See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328824135
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years
Book · January 2016
CITATIONS
5
READS
173
7 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
geomatics View project
Spatial Networks, Human Mobility, and Trajectory Data Analysis View project
Max J Egenhofer
University of Maine
294 PUBLICATIONS 16,620 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Keith Clarke
University of California, Santa Barbara
255 PUBLICATIONS 11,533 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Song Gao
University of Wisconsin–Madison
78 PUBLICATIONS 1,822 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Teriitutea Quesnot
Université de Bretagne Occidentale
13 PUBLICATIONS 80 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Keith Clarke on 06 March 2019.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.
ADVANCING GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SCIENCE: CHAPTER 1
© by the author(s) Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License
9
Contributions of GIScience over the
Past Twenty Years
Max J. Egenhofer1, Keith C. Clarke2, Song Gao2, Teriitutea Quesnot3,
W. Randolph Franklin4, May Yuan5, and David Coleman6
1 School of Computing and Information Science and National Center for Geographic
Information and Analysis, 5711 Boardman Hall, University of Maine,
Orono, ME 04469-5711, USA
2 Department of Geography, 1720 Ellison Hall, University of California, Santa Barbara,
Santa Barbara, CA 93106-4060, USA
3 Centre for Research in Geomatics, Laval University, 1055 Avenue du Séminaire, Pavillon
Louis-Jacques Casault, Quebec City, QC G1V 0A6, Canada
4 Department of Electrical, Computer & Systems Engineering, 6026 JEC, Rensselaer Polytechnic
Institute, 110 8th St, Troy, NY 12180, USA
5 School of Economic, Political, and Policy Sciences, The University of Texas at Dallas,
800 W Campbell Road, Richardson, TX 75080-3021, USA
6 Department of Geodesy and Geomatics Engineering, University of New Brunswick,
P.O. Box 4400, E3B 5A3, Fredericton, NB, Canada
Abstract: This paper summarizes the discussions related to the panel “Contributions
of GIScientists (or GIScience) over the past Twenty Years” at the 2015 Vespucci
Institute. Reflections about the past not only provide an account of what occurred, but
also may serve as a basis for comparison when in the future somehow related scenarios
arise. Such histories may be detailed enumerations of chronological events or, more
analytically, analyses of interactions that enabled or caused specific developments. The
purpose of this paper is to account for some key developments in the academic field of
geographic information science over the past twenty years (i.e., since 1995) and to
assess some of the impact of these developments. The panel in Bar Harbor, moderated
by David Coleman, included two invited presentations (by Max Egenhofer and Keith
Clarke), and responses by two early career panelists (Song Gao and Teriitutea
Quesnot), and by two senior panelists (Randolph Franklin and May Yuan).
Keywords: Emergence of GIScience; short recent history; outlets of GIScience
research; publication ranking; selected highlights of GIScience research; contributions
to other disciplines; research topics that have disappeared; recently emerging topics.
10 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
1 Introduction
Geographic information system (GIS) as the term and concept preceded geographic
information science. The term geographic information system is widely attributed to
Roger Tomlinson’s Canadian Geographic Information System [88]. The concept spread
over its first twenty years to sizeable software systems whose principal goal was to
perform computerized mapping.
The first Big Book [64] included a chapter by Coppock and Rhind [10], entitled “The
History of GIS,” which described primarily the roles of different organizations in
developing computerized mapping systems. To contrast this history’s focus on vector
representations, Foresman [28] provided a complementary history of GIS from the
raster perspective. A third approach—The GIS History Project [62]—aimed at a critical
examination of the history of GIS. All these efforts highlight that a single history about
geographic information is unlikely to represent fully the many different facets and
linkages that geographic information systems have.
As this paper focuses on developments since the two International Early Career
Summer Institutes in Geographic Information [11, 12], the examination and reflection
on geographic information science is limited here to new insights gained since the mid
1990s.
This chapter summarizes the main ideas and remarks that emerged from both the
panelists (i.e., the authors) and the audience during the first panel session. Specifically,
this panel reviewed the emergence of GIScience (Section 2), and its recent history
(Section 3). Panelists analyzed the proliferation of the terms GIS and GIScience
throughout the literature (Section 4) and examined the journal and competitive
conferences that are dedicated to GIScience (Section 5) and the most frequently cited
articles in some outlets (Section 6). Selected research highlights and contributions to
other disciplines are discussed in Sections 7 and 8, respectively. Finally, the change of
topics in the research landscape (Section 9) and recently emerging topics (Section 10)
are discussed. The chapter closes with conclusions in Section 11.
2 The Emergence of Geographic Information Science
The term Geographic Information Science emerged in the early 1990s. Goodchild’s
keynote address at the Fourth International Symposium on Spatial Data Handling
introduced ideas of some science behind the systems [32]. This approach was very
much in response to concerns expressed by Abler [1] that geographic information
systems were theory-poor, yet in the long term the success of such a field would
require strong theoretical underpinnings.
The introduction of a term that distinguished the systems from the science marked the
start of this transition. While Goodchild’s initial choice was Spatial Information Science
(possibly in line with the Symposium’s name), the longer version of the essay
published in the International Journal of Geographical Information Systems (IJGIS),
replaced spatial with geographical information science [34]. The minor discrepancy
between geographical and geographic had already been addressed by Abler [1] during
the emergence of the NCGIA, attributing the difference to the British (geographical) vs.
US (geographic) linguistic intricacies and the IJGIS’s preferences (Goodchild’s 1991
keynote at EGIS had used the term Geographic Information Science [33]).
Goodchild [36] reflects on twenty years of progress, including these historical accounts
in Geographic Information Science. The twenty-one research initiatives of the National
Center for Geographic Information and Analysis (NCGIA), which fuelled much
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 11
research publication in the GIS field between 1988 and 1996, can be seen as a first
comprehensive GIS research agenda (www.ncgia.ucsb.edu/research/initiatives.html).
Geographic Information Science was quickly adopted as a popular term in academia,
as it promotes scientific endeavors beyond technological GIS applications. The broader
adoption of geographic information science was evident by the establishment of the
(US) University Consortium for Geographic information Science (UCGIS). In 1997, the
flagship journal, IJGIS, changed its name from the International Journal of Geographical
Information Systems to the International Journal of Geographical Information Science.
Then editor-in-chief Peter Fisher highlighted that the name change was only after the
24th character (not counting blanks) so that future volumes would still be most likely
shelved in libraries in close proximity, when sorted alphabetically. A few years later,
the journal Cartography and Geographic Information Systems also adopted the science
term, changing to Cartography and Geographic Information Science. With the initiation of
the International Conference on Geographic Information Science in 2000, the term
Geographic Information Science gained further prominence within the scientific
community, as this biennial conference series caters on the many components of this
interdisciplinary field and its intricacies. The conference series’ acronym (GIScience)
became a popular way to refer to the field, distinguishing it from its systems (GISs).
3 A Short Recent History of Geographic Information
Science
Depending on when one wants to pinpoint the birth of geographic information science,
any of its histories may start between 1990 and 1992. The reflection on the early 1990s
through mid 2010s captured in this section develops from an earlier focus on a
somewhat longer time frame [18] during which the game changers contributed to the
formation of geographic information science, such as Vannevar Bush’s As We May
Think [5], Tomlinson’s Canadian Geographic Information Systems [88], Tobler’s
Computer Movie Simulating Urban Growth [86], Hägerstrand’s Time Geography [46],
Dutton’s Symposium on Data Structures for Geographic Information Systems [15],
Pat Hayes’s Naive Physics Manifesto [48], Peucker’s TINs [73], Tomlin’s Map
Algebra [87], Guttmann’s R-tree [45], and Abler’s vision about the US National Center
for Geographic Information and Analysis [1].
