Notes on Formalism–Part One
What is formalism? And what does it have to do with composition? And why are we starting a study of composition and rhetoric by reading poetry?
Formalism first: it is a study of literary form. “Form” is an idea that covers a lot of ground. You may think of form as something used to recreate a specific
shape over and over again, like a mold. A mold creates a form which can be repeated almost endlessly. That’s a form. A uniform is a common form, usually
of dress. Police officers wear uniforms. So do military personnel, or athletes on teams. The uniform is meant to identify members of a group (Police, armed
forces, sports teams) by supplying “one form” (Uni-form) for all members. So that’s another idea of form.
Form in literature can refer to types of stories. Fables, parables, and tales, are all forms of stories, each with distinctive elements that set it apart from any
other kind of story. For those three forms, length is an informal element (in order from fable to tale, each gets longer than the one before; but there’s no set
length of any one of them, no word count that divides one from the other). Content is an element, too: fables tend to have non-human objects or animals
behaving like humans, even talking. That element seldom appears in parables, and while it can appear in tales (like fairy tales), it’s more common to fables
than the other two. So there are ways of determining form in literature: one is length, which can be specific or general (how long is too long?); and content.
But stories are not the oldest form of literature; poetry is. Poetry goes back as far as evidence of human language does, and all cultures seem to have created
forms of poetry, mostly at first to tell stories. This brings up a question of form similar to the categories of fable, parable, and tale. Poetry is actually first
divided into categories based on content, and those categories are: lyric; narrative; dramatic (a subset of narrative, actually); and epic (also, actually, a kind
of narrative poem). These categories will be important in discussing poetry and formalism, so we’ll stop here to discuss them in greater depth.
LYRIC POETRY
Lyric poetry is so named because it was performed by the Greeks with a lyre, a small 5 string harp, for the musical accompaniment. Today we still call the
words of a song the “lyrics.” That’s where lyric poetry began: not as something read on a page in private and silently; but as something performed for an
audience, with music. We’ve been singing poetry since poetry began; and we still do today.
But lyric poetry was distinguished from a poem that told a story. For the Greeks poems that told stories told long, large, complicated stories. In prose, we tell
those stories in novels today. In ancient Greece, they told those stories in epic poems. But again, the poem was not written down and read silently, they way
you might read a novel. It was performed, recited in whole or in part, usually with music. It is that performance of a very extended story that formed the
basis of what we think of as poetry today.
POETRY AS MEMORY
When we think of poetry, we usually think of specific things that distinguish it from prose, things like rhyme and rhythm. Rap and hip-hop and most song
lyrics retain the rhyme we associate with poetry (there are different kinds of rhyme. We’ll get to that before we’re done.). One reason we remember song
lyrics is because of the rhyme. As poets figured out early on, rhyme is a mnemonic device: it’s an aid to memory. (“Mnemonic” comes from the Greek word
for memory, “mnemos.” The “m” is silent.). But rhyme is not the only, or the best, mnemonic device.
Poetry, then, was developed as a way to remember a long story, a story with details that were important and needed to be included in the telling. Rhyme
helped with this, but so did meter. Rhyme is a repetition of sounds; although it can be of similar sounds, not just of the same sounds. Meter is the measure of
the rhythm of a line of poetry. Consider a limerick for one example:
There was a young lady from Bright
Whose speed was much faster than light.
She set out one day
In a relative way
And returned on the previous night!
The pleasure of a limerick is the three “long” lines and the two short lines in between. “Long” here can be specified: the limerick has two lines of two lines
of three iambs each; then two lines of two iambs each, and a final line returning to the meter of three iambs. And already you’re wondering what the heck an
“iamb” is.
An iamb is a unit of measure, like a foot or a centimeter. It is actually called a “metrical foot,” meaning it is a unit of measure in poetic meter. The iamb is a
unit of two syllables, with the stress on the second syllable of the iamb. There is a similar unit, the trochee, where the stress is on the first syllable of the
unit. I mention this only to emphasize the importance of where the stress falls. The iamb is the most common metrical foot in English poetry; the number of
iambs per line determines how long the line is, and what mood it creates.
