Limited Offer Get 25% off — use code BESTW25
No AI No Plagiarism On-Time Delivery Free Revisions
Claim Now
Prices start at $5 per page · plagiarism-free papers · free revisions for 14 days 24/7 support: support@bestwriters.com
Uncategorized

Planning Mentoring: A Guide

  • Posted
  • Authoradmin
  • Length12,463 words
  • Reading time55 min
Write My Assignment FREE

Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Copyright
ii Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Copyright
© Original Copyright 2002 and revised 2005 and 2012 The Institute for Working Futures Pty. Ltd. acn: 22 054466769.
This work is copyright. Apart from any fair dealing under the Copyright Act 1968, no part of this publication may be resold,
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording, or otherwise, without prior permission from The Institute for Working Futures Pty. Ltd. (Working Futures™
www.workingfutures.com.au).
This resource may be reused, reproduced or electronically distributed for educational purposes.
Disclaimer
Working Futures™ makes every attempt to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information included in this resource. Users
should be aware of the following:
• Working Futures™ makes no guarantee or warranty as to the accuracy or authenticity of the information in this guide, or
other resources listed in this resource.
• Working Futures™ does not accept any liability to any person for any loss or damage incurred as a result of the use of the
information or arising out of the provision of the information in this resource.
In this disclaimer the term ‘Information’ includes any information (in any format) contained or incorporated into this resource by
references or any information provided.
Author
Dr Marcus S Bowles
Janette M. Bowles
International
Web: http://www.workingfutures.com.au
e-mail: info@workingfutures.com.au
If you like to get this Guide specifically redeveloped for the Transport & Logistics industry please go to
http://www.talc.com.au to see the T&L Mentoring Pocketbook and support resources, electronic studies and more
detail on mentoring.

Foreword

Planning Mentoring: A Guide iii
Foreword
In recent years corporations and industries have rediscovered Mentoring. Once the heart of
skills transfer in traditional guilds and an essential component of how leaders transferred
wisdom and guided followers, the importance mentoring had waned in the past century.
This Guide is intended to provide guidance and assistance for those seeking to re-establish a
mentoring programme. It is a summary of the steps and critical actions required by the
practitioner or leaders. It is designed to complement more extensive theoretical and
instructional resources. Nevertheless, the essential parameters are outlined sufficient to enable
users to appreciate the task at hand, plan the strategy and revisit the Guide to monitor progress.
The Guide is also designed to be useful for not just those planning the mentoring programme. It
can be used by both mentors and mentees. Nor is utility limited to one type of organisation or
industry. The actions and observations are ubiquitous; useful to any workplace.
It is through mentoring that the talent of the future and emerging leaders can access the
wisdom and the highly valuable tacit knowledge mentors have constructed from contextual
experience. It is through this knowledge and the construction of trust between those building
an organisation’s future that the capabilities essential to the modern organisation—agility,
customer responsiveness and transformational capacity—are embedded.
Contents
iv Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Contents
Foreword…………………………………………………………………………………………………………. iii
Part 1 Introducing Mentoring ……………………………………………………………………………….. 1
Some key questions ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 1
What is mentoring?…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..1
Who is involved in mentoring and what do they do? …………………………………………………………….2
Why should transport and logistics companies implement mentoring? …………………………………..3
Why do people get involved in mentoring?………………………………………………………………………….3
Where and when does mentoring occur?…………………………………………………………………………….4
Are mentoring and coaching the same? ………………………………………………………………………………4
Is mentoring a form of training? …………………………………………………………………………………………4
How do we implement mentoring? …………………………………………………………………………………….5
Part 2 Planning a Mentoring Programme ……………………………………………………………….. 7
Step 1 Analyse the mentoring programme outcomes ………………………………………………… 7
Step 1.1 Analyse audience, purpose and parameters ………………………………………………………7
Step 1.2 Define context and need …………………………………………………………………………………9
Step 1.3 Prepare the mentoring plan …………………………………………………………………………….9
Step 1.4 Define resources and requirements………………………………………………………………..10
Step 1.5 Develop metrics to assess, report and evaluate mentor programme impact………..11
Step 2 Design the mentoring programme………………………………………………………………. 12
Step 2.1. Structure and organise the mentoring programme …………………………………………..12
Step 2.2. Define the role and responsibility of key players ………………………………………………13
The mentor ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 13
The mentee………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 13
Co-ordinators……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 13
The steering committee…………………………………………………………………………………………. 14
Step 2.3. Test and pilot process and resources ………………………………………………………………14
Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme ………………………………………………………… 15
Step 3.1 Profile and select the mentors and mentees ……………………………………………………16
The mentor’s profile ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 16
The mentee profile ……………………………………………………………………………………………….. 17
Step 3.2 Inform individuals involved ……………………………………………………………………………18
Step 3.3 Train the mentor and mentee ………………………………………………………………………..18
Training the mentor………………………………………………………………………………………………. 18
Training the mentee ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 19
Step 3.4 Match mentors and mentee…………………………………………………………………………..19
Induction……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 20
Developing a personal action plan…………………………………………………………………………… 20
Step 3.5 Build strong mentoring relationships ………………………………………………………………21
Setting the foundations for a mentoring relationship ………………………………………………… 21
Phases to the mentoring relationship………………………………………………………………………. 21
Set some parameters…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 23
Step 4 Improve the mentoring programme……………………………………………………………. 24

Contents

Planning Mentoring: A Guide v
Step 4.1 Measure and evaluate the mentoring programme……………………………………………24
Step 4.2 Evaluate tools and materials and the learning process(es)…………………………………25
Step 4.3 Report and suggest improvements …………………………………………………………………26
Resources used ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 27

Part 1 Introducing Mentoring
Some key questions
This section sets the scene for our examination of Mentoring. We will cover some key questions
asked by those involved in sponsoring, researching or implementing a mentoring programme.
What is mentoring?
The traditional view
Mentor: 1. a wise and trusted counsellor or teacher
2. an influential senior sponsor or supporter
… An adviser, master, guide or preceptor.
– Dictionary.com http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/mentor
A contemporary view
Mentoring is defined as the process of providing constant encouragement and assistance to
another by either being a positive role model or an independent resource able to enhance
attainment of an individual’s personal and task related needs.
While some still see the mentor as a ‘wise old worker’ who knows all the ropes and passes their
knowledge onto the younger acolyte this view is certainly a myth. Being a mentor is not necessarily linked
to age. Nor should it be bounded by any preconceived ideas about gender, race, religion, area of
operation, location, or such like.
The mentor has wisdom and can offer insights the less experienced person does not possess. The mentee
on the other hand remains a person who has to have the drive to acquire this wisdom or insight.
Ultimately, the mentor cannot force the mentee to learn, nor can they control how their insights will be
deployed by the mentee to achieve success.
The relationship is based on mutual respect, trust and a two-way communication process. No matter how
it is structured, where it occurs, or who is involved mentoring programmes have been successful because:
• Wisdom—knowledge refined through experience—can be accessed from a real person
interacting within a real situation;
• Abstract, hidden knowledge can be conveyed as a story or in face to face discussion but would
never be captured in structured learning and or in a manual;
• Clear communication channels are forged, especially if tied to a learning and business process;
• Occurs just-in-time, when the people involved wish (i.e. It can be completed by telephone, or
online);
• Existing expertise can be accessed to promote or accelerate another individual’s acquisition of
what they need to know, not what others think they need to know;
• Humans learn best in collaborative, social exchanges;
• Knowledge is tied to a context and, if required, a purpose; and
• Done properly the mentoring cycle can be designed-into how we do business and the mentee of
today can become an effective mentor for others in the future.
Some key questions
2 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Who is involved in mentoring and what do they do?
Mentoring ultimately revolves around two individuals; the mentor and the mentee. While unusual, it may
occur that one mentee may have multiple mentors. It is less unusual that a mentor may have a number of
mentees. The individuals may be employed in the same organisation, or come from multiple business and
social backgrounds.
Surrounding the core interaction between the mentor and mentee will usually be a programme
coordinator, possibly other support staff and a steering or project management committee. All have
different roles.
Typically, the mentor needs to focus on:
• Mutual advantage of the relationship
• Empathy and understanding
• Network the mentee with key contacts
• Transfer trustworthy and accurate knowledge
• Open communication channels
• Role model behaviours
Ideally the mentee should focus on:
• Manage and communicate expectations
• Engage with the process and people involved
• Nurture the relationship
• Translate communication into personal reality
• Establish priorities and follow-through discussions
• Evaluate needs and outcomes
The programme coordinator:
• Acts as a central point for all enquiries
• Develops and manages the design plan or project brief
• Is responsible for reporting and gaining approval from the steering committee or senior
management
• Selects and manages any consultants required
• Coordinates training and the mentoring process (analysis, design, implementation and
improvement)
• Prepares written guidelines for the programme, the mentors and the mentees
• Coordinates communications and marketing in relation to the project
• Organises venues, resources and manpower
• Manages the programme including the budget, schedules, progress, resource distribution, etc.
• Handles complaints or grievance procedures
• Holds regular reviews with all involved and measures and evaluates the success of the
programme
There may also be a programme steering committee or body overviewing the process.

