SNUG202
Evidence Based Practice
ASSESSMENTS
SCHOOL OF NURSING
FACULTY OF SCIENCE, MEDICINE & HEALTH
2 | SNUG202 EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE
SNUG202 Assessment Details
OVERVIEW
| Assessment Item | Form of Assessment | Due Date | Return/Feedback Due Date |
Weighting |
| Formative Assessment * |
Online Quiz | X | By census date | 0% |
| Assessment 1 | Online quiz | Week 4 (Thursday 26th March, 1700hrs) |
After the quiz has closed. |
20% |
| Assessment 2 | Research Critique | Week 10 (Thursday 14th May, 1700hrs) |
Within 15 working days of the submission date |
40% |
| Assessment 3 | Report and Presentation | Week 14 (Thursday 11th June, 1700hrs) |
Release of results | 40% |
| Total Marks | 100% |
*This formative assessment occurs before semester consensus date and does not contribute to the overall subject mark. It provides
students with an opportunity to seek early feedback to determine if they are on track to meet the learning outcomes of the
subject. The quiz must be completed.
3 | SNUG202 EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE
| Formative | Quiz |
| Due date | Census Date |
| Weighting | 0% |
| Submission | The Quiz will be conducted via the learning management system, Moodle. *This formative assessment occurs before semester consensus date and does not contribute to the overall subject mark. It provides students with an opportunity to seek early feedback to determine if they are on track to meet the learning outcomes of the subject. The quiz must be completed. |
| Type of Collaboration | Individual Assessment |
| Length | 20 questions 30 minutes |
| Details | The quiz will examine the first modules which covers weeks 1- 2. It will consist of both multiple-choice questions. |
| Style and format | Moodle Quiz |
| Subject Learning Outcomes |
1-2 |
| Assessment 1 | Quiz |
| Due date | Week 4 (Thursday 26th March, 1700hrs) Opens at 12 pm on Wednesday 25th March Closes at 5pm on Thursday 26th March The quiz closes strictly at the time noted above; any student who has not attempted and submitted their quiz will receive 0 marks. The quiz will NOT REOPEN, and no alternative assessment will be set without extenuating circumstances and an approved AC. |
| Weighting | 20% |
| Submission | The Quiz will be conducted via the learning management system, Moodle. |
| Type of Collaboration | Individual Assessment |
| Length | 45 mins/40 questions |
| Details | The quiz will examine the first 2 modules which covers weeks 1- 4. It will consist of both multiple choice and short answer questions. |
| Style and format | Moodle Quiz |
| Subject Learning Outcomes |
1-2 |
| Marking Criteria | The quiz will be marked by the Moodle, each answer has only one correct answer and feedback will be provided shortly after the due date. |
4 | SNUG202 EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE
| Assessment 2 | Research Critique |
| Due date | Week 10 (Thursday 14th May, 1700hrs) |
| Weighting | 40% |
| Submission | Your assessments will be submitted into a Turnitin submission box within the SNUG202 Moodle site. You will have the opportunity to review and re-submit your assignment up to the due date and time. To learn more about using Turnitin please access the link: http://www.uow.edu.au/dvca/ltc/tel/resourcehub/students/index.html |
| Type of Collaboration | Individual Assessment |
| Length | 1500 Word Limit |
| Details | You are the RN working on a respiratory ward at a major Sydney Hospital. Your Nursing Unit Manager asks you to prepare a report that recommends a change in practice in relation to the self-management of asthma During your initial search for evidence on the self-management of asthma, you locate the National Asthma Council guidelines. https://www.asthmahandbook.org.au/management/adults/self management/self-management The purpose of this assessment is to critique 2 research articles using the checklist supplied on Moodle. It is recommended that you review the evidence from the above website – however, you can locate other evidence using the UOW databases. Your 2 articles should be related or have commonalities, e.g. both on the best methods of using inhalers. The task includes the following steps: 1. Using the Australian Asthma Handbook or the UOW databases find 2 research articles: 2. Identify the levels of evidence for each article. 3. Critique each research article using the supplied guidelines. (500 words for each article) 4. Select one idea from each of your articles and combine (synthesis) these 2 ideas into a discussion (500 words) about the change in practice in relation to the self-management of asthma you have selected. |
| Subject Learning Outcomes |
2 and 4 |
| Marking Criteria | The marking criteria for this assessment task is available in this guide. |
| Assessment 3 | Report and Pitch Presentation |
| Due date | Week 14 (Thursday 11th June, 1700hrs) |
5 | SNUG202 EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE
| Weighting | Report: 30% Pitch Presentation: 10% |
| Submission | Part A and Part B: Your assessments will be submitted into a Turnitin submission box within the SNUG202 Moodle site. You will have the opportunity to review and re-submit your assignment up to the due date and time. To learn more about using Turnitin please access the link: http://www.uow.edu.au/dvca/ltc/tel/resourcehub/students/index.html For your presentation pitch: Submit to Turnitin a word or PDF document with the following: 1. Your name and student number 2. Subject name and assessment 3. The title of your video 4. The URL link of your video (See ‘How to share your video’ below). How to share your video Upload your video to your own account on Vimeo or YouTube. Include on the submission document the unique URL link for your video. If you do not have a Vimeo or YouTube account or are unsure about how to share your video assessment, watch the following video tutorial: “How to share video assessments through YouTube” https://youtu.be/VEgzD5bMONo . |
| Type of Collaboration | Individual Assessment |
| Length | Part A Report: 2000 words Part B Presentation: 10 minutes |
