in as; making decisions, influencing people, communication and building relationships (Curtis, 2013, p. 298). Leadership theories evolved to address additional factors including the situations in which leaders are performing and how other influencing factors impact effectiveness. Peter Northouse (2016, pp. 43-46) describes the skills approach, initiated by Robert Katz in 1955, which identifies basic technical, people, and conceptual thinking skills that provide a foundation to accomplish goals and outcomes. Katz’s skills approach was elaborated, by Michael Mumford et al. (2000), in the skills-based leadership approach which strives to link knowledge and skills with performance. This approach frames the potential for leadership through both the capabilities that make leadership possible, and the willingness of individuals to develop leadership skills, tackle organizational problems and exert influence (Northouse, 2016, pp. 43-60). The complexity of leadership theories has evolved with the recognition of the multiple facets of leadership that influence outcomes adding evaluation of elements such as thinking styles, conflict resolution, situational effectiveness and ability to influence. The path-goal theory (House & Mitchell, 1975) and expectancy theory of motivation (Vroom, 1964) focus on enhancing performance by focusing on follower motivation, but are highly dependent on characteristics of the follower and the task. Bass and Avolio’s full range theory (Bass, 1999) includes: transformational leadership, transactional leadership and non-leadership (laissez-faire). Transformational leadership is associated with effectiveness and positive outcomes more than transactional leadership and much more than non-leadership. Leaders tap the motives of followers in order to better reach the goals of both leaders and followers (Burns, 1978, p. 18). Leadership is different from power because it is inseparable from followers’ needs (Northouse, 2016, p. 162). Transformational leaders: Motivate others to do more than they intended and often more than they thought possible, have a clearly defined vision and direction, behave to generate admiration and respect, and identify need for change and inspire action (Curtis, 2013, p. 304). Cognitive Experiential Leadership Theory (Cerni, Curtis, & Colmar, 2014) builds on full range theory, and Cognitive-Experiential Theory (Epstein, 2014) which focuses on rational/analytical and experiential/intuitive thinking processes, to provide a multi-dimensional model for contemporary analysis to improve leadership potential and organisational outcomes. Issue/Case study A report, Child and Adolescent Health Service (CAHS) Review of the morale and engagement of clinical staff at Princess Margaret Hospital (PMH) (the Review) was recently published amid concerns raised by medical staff regarding the morale and engagement of staff working within the Princess Margaret Hospital and the effects this may have on providing safe and quality care to its patients (Geelhoed, Keenan, Miller, & Munyard, 2017). The aim of the Review was to make recommendations to the Child and Adolescent Health Service (CAHS) Board with proposed timelines, resources, and actions to be implemented to improve the current situation and address outlined concerns. The Review interviewed more than 200 staff members and found that more than 90% of staff found PMH a “very unhappy place to work” and approximately 10% wanted to resign (Geelhoed, Keenan, Miller, & Munyard, 2017). The purpose of the Review was to assess the concerns raised by staff to organisations such as the Australian Medical Association (AMA) in regards to three areas; 1. Issues relating to the staff morale and clinical engagement of staff at PMH. 2. Culture of the workplace at PMH 3. The Medical administration processes For the purpose of this essay, we will focus only on the issue of staff morale and clinical engagement of staff and the identified contributing factors. The Review identifies factors affecting staff perceptions of low morale associated with ineffective communication and management styles from hospital leaders. According to the Review, the leadership style used by the executive group does not support an atmosphere of trust or effective change theory practice. An atmosphere of trust and supporting employees to engage in shared organisational wide goals is important to shape the working environment (Stone, Russell, & Patterson, 2004). A recurrent theme in the Review was the perception of an autocratic approach throughout the hospital which has been the catalyst for disengagement. Carroll (2006) describes an autocratic leader as someone “who makes decisions and expects subordinates to obey. The leader uses his or her power to command others and to control them”. Welford (2002) would argue that this style does not work well in the environment where there is a significant interdependence between the executive and employee. Oliver (2006)also agrees, as this is true when the organisation relies on the role modelling within this group to manage effective change. The lack of collaboration and requests for information from clinicians directly involved in changes to service and delivery provoked further disengagement of staff (Geelhoed, Keenan, Miller, & Munyard, 2017). This style is in contrast to Golden’s (2006) belief, who describes the need to maintain credibility