Some key questions

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 3

Mentees Skills & Knowledge + Context + Mentors Skills & Knowledge
Experience Experience

= Raised wisdom and increased capability
Why should companies implement mentoring?
The ability to learn faster than your competitors may be the only sustainable comparative
advantage (De Geus, 1988, p.71)
Done correctly mentoring is an important instrument in an organisation’s strategic tool box. It is an
investment that can affect the future of the individuals involved and the sponsoring organisation. It is
should never be seen as an intervention where the cost is just weighed against some learning outcome.
There are many reasons why modern organisations are increasing their use of mentoring.
• passing of the ‘hero’ leadership and ‘Great Man’ leadership models to focus on side-by-side
leadership that collaborates with and empowers others
• need to accelerate training rates
• overall loss of corporate memory and reduction in organisational capability, technical and
business leadership
• use of on-the-job and peer models has strong cost advantages
• learning is both more relevant and situated in the context where it will be applied
• humans are social animals and most want to learn best from others
• organisations need to network with people or other businesses that hold knowledge vital to
their competitiveness
• shrinking cohort of young recruits and more competition for them to enter into other
industry career pathways
• greater appreciation of tacit knowledge that is uncodified and much harder to transfer
through formal learning
• shorter lead times and greater speed in business processes
• adoption of new business models, especially electronic models
• knowledge is distributed across disciplines, levels of employment and types of work
Why do people get involved in mentoring?
Many may mentors get involved because:
• Opportunity to share critical knowledge and insights that make their job easier
• Peer recognition and respect for their knowledge
• Opportunity to work with younger people
• Desire to assist others
• Opportunity to identify and promote talent
For the mentee is may be about achieving:
• A sounding board for their thoughts
• Improved skills and knowledge
• Greater self confidence, greater recognition and a great deal of personal satisfaction
• Benchmark for their own skills and knowledge
Some key questions
4 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
• Nurture their talent
• Extend their understanding and knowledge
• Rapidly accelerate their career and job potential
• Desire to interact with others
• Opportunity to be sponsored by another, more senior, person
• Preference for learning through interaction than formal, written coursework
Conducting a mentoring programme also promotes the organisation’s image. Typically these
organisations are respected because they:
• Tie knowledge gains to competitive advantage;
• Develop talent and therefore improve career pathways;
• Learn collaboratively, openly and across boundaries;
• Value learning;
• Reinforce the importance of an individual’s quest for personal, ‘life-long’ learning; and
• Know future potential has to be nurtured.
Where and when does mentoring occur?
Mentoring can occur at any time, over any length or duration, and via any medium. Many more options
as to when, how and where mentoring occurs exist as technological development enable far greater
flexibility. For instance e-mentoring programmes have been used in both companies and by educational
providers.
Mentoring may be structured to set times and places, or it may be completely unstructured with
participants agreeing to times and places based on need or availability. With modern electronic
communication and computing technologies e-mentoring is now more popular and removes previous
restrictions as to when and where mentors and mentees may link with each other.
Just as outcomes and the aim of a mentoring programme may vary, so do the means level of structure
placed on completing the intervention.
Are mentoring and coaching the same?
Coaching and mentoring are not the same. However, they may have blurred edges.
Coaching is used to describe the one-to-one transfer of competencies in the organisation’s
workplace.
Building self-confidence in employees is critical if they are to actively want to learn and work.
Unlike mentoring, coaching herein is distinguished by the provision of direct assistance to enable task
completion. Coaching is an important aspect to the activity a manager or supervisor will undertake to
provide direct assistance to a team or an individual employee. The purpose for coaching can vary but it
may revolve around ensuring the successful attainment of standards of performance required for the
completion of a task or when working with others in the team context.
Coaching is often a key pillar of an appraisal and formal feedback system between supervisors and
employees. It may also be formally structured as part of other human resource activities such as
compliance and regulatory activities.
Is mentoring a form of training?
Mentoring may be a component of a training and development intervention. However, mentoring has a
specific role that may not be limited to training and development activities.

Some key questions

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 5
Training, especially competency-based training, is very focussed on skills and knowledge related to job
performance. While mentoring may be a strategy used for learning it is very much about the individual
taking control of their learning. This is often compared to training being too focussed on ‘filling an empty
vessel’ than actually being a process for leveraging off what the person already knows and can do. In this
way we remove the individual from a dependency model to a self-directed model that has benefits in
many other areas.
How do we plan a mentoring programme?
There exist many academic and commercial models for undertaking mentoring. This Mentoring Guide is
focussed mainly on the broad approach to establishing a mentoring programme, and then on detailing
what and how to implement each of these stages.
The process for planning a mentoring programme has four steps. A systematic and robust four step
approach is depicted below. This model is based on extensive research and analysis sponsored and
adopted by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia and completed by a consortium of international
Universities lead by the University of Tasmania (Bowles, 2003 & 2004).
Figure 1 The four-stage model for Planning a Mentoring Programme
The following section of the Guide will take us through how to complete each of these Stages. In
summary the stages, individual activities and deliverables are depicted in table 1 below.

Analyse
Analyse and establish
resources and outcomes for
mentor programme
Design
Design and develop how
it will be done
Improve
Evaluate, measure and
verify if improvements
are required
Need &
Improved
utcomes
capability
Implement
Run the mentoring
programme

Some key questions
6 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Table 1 Mentoring programme stages, activities and deliverables

Stages Key activities Deliverables
1. Analyse Step 1.1. Analyse audience, purpose and parameters
Step 1.2. Define context and need
Step 1.3. Prepare the mentoring plan
Step 1.4. Define resources and requirements
Step 1.5. Develop metrics to assess, report and evaluate
mentor programme impact
Identified need
The audience
Executive support
Mentoring programme plan or brief
Evaluation and reporting frameworks
2. Design Step 2.1. Structure and organise the mentoring
programme
Step 2.2. Define the role and responsibility of key players
Step 2.3. Test and pilot process and resources
Resources
Selection criteria for mentors and mentees
Tested (instructionally and technically
valid) approach
3. Implement Step 3.1. Profile and select the mentors and mentees
Step 3.2. Inform individuals involved
Step 3.3. Train the mentor and mentee
Step 3.4. Match mentors and mentees
Step 3.5. Build strong mentoring relationships
Profile of key players
Trained participants
Well matched relationships
Implemented programme
Report on learning and progress
Feedback and review data
4. Improve Step 4.1. Measure and evaluate the mentoring programme
Step 4.2. Evaluate tools and materials and the learning
process(es)
Step 4.3. Report and suggest improvements
Evaluation report and recommendations
for continuous improvement
Report on ROI and organisational and
individual benefits
Improvement plan
Step 1 Analyse the mentoring programme outcomes

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 7
Part 2 Planning a Mentoring Programme
Step 1 Analyse the mentoring programme outcomes
Aim:
This step ensures the mentoring
programme is planned, established and
resourced in a manner that optimises
individual and business success.
Tips:
 Before embarking on you mentoring
programme – carefully establish the
need
 Establish quantifiable operational,
process and achievable outcomes
 Confirm a ‘pool’ of mentors, both
from internal and external sources,
does exists to implement the desired outcomes
 Identify the discrete group of mentees you wish to grow and nurture
 Gain senior management support and sponsorship
 Before gaining support for your mentoring programme, prepare a written plan or brief
 Establish the resources required to deliver the programme successfully
 The best way to handle resistance, objections and delays is to be ready for them
 Make sure you get the support of top management (and other key people) before you proceed
Traps:
 Waste of time, money and effort through failure to examine other businesses’ successful mentoring
programmes
 Underestimating the resources and requirements to manage the process
 Failing to scale the programme to the available pool of mentors
 Lack of clear operational outcomes senior management can ‘buy into’
 Establishes unrealistic outcomes
 Over engineers the programme and how relationships between the mentor and mentee can operate.
Step 1 Analyse – actions we will cover

Step 1.1.
Step 1.2.
Step 1.3.
Step 1.4.
Step 1.5.
Analyse audience, purpose and parameters;
Define context and need;
Prepare the mentoring plan;
Define resources and requirements; and
Develop metrics to assess, report and evaluate mentor programme impact.