A limerick is a comic poem, and a lyric poem. The meter is part of the comedy of the poem. It is not serious and ponderous; it is light and bouncy. As a
form, it depends on rhyme; but it also depends on meter. A longer meter would slow the poem down and break the comedy it tries to create.
Look at a slightly longer line, this one with four iambs instead of three or even two:
Beware the Jabberwock, my son!
The jaws that bite, the claws that catch!
Beware the Jubjub bird and shun
Th f i B d h
Listen
ENGL-1302 6320 1 Composition & Rhetoric II SK
Content Grades Course Acƭviƭes Collaboraƭon Support
The frumious Bandersnatch.
That’s a stanza (a stanza is a group of lines in poetry, rather like a paragraph in prose) from Lewis Carroll’s “Jabberwocky.” It’s a four iamb line, and clearly
runs a bit longer than the lines in the limerick. But still it’s a comic poem, so still the mood is lighter. The number of iambs doesn’t mean the poem is always
silly and happy. Most ballads, especially the ones involving broken hearts and doomed lovers, are almost always in this same stanza form of four lines and 4
iambs per line. But to see the difference between a short line and a longer line, consider this stanza from Shakespeare:
That time of year thou may’st in me behold,
When yellow leaves, or none, or few, do hang
Upon those boughs which shake against the cold,
Bare, ruined choirs where late the sweet birds sang.
That is obviously a more serious poem than the first two. What may not be as obvious (yet) is the lines have five iambs each, not two, three, or four. The
extra iamb makes for a more serious line, Coupled with the rhyme, it also makes the line easier to memorize. (Actually this works with Shakespeare’s plays,
too. Most of the dialogue in Shakespeare’s plays is unrimed, but is in the same meter as this stanza. The meter makes it easier to remember the lines, even
without rhyme.)
We need to study meter further, but that gives you an idea of what we’ll be considering. It also opens the door on one of the many ways poetry works to be
memorable, even though we don’t need to memorize it as once we did. But meter and rhyme are the building blocks (rather like words construct sentences)
of poetic forms.
LINES, STANZAS, POETRY
Poetry is similar in important ways to prose. In an essay you write sentences, and sentences concerning a single topic are gathered into a paragraph. One
reason to do that is to make it easier for the reader. Imagine trying to read an essay that was simply one sentence after another, each sentence printed singly
on the page, no indication of paragraphs at all. It would be very difficult to read and to decide which sentence goes with which idea, and what the ideas of
the essay were, or even what the main idea of the essay was. Prose needs paragraphs; poetry needs stanzas. But paragraphs need sentences; and stanzas need
lines.
A sentence in prose is a complete thought. That isn’t necessarily the case in poetry.
Death, be not proud, though some have called thee
Mighty and dreadful, for thou art not so;
For those whom thou think’st thou dost overthrow
Die not, poor Death, nor yet canst thou kill me.
That’s the first four lines of John Donne’s Holy Sonnet 10. Pay attention to the punctuation, and you’ll see the four lines are actually one sentence. How,
then, do we determine what a line of poetry is?
There are two ways: rhyme, and meter. The rhyme scheme here is usually denoted as abba. The “a” refers to the last word of the first line that rhymes with
the last word of another line. The next line that doesn’t rhyme with “a” but does rhyme with another line, is “b”. Each line that rhymes with the first line is
“a”; each line that rhymes with the next non “a” line is “b.” The first line that rhymes with another line but doesn’t rhyme with “a” or “b” is “c”; and so on.
It’s a simple system that is used to identify the change from one stanza to another. Look at the whole Donne poem for our first example:
Death, be not proud, though some have called thee
Mighty and dreadful, for thou art not so;
For those whom thou think’st thou dost overthrow
Die not, poor Death, nor yet canst thou kill me.
From rest and sleep, which but thy pictures be,
Much pleasure; then from thee much more must flow,
And soonest our best men with thee do go,
Rest of their bones, and soul’s delivery.
Thou art slave to fate, chance, kings, and desperate men,
And dost with poison, war, and sickness dwell,
And poppy or charms can make us sleep as well
And better than thy stroke; why swell’st thou then?