and request information from the group to show respect is essential to gain support from clinicians. The ability to effectively communicate is considered an essential component when referring to a ‘good leader’. The leader needs to engage and influence behaviour to promote motivational behaviour with organisation, on an individual or larger scale perspective. This is done largely through a variety of communication techniques (Spurgeon, Long, Clark, & Daly, 2015). This is supported by Totman et al. (2011) who describe trust and loyalty as key factors in establishing good working relationships between teams. They also explore the need to allow staff to have their ideas heard in the wider organization and the subsequent link promoting staff morale. Surprisingly the Review describes no effects on quality of care delivery despite the significant issues within the workforce. The findings of McPherson (2008) support that this is possible as he states that there is no direct relationship with levels of morale relating to doing a good job for a service, as within the clinical group, the commitment is to the individual patient and not the organisation. This finding is supported in the Review (2017), noting many employees interviewed stated they still enjoyed the specific job they did despite the organisation they worked within. The Review describes that fear of retribution was present at varying degrees, even from those who were considered engaged champions for the organisation. Leaders who demonstrate punitive behaviour or lack appropriate leadership skills are traits that lead to poor leadership perception and cause increased employee stress (Kelloway, Sivanathan, Francis, & Barling, 2005). Lowe (2012) and Sherwood (2013) found that absenteeism, staff turnover, and productivity were significantly impacted when employees were disengaged. In areas of positive workplace culture, this was a stark contrast with improved performance, reduced absenteeism and a no blame culture as well as an inclusive environment raised positive perception of management and an increase in the ability to speak up and safety culture (Cameron, Mora, Deutscher, & Calarco, 2011). In the Review, the executive had a clear vision and strategic plan for PMH, but none of the staff interviewed were able to state what this was. There was a general feeling that too many things were happening at once, and if there was a step by step approach they weren’t aware of it (Geelhoed, Keenan, Miller, & Munyard, 2017). McPherson (2008) believed factors effecting morale were the quality of the leadership and the level of ‘people-skills’ held by line managers. Glickman et al (2007) discuss that it is clear that health care organisations must invest in frameworks that focus on leadership skills and manager abilities as they directly and indirectly affect quality of care due to the impact on the workforce culture. In a positive move, recent frameworks and programs that focus on improving manager and leadership skills for throughout all the levels of management, from the executive level down to Nurse Unit managers are being actively adopted across WA Health. To ensure the delivery of quality health care, it is essential to keep the morale and motivation of the hospital employees at high levels as it affects the employees desire to do the work both directly or indirectly and is associated with success in people’s life. The most important factor which negatively affects employees in the organization is taking decisions on issues related to their work without their involvement. It has been observed that morale has influence on the activities related result of any business. However, it is not true that low morale will have negative effect on the productivity. If the individual is willing and have high morale, the achievement of objectives of an organization will be guaranteed with employees’ useful and decisive contribution. There are various ways to raise employees’ morale in an organization. ? Rewarding employees for their performance beyond expectations ? Empowerment of employees ? Listening and resolving the complaints ? Addressing emotional needs ? Creating appreciation spirit ? Broadcasting work enthusiasm ? Not conducting them reminding they are just workers ? Having group focus instead of company focus Strategies: Coaching: Predominantly Nurse Managers enter leadership roles by progressing their career through clinical channels. They have refined skillsets and knowledge pertaining to patient needs and medical systems which they have acquired through experience and detailed training. Sound clinical skills, however, do not necessarily translate to motivational leadership skills. Coaching or mentoring provides leaders with the tools and resources required to confidently and positively manage subordinates. As outlined by the International Council of Nurses (2010) leadership skills are crucial to inspiring staff motivation, and as such, the provision of formal coaching should be regarded as a necessity rather than a luxury. Coaching leaders to become aware of their own management styles and strengths enables the manager to continually improve their practice (Stapleton, et al., 2007). Relationship building: Strong relationships between managers and clinical staff are not only essential for the development of trust; they also foster an environment that is supportive