Step 1.1 Analyse audience,
purpose and parameters
Mentoring is not limited to a set number of
applications; in fact, there can be an element of
mentoring within a number of tasks required by
modern organisations.
Researching and defining the need

Analyse
Analyse and establish
resources and outcomes
for mentor programme
Design
Design and develop
how it will be done
Improve
Evaluate, measure and
verify if improvements
are required
Need &
Improved
utcomes
capability
Implement
Run the mentoring
programme

Step 1 Analyse the mentoring programme outcomes
8 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
One way to identify the need for a mentoring
programme is through a skills audit or training
needs analysis. Training needs data can be
collected and confirmed through a number of
different methods. In a business context
different methods can target the different
levels of performance and learning needs. The
best methods, in priority order, for determining
a need for mentoring seem to be:
• Interviews by peer or coach with those
doing the work (i.e. in a performance
appraisal session)
• Questionnaires
• Assessment Centre for occupation/ group
• Interviews (by trainer/ assessor with those
doing the work)
• Observation of those doing the work
• Unstructured interviews by manager with
those doing the work
• Records of performance
• Expert data collection sessions
• Audits of team work for specific outcomes
over time.
Targeting the mentoring programme
Let’s look at a number of these instances and
see how mentoring plays a positive role.
Inducting new staff
Mentors help new arrivals to the
organisation learn ‘what’s going on around
here’ – often practical sessions are used to
explain the rather dry and theoretic
induction process. Some organisations have
set up ‘buddy systems’ to help ease a new
employee into the organisation and to help
the person understand the industry in which
they are employed.
Knowledge transfer
Facilitating the bringing together of people
with hard to codify knowledge with those
that need to know. This ensures the
unwritten wisdom of some employees is not
lost when they are not around.
Developing and enhancing skills
In this instance mentors can be used to help
introduce new skills to colleagues, or to
improve and develop their partners’ existing
skills. Practical in nature mentees can
undertake projects and assignments under
the watchful eye of a mentor – learning how
the more experienced worker handles the
situation.
Career development
Here mentors counsel and help the mentee
plan and develop their career path through
sometimes quite complicated industrial and
commercial settings – they take the time to
discuss the options available and help the
mentee set a course for future success.
Leadership and improvements to management
In this situation the development of
employees’ competencies can more easily be
gained by example and experience – senior
managers show (often by example) recently
promoted managers what to expect.
Education support
Mentoring can be used to help explain the
difference between the theoretical and
practical aspects of the job. Mentors and
mentees meet to discuss progress as the latter
attends a tertiary education.
Affirmative action
Success has been reported by women and
minority groups with progress in organisations
wishing to remedy imbalance in the workplace.
Here, members of the group meet together to
discuss issues, opportunities and
developments offering mutual support and
encouragement. The group members can often
come from a range of organisations.
Organisational development
Astute organisations are using available
mentoring skills among staff to assist other
staff members share the vision, mission and
plans for the future as members of the
industry equip for greater competition,
industrial rivalry and the effects of
globalisation.
Changing the culture of the organisation
Similarly organisations have used mentoring to
change the culture of their firms instilling new
values and improved ethical standards among
staff
Cultivating efficient work practices that target
customer needs

Step 1 Analyse the mentoring programme outcomes

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 9
The one-on-one nature of mentoring allows
the development of improved work
competencies and customer service that may
span many companies; for instance across a
supply chains, between trading partners, or
where cooperation and dealings between
companies in a value chain all has to result in
the satisfaction of the ultimate customer’s
needs.
Step 1.2 Define context and need
Traditional learning in organisations can a long
time to occur. For any organisation advantage
lies in responding to change quickly or
increasing how fast people can learn or use
new knowledge. This ‘speed of learning’ is
emphasised when we consider the business
drivers businesses need to respond to:
• Respond to strategic and market
opportunities
• Regulation and compliance
• Improve performance
• Reduce costs
• Improve profits
• Improve efficiency and effectiveness
• Improve service delivery
• Operational excellence
• Safety
• Innovation
The reality is mentoring is a strategy that
directly addresses not just a need, but the
speed with which learning can occur and be
translated into action. Mentoring is unique in
its impact as it can readily achieve improved
speed (rapid transfer), depth (level of detail)
and breadth (scope and associated issues) of
learning.
Step 1.3 Prepare the mentoring
plan
In its simplest form the mentoring programme
involves three main players – the mentor, the
mentee and the organisation that brings them
together. The organisation may be a company,
a professional body, an industry grouping or a
government agency. In reality, of course,
preparing a programme of this kind involves
much more than just “putting them together”.
As with most management initiatives the
programme will involve many people, some
directly, many indirectly.
The programme will need a coordinator;
someone to train the staff involved, key
performance indicators will need to be
set, mentors and mentees will need to
be selected, time frames will need to be
set, management and senior staff
briefed, and at the conclusion of the
programme it will need to be evaluated!
The secret is to prepare a briefing document in
which all the factors and variables can be set
down in advance – this will present a framework
which will provide a starting point for the team
that will eventually be given the responsibility of
developing the programme.
Having prepared the briefing, circulate it to the
key players involved, prepare a costing, discuss it
(and be prepared to defend it), and reach
agreement.
Figure 2 Preparing a mentoring programme brief
Checklist — Preparing the brief
Use this checklist to develop your plans for a
mentoring programme – the items listed should
be used as a starting point, as your business may
have a format for presenting documents like this.
Nor is the list a definitive one, you may need to
report on other considerations at your business
or in your industry setting.
Purpose
• What is the purpose of the recommended
mentoring programme?
Step 1 Analyse the mentoring programme outcomes
10 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
• What is the strategic setting for the
proposed programme?
• Is mentoring the best way to deliver this
strategy?
Key Performance Indicators
• Have we any prior outcomes against which
we can measure this proposal?
• What outcomes do we expect from the
programme?
• How will we measure these?
• How will the programme be evaluated?
Staff considerations – coordination
• Who will be responsible for the
programme?
• If there is no obvious person, how will we
select one?
• Who will prepare the job criteria?
Staff considerations – mentees and mentees
• Is there a target group of mentees?
• What are the selection criteria for the
mentees?
• Is there a target group of mentors?
• What are the selection criteria for the
mentors?
• Who will coordinate the selection of
mentees and mentors?
• What criteria will be used when pairing
mentors and mentees?
Staff considerations – the rest of the firm
• How will we communicate the programme
to the organisation?
• How will the mentees’ mangers be
involved?
• How will top management be involved?
How will their support be demonstrated?
Training
• What training is required for the
participants?
• What training is required for those
supporting the programme?
Timeframe, key dates
• What is the timeframe for
implementation?
• When will the programme be launched?
• What is the length of the pilot programme?
• What is the anticipated length of the total
programme?
Budget
• What are the anticipated costs of the
programme?
• Do you need to seek a special appropriation
to conduct the programme?
Reporting process
• What is the recommended reporting
process?
Step 1.4 Define resources and
requirements
Prior to delivery of any mentoring programme
the delivery and management plan should
translate into a resource plan that matches key
deliverables. This plan should at least identify:
• Delivery time and location;
• Recommended duration;
• Competency requirements of the facilitator
and assessor;
• Mode of delivery;
• Rules and responsibilities for key
participants;
• Resources required;
• Content, assessment tools or any related
materials; and
• Logistics, reporting and any related
administrative requirements.
Informal mentoring takes place in many
organisations – and most of us have experienced
informal aspects of the process in our lives from
time to time.
However for many organisations the idea of a
mentoring programme may be new and the idea
of ‘formalising’ the process leads to a number of
considerations unlikely to have been realistically
considered in the past. Mentoring requires
planning (as the previous section on preparing
the brief indicates) and the company considering
a mentoring project or initiative will need to plan
carefully.
Planning Mentoring: A Guide 11
Consideration of the process also tends to
create objections and resistance – new ideas
and new ways of doing things usually do.
It often centres on
• Lack of clarity over operational, not just
learning, outcomes
• Budget requirements
• Experience of staff
• Time commitments
• Fear of the unknown
Resistance and objections may come from any
level of the organisation and may be based
upon any number of apparently cogent
arguments – many which taken alone, and out
of them mentoring context may be quite logical
and may serve as good reason not to proceed
with, or even consider a mentoring initiative.
It is the role of the co-ordinator (or the steering
committee) to develop the plan for the
proposed mentoring programme; this plan
should be presented to the appropriate people
within the organisation to gain approval for the
programme and to gain their support as the
programme unfolds.
Step 1.5 Develop metrics to
assess, report and
evaluate mentor
programme impact
At the earliest possible stage of a mentoring
planning process it is essential to design how
the programme will be measured and
evaluated. This is not just about learning
outcomes. It is about the value-add to
customers, supply chains and business
processes. Evaluation of mentoring
programmes must be embedded from the
point of design, all the way through testing,
implementation and finally improvement.
Measurement and contribution of the
mentoring programme to the development of
an individual and an organisation’s capabilities
must be established before implementation.
The benefits of mentoring may be grouped and
measured in the following manner.
Improved Performance
• Improve business relationships
• Faster cycle time (business processes)
• Productivity increase
• Increased sales (higher comparative sales
revenue)
• ‘Better’ quality product/ service
• Reduced variations (waste and error rate
reduced)
• Improved ratio of labour cost to
production/ service costs
Building commitment and culture
• Improved personal and/or work
satisfaction
• Improved work attitude or workforce/
teams
• Decreased absenteeism
• Reduced staff turnover
Responsiveness of the workforce
• Improved customer satisfaction
• Reduction in (surveyed) complaints
• Adaptability or responsiveness of
workforce to opportunities
• More rapid adoption of innovations, work
practices, new technology
• Improved team work
• Ability to adopt new service modes (E.g.
E-commerce, etc.)
Reduced staff-replacement costs
• Mobility of existing staff to vacant jobs
(part-time, casual and full time)
• Cost of retraining reduced
• Cost of recruitment reduced
• Number of potential recruits (% fit of
employees to a job – recruitment pool)
• Staff retention, promotion and term of
employment (by commencement age and
employment level or area)
• Volume of part-time/ casual staff moving
into full-time jobs
Step 2 Design the mentoring programme
12 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Step 2 Design the mentoring programme
Aim:
To design and test a mentoring
programme appropriate for the people
involved that delivers the targeted
outcomes.
Tips:
 Keep your eye out for champions
 Develop a role for them in your
mentoring programme
 Consult with them as the mentoring
option is developed
 Consider using a steering committee
if your co-ordinator is busy, it will
help share the load and get more people involved more quickly
 Clearly define the role of the coordinator and the project/steering committee
 The only thing worse than not having a mentoring programme is spending lots of money on designing
and implemented one that does not work at all!
Traps:





