Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

Strategy, Valuation, and Deal Structure

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length4,120 words
  • Reading time18 min
Write My Assignment FREE
ENTREPRENEURIAL FINANCE: Strategy, Valuation, and Deal Structure
Case Study
EF 10-1

ConnectedHome, Inc. (A)1
The CEO of ConnectedHome, Inc., recently received an invitation to make a
presentation to Black Oak Partners, a venture capital group in Palo Alto that has
successfully raised $125 million in capital commitments for Black Oak Fund I, a new
venture capital fund it is organizing. The principals of Black Oak Partners are former
entrepreneurs of successful Internet-related technology ventures, who now want to try
their hand at forming and managing a venture capital fund. ConnectedHome is a directmail and Internet marketer of home improvement and home electronics products.
During the presentation, ConnectedHome’s CEO had an opportunity to discuss
the company’s historical development and the perceived opportunity the venture was
designed to address. ConnectedHome originated as a mail order business specializing in
electronic products with applications to household management. For example, the
company offers sophisticated home security systems that can be activated and monitored
by phone. It also offers systems that provide remote ability to adjust lighting and
heating. The list of products offered by the company has expanded gradually over time
and includes several items that have been developed specifically for it. ConnectedHome
has been in operation for several years and has a history of revenue generation and
modest profitability from its mail order business. More recently, the management team
has recognized that there is a significant opportunity to develop an Internet presence for
the business. Operations during the most recent year reflect a significant revenue
increase, but the increase is more than offset by expenses associated with developing a
web site.
During the meeting, the company CEO was able to discuss management’s
projections for future sales and profitability, the amount of funding they hoped to raise,
and their beliefs about the value of the opportunity. The Black Oak representatives at the
meeting had already received and reviewed the business plan, which included the
company’s revenue and earning projections. Exhibit 1 contains a summary of the
projections that were included in the business plan.2
Based on the projections, ConnectedHome was seeking $7 million in financing,
enough, they believed, to get them through the next fiscal year. Based on the projections,
company management was proposing to offer Black Oak a 16.7 percent share of the
company, implying a post-money valuation of $42 million.
The ensuing discussion was demoralizing. It seemed that the investors, while
they liked some aspects of the concept and agreed about the amount of capital that
currently was needed, were not particularly impressed with the company’s projections
and raised serious questions about the terms for investing that the CEO had proposed.
More specifically, Black Oak challenged the company’s mixed mail-order and Internet
strategy, its growth projections, and its implicit valuation. In addition, they pointed out
1 Names and other information are disguised to protect confidentiality.
2 Exhibits 1, 5, 6, and 7 are available as downloadable Excel files.
2
that even if the company achieved its objectives, it would need more than $7 million of
additional funding in the near future.
ConnectedHome had been looking for serious venture capital backing for several
months, with little success. The invitation to visit Black Oak had raised everyone’s
hopes, but the CEO reported back to the executive team that the meeting had not gone
well. It appeared, based on the meeting that the venture would need to look elsewhere
for financing.
Just as the team was beginning to gear up a new effort to search for financing,
ConnectedHome received a letter from Black Oak Partners (Exhibit 2). The letter
suggests that Black Oak is enthusiastic about investing in ConnectedHome. However, on
more careful reading, and based on the enclosures with the letter, it is not at all clear that
Black Oak and the ConnectedHome executive team are in agreement about the promise
of the venture or about the valuation.
Strategic Vision
At the core of the disagreement is a difference of opinion about business strategy.
The ConnectedHome group has taken a cautious stance of simultaneously pursuing both
mail order and Internet-based business. The company’s origin is mail order and the team
members believe their established record in mail order can both serve as a launch
platform for the e-commerce business, and protect against the uncertainties of the future
of the Internet. Black Oak Partners on the other hand, is pushing for abandonment of the
catalogue business and for an aggressive move to build the Internet business. The
venture capitalist proposes to drop the mail order business and to change the company
name and image to match its new Internet focus.
The venture capital investors also are seeking to expand the breadth of the
company’s product offerings. They argue that a broader menu will attract more web
traffic, reduce dependence on existing customers, and discourage competitive entry. The
ConnectedHome team, in contrast, believes they should stick with what they know best.