Although held only a week prior to Goodchild’s 1990 keynote [32], the NATO
Advanced Study Institute on Cognitive and Linguistic Aspects of Geographic
Space [66] became the foundation of the cognitive and computational aspects of
geographic information science. Together with the Conference on Spatial Information
Theory (COSIT) series and the Journal of Spatial Cognition and Computation, a subfield
was created that had high impact on geographic information science overall. Twentyfive years later the critique as to whether Las Navas’s Lakoffian credo was more an
advancement or an impediment to bringing other approaches on board [7] is up for
debate.
By 1992 the first traces of micro-sensors started to make an impact on the field as not
only GPS-based location (albeit crude at that time) emerged. The Active Badge
Location Systems [91] pioneered sensor-based location techniques to track people
movement in building complexes. Coupled with the advent of the World-Wide Web,
location data can be quickly disseminated across space. Negroponte’s visionary
account of a Being Digital [72] within a society started a novel perspective, also on
12 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
sharing spatial data digitally, instantaneously. Only shortly afterwards, the visions of
location sensors, the Web, and novel space-time interactions came together in the
concept of Digital Earth [41]. Access to scientific and cultural data with respect to the
sphere would enable global collaboration.
In addition, the virtual reality, augmented reality, and visualization technologies more
broadly pushed for immersive digital environments. The Virtual LA project [51] added
the facet that the traditional map based conveyance of geographic information could be
accomplished in a way that allows users to experience space more like they were
immersed in that space. In addition, the opportunity of combining photo-realistic
renderings of infrastructure with simulations about non-static objects and events
started to bring the community outside of its confines.
The setting of networked sensors [24] provided the backbone for real-time data
collections of distributed phenomena. Geosensor networks [82] highlight the particular
challenges that arise with static and mobile sensor colonies that are spatially
distributed. The amount, complexity, and diversity of datasets that arise within such
geosensor networks have fuelled the contemporary focus on spatial big data [79].
At the beginning of the millennium, the focus shifted towards the meaning of data. The
Semantic Web [4] provided a vision that the Web also needs logic in order to make
automatic inferences about the data. A critical role in this setting is reserved for
ontologies—specifications of conceptualizations [43]. Semantics and ontologies were
further specified within the context of geographic information, yielding such concepts
as the Geospatial Semantic Web [17] and Ontology-Driven GIS [27].
A new development in the recent history of geographic information science is the
concept of volunteered geographic information [35], which puts a focus on spatial data
collections that are community-driven rather than conducted and controlled by a
single authority. As such volunteered data sets do not necessarily follow a prescribed
format, they have the potential of great variability (e.g., quantitative vs. qualitative)
and accuracy. Volunteered datasets to which masses of users contribute have the
enormous prospectus of timely, up-to-date access to spatial information about
phenomena that undergo rapid change.
4 Proliferation of the Terms GIS and GIScience
The terms GIS and GIScience have become increasingly popular within the scientific
world, not only within its own field. In order to quantify such a development, we used
Scopus, the abstract and citation database of peer-reviewed literature to query the
number of publications that contain the keyword GIS or GIScience between 1991 and
2015 (Figure 1). The annual summary counts reveal for phases:
1. Up to 1995, annual counts were less than 1,000.
2. Between 1996 and 2000 the use of the two terms increases modestly to just
below 1,300.
3. Between 2001 and 2010, the counts essentially quadrupled to roughly 6,000
occurrences annually.
4. Since 2010, this count has plateaued at roughly 6,000 annual occurrences of the
terms GIS and GIScience.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 13
Figure 1: Total number of publications with the keywords GIS or GIScience, based on a
Scopus query for the years 1991 through 2015, executed in July 2015.
5 The Outlets of Geographic Information Science over
the last Twenty Years
The landscape of the outlets that cater to advances in geographic information science
and geographic information systems has changed quite dramatically over the last
twenty years. In 1995, the International Journal of Geographical Information Systems (IJGIS)
was the only journal that targeted GIS research as its primary goal. A year later,
Transactions in GIS published its first issue. At the First International Conference on
Geographic Information Science (GIScience 2000), a panel on journals that were interested
in recruiting papers on research in geographic information science was crowded with
editors of sixteen journals (Table 1).
14 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
Table 1: Journals represented at the editors’ panel at GIScience 2000.
Annals of the AAG
| Cartographica |
| Cartography and Geographic Information Science |
| Computers and Geosciences |
| Computers, Environment and Urban Systems |
| Environment and Planning B |
| Geographic Information Sciences |
| Geographical Analysis |
| Geographical Systems |
| GeoInformatica |
| Geomatica |
| International Journal of Geographical Information Science |
| Networks and Spatial Economics |
| Spatial Cognition and Computation |
| Transactions in GIS |
| URISA Journal |
A study of GIScience journals, published in 2008 [8], started with 121 journals, reduced
them to 84 that were deemed more core to GIScience, ultimately focusing on a subset
of 54 in an attempt to rank them. This means the core outlets for GIS and GIScience
research more than tripled over eight years. More recently, further reputable outlets
have appeared, such as the Journal on Spatial Information Science, ACM Transactions on
Algorithms and Systems, Earth Science Informatics, and Open Geospatial Data, Software and
Standard.
The landscape of regularly scheduled conferences that cater to geographic information
science research has seen less volatility. Launching a new journal may be less involved
than sustaining a conference series on a regular basis. The global distribution of the
events over the last 20 years highlights over the years a focus on Europe and North
America.
In the mid 1990s, the Spatial Data Handling Symposia (SDH) dominated the field of
theoretical contributions to GIS (Section 5.5). Autocarto continues as a viable
cartographically-oriented supplement to GIScience, and the AAG meetings included
selected sessions related to GIS research.
In the early 1990s, two new conferences series adopted the computer scientists’ rigor of
fully refereed full papers for conferences with the biennial Symposia on Large Spatial
Databases (SSD) and the Conference on Spatial Information Theory (COSIT) (Section 5.2),
with proceedings published in Springer’s Lectures Notes in Computer Science (LNCS)
series and a single-track conference program. Both established themselves as venues
for focused work in specific subfields of geographic information science. The annual
ACM Workshops on Geographic Information Systems, which also had a rigorous reviewing
system, attracted only small audiences, however.
In order to provide a forum for a more encompassing perspective of geographic
information science research, the biennial conference series on Geographic Information
Science, dubbed GIScience, started in 2000 (Section 5.1). With the formation of ACM
SIGSPATIAL (Section 5.4)—a Special Interest Group with a focus on the acquisition,
management, and processing of spatially-related information—in the early 2000s,
ACM GIS became the SIG’s annual meeting of that SIG, drawing large crowds to the
presentations of fully refereed papers on systems issues in GIS.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 15
Specialized meetings with a focus on a subfield of GIScience continue on Spatial
Accuracy, Spatial Cognition, GeoComputation (Section 5.6), Web and Wireless GIS, and
Digital Earth. Regional GIS meetings (e.g., GISRUK in the UK, AGIT in Austria, GeoInfo
in Brazil) complement the conference landscape.
The GIScience Conferences portal giscienceconferences.org is a comprehensive archive
of these events.
5.1 GIScience
The first International Conference on Geographic Information Science was held in
Savannah (Georgia, USA) in October 2000. It was hosted by NCGIA, UCGIS, and the
AAG. This conference aimed to bring together GIScience researchers from a wide
variety of disciplines, including cognitive science, computer science, engineering,
geography, information science, mathematics, philosophy, psychology, social sciences,
and statistics. In order to focus on fundamental GIScience advances papers that deal
with applications of Geographic Information Systems were systematically discouraged.
This multi-track conference brings around 300 researchers every two years. Since 2002,
GIScience has been offering both fully refereed papers as well as extended abstracts
that were screened by program committee members. This mixture catered to the
different disciplinary preferences in the computational and the geographic fields of
GIScience. Paper sessions are usually preceded by workshops and tutorials and
followed by a poster session.