The coordinator/facilitator does not have a detailed job description
Lack of time to properly design and test the mentoring programme
Ill defined rules and responsibilities for participants
Poor processes and resources that hinder interaction
Over engineering the process and limiting how mentors and mentees may interact

Step 2 Design – actions we will cover

Step 2.1.
Step 2.2.
Step 2.3.
Structure and organise the mentoring programme;
Define the role and responsibility of key players; and
Test and pilot process and resources.

Step 2.1. Structure and organise the
mentoring programme
The first point for many establishing a
mentoring strategy is to decide why they need it
and what it is supposed to do.
The second issue is the need to recognise that
mentoring may not be a simple one-on-one
relationship. Variations in the type of
mentoring relationships do occur.
More than one mentee
The business may have a shortage of suitably
trained mentors. In this case one person may
mentor a group of mentees. Meetings may
still be held on a one-to-one basis. Sometimes
they may meet together as group providing
opportunities for still more interaction and
cross-fertilisation of ideas.
Peer mentoring
Mentoring may, of course, take place
between peers, where colleagues mentor
each other providing mutual support and
encouragement. Peer mentoring can be
reasonably common in some professional and
industry groups where equals may work
towards a common goal, objective with a
common purpose.
Electronic and online mentoring
There are examples emerging of successful
online mentoring programs, where regular
face-to-face meetings are replaced by contact
by e-mail, telephone or facsimile. This contact

Analyse
Analyse and establish
resources and outcomes
for mentor programme
Design
Design and develop
how it will be done
Improve
Evaluate, measure and
verify if improvements
are required
Need &
Improved
utcomes
capability
Implement
Run the mentoring
programme
Step 2 Design the mentoring programme

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 13
follows an initial meeting at which the parties
get to know each other and, as well as, agree
on the mentoring programme agree to
maintain contact electronically.
Particularly suitable in workplaces where the
staff may be spread geographically – a sales
team for example, or a transport company
with city and country branches – this form of
mentoring provides greater opportunities for
mentors and mentees to remain in contact,
networking and providing, on occasions, peer
support.
Remember though, contact in this manner will
need to be supplemented by face-to-face
meetings for there is nothing quite the same
as a one-to-one meeting to help motivate the
mentee and to develop the whole mentoring
process.
Group Mentoring
Group mentoring can provide the opportunity
to mentor a wider group or people. Some
organisations have found this technique
useful to bring about a change in the
organisation’s culture or to encourage
learning across and organisation. The key is to
make sure the group being mentored is no
bigger that six to eight mentees. In this
situation the mentor acts as a facilitator and
moderator within the group guiding and
assisting the process along.
The third issue to be considered is usually
whether mentoring is to be an informal or
formal process. We now see a growing
movement within industry and commerce to
introduce mentoring programs as a way of
providing employees with a range of knowledge
and skills which assist them do their job better,
plan better and more personally satisfying
career paths and equip them better for the skills
and services they bring to the workplace.
Step 2.2. Define the role and
responsibility of key
players
The mentor
The key roles and responsibilities consistent
across a range of mentoring situations can
include:
• maintains confidentiality
• manages time efficiently
• is a good listener
• is objective
• supports and motivate
• is able to conduct a professional
relationship
• acts as a role model
• can identify opportunities
• manages conflict
• offers advice when asked – and knows
when enough advice is enough
• recognises the point at which the
mentoring relationship must end.
The mentee
The role and responsibilities of the mentee can
be summed up in this way
• acquires new skills and knowledge to apply
to his/her career
• seeks guidance and advice in his/her
professional development
• accepts responsibility for his/her own
decisions and actions
• be willing to accept expert and objective
advice
• carries out tasks and projects at agreed
times
Co-ordinators
Your mentoring programme will need a coordinator (or facilitator); often this person is
someone who is widely experienced in
conducting mentoring programs. Sometimes if
the person is not available in the organisation
someone may be chosen from outside or the
organisation may choose a staff member to
carry the project before it gains momentum.
The co-ordinator should be involved right from
the start:
• Advising the nature, size and content of the
programme
• Presenting information sessions
• Conducting (or arranging) training sessions
for mentors, mentees and support people
• Advising and counselling as the programme
unfolds
Step 2 Design the mentoring programme
14 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
• Providing feedback to senior management
and Chief Executive
Checklist the responsibilities of the
Programme Coordinator
□ Acts as a central point for all enquiries
□ Manages the project
□ Provides a link to top management
□ Selects any consultants required
□ Briefs any consultants used
□ Coordinates training workshops
□ Designs the programme – or coordinates its
design
□ Coordinates a review of the programme
□ Sets milestones
□ Prepares written guidelines for the
programme, the mentors and the mentees
□ Coordinates communications in relation to
the project
□ Coordinates any in-house PR or
promotional opportunities
□ Organises venues
□ Secures resources and manpower
□ Manages the budget
□ Schedules the programme
□ Reviews progress
□ Holds regular reviews with key personnel
involved
□ Collects all relevant material
□ Evaluates the success of the programme
The steering committee
Some organisations may well put the task of
developing the mentoring programme (or
possibly the case for the programme) in the
hands of a steering committee.
In some organisations this may suit the culture
of the organisation, and may well be one way of
ensuring the culture of the organisation is
brought into the nature and scope of the
programme itself.
If this is the case the steering committee would
assume the role of the co-ordinator and through
its team leader or chairperson give effect to
many of the decisions and activities listed
above.
If a steering committee is appointed the
following checklist may be helpful
Checklist – Some tips for creating a
steering committee
□ The committee should have clear terms of
reference
□ The committee should have a strong team
leader or chairman
□ Decide if the committee has a decision
making role or guidance role
□ The team leader should understand and
endorse mentoring as a strategy
□ The team leader should be ‘champion’
□ Members of the committee should form a
‘vertical slice’ of the organisation
□ The committee should meet regularly
□ Agendas should be issued and minutes kept
□ The committee should publicise itself and
its progress
□ The committee should invite comments and
submissions
Step 2.3. Test and pilot process and
resources
The Design Stage is intended to achieve the
desired individual learning and/or performance
outcomes from a mentoring programme. This
design should be reality tested. This should
answer the most fundamental question, Will the
planned approach enhance the individual
and/or the organisations’ capabilities? An
example of errors encountered later because
this step was not undertaken properly could be
as follows: where support materials and
content was poorly designed for the intended
users; rules and controls for the relationship
between mentors and mentees was unsuited to
the form of collaboration being undertaken, or
the outcomes were simply not achievable from
the mentor programme as designed. The
testing stage and its relationship to the overall
process is depicted below in Figure 3.
Testing may focus on
• Cost parameters;
• Validity of instruments for delivery and
reporting;
Planning Mentoring: A Guide 15

