La Trobe University
Statutory Interpretation
Child Employment Act Problem
Examiner’s Solution
(590 words)
Note to students
The Evaluation below is quite advanced and at an A+ level. An A- answer would be expected to have a much briefer evaluation.
Answer in Brief
Should Sam be charged with a breach of s 12(1) of the Child Employment Act 2003 (Vic), he should plead not guilty.
Unit of inquiry
Section 12(1)(b) of the Child Employment Act 2003 (Vic). The critical words are ‘fishing boat’.
Alternative constructions
Inspector: a person falls within s 12(1)(b) as long as the child is employed on a boat fitted out for, or capable of, fishing, regardless of the use of boat at the time.
Defence: s 12(1)(b) denotes being employed on a fishing boat only while it is being used as a fishing boat.
Arguments for prosecution construction
Provision Literal reading of ‘on a fishing boat’.
Provision (Alternative words)If Parliament had wanted to prohibit a fishing boat used as such it could have said so.
Wider context (Adverse consequences)The narrow construction urged by the defence would make enforcement of the law more difficult.
Wider context (Consequences) The literal construction does not have irrational consequences: prohibiting employment on a fishing boat could reduce the risk the boat could be used for fishing.
Arguments for defence construction
Provision Textual indications are:
- ‘inland waters’ in 12(1)(b): as there is no great danger in fishing in inland waters, this suggests that what is being prohibited is not all activities in a boat fitted out for fishing, but risky activities which are carried out in a boat used for fishing.
- ‘operating’ suggests operating as a fishing boat.
Act (Noscitur a sociis): the specified prohibited kinds of employment in s 12(1)(a) and (c) are all dangerous or involve considerable threats in the normal course. This suggests, it might be argued, that Parliament wished to declare what are dangerous, and hence prohibited, forms of employment.
Legislative history The Minister’s second reading speech refers to ‘working … in deep sea fishing’,1 which suggests the mischief is the danger of a boat operating as a fishing boat.
Re proposed s 12(1), see the comment that what the Parliament had in mind was preventing a risk that was ‘such a risk to children’.2
Legislative history The Explanatory Memorandum to the Child Employment Bill 2003 (Vic) states:
Clause 12 makes it an offence to employ a child in—
…
• deep-sea fishing;3
Wider context Theodd consequence of the prosecutor’s construction: it singles out a boat fitted out as a fishing boat. But why is a boat that happens to be fitted out as a fishing boat more dangerous than say any other boat?
Evaluation and Conclusion
The defence construction of the unit of inquiry is stronger because:
- The literal argument from ‘on a fishing boat’ — it is valid, but is overwhelmed by the contextual arguments raised by the defence.
- The alternative words argument — it is weak, as it is apparent from the immediate context that the legislature is aiming at boats used for fishing. In other words, no alternative words were necessary.
- The argument from purpose — it is a mere supposition and is therefore extremely weak. The argument is outweighed by the purposive arguments based on the provision and to a lesser extent the extrinsic parliamentary materials, especially the Explanatory Memorandum and Minister’s second reading speech.
- The argument from the wider context — it is weak. The narrow (defence) construction would merely have the consequence that particular evidence of use must be found. The narrow construction is still workable. There is no requirement that a court should prefer a construction merely because enforcement would be easier.
Note to students regarding the purpose of s 12
The purpose of the section may be gleaned from a number of indications from the Act as a whole, the legislative history and wider context. The strongest indication is from ss 20 and 23 (see below).
It would not be a strong answer (and may be a weak answer) to take either of the following alone as indications of the purpose of the section:
- The other paragraphs in 12(1)(a) and (c). This is because, first, they are only examples of prohibited activity. It is also because they give a misleading view of the purpose of s 12, read in context of the whole Act (see indications from Act as a whole, below).
- The Minister’s second reading speech’s reference to ‘such a risk’, which suggests an obvious or high risk to children. This is a very weak indication of legislative purpose. A second reading speech cannot alone be a source of legislative purpose as the purpose must reside in the text and structure of the legislation: Lacey: Week 4 lecture slides:
‘The application of the rules will properly involve the identification of a statutory purpose, which may appear from an express statement in the relevant statute, by inference from its terms and by appropriate reference to extrinsic materials. The purpose of a statute is not something which exists outside the statute. It resides in its text and structure, albeit it may be identified by reference to common law and statutory rules of construction.’ (Lacey v A-G (Qld) (2011) 242 CLR 573 at 592 [44]; [2011] HCA 10 per French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel And Bell JJ.)
Compare ss 20 and 23: these make it clear that a child may only be employed in ‘light work’ (defined in s 5). It is an offence to employ a person in employment that is not light work: s 23(1) (penalty 100/60 penalty units: same as for s 12). This suggests that the purpose of s 12 is to put beyond doubt that particular kinds of employment are not light work, particularly for employment in family businesses which are not administratively vetted by the employer having to apply for a permit: s 24. In other words, as the employment that is prohibited by s 12 is already prohibited by ss 20 and 23, the scope and purpose of s 12 is merely declaratory. Further, it suggests that the purpose is to put beyond doubt particular kinds of employment that are not light work. If I am right, this declaratory purpose tends to be a neutral indication in the context of the present problem.
1 Victoria, Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 9 April 2003, 947 (Mr Hulls).
2 Ibid.
3 Child Employment Bill 2003 (Vic), Explanatory Memorandum, 2.
The post Statutory Interpretation appeared first on My Assignment Online.