Step 1: Answer – “Question 1” below
(1,200 words – using OSCOLA referencing)
Step 2: Complete Instruction 1
22848341 3
NAME OF STUDENT: [insert your name]
CANDIDATE NUMBER: [insert your number]
QUESTION 1 – TERM SHEET NEGOTIATION COMMENTARY
Set out in the Clause section below is the wording from certain key clauses of the Pro-Customer Long Form Outsourcing
Agreement. Students will appreciate that in reality the entire contract would be set out in the term sheet. This paper
concentrates on the key issues of Service, Quality, IPR, Liability and Termination (and only parts of those sections).
Please set out in the Supplier Response column short summaries of arguments a Supplier would deploy in responding
to an RFP that contained these clauses to resist taking on this level of commitment. Then please set out the counter
arguments you would deploy if you were acting for a customer. The arguments can include both legal arguments and
commercial points (it would be fine for example to argue that a particular onerous provision is bad because it will drive
negative behaviour by the parties). Your responses to each section should generally be only one paragraph though
some may justify longer responses. Extra credit will be awarded for setting out fall back positions a supplier or customer
could accept.
Students will recall from Task 5 that this is classic way of managing a procurement process. You should treat the
process of completing the sections below as if you were briefing a senior colleague or a client on the positions as well
as drafting the actual push backs you are putting to the customer (in the supplier response column) or back to the
supplier (in the customer counter-arguments column).
Your response should argue why you are rejecting positions. Simply stating “Reject” or “Not Acceptable” will not suffice.
The model answers to this table is made up of around 1,500 words.
22848341 4
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| Services | ||
| 4.1 Commencing on the Effective Date, the Supplier shall provide the Customer and its Affiliates with the following services, functions and responsibilities (as they may evolve during the Term and as they may be supplemented, enhanced, modified or replaced in each case in accordance with this Agreement): |
||
| 4.1.1 The Services described in the Schedules; and |
[Note to Students: no need to comment as this is non contentious.]; |
[Note to Students: no need to comment as this is non contentious.]; |
| 4.1.2 any services, functions and responsibilities (including any incidental services, functions or responsibilities) not expressly specified in this Agreement as within the scope of the Supplier’s responsibilities but reasonably and necessarily required for, or related |
22848341 5
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| to, the proper performance and provision of the Services, including those functions provided by the Customer or the Outgoing Supplier prior to the Effective Date that are essential to support the Services unless such function or responsibility is specifically identified in this Agreement as being the responsibility of the Customer. |
||
| 4.2 The Supplier shall perform the Services in accordance with any dates specified for such performance, as amended from time to time by agreement between the parties via the Change Control Procedure. Services which do not have specified dates for completion shall be provided by the Supplier as soon as possible but in any event, within a reasonable period of time. |
22848341 6
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| 4.3 If required by the Customer, the Supplier shall increase or decrease the amount of the Services being provided or add or remove Services promptly, on reasonable notice. Any such Changes shall be effected through the Change Control Procedure and be subject to any agreed pricing arrangements set out in Schedule 9 (Charges). |
||
| 4.8 The Supplier agrees to co operate with any third parties engaged by the Customer in connection with the Services or in connection with the supply of goods or services related to the provision of the Services. |
||
| 10.1 The Supplier shall at all times achieve or exceed the Performance |
22848341 7
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| Standards in respect of the Services and shall perform the Services: |
||
| 10.1.1 at least at the same level of performance (including in respect of accuracy, quality, timeliness, responsiveness and efficiency) as was provided by or for the Customer prior to the Effective Date or, if higher, in accordance with Good Industry Practice; |
||
| 10.1.4 … The Supplier agrees that there shall be no measurement periods or validation of the Services after the Service Commencement Date in order for the Supplier to satisfy itself that it can provide the Services in accordance with the Service Levels; |
22848341 8
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| 10.5 Where a sum is expressed to be payable as a Service Credit the parties agree that: |
DO NOT COMMENT | DO NOT COMMENT |
| 10.5.1 such sums are a price adjustment and do not represent an estimate of the loss or damage that may be suffered by the Customer in respect of the breach of this Agreement which gives rise to the Service Credit; and |
||