The products they sell are often those they have developed themselves. Expansion of the
product line would dilute this aspect of the business, and there is some concern that the
company would have trouble managing the added complexity. They feel safe with the
existing lines and are not eager to take on other products that might make the entire
venture unprofitable. It is not that they are not eager to grow and expand the business,
they just had planned to do so in a more controlled fashion. Nonetheless, they believe
their projections reflect their ambition to grow rapidly.
Related to the proposal, Black Oak Partners raised other concerns about the
infrastructure that would be needed to support the Internet business as they envision it,
the company’s strategy with respect to such factors as product positioning, pricing,
quality, and customer support. They also would like to devote more time to thinking
about who the key competitors might be and what it would take to make the venture a
success.
3
The executive team has significant concerns about the new strategic orientation
that is being advanced by Black Oak. They wonder about the possible reasons for the
different views. Might they be wrong and Black Oak right? Are they overly concerned
about the risks? How might they be able to salvage a deal that would satisfy both sides?
Due Diligence
In the interest of closing the funding as quickly as possible, Black Oak Partners
had prepared a due diligence request list and enclosed it with their offer (Exhibit 3). The
partners knew that if ConnectedHome was like most ventures, completing the due
diligence review was one of the more likely impediments to closing on time.
The management team at ConnectedHome knew that the kind of financing they
were seeking would necessarily be associated with some level of due diligence review.
Thus, they were not surprised to receive the request list. Nonetheless, the detailed
deliberations that are reflected in the list have started some team members to question
whether the review will become a problem. On one hand, Black Oak is requesting a
great deal of confidential information and some members of the group are concerned
about what the venture capitalist might do with the information if the deal falls through.
On the other, there are areas where team members feel somewhat vulnerable, particularly
with regard to their ability to support their projections. The group wonders how
forthright and candid they should be in preparing a response to the request. They also
wonder about the best way to proceed.
Terms for Investing
While there is much work to be done before the parties can settle on a final
valuation, Black Oak decided to prepare a draft term sheet, setting out the conditions
under which it is interested in investing (Exhibit 4). Although the group has been
seeking an investment of about $7 million, the term sheet is explicit in stating that the
investment will not exceed that amount. Some members of the team question what
would happen if the venture were to run out of cash sooner than they expect. Other
aspects of the proposed agreement make this even more problematic. The anti-dilution
privilege and the restrictions over which Black Oak would have complete control are the
most disconcerting. Closely related, constraints in the term sheet, on how the funds
could be used, appear to virtually force ConnectedHome to adopt the venture capitalist’s
strategic vision that is focused on the Internet, and essentially abandon the mail order
business. Other concerns include the favorable position of the investor with regard to
payment of dividends, the suggestion that some of the managers would have to agree to
termination rights that include buy-out provisions, and the right of the investor to demand
registration. The group wonders how much opportunity exists to negotiate the various
provisions of the agreement and what sorts of counter-proposals are likely to be
acceptable to the investor.
4
Valuation
Black Oak supported their position and recommendations with a financial
analysis of the venture. Initially, they accepted the management team’s projections from
the business plan and the terms for investing that the team had proposed (Exhibit 5).
They applied a discounted cash flow valuation methodology to the projections. Because
the venture has yet to establish a significant amount of Internet business, they applied a
discount rate of 50 percent to the cash flow projections. They used the rate to discount
the explicit cash flows during the first five years of projected operation. To assess
continuing value after the five years, they based their valuation on a multiple of revenues.
Based on a study of mail order businesses that were similar to ConnectedHome, they
determined that a revenue multiple of 1.25 is appropriate for a pure mail-order business.
Based on their own judgment and the experience of other Internet businesses, they
estimated that the revenue multiple for a pure Internet business would be 6.0 times
revenue. The Black Oak submission to ConnectedHome included no formal support for
the 6.0 multiple. Using 1.25 and 6.0 as endpoints, Black Oak included in its analysis a
valuation of a mixed strategy and applied a multiple of 3.5 to projected revenue, based on
the assumption that the two activities contribute equally to value. In each case, it used