One short sleep past, we wake eternally
And death shall be no more; Death, thou shalt die.
The rhyme scheme is: abbaabba cdcdee. You should also notice that it is written as four sentences. Punctuation is not a requirement of poetry; but it does
indicate the poet means to indicate a complete thought, just as a prose essay would. Poetry is very different from prose in some ways, but the best way to
think of it is as compressed speech. A poet can compact an entire essay into only fourteen line, as in this sonnet. But while it is only four sentences, it can
say as much as a 40 sentence essay.
Now, to continue this matter of rhyme schemes, look at a Shakespearean sonnet:
That time of year thou mayst in me behold
When yellow leaves, or none, or few, do hang
Upon those boughs which shake against the cold,
Bare ruin’d choirs, where late the sweet birds sang.
In me thou see’st the twilight of such day
As after sunset fadeth in the west,
Which by and by black night doth take away,
Death’s second self, that seals up all in rest.
In me thou see’st the glowing of such fire
That on the ashes of his youth doth lie,
As the death-bed whereon it must expire,
Consum’d with that which it was nourish’d by.
This thou perceiv’st, which makes thy love more strong,
To love that well which thou must leave ere long.
Reflect in ePortfolio Download Print Open with docReader
The rhyme scheme here is different, although again there are only 14 lines in the entire poem. Here the rhyme scheme is:
abab
cdcd
efef
gg
Each stanza has a rhyme scheme different from the rhymes of the four lines before it or after it, until the final 2 line stanza. Donne’s poem is in a specific
form: the rhyme scheme indicates it’s in an octave (an 8 line stanza): abbaabba. The second stanza is a sestet, or 6 line stanza: cdcdee. Donne actually
includes a couplet, a two line stanza; we’ll come back to why he does that, later.
Shakespeare writes his sonnet in quatrains, or four line stanzas. But that gets him 12 lines total (4+4+4), and he needs 14 lines to have a sonnet. So he ends
with a couplet, a 2 line stanza (4+4+4+2=14).
In Donne’s poem, the first 8 lines are a paragraph addressing what is actually good about death (“soonest our best men with thee do go”), and how death is
neither mighty nor dreadful (“from rest and sleep, which but thy pictures be, much pleasure….”). The last 6 lines cinch the argument that death is neither
mighty nor dreadful, and how no one will die, ultimately, but death. Shakespeare takes a different approach: each stanza is on a different topic, but all the
topics are related to the central idea of the poem, an idea he finally and fully explains in the last two lines, the couplet.
The stanzas are identified by rhyme: the octave is different from the sestet because the rhyme changes. The quatrains are each distinct because the rhyme
changes every four lines. But what about the meter? Does that play no part?
METER and LINE
Meter actually determines line more than rhyme does. Meter is measured by the number of metrical feet per line. But the number of metrical feet the poet
wants in a line, determines the length of the line, and that determines where the lines are in the poem. I know that sounds a little circular, so let’s look at
meter and line more specifically.
Meter is designated by the kind of metrical foot, and the number of such feet per line. Metrical feet can be trochees, or dactyls, or spondees, or iambs, or
several other categories. Pay attention to iambs; but be aware they are one of many choices. An iamb is a unit of two syllables, with stress on the second
syllable. It produces a line as similar to ordinary English speech as possible. The number of iambs per line determines whether the line is dimeter, trimeter,
tetrameter, or pentameter.
Look back at the limerick, above. The first line is trimeter: three iambs per line. The third and fourth lines are dimeter: two iambs per line. In the stanza
from “Jabberwocky” the line is tetrameter: four iambs per line. In Donne’s sonnet, and Shakespeare’s, there are five iambs per line: pentameter.
So if the poet wants to write in trimeter, the line must have three iambs, and no more. That determines the line, and then the poet needs an end rhyme.
Tetrameter, pentameter: each decision determines where the line ends and a new one begins. The rhyme scheme determines how long the stanza is, or what
| You have viewed this topic |
| Activity Details |
Last Visited May 15, 2020 9:33 AM
The post we starting a study of composition and rhetoric appeared first on My Assignment Online.