Assessment 3: Report-B
| Due date: | Week 9 |
| Group/individual: | Individual |
| Word count / Time provided: | 2000 words |
| Weighting: | 30% |
| Unit Learning Outcomes: | ULO-1, ULO-3, ULO-4, ULO-5, ULO-6 |
Assessment Details:
Use the given incumbent and challenger below and conduct a thorough analysis of the current
conditions of this incumbent by referring to following relevant strategic analysis frameworks:
Incumbent: Burger king
Challenger: McDonald’s
1. Porter’s Five Forces Model
a. Degree of existing rivalry
b. Threat of potential entrants
c. Bargaining power of suppliers
d. Bargaining powers of buyers
e. Threat of substitutes
2. Stakeholders analysis
a. Strategic stakeholder analysis
b. Normative stakeholder analysis
3. Porter’s Value Chain Model
a. Primary activities
b. Support activities
4. PESTEL (Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental, Legal),
5. SWOT (Strength, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats)
6. Technology cycle
a. Era of ferment
b. Era of incremental change
7. The Utterback and Abernathy Model or 3 Phases of innovation model a. Fluid Phase
b. Transitional Phase
c. Specific Phase
8. The McKinsey 7-S Model
a. Hard elements (Strategy, Structure, System)
b. Soft element (Shared Values, Skills, Style and Staff)
You will have to use at least 4 strategic analysis frameworks, identify and evaluate the current
position of the incumbent and synthesize the findings. The first one (Porter’s Five Forces Model)
is compulsory. In technology cycle and 3 phases of Innovation model, you will have to explain at
which phase does the current position of the incumbent of your choice fall on. After assessing the
incumbent’s current position, provide a detailed solution for this incumbent to re-emerge in the
market. The solution has to be linked to innovation and new disruptive technologies. This will help
you to explain about the firm’s strategic intent. This solution should help you to identify and
explain resources and capabilities required by the incumbent that helps to close the gap between
its current position and its strategic intent. As part of your assessment, you will have to create a
mind map to show the possible solutions.
Marking criteria and Rubric: The assessment 3 – Report B will be marked out of 100 and will be
weighted 30% of the total unit mark.
| Marking Criteria | Not satisfactory (0-49%) of the criterion mark) |
Satisfactory (50-64%) of the criterion mark |
Good (65-74%) of the criterion mark |
Very Good (75-84%) of the criterion mark |
Excellent (85-100%) of the criterion mark |
| Demonstrate understanding of formulating technological innovation strategy by assessing the company’s current position and defining company’s strategic intent (20 marks) |
Inadequate understanding of formulating technological innovation strategy by assessing the company’s current position and defining company’s strategic intent. |
Basic knowledge of formulating technological innovation strategy by assessing the company’s current position and defining company’s strategic intent. |
Exhibits some breadth and depth of formulating technological innovation strategy by assessing the company’s current position and defining company’s strategic intent. |
Exhibits accurate and detailed breadth and depth of formulating technological innovation strategy by assessing the company’s current position and defining company’s strategic intent |
Displays exceptional understanding of formulating technological innovation strategy by assessing the company’s current position and defining company’s strategic intent. |
| Analyses the current position of the incumbent and synthesises the findings by using different strategic analysis frameworks (30 marks) |
Poorly analyses and synthesises the current position of the incumbent |
Partially analyses and synthesises the current position of the incumbent. Limited logical arguments presented. |
Good analysis of incumbent’s current position and synthesis of the findings by using at least three strategic analysis frameworks. |
An excellent analysis of incumbent’s current position and synthesis of the findings by using at more than three strategic analysis frameworks. |
An outstanding attempt at analysis of incumbent’s current position and synthesis of the findings by using more than three strategic analysis frameworks. |
| Identifies and describes a solution to close the gap between company’s current position and its strategic intent including a mind map. (30 marks) |
Poor identification and description of a solution to close the gap between company’s current position and its strategic intent including a mind map. |
Shows partial identification and description of a solution to close the gap between company’s current position and its strategic intent including a mind map. |
A good attempt at identifying and describing solution to close the gap between company’s current position and its strategic intent including a mind map. |
An excellent attempt at identifying and describing solution to close the gap between company’s current position and its strategic intent including a mind map. |
An outstanding attempt at identifying and describing solution to close the gap between company’s current position and its strategic intent including a mind map. |
| Writes clearly and succinctly in an appropriate academic style, Demonstrate appropriate use of language, grammar, spelling and punctuation with correct referencing (Harvard Author Date system (20 marks) |
The paper lacks transition and therefore difficult to read and understand. Inadequate use of language, grammar, spelling and punctuation Significant work is required to make citation and list of references consistent with Harvard Author Date system |
The paper lacks consistent transition. Some paragraphs appear unrelated to the preceding ones or to the topic. There are few grammatical error and unintentional errors in acknowledging sources. In-text citation and list of references mostly compliant with Harvard Author Date system |
The report is written with some transition. The report exhibits appropriate use of language, grammar, spelling, punctuation References are credited well and used appropriately. In-text citation and list of references mostly compliant with Harvard Author Date system |
The report is written with a good transition, which is evident from a structure that includes introduction, body and conclusion The report exhibits accurate use of language, grammar, spelling, punctuation. References are credited well and used appropriately. In-text citation and list of references mostly compliant with Harvard Author Date system |
This report is written with a good transition, in a persuasive, which is evident from a clear structure that includes introduction, body and conclusion. The report exhibits exceptional ability in use of correct language. grammar, spelling and punctuation. References are credited well and used appropriately. In-text citation and list of references mostly compliant with Harvard Author Date system. |
The post Assessment 3: Report-B appeared first on My Assignment Online.