• Profile of individuals involved (mentor,
mentees, etc.)
• Rigour and appropriateness or
approach;
• Relevance and suitability of supporting
content or resources;
• Editing (i.e. is further editing and
refinement required, checking whether
anything has been omitted);
• Communication strategy;
• Plans and processes (i.e. timing and
achievability); and
• Appeal, level of interaction and
suitability for the intended audience.
Figure 3 Testing the mentoring programme as
designed
Sign off
Pilot & Test
Alpha
Design
Analyse
Design
Implement
Improve Need &
Outcomes

Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme
16 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme
Aim:
To run a successful mentoring
programme that is efficient in operation
and able to achieve the outcomes the
business and the individual involved seek.
Tips:
 Provide as much information as
possible in your material, it helps
people make better decisions and
reduces the possibility of
misinformation and rumour!
 You need to know that the mentor
has the competencies and the right
style
 You may find additional roles for the mentee – every relationship is different
 While difficult ensure fact based decisions on how mentors are matched to mentees still permit the
individuals to be involved in the final decision
 Ensure mutual orientation towards agreed outcomes
 Confirm how collaborative processes assist individual development
 Ensure mentors and mentees have the tools and means to structure their interactions
Traps:
 Lack of linkage between an individual in the mentoring programme and their work and life goals
 Professionally competent mentors may not be good at sharing their experiences with others
 Fear of interpersonal contact by parties involved
 Failure to align individual and enterprise needs
 People like to work with people they like, make sure the mentors have interpersonal skills!
 Failure to plan an induction programme for mentors and mentees
 Inability of the mentee to gain access to, or schedule meaningful time with the mentor
 Everyone ‘feels good’ but ultimately the time and effort was not sufficiently tied to agreed outcomes
that the effort was felt to be worthwhile
Step 3 Implement- actions we will cover

Step 3.1.
Step 3.2.
Step 3.3.
Step 3.4.
Step 3.5.
Profile and select the mentors and mentees;
Inform individuals involved;
Train the mentor and mentee;
Match mentors and mentees; and
Build strong mentoring relationships.

Step 3.1 Profile and select the
mentors and mentees
The mentor’s profile
It’s now time to meet one of the two major cast
members of the mentoring process – the mentor.
Just as there are many ways in which mentoring
can be used, mentors come in many different
forms; some may help a colleague settle into a
new job, another may be a confidant, another may
take the role of career coach, or skills coach. For
some the strength of the relationship is in that
there is ‘someone there’ when the mentee needs
to get something off his or her chest.
However, no matter the shape, size or form of the
mentor there are certain qualities that stand out.

Analyse
Analyse and establish
resources and outcomes
for mentor programme
Design
Design and develop
how it will be done
Improve
Evaluate, measure and
verify if improvements
are required
Need &
Improved
utcomes
capability
Implement
Run the mentoring
programme
Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 17
• The mentor has a management perspective –
he or she understands how the business or
industry works and how it is administered.
• The mentor possesses organisational knowhow – simply put the mentor can ‘get things
done’
• The mentor has credibility – the mentor is
trustworthy, reliable and possesses integrity
• The mentor is accessible – the mentor can be
found when he or she is wanted
• He or she communicates well – the mentor
writes well, can address a roomful of people
and possesses the ability to help his or her
mentee develop the skills as well
• The mentor knows how to empower people –
that is has the ability to let the mentee get on
with their job, in their own time and way
• The mentor develops and encourages people
– he or she delights in seeing the mentee
develop their skills and abilities and
encourages them to aim higher
• The mentor is open to new ideas – and
recognises that a mentee will often find a new
way of doing something, or may think
differently.
Selecting the right mentor
It is important to confirm what type of mentor
may suit the programme, or indeed an individual
mentee. For instance, consider the following four
types of mentors – the Executive Coach, the Elder
Statesman, the Deep Thinker and the Facilitator.
‘The Executive Coach’
The mentor who uses this style perceives that
the mentee is concerned about their
performance, or wants to change some
behavioural pattern – often the mentee wants
to acquire new skills – hence the ‘executive
coach’ title.
‘The Elder Statesman’
In this case the mentee is looking for a role
model, or a sounding board, or wants to tap into
past experiences on the part of the mentor
‘The Deep Thinker’
In this case the mentee wants to develop and
maintain a fast pace of learning or perhaps
needs a challenge beyond the resources of the
relationship or the business.
‘The Facilitator’
Here the mentor assesses that the mentee
wants to get on and get things done! Maybe the
mentee wants to build a more complex personal
development plan than normal – or wants to
explore a wider range of issues as they emerge.
The mentee profile
We now turn to review the role and development
of the mentee, sometimes described as “the other
side’ of the equation. In fact this description is
rather apt, because if the mentoring programme is
to work both the mentor and the mentee must be
in balance, both parties must contribute and for it
work effectively both parties must gain something
from the experience.
Yet by definition, the mentor is the wiser and
more knowledgeable of the team, so it stands to
reason that attitude of the mentee is vital – he or
she must accept responsibility for his or her own
actions. Let’s look at the mentee in detail, first we
will look at the role that the mentee is expected to
play in the relationship and then we will examine
the qualities and skills a mentee should possess
(or be willing to develop).
It is accepted that not all mentees will bring to the
relationship the same blend of qualities and skills
– in fact, often, one of the reasons for the
establishment of a mentoring programme is to
bring out the very qualities and skills that makes
mentoring so successful
• The mentee should possess a level of
assertiveness – a willingness to take the and
show initiative from time to time