| 10.5.2 the crediting of such sums is without prejudice to any other remedy available to the Customer, whether under the Agreement, common law, or in equity (and such Service Credits are not to be taken into account for the purposes of the limitation on liability provisions set out in clause Error! Reference source not found. (Limitations of Liability)) and any material breach by |
22848341 9
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| the Supplier with respect to the Service Levels shall be without prejudice to the Customer’s right to terminate the Agreement. |
||
| 10.6 If the Supplier fails to meet any Minimum Service Level, the Customer shall have the right to terminate the Agreement for material breach pursuant to clause Error! Reference source not found. (Termination for Cause). |
||
| 10.10 The Supplier agrees that the Service Levels shall be improved over time and that, additionally, at the Customer’s election, Service Levels may be added, deleted or revised due to change in the Customer’s business requirements once suitable agreement on the impact of such changes on the Service and the Service Credits has |
22848341 10
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| been reached pursuant to the Change Control Procedure. |
||
| 11.2 The Supplier shall cause the delivery of the Services, as approved by the Customer, to evolve and be modified, enhanced, supplemented and replaced as necessary for the Services to keep pace with technological advances and advances in the methods of delivering services, where such advances are at the time pertinent and in general use. Accordingly, the Supplier shall proactively seek out new technologies by surveying key suppliers to identify advances or changes in technology that are appropriate and beneficial to the Customer. |
||
| IPR |
22848341 11
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| 26.1 [Any enhancements to Customer Pre-Existing Materials will be owned by the Customer.] |
||
| 26.2 The Customer grants to the Supplier and, to the extent necessary, to the Supplier Personnel, or shall use Commercially Reasonable Efforts to procure the grant of, a royalty-free, non-exclusive, non-transferable licence (or, where relevant, an appropriate sub-licence) to use the Customer Data, the Customer Material, the Customer-owned Intellectual Property Rights and the Customer Software to the extent necessary and for the sole purpose of providing the Services. |
||
| 26.3 The Supplier grants to the Customer and its Affiliates, and, to the extent necessary, its |
22848341 12
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| subcontractors, agents and representatives a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive licence to use, copy, modify, enhance and maintain the Supplier Material (including any Supplier processes) and the Supplier Software, for the purpose of the Customer and its Affiliates receiving the Services for the duration of the Term and any Termination Assistance Period and for the purpose of providing or receiving comparable services following the termination of this Agreement (whether such services are carried out by the Customer or a Successor Supplier). |
||
| Extracts from Liability Clauses | ||
| 35.1 The Supplier shall accept uncapped liability for any losses or claims suffered by the Customer |
22848341 13
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| (including any legal costs) arising from: 35.1.1 death or personal injury arising from the Supplier’s negligence or that of any of its subcontractors or Affiliates; 35.1.2 fraud or fraudulent misrepresentation; 35.1.3 the abandonment of work by the Supplier; 35.1.4 the employment indemnities set out in clause 16 (Personnel) and Schedule 20 (TUPE Provisions); 35.1.5 the breach by the Supplier, its Affiliates or any of its subcontractors of the duties of confidentiality contained in this Agreement; |
22848341 14
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| 35.1.6 the breach by the Supplier, its Affiliates or any of its subcontractors of the data protection obligations contained in this Agreement; |
||
| Termination | ||
| 37.6 The Supplier may only terminate this Agreement if the Customer fails to pay undisputed Charges for which properly submitted invoices have been delivered above fifty per cent (50%) of current year’s contracted Services and within a rolling one hundred and eighty (180) day period. The Supplier agrees that prior to exercising its rights and where reasonably possible before unpaid invoices reach this level, it shall escalate any non-payments in |
22848341 15
| Clause | Supplier Response | Customer counter-argument |
| accordance with the Dispute Resolution Procedure. |
TERM SHEET ENDS
Instruction 1 : Select “ONE” of the following questions, write around
1,200 words (using OSCALA referencing style to support your argument)
Question 2. One of the main drivers for outsourcing is to control costs. Describe the
approaches to pricing a customer can adopt to give itself clarity and control over what it pays
and further, consider how it might future-proof the contract to ensure it continues to get good
pricing.
OR
Question 3. Any long term relationship has its ups and downs. Consider those aspects of an
IT outsourcing contract which are designed to prevent disputes arising or to resolve disputes.
OR
Question 4. All outsourcing contracts end. Explain how to manage the process of contract
renewal and exit management in the context of the outsourcing life-cycle and the risks that
good practice in this regard is intended to mitigate.
The post TERM SHEET NEGOTIATION COMMENTARY appeared first on My Assignment Online.