5.2 COSIT
The initiation of the series of Conferences on Spatial Information Theory (COSIT) was
preceded by the international conference “From Space to Territory: Theories and
Methods of Spatio-Temporal Reasoning”, which was held in Pisa (Italy) in 1992. It is at
times referred as COSIT 0. The first COSIT meeting was held in 1993 as an
interdisciplinary biennial European conference on the representation and processing of
information about geographic space. COSIT changes its venue every two years, and so
far has been held in Australia, Austria, France, Germany, Italy, Switzerland, the UK,
and the US. The COSIT conferences cover multiple fields of interests, such as the
cognitive aspects of geographic information, the ontology of space, cartography, and
behavioral geography. COSIT is a single-track conference. It includes a doctoral
colloquium, workshops, tutorials, and poster presentations. Full papers have been
published in the LNCS series. Between 100 and 130 researchers participate in COSIT
every two years.
5.3 AGILE
The mission of the Association of Geographic Information Laboratories for Europe
(AGILE) is to “promote academic teaching and research on GIS at the European level
and to stimulate and support networking activities between member laboratories.”
This mission is notably achieved through an annual research conference that
systematically takes place in Europe. AGILE’s conference series on Geographic
Information Science started in 1998 in Enschede (Netherlands) and clearly became a
European reference in the area of GIScience. This conference focuses on research areas
related to GIScience, from spatial cognition to geodesign, through health and medical
Informatics. Full articles are published in Springer’s Lecture Notes in Geoinformation
and Cartography, whereas short papers are included in different electronic
proceedings.
16 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
5.4 ACM SIGSPATIAL
The ACM SIGSPATIAL International Conferences on Advances in Geographic
Information Systems is nowadays a series of symposia and workshops. It brings
together researchers and developers specialized in GIS and other systems based on
geospatial data. ACM SIGSPATIAL clearly emphasizes the technical aspects of
geographic information systems (e.g., algorithms, database systems, and geometric
computations). This annual conference is typically sponsored by such companies as
ESRI, Google, Oracle, and Microsoft. ACM SIGSPATIAL is organized around paper
and demo sessions as well as Ph.D. showcases. Topics addressed during ACM
SIGSPATIAL cover numerous research areas (e.g., currently Big Spatial Data, GPU and
Novel Hardware Solutions, Spatial Data Analytics, and Web and Real-Time
Applications). Proceedings are published by ACM.
5.5 Spatial Data Handling
The international symposium on Spatial Data Handling (SDH) began in Zurich
(Switzerland) in 1984. It is the key meeting of the International Geographical Union
(IGU) Commissions on Geographical Information Science and on Modeling
Geographical Systems. SDH is a well-know biennial research forum in the field of
GIScience. It brings together geographers, cartographers, computer scientists, and
other GIScientists every two years. The latest SDH (16th) was held in Toronto in
October 2014 jointly with the ISPRS Technical Commission II Symposium.
5.6 GeoComputation
The GeoComputation meetings started in 1996 in Leeds (UK) as an annual conference
centered on geographic analysis, statistics, modeling, and computation algorithms for
geospatial data. GeoComputation takes place every alternate year with the GIScience
conference since 2002. This is a classic conference where workshops, paper sessions,
and poster presentations are proposed.
6 Systematic Analyses of Publications
The development of a scientific community relies on many researchers and key
players’ contributions to this domain. A past analysis of social and spatial networks
aimed at identifying patterns of collaborations among researchers, universities, and
institutions in GIScience [2]. The results revealed to what degree individual trajectories
(change of affiliations) of researchers impact the formation of a network of the
GIScience communities. Citation counts remain a key currency when assessing the
impact of research. André Skupin presented a citation analysis of the GIScience
literature at the 2008 symposium, which identified Peter Burrough, Mike Goodchild,
and Max Egenhofer as the three most-cited researchers in GIScience [36]. These results
might be biased, however, because of the bibliographic datasets used in the analysis.
In a complementary analysis, Keßler et al. demonstrated how to semantically annotate
and interlink bibliographic datasets using Linked Data technology and enable complex
queries [49]. One such query showed that by 2012 only seventeen researchers had
published full papers at ACM GIS, COSIT, and GIScience conferences, and another five
have met this criterion in the meantime (Table 2). Most of them either have a
background in computer science or collaborate with computer scientists.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 17
Table 2: The seventeen researchers who published at least one full paper in each of the
three conference series ACM GIS, COSIT, and GIScience by 2012 [52], plus the five who
joined this club by 2015.
| Benjamin Adams | Krzysztof Janowicz | Andrea Rodríguez |
| Christophe Claramunt | Christopher B. Jones | John Stell |
| Matthew P. Dube | Werner Kuhn | Egemen Tanin |
| Matt Duckham | Lars Kulik | Jan Oliver Wallgrün |
| Max J. Egenhofer | Ross S. Purves | Stephan Winter |
| Leila De Floriani | Martin Raubal | Michael Worboys |
| Andrew U. Frank | Kai-Florian Richter | |
| Mark Gahegan | Claus Rinner |
In order to complement the previous review and assessment, we employed two
analyses based on 2015 data. The first analysis focuses on the most frequently cited
articles in key outlet (Section 6.1). The citation searches focused on two journals and
two refereed conferences. The second analysis looked at the development of the most
prominent terms used in the publications of a conference series over seven consecutive
events (Section 6.2).
6.1 Most Frequently Cited Papers in Selected GIScience Outlets
Occasionally, journal editors have published citation counts of their top-rated articles
in editorials of their journal [26, 57]. These counts show that typically, publications
must have been disseminated for some time before they collect significant numbers of
citations. Also, more dated publications have a greater opportunity to collect more
citations. While these side effects seem to favor mostly dated work, novel seminal
work often rises quickly into the top of the charts.
Here we used Google Scholar to identify the ten most frequently cited articles in five
different GIS and GIScience outlets: (1) The International Journal of Geographical
Information Science, and its predecessor The International Journal of Geographical
Information Systems (IJGIS), (2) Transactions in GIS (TG), (3) the series of conferences on
spatial information theory (COSIT), and (4) the GIScience conference series.
Among these four samples, the IJGIS citation counts are the highest (Table 3). IJGIS has
the longest history of the four (published since 1987) and the highest frequency. Three
of its top-ten papers appeared in 1995, the year of the first Young Scholars Institute.
Four of the top cited papers appeared during the pioneering years of geographic
information science. Only one of the top ranked papers—a survey article—appeared
after 2000. The top-ten articles are mostly methodological, focusing on novel theories
and models. IJGIS’s most frequently cited article relates to advances in theory, in
particular the modeling of spatial relations, one of the five bullets in the NCGIA
solicitation [1].
The top citation counts for TG include an article from the TG’s inaugural issue in 1996,
and most of the remainder from the early 2000s (Table 4). A rapidly rising paper from
2010 relates to the emerging theme of volunteered geographic information, while the
most frequently cited paper in TG addresses ontologies, one of the topics that are
emerged in recent years (Section 10.1). Unlike in the other samples publications, topics
related to the geographies of the information society [80] are more prominently
represented in TG’s top ten.
18 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
The COSIT conference series (Table 5), including the 1992 meeting in Pisa, reveals very
high citation counts in its early years (1992–1995), and another peak in 1999. Cognitive,
computational, and conceptual work is fairly balanced among the top COSIT papers.
Like with the IJGIS, COSIT’s most frequently cited paper focuses on the modeling of
spatial relations.
The GIScience conference series (Table 6) has the shortest history among the sampled
outlets as it started with full papers only in 2002. Nine of its top-ten papers are from
the first two LNCS volumes covering Geographic Information Science. Its top ranked
article deals with landmarks, a topic that also fared well among the COSIT papers.