• The mentee should possess skills in
communication

• The mentee should be self-disciplined
• The mentee should be willing to undertake
and relish the concept of adult learning
• The mentee should be willing to conduct self
assessment
• The mentee should be willing to conduct
information gathering exercises to augment
the information provided by the mentor
• The mentee should be will to undertake goal
setting and self appraisal as to his or her
ability to reach these goals
Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme
18 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
• The mentee should be able to prioritise work,
personal activities and educational
opportunities
• A mentee should possess vision
• A mentee should be willing to plan ahead
• A mentee should possesses evaluation skills
• Managing conflict should be seen as a
positive way of resolving issues and handling
feelings that may emerge
• A mentee should be organised, able to make
decisions, and follow through
• A mentee should be willing to resolve a
problem by negotiation
Step 3.2 Inform individuals involved
The announcement of the programme and its
attenuate publicity is vitally important for the
success of the project.
Publicity
• Arrangements should be made for the
programme to be promoted through the
firm’s existing communications channels
• Newsletter
• Website
• Intranet
• Social media
• HR Portal or similar
• Noticeboards
• Team meetings
• Circulars
• E-mail circulation lists
• Information sessions
What to include
• Information releases should contain
• The endorsement of the Chief Executive and
the Board
• An outline of the programme
• A list of the benefits to mentees, mentors,
and the firm
• The eligibility criteria for the pilot programme
• Invite written expressions of interest from
potential mentors and mentees
• A deadline for expressions of interest
• Details of any information sessions to be held
Holding information sessions
In organisations where it is possible the holding of
information sessions for interested people
provides a good opportunity to expand upon the
programme detail and to speak directly to those
most involved.
Potential mentors and mentees should be invited
along to theses sessions and should be
encouraged to attend – your firm, for example,
may make it obligatory for intending participants
to attend.
The sessions will be hosted by the co-ordinator,
(the steering committee should also attend along
with the most senior members of management
possible to add their imprimatur to the occasion
and the forthcoming programme).
Step 3.3 Train the mentor and mentee
Training the mentor
Yet for all their skills and potential, many mentors
still need to be trained to effectively manage the
task set for them.
As with most management functions, the level of
training required usually depends upon the
complexity of the mentoring task before them,
sometimes the mentors selected may be new to
the task, or need retaining in some way. Perhaps
circumstances have changed since the previous
mentoring programme. Therefore it becomes
essential to plan the training (or retraining)
programme carefully, filling gaps in knowledge
and improving skills and application.
Successful training programs usually consist of
four phases:
• Training needs assessment
• Programme design
• Implementation
• Evaluation
Mentors’ training needs usually fall into the
following groups of concern
Mentoring skills and processes
• The mentoring process -Understanding what
mentoring is all about
• The roles of mentor and mentee

Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 19
• The facilitation process
Interpersonal and communication skills
• Understanding and the development of
counselling skills
• Asking questions
• Listening skills
• Showing care and empathy
• Developing working relationships
Learning and development skills
• Developing people
• The learning cycle and styles
• Coaching
Training the mentee
The greater part of the relationship that grows
between mentor and mentee revolves around
learning – and here we must remember that
adults learn in a different way to children.
Although some mentees may not have
experienced full courses of tertiary education
(many will have of course); they will come into the
role expecting to learn from their mentor.
Therefore we can expect that:
• The mentee has already had undertaken at
least some learning activities, and may
already be an experienced learner.
• The mentee will some responsibility for
learning activities and opportunities
presented in the course of the programme
• The mentee will participate fully in the
activities presented during the course of the
programme.
The mentor must therefore bear in mind the
mentee’s levels of previous education and
interests, and adjust the mentoring style
accordingly. Competent learners may need less
direction than naive learners during the early part
of relationship – by the same token a mentee who
has less confidence in an area, may with time and
patience blossom, in which case the mentor will
need to make an adjustment.
Step 3.4 Match mentors and mentee
Usually the matching process in a mentoring
programme will start at the induction stage. This
is where the profiles developed for the mentor
and mentee are used to assess each individual’s
personal profile. After induction profiles are then
compared and mentor and mentees placed into a
relationship.
Note that there needs to be a follow up process to
ensure mentors and mentees both have the
opportunity to modify or change their matched
relationships. There may be many reasons other
than incompatible profiles that suggest a
relationship is not acceptable. These may include:
• Conflict of interest (commercial
incompatibility)
• Personal or family reasons (they may be
related)
• Process or procedural issues (incompatible
work schedules)
• Operational or technical issues (incompatible
areas of interest)
• Personal dislike.
The last is the most sensitive but must be
expected to arise. It is usually the mentor
programme coordinator that is responsible for
managing the processes that result in changing
mentor-mentee relationships.
It is also possible grievances and incompatibilities
may emerge later in the mentoring process. At
such stages these issues also have to be dealt with
by the coordinator.
Serious breaches of trust may also occur. These
breaches, such as sexual harassment, should be
linked into normal HR procedures for these
breaches. If the mentoring programme spans
more than one organisation or involved external
personnel clear rules and responsibilities have to
be set in when the programme is designed.
Use this checklist as a starting point to build the
relationship between the mentor and the mentee.
Checklist on tips for choosing a mentor
□ The mentor should have greater experience
and knowledge than the mentee
□ The mentor should have a flexible
management style
□ The mentor should be as flexible as possible
Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme
20 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
□ The mentee must trust the mentor to keep
confidences
□ The mentor should enjoy being a mentor
□ The mentor should be a confidant and mentor
first – if friendship follows that’s an added
bonus
□ The mentor should be someone other than
the mentee’s immediate manager
□ The mentor should have good inter-personal
skills
□ The mentor should be able to show leadership
□ The mentor should understand the role of
motivation in the relationship
□ The mentor should be able to identify
opportunities
□ The mentor should be honest with the
mentee, all the time!
Induction
Perhaps the first inkling mentees will have of the
scope and the possibilities of the mentoring
programme in which they are involved will be
during the induction sessions arranged before the
mentoring programme commences in earnest.
Here the mentee will not only be told about the
reasons for programme, they will in all probability
meet a group of fellow mentees an in all
probability their future mentor.
Most importantly the future mentees will be
provided with practical advice as to how to
conduct themselves during the programme and
what is expected of them during the programme.
This may include:
 An understanding of the role of the mentoring
programme
 An understanding of the mentee’s
commitments over the life of the programme
 An appreciation of what mentoring is, and is
not
 Provision of some basic learning skills – asking
questions and listening
 The need for a personal action plan
 Knowing how to get the most out of the
programme
At their induction programme mentees are usually
provided with a clear outline of the role expected
of the mentee – this is usually based upon the
following structure, although formats may change
depending upon the programme and the concern
conducting the programme.
Figure 4 The role of the mentee
EXAMPLE INDUCTION HANDOUT
Mentoring Programme for 2011
Recognise that participation in this exciting
and important mentoring programme has our
full support. Your role as a mentee will
include:
Attend this two hour induction training day
Commit to participate in the programme for
twelve months
Set and review your professional and personal
goals
Commit to the attainment of your goals
Abide by the Code of Conduct
Decide, in advance, what to discuss at each
mentoring session
Prepare a pre-session agenda an send it to
your mentor before each session
Complete the session outcomes form and send
it to the mentor within 48 hours of the
mentoring session
Be active in each session, don’t sit back,
participate, and seekclarity
Make decisions and take action
Attend group meetings – with other mentees
and their mentors
Commit to meetings with your mentor – at
least once a month for 1-2 hours
Our sincere best wishes.
B.G. Boss
CEO
Company XYZ
Developing a personal action plan
From the induction programme every candidate
(mentee) should have a personal action plan that
details what they want from the mentoring
programme. This can be shared with the

Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 21
coordinator(s) and then with the mentor they are
match with.
One of the pivotal moments of the mentoring
programme is when the mentor completes his or
her Personal Action Plan – this document seeks
from the mentee their input into the relationship,
a starting point and guide to the mentor and the
mentee as the relationship develops and a source
of evaluation at the end of the programme. The
completion of the Personal Action Plan also
implies commitment by the mentee to both the
programme and its outcomes.
Typically, a personal action plan will include the
following:
□ A definition of the mentee’s career and
business goals
□ Details of challenges or barriers to achieving
these goals
□ Identification of gaps in the mentee’s
knowledge, experiences, skills or personal
attitudes
□ It will highlight the mentee’s strengths and
weaknesses
□ It will commence to develop some strategies
for learning priorities
□ It will prioritise the mentee’s top three
professional development needs
□ It will prioritise the mentee’s top three
personal development needs
□ The mentor will be asked to nominate the
actions that need to be taken to achieve the
desired results?
□ The mentee will be asked to identify
appropriate support and resources
Step 3.5 Build strong mentoring
relationships
Setting the foundations for a mentoring
relationship
Ultimately mentoring is about building a
relationship, during the course of this relationship
the participants – the mentor and the mentee –
will grow in the knowledge of each other and the
things which they have agreed to achieve
together.
As you will appreciate the relationship is ‘one-toone’ and is acknowledged as generally having the
following features
• Rapport exists between the parties – the
mentor and the mentee
• Respect – both parties respect the other for
what they bring to the relationship
• Common ground – both mentor and mentee
seek to find common ground
• Two-way feedback – feedback flows
backwards and forwards between the parties
• Confidentiality – both parties respect the
other’s right to privacy
• Goal setting – goals and objectives are set by
mutual consent
• Progress measurement – both parties agree
to the to key performance indicators and how
they are to be measured
To start the process of building a relationship the
mentor and mentee need to confirm their mutual
outcomes and roles in this exchange. This is
depicted in the image below.
Figure 5 Mutual responsibilities when building a
mentoring relationship
Phases to the mentoring relationship
Mentoring relationships tend to pass through four
phases. These tend to be more or less predictable
allowing the mentor and the mentee to build upon
their joint experiences to form a ‘developmental
sequence’. Whilst nor all mentoring relationships
are the same – nor should they be – the phasing of
Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme
22 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
the relationship allows for planning and flexibility
during the association.
The four phases are detailed here:
1. Preparing
Remember each mentoring relationship is
different so before the association begins the
mentor and the mentee must take the time to
get know each other. Mentors should explore
their own personal motivations and those of the
mentee.
This phase has been described as ‘the discovery
phase’ as clarity about each person’s
expectations is sought. Often the initial
conversation between the mentor and the
mentee will set the tone for the whole
relationship.
2. Negotiating
During this phase the mentor and the mentee
reach agreement about the goals, content and
processes that will be employed during the
relationship. Mutual agreement on outcomes
and purpose are confirmed. Issues like
confidentiality and trust are discussed.
Some call this ‘the detail phase’ as it is during
this period matters such as how and when to
meet, individual responsibilities, achievement
criteria , the mentee’s accountability and the
length of the relationship are canvassed
3. Enabling
The enabling phase is the longest phase – for it
is during this period that the relationship
matures and grows. It is during this phase that
most of the contact between the partners takes
place .
Progress during this phase is not always smooth
and this depends upon the original goals and
objectives, and each parties understanding of
the process being employed. For knowledge and
skill so grow each must show mutual
understanding and respect.. The mentee usually
does eighty percent of the work during this
period as communication grows and the
learning process develops.
Sometimes known as the ‘implementation
phase’, the mentor’s nurturing sees his
associate grow in knowledge, develop skills and
understanding and successfully reach the agreed
objective.
4. Closing
Eventually the relationship will end, and both
parties must be prepared for this. There will be
a period of evaluation and appraisal involved as
both parties seek to assess the results of the
relationship.
Sometimes the relationship will end on a sour
note, on other occasions, after commencing
well, the association will lose its promise and
‘spark’.
Closure should be seen as an opportunity to
evaluate and move on as mentees take
responsibility for their own learning and growth.
Hopefully the mentee will apply the knowledge
gained to other relationships within the
organisation, profession, the wider industry and
in their personal relationships.
Building trust
Successful mentors and happy mentees will tell
you that the best relationships are those built on
trust and respect. So asking questions and really
listening to the reply creates the foundation upon
which the relationship can be built – but it goes
still further. The conversations between mentor
and mentee should be designed to build trust
between the participants.
Here are some ‘trust building’ strategies the
mentor can use during the initial conversation:
Take time getting to know each other:
• Talk about mentoring
• Determine the mentees goals
• Determine the mentees relationship needs
and expectations
• Define what you both hope to expect from
the relationship
• The mentor and mentee share assumptions
about each other
• Sharing needs
• Sharing expectations
• Sharing limitations
• Discuss options and opportunities for learning
and the gaining of knowledge

Step 3 Implement the mentoring programme

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 23
At the heart of the relationship lies the mentor’s
ability to build and maintain trust between the
parties. This is generally a result of the continuing
‘conversation’ between the pair – this is
highlighted by the questions asked, and yes, the
responses given but above all by the ability to
actively listen to the answers and the issues
raised.
Checklist Tips for supporting the mentee
• Re-read the job descriptions of all involved
from time to time
• Establish a regular pattern of contact
• Meet regularly
• Monitor the relationship continually
• Expect to make corrections as you go along
• Expect that the relationship will take time to
develop
• Ask yourself – ‘what am I learning?’
• Remember your role is provide professional
and work related guidance to the
mentee
• Look for learning opportunities continually
• Give the relationship space
• Give the relationship time
• Be consistent
• Look constantly for learning opportunities
(Adapted from: Zachary, 2000)
Set some parameters
The mentoring process involved at least two
people with different priorities and commitments.
The successful mentoring programmes have
typically had very strong commitments from these
two key players within agreed parameters. These
parameters are usually defined by:
• Agreed outcomes (usually based on the
personal Action Plan developed by the
mentor)
• Time commitments
• Rule governing interaction and access
Outcomes can be linked to business or personal
outcomes. They should be simply stated and
discussed so all parties understand what they
mean. If they are not realistic both the mentor and
mentee should refine them to until they can be
mutually agreed. If they cannot be agreed perhaps
it is necessary to change the relationship.
Some will find mentoring difficult as setting and
meeting deadlines is very hard within their work
context. The availability of time to complete
meaningful mentoring relationships is most often
at the heart of problems businesses face when
they review the effectiveness of mentoring
programmes. All players need to understand this
pressure and address it upon commencement of
their relationship.
The strength of the relationship that has
developed between the mentor and the mentee
can come under pressure. A health checklist for
the relationship may include questions asked by
the mentor to check the mentee’s progress.
□ How’s the programme proceeding?
□ What tasks have you completed?
□ What have you got left to be done?
□ Were you happy with the results?
□ Did you find anything particularly
difficult?
□ What was easy?
□ What do you have to do next?
Equally, an overall checklist, such as follows, can
be used to assess both the meeting(s) and
adherence to any established ground rules:
□ Our meetings will begin and end on time
□ We will both actively participate in this
relationship
□ We will have candid, open and direct
communication
□ Our planned actions from previous
meeting have been completed
□ We will respect or differences and learn
from them
□ We will honour each others experiences
and expertise
□ We will safeguard confidentiality and
privacy
□ We will manage our time appropriately
□ We will conducted the meeting without
interruption
□ We achieved the agreed outcomes for
the meeting
Step 4 Improve the mentoring programme
24 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Step 4 Improve the mentoring programme
Aim:
To review real measures that permit a
rigorous evaluation of the mentoring
programme and confirm the ways in
which it can be improved.
Tips:
 Avoid seeing and doing evaluation as
an isolated exercises at the end of the
programme
Traps:
 Unwillingness of trainer to indicate
poor performance
 Does not relate data to the core purpose of the evaluation
 Variations in outcomes with different mentors
 Evaluation materials or data is not collected consistently over time using scientific methods
Step 4 Improve – actions we will cover

Step 4.1.
Step 4.2.
Step 4.3.
Measure and evaluate the mentoring programme;
Evaluate tools and materials and the learning process(es); and
Report and suggest improvements.

