Learning Objectives
7-1 Identify the policy instruments used by governments to
influence international trade flows.
7-2 Understand why governments sometimes intervene in
international trade.
7-3 Summarize and explain the arguments against strategic
trade policy.
7-4 Describe the development of the world trading system
and the current trade issue.
7-5 Explain the implications for managers of developments in
the world trading system.
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Opening Case:
U.S. and South Korea Strike a Revised Trade Deal
Donald Trump – 2012 free trade deal between U.S. and South
Korea is a “job killer” especially in auto industry
• South Korea is an important ally against North Korea and
third largest supplier of foreign steel to U.S.
• Trump administration put a 25 percent tariff on steel imports
• Revised trade deal:
• South Korea exempt from 25 percent tariff on steel, but will limit
exports to 70 percent of 2017 levels
• South Korea will extend tariff on exports of light trucks and lift annual
quota on imports of U.S. cars
• South Korea’s agriculture industry remains the same
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Introduction
Free trade: a situation where a government does not
attempt to restrict what its citizens can buy from
another country or what they can sell to another
country
• While many nations are nominally committed to free
trade, they tend to intervene in international trade to
protect the interests of politically important groups
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 1
Seven main instruments of trade policy
- Tariffs
- Subsidies
- Import quotas
- Voluntary export restraints
- Local content requirements
- Administrative policies
- Antidumping duties
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 2
There has been a rise in nontariff barriers - Subsidies
- Quotas
- Voluntary export restraints
- Antidumping duties
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 3
Tariffs
• Tariff: a tax levied on imports that effectively raises the
cost of imported products relative to domestic products
• Specific tariffs: levied as a fixed charge for each unit of a good
imported
• Ad valorem tariffs: levied as a proportion of the value of the
imported good
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 4
Tariffs continued
• Increase government revenues
• Provide protection to domestic producers against foreign
competitors by increasing the cost of imported foreign
goods
• Force consumers to pay more for certain imports
• Tariffs are generally pro-producer and anticonsumer
• Import tariffs reduce the overall efficiency of the world
economy
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Did You Know?
Did you know that the
high price of SUVs in
the United States is the
result of the “chicken
tariff”?
Click to play video
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 5
Subsidies
• Subsidy: a government payment to a domestic producer
• Subsidies help domestic producers:
• Compete against low-cost foreign imports
• Gain export markets
• Consumers typically absorb the costs of subsidies
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 6
Import Quotas and Voluntary Export Restraints
• Import quota: A direct restriction on the quantity of some
good that may be imported into a country
• Tariff rate quota: A hybrid of a quota and a tariff where a
lower tariff is applied to imports within the quota than to
those over the quota
• Voluntary export restraint (VER): Quota on trade imposed
by the exporting country, typically at the request of the
importing country’s government
• Quota rent: The extra profit that producers make when
supply is artificially limited by an import quota
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Figure 7.1 Hypothetical Tariff Rate Quota
Access the text alternative for these images.
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 7
Export Tariffs and Bans
• Export tariff: a tax placed on the export of a good
• Goal is to discriminate against exporting
• Export ban: a policy that partially or entirely restricts the
export of a good
• Ban of exports of U.S. crude oil in 1975 to ensure sufficient supply
of domestic oil at home
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 8
Local Content Requirements
• A local content requirement demands that some specific
fraction of a good be produced domestically
• Can be in physical terms or in value terms
• Local content requirements benefit domestic producers
and jobs, but consumers face higher prices
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Is Having a Local Content Requirement a Good
Idea? Local content requirements refer to a specific fraction of a product that needs
to be manufactured domestically. Basically, LCRs establish a minimum level of
local content required under trade law when giving foreign companies the
right to manufacture in a particular place. In the wake of the economic
downturn in 2008, many economists feared that some governments would
institute protectionist policies similar to the tariff escalations during the Great
Depression of the 1930s. However, most public policy officials avoided
traditional forms of protection (e.g., tariffs, quotas). This led some observers
to underestimate the degree of protectionism. Instead, what had happened
was that so-called nontariff barriers in the form of local content requirements
had become increasingly popular. As a (1) citizen of a specific country and (2)
as a global customer, do you think local content requirements help you as a
citizen of a country, as a global customer, as both, or as neither?
Source: G. C. Hufbauer and J. J. Scott, “Local Content Requirements: A Global Problem Washington, D.C.,” Peterson Institute for Global Economics, 2013.