the discount rate of 50 percent to convert the continuing value estimates to present value.
After computing the value of total equity, Black Oak determined its share of the
value. To the extent that additional financing was projected to be required in a
subsequent year, Black Oak assumed that the financing would be raised at a valuation of
$2.00 per share and factored this into determination of its share of ownership. Finally,
recognizing that it did not expect to actually harvest the investment until three years
hence, the venture capitalist computed a rate of return between the investment amount
and the value of the investment.
Using the rates of return shown at the bottom of Exhibit 5, Black Oak suggested
to the ConnectedHome group that the opportunity could not meet its return expectations.
In this case, the venture capitalist focused on the mixed strategy valuation and the rate of
return of 11 percent that is shown in the exhibit.
Continuing with the projections provided by management, Black Oak prepared a
second valuation. In this case, instead of $1 per share, they assumed that they would
invest at a value of $.60 per share, which would give them 25 percent of the shares
outstanding after the investment (Exhibit 6). Pointing again to the mixed-strategy
projections, they noted that the 28 percent rate of return was one they might find
acceptable. However, they indicated that this did not appear to be the best arrangement
for ConnectedHome. To make this point, they emphasized that the founders’ share of
enterprise value in Exhibit 6 is $44 million under the mixed strategy.
If ConnectedHome would concentrate on the Internet, the venture capitalist
argued that capital expenditures and expenditures for working capital could be reduced,
profitability could be achieved more quickly and with a lower level of total sales (from a
broader product line), and the venture would be more attractive to the capital market as
an Internet company at the time of an IPO. These changes would enable the IPO to occur
5
a year earlier. The changes, they claimed, could also eliminate the need for an additional
round of private equity investment. The venture capitalist summarized its revised
assumptions and their implications in Exhibit 7. They noted that the rate of return of 38
percent was in their comfort zone. For the ConnectedHome founders, they pointed to the
$66 million value estimate, a value 50 percent higher than that shown in Exhibit 6.
To the ConnectedHome management team, the Black Oak valuation analysis was
the most disconcerting aspect of the proposal. It appeared to one member of the group
that Black Oak was attempting to double-up on the discount used in the valuation. Why,
he argued, would the venture capitalist discount the final revenue projections by 50
percent per year, and then still compute an IRR from the time of investment to the time of
harvest? Another member thought there could be some rationality to the adjustments.
She suggested that possibly the first discount could be a way to address the uncertainty of
the revenue projections and the fact that the business plan projections effectively
assumed that the venture would be a success. If so, then the IRR calculation could be a
way to reflect the investor’s opportunity cost.
After an extensive discussion, the team was unable to reach a consensus about the
investor’s valuation model. Nonetheless, it raised an important question for them. If the
Internet strategy could produce a higher multiple than the mixed strategy, and could get
them to an IPO more quickly, maybe they should consider it seriously. However, they
were not comfortable relying on the valuation numbers cited by Black Oak.
In preparation for their meeting with Black Oak, the team decided that they
needed to do their own analysis of value. As bases for that analysis, they acknowledged
that their projections had a fairly small chance of being realized, somewhere around 10
percent. There was a good chance that the growth rates of revenues would be only half
as rapid as projected, due primarily to weaker growth of the Internet business. A
reasonable worst case would be failure of the Internet business and growth of the
remaining business at a rate of about 20 percent per year. They assigned a 50 percent
probability to this outcome. With regard to the Black Oak projections for a pure Internet
venture, they assigned a 30 percent weight to the Black Oak projections and a 70 percent
weight to outright failure of the venture.
The team felt they could reasonably defend these projections and wondered how
they would influence the Black Oak equity requirements in exchange for investing.
Because of the different methodology, the team knew that a different discount rate would
be needed to evaluate the Black Oak investment. They assembled some data on market
interest rates to use in the analysis (Exhibit 8).
Even with a properly done valuation of common equity to Black Oak, some
nagging questions remained. Among them, how should the advantageous position of
Black Oak as a preferred stock investor be factored into the valuation? Equally
important, how should they factor the differences in risk between the alternative
strategies into their own decision of the best way to proceed?
6
Exhibit 1
Fiscal Year (12/31) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Sales Revenue* $7,540 $12,640 $24,016 $48,032 $84,056 $126,084 $163,909
Percent change 67.6% 90.0% 100.0%