| Details | This assessment uses and builds on the articles that you used in assessment 2. However, it is expected that you use additional references for this assessment. There are 2 parts to this assessment. Part A Report: You are asked to prepare a report that recommends a change in practice in the self-management of asthma. In your report, you must include a discussion that includes the following points: 1. Describe the practice change – the practice change must be informed by the evidence that you have collected. This evidence can include the articles used in assessment 2 and other articles/evidence you may have found. We suggest a minimum of 5 primary research articles. (800 words) 2. Discuss the need for the change in practice in the self-management of asthma. (400 words) |
6 | SNUG202 EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE
| 3. Reflect on the barriers that might impact or hinder the implementation of your practice change and describe how these barriers maybe overcome or managed. (500 words) As this is a report, you should include an executive summary (150 words); this is placed at the start of your report. References, headings and incidentals (150 words). An introduction/conclusion is not required. Part B: Pitch Presentation: Prepare a 10-minute pitch that will be used to convince the ward staff of the need to change their practice. Your ‘pitch’ will be uploaded as a verbal presentation. Your pitch can be delivered in any way that conveys your ideas but should summarise the practice change and why this is important. You may use voice over PowerPoint or use a combination of speaking directly to the camera with images, music or other creative video production techniques. You may use any video software e.g. iMovie or Windows Movie Maker. There are also free online video editing websites. References are not required for the pitch presentation. |
|
| Subject Learning Outcomes |
1-5 |
| Marking Criteria | The marking criteria for this assessment task is available in this guide. |
Assessment 2 Rubric – Research Critique
Please note: When using this rubric, you must fulfil all the lower criteria before being awarded a higher grade.
| Criteria | Fail | Pass | Credit | Distinction | High Distinction |
| Evidence selection and level of evidence | |||||
| Uses appropriate primary research and classifies each piece of evidence accurately |
Inaccurately classifies the evidence as per the levels of evidence. Does not use primary research. |
Classifies one piece of evidence as per the levels of evidence accurately. Uses one primary research article. |
Classifies one piece of evidence as per the levels of evidence accurately. Uses two primary research articles. |
Accurately classifies both pieces of evidence according to type and level of evidence. Uses two primary research articles from credible sources. |
Uses high quality primary research articles that relate to self-management of asthma. |
| Critique | |||||
| There is concise and clear critique that addresses the components of a research critique. |
The arrangement of content is haphazard and difficult to follow. There is no evidence of critique or analysis. |
Some evidence of analytical and evaluative skills, but the writing largely describes the key ideas.. The checklist is used as a framework for the critique. |
Well-reasoned argument using the evidence. Evidence of analytical and evaluative skills. The overall arrangement is logical but is occasionally difficult to flow. |
Clear evidence of analytical and evaluative skills. The reader is guided smoothly through the logically arranged paper. |
Demonstrates imagination and independent thought. There is evidence of highly developed analytical and evaluative skills. |
| Synthesis | |||||
| There is integrated evaluation and discussion of the concepts. |
There is no synthesis of ideas. | There is minimal synthesis with disjointed ideas. |
The synthesis is collated and summarised but is mostly a descriptive. |
The synthesis is well integrated and provides a comprehensive discussion as to the strengths and weaknesses of the effectiveness of the evidence; |
The synthesis is advanced, integrated and comprehensive; The analysis is clear and precise, identifying competing points of view. |
| Academic Writing – 10% | |||||
| Uses correct spelling and paragraph structure throughout. Structured as per UOW assessment Handbook |
Language hinders the effective flow of ideas & meaning. Sentences lack structure & are consistently too short or too long. Multiple errors in spelling, grammar and style. Not structured as per UOW Assessment Handbook. |
Adequate communication of information. Attempts to use paragraphs. Some sentences may be too long/short. Meets almost all style requirements including spacing, page numbers, font, headings. |
Evidence of sound academic writing. Paragraphs are 5-7 sentences in length and sentences are clear & concise. Minor errors only in syntax, spelling & grammar. Meets all style requirements. |
Evidence of superior academic writing skills. Correct use of paragraphs. Discussion in each paragraph provides sufficient depth to demonstrate understanding. Superior spelling, grammar, & syntax < 5 minor errors. Meets all style requirements. |
Outstanding academic writing. Introductory sentence used at the start of paragraphs. Main subject matter is developed within each paragraph. Concluding sentence used at the end of paragraphs. Exemplary spelling, grammar & syntax with no errors. Meets all style requirements. |
| References – 10% | |||||
| Uses APA style. Both in-text referencing and reference list included. |
Absent in-text referencing or reference list. Reference list & in text referencing has major errors. |
Attempts to use APA style. Some errors in reference list & in-text. References included in reference list not in-text & vice-versa. |
Complies with referencing style requirements. Some referencing errors in in-text or referencing list. |
APA referencing style is consistently accurate. Less than 5 minor referencing errors. |
Complies with all the referencing style requirements. There are no errors in referencing throughout. |
Assessment 3a Rubric – Report
Please note: When using this rubric, you must fulfil all the lower criteria before being awarded a higher grade.