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 9
Administrative Policies
• Administrative trade polices: bureaucratic rules that are
designed to make it difficult for imports to enter a country
• These polices hurt consumers by denying access to
possibly superior foreign products
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Instruments of Trade Policy 10
Antidumping Policies
• Dumping: selling goods in a foreign market below their
cost of production, or selling goods in a foreign market at
below their “fair” market value
• Antidumping policies protect domestic producers from
unfair foreign competition
• Vary from country to country
• U.S. firms that believe a foreign firm is dumping can file a
complaint with the government
• If the complaint has merit, antidumping duties, also known as
countervailing duties, may be imposed
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Case for Government Intervention 1
Political arguments are concerned with:
• Protecting the interests of certain groups within a nation
(normally producers), often at the expense of other
groups (normally consumers)
• Achieving some political objective such as protecting the
environment or human rights
Economic arguments are concerned with:
• Boosting the overall wealth of a nation (to the benefit of
all, both producers and consumers)
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Case for Government Intervention 2
Political Arguments for Intervention
• Protecting Jobs and Industries
• Protecting National Security
• Retaliating
• Use intervention as a bargaining tool and force trading partners to
“play by the rules of the game”
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Case for Government Intervention 3
Political Arguments for Intervention continued
• Protecting Consumers
• Ban unsafe products
• Furthering Foreign Policy Objectives
• Grant preferential trade terms to a country it wants to build
relations with
• Pressure or punish “rogue” states
• Protecting Human Rights
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Trading with Cuba
Even though the
United States
holds trade
sanctions with
Cuba, other
Western
countries
continue to
trade with the
island nation.
Source: ©Esben Hansen/123RF
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Case for Government Intervention 4
Economic Arguments for Intervention
• The Infant Industry Argument
• An industry should be protected until it can develop and be viable
and competitive internationally
• This argument has been criticized because:
• It is useless unless it makes the industry more efficient
• If a country has the potential to develop a viable competitive
position, its firms should be capable of raising necessary funds
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Case for Government Intervention 5
Economic Arguments for Intervention continued
• Strategic Trade Policy
• By appropriate actions, government can help raise national income
if it can ensure that firms that gain first-mover advantages in an
industry are domestic
• Might be beneficial for a government to intervene in an industry
by helping domestic firms overcome barriers to entry created by
foreign firms with first-mover advantages
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Revised Case for Free Trade 1
New trade theorists believe government intervention in
international trade is justified
• Classical trade theorists disagree
Some new trade theorists believe that while strategic
trade theory is appealing in theory, it may not be
workable in practice—they suggest a revised case for
free trade
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Revised Case for Free Trade 2
Retaliation and Trade War
• Krugman: strategic trade policies to establish domestic
firms in a dominant position in a global industry are
beggar-thy-neighbor policies that boost national income at
the expense of other countries
• A country that attempts to use such policies will probably provoke
retaliation
• A trade war could leave both countries worse off
• Don’t engage in retaliation but help establish rules to minimize the
use of trade-distorting subsidies
©McGraw-Hill Education
• The Revised Case for Free Trade 3
Domestic Policies
Governments can be influenced by special interest groups
• A government’s decision to intervene in a market may appease a
certain group but not necessarily support the interests of the
country as a whole
• Krugman sees this as a further reason for not embracing strategic
trade policy
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 1
Since World War II, an international trading framework
has evolved to govern world trade
• In its first fifty years, the framework was known as the
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT)
• Since 1995, the framework has been known as the World
Trade Organization (WTO)
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Do You Believe in Free Trade Agreements?
The benefits of free trade agreements are often hard to see. At
the same time, the benefits of protecting certain industries and/
or companies from foreign competition are often very visible.
Given these scenarios, many people often argue that free trade
agreements are bad for their country. Perhaps as a result, many
governments impose many tariffs, quotas, and other nontariff
barriers to trade. For example, the common perception is that
by establishing trade barriers, a country keeps the jobs at home
instead of jobs being shipped overseas. But is this really true?
Source: D. J. Boudreaux, The Benefits of Free Trade: Addressing the Myths (Washington, DC: Mercatus Center, George Mason University, 2013).