Table 3: The ten most frequently cited articles published in the International Journal of
Geographical Information Science/Systems, based on Google Scholar.
| Title | Authors | Year published |
as of August 2015 |
| Point-set topological spatial relations | Egenhofer and Franzosa |
1991 | 1,808 |
| The GARP modelling system: problems and solutions to automated spatial prediction |
Stockwell | 1999 | 1,185 |
| Integrating multi-criteria evaluation with geographical information systems |
Carver | 1991 | 891 |
| Loose-coupling a cellular automaton model and GIS: long-term urban growth prediction for San Francisco and Washington/Baltimore |
Clarke and Gaydos |
1998 | 858 |
| Geographical information science | Goodchild | 1992 | 858 |
| Kriging: a method of interpolation for geographical information systems |
Oliver and Webster |
1990 | 784 |
| Integrating geographical information systems and multiple criteria decision-making methods |
Jankowski | 1995 | 667 |
| GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature |
Malczewski | 2006 | 637 |
| An event-based spatiotemporal data model (ESTDM) for temporal analysis of geographical data |
Peuquet and Duan |
1995 | 605 |
| Interpolating mean rainfall using thin plate smoothing splines |
Hutchinson | 1995 | 551 |
Cited by
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 19
Table 4: The ten most frequently cited articles published in Transactions in GIS, based
on Google Scholar.
| Title | Authors | Year published |
as of August 2015 |
| Using ontologies for integrated geographic information systems |
Fonseca, Egenhofer, Agouris, and Câmara |
2002 | 507 |
| Integrating dynamic environmental models in GIS: the development of a dynamic modelling language |
Wesselung, Karssenberg, Burrough , and van Deursen |
1996 | 286 |
| GI science, disasters, and emergency management |
Cuttler | 2003 | 226 |
| Critical issues in participatory GIS: deconstructions, reconstructions, and new research directions |
Elwood | 2003 | 212 |
| A new GIS-based solar radiation model and its application to photovoltaic assessments |
Šúri and Hofierka | 2004 | 202 |
| Quality assessment of the French OpenStreetMap dataset |
Girres and Touya | 2010 | 196 |
| On the use of weighted linear combination method in GIS: common and best practice approaches |
Malczewski | 2000 | 180 |
| Use of information technology for community empowerment: transforming geographic information systems into community information systems |
Ghose | 2001 | 175 |
| Integration of space syntax into GIS: new perspectives for urban morphology |
Jiang and Claramunt |
2002 | 176 |
| Technical Note: A GIS-coupled hydrological model system for the watershed assessment of agricultural nonpoint and point sources of pollution |
Di Luzio and Srinivasan |
2004 | 165 |
Cited by
20 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
Table 5: The ten most frequently cited papers published in the proceedings of the
Conference on Spatial Information Theory (including COSIT 0), based on Google Scholar.
| Title | Authors | published | as of August 2015 |
| Using orientation information for qualitative spatial reasoning |
Freksa | 1992 | 648 |
| Naive geography | Egenhofer and Mark | 1995 | 600 |
| Cognitive maps, cognitive collages, and spatial mental models |
Tversky | 1993 | 526 |
| Scale and multiple psychologies of space |
Montello | 1993 | 416 |
| Reasoning about gradual changes of topological relationships |
Egenhofer and Al Taha |
1992 | 399 |
| People manipulate objects (but cultivate fields): beyond the raster vector debate in GIS |
Couclelis | 1992 | 389 |
| The nature of landmarks for real and electronic spaces |
Sorrows and Hirtle | 1999 | 358 |
| Network and psychological effects in urban movement |
Hillier and Iida | 2005 | 287 |
| Elements of good route directions in familiar and unfamiliar environments |
Lovelace, Hegarty, and Montello |
1999 | 285 |
| Pictorial and verbal tools for conveying routes |
Tversky and Lee | 1999 | 280 |
Year
Cited by
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 21
Table 6: The ten most frequently cited papers published in the fully-refereed
proceedings of the GIScience, conference series based on Google Scholar.
Title Authors Year
| published | as of August 2015 |
||
| Enriching wayfinding instructions with local landmarks |
Raubal and Winter | 2002 | 381 |
| The SPIRIT spatial search engine: architecture, ontologies and spatial indexing |
Jones, Abdelmoty, Finch, and Fu |
2004 | 165 |
| From objects to events: GEM, the geospatial event model |
Worboys and Hornsby |
2004 | 164 |
| Project Lachesis: parsing and modeling location histories |
Hariharan and Toyama |
2004 | 168 |
| Analyzing relative motion within groups oftrackable moving point objects |
Laube and Imfeld | 2002 | 125 |
| Transmitting vector geospatial data across the Internet |
Buttenfield | 2002 | 123 |
| Modeling the semantics of geographic categories through conceptual integration |
Kuhn | 2002 | 91 |
| GeoVSM: An integrated retrieval model for geographic information |
Cai | 2002 | 59 |
| Semi-automatic ontology alignment for geospatial data integration |
Cruz, Sunna, and Chaudhry |
2004 | 57 |
| What is the region occupied by a set of points? |
Galton and Duckham |
2006 | 57 |
Cited by
6.2 The Evolution of Terms in the GIScience Conference Series
The seven LNCS volumes of full papers published biennially in the GIScience meetings
since 2002 provide a relatively concise opportunity to examine how specific terms were
a focus in these articles of a period of twelve years. The word clouds for the titles and
keywords of all full papers in these seven conferences (Figure 2) present some
spatialization of the text strings. Authors used consistently the terms spatial and data in
high frequency (although not necessarily in combination). Also information and science
appear prominently throughout the years. Spatial is used consistently more frequently
than geographic or geospatial. In recent years, the terms ontology, indoor, and dynamic
emerged.
22 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
GIScience 2002 GIScience 2004
GIScience 2006 GIScience 2008
GIScience 2010 GIScience 2012
GIScience 2014
Figure 2: Word clouds of full papers of the GIScience conference 2002–2014.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 23
7 Selected Research Highlights
7.1 Advances in Theory
As the core concept of GIScience is to study the science behind the systems, great efforts
have been made towards advances in geographic information theories, such as models
for spatial relations [19, 21, 29, 42, 74] and uncertainty in geographic data and GIS
analysis, which exists in the whole process of data acquisition, geographical
abstraction, representation, processing and visualization [94]. The studies of
uncertainty help researchers and decision makers make better use of complex, multidimensional spatial data with regard to quality control that needs special handling,
cleaning, and processing. Fisher discussed the critical causes and conceptual models of
uncertainty in spatial data with a number of real-world examples [25]. Methods to
visualize uncertainty information on maps were proposed and summarized [60, 62].
Longley et al. suggested five general dimensions of uncertainty in GIS data [59],
namely, attribute accuracy, positional accuracy, logical consistency, completeness and
lineage. Achievements in this field advance scientific analysis for geographic data.
7.2 The Cognitive World
UCGIS’s research challenge on “Cognition of Geographic Information” investigates the
understanding of human perception, memory, reasoning and communication toward
spatial phenomena. Four of the former NCGIA research initiatives were dedicated to
this theme (I2: Languages of Spatial Relations, I10: Spatiotemporal Reasoning in GIS,
I13: User Interfaces for GIS, and I21: Formal Models of the Common Sense Geographic
Worlds). In the same vein, the NCGIA’s Varenius Project included a specific topic on
“Cognitive Models of Geographic Space” [67]. The book The Cognition of Geographic
Space [53] and the UCGIS research agenda on Cognition of Geographic Information [71]
provide a clear overview of the main contributions done before the establishment of
GIScience in 1992. These reviews notably include the concept of cognitive maps [14],
theories of human spatial knowledge [78] and its acquisition from direct experience,
languages, and maps [84, 85]. Recent advancements in the area of cognitive GIScience
fall into the categories of (1) human factors of GIS, (2) geovisualization, (3) navigation
systems, (4) cognitive geo-ontologies, (5) geographic and environmental spatial
thinking and memory, and (6) cognitive aspects of geographic education [70].
