| Well exceeds expectations | Exceeds expectations | Satisfy the criteria | Nearly Meets the criteria | Only covers the basics | Qn | |
| 1 | Mechanisms | Identified 4 clear mechanism that are logical with excellent level of detail on how these mechanisms can produce the effect observed. |
Identified 3 clear mechanism that are logical with excellent level of detail on how these mechanisms can produce the effect observed, but the remaining mechanism could be better explained or is missing some detail. Identified 4 mechanisms that are logical and are in agreement with the observation, however, a little more detail could be provided on how these mechanisms can produce the effects observed. |
Identify at least 3 mechansism that are logical and are in agreement with the observation. Provodied detailed explanation on at least 2 of these mechanisms can produce the effects observed. Or 4 mechanisms are identified, but the descriptions are brief and does not fully address how the mechanisms can produced the observations. |
Identified some (<3) of the relevant mechanisms but the details on how these mechanisms can produce the effects observed is vague or unclear . Or mechanisms identified are not appropriate to the observation, or the details are not accurate . Or the physiological concepts are not well explained or incorrect. |
Identified < 2 potentially accurate mechanisms with little explanation on how this can produce the effects observerd. The explanation of the identified mechanisms are poor, or inaccurate . |
| 2 | Manipulation hypothesis |
Identified all the relevant criteria for a manipulation hypothesis: Independent variable; dependent variable; relationship and directionality between the valiables; species. Also decribed a clear mechanism for the relationship between the variables. Is testable. |
Identified most of the relevant criteria for a manipulation hypothesis but is missing 1 criteria : Independent variable; dependent variable; relationship and directionality between the valiables; species. Decribe a clear mechanism for the relationship between the variables. Is testable. |
Identified some of the relevant criteria for a manipulation hypothesis but is missing 1-2 criteria: Independent variable; dependent variable; relationship and directionality between the valiables; species. The mechanism for the relationship between the variables is clear , or is not testable . |
Identified some of the relevant criteria for a manipulation hypothesis but is missing at least 2 criteria : Independent variable; dependent variable; relationship and directionality between the valiables; species. Also the decribed mechanism for the relationship between the variables is not clear . Is not testable . |
Identified few of the relevant criteria for a manipulation hypothesis but is missing at least 4 criteria: Independent variable; dependent variable; relationship and directionality between the valiables; species. Also the decribed mechanism for the relationship between the variables is not clear . Is not testable . |
| 3 | Preparation choice & rationale |
A clear choice of the preparation that will allow for the complete and specific testing of the proposed mechanism stated in Question 2. The rationale and explanation for the selection of this preparation is detailed , logical and clearly explained . |
A good choice of the preparation that will allow for the testing of the proposed mechanism stated in Question 2. The rationale or explanation for the selection of this preparation is logical , but the decision could be refined and better explained, including more detail on how this preparation will allow for specific testing of the proposed mechanism. |
A reasonable choice of the preparation that will allow for the testing of some (but not all) of the proposed mechanism stated in Question 2. The preparation chosen will only partially test the proposed mechanism . Or the rationale for the decision is not well explained. |
The choice of the preparation will allow for testing of some parts of the proposed mechanism stated in Question 2, however, may lack some aspects of the mechanism. The logic or rationale in the explanation for the selection of this preparation is weak and is not clearly explained . Or the chose of the preparation does not test the mechanism proposed. |
The choice of the preparation does not allow for testing of the proposed mechanism stated in Question 2. Or the rationale in the explanation for this selection does not make sense and does not explain the choice made . |
| 4 | Experimental Design |
The measurements to be taken are clearly described and are taken at appropriate timepoints. The experimental timeline makes sense and will appropriately test for the mechanisms proposed . The experimental design will test the proposed mechanism in the hypothesis. The choice of parallel vs serial control is appropriate and clearly explained. There is clear and logical thought in the control of the different parameters with excellent controls in the experiment proposed. |
The measurements to be taken are clearly described and are taken at appropriate timepoints. The experimental timeline makes sense and will test for the mechanisms proposed . The experimental design will test the proposed mechanism in the hypothesis. The choice of parallel vs serial control is appropriate and well explained. There is clear and logical thought in the control of the different parameters with adequate controls in the experiment proposed. The explanations and rationale for at least one of the above factours could be improved or be more detailed, or one of the above factors is missing. |
The measurements to be taken are described and are taken at appropriate timepoints. The experimental timeline makes sense and will test for the mechanisms proposed but may be missing one factor , such baseline or other measurements that will test for the mechanism. The experimental design will test the proposed mechanism in the hypothesis but could be more specific . The choice of parallel vs serial control is appropriate but could be better explained, or adequate control of the different parameters in the experiment proposed, but some control factors may be missing . The explanations and rationale for one or more of the above factours could be more detailed, or some of |
The measurements to be taken are described and are not detailed enough to clearly determine the timeline or the experimental timeline is vague and unclear . The proposed experiment does not adequately test the proposed mechanisms. The choice of parallel vs serial control is unclear and could be better explained , or inadequate control of the different parameters in the experiment are proposed. The explanations and rationale for two or more of the above factours could be more detailed, or some of the above factors is missing. |
The measurements to be taken are described but are not detailed enough to clearly determine the timeline or the experimental timeline is unclear and the proposed experiment does not test the proposed mechanisms. The choice of parallel vs serial control is unclear or inappropriate for the experimetal design, or inadequate control of the different parameters in the experiment are proposed. The explanations and rationale for two or more of the above factors lack detail, or some of the above factors is missing. |
| the above factors is missing. | ||||||
| 5 | Statistics and Data Presentation |
Chosen the best and most appropriate statistical test with clearly logical explanation for the choice. The data presentation method and style is clear and unambiguous, and presentation is excellent . |
Chosen an appropriate statistical test with a logical explanation for the choice. The data presentation method is appropriate and presentation is good . |
Chosen the an appropriate statistical test but the logic or explanation is not clear. Data presentation style is adequate but the message is not clear. OR Choosen an inappropriate statistical test, but makes a good case for the choice. OR There is incongruity between the statistics tests chosen and the graphical presentation of the data but the rationale for both is justified. |
The choice of statistcal test is not appropriate and the explanation for this choice is not well stated. The data presentation is unclear and not suited to the data set. OR There is incongruity between the statistics tests chosen and the graphical presentation of the data but the rationale for both is not well justified . |
The statistical test chosen is inappropriate for the data, or the logic or explanation is not clear . The data presention is unclear and inappropriate . |
| Word limit and Logical development of ideas |
The ideas are well-developed logically and clearly explained. The writing is clear , succinct , and easy to understand. All required details are well explained and covered in the answers. |
The ideas are logically presented and well – explained . The writing is clear , succinct , and easy to understand . Some required details are well explained and covered in the answers. A few instances where more detail would be beneficial or better developed . |
Most ideas are logical and clearly explained. The writing is mostly clear and easy to understand, although there is some repetition . Some required details are not fully explained and covered in the answers. A few instances where more detail would be beneficial or should be better developed . |
Some ideas are logical and clearly explained . The writing is somewhat vague and ambiguous, with some repetition or redundancy . Some required details are not fully explained and covered in the answers. Several instances where more detail would be beneficial or should be better developed . |
Most idea s are not well explained and the logic is fuzzy . The writing is vague and ambiguous, with many repetitive parts. Some required details are not explained and covered in the answers. Many instances where more detail would be beneficial and should be better developed . |
The post logical with excellent level appeared first on My Assignment Online.