of ongoing education and up skilling of staff. Furthermore, it has been identified by that positive relationship building is the number one factor for successful motivation of staff by leaders within the health industry (Stapleton, et al., 2007). Supportive role modelling: Role modeling has a significant impact on the way in which staff members behave professionally. According to Goleman (2002), the ability of the leader to act in a way that provokes excellence in others has a direct result on team motivation and morale, which is far more effective than direct instruction around behavioral expectations (McFadzean & McFazdean, 2005). Communication: Effective verbal and written communication strategies such as formal and informal debriefing, multidisciplinary meetings and regular team meetings can enable nurses to feel like valued members of the team (McFadzean & McFazdean, 2005). They are most effective when conducted at all levels of the organisation and are structured in such a way that allows for two-way contributions. Feedback and Praise: Many components of morale and motivation are heavily entwined with self-worth (McFadzean & McFazdean, 2005), with leaders having the ability to foster confidence through constructive feedback and praise. In contemporary healthcare settings managers often recognize that staff appraisal is not purely about outlining areas in need of improvement by the subordinate, but also about mutually identifying areas in which the individual would like to develop or grow professionally (Day, Minichiello, & Madison, 2006). Recommendations: Since the publication of the deeply critical report on staff morale levels at PMH, changes have started to become apparent, such as the highly publicized resignation of PMH’s CEO. This paper recommends that such leadership redesigning – shifting away from autocratic leadership styles – continues. The implementation of regular team building activities, especially when conducted within work hours, would allow for relationship building between leaders and subordinates and should be followed up with employee involvement in setting short and long term team goals. Current and future leaders of PMH would benefit enormously from formal managerial coaching and mentoring, with established techniques in reflecting on their leadership and motivational styles. The improvement of transparency and communication across all levels of staff and management at PMH should be an ongoing process, as well as implementing active engagement practices. Two-way feedback structures that allow for lower level staff to appraise management practices, without fear of retribution, could be incorporated as one of PMH’s engagement tools. Formal and informal methods of praising staff for their achievements as well as for their efforts, even when goals are not met, is a recommendation of this paper as it would have the capacity to boost feelings of selfworth among members of the team and thus boost motivation. Regular task alignment reviews would reduce the risk of employees acting in roles that are either below or above their capabilities as well as alleviating situations in which staff become bored with their work tasks. Finally, this paper recommends that assessment of staff morale continues. With the new Perth Children’s Hospital nearing completion, a multitude of changes are on the horizon for PMH employees. In order to improve staff morale, employees must feel as though they have been heard and that processes are in place to improve their work environment. Conclusion: This paper provided a discussion on leadership theories and strategies by using a recently published report on Princess Margaret Hospital as a case study. The report identified low morale and engagement of staff within the hospital, which was attributed to autocratic leadership, lack of collaboration between leaders and employees and consultation among employees. As outlined in the case study, leadership styles at PMH reflected inability to positively influence the working environment and showed a lack of trust and support in employees. This was particularly lacking in the area of fulfilling shared goals, leading to high levels of stress among staff. The report showed that even though this was evident, no ill effects were noted in relation to patient care. Strategies used at boosting staff morale were discussed, including the importance of formal leadership training of current and future leaders of PMH, strong emphasis on relationship building, supportive role modelling and effective communication. Regular formal and informal feedback and praise was highlighted as a strategy that PMH would benefit highly from. As a result of research into leadership theories, a case study of the PMH report, and a review of strategies used for boosting staff morale in healthcare settings, this paper presented several recommendations in relation to the improvement of staff morale and engagement at PMH. Along with these recommendations it is noted that ongoing assessment of staff morale at PMH and feedback from staff – without fear of retribution – could not be overstressed. References Bass, B. (1999). Two Decades of Research and Development in Transformational Leadership. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 8(1), 9-32. Burns, J. M. (1978). Leadership. New York: Harper and Row. Cameron, K., Mora, C., Deutscher, T., & Calarco, M. (2011). Effects of positive practices on Organizational effectiveness. Journal of Applied Behavioural Science, 47(3), 266-308. Carroll, P. (2006). Nursing Leadership and Management, a Practical Guide (1st ed. ed.). New York: Delmar Cengage Learning. Cerni, T., Curtis, G. J., & Colmar, S. H. (2014). Cognitive-Experiential Leadership Model: How leaders’ information-processing systems can influence leadership styles, influencing tactics, conflict management, and organizational outcomes. Journal of Leadership Studies, 8(3), 26- 39. Clark, J. H., & Nath, V. (2014). Medical engagement, a journey not an event. UK: The Kings Fund. Curtis, G. J. (2013). Leadership: power and influence. In A. Sarris, & N. Kirby, Organisational psycholog; research and professional practice (1st ed., pp. 289-316). Tilde Publishing and Distribution. Day, G., Minichiello, V., & Madison, J. (2006, Nov). Nursing Morale: what does the literature reveal. Australian Health Review, 30(4), 516-524. Epstein, S. (2014). Cognitive-Experiential Theory: An integrative theory of personality. New York: Oxford University Press. Geelhoed, G., Keenan, J., Miller, S., & Munyard, G. (2017). Child and Adolescent Health Service (CAHS) Review of the morale and engagement of clinical staff at Princess Margaret Hospital (PMH). Report to the Child and Adolescent Health Service Board, Government of Western Australia Department of Health. Retrieved July 2017, from http://ww2.health.wa.gov.au/~/media/Files/Corporate/Reports%20and%20publications/PM H/Attachment%20B%20PMH%20Review%20Final%20Report%20Signed.ashx Glickman, S. W., Baggett, K. A., Krubert, C. G., Peterson, E. D., & Schulman, K. A. (2007). Promoting quality: the health-care organisation from a management perspective. Healthcare Quarterly, 19(6), 341-348. Golden, B. (2006). Transforming Healthcare Organisations. Healthcare Quarterly, 10, 10-19. Goleman, D. (2002). The emotional reality of teams. Journal of Organizational Excellence, 21(55). House, R. J., & Mitchell, T. R. (1975). Path-goal theory of leadership. Technical Report TR-75-67, Washington University Seattle, Department of Psychology. Retrieved July 2017, from http://www.dtic.mil/get-tr-doc/pdf?AD=ADA009513 Kelloway, E. K., Sivanathan, N., Francis, L., & Barling, J. (2005). Poor Leadership. In J. Barling, Handbook of work stress (pp. 89-112). Thousand Oaks, CA, USA: Sage Publications. Lowe, G. (2012). How Employee Engagement matters for hospital Performance. Healthcare Quarterly, 15(2), 29-39. McFadzean, F., & McFazdean, E. (2005). Riding the emotional roller-coaster: A framework for improving nursing morale. Journal of Health Organization and Management, 19(4), 318. McPherson, B. (2008). Reasons to be cheerful: Staff morale improves at Lancashire County Council. Resource Management International Digest, 16(6), 10-13. Mumford, M., Zaccaro, S. J., Harding, F. D., Jacobs, T. O., & Fleischman, E. A. (2000). Leadership skills for a changing world: Solving complex social problems. Leadership Quarterly, 11(1), 11-35. Northouse, P. G. (2016). Leadership: Theory and Practice (Seventh Ed. ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage. Nurses, I. C. (2010). Position Statement: Management of nursing and health care services. Retrieved July 2017, from International Council of Nurses: http://www.icn.ch/images/stories/documents/publications/position_statements/A08_Manage ment_Nsg_Health_Care_Services.pdf Oliver, S. (2006). Leadership in Health Care. Musculoskeletal Care, 4(1), 38-47. Ravaghi, H., Mannion, R., & Sajadi, H. S. (2015). Organizational Failure in an NHS Hospital Trust: A Qualitative Study. The Healthcare Manager, 34(4), 367-375. Shamian, J., Spence Laschinger, H. K., & Thomson, D. (2001). Impact of magnet hospital characteristics on nurses perceptions of trust, burnout, quality of care and work satisfaction. Nursing Economics, 19(5), 209-219. Sherwood, R. (2013, October 30). Employee engagement drives health care quality and financial returns. Retrieved from Harvard Business Review: https://hbr.org/2013/10/employeeengagement-drives-health-care-quality-and-financial-returns. Simonton, D. (1985). Intelligence and personal influence in groups: four non-linear models. Psychology Review, 92(4), 532-547. Spurgeon, P., Long, P., Clark, J., & Daly, F. (2015). Do we need medical leadership or medical engagement? Leadership in Health Services, 28(3), 173-184. Stapleton, P., Henderson, A., Creedy, D. K., Cooke, M., Patterson, E., Alexander, H., . . . Dalton, M. (2007). Boosting Morale and Improving Performance in the Nursing Setting. Journal of Nursing Managemen, 15, 811-816. Stone, A., Russell, R., & Patterson, K. (2004). Transformational versus servant. Leadership and Organisational Development, 25(4), 349-351. Totman, J., Lewando Hundt, G., Wearn, E., Paul, M., & Johnson, S. (2011). Factors affecting staff morale on inpatient mental health wards in England: a qualitative investigation. BioMedCentral Psychiatry, 11(68). Vroom, V. H. (1964). Work and Motivation. Malabar, Fla: R.E. Krieger Pub. Co. Welford, C. (2002). Transformational leadership in nursing. Matching theory to practice. Nursing Management, 9(4). Yukl, G., & Mahsud, R. (2010). Why Flexible and Adaptive Leadership is Essential. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 62(2), 81-93.
The post relationship between high or low morale appeared first on My Assignment Online.