7.3 The Computational World
Spatial is special [16]. The storage of geographic data needs to handle not only the
attributes but also the geometry information. In addition, the rates of geographic data
generation were becoming far greater than that of the capabilities for the effective
processing, storage, manipulation and analysis of such datasets. Thus new approaches
to GIS data models, structures, management, queries and algorithms have been
developed in the computational world to advance GIS-based computing and
applications [76, 78].
7.4 The Social World
The NSF-funded National Center for Geographic Information and Analysis (NCGIA)
helped establish a global standard core curriculum in GIS [39]. This NCGIA Core
Curriculum was expanded from a set of hard copy lesson plans to various versions of
an on-line shared curriculum, which fuelled the teaching of GIS, both within the
24 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
discipline as well as the dissemination to many fields that use GIS in their domain
analyses. At the same time, the expansion of textbooks at all levels in the field has been
extraordinary. An important recent development has been the creation and subsequent
improvement of the Geographic Information Science and Technology Body of
Knowledge (www.aag.org/bok) [13]. This detailed specification of the core concepts
and skill sets necessary for study and proficiency in GIS has influenced the Department
of Labor’s job specifications and descriptions, and is now supported by substantial
online tools and an online ontology (http://gistbok.org/). In recent years the
availability of online social networks and VGI outlets has led to a sub-field of GIS that
studies social interactions via the Internet and the World Wide Web, using such tools
as the geotags in Flickr, place names in tweets, and geocodes in Foursquare, Google+,
and others. These activities often involve “big data” applications over millions or
billions of records, challenging the limits of traditional desktop GIS [47].
8 Contributions of GIS to other Disciplines
GIS has made contributions to various domains in computer science, such as
computational geometry. Geographers, such as at the Census, have been creating tools
to process large databases since before the term computational geometry was even used
in this context. One GIS contribution is to provide particularly hard problems with
large datasets that need workable, fast solutions. An example is label placement on
maps.
Another contribution within computer science is to the database domain. Spatial data
types have been brought into mainstream databases with geospatial data model and
query language support (e.g., Geodatabase, Oracle Spatial, PostgreSQL), as well as
providing spatial indexing and spatial join methods [44]. However, more research is
needed to improve support for network and field data, as well as spatial stream query
processing [6, 77, 78].
In addition, the visualization of geographic information also draws a lot of attention
from the computer scientists. Research of representation, visualization-computation
integration, interfaces, cognitive/usability issues in geovisualization should be
addressed in these crosscutting challenges [61]. Efforts have been made to foster a
capable and integrated science and engineering community to conquer these
challenges.
This influence of GIS is in the tradition of mathematics and physics where the big
theoretical advances and conceptual unifications respond to applied problems. For
example, in physics, Newton’s theory of gravity described and unified both the orbit of
the moon and the trajectories of small thrown objects. In GIS, the problem of
overlaying two maps with almost coincident edges that cause slivers and rounding
errors motivates the study of robust geometric algorithms in Computational Geometry.
This crosscutting influence has great potential to continue into the future, when
various 2D GIS algorithms may extend into 3D. For instance, overlaying maps in GIS
in 2D provides techniques that can lead to overlaying 3D triangulations, a new
approach that has benefits in the domains of Computer Aided Design and
computational fluid dynamics.
Countless application domains have benefitted from GIS spatial analysis over the past
twenty years. The two Big Books [58, 64] offer detailed accounts for many areas, but
more recent advancements continue to ignite new cross-fertilizations, some of which
we address here.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 25
In regional planning and urban studies, GIS has been widely applied as an analysis
and modeling tool to support decision-making [93], and as a simulator for urban
growth [9].
Advancements in GIS also enabled GeoDesign as an emerging sub-field of landscape
architecture that is supported by spatial decision analytical tools and illustrates using
science in design as well as design in science [3]. Also, GIScience brings spatial analysis
and statistics, as well as other location intelligence components, to facilitate traditional
social science research, such as migration, demographics, crime analysis [49], and
spatiotemporal access to urban opportunities [56].
In digital humanities, the development of geographic information retrieval spatial
search, and digital gazetteer research has contributed to the new form of geolibrary
[38]. The scientometrics community also addressed the importance of geospatial
components in the scientific analysis of bibliographic data in order to identify
institutional and international research collaboration and citation impact patterns [30].
GIS has led the spatial turn in health studies, in which spatial data, analysis, and global
health research will be systematically incorporated for creating new discovery
pathways in science [75]. This facilitates opportunities for new interdisciplinary
research in which GIScientists to collaborate with medical scientists on research funded
by the National Institutes of Health.
9 Changes of Topics in the Research Agenda of
Geographic Information Science
Over the past twenty years, the research agenda in geographic information science has
gone through a variety of iterations (Table 7), starting with Goodchild’s initial list. The
University Consortium for Geographic Information Science established in 1996 a list of
ten research priorities [89]. The Varenius Project of the National Center for Geographic
Information and Analysis [37] concisely formulated three research thrusts—cognitive
[67], computational [20], and societal issues [80]. UCGIS updated its research priorities
in 2004 and augmented them by another four challenges [63].
26 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
Table 7: Major priorities in GIScience research.
Goodchild [34] Data collection and measurement
| Data capture Spatial statistics Data modeling and theories of spatial data Data structures, algorithms, and processes Display Analytical tools Institutional, managerial, and ethical issues |
|
| UCGIS [89] | Research Priorities: Spatial data acquisition and integration Distributed computing Extensions to geographic representations Cognition of geographic information Spatial analysis in a GIS environment Future of the spatial information infrastructure Uncertainty in spatial data Interoperability of geographic information Scale GIS and society |
| Varenius [37] | Strategic Areas for Geographic Information Science Research Cognitive models of geographic space Computational methods for representing geographic concepts Geographies of the information society |
| UCGIS [63] | Research Challenges: Spatial data acquisition and integration Cognition of geographic information Scale Extension to geographic representations Spatial analysis and modeling in a GIS environment Uncertainty in geographic data and GIS-based analysis The future of the spatial information infrastructure Distributed and mobile computing Interoperability GIS and society: interrelation, integration, and transformation |
| UCGIS [63] | Emerging Themes: Geographic visualization Ontological foundations for GIScience Remotely acquired data and information in GIScience Geospatial data mining and knowledge discovery |
The major topics and priorities of GIScience research have changed over time. Some of
them disappeared or were less developed than other topics, while new topics have also
emerged. It is interesting to see how these research topics have been changed with
regards to the twenty-one NCGIA research initiatives
(http://www.ncgia.ucsb.edu/research/initiatives.html), which focused on the basic
research on geographic analysis utilizing GIS and brought all parts of the GIS
community to lay out appropriate research agenda. The topics of data modeling and
theories of spatial data seem to be well studied with the achievements of vector, raster,
and hybrid models in GIS. The geo-atom model, which represents the association
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 27
between space-time point and property, can be taken as one of the generic forms for
geographic information representations and combine discrete objects and continuous
fields [40]. The research on geospatial data structures and modeling are related to the
initiatives of “accuracy of spatial databases” and “multiple representations.”
10 Topics that Recently Emerged in the GIScience
Research Agenda
A series of new topics emerged recently in GIScience. Many of the are technologydriven or aimed at the development of new technologies, such as crowd-based
solutions; spatial analysis of social media data; high-performance computing and the
cloud; open-source solutions and software mashups; web-based mapping applications;
location-based services and mobile computing; embedded solutions (e.g., within GPS
routing systems), sensor-networks and their integration into real-time GIS; and
integration of spatial and temporal processes into GIS functionality. We elaborate on
four research threads (Sections 10.1-10.4) that are currently most prominent.
10.1 Ontologies in GIS
The study of ontologies in GIS bridges the gap between implementation and human
conceptual modeling for representing geospatial phenomena and their analysis.