75.0%
($4,203)
-5.0%
($4,203)
-5.0%
$1,441
$1,081
50.0%
$2,774
2.2%
$2,774
2.2%
$1,681
$1,261

30.0%
Operating Income** 270 -640 ($4,203) ($4,803) $12,621
Percent of revenue 3.6% -5.1% -17.5% -10.0% 7.7%
Net Income 270 -640 ($4,203) ($4,803) $12,621
Percent of revenue 3.6% -5.1% -17.5% -10.0% 7.7%
Change in Working Capital*** $1,955 $961 $1,513
Capital Expenditures**** $741 $720 $1,135
Free Cash Flow ($6,899) ($6,484) ($6,724) ($168) $9,973
*Mail order and Internet revenues are projected to be similar.
**Variable costs are projected to be 90 percent of sales revenue for both mail order and Internet revenues.
***Changes in working capital are projected to be similar for both mail order and Internet business.
****Capital expenditures are net of depreciation cash flows and are predominantly related to the Internet business.
Actual Projected
ConnectedHome, Inc.
Revenue, Income, and Cash Flow Projection
7
Exhibit 2
Principals
ConnectedHome, Inc.
Newport Beach, CA
My partners and I wish to thank you for affording Black Oak Partners the opportunity to
submit this proposal to become an equity investor in ConnectedHome. We believe our
experience with a wide range of entrepreneurial ventures and our extensive network in
Silicon Valley will enable us to serve as a highly effective partner. Our investment
capital is committed and we are eager to consummate a transaction with you on a timely
basis.
Following our recent meeting with you, we prepared an outline that can serve as the basis
for a discussion of ConnectedHome’s strategic potential. We would like to have this
discussion with the key members of your staff at your earliest convenience. We also
have developed a preliminary term sheet that outlines the terms under which we would be
prepared to invest, assuming we can agree on the strategic direction of the venture, and
following our due diligence review of your organization.
We also have conducted our own valuation of ConnectedHome. The results of our
analysis are reflected in the proposed terms for investing. Note, however, that we have
not settled on a final valuation of the company. However, we believe the correct
valuation is somewhat below the valuation you proposed at our meeting. If we are to go
forward, we need to agree on a valuation that can provide an adequate return to the
investors in our fund. We are enclosing some working papers that will set out our
thinking about the opportunity, using a hurdle rate that is typical for investors such as
ourselves.
The key factors that account for our differences about value are the company’s lack of a
history of profitability, risks about future profitability over the next few years,
uncertainty about whether the company will be able to achieve its e-commerce
positioning, risks associated with the need of the company to expand its product
offerings, and uncertainty about the level of investment that will be needed to support the
venture during the period of our investment. As you know, the business plan projections
are based on the assumption that you will be successful in accomplishing what you have
set out to do.
We would be delighted to meet with you soon to discuss all of the issues raised in this
letter and the attachments. We would like to be in a position to close the transaction
within about two weeks. Please do not hesitate to call if we can augment the information
we have provided. We look forward to speaking with you soon and to expeditiously
moving the process forward.
Sincerely,
Black Oak Partners
8
Exhibit 3
Black Oak Partners
Due Diligence Request List
ConnectedHome, Inc.
Management and Organization
Organizational chart
Resumes and references for all key members of the management team
Schedule of management ownership
Base and incentive compensation for current year and previous year
Description of management stock option program
Composition of Board and Board committees
Business History and Strategy
Review of company history since inception
Customer composition and purchase behavior for the most recent two years,
including identification of key customers
Identification of key suppliers and supplier relationships
Evidence of web site traffic since initiation of the site
Analysis of competitive advantages, strengths, and weaknesses
Description of current and proposed markets, including international markets
Strategy for growth of business
Identification and description of intellectual property, trademarks, and patents
Financial and Accounting
Detailed financing history
Audited financial statements since inception
Interview with company auditor
Copies of all corporate income tax filings
Detailed statement of assumptions used in developing financial projections in the
business plan
Terms of any debt, trade credit, or other vendor financing
Capital expenditures in most recent two years and planned expenditures reflected
in the business plan projections
Aging of accounts receivable and payable by year and current
Quarterly sales by product line and by mail order versus Internet
Gross profit margin by product line and by mail order versus Internet
Identification of any contingent liabilities of the company
Legal
By-laws and articles of incorporation
Copies of all material contracts, leases, and agreements
Review of outstanding litigation and potential litigation
Interview with corporate legal counsel
9
Exhibit 4
Proposed Terms
Principal Amount: Not to exceed $7,000,000
Price per Share: To be determined based on valuation
Closing Date: On or about January 15, 2000
Form of Investment: Preferred stock of ConnectedHome, Inc.
Dividends: The preferred stockholders are entitled to dividends of 10
percent per annum in preference to any dividends on
common stock. The preferred stock dividend is
cumulative.
Liquidation: In the event of liquidation, holders of the preferred stock
shall be entitled to receive, in preference to holders of
common stock, all declared and unpaid dividends plus the
original purchase price.
Conversion: At their option, by majority vote, holders of the preferred
stock may convert to common on a one-for-one basis.
Preferred stock will automatically convert in the event of a
public offering of $20 million or more, at a price per share
of not less than $3. Conversion price will adjust in the
event of a stock split or stock dividend.
Anti-dilution: In the event of issuance of equity securities at a price less
than the conversion price, the preferred stock investor shall
receive additional shares such that the investor’s weighted
average investment price is equal to the lowest subsequent
issue price.
Preemptive Right: The preferred stock investor will have the right to
participate in any future issuance of equity, except in
conjunction with employee stock incentive programs, to
preserve the investor’s share of equity as converted.
First Refusal: In the event of a proposed sale of shares by any existing
investor or employee, the preferred investor shall have the
first right to purchase the shares on terms offered by any
prospective purchaser.
10
Repurchase: For any employee who is terminated with cause, the
company shall have the right to repurchase the employee’s
shares at their original cost. For any employee who is
terminated without cause or terminates for any reason, the
company shall have the right to repurchase the employee’s
shares at their market value. In the event that a public
market has not been established, the company shall have
the right to purchase such shares at their fair value as
determined by the board of directors.
Restrictions: So long as the preferred shares are outstanding, approval of
the preferred stock investor shall be required for any action
that would (1) alter the rights of the preferred stockholder,
(2) alter the number of shares of preferred stock, or (3)
result in merger, corporate reorganization, or change of
control.
Co-sale: Prior to public offering, if an existing shareholder seeks to
sell his stockholdings, the preferred stock investor shall
have the right to participate in the sale in the same
proportion and on the same terms.
Registration: Upon the earlier of four years following the investment or
six months after a public offering of equity, the investor
shall have the right to demand conversion and registration
of its shares.
Directors: The company board shall consist of five directors. The
investor will be entitled to appoint one director. The
investor-appointed director shall serve on the compensation
committee of the board and on the audit committee of the
board.