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 2
From Smith to the Great Depression
• Up until the Great Depression of the 1930s, most
countries had some degree of protectionism
• U.S. enacted the Smoot-Hawley Act (1930): created
significant import tariffs on foreign goods
• Damaged employment abroad
• Other nations took similar steps, and as the depression
deepened, world trade fell further
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 3
1947 to 1979: GATT, Trade Liberalization, and Economic
Growth
• The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) was
established in 1947
• Multilateral agreement to liberalize trade and gradually eliminate
barriers to trade
• Membership grew from 19 to more than 120 nations
• Tariff reduction was spread over eight rounds
• Very successful in early rounds
• Superseded by the World Trade Organization (WTO)
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 4
1980 to 1993: Protectionist Trends
• Japan’s economic success strained what had been more
equal trading patterns
• Persistent trade deficits by the U.S caused significant
problems in some industries and political problems for the
government
• Many countries found that although GATT limited the use
of tariffs, there were many other forms of intervention
that had the same effect that did not technically violate
GATT
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 5
The Uruguay Round and the World Trade Organization
• Uruguay Round emphasized services, intellectual property,
and agricultural subsidies
• Dragged on for seven years
• The World Trade Organization
• The WTO encompassed GATT, the General Agreement on Trade in
Services (GATS), and the Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of
Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS)
• Procedures subject to strict time limits
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 6
WTO: Experience to Date
• Members account for 98% of world trade
• It was hoped that it would emerge as an effective
advocate and facilitator of future trade deals
• Started strong but has fallen off since late 1990s
• Brexit and Trump Administration suggest a return to
greater protectionism
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 7
The Future of the WTO: Unresolved Issues and the Doha
Round
• Antidumping Actions
• Encourage members to strengthen regulations governing the
imposition of antidumping duties
• Protectionism in Agriculture
• Concerned with the high level of tariffs and subsidies in the
agricultural sector of many economies
• Protection of Intellectual Property
• Members believe the protection of intellectual property rights is
essential to the international trading system
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Protecting Agriculture
Removing barriers to
trade and subsidies in
agricultural products
should benefit
consumers.
Source: ©Bloomberg/Getty Images
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 8
The Future of the WTO: Unresolved Issues and the
Doha Round continued
• Market Access for Nonagricultural Goods and Services
• Tariffs on services remain higher than on industrial goods
• A New Round of Talks: Doha
• Ongoing since 2001
• Concerned with cutting tariffs on industrial goods and services,
phasing out subsidies to agricultural producers, reducing barriers
to cross-border investment, and limiting the use of antidumping
laws
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 9
Multilateral and Bilateral Trade Agreements
• Reciprocal trade agreements between two or more
partners
• Trump Administration withdrew from the TPP, while
remaining 11 nations continued with revised agreement,
and trade agreement with the EU was put on hold
• Agreements are designed to capture gain from trade
beyond those agreements currently attainable under WTO
treaties
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Development of The World Trading System 10
The World Trading System Under Threat
• Two events suggest that global consensus on free trade
isn’t accurate:
• Decision by the British to withdraw from the EU
• Britain still does appear to be committed to free trade
• Election of Donald Trump, who seems opposed to free trade deals
• Withdrew from Trans Pacific Partnership
• Placed tariffs on certain imports
• Renegotiated NAFTA
• Expressed hostility to the WTO
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Focus on Managerial Implications 1
Trade Barriers, Firm Strategy, and Policy Implications
• Trade Barriers and Firm Strategy
• Tariff barriers raise the costs of exporting
• Quotas may limit a firm’s ability to serve a country
• Firms may need to conform to local content requirements
• Future trade barriers can influence firm strategy
• Antidumping actions limits ability to use aggressive pricing to gain
market share
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Focus on Managerial Implications 2
Trade Barriers, Firm Strategy, and Policy Implications
continued
• Policy Implications
• International firms have an incentive to lobby for free trade, and
keep protectionist pressures from causing them to have to change
strategies
• Three drawbacks to government intervention:
• Self-defeating as it protects the inefficient
• Dangerous as it might invite retaliation
• Unlikely to be well-executed as can be captured by special interest
groups
©McGraw-Hill Education
• Summary
In this chapter, we have
• Identified the policy instruments used by governments to
influence international trade flows.
• Understood why governments sometimes intervene in
international trade.
• Summarized and explained the arguments against
strategic trade policy.
• Described the development of the world trading system
and the current trade issues.
• Explained the implications for managers of developments
in the world trading system.
The post The Global Trade and Investment Environment appeared first on My Assignment Online.