Although it was not listed in the original research initiatives, it did play an increasing
role in the series of core GIScience conference topics, as shown in the word cloud
visualization of GIScience conference topics (Figure 2). Ontology plays an important
role in knowledge organization and information integration. The use of ontologies in
GIS development has been widely discussed in related research [27, 68], but relatively
few studies have addressed the design of the user interface based on semantic
integration [55]. Semantic reference systems were suggested for solving semantic
interoperability issues, especially to ground geospatial semantics in physical processes
and measurements [54]. With the advent of Semantic Web and Linked Data, research
on geospatial semantics is valuable for GIScientists interested in semantics research as
well as knowledge engineers interested in spatiotemporal data exploration [50].
10.2 Volunteered Geographic Information
The emergence of volunteered geographic information [35] and community mapping
engaged the fast growth of citizen science. The research on credibility, geoprivacy and
other societal implication issues become more and more important as the growth of
ubiquitous location awareness devices and crowdsourcing studies on geospatial Web
[23, 83].
10.3 Spatial Big Data
Recently, as the context for geographic research evolves from a data-scarce to a datarich or big-data environment, a data-driven geography [66] is emerging that describes
large volumes of data with a geospatial component (including structured, semistructured, and unstructured data) for various aspects of environment and society as is
being created by millions of sensors constantly, in a variety of formats such as remotely
sensed imagery, GPS logs, maps, blogs, videos, audios, and photos [31]. This trend
sheds new light on spatial modeling and geographic knowledge discovery, and brings
28 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
about innovative developments in GIScience. The topic of spatial big data has emerged
as one of the research challenges for advancing GIS in a new era.
10.4 CyberGIS
With the advancement of representative cloud computing systems, clusters and grids,
high performance computing infrastructures have attracted increasing attention for
GIScientists and geographers as a way of solving data-intensive, computingintensive,and access-intensive geospatial problems [92]. The emerging concept of
CyberGIS, which synthesizes cyberinfrastructure, spatial analysis, and highperformance computing, provides not only a promising solution to aforementioned
geospatial problems as a cloud service but also facilitates a community-driven and
participatory approach to achieve scientific breakthroughs across geospatial and other
communities [90].
11 Conclusions
Twenty years after the first Young Scholars Summer Institute in Geographic
Information, we reviewed the advances in the field. The field is still vibrant and
continues to reinvigorate itself with new challenges. Awareness of GIS and Geographic
Information Science has increased significantly, and the academic field has matured
with a much wider set of outlets for the dissemination of research results. Progress in
Geographic Information Science has come through seminal work, but inside and
outside of the field, which reflects its interdisciplinary character. Frequently, new
technology has required novel approaches to dealing with spatial data and
communicating spatial information. Over the last 20 years, the Web and mobile
computing have provided unprecedented new opportunities, to which the GIScience
research community responded with the development of a plethora of new methods. It
is critical that the community is led by the formulation of big intellectual challenges,
like those presented in the NCGIA solicitation [1], and the visions of a geographic
information science [34], a Naive Geography [22], a Digital Earth [41], a geospatial
semantic web [17], or the volunteered geographic information [35].
Acknowledgments
The panelists are grateful to the organizers of the 2015 Vespucci Summer Institute and
the Institute’s support provided by the US Bureau of the Census and by ESRI.
Max Egenhofer’s work is partially supported by NSF grants IIS-1016740 and IIS-
1527504. Keith Clarke acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation via
the I-UCRC program and the Spatio-temporal Innovation Center. Song Gao is
supported by a Jack & Laura Dangermond Travel Scholarship and thanks his Ph.D.
advisory committee Krzysztof Janowicz, Michael F. Goodchild, and Helen Couclelis
from the Department of Geography at the University of California, Santa Barbara.
Teriitutea Quesnot is supported by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research
Council of Canada (SSHRC) and the Geothink.ca project and he thanks his Ph.D.
advisor Stephane Roche from the Geomatics Department at Laval University.
Randolph Franklin is supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant
No. IIS-1117277. May Yuan’s work is partially supported by NSF grant OCI-0941501.
David Coleman’s research is supported by the Natural Sciences and Engineering
Research Council of Canada.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 29
References
[1] ABLER, R. F. The National Science Foundation National Center for Geographic
Information and Analysis. International Journal of Geographical Information
System 1, 4 (1987) 303–326.
[2] AGARWAL, P., BÉRA, R., AND CLARAMUNT, C. A social and spatial network
approach to the investigation of research communities over the World Wide
Web. In GIScience 2006: Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on
Geographic Information Science, N. Xiao, M.-P. Kwan, M. Goodchild, S., Eds.,
(Berlin, 2006), Springer, LNCS vol. 4197, pp. 1–17.
[3] BATTY, M. Defining geodesign (= GIS+ design?). Environment and Planning B:
Planning and Design 40, 1 (2013), 1–2.
[4] BERNERS-LEE, T., HENDLER, J., AND LASSILA, O. The semantic web.
Scientific American 284, 5 (2001): 28–37.
[5] BUSH, V. As we may think. The Atlantic Monthly. 176, 1 (1945), 101–108.
[6] CÂMARA, G., EGENHOFER, M. J., FERREIRA K., ANDRADE, P., QUEIROZ,
G., SANCHEZ A., JONES, J., AND VINHAS, L. Fields as a generic data type for
big spatial data. In GIScience 2014: Proceedings of the Eighth International
Conference on Geographic Information Science, M. Duckham, E. Pebesma, K.
Stewart, and A. Frank, Eds., (Berlin, 2014), Springer, LNCS vol. 8728, pp. 159–
172.
[7] CÂMARA, G. Revisiting research agendas in geographic information science,
Keynote, Vespucci Week in Advancing GIScience, Bar Harbor, ME,
http://www.dpi.inpe.br/gilberto/present/gcamara_vespucci_2015.pptx
[8] CARON, C., ROCHE, S., GOYER, D., AND JATON, A. GIScience journals
ranking and evaluation: an international delphi study. Transactions in GIS 12, 3
(2008), 293-321.
[9] CLARKE, K. C., AND GAYDOS. Loose-coupling a cellular automaton model and
GIS: long-term urban growth prediction for San Francisco and
Washington/Baltimore. International Journal of Geographical Information
Science 12, 7 (1998), 699–714.
[10] COPPOCK, J. T., AND RHIND, D. W. The history of GIS. In Geographical
Information Systems: Principles and Applications, D.J. Maguire, M.F. Goodchild,
and D.W. Rhind, Eds. Longman, 1991, pp. 21–43.
[11] CRAGLIA, M., AND COUCLELIS, H., Eds., Geographic information research:
Bridging the Atlantic. Taylor & Francis, 1997.
[12] CRAGLIA, M., AND ONSRUD, H., Eds., Geographic Information Research:
Transatlantic Perspectives. CRC Press, 1998.
[13] DIBIASE, D., DEMERS, M., JOHNSON, A., KEMP, K. K., LUCK, A. T., PLEWE,
B., AND WENTZ, E. Introducing the first edition of geographic information
science and technology body of knowledge. Cartography and Geographic
Information Science 34, 2 (2007), 113-120.
[14] DOWNS, R. M., AND STEA, D. Cognitive maps and spatial behavior: process
and products. In Image and Environment: Cognitive Mapping and Spatial
Behavior, R. M. Downs and D. Stea, Eds. Aldine Press, Chicago, pp. 8-26, 1973.
30 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
[15] DUTTON, G. First International Advanced Study Symposium on Topological
Data Structures for Geographic Information Systems, Vol.1-8, Harvard
University, Cambridge, MA, 1978.
[16] EGENHOFER, M. J. What’s special about spatial?—database requirements for
vehicle navigation in geographic space. ACM SIGMOD Record 22, 2 (1993), 398-
402.
[17] EGENHOFER, M. J. Toward the semantic geospatial web. In GIS ’02: Proceedings
of the 10th ACM International Symposium on Advances in Geographic
Information Systems (New York, NY, USA, 2002), ACM Press, pp.1–4.