Employment Contracts: Key members of the management team will be required to
enter into employment contracts that include termination
rights, and to enter into non-competition agreements.
Uses of Investment Funds: Initial Investment
Increase in working capital
Capital investment
Operating expenses related to Internet
Total
$1,500,000
$ 800,000
$4,700,000
$7,000,000

11
Exhibit 5
Fiscal Year (12/31) 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Sales Revenue $7,540 $12,640

$24,016
90.0%
($4,203)
-17.5%
($4,203)
-17.5%
$1,955
$741
($6,899)
$48,032
100.0%
($4,803)
-10.0%
($4,803)
-10.0%
$961
$720
($6,484)
$84,056 $126,084 $163,909
75.0%
($4,203)
-5.0%
($4,203)
-5.0%
$1,441
$1,081
($6,724)
50.0%
$2,774
2.2%
$2,774
2.2%
$1,681
$1,261
($168)
30.0%
$12,621
7.7%
$12,621
7.7%
$1,513
$1,135
$9,973

Percent change 67.6% Operating Income 270 ($640) Percent of revenue 3.6% -5.1% Net Income 270 ($640) Percent of revenue 3.6% -5.1% Change in Working Capital Capital Expenditures Free Cash Flow ConnectedHome, Inc.
Revenue, Income, and Cash Flow Projection (thousands)
Actual Projected
12

Investment Details Remarks
Valuation
Existing shares outstanding 35,000,000
Black Oak investment $7,000,000 First round
Price per share $1.00
Shares purchased 7,000,000 16.67% Investor shares – percentage of then outstanding equity
Additional investment required $13,500,000 Possible second round
Projected price per share $2.00
Additional shares issued 6,750,000
Ending shares outstanding 48,750,000 14.36% New investor shares – percentage of equity
Investment date 1/15/2000 Anticipated for first round
Anticipated harvest date 12/31/2002
Holding period (years) 3
Catalog Mixed Internet
Revenue Multiple at Exit 1.25 3.50 6.00
Discount Rate 50% 50% 50%
PV of Explicit Cash Flows ($8,194) ($8,194) ($8,194)
PV of Continuing Value $26,981 $75,547 $129,509
Enterprise Present Value $18,787 $67,353 $121,315
Debt $0 $0 $0
Equity Present Value $18,787 $67,353 $121,315
Black Oak Value $2,698 $9,671 $17,420
Black Oak IRR -27% 11% 36%
Founders’ Value $13,488 $48,356 $87,098

13
Exhibit 6
Fiscal Year (12/31)

1998
$7,540
1999
$12,640
67.6%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
$24,016
90.0%
($4,203)
-17.5%
($4,203)
-17.5%
$1,955
$741
($6,899)
$48,032
100.0%
($4,803)
-10.0%
($4,803)
-10.0%
$961
$720
($6,484)
$84,056 $126,084 $163,909
75.0%
($4,203)
-5.0%
($4,203)
-5.0%
$1,441
$1,081
($6,724)
50.0%
$2,774
2.2%
$2,774
2.2%
$1,681
$1,261
($168)
30.0%
$12,621
7.7%
$12,621
7.7%
$1,513
$1,135
$9,973

