To help you further understand what is expected from the discussion topic, I decided to post sample responses from former students as the situation calls for it. You should first read my guidelines post for the details of what you need to do, and then you can use these sample posts for ideas. I hope you find them helpful.
THE ORGANIC FOOD DILEMMA
Summary of the article
For my discussion topic I chose to read an article based on a subject I often find myself discussion with friends and family – is there really a difference between organic and non-organic food and is it worth the extra cost? People seem to fall on one end of the spectrum or the other, either fully-believing in the value or those who feel that “regular” food is just as healthy and don’t understand why people would opt to spend more on their already-high grocery bill. The article, “Is Buying Organic Worth It?” (Gerszberg 2013), explores this controversial topic and provides still more food-for-thought (pun intended) for those trying to make the right decision for themselves and their families.
Central question
My analysis will focus on striving to answer the key question on many peoples’ minds: Are there really health benefits to eating the more expensive organic food. While most would agree that organic food costs more than non-organic, the greatest contrast in opinion comes to light when you discuss the benefits of paying more to eat organically – will we be healthier as a result of eating it?
Methodology
In order to arrive at an answer to this long-standing question I would utilize regression analysis to determine if long-term health can be predicted by the consumption or non-consumption of organic food. As there are many health outcomes that could be measured to determine the value of eating organic (Ex. weight, cholesterol level, cancer risk, etc), it is likely that multiple analyses would need to be conducted in order to determine if, and where, organic food has impact.
As a place to start to fill a key gap in research, I would create a simple regression model to determine if eating organic food can reduce the risk of cancer. Such a study on the long-term impact of an organic diet on the likelihood to be stricken with cancer has not yet been conducted (Gerszberg 2013) and could be a significant breakthrough depending on the outcome. In this scenario, the independent variable would be the routine consumption of organic food with dependent variable being the prevalence of cancer.
The analysis would likely require a significant number of years to complete, as it would be helpful to follow those who follow a mainly-organic diet as well as those who do not, and follow their health status to identify if, and when, they were stricken with cancer. The difference in the cancer rate of those who eat organic and those who do not would then serve as the answer regarding if there is or isn’t a relationship. Once this initial study is complete and we have a baseline, future analyses can be conducted to determine the accuracy of the initial study based on how those outcomes compared to the original.
Where will your data come from? How will the results from this methodology answer the question you described above?
The data for this study would come primarily from the individuals participating, as they would be responsible for tracking their diet over a period of years as well as providing details on their health. Should a cancer diagnosis occur, the individuals’ physician(s) would then play an important role in the study as they would be the primary source for detailed insight into the health and diagnosis of their patient.
Based on the outcome of the study and the results received, we should be able to determine if an organic diet can impact the risk of cancer. If we find that the frequency of cancer in those who eat organic food is much the same as those who do not (which I recommend repeating multiple times to ensure accuracy), we can assume that organic food does not play a significant role in the battle against cancer. However, if we find that individuals have a much higher or lower diagnosis rate, we will be able to fairly confidently assume that an organic diet does play a role in the battle against cancer and determine what role this means such food will have in individuals’ ongoing lifestyle and prevention decisions.
Reference
Gerszberg R.N., D (2013). Is Buying Organic Worth It? Columbia University Medical Center, May 31, 2013. http://newsroom.cumc.columbia.edu/blog/2013/05/31/organic-or-not/
In this Discussion, you will explore how you can apply descriptive statistics, probability calculations, normal distribution calculations, hypothesis testing, regression, and forecasting to current events.
Research an article on a current event that centers on a controversial issue where the two sides are claiming opposing views. Then, describe how you would analyze the situation to settle the issue if you were involved in this event. For example, if the article was about whether a proposed new law about gun control will reduce deaths, you may describe how you would use hypothesis testing to compare data from states where such laws exist. Or, if the article was about actions to take to reduce gas prices, you could talk about how you would use regression to figure out which factors affected prices at the pump the most.
Please note that this Discussion should be limited to how statistical analysis can be applied to current issues. This is not the place to champion a particular position on the issue you are discussing or get into an argument about the various sides of an issue. Remember, you are here to analyze, not proselytize.
Also note that the article you are citing must be discussing the opposing views on the issue. Do not introduce your own perspective on what is being disputed. For example if the article is about the new budget being passed but does not discuss any conflicts of opinion, it doesn’t qualify.
Please use the template below in your answers so everyone can easily follow your answers to all the questions (copy and paste to your post).
Use this template for your Unit 6 Discussion.
Summary of the article
Briefly describe the current event described in the article.
Central question
What does the article say about the issue being disputed? What are the conflicting points of view according to the article? Use direct quotes from the article to summarize the dispute and the opposing sides.
There has to be some specific issue in dispute at the center (do tax breaks increase spending, what impacts health care costs the most, etc.), and the sides have to be defending a particular position.
Do not use examples where the issue is based on opinions or morality. For example, “Should abortion be legal?” is largely a morality question and is not suitable for statistical analysis. Conducting a survey to ask people about their opinions is not the same as analyzing data and making conclusions- you still only have opinions.
Methodology
Explain which methodology you will apply. Provide the relevant details. Where will your data come from? How will the results from this methodology answer the question you described above?
If you are going to use forecasting, explain how you will do that (which methodology and why) and how you will measure your accuracy. How will the forecast settle the issue?
If you do a regression analysis, explain what the dependent and independent variables will be.
If you will do hypothesis testing, what will the null and alternative hypothesis be?
The post In this Discussion, you will explore how you can apply descriptive statistics appeared first on EssayBishop.