[18] EGENHOFER, M. J. A future history of geographic information science
(Keynote), GeoInfo 2014, (Campos do Jordão, Brazil, 2014),
http://www.spatial.maine.edu/~max/FutureHistory.mov.
[19] EGENHOFER, M. J., AND FRANZOSA, R. F. Point-set topological spatial
relations. International Journal of Geographical Information Systems 5, 2 (1991),
161-174.
[20] EGENHOFER, M. J., GLASGOW, J., GUNTHER, O., HERRING, J. R., AND
PEUQUET, D. J. Progress in computational methods for representing
geographical concepts. International Journal of Geographical Information Science
13, 8 (1999), 775-796.
[21] EGENHOFER, M. J., AND HERRING, J. R. Categorizing binary topological
relations between regions, lines, and points in geographic databases, Tech. Rep.,
Department of Surveying Engineering, University of Maine, 1990.
[22] EGENHOFER, M. J., AND MARK, D. M. Naive geography. In: COSIT 1995:
Proceedings of the International Conference on Spatial Information Theory: A
Theoretical Basis for GIS, A. U. Frank and W. Kuhn, Eds. (Berlin, 1995), pp. 1-15.
[23] ELWOOD, S. Geographic information science: emerging research on the societal
implications of the geospatial web. Progress in Human Geography 34, 3, 2010,
349–357.
[24] ESTRIN, D., GOVINDAN, R., HEIDEMANN, J., AND KUMAR, S. Next century
challenges: scalable coordination in sensor networks. In MobiCom ’99:
Proceedings of the 5th Annual ACM/IEEE International Conference on Mobile
Computing and Networking (New York, NY, USA, 1999), ACM Press, pp. 263–
270.
[25] FISHER, P. F. Models of Uncertainty in Spatial Data. Geographical Information
Systems 1, (1999), 191–205.
[26] FISHER, P. F. Citations to the international journal of geographical information
systems and science: the first 10 years. International Journal of Geographical
Information Science 15 (2001), 1–6.
[27] FONSECA, F. T., EGENHOFER, M. J., AGOURIS, P., AND CÂMARA, G. Using
ontologies for integrated geographic information systems. Transactions in GIS 6,
3 (2002), 231–257.
[28] FORESMAN, T. W. Ed. The History of Geographic Information Systems:
Perspectives from the Pioneers. Prentice Hall, Chicago, 1998.
[29] FRANK, A. U. Qualitative spatial reasoning about distances and directions in
geographic space. Journal of Visual Languages & Computing 3, 4 (1992), 343-371.
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 31
[30] FRENKEN, K., HARDEMAN, S., AND HOEKMAN, J. Spatial scientometrics:
towards a cumulative research program. Journal of Informetrics 3, 3 (2009), 222–
232.
[31] GAO, S., LI, L., LI, W., JANOWICZ, K., AND ZHANG, Y. Constructing
gazetteers from volunteered big geodata based on Hadoop. Computers,
Environment and Urban Systems (in press).
[32] GOODCHILD, M. F. Spatial Information Science. In Fourth International
Symposium on Spatial Data Handling (Zurich, 1990) vol. 1: pp. 3–14.
[33] GOODCHILD, M. F. Progress on the GIS Research Agenda. In EGIS: Proceedings
of the Second European GIS Conference (Utrecht: The Netherlands, 1991), EGIS
Foundation, pp. 342–350.
[34] GOODCHILD, M. F. Geographical information science. International Journal of
Geographical Information Systems 6, 1 (1992), 31–45.
[35] GOODCHILD, M. F. Citizens as sensors: the world of volunteered geography.
GeoJournal 69, 4, (2007), 211–221.
[36] GOODCHILD, M. F. Twenty years of progress: GIScience in 2010. Journal of
Spatial Information Science 1, (2010), 3–20.
[37] GOODCHILD, M. F., EGENHOFER, M. J., KEMP, K. K., MARK, D. M., AND
SHEPPARD, E. Introduction to the Varenius project. International Journal of
Geographical Information Science 13, 8 (1999), 731-745.
[38] GOODCHILD, M. F., AND HILL, L. Introduction to digital gazetteer research.
International Journal of Geographical Information Science 22, 10 (2008), 1039–
1044.
[39] GOODCHILD, M. F., AND KEMP K. K. NCGIA education activities: the core
curriculum and beyond. International Journal of Geographical Information
Systems 6, no. 4 (1992): 309-320.
[40] GOODCHILD, M. F., YUAN, M., AND COVA, T. J. Towards a general theory of
geographic representation in GIS. International Journal of Geographical
Information Science 21, 3, (2007): 239–260.
[41] GORE, A. The digital earth: understanding our planet in the 21st century.
Australian surveyor 43, 2 (1998), 89–91.
[42] GOYAL, R., AND EGENHOFER, M. J. The direction-relation matrix: a
representation of direction relations for extended spatial objects. UCGIS Annual
Assembly and Summer Retreat (Bar Harbor, ME, USA, 1997),
http://www.spatial.maine.edu/~max/DRM.pdf.
[43] GRUBER, T. R. Toward principles for the design of ontologies used for
knowledge sharing. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 43, 5,
(1995), 907–928.
[44] GÜTING, R. H. An introduction to spatial database systems. The VLDB Journal
3, 4, (1994), 357–399.
[45] GUTTMAN, A. R-trees: A dynamic index structure for spatial searching. In
SIGMOD ’84: Proceedings of the 1984 ACM SIGMOD International Conference
on Management of Data (New York, NY, USA, 1984), ACM Press, pp. 47–57.
32 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
[46] HÄGERSTRAAND, T. What about people in regional Science? Papers in
Regional Science 24, 1 (1970), 7–24.
[47] HAN, S.Y., TSOU M.-H., AND CLARKE, K. C. Do Global Cities Enable Global
Views? Using Twitter to Quantify the Level of Geographical Awareness of US
Cities. PloS one 10, 7 (2015).
[48] HAYES, P. J. The naive physics manifesto. In Expert Systems in the MicroElectronic Age, D. Michie, Ed., Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, UK,
1979, pp. 242–270.
[49] HIRSCHFIELD, A., BROWN P., AND TODD, P. GIS and the analysis of
spatially-referenced crime data: experiences in Merseyside, UK. International
Journal of Geographical Information Systems 9, 2 (1995), 191–210.
[50] JANOWICZ, K., SCHEIDER, S., PEHLE, T., AND HART, G. Geospatial semantics
and linked spatio-temporal data—past, present, and future. Semantic Web 3, 4
(2012), 321–332.
[51] JEPSON, W., LIGGETT, R., AND FRIEDMAN, S. Virtual modeling of urban
environments. Presence—Teleoperators and Virtual Environments 5, 1 (1995),
72–86.
[52] KESSLER, C., JANOWICZ, K., AND KAUPPINEN, T. Spatial@linkedscience—
exploring the research field of GIScience with linked data. In GIScience 2012:
Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Geographic Information
Science, N. Xiao, M.-P. Kwan, M. Goodchild, and S. Shekhar, Eds., (Berlin, 2012),
Springer, LNCS vol. 7478, pp. 102–115.
[53] KITCHIN, R., AND M. BLADES. The Cognition of Geographical Space. I. B.
Taurus Publishers, 2001.
[54] KUHN, W. Semantic reference systems. International Journal of Geographical
Information Science 17, 5 (2003), 405–409.
[55] KUHN, W. Geospatial semantics: why, of what, and how? Journal on Data
Semantics III (2005), 1–24.
[56] KWAN, M. P. Gender and individual access to urban opportunities: a study
using space–time measures. The Professional Geographer 51, 2 (1999), 210–227.
[57] LEES, B. G. 25 Volumes of the international journal of geographical information
science. International Journal of Geographical Information Science 25, 1 (2011), 1–
5.
[58] LONGLEY, P. A., GOODCHILD, M. F., MAGUIRE, D. J., AND RHIND, D. W.