Sales Revenue Percent change Operating Income 270 ($640) Percent of revenue

3.6%
270
3.6%
-5.1%
($640)
-5.1%

Net Income Percent of revenue Change in Working Capital Capital Expenditures Free Cash Flow ConnectedHome, Inc.
Revenue, Income, and Cash Flow Projection (thousands)
Actual Projected
14
Existing shares outstanding 35,000,000
Black Oak investment (000) $7,000
Price per share $0.60
Shares purchased 11,666,667 25.00%
Additional investment required (000) $13,500
Projected price per share $2.00
Additional shares issued 6,750,000
Ending shares outstanding 53,416,667 21.84%
Investment date 1/15/2000
Anticipated harvest date 12/31/2002
Holding period (years) 3
Catalog Mixed Internet

Revenue Multiple at Exit
Discount Rate
1.25
50%
PV of Explicit Cash Flows ($8,194)
PV of Continuing Value $26,981
Enterprise Present Value $18,787
Debt $0
Equity Present Value $18,787
Black Oak Value $4,103
Black Oak IRR
Founders’ Value
-16%
$12,310

3.50 6.00
50% 50%
($8,194) ($8,194)
$75,547 $129,509
$67,353 $121,315
$0 $0
$67,353 $121,315
$14,710 $26,496
28% 56%
$44,131 $79,489
Valuation
15
Exhibit 7
Fiscal Year (12/31) 1998 1999

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
$21,488
70.0%
($3,223)
-15.0%
($3,223)
-15.0%
$1,065
$577
($4,866)
$34,381
60.0%
($1,031)
-3.0%
($1,031)
-3.0%
$387
$258
($1,676)
$51,571
50.0%
$516
1.0%
$516
1.0%
$516
$344
($344)
$74,778 $104,690
45.0%
$2,991
4.0%
$2,991
4.0%
$696
$464
$1,831
40.0%
$8,375
8.0%
$6,281
6.0%
$897
$598
$4,786

Sales Revenue*

$7,540 $12,640
67.6%
($640)
-5.1%
270
3.6%

Percent change Operating Income** Percent of revenue Net Income

270
3.6%
($640)
-5.1%

Percent of revenue Change in Working Capital Capital Expenditures Free Cash Flow *Projections are greater than half of Exhibit 5 revenue due to assumed switching of customers to Internet.
**Assumes that variable expenses are 90 percent of revenues. The balance of Operating Costs are fixed.
ConnectedHome, Inc.
Revenue, Income, and Cash Flow Projection (thousands)
Actual Projected
16
Existing shares outstanding 35,000,000
Black Oak investment (000) $7,000
Price per share $1.00
Shares purchased 7,000,000
Additional investment required (000) $0
Projected price per share $2.00
Additional shares issued 0
Ending shares outstanding 42,000,000
Investment date 1/15/2000
Anticipated harvest date 12/31/2001
Holding period (years) 2
Catalog Mixed Internet
Revenue Multiple at Exit 1.25 3.50 6.00
Discount Rate 50% 50% 50%
PV of Explicit Cash Flows ($3,099) ($3,099) ($3,099)
PV of Continuing Value $17,233 $48,252 $82,718
Enterprise Present Value $14,134 $45,153 $79,619
Debt $0 $0 $0
Equity Present Value $14,134 $45,153 $79,619
Black Oak Value $2,356 $7,526 $13,270
Black Oak IRR -42% 4% 38%
Founders’ Value $11,778 $37,628 $66,349
Valuation
17
Exhibit 8
Capital Market Data

Current return on Treasury Notes
Current return on Long-term Treasury Bonds
Historical average return on Treasury Notes
Historical average return on Treasury Bonds
Historical average inflation rate
Historical average return on the S&P 500
Projected market risk premium based on dividend growth
Mail-order business estimated asset beta
E-commerce venture estimated asset beta
Estimated correlation of CH mixed-strategy returns to market
Estimate correlation of CH Internet strategy returns to market
Annual standard deviation of market returns
4.0%
4.2%
3.2%
3.5%
2.8%
10.7%
6.5%
0.8
1.4
0.3
0.2
20.0%

The post Strategy, Valuation, and Deal Structure appeared first on My Assignment Online.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order