| Criteria | Fail | Pass | Credit | Distinction | High Distinction |
| Knowledge (70%) | |||||
| The practice change is underpinned by evidence that is appropriate and of good quality (30%) |
Does not outline a practice change. Uses poor quality or only secondary sources |
Outlines a practice change that is supported by minimal quality evidence or relies on secondary sources |
Outlines a clear practice change that is supported by good quality evidence. Uses at least 5 primary research articles and describes the level of evidence |
Clear articulation of a practice change that is supported by good quality evidence, which includes a description of the levels of evidence and synthesized clinical expertise |
Sophisticated articulation of practice change that is supported by a broad range of evidence (plus levels of evidence) and synthesized clinical expertise |
| The need for the practice change is discussed with reference to appropriate and evidence that is of good quality and is linked to person centred outcomes (15%) |
Does not describe why the practice change is needed |
Describes why the practice change is needed using limited evidence Links this practice change to person centred outcomes |
Provides a sound argument for why the practice change is needed, incorporating quality evidence Links this practice change to person centred outcomes |
Provides a superior argument for why the practice change is needed, incorporating a broad range of quality evidence |
Provides a sophisticated argument for why the practice change is needed, incorporating a broad range of quality evidence |
| Use of a reflection process and literature to describe the barriers to EBP implementation (10%) |
No reflection or understanding of the barriers and how these might impact practice change. |
Descriptive, rather than reflective, minimal discussion as to how barriers might impact practice change. Limited use of the other literature. |
Uses a reflective framework and the literature to form a judgement on the impact of barriers on practice change. |
Recognises and discusses the complexity of EBP implementation, |
Critically reflects on the analysed literature and makes a judgement on the impact as to how these might impact practice change |
| Targeted recommendations are described to manage or overcome the barriers (15%) |
Recommendations are not provided or targeted at identified barriers |
Recommendations are provided but are generic in nature or not supported by evidence of effectiveness for identified barriers. |
Recommendations are provided which target identified barriers and are supported by evidence |
Evidence of effectiveness in self management of asthma is included |
Insightful recommendations are provided demonstrating a strong knowledge of barriers |
| Writing – 10% | |||||
| Uses correct spelling and paragraph structure throughout. Structured as per UOW assessment Handbook |
Poor writing style hinders the effective flow of ideas & meaning. Multiple errors in spelling, grammar and style. |
Adequate communication of information. Meets suggested word count. |
Evidence of sound writing. Minor errors only in spelling & grammar. Meets all style requirements. |
Evidence of superior writing skills. Superior spelling, grammar, & syntax < 5 minor errors. Meets all style requirements. |
Outstanding writing. Exemplary spelling and grammar & syntax with no errors. Meets all style requirements. |
| Evidence & Referencing – 20% | |||||
| Uses APA style. Both in-text referencing and reference list included. |
No sources used. Includes minimal or mostly secondary sources or websites. No integration of sources. No reference list or the reference list has major errors. |
Includes primary and secondary sources. Attempts have been made to use APA for referencing. Some errors in referencing list. |
Includes mostly primary sources. Some integration of sources within the argument. Few minor errors in the reference list. |
Includes a selection of primary sources. Complies with all the referencing style requirements. There are a few reference list errors. |
Includes a wide variety of primary sources. Complies with all the referencing style requirements. |
Assessment 3b – Pitch Presentation
| Criteria | Fail | Pass | Credit | Distinction | High Distinction |
| Content (50%) | |||||
| The video presentation conveys knowledge of the practice change and the reason why this change is important. |
The message is unclear and repetitive and missing the depth of discussion. |
There is discussion that includes the practice change which is somewhat relevant but the key points and the reason for the change are limited. |
Clear discussion with demonstrates of understanding and awareness of the practice change. The rationale is clearly articulated and well linked to the change in practice. |
There is a deep awareness of the need for change is conveyed |
Demonstrates insight and awareness of the more subtle aspects of the practice change and why this needed. |
| Production (50%) | |||||
| The video is well structured and creative with clear easily understand audio |
Lacks authenticity and is difficult for an audience to understand. Audio and visuals are unclear |
Authentic video that may lack creativity. Video is structured but not particularly well sign posted. Visuals and audio are not always clear. |
Authentic video that demonstrates some degree of creativity. Video is structured but not particularly well sign posted. Visuals and audio are clear. |
Authentic and very creative video. Video is well structured and timed with clear segments. Visuals and audio are clear. |
Exemplary video with very high levels of authenticity and creativity. Video is well structured and timed with clear segments and headings. Visuals and audio are clear. |
The post SNUG202 Evidence Based Practice appeared first on My Assignment Online.