Geographical Information Systems: Principles, Techniques, Applications and
Management. John Wiley & Sons, 1999.
[59] LONGLEY, P. A., GOODCHILD, M. F., MAGUIRE, D. J., AND RHIND, D. W.
Geographic Information System and Science. John Wiley & Sons, 2005.
[60] MACEACHREN, A. M. Visualizing uncertain information. Cartographic
Perspectives 13 (1992), 10–19.
[61] MACEACHREN, A. M., AND KRAAK, M. J. Research challenges in
geovisualization. Cartography and Geographic Information Science 28, 1 (2001),
3–12.
[62] MACEACHREN, A. M., ROBINSON, A., HOPPER, S., GARDNER, S., MURRAY,
R., GAHEGAN, M., AND HETZLER, E. Visualizing geospatial information
Contributions of GIScience over the Past Twenty Years 33
uncertainty: what we know and what we need to know. Cartography and
Geographic Information Science 32, 3 (2005), 139–160.
[63] MCMASTER, R. B., AND USERY, E. L., Eds. A Research Agenda for Geographic
Information Science. CRC Press, 2004.
[64] MAGUIRE, D. J., GOODCHILD, M.F., AND RHIND, D. W., Eds., Geographical
Information Systems: Principles and Applications, Longman, 1991.
[65] MARK, D. M., CHRISMAN, N., FRANK, A. U., MCHAFFIE, P. H., AND
PICKLES, J. The GIS history project. UCGIS Summer Assembly. Bar Harbor, ME,
http://www.ncgia.buffalo.edu/gishist/bar_harbor.html, 1997.
[66] MARK, D. M., AND FRANK A. U. Cognitive and Linguistic Aspects of
Geographic Space. Kluwer, NATO ASI Series D, Vol. 63, 1992.
[67] MARK, D. M., FREKSA, C., HIRTLE, S. C., LLOYD, R., AND TVERSKY, B.
Cognitive models of geographical space. International Journal of Geographical
Information Science 13, 8 (1999), 747-774.
[68] MARK, D. M., SMITH, B., EGENHOFER, M. J., AND HIRTLE, S. C. Ontological
foundations for geographic information science. In A Research Agenda for
Geographic Information Science, R. B. MacMaster and E. L. Usery, Eds. CRC
Press, 2004, pp. 335–350.
[69] MILLER, H. J., AND GOODCHILD, M. F. Data-driven geography. GeoJournal
80, 4 (2015), 449–461.
[70] MONTELLO, D. R. Cognitive research in GIScience: recent achievements and
future prospects. Geography Compass 3, 5 (2009), 1824-1840.
[71] MONTELLO, D. R., AND FREUNDSCHUH, S. Cognition of geographic
information. In A Research Agenda for Geographic Information Science, R. B.
MacMaster and E. L. Usery, Eds. CRC Press, 2004, pp. 61–91.
[72] NEGROPONTE, N. Being Digital. Alfred A. Knopf Inc., 1995.
[73] PEUCKER, T. K., FOWLER, R. J., LITTLE, J. J., AND MARK, D. M. The
triangulated irregular network. In American Society of Photogrammetry, Digital
Terrain Models Symposium (St. Louis, MO, USA, 1978), pp. 516–540.
[74] RANDELL, D. A., CUI, Z, AND COHN, A. G. A spatial logic based on regions
and connection. In KR ‘92: Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on
Principles of Knowledge Representation and Reasoning, B. Nebel, C. Rich, and
W. R. Swartout, Eds. (Morgan Kaufmann, 1992), pp. 165-176.
[75] RICHARDSON, D. B., Volkow, N. D., KWAN, M. P., KAPLAN, R.,
GOODCHILD, M. F., AND CROYLE, R. T. Spatial turn in health research.
Science 339, 6126 (2013): 1390.
[76] RIGAUX, P., SCHOLL, M., AND VOISARD, A. Spatial databases: with
application to GIS, Morgan Kaufmann, 2001.
[77] RODDICK, J. F., HOEL, E., EGENHOFER, M. J., PAPADIAS, D., AND
SALZBERG, B. Spatial, temporal and spatio-temporal databases-hot issues and
directions for PhD research. ACM SIGMOD Record 33, 2 (2004), 126–131.
[78] SHEKHAR, S., CHAWLA, S., RAVADA, S., FETTERER, A., LIU, X., AND LU, C.
T. Spatial databases—accomplishments and research needs. IEEE Transactions
on Knowledge and Data Engineering 11, 1 (1999), 45–55.
34 Egenhofer, Clarke, Gao, Quesnot, Franklin, Yuan, and Coleman
[79] SHEKHAR, S., GUNTURI, V., EVANS, M. R., YANG, K. Spatial big-data
challenges intersecting mobility and cloud computing. In MobiDE ’12:
Proceedings of the Eleventh ACM International Workshop on Data Engineering
for Wireless and Mobile Access, (New York, USA, 2012), ACM Press, pp. 1–6.
[80] SHEPPARD, E., COUCLELIS, H., GRAHAM, S., HARRINGTON, J. W., AND
ONSRUD, H. J. Geographies of the information society. Cognitive models of
geographical space. International Journal of Geographical Information Science
13, 8 (1999), 797-823.
[81] SIEGEL, A. W., AND WHITE, S. H. The development of spatial representations
of large-scale environments. Advances in Child Development and Behavior 10
(1975), 9-55.
[82] STEFANIDIS, A., AND NITTEL, S., Eds., GeoSensor Networks. CRC Press, 2004.
[83] SUI, D., ELWOOD, S., AND GOODCHILD, M. F., Eds. Crowdsourcing
geographic knowledge: volunteered geographic information (VGI) in theory and
practice. Springer, New York, 2012.
[84] TAYLOR, H., AND TVERSKY, B. Spatial mental models derived from survey
and route descriptions. Journal of Memory and Language 31, 2 (1992), 261-292.
[85] THORNDYKE, P., AND HAYES-ROTH, B. Differences in spatial knowledge
acquired from maps and navigation. Cognitive Psychology 14, 4 (1982): 560-589.
[86] TOBLER, W. R. A computer movie simulating urban growth in the Detroit
region. Economic Geography 46 (1970), 234–240.
[87] TOMLIN, C. D. Geographic Information Systems and Cartographic Modeling.
Prentice-Hall, 1990.
[88] TOMLINSON, R. F. A geographic information system for regional planning. In:
G.A. Stewart (ed.) Symposium on Land Evaluation, Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research Organization, Melbourne, Australia, 1968.
[89] UCGIS , Research priorities for geographic information science. Cartography and
Geographic Information Science 23, 3 (1996), 115-127.
[90] WANG, S., ANSELIN, L., BHADURI, B., CROSBY, C., GOODCHILD, M. F., LIU,
Y., AND NYERGES, T. L. CyberGIS software: a synthetic review and integration
roadmap. International Journal of Geographical Information Science 27, 11
(2013), 2122–2145.
[91] WANT, R., HOPPER, A., FALÇAO, V., AND GIBBONS, J. (1992) The active
badge location system. ACM Transactions on Information Systems 10, 1 (1992),
91–102.
[92] YANG, C., GOODCHILD, M. F., HUANG, Q., NEBERT, D., RA SKIN, R., XU, Y.,
BAMBACUS, M., AND FAY, D. Spatial cloud computing: how can the geospatial
sciences use and help shape cloud computing? International Journal of Digital
Earth 4, 4 (2011), 305–329.
[93] YEH, A. G. Urban planning and GIS. In P. A. Longley, M. F. Goodchild, D. J.
Maguire, and D. W. Rhind, Eds., John Wiley & Sons, 2005, pp. 877-888.
[94] ZHANG, J., AND GOODCHILD, M. F. Uncertainty in Geographical Information.
CRC Press, 2002.
View publication stats
The post geomatics View project appeared first on My Assignment Online.