Step 4.1 Measure and evaluate the
mentoring programme
Evaluation of a mentoring programme has to
relate back to the original analysis and design
steps. The scope and outcomes being sought
determine the measures and evaluation
methods to be used.
Any evaluation must verify the total
contribution that mentoring has made to
improvement as determined by the
measurement of current and potential business
performance and individual development.
Kirkpatrick’s model for Summative Evaluation —
and its four levels — holds real relevance to
those seeking to orientation evaluation of a
mentoring programme:
Level 1: Reaction
Level 2: Learning
Level 3: Behaviour
Level 4: Results
Level 1: Mentee’s Reaction
In this first level, mentors and mentees are
asked to evaluate the mentor programme after
completion. The aim is to assess the mentee’s
satisfaction with a session, or programme. While
often reduced to simplistic surveys (so-called
happy sheets) completed at the end of a session
or programme, this type of evaluation can
survey individual responses on matters that can
be compared across all mentee’s involved. This
survey or questionnaire could for instance
investigate:
• The degree to which the mentors and
mentees felt in control of the learning
process;
• Access and ease of progress through the
programme;
• The relevance of the programme to life
and/or work;
• Satisfaction with the experience; and
• Level of personalisation.
Level 2: Learning Results
This level measures what participants have
learnt from a mentoring programme. It seeks to

Analyse
Analyse and establish
resources and outcomes
for mentor programme
Design
Design and develop
how it will be done
Improve
Evaluate, measure and
verify if improvements
are required
Need &
Improved
utcomes
capability
Implement
Run the mentoring
programme
Step 4 Improve the mentoring programme

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 25
quantify the extent to which the mentor and
mentee’s knowledge, skills and other attributes
have changed. This form of evaluation may
involve running evaluation tools before and
after the mentoring programme. Results are
then compared. This type of evaluation is not as
widely conducted as Level 1, but is still very
common.
Level 3: Behaviour in the Workplace
Knowledge retention is an important attribute
for those involved in the mentoring programme.
It is important to determine whether mentees
can transfer the new knowledge, skills and other
attributes to immediate and longer-term job
application. Level 3 involves follow-up
evaluation over longer periods than Level 2 after
the mentoring programme has been completed.
Over three to twelve months after completion is
not unusual.
Level 4: Business Results
The fourth level seeks to evaluate the business
impact that results from the mentoring
programme. The results may be organisation
wide, or across populations of learners (i.e. an
occupational group, team or business unit, or
functional unit; for instance, those trained for a
specific competency set such as help desk
attendants). This level requires evaluation
metrics to move beyond the mentee and
examine the contribution of the programme to
the organisation or sponsors of the investment.
Clearly Level 4 evaluation provides the best
indication of the business benefits of a
mentoring programme design or intervention.
Continuously improving metrics at this level
directly translates into improved integration of
mentoring into systems and overall
organisational strategic success. Yet it is at this
level that least evaluation is conducted.
Calculate ROI. Various methods have been used
and supported to evaluate organisational
effectiveness in terms of return on investment
at Kirkpatrick’s Level 4. While Kilpatrick suggests
a cost-to-benefit ratio (CBR)

CBR = Programme benefits
Programme costs

It may also extend to include a return on
investment (ROI) approach. ROI strategies seek
to convert data to monetary values depending
on the type of data and the particular approach
being used. The eight ways of determining costs
and the return on this investment could follow
these seven approaches:
1. Output data is converted to profit
contribution or cost savings;
2. Resource costs are calculated;
3. Time multiplied by personnel costs (wages
and benefits );
4. Historical or comparative costs are
examined;
5. Internal and external experts are sourced;
6. Senior management provides estimates;
and
7. Finance office/accountant provides cost
estimates.
Step 4.2 Evaluate tools and
materials and the learning
process(es)
Once delivered, content, resources and support
services for the mentoring programme must be
subject to feedback, adjustment and
maintenance. These have to be determined
during the delivery process in terms of the
requirements to support different mentors and
mentees.
Evaluation of the tools, processes and
procedures may also be conducted to record
appropriateness according to these three
dimensions:
Budgets: Cost projections, actual expenditure
and revised costs to support the
mentoring programme.
Cost-effectiveness:
This relates to matters such as the
cost-benefit analysis of mentoring
resources and administration in
relation to other factors, including
equity and access issues, cost of
different modes of interaction, cost
of external as opposed to internal
mentors, and perceived impact (from
mentor or mentee) on having access
to such resources.
Step 4 Improve the mentoring programme
26 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Diversity: Evaluating the type and profile of
people accessing the mentoring
programme. Mentoring by a person
sharing similar profile has in many
instance, enhanced the success of
mentor relationships. When planning
and matching it is possible to profile
the diversity of users and, for
instance, examine how design and
delivery is able to capture expert
mentors that have severe time
pressures, gender balance of those
involved (women mentoring
women), people with special needs
(can people with a disability for
instance access the programme?), or
involvement of certain demographics
(language groups, cultures, locations,
age, gender, etc.).
Step 4.3 Report and suggest
improvements
Kirkpatrick’s is, at best, an indicative model for
mentoring programme evaluation. It
emphasises the need to evaluate beyond
reaction and individual learning. The capture,
analysis and reporting of information must
enable a picture to be formed of how well
mentoring is effected at different organisational
levels. These levels include:
• The organisation;
• Major functional or occupational areas
(e.g. finance department or clerical
work);
• Job-specific requirements (e.g. clerical
or accounting);
• The operational unit (e.g. department,
team, division); and
• The individual.
Apply metrics to measure capabilities. The
overall advancement in building capabilities
(competencies such as skills and knowledge, and
identity attributes such as behaviours, roles,
culture) at individual, group or organisation
levels should be reported. This will provide a
gauge of overall mentoring programme
efficiency.
Compare actual against planned capability
outcomes. To determine effectiveness of
mentoring programme, the outcomes targeted
and planned in the Analyse stage should be
assessed against actual outcomes achieved.
Confirm overall knowledge capital asset
improvement. As established in the Design
stage, the overall value-add of mentoring
programme can be related not just to improved
productivity and performance, but also to the
knowledge capital (or intellectual capital)
possessed by the business. This value-add can
be reported on the bottom line and actually
used to illustrate not only current potential to
perform, but also agility and the ability to meet
future opportunities.
Overall progress and improvement may be
mapped as depicted in Figure 5 to illustrate the
overall integration of the mentoring programme
with business systems. This will also provide
tangible proof of the organisation’s readiness to
advance to higher level mentoring initiatives
and gain the resulting strategic benefits.
Report and suggest improvements. Evaluating
the impact of the mentoring programme on
organisations provides management with a
critical means to assess current investments in
mentoring, or other learning and development
strategies. The figure below illustrates how
advances in the mentoring programmes’
sophistication and strategic business impact
may evolve over time. Evaluation not only can
determine current progress, it also can analyse
and report an organisation’s capacity to achieve
improved results from the mentoring
programme.

Resources used

Planning Mentoring: A Guide 27
Figure 6: Evolving the contribution of mentoring to business gains
(Bowles, M. 1998, Workplace Learning: Coaching and mentoring, Used with permission)
Resources used
28 Planning Mentoring: A Guide
Resources used
Bell, C.R. 2002, Managers as Mentors. Second
Edition Berrett-Koehler Publishers, California
USA.
Bowles, M. 1998, Workplace Learning: Coaching
and mentoring, Woolworths Australia.
Bowles, M. 2003, Investigative Research Report
into ELearning. University of Tasmania and
Commonwealth bank of Australia, Sydney.
Bowles, M. 2004, Relearning to Elearn.
Melbourne University Press: Melbourne
Bowles, M. 2005, Undertaking Organisational
Training Needs Analysis, Diploma of Training
and Assessment Student Guide: Esset Australia.
Bowles, M. 2010, FNSICORG515A Provide
mentoring and coaching within the workplace.
BSB51107 Diploma of Management Study
Guide, Skillworks, Sydney, Australia.
Dictionary.com, definition of mentor, accessed
10 January 2012 at
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/mento
r.
De Geus, A. March-April, 1988, Planning as
Learning, Harvard Business Review, pp. 70-74.
Lewis, G. 1996, The Mentoring Manager. Pitman
Publishing UK.
NSW Premier’s Department 2004, Mentoring
Made Easy. Third Edition Sydney NSW Australia
Peddy, S. 1998, The Art of Mentoring. Bullion
Books Houston Texas USA.
Redding, J. & Catalanello, R. 1994, Strategic
Readiness. Jossey-Bass: San Francisco.
Rolf-Flett, A., 1996, Tailor Made Mentoring for
Organisations. Synergetic Management,
Kincumber South NSW Australia.
Rolf-Flett, A. 1998, Develop Your Mentoring
Skills. Synergetic Management, Kincumber
South NSW Australia.
Zachary, L. J. 2000, The Mentor’s Guide. JosseyBass Publishers, San Francisco CA USA.

The post Planning Mentoring: A Guide appeared first on My Assignment Online.

Plagiarism Free Assignment Help

Expert Help With This Assignment — On Your Terms

✓ Native UK, USA & Australia writers ✓ Deadline from 3 hours ✓ 100% Plagiarism-Free — Turnitin included ✓ Unlimited free revisions ✓ Free to submit — compare quotes

admin

Academic writer and editor at BestWriters.

Get your paper off your plate tonight

Post your instructions for free. Prices start at $5 per page.

Place an order